Introduction
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
The Personal Data Protection Authority has amended the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data of 28 October 2017 and the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry of 30 December 2017, and the regulations containing these amendments were published in Official Gazette No. 30758 of 28 April 2019.
The second development in personal data protection legislation was published in Official Gazette No. 30777 of 17 May 2019. Here the Authority introduced the Regulation on Disciplinary Superiors of the Personal Data Protection Authority and amended the Regulation on the Working Procedures and Principles of the Personal Data Protection Board. In this article I will consider what these amendments mean and what conveniences or difficulties they will bring in practice.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*
I. Introduction
The Personal Data Protection Authority has amended the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data of 28 October 2017 and the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry of 30 December 2017, and the regulations making these amendments were published in Official Gazette No. 30758 of 28 April 2019. The second development in the data protection legislation was published in Official Gazette No. 30777 of 17 May 2019. Here the Authority introduced the Regulation on the Disciplinary Superiors of the Personal Data Protection Authority and amended the Regulation on the Working Procedures and Principles of the Personal Data Protection Board.
In this article I shall examine what these amendments mean and what facilitations or difficulties they will bring in practice.
II. Regulation Amending the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data
Sub-paragraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 3 of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data defines the concept of “anonymisation”, and Article 7 governs the “erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data”. Paragraph 3 of Article 7 states that the procedures and principles concerning the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data are to be laid down by regulation. In addition, sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 22 of the Law provides that the Board has the duty and the power to adopt the necessary regulatory acts on matters concerning its field of competence and the functioning of the Authority. Thereupon the “Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data” was published in Official Gazette No. 30224 of 28.10.2017 and entered into force on 1 January 2018.1
Since the entry into force of Law No. 6698, one of the subjects that has caused the greatest difficulty and debate in practice has been the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data. Although the adoption of the Regulation in question dispelled the question marks to some extent, the debate on the subject continued intensely.
The published Regulation amends three articles of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data. The amended articles are Articles 4, 7 and 12 of the Regulation. These amendments are explained in detail below:
A. The Amendment to Article 4
Sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data, headed “Definitions”, defines the personal data processing inventory. According to this provision, the personal data inventory is “the inventory which controllers create by associating the personal data processing activities they carry out in connection with their business processes with the purposes of processing personal data, the data category, the group of recipients to whom the data are transferred and the group of data subjects, and which they set out in detail by explaining the maximum period necessary for the purposes for which the personal data are processed, the personal data envisaged to be transferred to foreign countries and the measures taken with regard to data security”.
In the published Regulation, by contrast, the personal data processing inventory is defined as “the inventory which controllers create by associating the personal data processing activities they carry out in connection with their business processes with the purposes and the legal basis of processing personal data, the data category, the group of recipients to whom the data are transferred and the group of data subjects, and which they set out in detail by explaining the maximum retention period necessary for the purposes for which the personal data are processed, the personal data envisaged to be transferred to foreign countries and the measures taken with regard to data security,”.
Looking at the differences between the two definitions, we see that under the new regulation the personal data inventory must, when it is created, also be associated “with the legal basis”, and that the phrase “the maximum period necessary” has been replaced by the phrase “the maximum retention period necessary”.
From this I conclude that, although the published regulation did make an amendment, it has not moved far from the definition in question and has merely corrected and specified points that could give rise to misunderstanding. Indeed, the fact that the phrase “the maximum period necessary” in the definition has been recast as the “retention” period is the clearest indication of this.
B. The Amendment to Article 7
Paragraph 4 of Article 7 of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data governs the method to be used in erasure, destruction and anonymisation operations. The former version of the provision read: “The controller is obliged to explain, in its relevant policies and procedures, the methods it applies in the operation of the erasure, destruction, anonymisation of personal data.” What is to be understood from this provision is that, unless the Board has decided otherwise, the controller must state which of the methods of erasure, destruction or anonymisation it uses, at the request of the data subject or of its own motion, in respect of the personal data it processes, and must explain the method it uses in its data storage and destruction policy and in the policies it has laid down.
With the amendment the provision now reads “The controller is obliged to explain, in its relevant policies and procedures, the methods it applies in the operation of the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data.” ; a change was made solely in terms of the rules of grammar, by adding the word “or”. The intention was thus to make it clear, in a way that leaves no room for confusion, that the controller may, depending on the circumstances, apply any of the three methods of destruction, but must explain how this is to be done.
C. The Amendment to Article 12
Paragraph 1 of Article 12 of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data, headed “Periods for erasing and destroying personal data where the data subject so requests”, reads as follows:
“Where the data subject, relying on Article 13 of the Law, applies to the controller and requests the erasure or destruction of the personal data relating to him or her;
a) If all the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist, the controller shall erase, destroy or anonymise the personal data to which the request relates. The controller shall finalise the data subject’s request within thirty days at the latest and shall inform the data subject.
b) If all the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist and the personal data to which the request relates have been transferred to third parties, the controller shall notify the third party of this situation and shall ensure that the necessary operations under this Regulation are carried out by the third party.
c) If not all of the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist, this request may be refused by the controller, stating the reasons, pursuant to the third paragraph of Article 13 of the Law, and the refusal shall be notified to the data subject in writing or by electronic means within thirty days at the latest.” Looking at the opening of the provision, we see that it is based on Article 13 of the Law. Article 13 contains the following provision: “The Board is empowered to remove the doubts that may arise and the shortcomings in practice during the application of the Regulation, to guide practice, to determine principles and standards and to make the necessary arrangements to ensure uniformity of practice, to request any information and documents necessary in this regard and, where a matter is not covered by this Regulation, to decide on it within the framework of the provisions of the relevant legislation.” As is also clear from the provision, where the data subject requests erasure, destruction or anonymisation, the Board too is competent to determine the periods.
The amendment changed the phrase “relying on Article 13” in the provision to “relying on Articles 11 and 13” . Thus, as regards the periods applicable where the data subject makes a request, reference is now made not only to Article 13 but also to Article 11, headed “Periods for erasing, destroying or anonymising personal data of one’s own motion”. In Article 11 of the Law, the operations of erasing, destroying or anonymising data have been tied to a periodic process, since they will be carried out continuously and will require considerable time and effort. Accordingly, the period for periodic destruction which controllers must state in their data storage and destruction policy may not exceed six months. The amendment to Article 12 emphasises that, where the data subject requests erasure, destruction or anonymisation, the period for periodic destruction must be taken into account in addition to the controller’s 30-day period for meeting the request.
III. Regulation Amending the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry
Paragraph 2 of Article 16 of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data lays down the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry, referred to as “VERBİS”. Paragraph 5 of the Article states that the other procedures and principles concerning the Data Controllers’ Registry are to be laid down by regulation. Thereupon the “Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry” was published in Official Gazette No. 30286 on 30 December 2017 and entered into force on 1 January 20182.
The published regulation amends 6 articles of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry. The amended articles are Articles 4, 5, 7, 11, 13 and 16 of the Regulation. These amendments are explained in detail below:
A. The Amendment to Article 4
Sub-paragraphs (ç), (h) and (p) of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry, headed “Definitions”, have been amended. Sub-paragraph (ç) of the first paragraph defines the contact person. According to the definition given in the Regulation, the term denotes “Contact person: the natural person who, for legal persons established in Türkiye and for the representative of a controller that is a legal person not established in Türkiye, is notified by the controller at the time of registration with the Registry for the purpose of the communication to be established with the Authority in connection with their obligations under the Law and the secondary legislation to be issued on the basis of this Law,”. With the amendment in question sub-paragraph (ç) now reads “Contact person: the natural person who is notified at the time of registration with the Registry, by the controller in the case of natural and legal persons established in Türkiye and by the controller’s representative in the case of natural and legal persons not established in Türkiye, for the purpose of ensuring communication with the Authority in connection with their obligations under the Law and the secondary legislation to be issued on the basis of this Law,” . Looking at the amendment, the original version of the regulation created the impression that a contact person could exist only in legal persons, whereas the amended version makes it clear that, in addition to legal persons, controllers may also be natural persons. In my opinion, wording the provision in this way has corrected a point that had previously been overlooked.
Another amendment to the same article was made in sub-paragraph (h) of paragraph 1. This sub-paragraph defines the personal data processing inventory, and an amendment has been made that parallels the one made to sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 4, headed Definitions, of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data.
The last amendment to the article was made to the definition of the controller’s representative in sub-paragraph (p). In the original version of the Regulation this definition read: “Controller’s representative: means the legal person established in Türkiye or the natural person who is a citizen of the Republic of Türkiye authorised to represent, at a minimum, controllers not established in Türkiye in the matters specified in the second paragraph of Article 11 of this Regulation.” Although this concept appears in Law No. 6698, it was defined for the first time in this regulation. Looking at the published amendments to the Regulation, it can be seen that the provision has been changed to read “Controller’s representative: the legal person established in Türkiye or the natural person who is a citizen of the Republic of Türkiye authorised to represent, at a minimum, controllers not established in Türkiye in the matters specified in the third paragraph of Article 11 of this Regulation,”. Paragraph 2 of Article 11 states that a certified copy of the decision appointing the controller’s representative must be submitted to the Authority. The third paragraph of the article, on the other hand, governs the duties of the controller’s representative and the matters in which he is authorised to act as representative. It is plain that an obvious error had been made in the cross-reference contained in the provision of the Regulation and that the amendment has corrected it.
B. The Amendment to Article 5
In paragraph 1 of Article 5 of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry, sub-paragraphs (ç) and
(ğ) have been amended. Sub-paragraph (ç) of the article, which read “The information to be disclosed to the Registry in Registry applications shall be prepared on the basis of the Personal Data Processing Inventory.” , stated that the information to be disclosed in the application for registration must be consistent with the personal data inventory and thereby emphasised the importance of the personal data inventory. In the published regulation sub-paragraph (ç) has been changed to read “Controllers who are under an obligation to register with the Registry are obliged to prepare a Personal Data Processing Inventory. The information to be disclosed to the Registry in Registry applications shall be prepared on the basis of the Personal Data Processing Inventory.” ; by stating first of all that there is an obligation to prepare an inventory, a misinterpretation of the provision has been prevented.
In sub-paragraph (ğ) of the article, again, an amendment parallel to the one made to Article 4 of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data was made, and the phrase “the maximum retention period necessary” was introduced in place of “the maximum period necessary”. The aim of this amendment was to prevent misinterpretation of the provision, and it was emphasised that the period required is the storage (retention) period.
C. The Amendment to Article 7
Article 7 of the Regulation governs access to the Registry, and paragraph 2 of the article emphasises that the information contained in the Data Controllers’ Registry must be disclosed to the public. In sub-paragraph
(a) of the second paragraph it was stated that “the name and address, and the registered electronic mail (KEP) address if one has been obtained, of the controller, of the controller’s representative, if any, and of the contact person,” must be disclosed to the public. With the amendment the paragraph was changed to read “the controller, the controller’s representative, if any, the address and, if one has been obtained, the KEP address,” , so that the phrase “the name of the contact person” was removed from the paragraph.
In my opinion, the fact that the regulation had made it mandatory to share the contact person’s personal data directly with the public was at odds with the rules adopted within the framework of Law No. 6698 and with the data protection culture that is sought to be established. The amendment is therefore in harmony with the philosophy of data protection law.
D. The Amendment to Article 11
Article 11 of the Regulation governs the obligations of the controller, the controller’s representative and the contact person. Paragraph 4 of the article provided: “Legal persons established in Türkiye shall enter the contact person’s details in the Registry at the time of registration with the Registry. The contact person is not authorised to represent the controller under the provisions of the Law and the Regulation. The contact person shall ensure communication with regard to the answering of the requests which data subjects address to the controller.” The paragraph was changed to read “Controllers established in Türkiye and, on behalf of controllers not established in Türkiye, controllers’ representatives shall enter the contact person’s details in the Registry at the time of registration with the Registry. The contact person is not authorised to represent the controller under the provisions of the Law and the Regulation.”, thereby clarifying who is to enter the contact person’s details in the Registry.
At the same time, since the expression “legal persons” alone is no longer used, it has once again been emphasised that controllers will not be legal persons only. In addition, the phrase “The contact person shall ensure communication with regard to the answering of the requests which data subjects address to the controller” has been removed from the provision. In my opinion the removal of this point, too, was appropriate. Indeed, this obligation of the contact person is already stated in paragraph 2 of the article; there is no need to repeat it.
Paragraph 5 of the same article states who the contact person is in public institutions and organisations. According to the provision, “In public institutions and organisations the contact person is the manager at the level of head of department or above who is designated by the senior manager for the purpose of ensuring communication with the Authority and who is entered in the Registry.” With the amendment this paragraph now reads “In public institutions and organisations the contact person is the manager at the level of head of department or above who is designated by the senior manager responsible for ensuring coordination, for the purpose of ensuring communication with the Authority, and who is entered in the Registry.” . The amendment made to the paragraph has clarified who is to appoint the contact person.
E. The Amendment to Article 13
Article 13 of the Regulation governs changes to be made to the registered information. Under the article, where there is a change in the information entered in the Registry, controllers must notify the Authority of the changes that have occurred within 7 days. In the text of the article this point was worded exactly as follows: “Where there is a change in the information registered in the Registry, controllers shall notify the Authority of the changes that have occurred, via VERBİS, within seven days.” In this form of the article it is not clear within which seven days the Authority must be notified.
With the amendment made on 28 April 2019 this article was reworded as “Where there is a change in the information registered in the Registry, controllers shall notify the Authority of the changes that have occurred, via VERBİS, within seven days of the date on which the change occurred.”, thereby clarifying when the notification must be made. According to this amendment, the controller is obliged to notify the Authority of changes arising in the records within seven days of the occurrence of the change.
F. The Amendment to Article 16
The last amendment made to the Regulation concerns the exemption criteria contained in Article 16 of the Regulation. This article states that, alongside the cases of exemption that are to be applied in any event, the Board has the power to introduce exemptions from the registration obligation, provided that it takes into account the conditions specified in the article. The published amendment adds one more to the exemption criteria. Under this added sub-paragraph, “Information on the controller’s annual number of employees or annual balance sheet total.” has also become one of the conditions under which the Board may introduce an exemption. This amendment has created a rule parallel to the criteria laid down, in Decision No. 2018/88 of the Personal Data Protection Board of 19/07/2018 concerning the “Starting Dates of the Obligation to Register with the Registry”, for the controllers on whom the obligation to register with Verbis is incumbent. According to the Decision, “controllers who are natural or legal persons and whose annual number of employees exceeds 50 or whose annual balance sheet total exceeds 25 million TL” must register with Verbis. In the paragraph added to the article, too, information on the number of employees and the annual balance sheet total has been added to the criteria, and the provision contained in the regulation has thus been brought into line with the decisions taken.
IV. The Amendments of 17 May 2019
By Official Gazette No. 30777 of 17 May 2019, the Regulation on the Disciplinary Superiors of the Personal Data Protection Authority was introduced and the Regulation on the Working Procedures and Principles of the Personal Data Protection Board was amended.
The Regulation on Disciplinary Superiors introduces supervisory rules concerning the internal functioning of the Authority and consists of seven provisions and one annex. The Regulation determines the disciplinary superiors and the senior disciplinary superiors of the Authority’s staff. The President of the Authority has been designated as the relevant disciplinary superior of the vice-president, the adviser to the presidency, the head of the private office and the heads of department reporting directly to the President of the Authority. On the other hand, while the disciplinary superior of the other heads of department will be the vice-president and their senior disciplinary superior the President of the Authority, the disciplinary superior of the staff working in the departments has been determined to be the head of the department concerned.
The regulation amending the Regulation on the Working Procedures and Principles of the Personal Data Protection Board, for its part, has brought into line with the presidential system the provision of the amended regulation which read “Five members of the Board shall be elected by the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye, two members by the President of the Republic and two members by the Council of Ministers.” The power in question of the Council of Ministers has been conferred on the office of the President of the Republic, which exercises the duties and powers of that body, and the provision has been changed to read “Five members of the Board shall be elected by the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye and four members by the President of the Republic.” . The amendment has also added to Article 5 the provision “Where the Second President is also absent, a member designated by the President shall deputise for the President.” , so that it is now provided that, where the President and the Second President are absent, a member to be designated will deputise for the President. In this way an attempt has been made to ensure that the functioning of the Board is not disrupted.
V. Conclusion
The conclusions reached on assessing the amendments to the regulations made by the Personal Data Protection Board and published in Official Gazette No. 30758 of 28 April 2019 and Official Gazette No. 30777 of 17 May 2019 may be listed as follows:
• By the amendment made to sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data, the definition of the personal data
inventory was recast, and it was stated that the inventory must also rest on legal bases and that the period required is the storage period.
• By the amendment made to paragraph 4 of Article 7 of the same regulation, the grammatical error contained in the regulation, which could give rise to confusion, was corrected and the word “or” was added.
• Again, by the amendment made to Article 12 of the regulation, it was stated that in erasure, destruction or anonymisation operations carried out at the request of the data subject reliance must be placed not only on Article 13 but also on Article 11.
• The definition of the contact person in sub-paragraph (ç) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry was revised and it was made clear that there may be controllers who are natural persons, so that the question whether controllers would consist of legal persons only was removed.
• Sub-paragraph (h) of the first paragraph of Article 4, for its part, again defines the personal data inventory, and the same amendment as that made to sub-paragraph (e) of the first paragraph of Article 4 of the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data was written into it so as not to cause confusion.
• In sub-paragraph (p) of the first paragraph of Article 4, an error that had been made was corrected and reference is now made to the third paragraph of Article 11 instead of its second paragraph.
• A new sentence was added to sub-paragraph (ç) of the first paragraph of Article 5 of the Regulation; by stating first of all that there is an obligation to prepare an inventory, a misinterpretation of the provision has been prevented.
• Again, in sub-paragraph (ğ) of the first paragraph of Article 5, the phrase “the maximum retention period necessary” was introduced into the paragraph, with the aim of preventing misinterpretation of the provision, and it was emphasised that the period required is the storage (retention) period.
• The disclosure to the public of the contact person’s name was removed from sub-paragraph (a) of the second paragraph of Article 7, and a rule consistent with the purpose of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data was thereby made.
• In paragraph 4 of Article 11 of the Regulation, again, an amendment was made which shows that controllers will not be legal persons only, and the phrase concerning the obligations of the contact person, which is already stated in paragraph 2, was removed from the paragraph.
• In paragraph 5 of Article 11, the question of who is to designate the contact person in public institutions and organisations was clarified.
• Article 13 of the Regulation states that changes occurring in the Verbis records must be notified to the Authority via Verbis within seven days of the date on which the change occurred. Here the uncertainty as to the period for notifying the change has been removed.
• One more criterion was added to the criteria for exemption from registration contained in Article 16 of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry, and a further criterion parallel to the situation of being obliged to register with the Registry was thereby introduced.
• By the introduction of the Regulation on the Disciplinary Superiors of the Personal Data Protection Authority, the relevant disciplinary superiors and senior disciplinary superiors in the internal supervision of the Authority were determined.
• By the Regulation Amending the Regulation on the Working Procedures and Principles of the Personal Data Protection Board it was provided, as regards the members of the Board, that the power to elect two members held by the Council of Ministers, which does not exist in the new system, is to be exercised by the President of the Republic, who holds its duties and powers.
• Lastly, the same regulation introduced a rule to the effect that, where the President and the Second President are absent, a member designated by the President will deputise for the President.
Footnotes
- Academic/Attorney-at-Law. ↑
- For my assessment of the Regulation see Murat Volkan Dülger, “Kişisel Verilerin Silinmesi, Yok Edilmesi veya Anonim Hale Getirilmesi Yönetmeliği’n Getirdikleri ve Yönetmelikte Dikkat Edilmesi Gereken Hususlar”, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.academia.edu/34991223/K%C4%B0%C5%9E%C4%B0SEL_VER%C4%B0LER%C4%B0N_S %C4%B0L%C4%B0NMES%C4%B0_YOK_ED%C4%B0LMES%C4%B0_VEYA_ANON%C4%B0M_HA LE_GET%C4%B0R%C4%B0LMES%C4%B0_HAKKINDA_Y%C3%96NETMEL%C4%B0K%C4%B0N_ GET%C4%B0RD%C4%B0KLER%C4%B0_VE_D%C4%B0KKAT_ED%C4%B0LMES%C4%B0_GERE KEN_HUSUSLAR (18 Mayıs 2019). ↑
- For my assessment of the Regulation see Murat Volkan Dülger, “Veri Sorumluları Sicili Hakkında Yönetmeliği’n Getirdikleri ve Yönetmelikte Dikkat Edilmesi Gereken Hususlar”, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.academia.edu/35552517/VER%C4%B0_SORUMLULARI_S%C4%B0C%C4%B0L%C4%B0_ HAKKINDA_Y%C3%96NETMEL%C4%B0K%C4%B0N_GET%C4%B0RD%C4%B0KLER%C4%B0_V E_Y%C3%96NETMEL%C4%B0KTE_D%C4%B0KKAT_ED%C4%B0LMES%C4%B0_GEREKEN_HU SUSLAR (18 Mayıs 2019). ↑
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Right to Be Forgotten” (Unutulma Hakkı), Essays in Honour of Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli (Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli’ye Armağan), Savaş Publishing, Ankara, 2024, pp. 1019–1141.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Assessment of the Amendments to the KVK Law on the Processing of Special Categories of Personal Data and the Transfer of Data Abroad” (KVK Kanunu’nda Özel Nitelikli Kişisel Verilerin İşlenmesi ve Yurt Dışına Veri Aktarımı Kapsamında Yapılan Değişikliklere İlişkin Değerlendirmeler), Academia.edu, 25 March 2024.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Our Assessment of the Decision Summaries Published by the Personal Data Protection Board on 18 July 2022” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulunun 18 Temmuz 2022 Tarihinde Yayınlanan Karar Özetlerine İlişkin Değerlendirmelerimiz), Dülger Law Office, 1 September 2022.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Use of Personal Health Data as Evidence in Divorce Proceedings” (Kişisel Sağlık Verilerinin Boşanma Davasında Delil Olarak Kullanılması), Hukuk ve Daha Fazlası Dergisi (Law and More), No. 9, June 2022, pp. 76–84.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “A Very Important Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board on Lawyers' Access to Enforcement Files Without a Power of Attorney” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulu’ndan Avukatların İcra Takip Dosyalarına Vekaletname Olmaksızın Erişebilmesine İlişkin Çok Önemli Bir Karar), Dülger Law Office, 15 August 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, Personal Data Protection Law (Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku), 4th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2026.

