2019Murat Volkan Dülger, Yavuz Selim Dicle, Sezen Yankı EsenPresentation / talk

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

For somewhat more than three years we have been carrying out compliance projects under Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK). We have so far taken part in more than fifty projects and continue to do so. In particular, as the deadline set for the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry (VERBİS) draws near, we are receiving a large number of questions from our colleagues about how the compliance process is to be carried out.

We observe that the level of knowledge on this subject is not sufficient, particularly in Anatolia. In the hope of going some way towards meeting this need, we offer this presentation to our colleagues and to everyone interested in the subject. I prepared it together with my esteemed colleagues, the lawyers Yavuz Selim Dicle and Sezen Yankı Esen, with whom we run the compliance projects. Starting from the idea that love and knowledge grow as they are shared, we believe that knowledge should be shared and not kept to oneself. We hope it will be of some use to those interested in the subject.

Text of the presentation

This text is a translation, prepared for this website, of the short prose version of the presentation. The slides, images and tables are in the PDF version.

The stages of a compliance project

Compliance with Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) is approached as a project made up of successive stages. The action plan begins with determining the strategy, followed by organisation and allocation of tasks, policies and procedures, and training, internal communication and awareness. The final stage is auditing, risk analysis and measures. Once the project plan has been drawn up, an information training should be held. If possible, this training is given to all employees of the organisation. Where that is not possible, at a minimum the whole working group, made up of one or two persons selected from each unit that will take an active part in the compliance project, must be informed. The training covers why data matter, the date of entry into force of the Law and the periods it prescribes, the definitions in the Law, the rights of the data subject, the erasure, destruction and anonymisation of data, the transfer of data, the compliance process, criminal liability and comparative data protection legislation.

The personal data processing inventory

The basis of compliance is the personal data processing inventory. Under sub-paragraph (h) of Article 4(1) of the Regulation on the Data Controllers' Registry, the inventory is the document which controllers create by associating the processing activities they carry out in connection with their business processes with the purposes and legal ground of processing, the data category, the group of recipients and the group of data subjects, and in which they explain the maximum retention period, the data intended to be transferred to foreign countries and the data security measures. Sub-paragraph (ç) of Article 5(1) of the same Regulation obliges controllers who must register with the Registry to prepare an inventory. Sub-paragraph (d) provides that the information submitted to the Registry on the basis of the inventory is to be taken as the basis in the obligation to inform, in responding to data subject applications and in determining the scope of explicit consent.

The inventory is filled in with information collected from the units that process the data. This information is entered by the “relevant user”. The relevant user is a person who processes personal data within the controller's organisation or on its instructions, excluding the information technology unit responsible for the technical storage, protection and backup of the data. Each unit first writes down its main process and then the sub-processes that make it up, as steps that follow one another. In this way the flow of data between business processes becomes visible. The examples in the presentation include processes such as recruitment, supplier selection, assignment of mobile devices, pre-employment and return-to-work medical examinations, and the preparation of annual sales reports.

For each sub-process, the data collected, used and stored, their categories (identity, contact, personnel file, finance, marketing, etc.) and the special categories of personal data listed exhaustively in Article 6 of the Law are recorded separately. To these are added the source of the data (the person themself, a different department, suppliers, government offices or a system), the group of data subjects and the purpose of processing. The form of storage is shown as printed, electronic or application. For electronic files the address is given down to the smallest folder; for printed documents the name of the cabinet and folder is written. Access rights are stated by role, not by the person's name. For the retention period, it is first checked whether a statutory period exists. How many years of data are currently held, and whether any destruction has been carried out so far, is also recorded. The inventory further covers internal and external sharing, the method of transfer, transfer abroad, the legal ground under Articles 5 and 6 of the Law and the data security measures taken. Data security measures should be entered in the inventory in line with the guide published by the Authority.

Registration with VERBİS

Under Article 16 of the Law, the Data Controllers' Registry is kept open to the public, and natural and legal persons who process personal data must register with the Registry before they begin processing. The Registry records the identity and address details of the controller and of any representative, the purposes of processing, the groups of data subjects and data categories, the recipient groups, the data intended to be transferred to foreign countries, the security measures and the maximum retention period. Those who process data only by non-automatic means, notaries, lawyers, mediators, financial advisers, customs brokers, political parties and, under certain conditions, associations, foundations and trade unions are exempted from this obligation.

Registration proceeds in seven steps. The controller sends the application form with a wet-ink signature to the Authority or registers via its registered electronic mail (KEP) address. If the Authority finds the application suitable, it sends the login details by e-mail. The controller designates a contact person. The contact person registers with the system via e-Government, enters the information and approves it. Finally, the information becomes accessible to the public. When the inventory is registered, the data categories are entered one by one, and the processing purposes, recipient groups, longest retention periods, data subject groups, transfer abroad and security measures are linked to them. Registration is completed with “Approve and Send”.

Policies, procedures and the committee

At the compliance consultancy stage, the deficiencies identified by the gap analysis are remedied. First, a Personal Data Protection Policy and a Policy on the Protection of Special Categories of Personal Data should be drawn up. At a minimum, request management, retention and disposal, and document and record management procedures should also be prepared. Article 6(4) of the Law makes it mandatory, in the processing of special categories of data, to take the adequate measures determined by the Board. These measures were determined by the Personal Data Protection Board's Decision of 31/01/2018, No. 2018/10. The Decision calls for a separate policy and procedure. Employees who process such data must receive regular training, sign confidentiality agreements and have their authorisations checked periodically. Where duties change or an employee leaves, the authorisations must be removed immediately. In the electronic environment, cryptographic methods, secure logging and, for remote access, at least two-factor authentication are required. For transfers, encrypted corporate e-mail or KEP is used, and VPN or sFTP between servers.

The principle in Article 4 of the Law of being “relevant, limited and proportionate to the purposes for which they are processed” requires data minimisation. The data in the inventory should be compared with the processing purposes, and data not necessary for the purpose should not be processed. Board decisions show the practical consequences of this principle. Making hand and fingerprint scanning the mandatory and only way for members to enter a gym was not found proportionate (Decisions No. 2019/81 and No. 2019/165). Requesting a front-and-back image of an identity card, which also contains blood group and religion, for identity verification was likewise held unlawful (Decision No. 2019/294).

It is recommended that a representative or a Personal Data Protection Committee be appointed within the company, tasked with implementing and developing the policy and supervising compliance. This body should have technical and legal knowledge and sufficient authority and resources; it should be appointed by an official letter of appointment and announced to all staff. In the retention and disposal policy, retention periods are set per data category, checked in at least two periods a year, and destruction records are kept for 3 years. Where the legislation sets no period, the criteria in Article 9(4) of the Regulation (sector practice, duration of the legal relationship, limitation period, etc.) are taken into account.

Applications, data breaches, the obligation to inform and explicit consent

An application system should be set up for the rights in Article 11 of the Law, and requests must be answered within 30 days at the latest. The Communiqué on applications governs written, electronic and application-based procedures. The Board instructed an operator that accepted applications only through a notary or e-signature to exercise the utmost care in complying with the Communiqué. It also issued a reminder to a bank that responded to an application only with an e-mail pointing to its service line (Decision No. 2019/277). A procedure setting out roles and the method of notification is needed for data breaches. The “as soon as possible” in Article 12(5) of the Law was interpreted as 72 hours by the Board's Decision No. 2019/10.

The obligation to inform must be fulfilled in every case of processing, whether or not there is explicit consent. It does not depend on a request by the data subject, and the burden of proof lies with the controller. The text should be intelligible and plain and should not contain vague expressions. Its minimum elements are the identity of the controller, the purpose of processing, the parties to whom data will be transferred and the purposes of transfer, the method of collection and the legal ground, and the rights in Article 11. Explicit consent must relate to a specific matter, be based on information and be given of free will. Information and explicit consent must be obtained separately (Decision No. 2018/90). Imposing explicit consent as a condition of the service, where processing is based on a contract, was treated by the Board as an abuse of right and resulted in an administrative sanction. An educational institution that sent advertising text messages without a legal basis was fined 50,000 TL (Decision No. 2019/276).

Transfer abroad and ongoing auditing

Data to be transferred abroad should be identified one by one and examined as to whether they meet the conditions in Article 9 of the Law. The Authority has not yet published a list of safe countries; it has published only a checklist. The first question in that checklist is reciprocity, which cannot be applied with respect to many countries. In that case, mutual undertakings must be signed and submitted for the Board's approval; in practice, however, no positive responses are received to such requests. Obtaining explicit consent, on the other hand, is operationally quite difficult. Once compliance has been achieved, it is recommended that audits be repeated annually. Measures addressing the findings should be taken according to a plan. Since joint and several liability with processors may arise, processors should also be audited at regular intervals. When new processes emerge, their risks should be assessed under the Law.

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic