26 January 2019Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

In the face of this development, it can first be said that the GDPR has made a swift entrance almost as soon as it arrived. This is shown by the administrative fine of EUR 50 million imposed on Google by the French authorities on the ground that it had breached the provisions of the GDPR, which had not yet been in force for even a year. Thus the first major breach since the GDPR entered into force has occurred, and the administrative fine provided for in the GDPR has been applied to it.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

In view of this development, it may first be said that the GDPR, having barely arrived, has made a swift entrance in the truest sense. This is shown by the administrative fine of 50 million euros imposed on Google by the French authorities on the ground that provisions of the GDPR had been infringed, even though not even a year has passed since it entered into force. The first major infringement since the GDPR entered into force has thus occurred, and the administrative fine regulated in the GDPR has been applied to it.

At a time when personal data are rapidly changing in scale, a need arose for a comprehensive reform in order to modernise the principles adopted in EU Data Protection Directive 95/46/EC and to safeguard individual rights in a manner appropriate to present-day conditions. It was precisely to meet this need that the GDPR was adopted by the European Parliament on 24 May 2016 to replace the Directive. A two-year transition period was laid down for the Regulation, and its date of application was set as 25 May 2018. The GDPR has therefore only just begun to be applied.

The GDPR is the most up-to-date legal instrument in the field of personal data protection and the one with the strictest requirements, and since its publication the Member States of the European Union had been preparing themselves for these requirements. Unlike the Directive, the fact that it is to be applied directly and uniformly in all Member States of the European Union, that its territorial scope has been considerably extended and that very high maximum amounts of administrative fines have been laid down were the most prominent and unsettling features of the GDPR.

Indeed, the very high penalty imposed on a large company such as Google, even though the GDPR has only just entered into force, has made it plain that the concerns felt were justified. Owing to the territorial scope of the GDPR, its importance and nature for Türkiye as well must not be forgotten, nor the fact that every personal data processing activity involved in any contact established with the Member States of the European Union, with citizens of the Member States of the European Union or even with persons living there is subject to the provisions of the GDPR. Consequently, companies that operate internationally, even if they are established in Türkiye, must be careful in this respect and must seek to comply with the provisions of the GDPR, which provide for a higher level of protection than Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK).

Indeed, companies that are aware of this request that their compliance projects be carried out not only in accordance with the Law but also in accordance with the provisions of the GDPR, and that they be compliant with the GDPR as well at the end of this process. For this reason, I would first like to use this fine to warn companies located in Türkiye that fall within the scope of the GDPR and to point out that they must be careful in this regard.

1. The Administrative Fine Imposed on Google by France

a. The investigation process initiated against Google

The investigation of Google began when two groups of privacy advocates raised a number of complaints between 25 and 28 May 2018. Both organisations alleged that Google did not have a valid legal basis for processing users’ personal data, in particular for the purpose of personalising advertising. In response to these complaints, CNIL (Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés), France’s largest data protection authority, took action immediately and opened an investigation and inquiry into Google while the GDPR was in application.

It has been reported that these privacy advocates also filed further privacy complaints in other Member States of the European Union against Facebook and its subsidiaries, the photo-sharing application Instagram and the messaging service WhatsApp. It may therefore be said that investigations have also been initiated against these companies and that, should a data breach be established, there is a possibility of high administrative fines being imposed, given their size.

Following the investigation, CNIL issued a statement on the investigation it had carried out and on its findings1. CNIL noted that during this investigation it had frequently been in contact and exchanged information with the data protection authorities of other Member States of the Union. It further stated that, under the new system, it was, like all the protection authorities of the Union, competent to take decisions on the practices carried out by Google.

CNIL mentioned that an online inspection had been carried out in September in order to investigate the complaints. It explained that the purpose of this inspection was to examine a user’s journey and the documents accessible to him when creating a Google account. In this way, Google’s compliance with French national legislation on the processing of personal data and with the GDPR could be verified.

Google has recently made a number of changes in order to comply with European Union rules. Nevertheless, CNIL stated that, since the infringements observed still relate to a very large amount of data, information on users’ private lives may be revealed through an unlimited number of possible combinations. Google was unable to explain fully how users’ personal information is collected and what it consists of.

Under the GDPR and other European Union data protection laws, however, a technology company must be able to give users a complete and clear picture of the personal data it collects. In addition, users must be offered simple, comprehensible and purpose-specific tools for consenting to the use of their personal data.

In response, Google stated that its next step would be to study the decision, and added the following:

“People expect high standards of transparency and control from us. We are deeply committed to meeting those expectations and the consent requirements of the GDPR.”

b. The deficiencies established in respect of Google at the end of the investigation

As a result of its investigation, CNIL established deficiencies on the part of Google in relation to two fundamental obligations laid down by the GDPR:

i. Obligation to inform

According to CNIL, the information provided by Google is not easily accessible to users. It found that the information the company chose to display at the first level did not include essential information such as the purposes for which data are processed, the data retention period and the categories of data used for personalising advertising. This information is scattered across a number of options and links. Moreover, this setting must be specifically activated in order to read additional information. The relevant documents can be accessed only after several steps, by performing five or six actions. For example, a user who wishes to obtain information on the collection of data for the personalisation of advertisements is faced with having to go through these steps. Furthermore, the instruction provided, which is in any event limited with regard to the relevant information, was not found to be clear and comprehensible in its content either.

For these reasons, CNIL stated that users do not understand the extent of the operations carried out by Google. It considers, however, that these operations involve a very large data processing activity and that they are described in a very general and vague manner. It was also found that the limited information provided did not state the retention period for certain data.

The GDPR deals with the obligation to inform individuals both under the principle of transparency and separately. Any information and communication relating to processing must be easily accessible and easy to understand for the data subject, using clear and plain language2.

ii. Transparency and clarity

CNIL addressed the deficiencies regarding transparency and clarity in particular in the context of personalised advertising practices. Because of the deficiencies it found, it takes the view that Google’s practices in this area have no legal basis.

Google obtains users’ consent for its personalised advertising practices and acts on that basis. CNIL, however, considers this consent to be invalid. First, it noted that the infringement of the generally applicable obligation to inform mentioned above also arises in this respect. It stated that users are not sufficiently informed about the consent and that, at this point, they are not enabled to grasp the extent of the information used. For example, it stated that in the section on ad personalisation it is not possible to become aware of the many other services, sites and applications involved in these services, such as Google search, Google Play, Google Home, Google Maps, Google Play Store and Google Photos. Yet a very large amount of data is processed and combined here.

Secondly, CNIL bases the invalidity of the consent obtained on grounds such as that the consent is not specific, unambiguous, determined and transparent. While acknowledging that users, when creating an account, have the possibility of changing some of the parameters associated with the account by clicking on the “more options” button, it stated that this does not comply with the provisions of the GDPR. It pointed out that, in order to adjust these settings, apart from the changes to be made through the more options button, the default settings must also be checked beforehand. It was also pointed out that, before the account is created, a declaration is obtained from the user, as a condition for creating the account, reading “I agree to Google’s Terms of Service” and “I agree to the use of my information as described in detail above”. Such a method, however, causes the user to give block consent for all purposes, including purposes such as ad personalisation and speech recognition, for which Google will process personal data on the basis of this declaration.

The GDPR, however, has adopted the requirement of purpose-specific consent, and this requires consent to be obtained separately for each purpose. This is required by the principle that data are to be collected and processed for specified and explicit purposes. In order for this principle to be properly implemented, it must first be determined, before the processing activity begins, which data will or will not be processed and for which purposes the data to be processed will be processed. The specified purpose must be sufficiently clear for the data subject to understand it and must be explained in that way3.

Moreover, transparency is an important innovation introduced by the GDPR in contrast to the Directive. Ensuring the principle of transparency requires that the data subject be informed of the identity of the controller and the purposes of the processing, and that every purpose for which personal data are processed be explicit and based on information, including information on the purposes of the processing and on the risks, rules and rights relating to the processing activities4. It may therefore be said that the principle of transparency is directly proportional to the obligation to inform, and that a personal data processing activity carried out on the basis of inadequate and limited information cannot at the same time be transparent.

c. The Sanction Decision Imposed on Google

Because of the infringements it found on the part of Google, CNIL decided to impose an administrative fine of 50 million euros. For CNIL, too, this decision contains the first penalty in which it has applied the high-level administrative fines introduced by the GDPR. CNIL explained that the amount of the administrative fine it decided to impose is proportionate to the seriousness of the infringement of fundamental principles of the GDPR such as the obligation to inform, transparency and consent.

For despite a number of measures implemented by Google, the deficiencies established are capable of revealing users’ entire privacy and deprive users of the fundamental safeguard in this regard. CNIL stated that Google’s users should be in control of their data, should be sufficiently informed and should be in a position to give valid consent.

It added that this infringement had not been found at a single moment limited in time, and that these deficiencies have continued up to the present.

d. Reactions Following the Decision

Undoubtedly, the most striking aspect of the decision is that a very large data breach was established under the GDPR. Moreover, the decision on the infringement was given against Google, the largest US technology company, and a very large administrative fine was imposed by the decision. The decision has consequently been commented on by many quarters.

Max Schrems, chairman of Noyb (None of Your Business), which was founded with the entry into force of the GDPR and runs projects relating to privacy infringements, stated that they were very pleased that the European data protection authorities were using the possibilities provided by the GDPR to punish clear violations of the law. In his view, it is highly significant that the decision states that it is not enough for the competent bodies merely to claim that they are compliant.

At this point a truly important rule introduced by the GDPR is touched upon. Unlike most national laws, such as our national Law No. 6698, the GDPR has also adopted the principle of “accountability”. Under this principle, controllers must comply with the principles and rules laid down by the GDPR and must also be able to demonstrate that they fulfil these obligations5.

Estelle Massé, data protection expert at Access Now, an organisation that defends users’ digital freedoms and their right to freedom of expression worldwide, made statements to similar effect and drew attention to the enforcement of the GDPR. She regarded the decision as the first major sign of Europe’s willingness to enforce the GDPR. She also pointed out that other companies engage in practices similar to Google’s and stated that technology companies will face fines.

Marc Rotenberg, Executive Director of the US-based Electronic Privacy Information Center, complained that the Federal Trade Commission, Washington’s chief privacy and security watchdog, had for so long failed to act against technology companies, and said that this was a major problem at present.

As regards the administrative fine imposed, criticism was voiced, particularly by consumer rights advocates, that the fine was low, and complaints were made that France had not gone far enough. Indeed, La Quadrature du Net, one of the groups that filed the complaints which led to the investigation of Google, stated that the fine was very low compared with Google’s annual turnover.

Conclusion

The decision is significant above all because a sanction decision was given by applying the GDPR. Since I have set out above the nature of the infringements established and the fundamental principles to which they relate, at this point I would like to dwell solely on the fact that a European data protection authority, applying the GDPR, has given a decision finding an infringement and imposing the sanction of an administrative fine.

As stated above, the GDPR, adopted on 24 May 2016, introduced very strict requirements regarding the protection and confidentiality of personal data, and during the two-year period laid down as a transition period, work to achieve compliance with the GDPR was carried out, particularly in companies located in the Member States of the European Union. This is an even greater necessity for technology companies that use very large amounts of data. Google, too, made many updates in line with the new data protection rules, but these updates were not considered sufficient by the data protection authorities for compliance with the GDPR.

This indicates that the Member States of the European Union will make no concessions in enforcing the GDPR. Moreover, although some quarters consider it low, the amount of the administrative fine imposed should also give controllers pause for thought. Consequently, the first lesson to be drawn from the decision is that, in an investigation conducted in response to a complaint, the provisions of the GDPR will be strictly applied and particular attention will be paid to whether the fundamental principles have been infringed; and that, where an infringement is established as a result of the investigation, the data protection authorities will not refrain from imposing sanctions and the administrative fine will be of a deterrent nature.

For this reason, as I stated above, I would like to warn companies located in Türkiye, and particularly those operating intensively at international level, that they too must be careful and avoid an attitude such as “We are not a Member State of the European Union anyway, so the GDPR does not apply to us”. For the GDPR is by no means a classical international instrument, as might be thought; it lays down a scope of application far wider than the geographical borders of the European Union. It is clear that Türkiye, which engages in intensive economic and commercial activity with the Member States of the European Union, will also be affected by the GDPR. I therefore recommend, particularly to companies already engaged in commercial activities with EU countries, that they not content themselves with complying only with Law No. 6698, but take concrete steps to bring themselves into compliance with the GDPR as well, which lays down far stricter requirements than the Law.

Footnotes

  1. Academic / Attorney. ↑
  2. For the full text of the statement made by the CNIL, see: https://www.cnil.fr/fr/la-formation-restreinte-de-la-cnil-prononce-une-sanction-de-50-millions-deuros-lencontre-de-la. ↑
  3. Murat Volkan Dülger, Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku, İstanbul, Hukuk Akademisi, 2019, s. 115. ↑
  4. Dülger, s. 117. ↑
  5. Dülger, s. 115. ↑
  6. Dülger, s. 139. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic