Introduction
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
It has become an unavoidable necessity for the internet, which enters our lives more each day as technology develops, to become the subject of legal regulation in step with that development. This is because both its presence in every area of our lives and its nature as a constantly changing and developing field require the law likewise to follow these developments. The most recent of the legal provisions made on the internet is the law that was adopted by the General Assembly of the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye and then entered into force on publication in the Official Gazette. The law brings broadcasts made on the internet under the supervision of the Radio and Television Supreme Council (RTÜK) and gives the Council the power to request the blocking of access.
In this piece, in order to assess the draft law that introduces RTÜK supervision, I will first explain in detail the internet and how, with the development of information technologies, the need to regulate it by law arose, and then explain Law No. 5651, which was enacted to meet that need, and its relevant provisions. I will then examine the lawfulness of the draft law introducing RTÜK supervision, particularly in the context of Law No. 5651, and voice my criticisms and concerns on this point. However, the addition made to Law No. 6112 on the Establishment of Radio and Television Enterprises and Their Media Services is in fact directly related to internet communication law.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*
With the development of technology the Internet enters our lives more and more each day, and it has become an unavoidable necessity that, in parallel with this development, it should also become the subject of legal regulation. For the fact that it has entered every sphere of our lives, and that it is a field which is constantly changing and developing, requires the law likewise to keep pace with these developments.
The most recent of the legal regulations concerning the Internet is the law that was adopted by the Plenary of the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye and then entered into force upon publication in the Official Gazette. The law subjects broadcasts made on the Internet to supervision by the Radio and Television Supreme Council and empowers the Council to request the blocking of access.
In this article, in order to be able to assess the bill introducing RTÜK supervision, I shall first explain in detail how, with the development of information technologies, the Internet and the need for legal regulation concerning the Internet arose, and shall then explain Law No. 5651, which was enacted in order to meet this need, and the relevant provisions of that Law. Next, I shall examine the lawfulness of the bill introducing RTÜK supervision, particularly within the framework of Law No. 5651, and shall voice my criticisms and concerns in this regard. However, the addition made to Law No. 6112 on the Establishment of Radio and Television Enterprises and Their Broadcasting Services is in fact directly related to the law of Internet communications. Therefore, only once it has first been set out what the Internet and freedom of expression on the Internet mean, and what criticisms have been levelled at Law No. 5651 from this standpoint, can the addition made to the law which forms the subject of this article be fully understood and criticised objectively.
The Emergence and Development of the Concepts of Information Technology, the Computer and the Internet, and Their
Relationship with One Another
Joint developments in the fields of science and technology have today given rise to the concepts of informatics and information technology. Put in general terms, the science of collecting, processing and storing data, or of transmitting them from one place to another by means of networks and keeping them available for access by users, is called informatics; the tools used in this field, which encompass all technologies including communication, are called information technologies1.
With the development of information technologies and their entry into every sphere of our lives, today we use information technologies, and need these tools, for every kind of task in every field, from our daily lives to the performance of our professional activities. These technologies, which have become part of every sphere of our lives, are today the field in which countries concentrate their investments most heavily, and they play a decisive role in identifying the developed countries.
Today, when information technology is mentioned, what first comes to mind is undoubtedly the computer. So much so that the concepts of computer and informatics can often be used interchangeably and confused with each other. While it is accepted that every computer is part of an information system, it is clear that an information system does not consist merely of a computer in the classical sense. Computers, which may be defined as digital devices capable of processing, storing, producing and transferring information digitally, can be regarded as an invention of almost revolutionary character in information technology. The most important reason why the concepts are confused in this way is that the computer is today the most widely used tool in the field of information technology.
The technological work that continued after the advent of computers gave rise to the concept of the Internet, which denotes a network of very extensive structure formed by the interconnection, in turn, of the networks that are themselves formed by the interconnection of all the information networks and computers in the world. The Internet, which is regarded as the network system that brings about the largest and most comprehensive union of humans and machines in the world, is developing and spreading very rapidly2.
The opening of the Internet to personal use from the mid-1990s onwards has been, for the time being, the latest and most important innovation, and it has brought many changes with it. At this stage it became possible for individuals to take an active part in the processes of building websites and to build their own websites. Indeed, with web 2.0 technology it has become possible for third parties to create and enter content on a website created and managed by one person. The conclusion is thus reached that the latest stage attained by the Internet is that it has entered even the everyday lives of individuals and has irreversibly become an inseparable part of them3.
The Development of the Internet in Türkiye and the Need for Legal Regulation on the Subject
As far as Türkiye is concerned, the development of the Internet began with the Internet network project, first of all in 1991 with the joint work of the Middle East Technical University (ODTÜ) and TÜBİTAK. As a result of the work carried out, Türkiye was connected to the Internet for the first time on 12 April 1993, at ODTÜ. After the first connection had been established, the Internet, which at the outset was used only in academic circles, spread over time to the whole country and came to be used by broad sections of the population. Today, according to the data on Türkiye given in the “Digital in 2017 Global Overview” report, 48 million people, that is, 60% of the country’s population, are stated to be active users of the Internet4. When we look at the data of the Turkish Statistical Institute (TÜİK) for 2017, we see that Internet users make up 66.8% of the population in Türkiye5.
Although the fact that Internet use has become so widespread in the world and in Türkiye offers many advantages in terms of catching up with technological developments and keeping pace with the times, it has also brought various dangers with it. The commission, by means of the Internet, of unlawful acts against which the legal order affords protection has become easier, or, with the development of the Internet and its opening to active use by individuals, new acts against which protection is required have emerged. Foremost among these acts are those carried out in the virtual world, together with, in particular, the content provided on the Internet, which has been very much on the agenda of late.
As individuals have turned the Internet into, as it were, an instrument of crime, one has begun to come across persons in this environment insulting one another, engaging in unjust propaganda and publishing pornographic material. In addition to unlawful acts of this kind, persons have, in what they share over the Internet, attacked one another’s personality rights, such as thought, sex, race, origin and religion. In our country, after the Internet connection had been established and had become widespread, no regulation was made on this subject for some time, nor were any decisions to block access taken by the courts or the administration; the Internet was left free, and so, unfortunately, the adoption of legal regulations on this subject too came late.
The Purpose of Law No. 5651, What It Introduced and Its Relevant Provisions
In parallel with these developments, it became an imperative need to develop protection mechanisms capable of making an effective and proper structure possible, in order to be able to prevent content which constitutes an offence and results from abuse of the use of electronic means, the Internet above all, and to protect public order. In Türkiye the first protection mechanism in the full sense was sought to be provided by the “Law on the Regulation of Publications Made on the Internet and Combating Offences Committed by Means of Such Publications”, No. 5651 of 04/5/2007.
The need for the Law was explained in its explanatory memorandum by the fact that, owing to the dizzying developments in information technologies, the existing regulations were inadequate to prevent publications on the Internet whose content constitutes an offence, and by the fact that no statutory regulation had yet been made on the subject. It was noted that regulations on the subject had been made in the world and in the countries of the European Union, and that various structures had also been set up alongside them. It was further stated that, for reasons such as the rapid increase in offences committed in the electronic environment, the difficulty of detecting these offences as against the ease with which they are committed, and the impossibility of subsequently making good the harm that may arise for society, it had become imperative to combat the matter urgently and effectively6.
Law No. 5651, which was enacted in order to meet the needs arising from the reasons explained in detail in the explanatory memorandum, regulates the obligations and responsibilities of content providers, hosting providers, access providers and collective use providers, and the principles and procedures for combating certain offences committed on the Internet through content, hosting and access providers. Since its entry into force the Law has been exposed to criticism, particularly as regards its provisions on the blocking of access.
According to Article 8 of the Law, headed “Decision to block access and its execution”, a decision to block access is given in respect of publications where there are sufficient grounds for suspicion that they constitute the following offences regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK):
• Incitement to suicide,
• Sexual abuse of children,
• Facilitating the use of narcotic or stimulant substances,
• Supplying substances dangerous to health,
• Obscenity,
• Prostitution,
• Providing a place and facilities for gambling.
According to Article 9 of the Law, headed “Removal of content from publication and blocking”, a person who claims that his personality rights have been violated by a publication made on the Internet may apply directly to the criminal judge of peace and request a decision that the publication be removed or that access be blocked. The judge decides on an application made under this article on the basis of the file, within twenty-four hours at the latest, without holding a hearing and without hearing the other party.
Criticisms Levelled at Articles 8 and 9 of the Law
The articles of the Law regulating the blocking of access and the removal of content have been exposed to criticism because persons’ right of access and right to create content are counted among fundamental rights and freedoms. At this point it is first necessary to clarify the relationship of the acts in question to fundamental rights and freedoms and the bases on which they are counted within this scope.
Since the blocking of access is directly connected with freedom of expression, which is one of a person’s most fundamental rights and freedoms and is protected by numerous national and international legal instruments, such blocking clearly amounts to a violation of freedom of expression.
Article 10, governing freedom of expression, of the European Convention on Human Rights, which is the basic international instrument that protects a person’s fundamental rights and freedoms most comprehensively and establishes effective supervisory mechanisms for that protection, states that everyone has the right to freedom of expression. The scope and limits of the freedom are determined by the phrase in the text of the article: “shall include the freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas”.
The 1982 Constitution, which is the highest norm in domestic law, addresses the matter in Article 25, headed “Freedom of thought and opinion”, and Article 26, headed “Freedom of expression and dissemination of thought”, and regulates it comprehensively. These provisions state that everyone has freedom of thought and opinion and that no one may be accused on account of his thoughts and opinions. In addition, the text of the article seeks to determine the scope of the freedom by stating that it also covers the liberty to receive or impart information or ideas without interference by official authorities.
When we look at the national and international instruments in which freedom of expression is regulated, we reach the conclusion that the freedom is a two-way right comprising the freedom to receive information and the freedom to convey it. Persons must be free not only in their thoughts and opinions but also in expressing and disseminating them. Accordingly, a person who can express his thought as he wishes is also free to receive the ideas, thoughts and opinions that are expressed and disseminated.
In the articles regulating the blocking of access and the removal of content there is, in addition to the substance of the matter, also an inconsistency with the principle that both sides be heard, which is fundamental to all judicial activity. In our law, whatever the subject of the proceedings may be, the rule is that both parties are heard and that the defence is taken in response to the allegation; the judge should decide only after these stages. This has also gained acceptance at the international level and has been adopted in almost all legal orders.
Since Article 6 of the ECHR, which guarantees the right to a fair trial, and Article 36 of the Constitution, headed “Freedom to seek one’s rights”, state that everyone has the right to be tried fairly before the judicial authorities, it follows that decisions rendered as a result of proceedings conducted without one party being heard will amount to a violation of persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms. Hence, irrespective of the merits of the matter, that is, even if the outcome would not change were the other party to be heard, both parties must be heard and a fair trial must be conducted. Yet the articles in question provide that the judge may decide on the basis of an assessment made on the allegation of a single party, without holding a hearing. It is thus possible to say that what we have here is a provision clearly contrary to the relevant provisions of the ECHR and the Constitution.
Moreover, the fact that the decision on a request for the blocking of access is given by the criminal judgeships of peace within a period as short as twenty-four hours constitutes another point of criticism. There is also a violation of the right to a fair trial in that a decision restricting freedom of expression, the most fundamental right of persons, can be taken after proceedings conducted within so short a time.
Alongside the objectionable aspects of decisions to block access and remove content with regard to persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms, it does not seem possible to deny that there is such a need in present-day conditions. In our day, when the Internet has been turned into an instrument of crime, resorting to the measures in question where various types of offence are constituted by publications made on the Internet, or where the personality rights of individuals are violated, will not be a violation of fundamental rights and freedoms; it will serve to protect those rights.
There is also a close relationship between the blocking of access and the right to be forgotten, which, although not protected by the Constitution, has been the subject of many decisions of the Court of Cassation. It is possible to protect by means of the blocking of access the right to be forgotten, which is defined in the case law of the Court of Cassation as the right to request that, in the absence of an overriding public interest, negative events of the past held in the digital memory be forgotten after a certain time, and that personal data which the person does not wish others to know be erased and their dissemination prevented7. By a request for the blocking of access, persons will be able to block access to data which, though relating to them, they wish to be forgotten.
Although the blocking of access is necessary and unavoidable in some cases, since it restricts fundamental rights and freedoms, decisions to that effect must be given in compliance with the rules on the restriction of fundamental rights and freedoms. The provisions on the blocking of access must therefore be framed in conformity with the criteria set out in Article 13 of the Constitution, which governs the restriction of fundamental rights and freedoms. Accordingly, restrictions on fundamental rights and freedoms may be imposed only by law; these restrictions must not be contrary to the requirements of the democratic order of society and the principle of proportionality; and, moreover, the essence of the restricted right must not be impaired.
It is highly important and indeed essential, for the purpose of securing the principles of legal security and certainty, that provisions which restrict the fundamental rights and freedoms of individuals be framed in conformity with the conditions mentioned. Moreover, those conditions prevent arbitrary interference with these rights and freedoms. Provisions framed otherwise will mean that persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms are restricted disproportionately and unlawfully.
The “Supervision by the Radio and Television Supreme Council” Provision
With the adoption by the Plan and Budget Committee of the “Bill on the Amendment of Tax Laws and Certain Laws and Decree-Laws” of 02/02/2018, known to the public as the omnibus bill, the bill introducing RTÜK supervision of broadcasts made over the Internet passed through parliament on 21/03/2018 and became law8. The Law entered into force upon its publication in the Official Gazette of 27/03/2018, No. 30373 (2nd Repeated Issue)9.
By Article 73 of the Bill, which is Article 82 of the Law, there was added to the “Law on the Establishment of Radio and Television Enterprises and Their Broadcasting Services”, No. 6112 of 15.2.2011, to follow Article 29, an Article 29/A headed “Provision of broadcasting services over the Internet”. The arrangements introduced by the provision contained in the article are as follows:
• Media service provider organisations that have obtained a temporary broadcasting right or a broadcasting licence from RTÜK are enabled to provide their broadcasts over the Internet as well, with these rights and licences, in accordance with the provisions of Law No. 5651.
• The last sentence of paragraph 1 of the article imposes on media service providers that broadcast solely over the Internet an obligation, in order to be able to continue their activities, to obtain a licence or broadcast transmission authorisation solely for this purpose:
There are question marks as to how this provision will be reflected in practice. Among the media service providers that broadcast solely over the Internet, the first to come to mind are organisations such as Youtube and Puhu tv. If the sites in question do not obtain a licence from RTÜK, will it be possible for access to them to be blocked by RTÜK? Can such blocking be regarded as a violation of the rights of users?
On this point I am of the view that there is a violation of rights, particularly as regards the users of organisations where paid subscriptions are involved. The blocking by an administrative body of access to a site to which a person has subscribed by paying the price will constitute a violation of rights, and may also entitle the person whose right has been violated to claim compensation.
Given that this is a provision which may cause problems in practice and lead to troublesome consequences, I am of the opinion that care must be taken on this point and that it is essential thereafter to determine how the provision is to be applied.
• Where the Council establishes that the broadcasting services of natural and legal persons who hold no temporary broadcasting right or broadcasting licence obtained from RTÜK, or whose right or licence has been revoked, are being transmitted over the Internet, it is made possible for the criminal judge of peace, at the request of the Supreme Council, to give a decision for the removal of the content or the blocking of access in respect of the broadcast on the Internet, without a hearing being held and within twenty-four hours at the latest:
Another provision that is open to debate is the power conferred on RTÜK by paragraph 2 of the article to request the blocking of access. Under the provision, RTÜK will be able to apply to the criminal judgeship of peace and request the blocking of access.
Here I think the basic problem stems from the danger, which I also explained above, of the right to a fair trial being violated. To begin with, Law No. 6112 regulates comprehensively the establishment, duties, powers and responsibilities of RTÜK. According to Article 32(9) of the Law, an administrative action may be brought against the decisions of the Supreme Council, which is an administrative body. In proceedings to be conducted in accordance with the procedures of administrative justice, a decision is given after the claims and defences of both parties have been received. Yet under this provision the blocking of access will be effected at RTÜK’s request by the criminal judge of peace on the basis of the file, without a hearing being held.
While an administrative action, in which a fair trial will be conducted, may be brought against RTÜK’s decisions, a decision given at RTÜK’s request without a fair trial process being conducted is clearly contrary to law and amounts to a violation of the right to a fair trial.
The same violation also holds true for the similar provisions of Law No. 5651 concerning the blocking of access.
• Paragraph 3 of the article imposes on organisations broadcasting abroad too, in parallel with paragraph 2, an obligation to obtain a licence or broadcast transmission authorisation in order to be able to continue their broadcasts on the Internet. The feasibility of this obligation is also highly debatable. The practical result of the provision is that the broadcasts of Internet broadcasters who cannot obtain a licence, or who, given the libertarian nature of the Internet, do not wish to trouble themselves with this, will be blocked. The harm from this will be suffered by the individuals who are unable to reach the broadcasts and content in question.
• Paragraph 4 of the provision removes individual communication from the scope of the article and states that platforms not dedicated to transmitting radio, television and on-demand broadcasting services over the Internet, and natural and legal persons who merely provide hosting for radio, television and on-demand broadcasting services, are not deemed platform operators within the scope of this article: By removing individual communication from the scope of the provision, this paragraph of the article has in essence narrowed the scope of the power conferred on RTÜK. Accordingly, in the case of persons who individually provide content and broadcast on the Internet,
it will not be possible to request the blocking of access to their broadcasts. For example, persons who broadcast from their personal Facebook profile or on Facebook pages may be counted within this scope. Since the broadcasts made by Youtubers who broadcast vlogs on Youtube, which has recently become very popular and has turned into a line of occupation, are also counted as individual communication, they remain outside the provision in question.
The uncertainty in the provision as to the limits of the power has thus been removed, at least to some extent. Otherwise it would be understood that RTÜK had a power to request that access to a site broadcasting on the Internet be blocked in its entirety, which would amount to a wholly unlimited and serious power. Despite this limitation, however, uncertainty still remains on a number of points. For instance, will RTÜK be able to request the blocking of access to the whole of Facebook, one of the most widely used social media tools? If it has such a power, access to the broadcasts of those who broadcast individually on these media will also have been blocked; in such an eventuality, will there not be an inconsistency with the paragraph of the provision that keeps individual communication outside its scope?
The most illuminating example on the subject is the judgment in “Ahmet Yıldırım v. Türkiye”10. In the case in question the applicant complained that his freedom of expression had been restricted on account of a measure ordering the blocking of all access to a site, which had been given in the context of a criminal investigation that had no connection whatsoever with him or his site. In its judgment the Court, without departing from the general principles it had established in its earlier case law on the subject, stated that everyone’s freedom of expression must be guaranteed and that this guarantee applies not only to the content of information but also to the means of its dissemination. It was further concluded that the decision given by the Local Court was not a wide-ranging ban but was clearly a restriction on Internet access. In conclusion, it was accepted that, as a result of the blocking of access to the whole of the website, the freedom of expression of the person publishing within the scope of individual communication had been violated.
With the increase in individual use on the Internet and with it becoming possible for persons to create content, the connection of the publications made in this environment with freedom of expression and with the fundamental rights and freedoms of the person has increased in parallel. For this reason, since this paragraph of the provision in particular may be such as to damage the fundamental rights of the person, I think that great care must be taken in practice.
• It is stated that the principles and procedures concerning the provision and transmission of radio, television and on-demand broadcasting services over the Internet, the granting of broadcasting licences for the Internet to media service providers and of broadcast transmission certificates to platform enterprises, the supervision of the broadcasts in question, and the implementation of the article are to be laid down by regulation by the Supreme Council and the Information and Communication Technologies Authority.
Criticisms Concerning the RTÜK Supervision Provision
Conferring on RTÜK the power to supervise broadcasts made on the Internet and to request the blocking of access to broadcasts raises, first of all, a number of problems with regard to the administrative body so empowered. In the first place, it is a major question mark how sound a practice it will be to confer on a media body the power to grant licences for Internet broadcasts or to supervise the content of those broadcasts. The Internet is by its nature a field different from classical media, and conferring the powers relating to these fields on the same body is liable to cause difficulties, particularly in practice.
On the other hand, a power of this kind has in any event already been conferred on the Information and Communication Technologies Authority and the Union of Access Providers. Furthermore, conferring the same power once more on another institution such as RTÜK, which in essence has no connection with those institutions in terms of its functions, is in the first place unnecessary; and in the second place, if this provision is put into effect, a conflict of competence between the institutions in question becomes inevitable.
The provision giving RTÜK the power to supervise broadcasts made on the Internet and to request the blocking of access to broadcasts must, secondly, be examined from the standpoint of censorship and freedom of the press. Since the present situation in Türkiye is already a cause for concern as regards freedom of the press, particular care must be taken in the steps to be taken on the subject.
The ECHR deals with freedom of the press within the scope of Article 10, which governs freedom of expression, and its importance is sought to be explained through case law. In the judgments in “Sunday Times v. the United Kingdom”11 and “Handyside v. the United Kingdom”12, which are the most important judgments concerning freedom of the press, the importance of freedom of the press was addressed by stating that freedom of expression is one of the requirements of the democratic order of society but that this freedom becomes even more important where the press is concerned. Mention was made of the need to protect within this scope also information and ideas that are against the State or a section, or that strike it as shocking or disturbing, and an attempt was thus made to broaden the scope of the concept of freedom of the press. In its judgment in “Kjeldsen, Busk Madsen and Pedersen v. Denmark”13, in which it used expressions to the same effect, the Court stated that, in addition to the organs of the press and media being under a duty to impart information to the public, the public also has a right to receive information and ideas, and it thus also touched upon the two-sided aspect of freedom of the press, that of imparting and of receiving information.
When we look at the constitutional provisions on the subject, we see that freedom of the press is protected in Article 28 of the Constitution, headed freedom of the press. While the text of the article states that the press is free and may not be censored, the taking of measures to ensure freedom of the press and freedom of information is framed as a positive obligation of the State.
It is plain and clear that the powers of supervision and of requesting the blocking of access conferred on RTÜK are such as to lead to the arbitrary censoring of the Internet and that freedom of expression and freedom of the press will consequently be damaged. As I explained above, decisions to block access and remove content already harbour certain dangers for fundamental rights and freedoms, so that restrictions on the subject need to be imposed in conformity with the conditions set out in Article 13 of the Constitution; to confer this power, on top of that, on an institution such as RTÜK, which can in no way be regarded as a judicial authority, amounts to a clear violation of persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms.
Furthermore, the criticisms made above of the relevant provisions of Law No. 5651, on the ground that the decision is given within a period such as twenty-four hours, without a hearing being held, on the allegation of a single party, are valid at this point too.
The danger of a violation of freedom of the press posed by the bill attracted attention even at the international level, and the Office of the Representative on Freedom of the Media of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe voiced the warning and concern that, should the bill be approved, pluralism in the media would be limited still further. What is more, the Council of Europe had recently stated that the press in Türkiye was in a dramatic situation and that there was concern about the situation. When the matter is considered together with these views, there is a danger that the article of the law will be perceived, and will function, as a new step in the narrowing first of freedom of expression and then of freedom of the press.
Conclusion and My View
I stated above that, because the computer and the Internet emerged as a result of the developments in the field of information technologies and these technologies in time entered every sphere of life and became an indispensable part of it, the need for statutory regulation became imperative. For by means of the Internet the commission of the existing types of offence has become easier, or new types of offence have emerged.
In particular, the fact that it has become very easy for child abuse, child pornography and other acts constituting offences against children to be carried out by means of the Internet, and also the commission of the types of offence regulated in the TCK by publications made on the Internet, mostly via social media, must be prevented. In this context I find it necessary and appropriate for the State to take steps to provide a safe Internet space. However, the making of regulations that may amount to restricting fundamental rights and freedoms and blocking communication in the name of creating a safe environment must not be accepted either.
Since the blocking of access to publications made on the Internet and the removal of the content of those publications are directly connected with persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms, care must be taken in the regulations on the subject. Although, because individuals nowadays turn the Internet into an instrument of crime, it is in some cases imperative to take the measures in question, these measures must be taken in conformity with the rules to be observed in restricting fundamental rights and freedoms and must not be open to arbitrary use. Otherwise there will be a contravention of the international treaties to which we are a party, the ECHR first and foremost, and of the provisions of the Constitution.
Law No. 5651 and its relevant provisions regulating the blocking of access and the removal of content appear, as I have explained in detail above, to be open to debate in terms of both substance and procedure. That being so, I am of the opinion that conferring on RTÜK, which is not a judicial authority, the power to request the taking of decisions that directly restrict persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms is in no way an acceptable arrangement.
I think that the powers conferred on RTÜK to supervise the content of broadcasts made on the Internet and, where it deems it necessary, to request the blocking of access to that content and its removal pose a threat not only to freedom of expression and the right to a fair trial but also, and to a greater and more serious degree, to freedom of the press, which I already regard as being in a grave state in Türkiye. Yet the existence of free media and the ability of individuals to voice their thoughts and opinions freely is one of the most important points distinguishing democratic societies from totalitarian and oppressive regimes. I am hopeful that Türkiye, which claims to be a democratic country, will also put an end to regulations of this kind and make statutory regulations that attach importance to persons’ fundamental rights and freedoms and are compatible with the principles of justice and of being a state governed by the rule of law.
Footnotes
- Academic/Attorney-at-law. ↑
- Murat Volkan Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, 6. Baskı, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2015, s.14. ↑
- Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, (6), s.24, 25. ↑
- Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, (6), s.35, 36. ↑
- For the full report see: https://wearesocial.com/uk/special-reports/digital-in-2017-global-overview ↑
- For the Hanehalkı Bilişim Teknolojileri Kullanım Araştırması 2017 Raporu see: http://www.tuik.gov.tr/HbPrint.do?id=24862 ↑
- Murat Volkan Dülger, Bilişim, Kişisel Verilerin Korunması ve İnternet İletişimi Mevzuatı, 3. Baskı, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2018, s. 629-631. ↑
- YHGK 2014/4-56 E. 2015/1679 K. ↑
- For the bill (1/914) and the Report of the Plan and Budget Committee see: https://www.tbmm.gov.tr/sirasayi/donem26/yil01/ss533.pdf ↑
- For the full text of the Law see: http://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/main.aspx?home=http://www.resmigazete. gov.tr/eskiler/2018/03/20180327m2.htm&main=http://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2018/03/20180327m2.htm ↑
- For the full judgment see: file:///C:/Users/hp-pro/Downloads/Chamber%20judgment%20Ahmet %20Yildirim%20v.%20Turkey%2018.12.2012.pdf For the Turkish translation of the judgment see also: http://www.inhak. adalet.gov.tr/ara/karar/ahmetyildirim.pdf ↑
- For the full judgment see: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{"fulltext":["sunday times"], "documentcollectionid2":["GRANDCHAMBER","CHAMBER"],"itemid":["001-57584"]} ↑
- For the full judgment see: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{"fulltext":["Handyside"],"document collectionid2":["GRANDCHAMBER","CHAMBER"],"itemid":["001-57499"]} ↑
- For the full judgment see: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{"itemid":["001-57509"]} ↑
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Use of Crypto Assets in the Laundering of Proceeds of Crime and the Measures to Be Taken” (Kripto Varlıkların Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasında Kullanılması ve Alınması Gereken Önlemler), Istanbul Aydın University Faculty of Law Journal (İstanbul Aydın Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi), Vol. 10, No. 1, 2024, pp. 41-94.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Legal Regime of Social Network Providers, Internet News Sites and Over-the-Top Service Providers, and a Critique” (Sosyal Ağ Sağlayıcıların İnternet Haber Sitelerinin ve Şebekeler Üstü Hizmet Sağlayıcıların Hukuki Rejimi ve Eleştirisi), Dülger Law Office, 1 June 2023.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Electronic Document as the Object of Document Forgery Offences” (Belgede Sahtecilik Suçlarının Konusu Olarak Elektronik Belge), Symposium on Forgery of Documents and Tax Offences (Belgede Sahtecilik ve Vergi Suçları Sempozyumu), 21–24 October 2019, Publication of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation / TOBB ETÜ Faculty of Law, Ankara, 2020.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “What Does WhatsApp's Privacy Change Mean? Will Our Data Be Shared?” (WhatsApp Güvenlik Değişikliği Ne Anlama Geliyor? Verilerimiz Paylaşılacak mı?), Dülger Law Office, 5 January 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Commercial Electronic Messages and the Message Management System” (Ticari Elektronik İleti ve İleti Yönetim Sistemi), Dülger Law Office, 15 November 2020.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Cybercrime and Internet Communication Law (Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku), 11th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2025.

