2019Murat Volkan DülgerPresentation / talk

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

A short presentation explaining what has happened in this field in Türkiye from the date on which Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) entered into force until today, and what needs to be done.

Text of the presentation

This text is a translation, prepared for this website, of the short prose version of the presentation. The slides, images and tables are in the PDF version.

A field that concerns everyone

Personal data, their protection and, increasingly, personal data protection law formed a field that, at the time of the presentation, had been frequently discussed in Türkiye and had aroused curiosity, particularly over the preceding two years. This field relates directly to persons and to the data of persons. For that reason, no distinction can be drawn between those who are concerned with it and those who are not. For today everyone is in the position of a controller, a processor or a data subject. In our professional activities we are mostly controllers or processors, while as recipients of services or as consumers we are data subjects.

Various provisions on the subject already existed in Türkiye; what was lacking, however, was legislation dealing with the field as a whole. Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK), which entered into force on 7 April 2016, sought to remedy this deficiency to a large extent. For Türkiye, this date must be regarded as a turning point and a point of transformation in the field of personal data protection.

What has the Law brought?

The Law laid down general principles on the processing of personal data, determined the processing conditions and regulated the rights of the data subject. A general framework for processing has thus been created, whatever the field or sector. The controller or processor can no longer process whatever data it wishes, in whatever quantity and in whatever manner. If one of the processing conditions provided for in the Law is present in its activity, it bases the processing on that condition; if not, it may process data only with the data subject's explicit consent. Explicit consent is a concept that entered our lives with data protection law and denotes a declaration of intent by the data subject that is based on information and expressed of his free will. The era of processing data without reason and without purpose, as before the Law, has thus come to an end.

As regards the data subject, the person has been given control over his data. It has been made clear that explicit consent can be given only without any precondition and of the person's free will. The person has the right to learn for what purposes and how his data are processed and to whom they are transferred, and the right to have his data erased without fail upon request. The person has thus been given the right to determine the future of his data. All of this is gathered in the general principles that must be observed in every operation, starting from the first acquisition of the data. These principles must lie at the core of all data processing activities.

The supervisory mechanism

The Law also provided for a regulatory and supervisory body. To this end, the Personal Data Protection Authority was established, and the Personal Data Protection Board took office as the Authority's principal decision-making body. The regulations and communiqués issued by the Board, the decisions it has given, its publications and its academic events show that it is far more than a supervisory body. Before the Law, there was no public body to which the data subject could address a complaint, and the controller did not feel the pressure of a body that could effectively review an infringement and impose an administrative fine.

The proper functioning of this mechanism depends on data subjects having sufficient knowledge and awareness of their rights. However, the purpose of the Law and of the Board is not that the data subject should complain and the Board should impose penalties. Nor is it right, or even possible, to expect controllers who for years carried on their activities without being bound by specific and clear rules to comply with strict conditions all at once. Sufficient time and an effective process specific to the subject are required for this. Indeed, in some of its decisions the Board, although it found an infringement, did not impose an administrative fine but ordered that the controller be given instructions.

The compliance process

Controllers must act in conformity with the principles, procedures and rules of data protection law at every stage after the data are first obtained. This, in turn, depends on the projects we call the “process of compliance with the Law”. The process encompasses a body of material made up of regulations, communiqués, resolutions of principle, Board decisions, the case law of the courts, guidelines and examples from practice. Companies operating internationally are prepared, since they have been bound by Directive 95/46/EC since 1995 and by the GDPR since 25 May 2018. In companies operating nationally, however, sufficient awareness has not yet developed. Even so, thanks to academic work and the efforts of the Board, considerable progress has been made compared with the period when the Law first entered into force.

Controllers often see the process as a mere obligation and try to avoid it as far as possible. This is because the process both creates an area of uncertainty and brings a long workload that has to be carried out with the participation of employees. Our recommendation is to view compliance not as a project to be completed but as learning a human right that applies to everyone and acting accordingly in every activity. The aim is to create a basis on which the company can conduct all its data processing activities in conformity with the Law for as long as it exists, including the activities it carried out before the Law.

What has changed in Türkiye, and what needs to be done?

First of all, a new branch of law has emerged under the name of personal data protection law, and there is no branch of law it does not touch. This law must become established throughout society as a way of behaving and as a culture. In our view, Türkiye has not yet reached an adequate level in this field. The reason is not only that it has lagged behind; Türkiye's position requires it to be at a high level in this field. A policy of continuous development and improvement should therefore be adopted.

For controllers, the most important element is the human factor. Creating a basis that complies with the Law is the task of everyone who works within the company or has any relationship with it. Everyone must therefore be trained and made aware of data protection law. Training should be built on the legislation, academic work and problems arising in practice, and should be repeated at regular intervals, taking updates into account. The protection of personal data should be approached here not out of fear of an administrative fine but as a human right that must be respected. Instead of general training based on rote learning, the aim should be an understanding that reaches every person and every point of the company and becomes firmly established.

As regards the data subject, it should be recalled that all the obligations listed for the controller and the processor in fact derive from the right granted to the data subject. With the Law, this right has been placed on a statutory footing, and the concept of the data subject has emerged. Awareness has developed among individuals, and they have also been given the legal power to act on it. The concrete expression of this power is the right to lodge a complaint with the Board. The examination may lead to two outcomes. If the controller genuinely needs the information and relies on one of the processing conditions in the Law, there is no infringement. If data that are not necessary for the operation are requested, this can be based only on explicit consent obtained in accordance with the Law. If explicit consent cannot be obtained, the processing of those data or the service requiring consent must be abandoned. Making explicit consent a condition of the service by stating that the service will not be provided unless consent is given is a violation of rights which the Law does not accept and which has also been found unlawful by a decision of the Board.

The right to the protection of personal data concerns everyone, and there is no field or sector it does not touch. This law has required updates in every field. Bearing in mind that this law has become a necessity in a developing world, it should be seen as an opportunity to keep pace with the times; the effort should be made to understand its essence in every activity, above all in the compliance process, and to turn data protection into a culture.

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic