7 May 2018Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

At a time when successive pieces of legislation are being enacted and decisions and communiqués published in order to regulate the field of personal data protection in full, there has been a further recent development on the subject: the “Regulation on the Organisation of the Personal Data Protection Authority”, which sets out the organisational structure of the Personal Data Protection Authority, the duties, powers and responsibilities of its service units, and its working procedures and principles, was published in the Official Gazette of 26 April 2018, No. 30403.

That the Authority’s organisational structure and service units would be governed by a regulation was, like the regulations published earlier, essentially an expected development. This is because paragraph 5 of Article 25 of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK), the article headed “Formation and duties of the Presidency”, stated that the service units and their working procedures and principles would be determined by regulation. A further step envisaged by the KVKK has thus been taken.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

In these days when one piece of legislation after another is being adopted, and decisions and communiqués are being published, in order to regulate the field of personal data protection comprehensively, there has been one more recent development on the subject: the “Regulation on the Organisation of the Personal Data Protection Authority”, which determines the organisational structure of the Personal Data Protection Authority, the duties, powers and responsibilities of its service units and the procedures and principles governing their work, was published in Official Gazette No. 30403 of 26 April 2018.

That the Authority's organisational structure and service units would be regulated by a regulation was in fact, like the regulations published earlier, an expected development. For Article 25(5) of Law No. 6698, entitled “Formation and duties of the Presidency”, had stated that the service units and the procedures and principles governing their work would be determined by a regulation. Thus one more step envisaged by the Law has been taken.

This was followed by the publication, in Official Gazette No. 30412 of 5 May 2018, of the “Regulation on Promotion and Change of Title of the Personnel of the Personal Data Protection Authority”. In this way the procedures and principles governing the promotion and change of title of the personnel serving at the Personal Data Protection Authority were determined, within the framework of the principles of merit and career and on the basis of the requirements of the service and personnel planning.

The subject of this article, however, is essentially the Organisation Regulation. In this context, in order to understand the provisions of the Regulation better, I shall first speak briefly of the structure of the Personal Data Protection Authority; I shall then set out my own views and assessment within the framework of the provisions of Law No. 6698 concerning the Authority and the innovations introduced by the Regulation.

Personal Data Protection Authority

The Personal Data Protection Authority was established, with administrative and financial autonomy and with public legal personality, to perform the duties assigned to it by Law No. 6698, and was regulated under Chapter 6 of the Law, entitled “Personal Data Protection Authority and Organisation”. Chapter 2 of the Regulation likewise sets out the structure and duties of the Authority in parallel with the Law.

The Personal Data Protection Authority, whose headquarters are in Ankara, consists of two separate branches, the Personal Data Protection Board and the Presidency, while its service units are organised as departments. The Regulation also states that the Authority is free to use the resources allocated to it within the framework of the procedures and principles laid down. As regards the duties of the Authority, no innovation was made and the relevant provision of the Law was repeated.

Personal Data Protection Board

The body that is envisaged as the Authority's decision-making organ and has nine members, one of whom is the President and one the Second President, is called the Personal Data Protection Board. The Board is able to exercise the duties and powers determined by the relevant legislation independently, without receiving orders, instructions or recommendations from any other person or organ. This shows that the intention was to set up the Board with an autonomous structure and that the legislation was framed accordingly; it also shows that an effort was made to bring the Law and the Regulation into line with the Council of Europe's Convention No. 108 on the Protection of Personal Data and with the EU's Directive 95/46/EC.

The activities which the Regulation, in addition to the Law, brings within the Board's remit are the following:

• To determine the procedures and principles for the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data:

In order to achieve this aim, the “Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction and Anonymisation of Personal Data” had been published in Official Gazette No. 30224 of 28 October 2017. Thus an obligation that was in fact already being performed in practice has been included among the duties by an article of the Regulation.

• To determine and announce the countries that have adequate protection for data to be transferred abroad and the countries that do not:

The article of the Law concerning data transfers had stated that the countries with adequate protection would be determined by the Board. The Regulation repeats the Board's duty to determine the countries that have adequate protection. In addition, from the literal meaning of the separate inclusion of the words “the countries that do not” it follows that the countries that do not have adequate protection will also be indicated separately. It may nevertheless also be understood to mean that a country not listed among those having adequate protection will be regarded directly as a country without adequate protection, with no need for any separate determination.

• To determine the sectoral implementation principles relating to the protection, processing and security of personal data, and to determine the procedures and principles in matters of accreditation, certification, training and guidance:

I think that this paragraph of the relevant article of the Regulation, in which the Board's duties are listed, is noteworthy. The fact that the personal data used differ from sector to sector, and that the principles for protecting and processing the data and ensuring their security accordingly also differ from one another, makes a sector-based practice indispensable. For this reason, determining on a sectoral basis the principles for the processing and security of personal data, so as to ensure their protection, has been listed among the Board's duties. I think that this is extremely important for practice and that, if sectoral determinations are made and decisions taken, practitioners will be able to take decisions more easily and more clearly.

In addition, once it was understood that, in order to ensure that work for the protection of personal data continues effectively, accreditation, certification and training work and guidance activities on the subject have to be carried out,

it was stated that the principles governing these activities must be determined by the Board.

• To inform institutions and organisations about the protection of personal data and to carry out awareness-raising activities directed at the public:

Because personal data are, unfortunately, a subject that has only recently come onto the agenda in our country, and sufficient awareness has therefore not yet developed, it was considered necessary to hold awareness training on personal data for institutions and organisations and for the public. The most recent initiative aimed at meeting the need for information and awareness that has arisen in this field is the publication, from the Authority's official Twitter account, of videos in the form of public service announcements in which the basic concepts specific to personal data are defined. In addition, the President and members of the Board take part as speakers in conferences and symposia all over the country, answer questions, and also hold regular meetings in Ankara, where the Authority has its headquarters. Work of this kind is very important and useful for bringing about sufficient awareness of the importance of personal data.

• To carry out cooperation and coordination work with universities and other relevant domestic and foreign institutions and organisations:

It is clear that the Authority's activities alone will not suffice for the Law to be applied and for the protection of personal data to be ensured. For, since personal data are a field peculiar to the human being, effective implementation is not possible through the internal work of one particular institution. For this reason the article of the Regulation lays down that the Board must establish cooperation on personal data with institutions and organisations. This cooperation and coordination work is also mentioned separately among the Board's duties.

Organisation of the Presidency

1. President

The President, who is elected by the Board from among its members, is, as head of the Board and of the Authority, the highest-ranking officer of the Authority. The President is responsible for the general management and representation of the Authority, with a view to conducting the Authority's services in conformity with the legislation. As regards the President's duties and powers, the relevant provision was repeated verbatim, without departing from the provisions of the Law.

Together with the President, a Second President is also elected, again by the Board, since the Second President deputises for the President in the latter's absence. In the absence of the Second President as well, a member designated by the President performs the office of President in an acting capacity.

2. Vice President

The duty of assisting the President in exercising the duties and powers conferred on the President by the Law and in performing the President's obligations is carried out by the Vice President.

3. Heads of service units

The heads of the service units are appointed by the President and are charged with performing the obligations determined by the relevant legislation and by decisions of the Board. In the Organisation Regulation, ensuring harmony, cooperation and the division of labour among their staff, and the other duties assigned by the President, are laid down as their principal obligations.

Service Units and Their Duties

The service units of the Authority determined by the Regulation are as follows:

• Department of Data Management:

The Department's principal duties include determining the procedures and principles for the processing of personal data and carrying out work on the duties and responsibilities of the controller, the controller's representative and the contact person. In addition, all work and acts relating to the Data Controllers' Registry, and the proceedings to be taken against those who fail to fulfil the obligation to inform, are laid down among the duties of the Department of Data Management.

• Department of Examination:

The Department's most important duty is to carry out the preliminary examination or the examination on the merits of applications to the controller and of complaints to be made to the Board, and to conduct all related work and acts. Besides applications made to the Board, where an ex officio examination is at issue the Department of Examination will likewise act in the matter. Conducting the proceedings against those who fail to comply with the decisions given by the Board, and the business relating to the Board's decisions and meetings, are also listed among the Department's duties.

• Department of Legal Affairs:

As is clear from its name, the basic duty of the Department of Legal Affairs is to conduct and conclude the legal transactions to which the Authority is a party and, in addition, to provide opinions and advisory services on legal matters.

• Department of Data Security and Information Systems:

It must be accepted that taking legal measures alone is not sufficient to achieve compliance with the Law and to ensure the protection of personal data. In projects for compliance with the Law in particular, companies providing data security must without fail take part alongside lawyers specialising in personal data. It is precisely at this point that determining and supervising the technical measures to be taken in protecting personal data, and conducting all work and acts relating to data security, have been left to the Department of Data Security and Information Systems.

• Department of Guidance, Research and Corporate Communication:

The Department's basic duties include conducting research at national and international level on the matters within the Authority's remit, determining standards relating to the protection of personal data and running projects on matters where they are needed. The aim is thus for the Authority to develop by also establishing cooperation with institutions and organisations in the field of personal data protection, with universities and with civil society organisations. The Department of Guidance, Research and Corporate Communication will take the lead in raising the level of awareness in the field of personal data, keeping pace with developments and bringing about innovations.

• Department of Human Resources and Support Services:

The Department concerned has been made responsible for all work and acts relating to the Authority's personnel, above all determining the Authority's human resources policy and preparing and implementing the career and training plans of the personnel.

• Department of Strategy Development:

Preparing the Authority's internal strategic plan, determining its aims and objectives, service quality standards and performance criteria, drawing up a financial budget in parallel with these, and preparing reports on its financial position, including the Authority's performance, and on its annual activities are laid down among the Department's basic duties. All transactions relating to the Authority's budget and financial position, such as its charts of accounts, financial expenditure and annual financial reports, are carried out here.

Personnel of the Authority

It is stated that changes of title and grade, the addition of new titles and the cancellation of vacant posts will be effected by decision of the Board, provided that the total number of posts is not exceeded and within the limits of the post titles determined by the relevant legislation. The power to distribute the personnel has been given to the President, also in view of the service units I have explained above.

We see that the provisions of the Regulation on the Authority's personnel include two new titles. Accordingly, up to ten persons may be appointed as “presidency adviser” to provide advisory services to the President and to perform the other duties to be determined by the President. In addition, a “head of the private office” will be appointed to perform the duty of organising and running the President's schedule.

Miscellaneous and Final Provisions

The seventh and last chapter of the Regulation, entitled miscellaneous and final provisions, contains the provisions on internal audit and on the power to regulate. Accordingly:

• Internal audit and examination and investigation proceedings within the Authority will be carried out through authorised persons to be assigned by the President. However, those of the said proceedings, or of their results, that fall within the Board's duties and powers must be submitted to the Board for its information.

• The power to decide on matters concerning the organisational structure of the Personal Data Protection Authority that are not covered by this Regulation or on which it leaves a gap belongs to the Board, subject to compliance with the relevant legislation.

Conclusion

The latest stage in the developments concerning the field of personal data protection has been realised with the “Regulation on the Organisation of the Personal Data Protection Authority” and the “Regulation on Promotion and Change of Title of the Personnel of the Personal Data Protection Authority”, which were also envisaged by Law No. 6698. For this reason I regard the publication of the Regulation as a positive development, first of all because the legislation envisaged by the Law is being made and an effort is being made to ensure that work in the field of personal data continues effectively.

I should like to touch on the importance of the Regulation on two points in particular. The first of these is the paragraphs listed among the Board's duties in addition to the duties specified in Law No. 6698. As I explained in detail above, new duties have been added to those of the Board, and it is envisaged that new work will be done with the aim of ensuring the protection of personal data. I think that these new duties listed in the relevant article will be very effective for the application of the Law.

The other important point is that the departments forming the service units, which constitute one branch of the Authority's organisational structure, have been determined by the Regulation, and that duties have been allocated by listing the duties and powers of the departments so determined. Each department will thus provide services within its own remit and will also be able to work together with the other departments in common areas. In particular, the fact that the periods set for compliance with the Law expired as of 7 April 2018 is such as to intensify the Board's work. For this reason the determination of duties has come at the right time, especially with regard to the Board's examinations upon complaint or ex officio and the decisions it will give as a result of those examinations.

The Organisation Regulation has determined the organisational structure of the Personal Data Protection Authority, the duties, powers and responsibilities of its service units and the procedures and principles governing their work. The aim is thus that the duties and powers conferred on the Authority by Law No. 6698 and the other relevant legislation should be carried out not only by the President and the Vice President but also through the service units provided for. Work having been distributed among the service units, the protection of personal data and compliance with the Law will be pursued within the framework of the cooperation to be established among these units.

The Regulation on Promotion and Change of Title has determined, within the framework of the principles of merit and career and on the basis of the requirements of the service and personnel planning, the procedures and principles governing the promotion and change of title of the personnel serving at the Personal Data Protection Authority. Determining the principles and procedures according to which the Authority's employees will advance in their profession is an important development for its institutionalisation.

Footnotes

  1. Academic/Attorney-at-law. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic