Abstract
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
Personal data is a concept whose boundaries cannot be drawn precisely. In international and national instruments, “any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person” is accepted as personal data. In other words, every kind of information we can think of that serves to identify a person is that person’s personal data. The place a human being takes in the universe as a human being, and his or her position in society, turn certain values attached to the person into personal data. In addition, developments in science and technology, particularly over the last century, and their reflection on society and on the components that make up social life have turned a great deal of information into personal data.
While many of these data make up the category of personal data, some have been recognised as “special categories” of personal data. The reason why certain data are recognised as special categories of personal data, and are thereby placed under more effective protection, is that these data are more closely connected with the person’s fundamental rights and freedoms. This distinction was made out of concern that, if such data were misused, the harm and hardship that could be caused to the data subject would be greater.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
MURAT VOLKAN DÜLGER
Assoc. Prof. Dr., Istanbul Aydın University Faculty of Law, Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Law and IT Law / Attorney-at-Law
Personal data is a concept whose boundaries cannot be drawn precisely. In international and national instruments it is accepted that “any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person” is personal data. In other words, every kind of information we can think of that serves to identify a person is that person’s personal data1.
The place that the human being takes in the universe as a human being, and his position in society, turn certain values attached to the human being into personal data. In addition, the developments in science and technology, particularly in the last century, and their reflection on society and on the components that make up social life have turned a great deal of information into personal data. While many of these data make up the category of personal data, some have been recognised as “special categories” of personal data. The fact that certain data have been recognised as special categories of personal data and have thereby been placed under more effective protection stems from the closer relationship of these data with the fundamental rights and freedoms of the person. For such a distinction was made out of the concern that, should the data in question be misused, the harm and injury that might arise for the data subject would be greater. The health data of individuals
are likewise data regarded as falling within the special categories of personal data, and in this paper the protection of personal data in health law and patient privacy will be assessed within the framework of international and national instruments.
With the development of information technologies and the spread of the internet, the existence and importance of personal data have come to be better understood because of the problems that have arisen. For this information, which was previously kept on file in written form in the hands of a small number of persons or institutions, was transferred to the digital environment as technology developed and, as a result of the spread of the internet, became open, lawfully or unlawfully, to access by everyone, whether concerned or not. This was also the point at which the danger relating to personal data emerged. For even the concern that persons who have no connection with them may gain access to personal data and may use and disseminate them constitutes a real threat to individuals. In the last 30 years technology has changed our lives in a way that no one could have imagined. As a result of this rapid progress in technology, the existing legal rules fall short in many different respects. For this reason the need to review and update the existing rules of law has come onto the agenda. As a result of this necessity, important arrangements and amendments were made, as part of the reform process between 1995 and 2018, in the EU data protection legislation, which has long been regarded as a gold standard in the world. Before the GDPR, the “Directive on the Protection of Individuals with regard to the Processing of Personal Data and on the Free Movement of Such Data”, No. 95/46/EC, which entered into force in 1998, offered a framework in the field of the protection of personal data that was not confined to the geography of Europe and was accepted throughout the world, and, because it was not directly legally binding, it was used as a reference by each member country of the Union in creating its own domestic legislation. The GDPR emerged from the need for a comprehensive reform aimed at adapting the principles adopted to the present day, in the wake of data traffic of increasing variety and capacity, new approaches to the processing of the data collected and developments in technology. Among these arrangements, the GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation), which the EU adopted in 2016 and which entered into force on 25 May 2018, is regarded as one of the most important achievements of the EU in recent years. This instrument replaced the Data Protection Directive 95/46/EC, which had been adopted at a time when the internet was in its infancy.
As a reflection of all these developments and reforms, the Law on the Protection of Personal Data, which was designed in our country by drawing inspiration from the provisions of Directive 95/46/EC, was adopted by the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye (TBMM) on 24 March 2016 and entered into force as Law No. 6698 upon its publication in the Official Gazette No. 29677 of 7 April 2016.
Today the right to the protection of personal data is recognised as a fundamental right and, as stated above, there are many international and national instruments that protect this right. Personal data and special categories of personal data have been placed under protection by these instruments, and, because the processing of special categories of personal data is more closely related to the fundamental rights and freedoms of individuals, the processing of these data has been made subject to stricter conditions. The processing of health data, which are recognised as a special category of personal data, has likewise been made subject to strict conditions in international and national instruments. Where controllers fail to comply with these conditions when processing the special categories of personal data in question, various sanctions are imposed by the competent data protection authorities.
The Protection of Health Data within the Framework of International and National Instruments
When one looks at the national and international legislation on the protection of personal data, it is seen that certain data have been placed under greater protection than others and that these data are defined as sensitive data, in other words as special categories of data. Although no such distinction is made in some of the instruments on the subject, important texts such as Council of Europe Convention No. 108, the United Nations Guidelines, Directive 95/46/EC and the GDPR do refer to special categories of (sensitive) data. Although this recognition is common to them, in some texts a larger number of personal data have been recognised as special categories, or the types of special categories of data differ.
In the GDPR, which entered into force to replace Directive 95/46/EC, a difference can be seen in comparison with the Directive as regards the types of special categories of personal data. Accordingly, by Article 9 of the Regulation, entitled “Processing of special categories of personal data”, “genetic data and biometric data for the purpose of identifying a natural person” and “data concerning sexual orientation” were, in addition to those in the Directive, included in the category of special categories of data. This provision is also important in that it protects individuals against the dangers arising as genetic and biometric data come to be collected more and more as technology develops. Moreover, by listing information on sexual orientation among the special categories of data alongside sex life, protection has been given not only to concrete information about the sex life of individuals but also to information about the direction of their sexual orientation. Indeed, at a time when individuals are subjected to discrimination on account of their sexual orientation without any concrete knowledge or first-hand observation, the amendment made
is also in keeping with the reason for which special categories of personal data were provided for2.
Law No. 6698 lays down stricter conditions for the processing of these data and prohibits their processing unless the adequate measures determined by the Personal Data Protection Board have been taken. Unlike other personal data, which data are of a special category is specified exhaustively in Law No. 6698. It is not possible to treat any data other than those listed as being of a special category and to act accordingly. Accordingly, while special categories of data constitute a narrower group than personal data, they denote an area that benefits to a greater extent from the protection of the Law.
Special categories of personal data are regulated in Article 9 of the GDPR as follows: “Processing of personal data revealing racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, or trade union membership, and the processing of genetic data and biometric data for the purpose of identifying a natural person, data concerning health or data concerning a natural person’s sex life or sexual orientation shall be prohibited.” Data of the same nature are specified in Article 6 of the KVKK, Law No. 6698, as follows: “Data relating to the race, ethnic origin, political opinion, philosophical belief, religion, sect or other beliefs, appearance and dress, membership of associations, foundations or trade unions, health, sex life, criminal convictions and security measures of persons, as well as their biometric and genetic data, are special categories of personal data.” Accordingly, in both instruments data concerning the health of persons are listed as special categories of personal data. This point is common to the GDPR and the KVKK, whereas the conditions under which health data may be processed differ.
Conditions for the Processing of Personal Health Data under the GDPR
In accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 9 of the GDPR, the processing of special categories of personal data, including health data, is prohibited as a rule, and it is provided that special categories of personal data may be processed solely and exclusively in the exceptional cases listed in paragraph 2. Those exceptional cases are, in the main, the following: the data subject has given explicit consent to the processing of data; the processing is necessary for carrying out the obligations and exercising the rights of the controller or of the data subject under employment and social security law; the personal data are processed by a foundation, association or any other not-for-profit body in the course of its legitimate activities carried on with a political, philosophical, religious or trade union aim and with appropriate safeguards, on condition that the processing relates solely to the personal data of the members or former members of the body or of persons who are connected with those purposes and have regular contact with it and that the personal data are not disclosed outside that body without the consent of the data subject; the personal data have been made public by the data subject; the processing of data is necessary for the establishment, exercise or protection of a right; the processing is necessary for reasons of substantial public interest, on the basis of Union or Member State law which is proportionate to the aim pursued, respects the essence of the right to data protection and provides for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the fundamental rights and interests of the data subject; the processing is necessary for the purposes of preventive or occupational medicine, for the assessment of the working capacity of the employee, medical diagnosis, the provision of health or social care or treatment or the management of health or social care systems and services, on the basis of Union or Member State law or pursuant to a contract with a health professional and subject to the conditions and safeguards referred to in paragraph 3; the processing is required for reasons of public interest in the area of public health, such as protecting against serious cross-border threats to health or ensuring high standards of quality and safety of health care and of medicinal products or medical devices, on the basis of Union or Member State law which provides for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the rights and freedoms of the data subject, in particular professional secrecy; and the processing is required for archiving purposes in the public interest, scientific or historical research purposes or statistical purposes in accordance with Article 89(1), on the basis of Union or Member State law which is proportionate to the aim pursued, respects the essence of the right to data protection and provides for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the fundamental rights and interests of the data subject. In these cases special categories of personal data may be processed.
Where special categories of personal data are processed by a professional subject to the obligation of professional secrecy under Union or Member State law or to rules established by national competent bodies, or under the responsibility of such a professional, or by another person subject to the obligation of professional secrecy under Union or Member State law or to rules established by national competent bodies, the data in question may be processed, in line with the purposes of preventive or occupational medicine, on the basis of Union or Member State law or pursuant to a contract with a health professional
and subject to the conditions and safeguards referred to in paragraph 3, only for the purposes of the assessment of the working capacity of the employee, medical diagnosis, the provision of health or social care or treatment or the management of health or social care systems and services. Within the framework of paragraph 4 of Article 9 of the GDPR, Member States may continue to apply, or may introduce, additional conditions, including limitations, with regard to health data.
This provision of the GDPR covers a considerably wider area than the KVKK and creates a wider space for controllers to be able to process health data.
Conditions for the Processing of Personal Health Data under Law No. 6698
Compared with the GDPR, Law No. 6698 contains a more restrictive regime for the processing of special categories of personal data, including data concerning the health of persons.
Under the provision in Article 6 of Law No. 6698, data relating to the race, ethnic origin, political opinion, philosophical belief, religion, sect or other beliefs, appearance and dress, membership of associations, foundations or trade unions, health, sex life, criminal convictions and security measures of persons, as well as their biometric and genetic data, are special categories of personal data, and the processing of the data in question without the explicit consent of the data subject is prohibited as a rule.
Although the processing of special categories of personal data without explicit consent is prohibited as a rule, in paragraph 3 of Article 6 special categories of personal data are themselves divided into two groups, namely data other than those concerning health and sex life and data concerning health and sex life, and different conditions for processing are laid down for each of the two groups.
Under paragraph 3 of Article 6 of Law No. 6698, among the special categories of personal data, personal data other than those concerning health and sex life may be processed without seeking the explicit consent of the data subject in the cases provided for by laws; whereas it is provided that personal data concerning health and sex life may be processed without seeking the explicit consent of the data subject only by persons under an obligation of secrecy or by authorised institutions and organisations, for the purposes of the protection of public health, preventive medicine, medical diagnosis, the provision of treatment and care services, and the planning and management of health services and their financing.
In other words, under Law No. 6698 data concerning the state of health of persons may be processed without seeking the explicit consent of the data subject only by persons under an obligation of secrecy or by authorised institutions and organisations, where the protection of public health, preventive medicine, medical diagnosis, the provision of treatment and care services, and the planning and management of health services and their financing are at issue.
It must nevertheless be stated as a basic point that, even though the GDPR and Law No. 6698 have introduced provisions that differ in certain respects as regards the conditions for the processing of health data, under both of them health data must be processed in accordance with the fundamental principles to be observed in data processing activities. These principles are: the principle of compliance with the law and the rules of good faith; the principle of lawfulness, fairness and transparency; the principle of processing for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes; the principle that personal data must be relevant, limited and proportionate to the purpose; the principle that data must be collected for specified, explicit and legitimate purposes; the principle of being accurate and, where necessary, kept up to date; the principle that data must be retained for the period necessary for the purpose; the principle of integrity and confidentiality; and the principle of the obligation of accountability.
The Importance of the Protection of Personal Health Data (The Right to Privacy)
As I have also stated above, health data are among those personal data that have a greater effect on fundamental rights and freedoms, and the protection of these data is of considerable importance, particularly for the protection of patient privacy and of the right to privacy.
In the Dictionary of the Turkish Language Association, privacy is defined by the concept of “confidentiality”. In the legal dictionary, this concept is explained as “being intimate; being secret; confidentiality”. Privacy is therefore a concept relating to a person’s being able to conceal, and to have disregarded, whatever information about himself he wishes, whenever he wishes. As can be seen, the concept of privacy carries meanings very close to the concept of respect for private life. It must also be pointed out, however, that the concept of privacy differs from the concept of respect for private life and that the two are not synonymous.
The concept of privacy finds its intellectual foundation in the understanding that the individual possesses personal autonomy. Although the expectation of privacy has existed since very ancient times, its transformation into a human right and into a fundamental right and freedom became possible with the emergence of the concept of human rights.
Today the right to privacy is guaranteed both in international law and in domestic law. However, the history of the concept of privacy in legal scholarship, in legal instruments and in judicial decisions does not go back very far.
Articles 4 and 5 of the American Bill of Rights protect the right to respect for private life. In America, a law of 1792 prohibited those working in the postal services from opening the letters of individuals. Another law, of 1825, provided that letters could be opened only by decision of a judge.3 In this context, in its Jackson decision of 1878 the Court held that a letter handed over in a sealed envelope in reliance on the postal service could be opened only with a search warrant. Nevertheless, the concept of privacy was first expressed “as a right” in 1890, in the article written jointly by Samuel D. Warren and Louis Brandeis. In this article, entitled “The Right to Privacy”, it was stated that the concept of privacy had an independent field of regulation, and this right was defined as “the right to be let alone”. This step is regarded as the first step of the ideas that shed light on today’s legal rules concerning private life.
Brandeis first voiced the right to privacy in a judicial decision in the following terms: “The scope of protection of the Constitution, as guaranteed by the Amendments, is very broad. The makers of our Constitution undertook to secure favourable conditions in the pursuit of happiness. They recognised the importance of man’s spiritual nature, of his feelings and of his intellect. They knew that only a part of the pain, pleasure and satisfactions of life are to be found in material things. They sought to protect Americans in their beliefs, their thoughts, their emotions and their sensations. They recognised, as against the State, the right to be let alone, the most comprehensive of rights and the one most valued by civilised people. To protect that right, every abuse of the privacy of the individual by the State, by whatever method it is carried out, amounts to a violation of the Fourth Amendment.” This quotation draws attention to three points: that the right to privacy is a right which protects the spiritual feelings of persons; that it is the most comprehensive of rights and the one most valued by civilised people; and that it is a right directed at protecting the intimate sphere of persons.
Article 17 of the UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights regulates the right to privacy. Similarly, Article 12 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, in order that personal privacy may be protected, recognise the right to respect for private life as a fundamental human right and thereby lay emphasis on the protection of personal data.4 In health law, for its part, there is no doubt that the utmost care must be taken with the protection of the data that come to light particularly at the stage of the diagnosis and treatment of the illness, and with patient privacy.
For privacy gives persons mental ease as regards their readiness for treatment. For example, in the case of sexually transmitted diseases, a person’s confidence that his privacy will be ensured helps to strengthen his resolve as regards treatment. The “Z. v. Finland judgment” of the European Court of Human Rights is highly noteworthy in this respect. In that judgment, which concerned the violation of the privacy of the information of an HIV-positive person, the Court states: “Ensuring the privacy of health data is important for the protection of general health. For a violation of privacy may cause the person to refrain from obtaining diagnosis and treatment, especially in situations where he or she thinks that he or she may face social pressure should the matter come to light, and may thus cause society to fall behind in combating epidemic diseases and cause that fight to be disrupted.”5
Another example in this regard: by means of medically performed genetic predisposition tests it can be established which diseases persons are genetically predisposed to and that they have the potential to encounter these diseases in the future. In such a situation the persons are not yet ill, nor is it certain whether in the future they will contract the diseases to which they have been found to be genetically predisposed. Sharing these data with insurance companies while only probabilities are as yet at issue may result in the companies refusing to insure individuals because of the increased risk and may cause individuals to suffer injury.
As stated above, the nature of health data requires that these data be protected in a manner specific to them. To this end, the “Regulation on Personal Health Data”, issued pursuant to Law No. 6698, was published in the Official Gazette No. 30808 of 21.06.2019 and entered into force6. In sub-paragraph (i) of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Regulation, personal
data are defined as “any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person”, and in sub-paragraph (j) personal health data are defined as “any information relating to the physical and mental health of an identified or identifiable natural person, and information relating to the health service provided to the person”. It is entirely natural and appropriate that this Regulation, which also cites Law No. 6698 among its legal bases, should give a definition parallel to that Law.
It is noteworthy that this definition in the Regulation states that “information relating to the health services provided to the person” is also personal health data. Accordingly, in addition to information concerning a person’s health, such as his state of health, the medicines he uses or his illness, information on the health unit from which he receives services and on any stage of treatment applied is also regarded as health data. For example, together with the illness, the course of treatment or the medicines of a patient being treated in the neurology ward, even the information on the neurology ward service provided by the hospital is regarded as that person’s health data. Moreover, even the mere fact that the name of the hospital is known may at times cause irreparable harm in the person’s inner world. It is known that some health institutions provide services only in particular fields in which they specialise, such as maternity hospitals, children’s hospitals, hospitals for venereal diseases or mental health hospitals. Particularly in cities that are small in terms of population, it must be regarded as natural that those who wish to be treated in these hospitals do not want the name of the hospital to be known.
Keeping information belonging to the patient confidential is a matter relating to patients’ rights. It is seen that this matter is expressly regulated in the Regulation on Patients’ Rights (HHY), published in the Official Gazette No. 23420 of 01.08.1998. Article 23 of the HHY regulates the “Keeping of Information Confidential”. The provisions of the HHY lay down certain principles concerning the keeping of information confidential. The principles relating to the obligation to keep information confidential are as follows:
Principle of confidentiality: As a general rule, information obtained about the patient in the course of medical practice must be kept confidential. Under this principle, all records and information belonging to the patient that are obtained by reason of the provision of the health service may not be disclosed in any way, except in the cases permitted by law (HHY Art. 23(1)).
Individuals share their most intimate information with those who provide the health service in the course of medical practice. Those who provide the health service must keep this information confidential. This confidentiality may rest on reasons such as preventing discrimination that might be directed against the person in connection with his state of health and preventing the patient from being humiliated before society, and on similar psychological, social and legal reasons.
Principle of legal liability: Even if it is based on the person’s consent, the disclosure of information in cases that result in the complete waiver of personality rights, the transfer of these rights to others or their excessive restriction does not remove the legal liability of the person who discloses it (HHY Art. 23(2)).
Principle of the likelihood of harm: The disclosure, without relying on a legally and morally valid and justified reason, of information that is likely to harm the patient will also give rise to both the legal and the criminal liability of the staff and of other persons (HHY Art. 23(3)).
Principle of research/educational purpose and consent: In activities carried out for the purposes of research and education too, the patient’s identity details may not be disclosed without his consent (HHY Art. 23(4)). Medical education is an important matter for the development of medical science. In order to bring forth scientific knowledge relating to medicine and to remedy the shortage of the necessary technical personnel in the field of medicine, medicine must be taught to new prospective physicians and to young physicians.
It is precisely during these research and educational activities carried out for the purpose of developing medical science that the patient’s information must likewise remain confidential. During the research and educational activities carried out, personal information must be kept confidential vis-à-vis the outside world and the necessary sensitivity must be shown in this regard.
Principle of taking precautions and of due care: Article 5 of the HHY lists the principles to be observed in the provision of health services, and its sub-paragraph (f) contains the mandatory rule that, except in the cases permitted by law and cases of medical necessity, the confidentiality of the patient’s private life and family life may not be interfered with; Article 21 of the Regulation, entitled “Respect for Privacy”, states that every kind of medical intervention shall be carried out with respect for the patient’s privacy, and emphasises that not even the event of death confers the right to violate privacy.
Article 23 of the HHY, entitled “Keeping of Information Confidential”, for its part states that information obtained by reason of the provision of the health service may not be disclosed in any way except in the cases permitted by law, and that, even if it is based on the person’s consent, the disclosure of information in cases that result in the complete waiver of personality rights, the transfer of these rights to others or their excessive restriction does not remove the legal liability of the person who discloses it; and it sets out that, in activities carried out for the purposes of research
and education too, the patient’s identity details may not be disclosed without his consent.
In order that patients’ rights, which fall within fundamental human rights, may be protected, those who are involved in the process of medical practice and provide health services are obliged to act within the framework of health legislation, to exercise the care required for the protection of patients’ rights and, as that care demands, to take all precautions.
In the course of medical practice, physicians and health personnel are under an obligation to keep confidential the information they learn about the patient. This obligation is based on the rules of medical ethics.
Principle that the confidentiality of the patient’s private life and family life may not be interfered with: Except in the cases permitted by law and cases of medical necessity, the confidentiality of the patient’s private life and family life may not be interfered with (HHY Art. 5(f)).
The confidentiality of patients’ private life must be assessed within the framework of two principles:
- The first is the principle of “showing respect”, that is, of non-interference,
- The second is the principle of “the confidentiality of personal data and the protection of these data”.
Institutions and organisations providing health services and health personnel are obliged to protect the confidentiality of the test results belonging to the patient. The scope of this protection also includes preventing unauthorised persons other than the patient from gaining access to the results and reports. Indeed, according to the European Court of Human Rights too, respect for the confidentiality of health data is a fundamental principle in the legal systems of the States Parties to the Convention.
Principle of confidentiality in informing the patient: The patient must also be informed in a suitable setting and with the patient’s privacy protected. (HHY Art. 18(5))
Medical records: These are in the nature of the patient’s personal data, and the patient may not want others to know this information. For example, information that an unmarried woman is pregnant, or information about the patient’s sexual identity, is of this kind. This may generally hold true for situations that create a danger of individuals falling into a bad position in society. Apart from this, it may also arise in the case of prohibitions which the patient imposes of his own choice. Physicians and health personnel must comply with the principle of confidentiality in the course of medical practice and must exercise the necessary care to ensure that others do not learn the patient’s personal data.
Since medical records are in the nature of the patient’s personal data, the offences defined in Articles 136 and 137 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK) may be constituted if this information is disclosed unlawfully.
In line with our explanations above, it must be borne in mind that data concerning the health of all persons are regarded as falling within the special categories of personal data and that the processing of these data is subject to stricter conditions than personal data which are not of a special category; and the right of individuals to the protection of their personal data and their right to privacy, which are today recognised as a fundamental right and are protected by both international and national instruments, must not be violated.
Conclusion
Data concerning the health of persons are listed in the category of special categories of personal data under the GDPR and Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data, and, as a rule, their processing without explicit consent is made subject to special conditions. Data concerning health are closely connected with fundamental rights and freedoms of persons such as the right to privacy, and, on account of this characteristic, an attempt has been made in our law too to establish an effective protection mechanism in this field.
To this end, the “Law on the Protection of Personal Data” No. 6698 and the “Regulation on Personal Health Data” were put into force, and administrative and criminal sanctions relating to acts against the privacy of personal data were laid down under both Law No. 6698 and the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237.
The reason why health data are subject to such special protection is, on the one hand, that they contain the most intimate information about individuals, together with the interests and claims of individuals that this information should not be learnt by others and their right to privacy; and, on the other hand, that if this information could easily be accessed by everyone, the great majority of individuals would refrain from going to medical diagnosis and treatment institutions and/or to doctors, which in turn could lead to very serious and significant adverse consequences for public and community health.
For this reason, when health data are recorded, processed, transferred and destroyed, care and attention several times greater than normal must be exercised.
Footnotes
- For detailed information on such matters as the concept of personal data, the historical development of this field, its position in terms of fundamental rights and freedoms and how personal data are protected in practice, see: Murat Volkan Dülger, Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku, 2. Basım, İstanbul, Hukuk Akademisi, 2019, s. 1 vd. ↑
- Murat Volkan Dülger, “Avrupa Birliği Genel Veri Koruma Tüzüğü Bağlamında Kişisel Verilerin Korunması”, Yaşar Hukuk Dergisi, C. 1, S. 2, Temmuz 2019, s. 71 vd. ↑
- Ömer Gedik, İnsan Hakları Açısından Mahremiyet Kavramı ve Hastanın Kişisel Verilerinin Mahremiyeti, II.Uluslararası Tıp Hukuku Kongresi Bildirileri Kitabı, Ed. Hakan Hakeri - Cahid Doğan, Ankara, Adalet Yayınevi, 2018, s. 649 ↑
- Gedik, s.651 ↑
- Avrupa İnsan Hakları Mahkemesi (AİHM) K. 95 22009/93(25 Şubat 1997) Z v. Finlandiya Kararları ↑
- For detailed information on the regulation issued before this regulation, the stay of execution ordered by the Council of State in respect of that regulation, the amendment made to the regulation after that decision, the stay of execution ordered by the Council of State in respect of the amendment made, and the newly issued regulation referred to above, see: Murat Volkan Dülger, “Kişisel Sağlık Verileri Hakkında Yönetmelik’e İlişkin Değerlendirme”, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.academia. edu/39844597/Ki%C5%9Fisel_Sa%C4%9Fl%C4%B1k_Verileri_Hakk%C4%B1nda_Y%- C3%B6netmelike_%C4%B0li%C5%9Fkin_De%C4%9Ferlendirme, (25.01.2020). ↑
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Right to Be Forgotten” (Unutulma Hakkı), Essays in Honour of Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli (Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli’ye Armağan), Savaş Publishing, Ankara, 2024, pp. 1019–1141.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Assessment of the Amendments to the KVK Law on the Processing of Special Categories of Personal Data and the Transfer of Data Abroad” (KVK Kanunu’nda Özel Nitelikli Kişisel Verilerin İşlenmesi ve Yurt Dışına Veri Aktarımı Kapsamında Yapılan Değişikliklere İlişkin Değerlendirmeler), Academia.edu, 25 March 2024.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Our Assessment of the Decision Summaries Published by the Personal Data Protection Board on 18 July 2022” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulunun 18 Temmuz 2022 Tarihinde Yayınlanan Karar Özetlerine İlişkin Değerlendirmelerimiz), Dülger Law Office, 1 September 2022.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Use of Personal Health Data as Evidence in Divorce Proceedings” (Kişisel Sağlık Verilerinin Boşanma Davasında Delil Olarak Kullanılması), Hukuk ve Daha Fazlası Dergisi (Law and More), No. 9, June 2022, pp. 76–84.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “A Very Important Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board on Lawyers' Access to Enforcement Files Without a Power of Attorney” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulu’ndan Avukatların İcra Takip Dosyalarına Vekaletname Olmaksızın Erişebilmesine İlişkin Çok Önemli Bir Karar), Dülger Law Office, 15 August 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, Personal Data Protection Law (Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku), 4th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2026.

