30 April 2018Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

One of the matters that aroused most curiosity in the field of personal data protection was undoubtedly the decisions that the Personal Data Protection Board would render. Because the practice was new, many open questions naturally caused confusion: which points the Board would attend to and give weight to when deciding, which subjects the decisions would concentrate on, on what basis a breach would be assessed in a specific case, and whether the decisions would be published. At last a development capable of answering such questions to a certain extent has taken place, and the Board has published summaries of some of the decisions it has rendered.

The publication of a variety of decisions finding breaches in relation to personal data offers guidance, particularly for those concerned with the subject and for data controllers and data processors who have to bring themselves into compliance with the obligations introduced by Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK). I will examine the decisions published by the Board from the standpoint of the obligation that was introduced by the KVKK and is the subject of each decision, and I will touch on the points at which, and the reasons for which, a breach was found in the specific case. In this way I will try to make the Board’s approach to the subject understood and to enable the KVKK to be considered and assessed within the scope of the decisions rendered.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

One of the most keenly awaited matters in the field of the protection of personal data was undoubtedly the decisions that the Personal Data Protection Board would render. Because the practice is new, a great many question marks naturally caused confusion: what points the Board would pay attention and attach importance to when deciding, what subjects its decisions would concentrate on, on what basis the assessment of a breach would be made in a concrete case, and whether or not the decisions would be published.

At last, a development capable of answering questions of this kind to a certain extent has taken place, and the summaries of some of the decisions rendered by the Board have been published by the Board. The publication of a variety of decisions finding breaches in relation to personal data provides guidance, in particular for those interested in the subject and for the controllers and processors who are obliged to bring themselves into compliance with the obligations introduced by the Law.

I shall take up the decisions published by the Board from the standpoint of the obligation that was introduced by Law No. 6698 and forms the subject of each decision, and shall touch upon the points at which, and the reasons for which, the conclusion that there had been a breach was reached in the concrete case. In this way I shall try to make the Board’s perspective on the subject understood and to have the Law addressed and assessed within the framework of the decisions rendered.

Decisions of the Personal Data Protection Board

1. Late notification of a personal data security breach

The duties and powers of the controller with regard to ensuring the security of personal data are regulated in Article 12 of the Law, headed “obligations concerning data security”1. Accordingly:

• The controller is obliged to take all necessary technical and administrative measures in order to prevent the unlawful processing of personal data and unlawful access to such data, and to ensure that the data are preserved.

• Where there is a processor, the controller and the processor are jointly responsible for the taking of these measures.

• The controller is obliged to carry out, or to have carried out, the necessary audits in order to ensure the implementation of the Law.

• Controllers and processors may not unlawfully disclose or use the personal data they have learned in the course of their duties; this also applies after they have left office.

• Where the personal data processed are obtained by others by unlawful means, the controller must notify the data subject and the Board of this situation within the shortest time.

Among the obligations that the controller must fulfil in order to ensure data security, the requirement that, where the personal data processed are obtained by others by unlawful means, the controller notify the data subject and the Board of this situation within the shortest time is noteworthy. For since the expression “the shortest time” in the text of the article does not denote a specific period, it cannot be fully understood what this concept is to be taken to mean. That said, it is not possible for the legislature, when making a statutory provision, to foresee the shortest time for each concrete case. Indeed, there are situations in which the time needed to fulfil the obligation laid down by law may differ from one case to another on account of the prevailing circumstances. Where uncertain situations and concepts of this kind exist, what needs to be done is to try to clarify the uncertain concept through the decisions to be rendered by the institutions and bodies charged with ensuring the implementation of the Law.

In the concrete case on this subject that came before the Board, the data breach that occurred was notified

by the controllerto the data subjects after 17 months and to the Board after a period of 10 months. The Board concluded that these periods
exceeded the shortest time specified in the Law and that a data security breach
had therefore occurred. In this context, with regard to the controller concerned, pursuant to Article 18
paragraph 1(b) of the Law, which provides forthe administrative sanction to be imposed on those who fail to fulfil the obligations concerning data security,

it was decided that a sanction be applied accordingly.

In order for the controller to be able to fulfil the obligation to notify the data subject and the Board within the shortest time where the personal data processed are obtained by others by unlawful means, it is important that this period be determined; and exactly what was to be understood by this period was a matter of curiosity for controllers. We have thus come to understand that 17 months as regards the persons concerned, and 10 months as regards notification to the Board, is a long period. In this respect the decision rendered on the subject is decisive and helpful.

However, the failure to disclose which sector the decision relates to is a significant shortcoming for the purpose of assessing this period; and even if the sector were disclosed, the Board’s failure to state what the minimum period for it is would also remain a significant shortcoming, and the question marks in people’s minds would remain unresolved. My expectation, therefore, is that the Board should publish its decisions in full; that, even if it does not disclose the natural or legal person against whom it has decided, it should at least give information about that person’s sector; and that, by setting as far as possible sub-periods in the nature of recommendations, it should act in accordance with the principle of certainty and provide guidance to practitioners.

2. Making explicit consent a condition of the service

The concept of explicit consent is defined by an article of the Law; according to this definition, the following conditions must be met before explicit consent can be said to exist:

• relating to a specific subject,

• based on information,

• expressed with free will: the existence of a declaration of consent of this kind means explicit consent2. Article 5(1) of the Law, headed “conditions for the processing of personal data”, and Article 6(2), headed “conditions for the processing of special categories of personal data”, prohibit the processing of personal data and of special categories of personal data without explicit consent. The exceptions under which processing may take place without explicit consent are then set out in the remainder of those articles.

The point I particularly wish to clarify here is whether explicit consent and the other exceptional cases have any precedence over one another. An interpretation based on the wording of the Law yields the meaning that explicit consent is the rule and takes priority over the other exceptional cases. From the statement made by the Board in reply to the questions we put to it on this matter, however, it became clear that the Board’s perspective is entirely different from the interpretation based on the wording of the Law. According to the Board’s statement, the case in which explicit consent is obtained from the data subject is likewise, in parallel with the provisions of Directive 95/46/EC, on the same level as the other exceptional cases. Consequently, in personal data processing activities there is no question of any precedence of one over the other.

Another point that I wish to underline is whether explicit consent needs to be obtained from the data subject where the exceptional cases for the processing of personal data and of special categories of personal data listed in Article 5(2) and Article 6(3) of the Law exist. If it is obtained, does this explicit consent have any validity? Moreover, is the obtaining of explicit consent lawful even where the exceptional cases exist?

The conclusion reached on this matter by interpreting the Law was that obtaining explicit consent is unnecessary where the exceptional cases exist. It was unclear, however, whether this would constitute unlawfulness. Again according to the statement made by the Board in reply to these questions of ours, since obtaining explicit consent where the exceptional cases exist is liable to mislead and misdirect the data subject, where any one of the exceptional cases for data processing specified by the Law exists for the controller, obtaining explicit consent is not merely unnecessary; it is prohibited and unlawful. For in such a situation the impression is created in the mind of the data subject that, if he withdraws explicit consent, the controller must put an end to the data processing activity. Yet the controller must continue the data processing activity in question in order to be able to fulfil the obligations imposed on it by the Law. For this reason, where an exceptional case exists, the data processing activity will be based by the controller on that exception, and explicit consent may not be obtained from the data subject.

In the concrete case that was the subject of the decision rendered by the Board, the controller’s personal data processing activity rests on the exceptional case specified in Article 5(2)(c) of the Law: “it is necessary to process personal data belonging to the parties to a contract, provided that this is directly related to the conclusion or performance of that contract”. However, despite the existence of this exceptional case,

explicit consent was obtained from the data subject, and this explicit consentwas imposed as a condition of the membership and of the service, and hence
of the contract. Two distinct instances of unlawfulness thus
arose in the case:

• The controller obtained explicit consent from the data subject even though it was in any event obliged to carry out the personal data processing activity in order to fulfil the obligations imposed on it by the Law within the scope of the contract to which it is a party.

• The explicit consent obtained from the data subject was made subject to a condition, and it was insisted that the service would be provided only if explicit consent was given. Yet according to the definition in the Law, explicit consent must be expressed with free will and must therefore not be made subject to any condition.

The unlawful situations described resulted, on the part of the controller, in a breach of the Law’s “General

principles” in Article 4, namely of paragraph 2(a), “conformity with the law and the rules of good faith”, and of
paragraph 2(ç) of the same article, “being connected with, limited to and proportionate to the purpose of processing”.
It was therefore concluded that the controller had failed, as regards data security,
to fulfil its obligations, and pursuant to Article 18 paragraph 1(b) of the Law
it was decided that an administrative sanction be imposed.
This situation clearly shows us that, where one of the grounds for processing personal data specified in Article 5(2) of the Law
exists, explicit consent must not be obtained.
The aim is thus to prevent “consent pollution”, and it is stated in clear terms that acting on the logic of “you never know, I had better obtain it
and have it to hand” is unlawful, will give rise to a breach and
will be met with a sanction.
3. Processing/transfer of more personal data than the purpose of processing requires3 (Breach of the principle of data
minimisation)

According to Article 4(1)(ç) of the Law, headed “General principles”, which sets out the procedures and principles to be observed during the processing of personal data, personal data may be processed only in a manner that is connected with, limited to and proportionate to the purpose for which they are processed. As is also explained in the explanatory memorandum to the Law, this principle requires that the data processed be suitable for achieving the specified purposes and that the processing of personal data which are unrelated to the achievement of the purpose or are not needed be avoided. Accordingly, all processing and transfer activities to be carried out on personal data must be carried out only on as much personal data as is necessary.

In the case decided by the Board, a courtrequested from the controller, concerning the data subject,
certain personal data. The controller is bound to comply with this request of the court pursuant to the Law’s
Article 8, headed “transfer of personal data”, whose paragraph 2 refers to the Law’s Article 5,
paragraph 2(ç), which provides: “it is necessary for the controller to be able to fulfil

its legal obligation”. However, the controller must carry out the activity of transferring personal data, which it will perform lawfully, only to the extent of the personal data requested by the court, and must not transfer more than the personal data requested. In the case at hand, however, it was established that the controller had transferred more personal data than the court had asked for, and hence more than was necessary. A breach of the general principles to be observed in the processing of personal data thus occurred. As a result, on the ground of failure to fulfil the obligations concerning data security, it was again decided, pursuant to Article 18(1)(b) of the Law, that an administrative sanction be imposed on the controller.

This is a form of unlawfulness that I have frequently encountered and criticised in practice in the investigation and prosecution
(trial) of various disputes. In private law
proceedings the parties, and in criminal procedure in particular the law enforcement authorities, the auxiliaries of the investigating authority,
or the intervening party, resort to this course in order somehow to belittle the other party or the accused in the eyes of the court,
to prove their own position better, or to turn the proceedings into a trial of the perpetrator rather than of the act.
With the decision it has rendered, the Board has, quietly,
in fact taken a step towards a very great change. This is a change of mentality, and everyone must
embrace it and comply with it. In this way, on the one hand, the unnecessary and unlawful dissemination to the public of a great many
personal data will be prevented; on the other, the discussion before the courts of matters
unrelated to the subject of the dispute will be avoided; and lastly, a contribution will also be made to
procedural economy. This decision is therefore, from whichever angle one looks at it, extremely positive and
beneficial.
4. Failure by the controller, within the period laid down in the Law, to reply to the data
subject
With regard to the implementation of the Law, the data subject has, under the article of the Law headed “application to the controller”,
namely Article 13, the right to apply to the controller. This application
will be made within the framework of the rights listed in Article 11 of the Law, headed “rights of the data subject”.
The article regulates the data subject’s right to learn of, and to request, every kind of operation and act concerning his personal data,
and to obtain information about those data.

Pursuant to Article 13 of the Law, the controller must conclude the requests contained in the data subject’s application free of charge within the shortest time, depending on the nature of the request, and within thirty days at the latest. In addition, pursuant to Article 15(5) of the Law, where, as a result of the examination carried out upon complaint or of its own motion, the Board concludes that there has been a breach, the Board decides that the instances of unlawfulness identified be remedied by the controller, and this decision is notified to those concerned.

In the decision rendered by the Boardit was decided that the controller, as regards the decision notified under Article 15 paragraph 5 of the Law,
must reply to the data subject within 30 days of the notification of that decision,
failing which an administrative sanction would be imposed on it pursuant to Article 18 of the Law,
and that the controller be instructed to this effect.
This decision shows us that the data subject must be given a reply; that, where there is a complaint that no reply was given,
this will be classified as a breach if the conditions are met; that such complaints are taken into
account; and that, as regards compliance by controllers with the obligations contained in the law and the regulation,
the Authority is exacting. In this respect the decision is extremely
important.

5. Failure to comply with the data subject’s request for the erasure of his personal data4

As regards the case forming the subject of this Board decision, the relevant provision is, within the article of the Law that lists, for the processing of personal data,
the procedures and principles to be observed, namely Article 4, paragraph 2(d). According to it, in the processing of personal data
the following principle applies: “Being retained for the period laid down in the relevant legislation or for the period necessary for the purpose

for which they are processed”. This principle is highly important in the processing of personal data; indeed, it is one of the matters with which compliance proves most difficult. Since, unfortunately, the importance of the protection of personal data has not yet been sufficiently realised in our country, controllers refrain from erasing the personal data on which processing activities have been carried out even when those data are no longer needed. This gives rise to the phenomenon we call a “data dump”. However, with the Law and the other relevant statutory provisions, these habits must be abandoned, and the awareness must take root that personal data are to be kept for as long as is necessary for the purpose for which they are processed.

Personal data lawfully processed by the controller must be retained for the period laid down in the relevant legislation or, failing that, for the period necessary for the purpose for which they are processed. Once this period has elapsed, pursuant to Article 7 of the “Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data”, the personal data processed must be erased, destroyed or anonymised by the controller, of its own motion or at the request of the data subject5.

Attention must also be paid to the retention of the personal data processed for the period laid down in the legislation or necessary for the purpose for which they are processed, particularly in the context of the processes of compliance with the Law. Indeed, according to the definition of the personal data inventory in the above-mentioned Regulation, the maximum period necessary for the purposes for which the personal data are processed must be included in the personal data inventory.

In the case that was the subject of the Board’s decision, the controller,under the legislation to which it is subject, is obliged to retain the
personal data it has processed for 10 years. For this reason, the Board
decided that, as regards the personal data of inactive customers, in conformity with the general principles set out in Article 4 of the Law,
such data must not be processed for any purpose other than storage, and that the
controller be instructed accordingly.
Consequently, even if the controller has a valid legal ground and a reason for processing data,
it must do so in line with the ground for processing that it has indicated in the data inventory for processing the data, that is, the legitimate reason.
Even if the other elements are present, where there is no legitimate reason
and it nevertheless processes the data, the Law will have been breached.
6. Failure to take the necessary administrative and technical measures aimed at providing an appropriate level of security
for the purpose of ensuring the security of personal data

The controller’s obligations concerning data security are regulated in Article 12 of the Law, as I explained in detail above in the part in which I assessed the Board’s first decision. Accordingly, the controller is obliged to take all necessary technical and administrative measures in order to prevent the unlawful processing of personal data and unlawful access to such data, and to ensure that the data are preserved.

In the case that was the subject of the decision,

the sending by the controller of a document containing the personal data of the data subject, who is also its customer,
to another person bearing the same name, and
the querying by an employee of the controller, although there was no request to that effect, of the personal data of the data subject, who is also its
customer, through the systems for which the employee had been granted authorisation,
for the employee’s own personal purposes

were at issue.

The sending of the document containing the customer’s personal data to another person of the same name was regarded by the Board as indicating a systemic vulnerability on the part of the controller.

It was thus concluded that the controllerhad not taken, with regard to ensuring data security, the necessary technical and administrative
measures.
The querying by an employee of the controller of a customer’s personal data for the employee’s own personal purposes
is in fact a frequently encountered instance of a breach of the protection of personal data.
For example, the employees of companies that are controllers are in the position of processors, and, so that
they can fulfil the obligations arising from their professional activities, there are systems
for which they have been granted authorisation. However, employees in the position of processors
must use these systems only within the scope of the activities that they are obliged to carry out
by reason of the position they hold. Yet nowadays this is frequently violated, and
persons who are able to reach people’s data gain access to those data in pursuit of their own personal interests.
In essence this has to do with people’s outlook on the protection of personal data
and is a matter of a culture on the subject taking shape. Controllers, who, together with processors,
are in the position of being jointly responsible, must be highly careful
in this regard. For even if the controller has ensured that the necessary administrative and technical measures on the matter are taken,
it must, as part of those measures, additionally ensure that the processors who are in the position of employees
acquire the necessary awareness through training to be given in the field of the protection of personal data.
Otherwise the controller itself will also be held responsible alongside the processor.
In the decision too, because the employee, a processor, by means of the systems assigned to him,
queried the customer’s personal data in pursuit of his own personal interests, it was concluded that the
controller had not taken the necessary technical and administrative measures to ensure data security.
For both unlawful acts it was decided, pursuant to Article 18 of the Law, that administrative
action be taken.

7. Processing of personal data contrary to the general principles contained in the Law

During every kind of processing activity to be carried out on personal data, the general principles listed in Article 4 of the Law must be observed6. Where personal data are processed contrary to these principles, there will be unlawfulness.

In the case examined by the Board, in a transaction carried out by the controller at the request of the data subject,
the controller asked the customer for a document containing personal data that the transaction did not
require. However, the request for this document is not based on any provision of legislation,
nor is it compatible with the aim pursued. For these reasons, it was concluded that the
act of requesting the document carried out by the controller was contrary to Article 4 paragraph 2(a) of the Law,
that is, to the principle of “conformity with the law and the rules of good faith”, and to paragraph 2(c),
that is, to the principle of “being processed for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes”.
As a consequence of this conclusion, with regard to the controller, which had not taken the necessary technical
and administrative measures to ensure personal data security, it was decided, pursuant to Article 18 of the Law, that an administrative
sanction be imposed.
One of the acts we frequently see in practice, namely the requesting, even for a simple transaction, of an unnecessarily large number of personal data, and of special categories at that,
formed the subject of this decision. After this decision,
controllers need to review their business processes and, in their personal data protection and processing
policies, make the necessary corrections and changes, and, if they have no such policies, to draw them up
as soon as possible.

8. Sharing of personal data in breach of the Law

The sharing and transfer activities carried out in the context of the processing of personal data
must be based on the relevant provisions of the Law in which the conditions for processing are set out. Where the
controller shares personal data with third parties without relying on these conditions,
unlawfulness will arise.
In the case that was the subject of the Board’s decision, the controller sent to the employees of a company, by e-mail,
sample contracts. In the part of the contracts for the employer’s e-mail address,
the company’s address should have been entered; yet the controller, without relying on any condition for processing,
entered the home address of the data subject, the person responsible for managing the process on the company’s behalf.
The controller thus shared, in respect of the data subject responsible for managing the process on the company’s behalf,
that person’s personal data with third parties without any justification; within the scope of Article 12
of the Law it had thereby failed to ensure data security, and pursuant to Article 18
of the Law it was decided that an administrative sanction be imposed on the controller.

This decision is important in that it shows that the Board is exacting even in respect of acts committed negligently. Even if the person is the company’s own employee, the erroneous sharing of his full address amounts to a breach of the controller’s obligations. Of course, what we cannot see in this decision

is how this application by the company employee affected the employee–employer
relationship.

Conclusion

Following an assessment of the decisions which the Personal Data Protection Board published after evaluating the complaints lodged with it and carrying out its examination,
the points to which, in my view, attention needs to be paid
are as follows:
Where the personal data processed are obtained by others by unlawful means,
the controller must notify the data subject and the Board within the shortest time.
The shortest time must be determined according to the circumstances of the concrete case. In the case that was the subject of the Board’s decision,
the periods at issue, 10 and 17 months, are such as to be of assistance
in determining these periods.However, I must state that the absence from the decision of any indication of the sector to which it relates,

and, even if the sector were disclosed, of the minimum period envisaged by the Board for the sector in question, is something I regard as a shortcoming. My expectation for the decisions to be published from now on is that the Board should publish its decisions in full, give information about the sector against which it has decided and, by setting as far as possible sub-periods in the nature of recommendations, act in accordance with the principle of certainty and provide guidance to practitioners.

• In cases where explicit consent must be obtained from the data subject for the processing of personal data, it is not possible for the controller to make this explicit consent subject to a condition. Moreover, since obtaining explicit consent where the exceptional cases specified in Article 5(2) of the Law exist is liable to mislead the data subject, the obtaining of explicit consent in such cases is unlawful. The aim is thus to prevent “consent pollution”, and it is stated in clear terms that acting, despite the existence of the exceptional cases, on the logic of “you never know, I had better obtain it and have it to hand” is unlawful, will give rise to a breach and will be met with a sanction.

• In accordance with the principle that personal data may be processed only in a manner that is connected with, limited to and proportionate to the purpose for which they are processed, the data processed must be suitable for achieving the specified purposes, and the processing of personal data that are unrelated to the achievement of the purpose or are not needed

must be avoided.In the face of this situation, which I have frequently encountered in practice in the investigation
and prosecution (trial) of various disputes,
the decision rendered by the Board has in essence been the first step taken towards a very great
change. With this decision, which I believe will be extremely beneficial in every respect,
the unnecessary and unlawful dissemination to the public of a great many personal data will be prevented,
the discussion before the courts of matters unrelated to the subject of the dispute
will be avoided and, lastly, a contribution will also be made to procedural economy.
The controller must reply to the data subject, on the matters he has requested under Article 11 of the Law,
pursuant to Article 15 paragraph 5 of the Law, counting from the notification of the Board’s decision,
within 30 days. This decision is extremely important in that it shows us that the data subject must be given a reply;
that, where there is a complaint that no reply was given, this, if the conditions are met,
will be classified as a breach; that such complaints are taken into account; and that, as regards compliance by controllers
with the obligations contained in the law and the regulation,
the Authority is exacting.

Where the controller does not comply with the request of a customer who is currently inactive for the erasure of his personal data
on the ground that, under the legislation to which it is subject, it is under an obligation to retain them,
then, even though the personal data are not erased,
the personal data in question must not, in conformity with the general principles, be processed for any purpose other than storage.
Consequently, even if the controller has a valid legal ground and a reason
for processing data, it must do so in line with the ground for processing that it has indicated in the data inventory for processing the data,
that is, the legitimate reason. Even if the other elements
are present, where there is no legitimate reason and it nevertheless processes the data,
the Law will have been breached.
The sending by the controller, as a result of an error, of a document containing personal data to another
person, and the querying by one of its employees, through the systems for which that employee had been granted
authorisation, of the data subject’s personal data in pursuit of the employee’s own personal interests,
indicate a systemic vulnerability and therefore mean that the controller, as regards data security,
has not taken the necessary technical and administrative measures to ensure it.
In every kind of processing activity carried out on personal data, the general principles laid down by the
Law must be complied with. After this decision, rendered in response to something we also frequently
see in practice, namely the requesting of an unnecessary number of personal data even for a simple transaction,
controllers need to review their business processes and,
in their personal data protection and processing policies, make the necessary corrections and changes
or, if they have no such policies, draw them up as soon as possible.
The sharing and transfer activities carried out in the context of the processing of personal data
must be based on the conditions for processing personal data laid down by the Law. The real importance of this decision,
however, lies in the fact that, even in the case of negligent acts committed by erroneously sharing a person’s full address,
even where that person is the company’s own employee, the Board is exacting,
as the decision shows.
I think that the publication of the decisions rendered by the Board on matters constituting the fundamental points
of the field of the protection of personal data will, for controllers, be highly
beneficial.

Another point that I wish to underline here is that the controllers who are obliged to bring themselves into compliance with the Law had to do so within 6 months for the new personal data they recorded after 7 April 2016, the date on which the Law was published, and within 2 years for the data recorded before that date, which we call archive data. At present, therefore, the obligations introduced by the Law must be complied with in the processing of all personal data that have been or are being kept, whether old or new. The periods laid down by the Law have already expired. For this reason, the examinations to be carried out by the Board of its own motion or upon the application of the data subject will intensify, and decisions will be rendered on many different points. Moreover, the fact that controllers have not brought themselves into compliance with the Law even though the periods have expired will bring about an increase in the decisions finding breaches to be rendered by the Board. For this reason too, I warn controllers that they need to bring themselves into compliance with the Law as soon as possible, also taking into account the decisions in question rendered by the Board, and I recommend that they undertake projects for compliance with the Law.

Footnotes

  1. Academic/Attorney-at-law. ↑
  2. For the Kişisel Veri Güvenliği Rehberi (Teknik ve İdari Tedbirler) see: https://kvkk.gov.tr/SharedFolder Server/CMSFiles/7512d0d4-f345-41cb-bc5b-8d5cf125e3a1.pdf. ↑
  3. For the Açık Rıza Rehberi see: https://kvkk.gov.tr/SharedFolderServer/CMSFiles/66b2e9c4-223a-4230-b745- 568f096fd7de.pdf. ↑
  4. For the Kişisel Verilerin İşlenme Şartları Rehberi see: https://kvkk.gov.tr/SharedFolderServer/CMSFiles/ 8c90423f-97ea-4d81-a7c1-ace74295c2b8.pdf
  5. For the guide on the data subject’s methods of seeking redress see: https://kvkk.gov.tr/SharedFolderServer/CMSFiles/ 7226b55d-b1e7-4e78-a3c4-0b1ba82ce542.pdf. ↑
  6. For the Kişisel Verilerin Silinmesi, Yok Edilmesi veya Anonim Hale Getirilmesi Rehberi see: https://kvkk.gov.tr/SharedFolderServer/CMSFiles/bc1cb353-ef85-4e58-bb99-3bba31258508.pdf. ↑
  7. For the guide on the fundamental principles relating to the processing of personal data see: https://kvkk.gov.tr/SharedFolderServer/ CMSFiles/d0fbca08-30af-41fe-a7c9-65663b9c5231.pdf. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic