Introduction
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
If, in considering the concept of sexual offences, only the offence types set out in criminal codes are taken into account, it is understood as consisting of sexual harassment, molestation (sarkıntılık), simple sexual assault and aggravated sexual assault. Yet the concept of sexual offences is broader than this, and in terms of its effects goes beyond it. Especially since the information revolution, as the internet has become an indispensable part of our lives and all kinds of our personal data, including our private lives, have moved onto social media, the frequency and reach of these offences have increased in an unforeseeable way. In the pre-internet era, committing a sexual offence against a person required being close enough to make physical contact with that person, or at least sending a letter or the like; today it is extremely easy for a perpetrator to commit sexual assault in the digital sphere while remaining anonymous.
This is an environment that makes it harder to find the perpetrator on the one hand and easier to commit the offence on the other. The most widespread example of this is the phenomenon of “revenge porn”, in which former partners or spouses have recently been anonymously sharing images or videos of the other party naked or taken during sexual intercourse. Another method of committing sexual offences brought about by the digital age is to blackmail victims by using private images or information obtained in some way in the digital environment, and so to force them into sexual intercourse with the perpetrator or with third parties. A further sexual offence is the ease with which access is obtained to child pornography, animal pornography or pornographic content involving violence.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
SEXUAL OFFENCES COMMITTED THROUGH THE INTERNET* (SEXUAL OFFENCES COMMITTED THROUGH INTERNET)
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger* SUMMARY
If the concept of sexual offence is taken to cover only the types of offence laid down in the criminal codes, it is perceived as consisting merely of sexual harassment, molestation, simple sexual assault and aggravated sexual assault. The concept of sexual offence is, however, broader than this and, in terms of its effects, goes beyond it. Particularly since the information revolution, as the internet has become an indispensable part of our lives and all kinds of personal data, including our private lives, have been carried over to social media, the frequency with which these offences are committed and their sphere of impact have increased to an unforeseeable extent.
In the pre-internet era, committing a sexual offence against a person required being close enough to make physical contact with the victim, or at least sending a letter or the like; today, by contrast, it is extremely easy for the perpetrator to carry out a sexual attack in the digital sphere while remaining anonymous. This is an environment which, on the one hand, makes it harder to find the perpetrator and, on the other, makes it easier to commit the offence. The most common example of this is the recently emerged phenomenon of “revenge porn”, in which former partners or spouses anonymously share images or videos of the other party taken while naked or during lovemaking.
Another method of committing sexual offences brought to the fore by the digital age is to subject victims to blackmail by using private images or information obtained in some way in the digital environment, thereby forcing them into sexual relations with the perpetrator himself or with third parties.
A further sexual offence consists in the easy access provided to child pornography, animal pornography or pornographic content involving violence. These, in particular, are patterns of offending that the whole world is fighting against.
In my article I shall attempt to make a general assessment of the transformation that sexual offences, in fact a very old type of offence, have undergone in today’s digital world, of the opportunities, in the negative sense, that this has created for offenders, and of the methods of combating them.
Keywords: internet, sexual offences, sexual assault, sexual harassment, cybercrime, revenge porn, child pornography.
ABSTRACT
If sexual offences to take into account are only the types of crimes that are prescribed in criminal codes, the concept of sexual offences would be perceived no more than sexual harassment, molestation, simple sexual assault and qualified sexual assault. However, the concept of sexual offences is broader than and beyond these in terms of the effects. The frequency of committing these offences and the incidence of them are raised unforeseeably by means of that internet has become the indispensable part of our lives and all sort of our personal data including private life are brought out social media particularly after information revolution.
Whereas it must have been far away in a certain distance to conduct physical contact such as sending letter at least etc., in today’s world it is immensely easy the perpetrator to conduct sexual assault in digital platform anonymously. On one hand this platform obstructs the perpetrator to be found, on the other hand enables crimes to be committed. Lately “revenge porn” is the most common example of that ex-partner or spouse shares anonymously the other one’s naked images or videos during sexual affair.
It is another method of committing sexual offence which digital era brought out, to compel the victims to have an affair with the perpetrator or third person by blackmailing them by means of using their private images or data.
Another sexual offence is to enable to reach the contents including child pornography, animal pornography or violence. Especially these are the methods of committing crime against which the whole world has been fighting.
In this article, I am going to try to evaluate the overview of the opportunities in a negative way for the perpetrators and the conversion of sexual offences that actually date back to old times in digital era and method of combat them.
Keywords: internet, sexual offences, sexual assault, sexual harassment, cybercrime, revenge pornography, child pornography.
Extended Abstract
The present work is aimed to look at the issue of sexual offences committed by means of internet, going through the statistics, the legal framework under the Turkish criminal law, also their incentives, means and methods.
As with other “traditional” crimes, the internet diversified the types of sexual offences and the means and methods to commit them, also it eased to get engaged with these offences. To exemplify, in today’s world, one does not need to be anywhere near the victim in order to be able to commit sexual offences; the perpetrator and the victim could easily be in different cities or countries, even continents, but the offence could still be formed.
Statistics demonstrate that there is an increase in the perpetration of sexual offences. Considering that the most searched words on internet found to be “sex” and similar words regarding sexuality and pornography according to several research, such outcome is no surprise. In addition, it has been revealed that pornographic content constitutes more than half of the overall content on the internet.
It is indisputable that all sexual content cannot be considered as illegal, and it cannot be concluded that using internet for sexual purposes constitute an offence per se. However, cyber sexual criminality comprises a considerable portion of the utilisation of the internet for sexuality.
The proliferation of the usage of the internet for deviant purposes and the increasement in the numbers of cyber sexual offences can be directly associated with three inherent characteristics of the internet: accessibility, affordability and anonymity. To clarify, persons who cannot access to sexuality “offline”, can easily do this by simply clicking, and for the vast majority of time without any price. Furthermore, the perpetrators are of the belief that their identity would not be disclosed, and this belief trigger them to loosen their control and act more freely, comparing to their “real life”. Having said that, it should always be borne in mind that the mere reason of engaging in sexual offences is not sexual desires, rather other emotions like anger, sadness or hate. Besides, it is noticeably common that the fact that cyber sexual offences take places on the internet creates some sort of indifference both at the victim and at the perpetrator.
By its definition, sexual assault cannot be committed through internet. Sexual harassment, on the other hand, is a very common type of cyber sexual offence which can be examined under three main subgroups: gender harassment, unwanted sexual attention and sexual coercion. Likewise, non-consensual pornography, revenge pornography and child pornography are other widely-committed cyber sexual offences.
Among pornographic content, revenge pornography will be placed under scrutiny which got disquietedly widespread with the utilisation of the internet. Revenge porn is basically dissemination of private and sexual content which the perpetrator recorded or received due to his/her private relationship with the victim, then spread after the end of that relationship with the aim of retribute. Unlike most of the sexual offences, revenge porn contains a “trust” element, i.e. the victims of this offence consensually share their intimate and sexual photos and videos and/or they give consent to the perpetrators to record such scenes, trusting the relationship they have with the perpetrators. The latter behaviour is, however, triggered with the intent of vengeance, following the end of their relationship; thus, it occurs without the victims’ consent and/or beyond their knowledge.
Consequently, in this study, first the utilisation of internet to commit crimes and its relation with sexual offences will be explained. Subsequently, the concept of cyber sexual harassment and its evaluation under Turkish Criminal Law will be discussed. This work will continue with examining other cyber sexual offences, namely, non-consensual pornography, revenge pornography and child pornography.
Introduction
Sexual offences are generally assessed differently from other types of offence, and because of the anger society feels towards this form of criminality they occupy a very large place on the agenda of the fight against crime. These offences, which target sexual inviolability, are perceived as more invasive and more disturbing than other types of offence and, as a consequence, as more serious offences1.
Moreover, both in our country and worldwide, the rates at which sexual offences are committed, or at least reported, are rising year by year, and the concept of sexual offence is becoming an ever greater source of concern for society. One of the most important phenomena affecting the number and types of sexual offences is the internet. In this study I shall attempt to make a general assessment of the transformation that sexual offences, in fact a very old type of offence, have undergone in today’s digital world, of the opportunities, in the negative sense, that this has created for offenders, of the methods of combating them, and of revenge porn, which has emerged as a new phenomenon both as a sexual offence and as a social problem.
I. Sexual Criminality on the Internet
The internet, frequently described as a chaotic, lawless and dangerous space, is a very extensive network formed by the interconnection of networks that are themselves formed by connecting millions of computers around the world2. Although the two terms are mostly used synonymously or assumed to be identical, the internet and the web (www – World Wide Web) differ from each other. The internet is the overarching concept denoting every kind of network made up of networks linking information systems, whereas the web is merely one type and sub-part of the internet. The web, through which, by means of websites and web browsers, we obtain unlimited access to and interaction with IT devices on which text, images, sound and the like are stored, is the most widely used type of network on the internet. Although today by far the greater part of internet use takes place via the web, it should be remembered that the internet does not consist solely of the web.
We all know that the internet, which has become the fastest and easiest way of obtaining information today, has brought radical changes to our world and has affected every area of our lives almost like an epidemic. The aspect of this phenomenon that falls within the scope of my study is the opportunities it creates for sexual offenders and, as a new type of criminality and a new field of crime to which it has given rise, sexual offences committed through the internet.
In fact, sexuality is among the foremost purposes for which the internet is used. In most research in this field, the word “sex” turns out to be the most searched word on the internet3. In other studies, too, the most searched words are always words related to sexuality and pornography4. Considering that approximately 70% of internet content consists of pornographic content, that close to three million e-mails with sexual content are sent every day and that approximately one hundred million people access pornographic content daily, it would not be wrong to say that people’s primary purpose in using the internet is sexuality. Sexuality experienced on the internet is commonly referred to as “cyber-sexuality” or “cyber-sex”. I too shall follow this terminology in my study.
A significant part of the use of the internet for sexual purposes consists of activities that are not unlawful or, at least, do not constitute an offence5. Examples are sex education, the trade in erotic products, legitimate sexual entertainment, sex therapy, platforms for finding sex partners and virtual sex platforms; although these are areas that may be abused in line with the aims of individuals, they are essentially legitimate areas of use6. However, the use of the internet for “deviant” sexual purposes is also of no small extent.
My criterion of deviance here is, of course, that the conduct is not regarded as legitimate by the legal order. User conduct regarded as deviant in the moral sense falls outside the scope of our study. However, the pursuit of sexual gratification on the internet mostly ends in addiction7. As with gambling addiction, an addiction that always proceeds in pursuit of the “big score” brings the person, beyond a certain point, across the line into illegality. An individual who is initially aroused by “reasonable” content comes after a while to need “deviant” content, then becomes desensitised to sexual deviance and, as a result, may easily turn to crime8. This brings to the fore the phenomenon of the use of the internet for sexual offences. The use of the internet for sexual offences is commonly referred to as “cyber sexual criminality”, and sexual offences committed on the internet as “cyber sexual crimes/offenses”.
Cyber sexual offences are increasing day by day and cyber sexual criminality is becoming ever more widespread9. The use of the internet for deviant sexual purposes and the increase in cyber sexual offences have causes stemming from the nature of the internet. These causes may be listed as accessibility, affordability and anonymity10. The existence of the internet makes the means necessary for engaging in deviant sexual behaviour accessible at any time from anywhere and obtainable almost free of charge. Moreover, it is also possible to carry out these acts while concealing one’s real identity, that is, anonymously.
While accessibility and affordability make it easier to engage in deviant sexual behaviour, what attracts cyber sexual offenders most is the ability to remain anonymous. Although the perception of remaining anonymous and not being traced often does not reflect reality, many people who in real life keep away from crime for fear of their identity being revealed and of being caught turn to crime on the internet, emboldened by the assurance that anonymity provides11. According to a study conducted in the United States of America, the great majority of cyber sexual offenders are entry-level offenders with no previous criminal record12. In other words, these persons do not turn to crime in this way in the physical world. This confirms the thesis that individuals who keep their deviant sexual urges under control in social life are extremely likely to commit offences as a result of opportunities such as the accessibility, affordability and anonymity offered by the internet.
Anonymity on the internet also paves the way for potential victims of cyber sexual offences to become more vulnerable. The freedom that drives the perpetrator to act paradoxically lowers the victim’s resistance. Moreover, a potential victim who believes his identity to be hidden discloses his emotional world far more easily and becomes open to manipulation13. The confidentiality of the victim’s identity provides no protection with regard to offences that do not target a specific victim14.
Another reason for widespread cyber sexual criminality is the desensitisation caused by the internet environment. Scruples of conscience and feelings of empathy, which generally serve to deter people from crime, lose their effect on the internet. The perpetrator, who mostly does not come face to face with the victim and does not target a specific victim, distances himself from his scruples of conscience and becomes desensitised, an effect reinforced by the virtual nature of the internet15. Furthermore, the victim, too, with the ease that comes from being in the virtual world, may readily engage in sexual approaches which, owing to various sensitivities, he would not enter into in normal life, and this, too, feeds the phenomenon of cyber sexual criminality.
The term sexual offences is understood to mean offences committed against sexual inviolability. According to the traditional view, these are the offences of sexual harassment, sexual assault and sexual intercourse directed at adults or minors, irrespective of patterns of sexual identity. Although the commission of some of these offences through the internet is not regarded as possible (e.g. aggravated sexual assault, sexual intercourse with a minor), the forms committed through the internet (e.g. sexual harassment) should be dealt with within the scope of cyber sexual criminality. These offences, as defined by the criminal statutes, mostly concern physical contact between perpetrator and victim. In cyber sexual criminality, by contrast, the prominent types of offence are offences mostly targeting children, such as non-contact abuse in the virtual environment, grooming for contact abuse planned in the real environment, or child pornography. Besides the fact that it is these offences, rather than the traditional sexual offences, that are committed with great frequency on the internet, the attention of politics, public opinion and law enforcement is also focused on these offences16.
In dealing with sexual offences committed on the internet, I intend to interpret the concept of “sexual offence” somewhat more broadly and, in addition, to deal within this scope with certain acts of a sexual nature even where they are based on consent. In this context I shall assess the concept of revenge porn.
II. Sexual Harassment through the Internet A. The Normative Place of Sexual Harassment
The offences regulated by the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK) under the heading “Offences against Sexual Inviolability” are sexual assault, sexual abuse of children, sexual intercourse with a minor and sexual harassment. Since physical proximity and contact between perpetrator and victim are indispensable for the offences of sexual assault, sexual abuse of children and sexual intercourse with a minor, it is not possible for these offences to be committed virtually on the internet. Although the phenomenon of remote sex known as “virtual sex” or “cyber sex”, based on stimulating and satisfying one another through written, oral and visual communication on the internet, is becoming increasingly widespread17, it is not possible, under the principle of legality of offences and penalties and the prohibition of extensive interpretation in criminal law, for such acts, which involve neither physical contact nor physical togetherness, to constitute the offence of sexual assault or of sexual intercourse with a minor. Accordingly, it may be said that these three types of offence cannot be committed via the internet and fall outside the concept of cyber criminality.
With regard to these offences, the internet can be used as an instrument only in the context of preparatory acts. Although the use of the internet as an instrument of preparation in this way is also a subject worth examining from the point of view of combating crime and criminality18, I shall not go into this dimension of the subject, since the boundaries of criminal law form the framework of my study. In this respect I shall deal only with the offence of sexual harassment.
B. Definition
The offence of sexual harassment is regulated in Art. 105 TCK. Accordingly, “A person who harasses another person for sexual purposes shall, upon the complaint of the victim, be sentenced to imprisonment from three months to two years or to a judicial fine, or, where the act is committed against a child, to imprisonment from six months to three years”19. As can be seen, a definition is given here by means of the term “harassment”, but no explanation of harassment is provided.
According to the Turkish Language Association, the dictionary meaning of harassment is “to unsettle, to disturb”20. According to a somewhat more comprehensive definition, harassment is “to annoy a person, to deprive him of his peace, to cause him distress”21.
Harassment without a sexual purpose does not fall within the scope of Art. 10522. For this reason, the concept we actually need to deal with is that of sexual harassment. This concept, for which no definition is found in the basic dictionaries, is defined by the explanatory memorandum of the Law and by legal scholarship. According to the explanatory memorandum of Art. 105, sexual harassment is “sexual conduct that does not amount to a violation of the victim’s bodily inviolability”. In legal scholarship there are many definitions that define sexual harassment broadly so as to include molestation, or restrict it to conduct directed by men at women23. I am of the opinion that these definitions, formulated in the light of the provisions of the former TCK No. 765, have become outdated. Among the definitions I consider current and accurate, according to one view “sexual harassment consists in … disturbing the victim in a sexual respect”24. According to another view, sexual harassment is “any oral or written act for sexual purposes, of a disturbing nature, directed at the sexuality of an individual or individuals and involving no bodily contact”25. On the basis of these definitions, sexual harassment can be committed by words, in writing or by bodily gestures. What matters is that conduct of a sexual nature is carried out targeting the victim but without physical contact with the victim.
Although the authors of the first definition above used the expression “contrary to moral decency”, I do not agree with it. The first reason for this is that, while most immoral conduct constitutes an offence, some immoral conduct is not defined as an offence (e.g. adultery), and some offences are not immoral (e.g. the offences of contravening the Law on Meetings and Demonstrations). Crime and immorality are therefore not the same concepts and cannot be explained in terms of each other. On the other hand, what is prohibited and punished in sexual offences is not “immoral conduct” but conduct directed against the individual’s sexual freedom. Types of offence in which the protected legal interest is the sexual freedom of the individual cannot be explained by “immorality”. This explanation of mine does not deny the fact that most sexual offences are, from the point of view of present-day society, “also found to be immoral”; that is true. A criminal law norm, however, must not be explained by immorality. Consequently, conduct directed against the sexual freedom of the individual will constitute a sexual offence even if it is not perceived and/or accepted as immoral by the individual or by society.
Acts of sexual harassment can be grouped under three main headings: gender harassment, unwanted sexual attention and sexual coercion26. In gender harassment the perpetrator addresses the victim in a hostile or disturbing manner on the basis of the victim’s gender. Unwanted sexual attention is the showing of attention to the victim to a disturbing degree through one-sided conduct or statements of a sexual nature. Sexual coercion, finally, is putting the victim under pressure, or forcing him by threats, to engage in sexual conduct. The object of this pressure may be acts that would fall under the offences of sexual assault or abuse, but it may also be sexual conduct that does not fall within the scope of those offences, such as sexual exposure or being forced to declare that one sexually desires the perpetrator.
C. Forms of Sexual Harassment
Acts of sexual harassment taking place on the internet are, like other types of cyber sexual offence, referred to as “cyber sexual harassment”. All three types of face-to-face sexual harassment also exist on the internet. The act of cyber sexual harassment appears in the following forms: active verbal, passive verbal, active graphic and passive graphic27.
In active verbal harassment the perpetrator sends the victim written or oral sexual messages of a harassing nature. Acts of active verbal harassment, which in the early days of the internet mostly took the form of written messages, are today encountered frequently in the true sense of the word, with the spread of internet-based messaging applications such as WhatsApp and of internet platforms that make oral communication possible. In passive verbal harassment the perpetrator shares his message not by directly targeting a specific victim but by addressing it to potential victims. The act of active graphic sexual harassment is carried out very much like the active verbal act, but using images containing obscenity. In passive graphic harassment, too, the perpetrator shares the obscene image without targeting a specific victim. The passive forms of these acts do not as a rule constitute an offence, but may constitute the offence of sexual harassment under certain conditions. I shall deal with these in detail below.
D. Types of Sexual Harassment 1. Gender Harassment
Gender harassment is something to which internet users of many kinds are frequently exposed. Gender harassment may take an active verbal form. Degrading comments targeting a gender should be assessed in this context. Comments containing hatred and contempt directed at trans individuals in particular are an obvious example of gender harassment. Comments with sexual content that are disturbing, even if not directly degrading, also constitute gender harassment. Obscene jokes and comments that do not openly express a sexual interest directed at the addressee, or that are not coercive towards the addressee, fall into this category. Such comments, not requested by the addressee and unwelcome to him, are harassment and may give rise to the offence of sexual harassment. Active verbal gender harassment is generally committed in places such as chat rooms and forums and by means of internet communication tools (e-mail, WhatsApp, etc.). Of average internet users, 62% are exposed to such unwanted content on sexual topics28.
Gender harassment may be graphic as well as verbal. The sending of images with sexual content to an addressee by means of internet communication tools is the principal example. Sexual harassment occurs where erotic or pornographic content is sent to an addressee who does not want it and the addressee is disturbed by it. Here the problem arises of how the disturbing character of the graphic material in question is to be determined. For instance, a simple photograph containing nudity and a pornographic image containing violence are not equally disturbing. Moreover, the personal characteristics of the addressee and the relationship between recipient and sender will also be decisive in whether a given piece of content is perceived as disturbing. These are variables that also exist for acts of sexual harassment taking place in the physical environment, and the same problems in determining the harassing character of the act also exist for acts taking place outside the internet. At this point I believe that the existing approaches in legal scholarship and the case law will also be valid and offer guidance for acts taking place on the internet.
Verbal and graphic gender harassment may also take passive forms. Verbal or visual content may have been published on the internet for potential victims without targeting a specific addressee or addressees. Sound, text and images published on websites and the details of account information (bio) on some platforms are of this kind.
The most important factor in characterising a post with sexual content as harassing is the consent of the persons concerned. Unlike erotic or porn sites, which adults may enter with their consent, harassing posts draw their addressees to them by misleading advertising or coercive mechanisms (automatic redirection, pop-ups, etc.). Of internet users involuntarily exposed to content on sexual topics, 75% were not specifically made addressees of this content; they themselves came to it as a result of automatic redirection, pop-ups or misleading search engine results29. This shows how widespread passive gender harassment is.
Although gender harassment in passive forms is very widespread, it cannot constitute an offence within the meaning of Art. 105 TCK. Since the provision expressly requires the harassment of “a person”, the victim must be a specific person. Conduct by which the perpetrator, through acts with no specific addressee, violates the sexual inviolability of random persons does not give rise to the offence of sexual harassment but, if the conditions are met, may give rise to the offences of indecent acts regulated in Art. 225 TCK or of obscenity regulated in Art. 226. An example is a person talking obscenely or displaying obscene images in a public place without targeting anyone. The same criteria apply on the internet. For this reason, acts of sexual harassment in passive form, which are classified as sexual harassment in the eyes of various disciplines, above all the behavioural sciences, do not constitute sexual harassment in the criminal law sense.
2. Unwanted Attention
Unwanted attention is the expression of interest in sexual matters in a disturbing (harassing) manner, targeting a specific victim. This type of harassment, carried out through individual communication, takes the form of the perpetrator asking the victim questions about the victim’s genitals, sex life or other matters requiring intimacy, or inviting, encouraging or persuading the victim to engage in acts of a sexual nature. Unlike in gender harassment, here the perpetrator intends to steer the victim towards a sexual act involving reciprocity. The intended act may be a sexual act taking place in the physical environment or one taking place in the virtual environment (e.g. webcam exposure or cyber sex). An active act on the part of the perpetrator is indispensable for harassment in the form of unwanted sexual attention. This act may be verbal or graphic, but must in any event be an active act.
Cyber sexual harassment in the form of unwanted attention may be aggressive in style but may also be milder and inviting. What matters is that the act is perceived by the victim as disturbing to a harassing degree. Here again I must refer to the criteria relating to sexual harassment in the physical environment. As regards the internet specifically, I am of the opinion that on platforms where sexual interest is normal, in particular forums for finding sexual partners or for chats with sexual content, the act must be manifestly aggressive in order to be characterised as harassment. Of course, on such a platform the addressee of non-aggressive attention may also be disturbed by it. In that case, however, it can be said that the perpetrator will benefit from the provisions on mistake within the meaning of Art. 30 TCK and that no offence will be constituted because of a mistake excluding intent.
3. Cyber Sexual Coercion
Cyber sexual coercion is a type of harassment different from, and perhaps more serious than, gender harassment and unwanted sexual attention. Cyber sexual coercion denotes putting the victim under pressure towards sexual togetherness by means of coercion available or possible in the virtual environment. Cyber sexual coercion may be carried out with the coercive means used in traditional sexual coercion, such as force, threats and blackmail, but also by means of an unlimited number of coercive means specific to the internet. Although physical force is not possible in the virtual environment, it is even possible, by using IT capabilities, to coerce the victim to an extent equivalent to physical force. For example, the victim may be coerced in a manner equivalent to physical coercion by methods of computer espionage such as forcibly redirecting him to certain pages, not allowing him to leave a website or communication channel, or installing on his information systems malicious applications that capture or transmit images or sound. In this case the offence of sexual harassment is constituted; such non-physical coercion, however, does not give rise to the offence of force within the meaning of Art. 108 TCK, in accordance with the prohibition of analogy and of extensive interpretation.
Threatening the victim that he will suffer certain harm in the physical environment or on the internet is also a frequently encountered type of sexual coercion. In particular, a perpetrator who has obtained obscene images of the victim by force or with consent forces the victim into sexual togetherness by threatening to disseminate them on the internet. Where the victim is coerced by methods such as threats, blackmail, seizure of his IT device or intimidation by the dissemination of obscene photographs, then in addition to the offence of sexual harassment the offences of “Threat” (Art. 106 TCK), “Blackmail” (Art. 107 TCK), “Illegal access to an information system” (Art. 243 TCK) and “Hindering or disrupting the system, destroying or altering data” (Art. 244 TCK), as well as the offences against private life and the secret sphere of life regulated in Articles 132 to 138 TCK, will find application.
In addition, the act of “stalking”, meaning tracking or covertly watching, which involves no serious coercion and constitutes no other offence, may also be a suitable means of putting pressure on the victim. A victim who notices that he is constantly being tracked and followed on the internet may feel compelled into the sexual togetherness demanded by the perpetrator. As with the physical following of a person in real life, stalking carried out for sexual purposes on the internet may constitute cyber sexual harassment in the form of sexual coercion and may give rise to the offence of sexual harassment within the meaning of Art. 105 TCK.
III. The Concepts of Non-Consensual Pornography and Revenge Porn
As a new way of committing the offence of sexual harassment, non-consensual pornography (nonconsensual pornography) may be defined as the creation30, recording and/or dissemination of intimate and sexual images of the victim31. In this respect the definition of non-consensual pornography covers images obtained without the victim’s consent (e.g. covert recordings of the person or recordings of a sexual assault), but it also includes images that the person consented to giving or to having recorded on the basis of a private relationship32.
On the other hand, revenge porn (revenge pornography), a media term, means the non-consensual sharing, after the relationship between the persons has ended and with the aim of “revenge” , of sexual and intimate photographs or videos which the victim consented to having recorded by, or to giving to, a former partner33. The prevalence of the concept of revenge porn leads to the term being wrongly used in place of every kind of non-consensual pornography. Non-consensual pornography, however, is not always carried out with the aim of revenge34. For instance, a perpetrator who records images of the act he commits during a sexual assault may, by disseminating these images and threatening the victim with their dissemination, also act with the aim of silencing and humiliating the victim35. Perpetrators also act with motives of obtaining financial gain, damaging the victim’s reputation and harming the victim’s social relationships36.
The use of the term pornography is, moreover, itself the subject of criticism. The word pornography, preferred in legislative work as in the example of England and Wales, has been considered inappropriate because pornography is disseminated above all for purposes of sexual pleasure, so that the act involving the images may be perceived as a choice directed at such entertainment, or because the word carries the connotation of conferring legitimacy on the acts37. The use of the word pornography has also been criticised because it may give rise to the impression that people photographing themselves naked or engaging in a sexual activity is in itself pornographic38.
In response to a concept produced by the media such as revenge porn, legal scholarship, for reasons parallel to those above, shows intensive efforts to name this subject and, correspondingly, a terminological confusion. Concepts such as “image-based sexual abuse”39, “technology-facilitated sexual violence”40, non-consensual pornography41, “involuntary porn”42 and revenge porn43 have been preferred by various authors in the literature.
Since in my study I focus on the dissemination of the images rather than on how they were obtained, I shall use non-consensual pornography and “revenge porn”, the most frequently encountered term and the one accepted by the public, in the scope and context indicated above.
A. The Nature of the Images Forming the Subject Matter of Revenge Porn
Revenge porn consists of the stages of obtaining intimate and sexually explicit photographs or videos of the victims44 and disseminating them online or physically45. The obtaining stage takes place with the victim’s consent as a result of the private relationship between perpetrator and victim, the images being recorded by the perpetrator or shared with the perpetrator by the victim. The dissemination of the images, by contrast, takes place without the victim’s consent and in some cases even without the victim’s knowledge; the feeling of revenge felt because the relationship has ended for reasons such as rejection or being cheated on drives the perpetrator to act. Since the subject matter of the offence consists of intimate, sexually explicit and obscene images of the victim, these concepts first need to be defined and their framework determined.
1. Obscene Image
Obscene images must first of all be images capable of causing the victim harm in a sexual respect. In this respect, the perpetrator’s attack must, by exposing the person’s sexual identity, be directed against and cause harm to the victim’s personal dignity and sexual autonomy46.
There is no doubt that images showing persons’ genitals/intimate areas or showing them while engaged in sexual activities will be regarded as obscene. Likewise, images that, taken as a whole, may be regarded by a reasonable third person as sexual in content may also be assessed as falling within the scope of obscene images. The reasonable third person test has been adopted by the United Kingdom legislature47. For example, although a person’s foot is not regarded as an intimate area, it may, by the nature of the images and in their context, form an image of a sexual nature.
2. Intimacy
Obscene images mostly also fall within the person’s intimate and private sphere. This, however, need not always be the case. Nude photographs that persons have had taken for an erotic magazine will be classified as images of a sexual nature but do not have an intimate character. On the other hand, nude photographs that persons send privately to someone with whom they are in a relationship are assessed as both sexual and intimate images48.
An important question to be answered at this point is whether a person’s sharing of his image with another person or persons is to be regarded as making the images public. The answer to this question must of course be no: a person’s sharing of his photograph with someone does not mean that he consents to this content being shareable with everyone and accessible to all other persons.
Indeed, the obtaining of the images, which forms the first stage of revenge porn, generally involves consensual sharing by the person as a result of the trust he places in his private relationship, while the exposure and dissemination forming the second stage take place without consent and mostly without knowledge49. This sharing, however, is personal to the recipient and confers no power to disseminate it. For example, just as, when we hand our bank card to a cashier to make a payment, the cashier may not use that card for his personal payments, or, when sensitive data are shared with doctors for the purpose of diagnosing an illness, the doctors may not share these data of ours with others, the same applies to photographs that persons send to their lovers50. Just as the first act I have taken as an example would constitute the offence of “Misuse of bank or credit cards” (Art. 245 TCK) and the second the offence of “Unlawfully giving data” (Art. 136 TCK), revenge porn too will, depending on the manner in which it is committed, give rise to various offences under Turkish criminal law. Since this subject will be examined in detail below, I shall not go into the details here.
Another point worth discussing with regard to intimate images is whether images taken in a public space can also have an intimate character. Just as the fact that images were not taken in a public space does not in itself make their content intimate, the fact that they were taken in a public space does not require the images to be regarded as public51. At this point, only the persons’ will that their images be disseminated, and their expressing this clearly in words or through their conduct, can make the images public. For it is not possible to separate the public sphere and private life from each other by sharp lines52, and claims to intimacy covering the persons’ private sphere may also arise in the public sphere. In this respect the place where the images were taken is not decisive either.
Finally, the basic criterion to be adopted with regard to intimate images must be how wide a circle the person depicted wishes the content to be accessible to. This circle may consist of a single person or may include more than one person, that is, a small group, but this does not alter the intimate character of the images. Furthermore, it must be accepted as a presumption that every sexual image is also intimate to the person. Obscene images can become public only if the person depicted consents to their publication to a specific person or persons or publishes them himself of his own free will53.
B. The Question Whether Revenge Porn Can Be Regarded as an Offence against Sexual Inviolability
Whether revenge porn is to be regarded as sexual harassment or merely as conduct violating persons’ right to respect for private life and their rights over personal data is another debatable aspect of the concept. I must point out that there is no doubt that revenge porn violates the right to respect for private life; however, characterising such conduct merely as conduct violating privacy gives rise to the error of entirely disregarding the aspect of the act that is sexual and gendered and that, in terms of the legal interest, targets persons’ sexual freedom and autonomy.
Determining whether an act violates sexual inviolability requires determining what an attack on sexual inviolability is. An attack on sexual inviolability is characterised as an attack directed in a harassing, intimidating, coercive, threatening and violent manner against sexual identity and sexual autonomy and integrity54. When all these elements are considered, it becomes clear that, in terms of the consequences of the offence, the experience of the victim and the act the perpetrator engages in are essentially identical to the offence of sexual harassment, and that this is merely a new way of committing the offence brought about by technology.
Article 40 of the Council of Europe Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence (Istanbul Convention) defines sexual harassment as follows: “Parties shall take the necessary legislative or other measures to ensure that any form of unwanted verbal, non-verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature with the purpose or effect of violating the dignity of a person, in particular when creating a degrading, hostile, insulting, humiliating or offensive environment, is subject to criminal or other legal sanction.”
In the light of this definition, it is clear that whether an act is a sexual attack must be determined on the basis of the nature of the attack carried out against the victim in a sexual respect and of the legal interest at which the perpetrator aims. In this respect, non-consensual pornography and revenge porn, being an attack on sexual inviolability, should find their place in the criminal codes either as a variant or mode of commission of sexual harassment or as an independent type of offence.
Indeed, many countries are making revenge porn the subject of legislation and are working on regulating it as a type of offence in criminal law, and worldwide this work is also followed by many non-governmental organisations. The first revenge porn law was enacted by Israel in 2014; it classifies revenge porn as an offence violating sexual inviolability and provides for imprisonment of up to 5 years for perpetrators. Belgium, too, by a law adopted in 2015, made both revenge porn and voyeurism an offence punishable by imprisonment of 6 months to 15 years. England and Wales likewise defined revenge porn as an offence by the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, which entered into force in 2015, and provided for imprisonment of up to 2 years for perpetrators. In the United States of America, 45 states, including Washington DC, have revenge porn laws.
The most recent regulation has been introduced by Italy. The law known as the “Red Code” aims to protect women from violence and persistent harassment (stalking) and to punish the perpetrators of revenge porn. Under the Italian legislation criminalising revenge porn, perpetrators will face imprisonment of up to six years or a fine of up to 15,000 euros.
C. The Effects of Revenge Porn on the Victim
The dissemination of revenge porn has many direct or indirect negative effects on the victim. These effects can be grouped into three main categories: physical, psychological and financial harm caused to the person; violation of personal dignity and privacy; and the obstruction of sexual freedom and expression.
First of all, revenge porn has a severe psychological impact on its victims. Because the most intimate areas of their lives are made accessible to a large number of people, and because of the feelings of humiliation and shame they experience, they face problems of anxiety and panic attacks at a very high rate55. Since revenge porn is by its nature permanently available on the internet and accessible to everyone, these mental problems recur frequently and may confront the persons concerned at any moment. This does not allow the psychological wounds to heal, and victims cannot free themselves from these feelings of humiliation and shame. They live every day with the thought that their images are being accessed by other people as well and, in the words of the famous American sportscaster Erin Andrews, whose nude images were posted on the internet by a pervert, “cannot escape being a victim every day.”56.
In addition, the victim’s contact details, social media accounts and addresses can be found and linked to the pages on which the images are shared (doxxing)57, and this creates for exposed victims the danger not only of psychological but also of physical harm58. Victims who, by means of this information, become open to being tracked live in fear of being sexually assaulted, and for some of them this becomes reality.
Holly Jacobs, the founder of the Cyber Civil Rights Initiative and pioneer of the “End Revenge Porn” movement, is also one of the victims of this offence. In what happened to Jacobs, sexually explicit photographs of her obtained by her former boyfriend were disseminated through hundreds of websites, and her CV and e-mail address were shared with users59. Posts on some websites also contained untrue information, such as that she had sex for money and that she had sexual relations with her students.
When Jacobs went to the police, the officers stated that nothing could be done since she had shared the photographs with her former boyfriend of her own free will. Jacobs explains that because of the revenge porn she changed her name and her job, stopped publishing academically in her field despite being a doctoral student, and had to change her e-mail address four times and her telephone number three times60.
Victims may also have to face the financial consequences of the offence61. Information about a person accessible on the web is decisive in recruitment processes62. This leads to persons being unable to find work or having to leave the jobs in which they are employed. Victims who are employed are unable to continue their working lives because of the pressure they may face at the workplace, the fear that people will attack them and the shame they experience in society. In a revenge porn case concerning a 33-year-old teacher named Hollie Toups, the victim’s nude photographs were posted on a porn site together with her home address and Facebook profile. Toups states that she could not leave the house alone because she did not know what might happen to her63. Not only are persons unable to continue working; it is also seen that employers who learn of the situation dismiss the victim64.
Victims likewise have to change the schools they attend and the cities they live in, avoid expressing themselves in society and close their social media accounts65. In the end, in fact, the victims of this offence are forced into isolation from social life. Indeed, unlike in the offences against sexual inviolability, here the whole internet world is a witness to the offence.
Another consequence of the offence manifests itself in the attack on personal dignity and in the violation of the right to respect for private life66. While the fact that a person’s obscene photographs, which ought to remain intimate, are accessible to everyone on the internet in itself damages the person’s honour and dignity, texts humiliating and insulting the victim are, as I indicated earlier, often shared together with these images, and in this sense the conduct constitutes an attack on the person’s moral personality.
With regard to cyber sexual offences and revenge porn in particular, such posts send women who are not themselves the focus of the harassment the message that this could happen to them too, and legitimise the behaviour of those who have not taken part directly in the abuse but display a similar attitude towards women or think that the abuse is “just a bit of fun”67. In this respect, attacks carried out by means of revenge porn target not only the dignity of the person concerned but also the community of women to which she belongs and her identity68.
As regards the violation of the right to respect for private life, the obtaining of the images, the first stage of the offence, generally takes place in revenge porn with the victim’s consent and therefore does not amount to a violation, but the dissemination of the images without the persons’ consent and knowledge undoubtedly constitutes in every case a violation of the persons’ right to respect for private life. Since this, moreover, also eliminates the data subjects’ rights and sphere of control over their personal data, it also constitutes a violation of the right to the protection of personal data.
Finally, sexual personality, expression and autonomy, a reflection of moral personality, are also among the values harmed by the offence. Moreover, because women victims initially shared their images consensually, they are perceived by society as the main culprits of the offence and the initiators of the act, and victims are regarded as chiefly responsible for their own abuse69. Regrettably, this perspective softens society’s attitude towards this offence and this criminality and, so to speak, lowers the victims’ guard.
D. The Spread of Revenge Porn – Websites
The role of smartphones and internet access in revenge porn becoming so widespread and confronting countries as a significant social problem cannot be denied70. Just as technology changes the ways in which offences of every kind are committed, it shows this effect with regard to sexual offences as well. The dissemination of persons’ intimate sexual images on websites where such sexual content is shared, and the sharing of the private images of many celebrities after their cloud accounts were hacked, have become news items we frequently encounter in the press today71.
In parallel with these developments, revenge porn has also become a sizeable industry. Hunter Moore’s popular website “Is Anyone Up?” was viewed by more than 300,000 visitors a day before it was shut down in April 201272. Moore had created an upload form on the site, and this form relied on the American Communications Decency Act of 1996, which severely limits the liability of content providers73. By filling in the form and uploading images to the content provider’s website, persons also assumed legal responsibility in this regard.
Because of American legislation, Moore could not be held liable for his exploitative and degrading conduct. On the website in question, obscene images of persons were posted together with their identity details and social media accounts. Moore also did not respond in any way to victims’ requests for removal of the content. The section of the site called “Daily Hate” consisted of the complaints of persons whose images had been shared without their consent. In this section Moore posted the victim’s images together with the complaint, giving rise to further abuse and psychological violence74.
Running this website, however, proved highly profitable for Moore75. Moore earned between 8 and 30 thousand dollars a month from advertising on the site. In 2012, however, an investigation conducted by the FBI began to look into Moore’s connections with hackers. Moore, who shut down the website following these developments, had his home in the state of California raided in 2013. It emerged that Moore had paid hackers to steal sexually explicit images from password-protected computers and e-mail accounts76. Moore, who was arrested in 2014, was sentenced to 5 years and 6 months’ imprisonment77. Of course, Moore’s punishment did not stop those wishing to profit from revenge porn. Today it is estimated that there are over three thousand websites providing exclusively revenge porn content78.
As for the photographs or videos that are the subject of revenge porn, even if the perpetrator obtains the images, whether recording them or not, solely for his own access, these images are sooner or later uploaded to these websites created for sharing such images. The economic development of the industry encourages perpetrators to act on financial motives, and the prevalence of the industry serves the aims of humiliating the victim and inflicting psychological violence.
The most serious and invasive form of these images is, of course, images recorded during a sexual assault. In an incident in America in 2013, the sexual assault committed by two high-school football players on a 15-year-old girl caused a great stir in the media79. The main reason why the subject received so much media coverage was that the perpetrators broadcast the sexual assault online and live while committing it. While the images were subsequently used to humiliate and harass the victim, the victim also received numerous death threats. On the other side of the coin, however, it was these very images that brought to light the offence committed against the young girl, who, because of the violence she had suffered, remembered nothing of the incident.
Another aspect of websites that is significant for revenge porn is that these sites act as intermediaries in the offence. While in the first stage of the dissemination of the images there is the perpetrator seeking revenge, revenge porn websites act as intermediaries in the commission of the offence by making the images accessible to the entire internet world. These websites, which may be called “secondary distributors”, cause the images to spread to everyone and to go “viral”, and sometimes, by sharing the images together with degrading expressions and the persons’ data, increase the wrongful content of the offence80.
E. Assessment of Revenge Porn under the Turkish Criminal Code
Depending on the manner in which it is committed, revenge porn conduct may correspond to a number of types of offence in the TCK. First of all, since persons’ images constitute personal data, where the images were recorded without consent in the first stage of the offence, the act constitutes the offence of “Recording of personal data” (Art. 135 TCK). Since these intimate and obscene images relate to the sexual life of the data subject, the perpetrator should be punished under the aggravated form of this offence. Similarly, where in the first stage the images are obtained by stealing them from the victim’s computer, e-mail or the cloud system the victim uses, these acts of the perpetrator constitute the offence of “Illegal access to an information system” (Art. 243 TCK), since the information system was accessed unlawfully, and, since the data are sent from the victim’s account to another system, generally one belonging to the perpetrator, the offence of “Hindering or disrupting the system, destroying or altering data” (Art. 244(2) TCK). Furthermore, since these images constitute the victim’s personal data, the offence of “Unlawfully giving or obtaining data” (Art. 136 TCK) will also be at issue. Likewise, the perpetrator who uploads pornographic images to a website and the website administrators who share these images with everyone may also be held liable for the offence of “Obscenity” (Art. 226 TCK).
There is also no doubt that the obtaining and publication of the images, since they contain images relating to persons’ private sphere, will constitute the offence of “Violation of the privacy of private life” (Art. 134 TCK). Where the perpetrator uses the revenge porn images to threaten the victim, the offence of “Threat” regulated in Art. 106 will find application, and where this threat involves the aim of forcing the victim into sexual togetherness and the victim is compelled to have sexual relations against his will, revenge porn may additionally be used as an instrument of the offence of “Sexual assault” .
Finally, revenge porn can be assessed with regard to the offence of “Sexual harassment” (Art. 105 TCK). The scope of the offence of sexual harassment, which protects persons’ sexual freedom, identity, ways of sexual self-expression and autonomy, is formed by every kind of conduct that involves no physical contact but harasses persons for sexual purposes. By committing the act of revenge porn, the perpetrator targets precisely the legal interest protected by the offence, aiming to wear the victim down sexually and to restrict the victim’s sexual freedom. Moreover, considering that revenge porn bears the harassing, intimidating, coercive and threatening characteristics of every kind of sexual attack, it must be accepted that the act constitutes an attack on sexual inviolability. In this respect, in my opinion, the perpetrator of revenge porn should also be held liable for the offence of sexual harassment.
Furthermore, administrators of content-providing websites will also be held liable as material aiders/co-perpetrators if they have designed their sites solely for revenge porn or exposure. Since social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter and Instagram are not dedicated to the sharing of revenge porn, no intention to participate can be spoken of in their case. In the case of websites that create a platform for the sharing of revenge porn and turn it into a source of financial income, however, there is an intention to participate and a causal contribution to the commission of the offence.
However, none of the above criminal norms fully captures the wrongful content I have defined above. This lack of correspondence applies both to the type of offence and to the sanction. Violating the privacy of private life with a motive of revenge, in particular disseminating nude and/or sexual intercourse photographs and images over the internet, is in itself a distinct type of act. This difference exists with regard to both the act element and the mental element of the offence. On the other hand, in view of the effect the offence has on the victim, the victim’s relatives and society, the corresponding sanction must also be heavier than the penalties for the offences mentioned above. It is therefore clear that a new criminal norm is needed in this area as well. Since the legal interest protected by this type of offence is the sexual freedom of the individual, the type of offence should be placed among the offences against sexual freedom.
IV. Child Pornography
Child pornography may be defined as abusive images of children of a pornographic nature, including images showing a child’s genitals/intimate areas, that sexually gratify persons with deviant behaviour towards children, in psychological terminology paedophiles81. The child in the image may be a real child engaged in sexual activity, but the creation of content of a sexual nature by generating extremely realistic images of a minor who does not exist in reality also falls within the scope of child pornography. It is a generally shared view that data relating to child pornography and the practices of paedophiles in virtual space, such as exchanging ideas, fantasies and views, play an important role in feeding, encouraging and facilitating offences committed against children82.
This pornographic content directed at children, one of the greatest harms that may befall children through the internet and regulated in comparative law as a type of offence in the criminal law of many foreign countries, together with the use of children in the preparation of such content83, constitutes one of the most important problems encountered because of the internet84. This important subject has been addressed in many national and international legal instruments, both as regards children being affected by such content and as regards children being used as objects in obtaining it. Particularly in the context of our subject, in view of the fact that acts of producing, distributing and possessing data with child pornography content by means of information systems are increasing day by day and have become devastating for the health and psychosocial development of children, and of the concerns this situation creates, the European Convention on Cybercrime has imposed on the contracting states an obligation to adopt important and serious regulations in this area.
Article 9 of the Convention deals with child pornography. This article aims to strengthen measures to protect children, in particular from sexual exploitation, to have the relevant provisions of the national criminal law systems of the States Parties to the Convention reformulated in line with the Convention or, where there is no regulation at all on this matter, enacted, and thereby to create more effective provisions against the use of information systems in sexual offences against children.
The Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse, which aims to prevent and combat the sexual exploitation and sexual abuse of children, to protect the rights of child victims of sexual exploitation and sexual abuse and to promote international cooperation against this social problem, introduces preventive and protective measures as well as provisions on criminal law and criminal policy. Türkiye signed this Convention in Lanzarote on 25 October 2007, and with Law No. 6084 of 10 December 2010 “on the Approval of the Ratification of the Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse” the Convention became part of our domestic legal system. Under Article 20 of the Convention, producing, offering, distributing and possessing pornographic material concerning children and viewing it on the internet are recognised as acts constituting offences.
The offence of “Obscenity”, which also encompasses child pornography, is regulated in Art. 226 under the seventh chapter, entitled “Offences against public morality” , of the third part of the TCK, entitled “Offences against society”. This offence prohibits conduct that both offends public decency and harms the psychological and physical integrity of children, who form the material object of the offence. The first point to be addressed regarding the provision is the preference, in naming the offence, for an open-ended concept that may change over time, such as “obscene”85. Using the term pornography instead of the word obscene would make the type of offence much better and more determinable.
Apart from this, the failure to regulate child pornography as a separate offence, taking as a model in particular the relevant articles of the European Convention on Cybercrime, also constitutes a significant shortcoming of the TCK86. The attempt to regulate a wide field of offending such as pornography within a single article is the main source of the provision’s inadequacies. While the provision deals in detail with matters such as how and by what method obscene publications are to be sold or shown, the provisions concerning those who sell, export or store such content and those involved in other acts fail to provide sufficient clarity. In line with the explanations above, every act relating to child pornography carried out over data transmission networks needs to be made a separate type of offence87.
An important point I wish to make in this regard is my view that perpetrators engaging in acts of abuse against children via the internet can be punished under Art. 103 TCK. Although at first sight this view may appear contrary to the principle of legality of offences and penalties, careful examination of the criminal norm shows that there is no contradiction with this principle. Moreover, this norm must be applied if one takes as a basis the purpose of the historical legislator in creating this type of offence and the method of teleological interpretation that must be adopted in the face of a developing society and emerging problems.
Let us consider the subject by way of an example. Let us assume that the perpetrator gets to know a child under the age of eighteen through a social media account, somehow obtains nude images of the child and uses them as a means of blackmail, thereby breaking the child’s will and getting the child to sit in front of the computer completely naked, and, continuing the blackmail, gets the child to caress the child’s own body and even to insert objects into the vagina and anus, records these images as well and shares them on the internet.
For the basic form of the offence, Art. 103(1) TCK uses the expression “a person who sexually abuses a child”, and goes on to state that sexual abuse is to be understood as “any sexual conduct”. While the type of offence requires no further element with regard to children who have not completed the age of fifteen, or who have completed it but lack the capacity to perceive the legal meaning and consequences of the act, it states that, against other children, sexual conduct is abuse only where carried out by force, threat, deception or another cause affecting the will. On the other hand, paragraph 2 of the provision regulates the insertion of an organ or other object into the body as an aggravated form of the offence. The commission of the act by the use of force or threat against children who have not completed the age of fifteen, or who have completed it but lack the capacity to perceive the legal meaning and consequences of the act, is also regulated as an aggravated form increasing the penalty. Accordingly, committing this act against minors who cannot perceive what the act carried out against them is and what its consequences are, and whose capacity of will is weak or absent, is an offence, and committing it against children who do have the capacity of will, by affecting their will through force, threat, deception or another cause affecting the will, is likewise an offence. In other words, the offence is committed either against a child whose will is weak or entirely absent or against a child whose will is affected.
It is therefore possible to apply Art. 37(2) TCK, which regulates indirect perpetration, here. The perpetrator, by reducing to the position of an instrument the minor whose will he has weakened by deception and/or threat, or whose will is weak in any case, carries out sexual acts on the child’s own body and abuses the child. In my view, this interpretation is consistent both with the principle of legality of offences and penalties and with the purpose for which the norm was enacted.
If this view of mine is opposed on the basis of the requirements of criminal law and it is said that this norm cannot be applied (this may be for both theoretical and practical reasons), then it must be accepted that there is a legal gap in this regard and legislation must be enacted urgently.
With regard to Art. 102 TCK, making this interpretation is, because of the structure of the type of offence, not impossible but more difficult. This difficulty, however, does not change the fact that adults are abused in the same way. The legislator must therefore close the legal gaps in this regard as soon as possible.
Although legislators have made child pornography subject to sanctions through criminal law instruments, it can be seen that the rate at which the offence is committed has not fallen but, on the contrary, has risen with developments in information and communication technologies. According to research conducted by the organisation End Child Prostitution and Trafficking (ECPAT) jointly with Unicef, the number of persons arrested for child pornography offences increased by 30 per cent between 2000 and 2006 and had doubled by 200988. The words of the American Attorney General Eric Holder, “Unfortunately, we have seen a historic increase in the distribution of child pornography, in the number of images shared online and in offences committed against the sexual inviolability of children. Tragically, the only place where we have seen a decrease is in the age of the victims.” , reveal the gravity of the situation89.
Conclusion
The internet, which has radically changed every area of our lives from top to bottom, inevitably also affects offences and the ways in which they are committed. Sexual offences, too, are at the centre of this effect of the internet, and changes are observed in the number and types of sexual offences. The number of cyber sexual offences, meaning sexual offences committed through the internet, is increasing day by day, and cyber sexual criminality is becoming ever more widespread.
The basis of this transformation that sexual offences have undergone with the internet lies in the opportunities, in the negative sense, that the internet creates for offenders. The wide accessibility and affordability, owing to the existence of the internet, of the means necessary for engaging in deviant sexual behaviour, and the possibility of carrying out these acts anonymously, are the principal reasons for the expansion of the field of cyber sexual criminality.
Preventing the phenomena of cyber sexual offending, which can be grouped under the main headings of cyber sexual harassment, non-consensual pornography and child pornography, will be possible only if legislators recognise the reactions of victims and swiftly adopt legal regulations to protect persons in this regard. Many countries have embarked on feverish legislative activity concerning cyber sexual offences, above all revenge porn, a type of cyber sexual attack. In carrying out such legislative activities, it is essential to take into account that the internet today constitutes persons’ most important sphere of expression, and to strike a reasonable balance between persons’ rights based on freedom of thought and the aim of protecting victims from cyber sexual threats.
As far as the criminal law of our country is concerned, a separate criminal norm should be created for revenge pornography; because of its devastating effect on the victim, the victim’s relatives and society, its sanction should be severe, as in the case of the other offences against sexual freedom, and it should be regulated as an independent type of offence among the offences against sexual freedom. In the case of sexual abuse of a child via the internet, either Art. 103 should be applied by making use of the institution of indirect perpetration, or a separate type of offence should be created for this. For acts of sexual abuse of adults via the internet, a separate criminal norm must definitely be enacted.
Bibliography
Akdeniz, Yaman, Internet Child Pornography and the Law, Ashgate 2008.
Artuk, Mehmet Emin/Gökcen, Ahmet/Alşahin, Mehmet Emin/Çakır, Kerim, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 17. Ed. Adalet 2018.
Barak, Azy, “Sexual Harassment on the Internet” (2005) Social Science Computer Review, 23(1), 77-92.
Briggs, Peter – Simon, Walter T./Simonsen, Stacy, “An Exploratory Study of Internet-Initiated Sexual Offenses and the Chat Room Sex Offender: Has the Internet Enabled a New Typology of Sex Offender?” (2011) Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 23(1), 72 –91.
Burns, Anne, “In Full View: Involuntary Porn and the Postfeminist Rhetoric of Choice”, in C Nally & A Smith (eds) Twenty – first Century Feminism: Forming and Performing Femininity, Palgrave 2015, 93–118.
Citron, Danielle Keats/Franks, Mary Anne, “Criminalizing Revenge Porn” (2014-1), 49 Wake Forest Law Review, 345–391.
Citron, Danielle Keats, “Revenge porn should be a crime in U.S.”, (2014), CNN, https://edition.cnn.com/2013/08/29/opinion/citron-revenge-porn/, 10.05.2019.
Cooper, Alvin ve diğerleri, “Sexuality on the internet: From sexual exploration to pathological expression” (1999) Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 30, 154–164.
Cross-Tab, Online Reputation in a Connected World (2009), https://jobhunt.org/guides/DPD_Online-Reputation-Research_overview.pdf, 10.05.2019.
Cyber Civil Rights Iniative (CCRI), 2017 Nationwide Online Study of Nonconsensual Porn Victimization and Perpetration: A Summary Report.
DeKeseredy, Walter S. / Schwartz, Martin D., “Thinking Sociologically About Image-Based Sexual Abuse: The Contribution of Male Peer Support Theory”, (2016-4), Sexualization, Media, & Society Vol.2, 1–8.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, 7. Ed. Seçkin 2018.
ECPAT International, “Trends in online child sexual abuse material”, (2018), https://www.ecpat.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/ECPAT-International-Report- Trends-in-Online-Child-Sexual-Abuse-Material-2018.pdf, 10.05.2019.
Flynn, Asher/Powell, Anastasia/Henry, Nicola/Scott, Adrian, “Image-based sexual abuse: The extent, nature, and predictors of perpetration in a community sample of Australian residents”, (2019), Computers in Human Behavior, Vol. 92, 393–402.
Flynn, Asher/Powell, Anastasia/Henry, Nicola, “Image-based Sexual Abuse”, in Walter S.
DeKeseredy and Molly Dragiewicz (Eds), Routledge Handbook of Critical Criminology, 2. Ed. Routledge 2018, 305–315.
Flynn, Asher/Powell, Anastasia/Henry, Nicola, More than Revenge: Addressing the Harms of Revenge Pornography, Summary Report of the “More than Revenge” Roundtable, Monash University 2016.
Franks, Mary Anne, “The Fight Against Digital Abuse: The View from the US” (2015), Womensaid, https://www.womensaid.ie/16daysblog/2015/12/15/the-fight-against-digital-abuse-the-view-from-the/, 10.05.2019.
Franks, Mary Anne, Drafting an Effective “Revenge Porn” law: A Guide for Legislators, (Cyber Civil Rights Initiative 2016), http://www.cybercivilrights.org/guide-to-legislation/, 10.05.2019.
Hall, Matthew/Hearn, Jeff, Revenge Pornography: Gender, Sexuality and Motivations, Routledge 2018. Jacobs, Holly, “Being A Victim Of Revenge Porn Forced Me To Change My Name”, (2013), Thought Catalog, https://thoughtcatalog.com/dr-holly-jacobs/2013/11/being-a-victim-of-revenge-porn-forced-me-to-change-my-name/, 10.05.2019.
Kelly, Liz, “The Continuum of Sexual Violence” (1987) in Hanmer J., Maynard M. (eds) Women, Violence and Social Control, Explorations in Sociology, British Sociological Association Conference Volume series, Palgrave Macmillan, 1987.
Koca, Mahmut/Üzülmez, İlhan, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 3. Ed, Adalet 2017.
Lee, Dave, “IsAnyoneUp's Hunter Moore: 'The net's most hated man'”, (2012), BBC, https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-17784232, 10.05.2019.
McGlynn, Clare/Rackley, Erika/Houghton, Ruth, “Beyond ‘Revenge Porn’: The Continuum of Image-Based Sexual Abuse”, (2017) Feminist Legal Studies 25-1, 25–46.
McGlynn, Clare/Rackley, Erika, “Image-Based Sexual Abuse”, (2017), Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol.37, 534–561.
Mitchell, Kimberley/Wolak, Janis/Finkelhor, David, “Police posing as juveniles online to catch sex offenders: Is it working?” (2005) Sexual Abuse, 17(3), 241–267.
Neto, Abilio C. de Almeida ve diğerleri, “Internet Sexual Offending: Overview of Potential Contributing Factors and Intervention Strategies” (2013) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law, Vol. 20, No. 2, 168–181.
Nisselbaum, Helen, “Protecting Privacy in an Information Age: The Problem of Privacy in Public” (1998), Ethics & Behavior, 207–219.
Olheiser, Abby, “Revenge porn purveyor Hunter Moore is sentenced to prison”, (2015), Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2015/12/03/revenge-porn-purveyor-hunter-moore-is-sentenced-to-prison/?utm_term=.c77228683d0f, 10.05.2019.
Powell, Anastasia/Henry, Nicola, “Embodied Harms: Gender, Shame, and Technology-Facilitated Sexual Violence”, (2015-6), Violence Against Women Vol.21, 758–779.
Powell, Anastasia/Henry, Nicola, “Technology-Facilitated Sexual Violence: A Literature Review of Empirical Research”, (2015-2), Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, Vol. 19, 195–208.
Powell, Anastasia/Henry, Nicola, Sexual Violence in a Digital Age, Palgrave Studies in Cybercrime and Cybersecurity, Palgrave 2017.
Putnam, Dana E., “Initiation and maintenance of online sexual compulsivity: Implications for assessment and treatment.” (2000) CyberPsychology and Behavior, 3(4), 353–363.
Salter, Micheal/Croft, Thomas/Lee, Murray, ‘Beyond Criminalization and Responsibilisation:
Sexting, Gender and Young People’ (2012–13) 24(3) Current Issues In Criminal Justice, 301- 316.
Salter, Micheal, ‘Responding to revenge porn: Gender, justice and online legal impunity’, (2013), Paper delivered at: Whose justice? Conflicted approaches to crime and conflict, University of Western Sydney, https://www.academia.edu/4585975/Responding_to_revenge_porn_Gender_justice_and _online_legal_impunity, 10.05.2019.
Sheldon, Kerry/Howitt, Dennis, Sex Offenders and the Internet, John Wiley & Sons 2007.
Sieber, Ulrich, İnternetteki Suçlar ve Suçun İnternetteki Takibi: Global Bilgi Toplumundaki Yeni Gelişmeler Işığında Hangi Önlemler Tavsiye Edilmektedir?, (Çev. Yener Ünver - Mustafa Temmuz Oğlakçıoğlu), Özyeğin Üniversitesi 2014.
Sokullu Akıncı, Füsun, “Avrupa Konseyi Siber Suç Sözleşmesi’nde Yer Alan Maddi Ceza Hukukuna İlişkin Düzenlemeler ve İnternette Çocuk Pornografisi” (2001), İÜHFM, İstanbul, C:LIX S:1–2, 11–38.
Taylor, Max/Quayle, Ethel, Child Pornography: An Internet Crime, Brunner-Routledge 2003.
Thomas, Terry, Sex Crime, Sex Offending and Society, 3. Ed, Rootledge 2016.
Waldron, Jeremy, The Harm in Hate Speech, Harvard University Press 2012.
Yar, Majid, “The policing of Internet sex offences: pluralised governance versus hierarchies of standing” (2013)
Policing & Society Vol. 23, No. 4, 482-497.
Footnotes
- This is the article version of the paper I presented at the 14th Criminal Law Days, held in memory of Prof. Dr. İbrahim Dülger on 14–16 June 2019, hosted by Istanbul University Faculty of Law and devoted to the main theme of “Sexual Offences”. ↑
- Faculty member in Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Law and IT Law, Faculty of Law, Istanbul Aydın University. ↑
- Terry Thomas, Sex Crime: Sex Offending and Society (3. Ed. Rootledge 2016) 1. ↑
- Murat Volkan Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku (7. Ed. Seçkin 2018) 80. ↑
- Kerry Sheldon/Dennis Howitt, Sex Offenders and the Internet (John Wiley & Sons 2007) 3. ↑
- Abilio C. de Almeida Neto ve diğerleri, “Internet Sexual Offending: Overview of Potential Contributing Factors and Intervention Strategies” (2013) Psychiatry, Psychology and Law, Vol. 20, No. 2, 169. ↑
- Sheldon/Howitt, (n.3) 5. ↑
- Sheldon/Howitt, (n.3) 5. ↑
- Neto ve diğerleri, (n.4) 170. ↑
- Putnam Dana E, “Initiation and maintenance of online sexual compulsivity: Implications for assessment and treatment.” (2000) Cyber Psychology and Behavior 3(4), 361. ↑
- Neto ve diğerleri, (n.4) 168. ↑
- Alvin Cooper ve diğerleri, “Sexuality on the internet: From sexual exploration to pathological expression” (1999) Professional Psychology: Research and Practice 30, 157. ↑
- Sheldon/Howitt, (n.3) 8. ↑
- Kimberley Mitchell/Janis Wolak/David Finkelhor, “Police posing as juveniles online to catch sex offenders: Is it working?” (2005) Sexual Abuse, 17(3), 247. ↑
- Neto ve diğerleri, (n.4) 170. ↑
- Peter Briggs/Walter T. Simon/Stacy Simonsen, “An Exploratory Study of Internet-Initiated Sexual Offenses and the Chat Room Sex Offender: Has the Internet Enabled a New Typology of Sex Offender?” (2011) Sexual Abuse: A Journal of Research and Treatment 23(1), 73. ↑
- Neto ve diğerleri, (n.4) 171. ↑
- Majid Yar, “The policing of Internet sex offences: pluralised governance versus hierarchies of standing” (2013) Policing & Society Vol. 23, No. 4, 483. ↑
- Briggs/Simon/Simonsen, (n.14) 74. ↑
- Yar, (n.16) 484. ↑
- The full text of Art. 105 TCK, entitled “Sexual harassment”, reads as follows: (1) A person who harasses another person for sexual purposes shall, upon the complaint of the victim, be sentenced to imprisonment from three months to two years or to a judicial fine, or, where the act is committed against a child, to imprisonment from six months to three years. (2) (Amended: 18/6/2014-6545/61 md.) Where the offence is committed a) by taking advantage of the ease afforded by public office, a service relationship or a family relationship, b) by a guardian, educator, teacher, carer, foster family or person providing health services, or by persons under a duty of protection, care or supervision, c) by taking advantage of the ease afforded by working in the same workplace, d) by taking advantage of the ease afforded by postal or electronic communication means, e) by means of exposure, the penalty to be imposed under the preceding paragraph shall be increased by one half. If, because of this act, the victim has had to leave his job, school or family, the penalty to be imposed shall not be less than one year. ↑
- Türk Dil Kurumu Güncel Türkçe Sözlük, http://tdk.gov.tr/index.php?option=com_bts&arama=kelime&guid= TDK.GTS.5cd546ee19b156.34835455, 10.05.2019. ↑
- Büyük Larousse, (İstanbul 1986) C. 18, 11134. ↑
- By contrast, the Court of Cassation can be seen to have assessed as sexual harassment the expressions "If my love is in my heart, if your happiness is in your hands, if what you want is two words, I love you.", "You are my 61st minute, my 13th month, my 5th season, my 7th sense, my 3rd eye, my 2nd heart, you are one more than everything, different in every way, because you are my dearest.", "I love you my love" in messages which the accused sent to the victim by telephone and which, as is clear from the account of the facts, had no sexual content; see Yargıtay 2. CD, 23.9.2013, E. 2011/29772, K. 2013/21228. Likewise, another decision to the same effect states that the accused’s sending the victim the message “I love you” more than once within three days is to be assessed as the execution of a single decision to commit an offence and that the act constitutes the offence of sexual harassment in the form of a continuing offence; see Yargıtay 14. CD, 21.1.2015, E. 2014/11220, K. 2015/436. However, just as the feeling of love cannot be equated with sexual purposes, it is clear that only acts with a sexual motive should form the subject matter of the offence of sexual harassment. The Court of Cassation should therefore depart from its erroneous case law on this matter. ↑
- For these definitions see Mehmet Emin Artuk/Ahmet Gökcen/Mehmet Emin Alşahin/Kerim Çakır, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler (17. Ed. Adalet 2018) 330. ↑
- Mahmut Koca/İlhan Üzülmez, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler (4. Ed. Adalet 2017) 337. ↑
- Artuk/Gökçen/Alşahin/Çakır, (n.23) 330. ↑
- Azy Barak, “Sexual Harassment on the Internet” (2005) Social Science Computer Review, 23(1), 79. ↑
- Barak, (n.26) 81. ↑
- Barak, (n.26) 79. ↑
- Barak, (n.26) 79. ↑
- The creation of sexual images of persons has emerged as a new phenomenon with technological developments. With fake video technology, the face of a person of whom only photographs are available is superimposed on the face of an actress in a porn video. As the tools that make it possible to produce the videos known as “deepfakes” become more powerful and easier to use, people are able to transfer the sexual fantasies of their imagination to the internet. Although the most popular fake pornographic images are those featuring celebrities, a deepfake video can be made of any person of whom there are sufficient photographs for the software. Of course, these videos may be produced not only for pornographic purposes but also in order to exploit a political figure politically. In the context of our subject, however, perpetrators who cannot obtain images of their former partner but wish, out of a feeling of revenge, to abuse that person in this way can also commit the offence in question by creating such images. ↑
- Danielle Keats Citron/Mary Anne Franks, “Criminalizing Revenge Porn” (2014-1), 49 Wake Forest Law Review, 345; Clare McGlynn/Erika Rackley, “Image-Based Sexual Abuse”, (2017), Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol.37, 534; Matthew Hall/Jeff Hearn, Revenge Pornography: Gender, Sexuality and Motivations, (Routledge 2018) 15; Cyber Civil Rights Iniative (CCRI), 2017 Nationwide Online Study of Nonconsensual Porn Victimization and Perpetration: A Summary Report, 3. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.30) 345. ↑
- Clare McGlynn/Erika Rackley/Ruth Houghton, “Beyond ‘Revenge Porn’: The Continuum of Image-Based Sexual Abuse”, (2017) Feminist Legal Studies 25-1, 25; Hall / Hearn, (n.31) 14; European Parliament’s Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs, Cyber Violence and Hate Speech Online against Women, (2018), http://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2018/604979/IPOL_STU(2018)604979_EN.pdf, 10.05.2019, 17; Asher Flynn/Nicola Henry/Anastasia Powell, More than Revenge: Addressing the Harms of Revenge Pornography, Summary Report of the 'More than Revenge' Roundtable (Monash University 2016), 4. ↑
- Mary Anne Franks, Drafting an Effective “Revenge Porn” law: A Guide for Legislators, (Cyber Civil Rights Initiative 2016), http://www.cybercivilrights.org/guide-to-legislation/, 10.05.2019, 2. ↑
- Asher Flynn/Nicola Henry/Anastasia Powell, “Image-based Sexual Abuse”, in Walter S. DeKeseredy and Molly Dragiewicz (Eds), Routledge Handbook of Critical Criminology, (2. Ed. Routledge 2018), 306. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley/Houghton, (n.33), 38; Flynn/Henry/Powell, (n.33) 4. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley/Houghton, (n.33) 38. ↑
- Franks, (n.33) 2. ↑
- Asher Flynn/Anastasia Powell/Nicola Henry / Adrian Scott, "Image-based sexual abuse: The extent, nature, and predictors of perpetration in a community sample of Australian residents", (2019), Computers in Human Behavior, Vol. 92, 393; McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 535; Walter S. DeKeseredy/Martin D. Schwartz, “Thinking Sociologically About Image-Based Sexual Abuse: The Contribution of Male Peer Support Theory”, (2016-4), Sexualization, Media, & Society Vol.2, 1. ↑
- Anastasia Powell/Nicola Henry, Sexual Violence in a Digital Age, Palgrave Studies in Cybercrime and Cybersecurity, (Palgrave 2017), 5; Anastasia Powell/Nicola Henry, “Embodied Harms: Gender, Shame, and Technology-Facilitated Sexual Violence”, (2015-6), Violence Against Women Vol.21, 759; Anastasia Powell/Nicola Henry, “Technology-Facilitated Sexual Violence: A Literature Review of Empirical Research”, (2015-2), Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, Vol. 19, 195. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 346; Franks, (n.33) 2. ↑
- Anne Burns, “In Full View: Involuntary Porn and the Postfeminist Rhetoric of Choice”, in C Nally & A Smith (eds) Twenty – first Century Feminism: Forming and Performing Femininity, (Palgrave 2015), 93. ↑
- Hall/Hearn, (n.31) 14. ↑
- The victims of the offence are overwhelmingly women. Research conducted by the Cyber Civil Rights Initiative has shown that 90% of victims are women. See Cyber Civil Rights Initiative, Cyber Civil Rights Statistics on Revenge Porn, https://www.cybercivilrights.org/revenge-porn-infographic/, 10.05.2019. This also applies to other types of cyber sexual offence. The United States National Violence Against Women Survey found that 60% of victims of cyber stalking were women. According to the records of face-to-face interviews with victims conducted by Working to Halt Online Abuse (WHOA), 72.5% of victims of cyber sexual harassment between 2000 and 2012 were women. Working to Halt Online Abuse (WHOA), Online Harassment/Cyberstalking Statistics, http://www.haltabuse. org/resources/stats/, 10.05.2019, Citron/Franks, (n.30) 345. Apart from women, lesbians, gays, bisexuals, trans and intersex persons (LGBTI), whom we may regard as sexual minorities, are very likely to become victims of cyber sexual offences. In this respect there is fundamentally no difference from the traditional physical offence of sexual harassment. Indeed, in the cyber world too, online sexual violence and harassment are based on socially constructed heterosexual beliefs and attitudes about gender and sexuality. Perpetrators, acting on motives of power and control, blame, humiliate and stigmatise the victim because of his differences. See also Powell/Henry, “Technology-Facilitated Sexual Violence: A Literature Review of Empirical Research”, (n.40), 196-198. ↑
- When revenge porn is mentioned, dissemination activities carried out over the web come to mind first, but this activity need not necessarily take the form of online sharing. Revenge porn can also be carried out by passing the victim’s images from hand to hand. This was the case in an incident in America in 2007. In that incident, the perpetrator made numerous DVD copies of a video in which he had recorded sexual and intimate images of the victim. Angered by the end of the relationship, the perpetrator distributed these copies, together with the victim’s name, address and telephone number, by placing them on the windscreens of random cars. The victim, who was unaware that the images had been recorded and distributed, was disturbed by men who took the video as a sexual proposition, visiting the home many times and calling numerous times by telephone. For the incident see Citron/Franks, (n.31) 350. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 543. ↑
- UK Legislation, Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, Sec. 35. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 544. ↑
- Nevertheless, the first stage of the offence may also involve the victim being filmed covertly. While there is no doubt that covertly recorded images violate privacy, images obtained with consent also have the character of intimate images, since there is no consent to their being shared. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 355. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 545. ↑
- Helen Nisselbaum, “Protecting Privacy in an Information Age: The Problem of Privacy in Public” (1998), Ethics & Behavior, 208-209. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 544. ↑
- Liz Kelly, “The Continuum of Sexual Violence” (1987) in Hanmer J., Maynard M. (eds) Women, Violence and Social Control, Explorations in Sociology (British Sociological Association Conference Volume series). (Palgrave Macmillan 1987) 46; McGlynn/Rackley/Houghton, 36. ↑
- According to research conducted by the Cyber Civil Rights Initiative on this subject, 93% of victims suffer severe emotional distress and anxiety problems. Cyber Civil Rights Initiative, (n.44). ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 364; Hall/Hearn, (n.31) 19. ↑
- This harassment technique, known as doxxing, consists in obtaining various personal data of persons, such as their addresses and telephone numbers, through their social media presence and then exposing this information. ↑
- According to a 2013 study by the American computer security software company McAfee, the social security numbers of 2% of victims, the work addresses of 14% and the home addresses of 16% are exposed. Likewise, the e-mail addresses of 26% of victims, the social media details of 49% and the identity details of 59% are exposed together with the obscene posts. See McAfee, “Love, relationships, and technology: How we expose ourselves today”, (2013), https://promos.mcafee.com/offer.aspx?id=605366&culture=en-us&cid=140612, 10.05.2019. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 367, Franks, (n.33) 13, Micheal Salter, ‘Responding to revenge porn: Gender, justice and online legal impunity’, (2013), Paper delivered at: Whose justice? Conflicted approaches to crime and conflict, University of Western Sydney, https://www.academia.edu/4585975/Responding_to_revenge_porn_Gender_justice_and _online_legal_impunity, 10.05.2019, 3. ↑
- Holly Jacobs, “Being A Victim Of Revenge Porn Forced Me To Change My Name”, (2013), Thought Catalog, https://thoughtcatalog.com/dr-holly-jacobs/2013/11/being-a-victim-of-revenge-porn-forced-me-to-change-my-name/, 10.05.2019. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 547. ↑
- A study conducted on this subject in 2009 shows that information about candidates obtained via the web, and the impressions formed from that information, play an extremely important role in the recruitment process. Of human resources officers, 80% carry out web research on candidates, and 89% of those who do so state that the impressions formed from this research influence the recruitment process. Moreover, information obtained online plays a role with regard to 70% of rejected candidates. See Cross - Tab, Online Reputation in a Connected World (2009), https://jobhunt.org/guides/DPD_Online-Reputation-Research_overview.pdf, 10.05.2019. Given that this was the case even 10 years ago, it may be said that today persons’ social media presence plays a very large role not only in recruitment processes but in their lives as a whole. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 351. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 351; Danielle Keats Citron, "Revenge porn should be a crime in U.S.", (2014), CNN, https://edition.cnn.com/2013/08/29/opinion/citron-revenge-porn/, 10.05.2019. ↑
- Mary Anne Franks, “The Fight Against Digital Abuse: The View from the US” (2015), Womensaid, https://www.womensaid.ie/16daysblog/2015/12/15/the-fight-against-digital-abuse-the-view-from-the/, 10.05.2019. The victim’s having to leave his job, school or family as a result of sexual harassment is also regulated in the TCK as a form of the offence of sexual harassment aggravated by its result. This provision will apply where, even if the sexual harassment is not continuous or has ended, the psychological effects of the act have prevented the victim from maintaining his relationships in a healthy manner and have caused him to leave. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 549. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 550. ↑
- In fact, pornographic content of every kind, whether of the revenge porn type or not, objectifies women for men’s sexual experience and, as a general practice, reinforces the perception of women as a commodity to be used and owned. See Jeremy Waldron, The Harm in Hate Speech, (Harvard University Press 2012), 74 vd. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 551, Micheal Salter / Thomas Croft / Murray Lee, ‘Beyond Criminalization and Responsibilisation: Sexting, Gender and Young People’ (2012–13) 24(3) Current Issues In Criminal Justice, 309; Hall/Hearn, (n.31) 21. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 536; Flynn/Henry/Powell, (n.33) 4. ↑
- The scandal known as “Celebgate”, in which the accounts of many celebrities, above all the famous Hollywood actress Jennifer Lawrence, were hacked and their obscene photographs shared, took place in 2014. In a statement, Lawrence called the theft of her photographs a sexual offence. Vanity Fair, “Jennifer Lawrence Calls Photo Hacking a “Sex Crime”, (2014) https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2014/10/jennifer-lawrence-cover, 10.05.2019. In the trial held in the USA, one of the perpetrators, Ryan Collins, was sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment for stealing the photographs from the information system. BBC, "Celebgate hack: Collins sentenced over nude photos theft", (2016), https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-37796986, 10.05.2019. ↑
- Dave Lee, “IsAnyoneUp's Hunter Moore: 'The net's most hated man'”, (2012), BBC, https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-17784232, 10.05.2019; McGlynn/Rackley/Houghton, (n.33) 29. ↑
- Salter, (n.60) 4. ↑
- Salter, (n.60) 4. ↑
- Salter, (n.60) 4; Hall/Hearn, (n.31) 21. ↑
- Citron/Franks, (n.31) 368. ↑
- Abby Olheiser, “Revenge porn purveyor Hunter Moore is sentenced to prison”, (2015), Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2015/12/03/revenge-porn-purveyor-hunter-moore-is-sentenced-to-prison/?utm_term=.c77228683d0f, 10.05.2019. ↑
- DeKeseredy/Schwartz, (n.39) 2. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley/Houghton, (n.33) 35. ↑
- McGlynn/Rackley, (n.31) 541. ↑
- Yaman Akdeniz, Internet Child Pornography and the Law, (Ashgate 2008), 9-11; Max Taylor/Ethel Quayle, Child Pornography: An Internet Crime, (Brunner-Routledge 2003), 3. ↑
- Füsun Sokullu Akıncı, “Avrupa Konseyi Siber Suç Sözleşmesi’nde Yer Alan Maddi Ceza Hukukuna İlişkin Düzenlemeler ve İnternette Çocuk Pornografisi” (2001), İÜHFM, İstanbul, C:LIX S:1–2, 31; Dülger, (n.2) 200. ↑
- Austrian Criminal Code, section 207a; Belgian Criminal Code, article 383; Canadian Criminal Code, section 163.1; Danish Criminal Code, section 235; New French Criminal Code, article 227-23; German Criminal Code, section 184 (3), Irish Child Pornography Act of 1996, section 2; Dutch Criminal Code, section 240b, Norwegian Criminal Code, section 211; Swedish Criminal Code, chapter 16 section 10a; English Protection of Children Act 1978, as supplemented by the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, section 1; Ulrich Sieber, İnternetteki Suçlar ve Suçun İnternetteki Takibi: Global Bilgi Toplumundaki Yeni Gelişmeler Işığında Hangi Önlemler Tavsiye Edilmektedir?, (Çev. Yener Ünver 7 Mustafa Temmuz Oğlakçıoğlu), (Özyeğin Üniversitesi 2014), 51. ↑
- Sieber, (n.82), 52. ↑
- Dülger, (n.2) 496. ↑
- Dülger, (n.2) 496. ↑
- Dülger, (n.2) 498. ↑
- ECPAT International, “Trends in online child sexual abuse material”, (2018), https://www.ecpat.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/ECPAT-International-Report-Trends-in-Online-Child-Sexual-Abuse-Material- 2018.pdf, 10.05.2019, 9. ↑
- The United States Department of Justice, Child Pornography, (2017), https://www.justice.gov/criminalceos/child-pornography 10.05.2019. ↑
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Use of Crypto Assets in the Laundering of Proceeds of Crime and the Measures to Be Taken” (Kripto Varlıkların Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasında Kullanılması ve Alınması Gereken Önlemler), Istanbul Aydın University Faculty of Law Journal (İstanbul Aydın Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi), Vol. 10, No. 1, 2024, pp. 41-94.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Legal Regime of Social Network Providers, Internet News Sites and Over-the-Top Service Providers, and a Critique” (Sosyal Ağ Sağlayıcıların İnternet Haber Sitelerinin ve Şebekeler Üstü Hizmet Sağlayıcıların Hukuki Rejimi ve Eleştirisi), Dülger Law Office, 1 June 2023.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Electronic Document as the Object of Document Forgery Offences” (Belgede Sahtecilik Suçlarının Konusu Olarak Elektronik Belge), Symposium on Forgery of Documents and Tax Offences (Belgede Sahtecilik ve Vergi Suçları Sempozyumu), 21–24 October 2019, Publication of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation / TOBB ETÜ Faculty of Law, Ankara, 2020.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “What Does WhatsApp's Privacy Change Mean? Will Our Data Be Shared?” (WhatsApp Güvenlik Değişikliği Ne Anlama Geliyor? Verilerimiz Paylaşılacak mı?), Dülger Law Office, 5 January 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Commercial Electronic Messages and the Message Management System” (Ticari Elektronik İleti ve İleti Yönetim Sistemi), Dülger Law Office, 15 November 2020.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Cybercrime and Internet Communication Law (Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku), 11th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2025.

