2019Murat Volkan DülgerPresentation / talk

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

This contains the GDPR presentation that I gave on 7 February 2019 at the 2nd Personal Data Protection Symposium (II. Kişisel Verileri Koruma Sempozyumu) organised by the Personal Data Protection Authority.

Text of the presentation

This text is a translation, prepared for this website, of the short prose version of the presentation. The slides, images and tables are in the PDF version.

The emergence of the Regulation

For a long time, the protection of personal data was dealt with under the headings of “privacy” or “respect for private and family life”. Over time it came to be accepted that the scope of these rights differs, and the right to the protection of personal data began to be regarded as a separate and independent right among the fundamental rights.

Directive 95/46/EC, which governed this field in the EU, was interpreted differently in different countries and therefore could not be transposed uniformly into national laws. Technological development made it necessary to harmonise the law and to adopt new legislation. With the aim of modernising the existing principles, the European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) was adopted on 24 May 2016 and, after a two-year transition period, became applicable on 25 May 2018. Replacing the Directive, the Regulation consists of 99 articles grouped in 11 chapters and 173 recitals.

Basic concepts and scope of application

Personal data means any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person (Art. 4). In assessing identifiability, account is taken of all reasonable means that may be used, directly or indirectly, to identify the person. The controller determines the purposes and means of the processing; the processor processes the data on the controller's behalf and in accordance with its instructions. Special categories of personal data include racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, beliefs, trade union membership, genetic and biometric data, and data concerning health and sex life.

The Regulation applies to processing in the context of the activities of an establishment of a controller or processor in the Union, even where the processing does not take place in the Union (Art. 3). Those established outside the Union who offer goods or services to persons in the Union, or who monitor their behaviour within the Union, are also subject to the Regulation. In its Weltimmo judgment (C-230/14, 1 October 2015), the CJEU interpreted the concept of “establishment” broadly. A company incorporated under the law of another country is regarded as established in a country where it carries on activities in a stable and effective manner.

Principles of data processing

Article 5 lists the principles of lawfulness, fairness and transparency; purpose limitation; data minimisation; accuracy; storage limitation; data security; and accountability. Under the transparency principle, every communication to the data subject must be concise, intelligible, easily accessible and in clear and plain language. In this context the presentation referred to the ECtHR judgments in K.H. and Others v. Slovakia and Haralambie v. Romania.

Under the purpose limitation principle, processing for a purpose incompatible with the original one requires fresh consent or another legal basis; where the purposes are compatible, no fresh consent is needed. Archiving in the public interest, scientific or historical research and statistical purposes are deemed a priori compatible with the original purposes. Data minimisation requires the data to be “limited to what is necessary”, whereas the Directive and Convention No. 108 used the criterion of “not excessive” (CJEU, Digital Rights Ireland). As regards accuracy, the Regulation requires data to be kept up to date only “where necessary”. For this reason, updating certain data is legally prohibited; for example, the findings in a medical record must not be altered even if they later turn out to be wrong. The storage period is limited by the purpose of processing, and the controller must set time limits for erasure or periodic review (ECtHR, S. and Marper). Accountability, finally, requires the controller to be able to demonstrate compliance with the principles (Art. 5(2)).

Grounds for lawfulness and consent

Processing may be based on consent, on the conclusion or performance of a contract, on a legal obligation, on vital interests, on a task carried out in the public interest, or on legitimate interests. Consent is a freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication (Art. 7). Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) defines only explicit consent. Although the word “explicit consent” does not appear in the Regulation, consent there is based on information and is therefore similar to explicit consent under the KVKK. Consent must be capable of being withdrawn at any time and as easily as it was given. The performance of a contract cannot be made conditional on consent to the processing of data that are not necessary for it. The Article 29 Working Party has stated that employees, because of their dependence on the employer, are almost never in a position to give consent freely. The processing of special categories of personal data is prohibited as a rule and is possible only in the exceptional cases listed in Article 9.

Obligations of the controller

A controller or processor outside the Union must designate a representative in the Union in writing (Art. 27). Joint controllers allocate their obligations by means of an arrangement (Art. 26(1)). The controller works only with processors that provide sufficient guarantees (Art. 28(1)). Technical and organisational security measures appropriate to the risk must be taken (Art. 32). A personal data breach must be notified to the supervisory authority within 72 hours at the latest after becoming aware of it, unless it is unlikely to result in a risk (Art. 33). Breaches likely to result in a high risk are also communicated to the data subject without undue delay.

Designating a data protection officer is mandatory where processing is carried out by a public authority, where the core activities require large-scale and systematic monitoring, and where special categories of data are processed on a large scale (Art. 37-39). The officer is independent and may not be dismissed for performing his or her tasks. Records of processing activities must be kept (Art. 30); enterprises employing fewer than 250 persons are exempt from this obligation under certain conditions. A data protection impact assessment is carried out before high-risk processing, and the supervisory authority is consulted if the risk cannot be mitigated (Art. 35-36). Codes of conduct and voluntary certification mechanisms are means of demonstrating compliance (Art. 40-43). Article 25, in turn, requires safeguards to be integrated at the design stage and, by default, only the data necessary to be processed.

Cross-border transfers and independent supervision

If the Commission decides that a third country or an international organisation ensures an adequate level of protection, transfers may take place without any specific authorisation (Art. 45). According to the CJEU, this protection must be essentially equivalent to the guarantees provided by EU law. Adequacy decisions are reviewed at least every four years and may be withdrawn, amended or suspended at any time. In the absence of such a decision, appropriate safeguards such as binding corporate rules or standard data protection clauses are required (Art. 46). Failing these, the derogations in Article 49, such as explicit consent or the performance of a contract, may apply. According to the Article 29 Working Party, such transfers must remain exceptional and must not be repetitive.

Each Member State establishes an independent supervisory authority (Art. 51). These authorities have powers to advise, investigate, issue warnings, order the erasure of data, restrict processing and refer matters to the courts. Under the “one-stop-shop” mechanism, the supervisory authority of the main establishment is the lead authority for a controller operating in more than one Member State. Authorities respond to requests for mutual assistance within one month at the latest (Art. 60-61). The European Data Protection Board (Art. 68-70) and the consistency mechanism (Art. 63) serve uniform application. In urgent cases an authority may adopt provisional measures for a period not exceeding three months (Art. 66).

Rights of the data subject and sanctions

The data subject has the rights to information, access, rectification, erasure (to be forgotten), restriction of processing, data portability and objection, and the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing. These rights may be restricted only by an interference that is provided for by law, pursues a legitimate aim and is necessary in a democratic society (Art. 23). The right to erasure was not set out as an explicit right before the Regulation (CJEU, Google Spain). Whether the right to be forgotten is identical to the right to erasure remains open to debate. Data portability is a new right not regulated in any earlier instrument. Regarding objection, the CJEU has stated that the rights of the data subject, as a rule, override the economic interests of the controller.

The data subject may lodge a complaint with the supervisory authority, seek an effective judicial remedy, be represented by a not-for-profit body and claim compensation for material or non-material damage suffered (Art. 77-82). Administrative fines (Art. 83) may reach EUR 20,000,000 or 4% of the total worldwide annual turnover of the preceding financial year for infringements of the basic principles, the conditions for consent, data subjects' rights and the transfer rules, and EUR 10,000,000 or 2% of turnover for other infringements, whichever is higher. Member States may also lay down criminal rules. For example, Germany's Federal Data Protection Act (Bundesdatenschutzgesetz) provides for a fine or imprisonment of up to three years for the unlawful transfer of non-public data of a large number of persons. A four-stage approach was proposed for compliance with the Regulation: gap analysis, risk analysis, project management and resource/budget planning, and implementation.

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic