30 January 2019Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

When one speaks of what personal data protection law brings, I think that, rather than setting out the legislation and the theoretical knowledge on the subject, what needs to be discussed and raised is individuals’ interest in, knowledge of and level of awareness of personal data protection law. Of course, this is not entirely independent of the legal rules on the subject and must be considered first of all together with Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK).

For in Türkiye the protection of personal data essentially came onto the agenda and began to be discussed after 7 April 2016, the date on which the KVKK entered into force. For this reason, in this study I will essentially try to explain what the climate regarding the protection of personal data has been in Türkiye since 7 April 2016, what has been understood incompletely or wrongly, and which points need to be improved.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger**

Personal data, the protection of personal data, the Law on the Protection of Personal Data and, going further still, the law of personal data protection form a field that has been frequently mentioned, discussed and the subject of curiosity in Türkiye, particularly over the last two years. For those interested in the subject this goes back to earlier years, but we now see that everyone, whether interested or not, has become quite familiar with these concepts.

In fact, it is not possible to speak of a group that could be described as “not concerned” with this field. For, as is clear from the content of the concept, what is at issue is a field concerning “persons” and “persons’ data”. It is evident that one cannot speak of anyone not being concerned with such a field. Today, particularly as a result of the point reached in the use in daily life of information technologies, of the concept of big data that has emerged thanks to this technology, and of artificial intelligence algorithms, everyone is in the position of either a controller, a processor or a data subject. This is also why the protection of personal data has, so to speak, “exploded” in such a short time.

I should point out that the fact that some people are unaware that the protection of personal data concerns them does not mean that this field does not concern them in any way. For this reason, in my opinion, what needs to be done first is, alongside and indeed before theoretical knowledge and discussions on the protection of personal data, to create sufficient and necessary awareness of the subject. First and foremost, individuals must understand that their personal data form a sphere that must be protected and why personal data need protection. On the other hand, individuals must know that they must protect the personal data they process and what the need for this protection stems from. What is essential, therefore, on the side of the data subject as well as on that of the controller and the processor, is to understand the essence, the philosophy, of the protection of personal data. Only then can it be ensured that everyone acts in accordance with the legislation on the subject. Otherwise, regrettably, as in many other areas in Türkiye, a situation will arise in which personal data are protected by legal norms but this protection is not achieved in practice.

It is for this reason that, when speaking of what the law of personal data protection has brought, I believe that, rather than setting out the legislation and theoretical knowledge on the subject, what needs to be discussed and raised is individuals’ level of interest in, knowledge of and awareness of the law of personal data protection. Of course, this is not entirely independent of the legal regulations on the subject and must be dealt with first and foremost together with Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK). For in Türkiye the protection of personal data essentially came onto the agenda and began to be discussed after 7 April 2016, the date on which Law No. 6698 entered into force. For this reason, in this study I shall essentially try to explain what the climate regarding the protection of personal data has been like in Türkiye since 7 April 2016, what has been understood incompletely or wrongly, and which points need to be developed.

1. The Entry into Force of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data

In Türkiye, personal data began to be talked about and discussed with the entry into force of Law No. 6698. Although other legislation also contained various provisions on the subject, there was no legislation dealing with the subject as a whole. At the national level this caused many disruptions and uncertainties in every area, from everyday activities to economic activities, and at the international level it was also regarded as a major shortcoming, particularly in respect of the process of harmonisation with the European Union and commercial activities with Europe.

In this context, the Law on the Protection of Personal Data, which entered into force on 7 April 2016, sought to remedy this shortcoming to a large extent and introduced rules on the protection and processing of personal data. For this reason, 7 April 2016 should be regarded as a turning point and a point of transformation for Türkiye in the field of the protection of personal data. It can therefore be said that in Türkiye personal data began to be protected in the true sense with Law No. 6698 and with the Personal Data Protection Board, established under this Law, taking up its duties.

2. What Law No. 6698 Has Brought

a. In General

Because of present-day conditions, we use personal data in almost all the activities we carry out every day. When carrying out our professional activities we are mostly controllers or processors; when receiving a service or acting as consumers, we are data subjects. Within a company, the human resources department keeps and records the personal data of all employees and job applicants, including special categories of personal data. A hospital staff member records patients’ health data, a bank employee keeps people’s financial information, and an accountant processes people’s financial data. When we go to a place monitored by cameras and buy a coffee with our credit card, both our credit card details and our image and voice are recorded and processed. These examples can be multiplied across all the activities we carry out in a single day. The real question to be asked at this point, however, is this: according to which rules are these data collected and processed? Do the persons whose data are processed have any say? It is precisely at this point that Law No. 6698 comes into play, introducing rules on every kind of activity relating to the processing of personal data, from the obligations of the controller and the processor to the rights of the data subject.

With the entry into force of Law No. 6698, what must first be understood from the controller’s point of view is this: “As a controller or processor, I cannot process whatever personal data I wish, in whatever quantity I wish and in whatever manner I wish.” The data subject, for his part, will become aware of the following: “I have control over my data and I have the right to determine the future of my data; therefore no one may process my data without obtaining my explicit consent or without relying on one of the legal grounds provided for.” For Law No. 6698 has subjected every stage of the processing of personal data to rules. Since these rules are already explained in each article of the Law, rather than setting them out one by one, I wish to make clear what the Law seeks to achieve, in other words to bring out the essence of the protection of personal data.

The Law has essentially established general principles for the processing of personal data, laid down the conditions for processing personal data and regulated the rights of the data subject. It has thus been clarified under which conditions the controller and the processor may process data and, correspondingly, what the data subject can do. In order to process personal data, the controller or processor must either obtain the explicit consent of the data subject concerned or rely on one of the processing conditions provided for by the Law. At this point attention must be drawn to explicit consent and to the processing conditions provided for by the Law. Although, before the Law, various pieces of legislation had regulated, in a subject-specific way, the cases in which personal data could be processed, these cases were above all very narrow and limited. Moreover, they were not fully compatible with today’s understanding of data protection law. The clear and precise determination by the Law of the conditions for processing personal data has ensured that there is a general regulation of processing, regardless of the field or sector concerned.

Moreover, there was formerly no requirement of explicit consent for processing the data subject’s personal data. The concept of explicit consent entered our lives with data protection law and denotes a declaration of will by the data subject concerning the processing of his personal data, based on information and expressed of his own free will. In order to process personal data in the course of an activity, the controller or processor must check whether any of the processing conditions provided for in the Law is present for that activity. If so, he will base the personal data processing activity on that condition; if not, he may process personal data only if he obtains the explicit consent of the data subject. Data processing without justification and without purpose, as was the situation before the Law, has thus come to an end.

As regards the data subject, it has been ensured that the person has control over his data in every sense. It has been made clear that the person can give explicit consent to the sharing and processing of his data only without any precondition being imposed and of his own free will. Moreover, the person has been granted the right to learn for what purposes and in what manner his data are processed and to whom they are transferred, and has been given the possibility of having them erased without fail upon request. The person has thus been given the right to determine the future of his data1.

All of this is essentially gathered in the aims and functions of the general principles relating to the processing of personal data. The characteristic and function of these principles is that they determine the rules to be observed during every operation carried out on personal data, starting from when the data are first obtained. Accordingly, personal data may be processed only within the scope of the general principles laid down by statutory regulations and in accordance with these procedures and principles. These principles must therefore lie at the heart of all personal data processing activities, and all personal data processing activities must be carried out in conformity with them. Although I shall not set out these principles one by one here, I must underline that they are very important for understanding the rules on the processing of personal data, and, more generally, the aim and philosophy of the protection of personal data2.

b. Supervisory mechanism

Almost all national regulations governing the protection of personal data provide for data protection authorities to supervise whether the requirements of these laws are being met. One of the most important arrangements introduced by Law No. 6698 is likewise the provision for a regulatory and supervisory body to carry out the duties assigned by the Law. For this purpose the Personal Data Protection Authority was established, and the Personal Data Protection Board took up its duties as the Authority’s principal decision-making body.

I should point out that, although the Board is essentially regarded as a supervisory body, it would be a great injustice to think of it as consisting solely of supervision. The regulations and communiqués issued, the decisions taken and the publications, studies and academic events produced by the Board since the entry into force of the Law reveal that it is much more than a supervisory body. Although sufficient knowledge and awareness of the protection of personal data has not yet developed among the public, I believe the Board has played a large part in Law No. 6698 becoming a subject attracting interest despite its having entered into force only a short while ago.

Indeed, the decisions taken by the Board also show that the greatest change since the publication of the Law has been in this respect. Before the Law there was no public body to which the data subject could address an allegation or complaint of a violation relating to the processing of personal data; and for the controller, if he became the subject of such an allegation of violation, there was no danger of, or pressure from, a public body that would effectively examine it and could impose an administrative fine.

For this mechanism to function optimally, it is important that the data subject has sufficient knowledge and awareness of his rights relating to the protection of personal data. For although there is no requirement to this effect in the Law, the Board currently carries out inspections upon notification or complaint and rules on them. Whether such supervision takes place therefore mostly depends on a complaint by the data subject.

It must not be forgotten, however, that the purpose for which the Law and the Board were provided for is in no way for the data subject to complain and for the Board to impose penalties. Regrettably, since the Law was published, there has been a perception on the part of controllers that a Law has been enacted for the purpose of penalising them and an Authority established with the task of imposing those penalties. However, when we go back to before the data subject’s complaint and allegation of a violation, we find the controller’s acts relating to the processing of personal data that are the subject of the violation. That said, it is not right to expect controllers, who for years have carried on their activities without being bound by specific, clear and precise legal rules on the processing of personal data, suddenly to be subject to strict conditions; what is more, this is not even possible. Although one of the first steps in ensuring the lawfulness of the processing of personal data is to enact legislation in this field, this is by no means sufficient. Just because certain rules have been introduced by the Law, all of a company’s processes do not become compliant with personal data processing legislation. This requires sufficient time and an effective, subject-specific process. Indeed, the Board too, taking this situation into account, has in some of its decisions, despite finding a violation, not resorted to an administrative fine but ruled that the controller concerned by the violation be “instructed”. Accordingly, in addition to the Board acting as a supervisory body, the Board and the Authority together act as a body “regulating” this field, which is new for Türkiye, and this is extremely important.

Consequently, the Board, referred to as the supervisory and decision-making body in the field of the protection of personal data, should essentially be regarded as the greatest and most effective force for the formation and development of the law of personal data protection in Türkiye, owing also to its position and the means at its disposal. Indeed, the Board’s work and efforts to date support this.

c. Compliance process

The main reason why the Law has attracted interest from all quarters since its entry into force, and has aroused great curiosity particularly in all companies, is undoubtedly that it has introduced a “compliance process” that must be carried out by controllers. After the Law, an atmosphere of near panic arose in companies because of this process, and uncertainty as to what needed to be done began to prevail.

Controllers must act in conformity with the principles, procedures and rules of data protection law at every stage relating to personal data after the data are first obtained. Acting in accordance with these principles, procedures and rules depends on their carrying out compliance projects, which we call the “process of compliance with the Law”. The aim of this process is that, at the end of the project, all personal data held and processed, including personal data held before the entry into force of the Law, have been brought into full compliance with the Law from both a legal and a technical point of view. The process of compliance with the Law covers a whole consisting of the regulations, communiqués and resolutions of principle issued on the basis of the Law, Board decisions, case law of the courts, guidelines and examples from practice. At this point, rather than giving information on how the compliance process should be carried out, I consider it more appropriate to discuss the obligations this process brings and how it should be approached.

The first point I wish to make regarding the compliance process is that, regrettably, it is still not fully understood, people do not wish to understand it, or it has simply not been accepted. Moreover, there are still controllers who are, so to speak, “unaware” of this process. Companies operating internationally in particular are already prepared and willing to comply in this respect, since they have been bound since 1995 by Directive 95/46/EC and since 25 May 2018 by the GDPR. In companies operating nationally, however, sufficient awareness of the compliance process has not yet developed. Nevertheless, I must also point out that, compared with the date on which the Law first entered into force, considerable progress has been made thanks to academic work on the subject and the efforts of the Board, and that a relatively higher level has been reached with regard to the protection of personal data. But one should never be content with the point reached. For while Türkiye drafted Law No. 6698 taking into account the provisions of the Directive adopted by the European Union in 1995, the countries of the European Union are now subject to the GDPR, which has only just entered into force and contains much more up-to-date and comprehensive provisions. Since the GDPR does not cover only the countries of the European Union, acting in conformity with the provisions of the GDPR has also become mandatory for companies operating internationally. Consequently, the law of personal data protection should be developed in Türkiye as well, and efforts should be made to ensure parallelism with EU rules.

Secondly, mention must be made of controllers’ attempts to strip the compliance process of its mandatory character and to avoid this process as far as possible. First of all it must be stated that no one, whoever he may be, may engage in conduct harmful to the data subject’s right to the protection of personal data in the course of personal data processing activities. All natural and legal persons must act in conformity with the Law and, more generally, with the law in every activity relating to personal data. Although certain groups have been exempted from certain obligations by regulations, communiqués or Board decisions published after the Law, the basic rule is that everyone must act in compliance with the Law and, accordingly, carry out projects of compliance with the Law.

That said, it is also clear that this process constitutes an additional obligation for controllers. The facts that the process constitutes an uncertain area for controllers and that it is a long and tiring task that must be carried out with the participation of company employees cause controllers to avoid it. My recommendation at this point is that the process should be viewed not as a project to be completed but as learning a human right that must be secured for everyone in every area of life, and ensuring that every activity is carried out in accordance with it. What is more, it should not be forgotten that, just as we are controllers in a certain area, we are at the same time also data subjects and, as data subjects, want our rights to be respected.

3. The Period after the Entry into Force of the Law: What Has Changed in Türkiye?

First and foremost, a new branch of law has emerged in Türkiye under the name of the law of personal data protection. And this branch of law is such that there is no branch of law it does not touch. When personality rights are mentioned, civil law; when the right to the protection of personal data as a human right is mentioned, constitutional law and human rights law; where a breach of the protection of personal data constitutes an offence, criminal law; when the processing of personal data by companies in the course of their commercial activities is mentioned, commercial law; when personal data processed because of persons’ purchases are mentioned, consumer law; and where administrative penalties and regulations are at issue, administrative law: these most fundamental disciplines come to the fore. Moreover, even when we consider more specialised areas, we see that one end of them is in some way again tied to the law of personal data protection. In all the areas arising through IT tools, such as e-commerce, e-sports, e-shopping, e-gaming and the like that have emerged with IT law, or more generally electronic communications, there are new regulations in parallel with the provisions of the law of personal data protection because of intensive personal data traffic.

These examples can be multiplied for every branch of law. As I mentioned earlier, personal data undoubtedly exist in every area where the individual exists. Since law, in its most general and simple definition, is defined as the body of rules regulating society, wherever there is law there will be personal data, and therefore at one end of every branch of law the law of personal data protection will, a fortiori, be present.

In conclusion, I can say that, in addition to the emergence of the law of personal data protection, a new perspective in line with the provisions on the protection of personal data has also developed in other branches of law. My greatest expectation at this point is that the law of personal data protection will not remain limited solely to subject-specific legislation, and that the necessary amendments will also be made to the provisions of other laws relating to the protection of personal data in line with this new perspective.

In my opinion, awareness of the protection of personal data among legal practitioners and theorists and in society can be created not merely by regarding it as a subject-specific branch of law, but by conveying the impression that it is to be established as a culture. In view of the importance of personal data and the need for their protection, data protection law must become established throughout society as a mode of behaviour and a culture.

So what exactly should be done for this, what has been done, and has what has been done worked?

Is the personal data protection legislation created by Law No. 6698 and the regulations subsequently published sufficient for a situation such as the one I have described above to come about? What is the situation that has currently developed?

First of all, I must point out that a sufficient level has not yet been reached in Türkiye in the field of data protection law. This is not merely because Türkiye lags behind in this respect; it also stems from the necessity, given Türkiye’s position, for it to be at a high level in the field of data protection law. For Türkiye is a country with a large population, the great majority of which uses IT tools effectively and intensively, and in which commercial activities and relations are also conducted very intensively at both national and international level. These points, which I particularly wish to highlight, entail intensive personal data processing traffic. In such a situation, since the need for the protection of personal data is greater, the level of protection and security in this regard must be very high in every sense.

Of course, the need for the protection of personal data and the difficulty of protecting personal data develop in parallel. In other words, the more the protection of personal data is needed, the more difficult protecting personal data will be. This, however, should in no way be seen as an excuse. What I really want to underline here is the importance of data protection law for Türkiye, the need for it and, consequently, the necessity of adopting a policy of continuous development and improvement in this field.

Since its entry into force, the Law has attracted considerable interest, particularly because companies are obliged to bring themselves into compliance with it and because there is a supervisory mechanism in this regard. In this context almost everyone is trying to understand the obligations introduced by the Law and what needs to be done to act in accordance with them. Suddenly, in-house legal counsel who had never done any work on personal data before, and indeed had never needed to within the company, found themselves confronted with the field of the protection of personal data. All law firms, regardless of whether they specialise in private law, criminal law or commercial law, began to receive questions on the protection of personal data from their clients. There were undoubtedly lawyers who had already been working on the protection of personal data before the Law entered into force, but for almost everyone outside this group the protection of personal data became a subject of curiosity, with an attitude of, as it were, “so there is such a thing as personal data”. In my opinion, therefore, first of all, whether or not we had worked on the subject before the Law entered into force, we have all learned about personal data, and more particularly about the protection of personal data under Law No. 6698, and we continue to learn.

This situation must also be viewed from the side of the controller or processor and from that of the data subject. What have both sides learned since the entry into force of the Law, and what changes have occurred? On the controllers’ side, a perception has truly formed that there really is such a thing as personal data and that they must protect it. But how are they to do this? Can the mere fact of having worked with lawyers carrying out compliance projects and with IT specialists expert in data security mean in itself that everything that needs to be done has been done?

I must point out that, although projects of compliance with the Law are a necessary step for companies to become compliant with the Law, they are not sufficient on their own and form only one part of compliance with the Law. It must not be forgotten that a compliance process carried out with a legal and technical team is a project, embarked upon in order to be completed. The processing of personal data, however, is an ongoing activity for every company. It is clear that the meaning of the compliance process is not that a company carries out and finishes all its data processing activities during this project. The real aim is to create a basis on which all personal data processing activities, including those the company carried out before the Law, can be conducted in compliance with the Law at all times from the company’s inception to its dissolution. Compliance processes should therefore be approached not as a project that starts and ends, but as work to place an ongoing process on a lawful footing. Such a perspective will make compliance with the law of personal data protection much easier.

At which points must controllers take care in order to act

with such a perspective?

It is a fact that many activities can be carried out by means of IT tools without the need for human action and that digitalisation is increasing day by day in every sector. Nevertheless, one still cannot speak of the existence of a controller, for example a company, that carries on its activities without any need whatsoever for human labour. Although I foresee and believe that such a situation will come about in the not too distant future, at least today’s artificial intelligence technology is not yet that advanced. Consequently, first and foremost the human factor in companies must be addressed, that is, above all the company’s employees and everyone who is in any way in contact with that company. Considering that there are particular employees in each department of a company, do all employees need to be involved in this process? For example, can it be that the legal department, which must necessarily be present in the compliance process, is directly a party to carrying out this process, while departments such as sales and marketing, production or human resources play no part in it at all? Although the project could no doubt be carried out in this way, is it possible for such a project to serve the purpose sought by the Law?

As I mentioned earlier, just as there is no branch of law or sector that personal data do not touch, there cannot be a department or unit within a company that they do not touch. For anyone, whatever his position, may cause a data breach, knowingly or unknowingly, though its scale may vary. Creating a basis compliant with the Law therefore concerns everyone working in any capacity within the company in question; it is everyone’s duty. For this reason, the most important matter on which controllers must focus is the training and awareness-raising, regarding data protection law, of everyone working at the company and everyone who has any kind of relationship with the company. This is what must be focused on above all. Rather than placing pages of documents or legal norms in front of a company employee and expecting him to comply with them, it must be ensured that he can grasp the essence of why that controller is obliged to protect personal data.

How can a company employee be enabled to grasp the essence of data protection law?

The first and indispensable step is, of course, training based on the legislation on data protection law, academic work and the questions and problems arising in practice. The second step to be taken for this training to achieve its purpose is training continuing at regular intervals that takes into account updates on the subject. In these training sessions, the protection of personal data must be presented not out of fear that an administrative fine will be imposed if data are not protected, but as a sphere that must be respected as a human right.

At this point I would like to address the problems I frequently encounter in practice. Since the entry into force of the Law, we see that companies, particularly those currently carrying out or having completed compliance projects, have taken certain concrete steps. This is even more evident at points where consumption is at issue and one-to-one contact with people takes place. In this respect, the step that has most caught my attention is the hanging, in almost every shop or supermarket, of a frame containing general information on the protection of personal data under various titles such as “Protection of personal data”, “Our policy on the protection of personal data” or “Information notice on the processing of personal data”.

Is the text that has been hung up necessary? In my opinion it is. However, if the people working in that shop or supermarket have no knowledge of the protection of personal data, that text has no meaning or significance, nor can it achieve its purpose. The text that has been hung up acquires meaning only if the controller has processors or employees capable of living up to it. It is precisely this kind of approach to the law of personal data protection and to compliance processes that must be adopted on the controllers’ side. Otherwise there will be a situation that is compliant only in appearance while, on the unseen side of the mountain, a bomb is ready to explode. For this reason, rather than a general, rote application of the law of personal data protection, it must be ensured that it reaches every person and every point within a company from A to Z and becomes firmly established.

How, besides the changes on the controller’s side, are the changes on the data subject’s side

being observed?

In fact, data protection law forms a whole, and it is not possible to separate the changes occurring on the controller’s side from those on the data subject’s side by a sharp line. For the obligations explained above for the controller or processor already derive from the data subject. To put it more clearly, the controller’s obligations, although they will not correspond one to one, will in general also constitute the rights of the data subject. For this reason, I must first point out that all the matters I have addressed above apply in the same way to the data subject. Moreover, it must not be forgotten that a person who is a controller or processor while carrying out his professional activity is a data subject when buying a product from a shop, and that, consequently, the concepts of controller, processor and data subject are, with regard to the person in whom they are combined, concepts that cannot be sharply separated from one another.

On the other hand, the protection of personal data is essentially a right, and this right has been granted to the data subject. The foundation of the law of personal data protection lies in the protection of the data subject and of his privacy. Indeed, the purpose of Law No. 6698 has been stated as protecting natural persons whose personal data are processed and laying down the obligations of those who will engage in processing activities and the rules they must observe. The law of personal data protection should therefore be approached essentially as the rights of the data subject and the obligations of the controller or processors.

The entry into force of the Law and the subsequent adoption of legal regulations on the subject have indicated, first and foremost, that there is a sphere of personal data that must be protected and that this sphere must be placed under protection through legal regulations. Consequently, with the Law, individuals’ right to the protection of personal data was placed on a statutory footing and the concept of the data subject thus emerged.

In fact, even some groups who today, as data subjects, have many rights under the right to the protection of personal data were not fully aware of the subject. There was insufficient awareness on matters such as why their data should be protected, what kinds of violations were taking place with regard to these data and for what they were being used. Moreover, since violations committed with regard to data, and in particular situations such as data being bought and sold by advertising companies, did not take place in plain sight, I consider it normal that there was insufficient knowledge on this matter. However, the entry into force of the Law and the many studies on the subject carried out thereafter, particularly in the academic field, have created awareness among individuals of why their data constitute a sphere that must be protected.

A person who understands why his data must be protected must then also have the legal power to achieve this. It is precisely after the entry into force of the Law that legal power under the right to the protection of personal data has been fully provided. The existence of a general and comprehensive Law on the subject, the existence of a national authority supervising it, and the subsequent spread of the protection of personal data to such an extent have enabled individuals to become aware of their rights and to demand to be allowed to benefit from them. Whereas before the Law individuals were in a weak position vis-à-vis controllers and processors, they are now in a stronger position.

Indeed, in practical terms too, we see that people adopt a more questioning attitude than before when data are requested from them. Today, in every relationship we enter into in any way, our personal data are requested according to the nature of the relationship established. This is sometimes necessary for interests such as enabling the relationship to be established and continued or the parties’ purpose to be achieved, while sometimes it may go beyond this necessity. A data subject faced with such a suspicion questions why this information is being requested from him and what will be done with it. If he does not receive a satisfactory answer in return, he refrains from giving this information. This is precisely the awareness that ought to exist and become established.

So, if the transaction is not carried out because the information is not provided, what can the data subject

do?

Where the data subject refrains from giving the information requested from him, the controller or processor may state that the transaction cannot be carried out. In that case the data subject’s right to lodge a complaint with the Board comes into play. Indeed, the Board has announced that a very large number of applications have been made to it. These applications are decided favourably or unfavourably, and decisions deemed necessary are shared with the public.

An examination carried out upon a complaint by the data subject may lead to one of two outcomes. If, in the specific case, the controller or the processor genuinely needs that information in order to carry out the transaction in question and relies on any of the processing conditions laid down in the Law, no violation can be said to exist. For the controller is requesting the information not for personal reasons of his own but because he needs it. In that case, if the data subject wishes to take part in the transaction, he must share the data; if he does not wish to share it, he must be prepared to accept that he will not be a party to the transaction. If, however, the controller or the processor requests data that is not necessary for the transaction in question, he can base this only on the explicit consent of the data subject obtained in accordance with the Law. Where the data subject does not wish to provide the information, it is clear that he has not given explicit consent. It is precisely at this point that the refusal of the controller or the processor to carry out the transaction amounts to a violation of the right to the protection of personal data. In that situation, a threat has been created that the service will not be provided unless consent is given, and the declaration of explicit consent has been made a condition of the service. This is a violation of rights which the Law in no way accepts and which has also been found unlawful by a decision of the Board.

Conclusion

The right to the protection of personal data, which in Türkiye has become a subject of curiosity and interest especially since 7 April 2016, the date on which the Law entered into force, is by its very nature a field that concerns everyone. Since personal data relate to persons and to information about persons, there is no field or sector they do not touch. All economic and commercial activities, whatever their field, fall within this scope, and so do the various fields of law. The law of personal data protection, shaped by the entry into force of the Law, by the legal instruments published thereafter, by the work of the Board and by the Board’s decisions, has affected every field and has made it necessary to carry out updates in every field from the perspective of data protection law.

For this very reason, rather than regarding what the law of personal data protection has brought as an additional burden or nuisance and avoiding compliance with it as far as possible, one should seek to understand the meaning and importance of this newly emerged branch of law. Bearing in mind that the law of personal data protection has become a necessity in a developing world, what it has brought should be treated as an opportunity to keep pace with the times. In this context, the essence of the law of personal data protection should be understood in every activity undertaken, above all in the process of compliance with the Law that companies must carry out. With this essence kept in view in every activity, efforts should be made so that the protection of personal data takes root and becomes a culture.

Footnotes

  1. This paper was presented at the “28 January Data Protection Day Conference” organised by the Personal Data Protection Authority in Ankara on 28 January 2019. ↑
  2. Academic / Attorney. ↑
  3. For details see: Murat Volkan Dülger, Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku, Hukuk Akademisi, İstanbul, 2019, s. 146-178. ↑
  4. For details see: Dülger, s. 107-146. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic