2021Murat Volkan Dülger, Cansu Ceren KahramanArticle

Update note: This text was written under the former version of Article 9 of the KVKK on transfers abroad. The article was amended by Law No. 7499 (Official Gazette of 12 March 2024, No. 32487); the amendment entered into force on 1 June 2024.

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

Under the European Union’s data protection rules, when group companies located in different countries shared data among themselves, the obligations under the personal data protection legislation of more than one country had to be fulfilled at the same time. Because multinational companies share data regularly in the course of their business processes, they began to look for easier ways of meeting these obligations. The solution they found was to draw up an almost worldwide data privacy policy that would cover the obligations in all the countries in which they shared data. For the companies that had drawn up their policies, one more step remained before everything went as they wished: having the Data Protection Authorities (DPO) accept the policies they had prepared.

To that end they began to put pressure on the data protection authorities. Once this pressure produced results, personal data began to be shared under company privacy policies that appeared to contain adequate safeguards (but in fact without adequate safeguards being taken). “Binding Corporate Rules” were created in order to prevent this. Today, although almost every company in the European Economic Area has a personal data protection policy, many data protection authorities state that companies’ information systems are inadequate for full protection.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER & Attorney Cansu Ceren KAHRAMAN

In the years before Directive 95/46/EC was adopted, it was anticipated that cross-border data flows would arise as commercial relations developed in the European Union. For this reason the need was felt to legislate for the protection of personal data, and the Directive in question was adopted.

The phenomenon of big data, which arose when the internet was opened to the public, and its positive and negative consequences showed just how accurate the European Commission's forecast had been when it adopted the Directive. Indeed, with the digital age there was a great increase in the processing and flow of personal data, especially within the business processes of multinational companies. Multinational companies processed, within their group companies located in different countries, employees' data such as salary and seniority for the purpose of fulfilling the obligations arising from employment contracts and statutes, and their customers' data in the course of their sales

activities. They shared all the data they had processed with their suppliers, business partners and other group companies at international level. With the advances in technology, multinational companies began to use, alongside a central information system, information systems located in more than one place that allow data to be shared internationally at very high speed. Following these developments, and once dynamic routing and cloud systems had also come into use, the data shared • and stored on the internet became almost impossible to trace.

As a result the Directive proved inadequate, and the GDPR, which may be described as an upgraded version of the Directive, was adopted.

Under the European Union's data protection rules, when group companies located in different countries shared data among themselves, the obligations laid down in the data protection legislation of more than one country had to be fulfilled at the same time. Since multinational companies shared data regularly in the course of their business processes, they began to look for easier ways of fulfilling these obligations.

The solution they found was to draw up an almost worldwide data privacy policy that would encompass the obligations in all the countries with which they shared data.

For the companies that had drawn up their policies, one more step remained before everything went as they wished, namely to get the Data Protection Authorities (DPO) to accept the policies they had prepared.

To that end they began to put pressure on the data protection authorities. Once this pressure had produced results, personal data began to be shared on the basis of corporate privacy policies that appeared to contain adequate measures

(but in fact without adequate measures having been taken). In order to prevent this state of affairs, what are known as

“Binding Corporate Rules” were created.

Although almost every company in the European Economic Area today has a policy on the protection of personal data, many data protection authorities state that companies' information systems are inadequate for full protection. To put this finding in other words, although companies undertake to protect personal data, they do not, or cannot, actually protect them.

It may thus be said that imposing fines on companies calculated as a certain percentage of their turnover for infringements of the provisions of the GDPR (fines far higher than the administrative fines imposed in Türkiye) is not sufficient, and that the means available to the data protection authorities are on their own inadequate to compel companies to comply with data protection legislation.

In this article we shall first discuss the reasons why binding corporate rules were created, their functions,

and how the application for approval is to be made in order for the rules to be accepted; we shall then touch on the other features relating to the nature of these rules and assess the relationship between these rules and the undertakings for the transfer of data abroad under Law No. 6698.

THE EMERGENCE OF BINDING CORPORATE RULES

The cross-border transfer of personal data is extremely important and necessary for the development of global trade and of social relations. Out of concern that foreign persons and organisations might gain access to their citizens' data, countries have chosen to adopt regulations that restrict such transfers. For this reason almost every country today has legislation on the protection of personal data.

Under the Directive, multinational companies had to fulfil at the same time the obligations arising from the legislation of more than one country when transferring data to their group companies. The fact that every country had its own data protection legislation (even though the data protection legislation of other countries was taken into account when these regulations were made) prevented data

from being shared between countries as freely as was desired. To overcome this obstacle, companies drew up their own privacy policies and tried to get the Data Protection Authorities to accept them. Unfortunately, however, the policies they drew up were policies that protected personal data in appearance only.

In order to prevent companies from transferring personal data without fully protecting them, the European Commission's Article 29 Working Party established certain criteria that corporate privacy policies had to meet. The first of these criteria was that corporate privacy policies should be binding on companies both internally (within the company and its affiliated group companies) and externally, in the interests of individuals. It was precisely in order to emphasise this binding character that the Article 29 Working Party named these policies “Binding Corporate Rules”.

However, some data protection authorities, notwithstanding the opinions of the Article 29 Working Party, refused to accept binding corporate rules and required certain additional conditions for data transfers. The same holds true today, when the GDPR is in force. In this respect there is still uncertainty as to whether binding corporate rules will also be accepted as a valid instrument for data transfers by countries outside the EU (which have national regulations on data transfers).

In other words, it is still uncertain whether binding corporate rules can be realised at global level – essentially, in the full sense – and, if they can, when that will be.

Nor does it seem likely that a global data protection regulation will be adopted within the next ten years. Until a global data protection regulation is adopted, these rules are a very important instrument for accelerating trade and social developments and for paving the way for new ones.

Thanks to them, data can be transferred between countries more easily and at lower cost.

BINDING CORPORATE RULES IN THE GDPR

Binding corporate rules, which were created by the Article 29 Working Party at the time of Directive 95/46/EC, are regulated in detail in the GDPR.

According to Article 45 of the GDPR, “Where the Commission has decided that a third country, or

a territory or one or more sectors within that third country, or an international organisation ensures an adequate level of protection, a transfer of personal data to that country or international organisation may take place. Such a transfer shall not require any specific authorisation.” However, “In the absence of a decision pursuant to Article 45(3), a controller or processor may transfer personal data to a third country or an international organisation only if the controller or processor has provided appropriate safeguards, and on condition that enforceable data subject rights and effective legal remedies for data subjects are available.”

Appropriate safeguards may be provided, without the need to obtain any specific authorisation from a supervisory authority, by one of the means listed in Article 46(2).

Binding corporate rules are one of these.

Article 47 of the GDPR lays down the minimum elements that binding corporate rules must contain.

These are:

• the structure and contact details of the group of undertakings, or group of enterprises engaged in a joint economic activity, and of each of its members,

• the data transfers or set of transfers, including the categories of personal data, • the type of processing and its purposes, the type of data subjects affected and the indication of the third country or countries in question,

• their legally binding nature, both internally and externally,

• the application of the general data protection principles, in particular purpose limitation, data minimisation, limited storage periods, data quality, data protection by design and by default, legal basis for processing and processing of special categories of personal data, of the measures to ensure data security, and of the requirements in respect of onward transfers to bodies not bound by the binding corporate rules,

• the right not to be subject to decisions based solely on automated processing, including profiling, in accordance with Article 22,

• the rights of data subjects in regard to processing – including the right to lodge a complaint with the competent supervisory authority and before the competent courts of the Member States in accordance with Article 79 and to obtain redress and, where appropriate, the right to compensation for a breach of the binding corporate rules –

and the means of exercising those rights,

• the acceptance, by the controller or processor established on the territory

of a Member State, of liability for any breach of the binding corporate rules by any member not established in the Union,

• how the information on the binding corporate rules, in particular on the provisions referred to in points (d), (e) and (f),

is provided to the data subjects in addition to Articles 13 and 14,

• the tasks of any data protection officer designated in accordance with Article 37

or of any other persons or entities in charge of monitoring compliance with the binding corporate rules within the group of undertakings, or group of enterprises engaged in a joint economic activity, as well as of monitoring training and handling complaints,

• the complaint procedures,

• the mechanisms, within the group of undertakings, or group of enterprises engaged in a joint economic

activity, for ensuring the verification of compliance with the binding corporate rules, • and the mechanisms for reporting and recording changes to the rules and for reporting those changes to the supervisory authority.

THE CONCEPT OF BINDING

CORPORATE RULES,

THEIR SCOPE AND THEIR DIFFERENCE FROM CODES OF CONDUCT

A transfer to a third country consists in communicating the data to another controller or processor in a third country; its lawfulness must (today) be assessed in the light of the principles laid down by the GDPR and the circumstances of the specific case. The protection principles contained in binding corporate rules must largely conform to the protection principles of the GDPR. From this perspective, as a general principle, the application of binding corporate rules within the group does not pose any problem, provided that the rules comply with national data protection legislation. If these conditions are met, the rules enable corporate groups to have a truly global privacy policy.

By the same reasoning and by definition, binding corporate rules are global, and no distinction should therefore be made in their application. The rules must be applied throughout the corporate group irrespective of criteria or considerations such as the place of establishment of the members or the nationality of the data subjects

and the like.

Nevertheless, even though the corporate group endeavours to comply with the rules, the applicability of the rules may come to differ over time in respect of personal data that are also referred to as data of EU origin, are subject to EU legislation and are subsequently transferred abroad.

In conclusion, since the purpose of these instruments differs from that of the codes of conduct provided for in Article 27 of the Directive, it seems more appropriate to find a suitable terminology than to refer to them as “codes of conduct”. For the true nature of these instruments is the provision of sufficient safeguards for the protection of personal data transferred outside the Community.

Codes of conduct are regulated in Article 40 of the GDPR in greater detail than in the Directive.

Codes of conduct are no more than a practical interpretation of the provisions contained in the GDPR. Controllers draw up their own compliance rules for their sectors by interpreting the GDPR.

In this respect they are important because they make it possible to devise solutions to the sectoral and technological problems that may be encountered in the application of the GDPR and ensure

better protection of personal data. The GDPR lists, albeit not exhaustively, the matters on which codes of conduct may be drawn up:

• fair and transparent data processing,

• the legitimate interests pursued by controllers in specific contexts,

• the collection of personal data,

• the pseudonymisation of personal data,

• the information provided to the public and to data subjects,

• the exercise of the rights of data subjects,

• the information provided to children and the protection of children, and the manner in which the consent of the holders of parental responsibility over children is to be obtained,

• the measures and procedures referred to in Articles 24 and 25 of the GDPR and the measures to ensure security of processing referred to in Article 32,

• the notification of personal data breaches to supervisory authorities and the communication of such personal data breaches to data subjects,

• the transfer of personal data to third countries or international organisations,

• without prejudice to the rights of data subjects pursuant to Articles 77 and 79, out-of-court

proceedings and other dispute resolution procedures for resolving disputes between controllers and data subjects.

Associations and other bodies which intend to prepare a code of conduct or to amend or extend an existing code submit the draft code, amendment or extension to the supervisory authority which is competent pursuant to Article 55 of the GDPR. The supervisory authority gives an opinion on whether the draft code, amendment or extension complies with the GDPR and, if it finds that the code provides sufficient appropriate safeguards, approves the code or the draft. Where the code, or the draft amendment or extension, is approved and where the code of conduct concerned does not relate to processing activities in several Member States, the supervisory authority registers and also publishes the code.

After a code of conduct has been approved, companies are obliged to monitor themselves continuously for conformity with the requirements of the code of conduct. In this context the supervisory authorities will carry out more or less non-routine checks in order to determine whether the undertaking's activities continuously conform to the code of conduct. • It is plain that, although binding corporate rules and codes of conduct have aspects in common, they are fundamentally two different institutions. Codes of conduct set out the administrative and technical requirements of the company in the context of data processing. Companies are thereby allowed to determine whether their activities comply with the GDPR and how they are to be monitored. However, their own monitoring of compliance cannot be used as proof of compliance before the data supervisory authorities.

In fact, codes of conduct are a practical interpretation of the abstract provisions of the GDPR.

Binding corporate rules, by contrast, are rules that enable controllers to transfer data to third countries and ensure the security of the data during the transfer.

Binding corporate rules may (in terms of terminology)

be referred to as “binding corporate rules for international data transfers” or “legally enforceable corporate rules for international data transfers”. The expression “binding or legally enforceable” was preferred here because the rules can be regarded as “sufficient safeguards” within the meaning of Article 26(2)

of the Directive; the word “corporate” was preferred because they generally consist of rules applied in multinational companies and set up under the responsibility of the headquarters; and “international data transfers” because that is the main reason for their existence. Indeed, the use of such terminology brings out the nature of binding corporate rules more accurately.

The concept of a corporate group may sometimes denote hierarchically structured multinational companies and sometimes a group of companies engaged in different economic activities. For this reason the differences in the structure and activities of companies must be taken into account when an application for binding corporate rules is made.

For holdings (loose conglomerates), binding corporate rules are unlikely to be a suitable instrument. For it is very difficult to meet, by means of a single text, the needs of all the companies within the holding, which operate in fields that differ from one another. For such holdings it is necessary to separate the sub-groups within the same corporate group from one another and to lay down strict limitations and conditions for the exchange of data.

In practice, (because they wish

to regulate their worldwide intra-group transfers in this way) multinational companies are expected to be the most frequent users of these mechanisms. The Article 29 Working Party emphasises that the scope of any authorisation granted on the basis of this document will affect only the transfers or categories of transfers within the corporate group, in other words the exchange of personal data between the companies bound by these corporate rules.

THE FUNCTION OF BINDING CORPORATE RULES

Binding corporate rules were created in order to enable multinational companies to transfer data to their affiliates outside the European Economic Area in compliance with Article 25 of Directive 95/46/EC and the data protection principle. The first and foremost function of binding corporate rules is therefore to make data transfers possible. For personal data to be transferred, EU personal data legislation requires that protection also exist in the country to which the data are transferred and that that country, too, fulfil its obligations.

For multinational companies in particular, applying different procedures and policies from country to country is something that disrupts

business processes. Indeed, the very purpose for which binding corporate rules emerged is to prevent the disruptions that have occurred and may occur.

Another function of binding corporate rules is accountability. In other words, because the rules are recognised by, and can be audited by, all the authorities within the EEA, companies are under an obligation to carry out processing in conformity with the rules and, where necessary, to give an account of the processing they have carried out. A further function of the rules is that they ensure the management of data privacy. They achieve this through the fact that companies can be subjected to audit by every authority. Since the company is audited by every authority, its data privacy can be kept under control. The final function of the rules is to raise awareness of the protection of personal data and to ensure data protection. Under the rules, companies acting as controllers are obliged to protect personal data in full. This, too, is directly related to audit and accountability.

In addition to all this, because binding corporate rules express the fact that the company protects personal data, they create trust among customers

and thereby also have the effect of enhancing commercial reputation and, consequently, commercial revenue.

THE ROLE OF BINDING CORPORATE RULES WITH REGARD TO THE APPROACHES TO THE SHARING OF PERSONAL DATA

It can be seen that each country proceeds from a different perspective when legislating on the protection of personal data. The European Union, for example, regards the protection of personal data as part of the protection of fundamental rights and freedoms and frames its legislation from that perspective.

The Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation and the United States of America, by contrast, treat the matter as a property right, with a view to protecting economic interests. These differences in fact reveal how greatly data protection regulations vary from country to country.

There are essentially two approaches to the sharing of personal data.

The first is the approach of territory-based rules and the second that of organisation-based rules. The approach of the European Union is an example of the first method, since it protects personal data within its territory. The Privacy Framework drawn up by the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC),

by contrast, is an example of the second approach, in that the organisation protects personal data in respect of the activities within its own structure regardless of where it is located (and also after data have been transferred to another organisation). Although the starting points of these two approaches appear very different, the two systems largely converge in their application.

Through the Privacy Framework, APEC also pursues a similar organisational objective by seeking to have the organisations of member countries adopt “Cross-Border Privacy Rules” (CBPR) in a manner that will facilitate their transfers of data abroad. At the same time, the APEC Privacy Framework also contains elements of the territorial approach, since it encourages member countries to develop bilateral or multilateral arrangements for cooperation between participating countries in the investigation of data protection breaches. The APEC Privacy Framework further states that bilateral or multilateral cooperation may be limited, or even refused, where it would lead to a breach of national laws or policies. Accordingly, if the laws of the other party are not regarded as • “equivalent” to a country's national laws, cooperation may be refused. This produces a result very similar to the EU's adequacy rules. The role of binding corporate rules in such a situation is to act as a bridge between the two systems by facilitating international data transfers in cases where the EU and the APEC member countries cannot agree on what the appropriate universal level of data protection should be.

THE ROLE OF BCRS WITH REGARD TO THE SCOPE OF THE LEGISLATIVE AND EXECUTIVE POWERS OF STATES

As a rule, every law is valid within the political borders of the country in which it has been enacted. This rule is a natural consequence of sovereignty and is called the principle of territoriality. Sometimes countries transfer part of their legislative, executive or judicial powers (their sovereignty) and accept the authority of a higher organisation at international level. The European Union is the most important and typical example of this.

The development of technology has made it possible for personal data to be shared with the other end of the world within seconds. Particularly through the commercial activities of multinational companies, the data of the citizens of a great many

countries have come to be shared at the same time. For this reason, regulations on personal data that are applied and afford protection only within a country's own political borders have proved inadequate. Many countries, too, seek to protect their data shared abroad by giving their data protection laws a broad scope of application.

However, countries' efforts to protect their data transferred abroad have brought with them many questions and problems from the standpoint of international law.

For, in the absence of an agreement and of jurisdiction, it is not possible under national legal rules for the law of one country to be applied in another. For this reason, what needs to be done in matters of data protection, particularly where a personal data breach has occurred, is to cooperate with the other Data Protection Authorities. In this way the protection of personal data will be ensured without infringing the legislative, executive and judicial powers of any country. However, we do not think that even full cooperation can, in the field of data protection, (owing to the legal gaps that may arise

from the differences between countries' legislation) prevent breaches altogether.

It is precisely at this point that the importance of adopting a regulation applicable on a global scale becomes apparent. In our day, when very large quantities of personal data can be shared between countries within seconds or even fractions of a second and these data have created a commercial market of their own, the need to protect personal data is inescapable.

This is why it has been provided that, where the personal data of a person living in the European Union are processed outside the EEA, the GDPR may also be applied in the country that processes the data.

However, while it should not be overlooked that the GDPR is an important step in that it is a single regulation for all the countries of the European Union, its scope may pose a problem with regard to the sovereignty of states (for countries that are not members of the EU).

When becoming members of the EU, countries transfer part of their sovereign powers to the Union on account of the advantages that membership will bring them. For countries that are not members of the Union, however, no such situation exists. This amounts to an attempt to apply in Türkiye the regulation of an international organisation

to which it is not a party. To give an example: where the personal data of a person who is in fact a citizen of Uzbekistan but lives in Germany, and who comes to stay at a hotel based in Türkiye, are shared in breach of the GDPR, how will the German Data Protection Authority impose a sanction on the hotel, which is subject to Law No. 6698 in Türkiye? The best way of resolving this problem is for the Personal Data Protection Authority, which is the Turkish data protection authority, and the German Data Protection Authority to cooperate. That is to say, the German Data Protection Authority will alert the Personal Data Protection Authority that a breach has occurred, whereupon the latter will carry out its inspections and impose an administrative fine under Law No. 6698. Although this solution helps to resolve problems such as how the sanction is to be imposed, it cannot prevent the problems and the breaches that stem from the differences between legal systems.

It is in these gaps, which even cooperation cannot fill, that binding corporate rules come into play; and, particularly because multinational companies apply them to group companies in countries where data protection does not exist or is weaker, they perform an important function (since the citizens of that country also benefit from this protection).

BINDING CORPORATE RULES AND US - EU DATA TRANSFERS

In the GDPR, the transfer of data to third countries is subject to strict conditions. Data may nevertheless be transferred if adequate data protection is also ensured in the third country to which the data are to be transferred. Adequate protection is deemed to be ensured where there is a European Commission decision, or model clauses contained in contracts, or binding corporate rules. To begin with the first, the European Commission announces the third countries which (through the laws of the third country to which the transfer is to be made) protect personal data adequately and to which transfers may therefore be made. However, the number of countries in respect of which such a decision has been taken is very small.

Switzerland and Israel may be cited as examples of countries for which a decision has been taken (the USA is not one of these countries).

The main advantage of binding corporate rules is that, once they have been developed and put into operation, they can provide a framework for a variety of intra-group transfers (in order to meet the company's needs).

On the other hand, however, companies that adopt these

rules must maintain compliance by monitoring it regularly. In this context it is important that companies carry out audits both at fixed intervals and unannounced, and that they train their staff.

Apart from binding corporate rules, another route by which data transfers are permitted (and which spares companies the trouble of concluding a large number of agreements with all the data protection authorities) is the use

of the “model clauses” contained in contracts.

Although the use of these clauses is permitted, in practice some data protection authorities, even though the clauses have been approved by the European Commission, operate a separate, time-consuming procedure. This reduces the rate at which the clauses are used. Nevertheless, this mechanism, known as “standard contractual clauses” or “model clauses”, has traditionally been the one most frequently used to legitimise data transfers to countries that do not ensure an adequate level of protection.

These rules are contractual clauses approved in advance by the European Commission under the Data Protection Directive 95/46/EC and, in order that personal data be protected in accordance with EU standards,

have established certain obligations applicable to both exporters and importers. These model clauses, created at the time of the Directive, remain valid until they are amended or replaced by clauses that are legally more comprehensive under the GDPR.

The model clauses approved by the European Commission play an important role in the development of contractual routes for data transfers (because new contracts of this kind are assessed by the data protection authorities). Some technology companies, such as Microsoft, Amazon Web Services and Google, have taken the lead in drafting their own contracts for the transfer of data to third countries and submitting them to the data protection authorities for approval.

The greatest advantage of model clauses is that, since companies draft the contracts according to their own structure, activities and means, they commit themselves to a more realistic level of data protection, so that possible breaches of their contractual obligations are prevented.

The main advantages of model clauses

are as follows:

• To the extent that the contract is based on the standard contractual clauses adopted by the European Commission or by the European data protection authorities, it is in principle accepted as a valid mechanism for legitimising data transfers.

• Drafting and concluding the contract is not very time-consuming. However, they also have some fundamental disadvantages:

• Given the static nature of contractual texts, they may not be adequate for multiple and changing transfers.

• In order to meet the standards required by the European Commission or the data protection authorities, the contract must contain very strict terms affecting the use of the personal data by the parties. Until 2016, another route besides model clauses that facilitated the transfer of data abroad for controllers was the Safe Harbor principles. Safe Harbor, in other words the International Safe Harbor Privacy Principles, were principles developed between 1998 and 2000 (and designed to facilitate data transfers) in order to prevent private organisations in the USA and the EU from disclosing and losing personal • data.

These are notice, choice, onward transfer, access, security, data integrity and enforcement.

By means of Safe Harbor, companies certified that they had taken data protection measures and complied with the seven core principles. However, in 2016 the European Court of Justice ruled that the Safe Harbor Principles were no longer valid. The invalidation of the Safe Harbor Principles caused the validity of methods that legitimise data transfers, such as binding corporate rules, to be viewed with doubt.

Since this would have meant that companies once again had to use model clauses for data transfers and to deal with a great deal of paperwork, an arrangement to replace the Safe Harbor Principles was created as a result of negotiations between the European Commission and the USA. First, the European Commission made thirteen recommendations which addressed the weaknesses of Safe Harbor and were aimed at ensuring that it remained a valid mechanism. These recommendations were examined by the US authorities with a focus on four broad

priorities, namely transparency, redress, enforcement and access to data. In June 2014 the then Commissioner for Justice, Viviane Reding, announced that the US Department of Commerce had accepted twelve of the Commission's thirteen recommendations. The contentious point, however, was the final recommendation, to the effect that the national security exception should be applied only when necessary and proportionate.

The event that really led to the invalidation of Safe Harbor, however, was the complaint lodged with the Irish Data Protection Authority by the Austrian law student Maximilian Schrems, who requested that the transfer of personal data to the United States of America by Facebook Ireland be brought to an end. Schrems claimed that Facebook Ireland was the controller in respect of Facebook's European users and that, because of the broad access to these data (such as that enjoyed by the US intelligence agencies), the legal framework of Safe Harbor could no longer be relied upon to legitimise transfers to the USA.

The complaint was subsequently referred to the Irish High Court and from there to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), the highest judicial authority on the interpretation of EU law. On 6 October 2015 the Court of Justice

of the European Union delivered its judgment and declared the Safe Harbor adequacy decision invalid. This judgment increased the pressure on the European Commission to adopt a more robust alternative mechanism for data transfers from the EU to the USA.

This arrangement, called the Privacy Shield, was prepared with the GDPR in mind (even though it had not yet entered into force at that time). It thus became possible for companies registered with the Federal Trade Commission to exchange personal data with the EU without the restrictions to which non-registered companies are subject. This arrangement introduced redress mechanisms for data subjects for the protection of their individual rights, provisions safeguarding privacy with regard to US government access to data, and additional obligations for companies. For example, under the Privacy Shield organisations must inform individuals about the collection and use of their data. In addition, stricter conditions and greater liability were imposed on organisations for the sharing of data with third parties.

In fact, these arrangements show that binding corporate rules are not

a preferred method for data transfers between the USA and the EU.

We think that the reason for such an approach is that binding corporate rules would not produce the desired result in respect of countries that have no national data protection legislation.

For, if we disregard the data protection regulations adopted in recent years, which cover the State of California in particular, there is in the USA no personal data legislation under which companies would fulfil their obligations and in accordance with which they would draw up binding corporate rules.

In the USA, personal data are regulated at state level. This means that companies must fulfil different obligations for each state in which they enter into business relations, which in turn leads to both higher costs and loss of time for companies. This is the strongest indication that, in order to prevent this situation, a data protection law applicable throughout the USA, similar to the recent regulations in the State of California in particular, will be enacted in the coming years.

BINDING CORPORATE RULES IN THE LIGHT OF THE PRINCIPLES OF THE

GREAT BRITAIN DATA PROTECTION ACT OF 1998

Binding corporate rules were created during the period in which Directive 95/46/EC was in force. But the Directive was not the only instrument that left its mark when the rules were being created.

In 1998 the Data Protection Act 1998 was adopted by the Kingdom of Great Britain (the country known in everyday usage as England).

The Act was created in order to fulfil the obligations under Directive 95/46/EC (it also meets the requirements of the Council of Europe Data Protection Convention of 1981) and repealed the Data Protection Act of 1984. The Data Protection Act 1998 describes itself as making provision for the processing of information relating to individuals. In terms of its consequences, this sentence is in fact worth reflecting on. For every public body, every company and indeed every person who has a computer carries out processing. The conclusion drawn from this is that the Act imposes obligations on everyone.

This Act regulates the processing of the data of identifiable natural persons. Two ideas underlie

the making of this Act. The first is to ensure the confidentiality of personal data while they are being processed; the second is to ensure that data flows between countries continue. Indeed, it is plain that the same ideas underlie all the regulations made on personal data, including the GDPR. With the development of technology, only the regulations on the protection of personal data have changed and evolved. The Data Protection Act 1998 is very important because of its influence on binding corporate rules. A total of eight principles were laid down in the Data Protection Act 1998. These are the principle of fairness and lawfulness, the purpose principle, the adequacy principle, the accuracy principle, the retention principle, the rights principle, the security principle and the international transfer principle. Principles similar to these are also laid down in the GDPR. By way of difference, the GDPR lays down the principle of accountability but does not lay down principles on rights and international transfers; these matters are dealt with in detail in Chapter Three and Chapter Five.

What matters for binding corporate rules, however, is the eighth principle. According to the eighth principle, “Data may not be transferred to a country or territory outside the European Economic Area unless adequate protection is ensured • for the rights and freedoms of the data subject in relation to the processing of personal data.”

The principle also gives companies the opportunity to carry out their own audits with regard to data transfers. It is clear, however, that where data are transferred to a country outside the EEA the audit will be limited. Although the GDPR is the principal instrument for the protection of personal data, the eighth principle is one that must be mentioned when binding corporate rules are discussed, because it influenced the GDPR and is consistent with the logic of the GDPR.

Following the adoption of the GDPR, the Kingdom of Great Britain brought the Data Protection Act into force in 2018 in order to ensure compliance with the GDPR. While the GDPR applies to every EU Member State, it also empowers states to make their own “personal data protection legislation”. The Act adopted in 2018 is in the nature of a kind of explanation of the GDPR. For this reason the GDPR and the Data Protection Act adopted in 2018 must be read together. The Act, too, applies the GDPR standards. However, it has enacted the provisions of the GDPR in such a way that they are applied

at national level. For example, the Data Protection Act (2018) contains a special provision on data processing relating to immigration that is not found in the GDPR.

THE CRITERIA THAT BINDING CORPORATE RULES MUST MEET

Under binding corporate rules, data subjects must be third-party beneficiaries, either by virtue of the legal effects of unilateral undertakings (where possible under national law) or by virtue of contractual arrangements (between the members of the corporate group that make this possible). In other words, binding corporate rules must confer on data subjects rights in respect of their personal data.

The rules must also contain an express provision to the effect that mandatory legal obligations applicable to the entire corporate group may prevent the application of these rules. By its nature, such a provision has an adverse effect on the fulfilment of the commitments to protect personal data. However, since compliance with the legislation takes priority, such a provision must be included. Where such a situation is encountered, the European Union must be informed (unless there is a circumstance such as the confidentiality of an investigation).

The European Union, after consulting the competent data protection authority, takes a decision on what

is to be done and notifies the company of the decision so that it may implement it.

It should be noted that mandatory legal requirements which apply to the whole group and do not go beyond what is necessary in a democratic society do not conflict with binding corporate rules.

Reporting obligations for the prevention of the laundering of the proceeds of crime or tax reporting obligations may be cited as examples of such non-conflicting obligations. Where doubt arises with regard to these obligations too, corporate groups should likewise consult the competent Data Protection Authority.

THE BINDING NATURE OF BINDING CORPORATE RULES

Companies respond to their data processing needs on the basis of different legal and cultural backgrounds and different business philosophies and practices. With regard to these factors it may be said that almost every multinational company approaches this matter in a different way. Despite these differences, the most important feature of binding corporate rules (which are to be used to protect personal data when data are transferred abroad) is that the rules are binding both internally and externally.

In order that the binding nature may be better understood and possible confusion

avoided, it is necessary to discuss the relationship between these rules and the concepts of compliance and legal enforceability. The binding nature of binding corporate rules denotes the joint assessment of these two aspects. In other words, since an assessment solely of the legal enforceability of the unilateral undertakings given, or of the contracts producing the same effect, may entail a disproportionate effort, particularly with regard to the rights of data subjects, their practicability must also be assessed; that is to say, it must be ensured that they are binding in practice as well. In practice, the binding nature of the rules can be ensured only by training employees and by applying disciplinary procedures in the event of non-compliance. It is in particular through the existence of disciplinary procedures that employees will feel obliged to apply the rules. Otherwise, data subjects would be granted rights on paper while being unable to exercise their rights in fact. This, indeed, is all that the binding nature expresses. In short, binding corporate rules must both conform to the legislation and be effective for those who apply them.

THE APPLICATION FOR BINDING CORPORATE RULES

In order to be able to apply binding corporate rules, companies must apply to the data protection authorities for approval. Pursuant to the provision in Article 63 of the GDPR, according to which “In order to contribute to the consistent application of this Regulation throughout the Union, the supervisory authorities shall cooperate with each other and, where relevant, with the Commission, through the consistency mechanism as set out in this Section.”, the rules will be approved by the authority concerned in accordance with the consistency mechanism.

Where the controller applying for approval of binding corporate rules has legal entities in more than one country, this application must be made to the data protection authorities in all the countries in which the legal entities are located. The Data Protection Authority communicates its draft decision to the European Data Protection Board (EDPB), which will give an opinion on the binding corporate rules. Once the binding corporate rules have been finalised in line with the EDPB opinion, the Data Protection Authority, as the competent authority, approves the rules.

The assessment carried out for the purpose of granting approval concerns the safeguards undertaken by the controller in order to protect the data

when personal data are transferred abroad. This practice therefore differs from the approval of the codes of conduct referred to in Article 27 of the Directive, that is, of professional rules intended for the practical application of national data protection legislation in a particular sector. The internal rules of a corporate group cannot take the place of data protection obligations. Compliance with national law is of course a sine qua non for any authorisation to be granted. The following procedure must be followed for the approval of binding corporate rules:

First, the form (which can be used by all EEA Member States) must be submitted to the Data Protection Authority that is considered to be the lead authority. The lead Data Protection Authority is the authority that, by ensuring coordination with all the authorities, conducts the approval procedure for binding corporate rules within the EEA. An applicant corporate group must justify its choice of lead data protection authority on the basis of the following criteria: a. the location of the group's European headquarters; b. the location within the group of the company with data protection responsibilities; c. the location of the company in the group that is best

placed (in terms of management function, administrative burden, etc.) to apply the binding corporate rules; d. the place where most decisions on the purposes and means of the processing are taken; e. the Member States within the EU from which most transfers outside the EEA will take place.

One of the data protection authorities acts as lead authority for the approval of the binding corporate rules.

In order that the lead authority may be determined, the form is sent by the Data Protection Authority to all the authorities from which the company wishes to obtain approval. Once the lead authority has been determined, the competent authority is notified to the company that made the application for approval. The lead authority then ensures cooperation with all the authorities concerned (in order to reach a decision) by sending them the entire form, including the binding corporate rules. Thereafter the lead authority communicates its draft decision to the European Data Protection Board. After the binding corporate rules have been finalised in line with the opinion of the European Data Protection Board, they are approved by the authority. A copy of the approved rules is then sent to all the data protection authorities within the EEA.

The approval process takes approximately 16 - 17 months: 5 months for the lead authority

to assess the application, 3- 4 months for the mutual recognition and cooperation procedure with the other authorities to be conducted, and 8 months for the reply to be given to the applicant.

The application form in question essentially consists of three parts. The first part contains information on the structure of the applicant and of the group. The second part gives brief information on the data flows.

The application form in question essentially consists of two parts, namely the applicant information and the background paper. The first part contains information on the structure of the applicant and of the group, on the data flows and on the determination of the lead Data Protection Authority. In giving information on the data flows, the nature and purpose of the data transfers and the persons to whom the data are transferred are described. The Data Protection Authorities are not bound by the applicant's designation and, as we have stated above, may choose another authority as lead authority. It must be stated expressly in the form that, where it is alleged that the rules have been breached, the burden of proof – whether at the centre of the transfer or at the European Union headquarters, and irrespective of where the claim originates – •

lies with the part of the organisation that has delegated data protection responsibilities. The form must go on to provide for mechanisms to verify compliance and, in view of the possibility that a country's domestic law may not permit audits by every authority, must grant permission for all the authorities to carry out audits. The next section of the second part must indicate how coordination between the binding corporate rules and all the authorities will be ensured. Thereafter the data flows and the data processing must be described, and the mechanism for notifying changes to the rules to the data protection authorities and the security measures undertaken for the protection of the data must be explained. Where the fields in the form are insufficient, additional pages may be attached to the form. It may be indicated that some of the information attached to the form must be kept confidential, being a trade secret or the like. Where a third party requests disclosure of this information, the request is assessed by the Data Protection Authority in accordance with national legislation.

It should be noted that, as of 2015, a total of 66 BCRs had been approved, namely in the United Kingdom (17), the Netherlands (12), Germany (7), France (24), Belgium (1), Ireland (1), Malta (1), Luxembourg (2) and Denmark (1). As of 25 May 2018 this number had risen to 135.

AMENDING BINDING CORPORATE RULES

Since the sharing of personal data may also change as a result of changes that occur over time in business activities and processes and of developments in technology, the Article 29 Working Party provided that companies may make changes to their binding corporate rules.

Provided that the necessary conditions are fulfilled, binding corporate rules may be updated without the need to apply again for approval.

Companies have thus been enabled to adapt easily to changes.

The relevant conditions are as follows:

• Personal data must not be transferred without making sure that the controller or processor to which the data are transferred will effectively comply with the rules.

• Updates to the rules must be kept track of by a part of the corporate group or by a designated person, and the necessary information must be provided, on request, to data subjects and to the data protection

authorities.

• Any change to the rules must be reported once a year to the Data Protection Authority concerned, together with the reasons and explanations justifying the change.

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BINDING CORPORATE RULES AND THE UNDERTAKINGS FOR THE TRANSFER OF DATA ABROAD IN TURKISH LAW

Under Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data, the main rule for the transfer of personal data abroad is that the explicit consent of the data subject be obtained. However, the Law provides that, if certain conditions are met, it is not mandatory to obtain explicit consent when data are transferred abroad.

According to Article 3 of the Law, explicit consent means “consent that relates to a specific subject, is based on information and is expressed with free will”. This consent must be specific to the subject, and the data subject must be informed about the subject before consent is obtained. Furthermore, consent must not be a precondition for the provision of a service. Since explicit consent may be withdrawn by the data subject at any time, in order for commercial life to be sustained, personal data should, as far as possible,

not be processed on the basis of explicit consent, and activities should be carried on under the exceptions that permit data processing without explicit consent. In our day, when data can be transferred abroad within seconds, the withdrawal of consent by even a single data subject in the course of trade will affect the running of the business to a great extent. In order to prevent such situations, the law of personal data protection should be interpreted not as a factor that makes commercial activities more difficult but as a body of law that also protects personal data while commercial activities continue.

In Turkish law, the exceptions for the transfer of data abroad are regulated in Article 9 of Law No. 6698 as follows:

“Personal data may, where one of the conditions set out in the second paragraph of Article 5 and the third paragraph of Article 6 is met and provided that, in the foreign country to which the personal data are to be transferred,

a) adequate protection exists,

b) where adequate protection does not exist, the controllers in Türkiye and in the foreign country concerned undertake in writing to provide adequate protection and the Board has given its permission, be transferred abroad without seeking the explicit

consent of the data subject.” According to the provision, when personal data are transferred abroad, either there must be adequate protection in the country to which they are transferred, or an undertaking that the personal data will be protected must be drawn up by the controller and approved by the Board. In fact, for either condition to be capable of being met, the Board must announce which countries are safe and which are not. Once the countries have been announced, personal data may be transferred without obtaining explicit consent, since adequate protection is deemed to exist in the safe countries. However, for a country to be recognised as a safe country, that country must also recognise Türkiye as safe. At present, for diplomatic reasons, it cannot be announced which countries are safe and which are not. Consequently, since companies at present do not obtain explicit consent when transferring data abroad, all the transfers made are unlawful. In recent days, however, press statements issued by the Presidency of the Republic have indicated that the legislation on the transfer of data abroad will be amended and that the intention is to resolve this problem. • What really matters for the subject of our study, however, is the drawing up of an undertaking and the conditions for its approval by the Board. This method has gained even greater importance in particular because the applications for undertakings made by the Amazon Türkiye companies have been accepted.

The minimum elements that undertakings must contain are regulated in the following paragraph of the same article of the Law. According to that paragraph, the undertaking must contain “a) the international conventions to which Türkiye is a party,

b) the state of reciprocity concerning data transfers between the country requesting the personal data and Türkiye,

c) with regard to each specific transfer of personal data, the nature of the personal data and the purpose and duration of the processing,

ç) the relevant legislation and practice of the country to which the personal data are to be transferred,

d) the measures undertaken by the controller located in the country to which the personal data are to be transferred.”

When the elements that binding corporate rules must contain are compared with the elements of the undertaking (or the conditions it must satisfy), it is seen that the elements of binding corporate rules are more numerous

and that they call for more detailed information.

Unlike the KVKK's conditions for the transfer of data abroad, binding corporate rules contain elements relating to the structure of the company, the lead Data Protection Authority and the supervisory powers of the authorities.

The reason for these differences is that the GDPR in force in the EU (and before it the Directive) is a single instrument applicable in all EU countries, whereas there are numerous Data Protection Authorities in the EEA. In Türkiye, by contrast, the sole competent authority for the protection of personal data is the Personal Data Protection Authority.

It is therefore the only body with the power to supervise companies. Nor is there any question of companies accepting a lead authority or accepting that other bodies may supervise them. In respect of the other elements, the elements of the undertaking and of the rules are similar.

CONCLUSION

Assessed together with the points set out above, the undertakings cannot, despite their similarities, be regarded as binding corporate rules. However, since the 11th Development Plan for 2019-2023 also states that the legislation on the protection of personal data will be aligned with the GDPR and that amendments will be made to that end, we think that the undertakings, which are drawn up on a country-by-country basis, will subsequently come to cover all transfers of data abroad made within the company and will take the form of binding corporate rules, and that the undertakings should also be viewed from this perspective.

As for how Binding Corporate Rules will be applied in Türkiye, this still remains uncertain.

On this matter the Board made an announcement on 10 April 2020, and the application form and a guidance document on the basic points were published as annexes to the announcement.

As far as we know, however, no application has yet been concluded.

On the other hand, the expectation for the near future is that significant amendments will be made to the KVKK legislation, in particular in order to facilitate the transfer of data abroad and to clear the blockage in this area, and that the existing legislation will be brought closer to the GDPR.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Avrupa Parlamentosu Araştırma

Servisi, From Safe Harbour to Privacy Shield, Temmuz 2017.

Jan Dhont, Binding Corporate Rules: Building A Future- Proof Privacy Compliance Solution, 2015,https://www.slideshare. net/JanDhont1/20150318- gac-presentation-bcr- 05052015-48184562,Erişim Tarihi: 23.01.2020.

Madde 29 Çalışma Grubu, Recommendation 1/2007 on the Standard Application for Approval of Binding Corporate Rules for the Transfer of Personal Data, 10 Temmuz 2007.

Madde 29 Çalışma Grubu, Working Document: Transfers of personal data to third countries: Applying Article 26

(2) of the EU Data Protection Directive to Binding Corporate Rules for International Data Transfers 3 Haziran 2003.

Madde 29. Çalışma Grubu, Working Document Setting up a Framework For The Structure of Binding Corporate Rules, 24 Haziran 2008.

Madde 29. Çalışma Grubu, Working Document Setting Forth a Co- Operation Procedure For Issuing Common Opinions on Adequate Safeguards Resulting From “Binding Corporate Rules”, 14 Nisan 2005.

Lokke Moerel, Binding Corporate Rules, 1. Baskı, Oxford Yayınları, İngiltere, 2012.

Türkiye Cumhuriyeti

Cumhurbaşkanlığı, Strateji ve Bütçe Başkanlığı, 2019- 2023 11.Kalkınma Planı, Temmuz 2019

Samantha Cutler, The Face- Off Between Data Privacy and Discovery: Why U.S.

Courts Should Respect EU Data Privacy Law When Considering the Production of Protected Information, Boston College Law Review, Cilt 59, Sayı 4.

Paul Lambert, Understanding The New European Data Protection Rules, Boca Raton, CRC Press, 2017.

Peter Carey, Data Protection, Oxford, 5.Baskı, Oxford University Express, 2018.

Paul Voigt/ Axel von dem

Bussche, The EU General Data Protection Regulation, Cham, Springer Iternational Publishing, 2017.

Rolf H. Weber/ Dominic

Staiger, Transatlantic Data Protection in Practice, Berlin, Springer-Verlag GmbH, 2017

Stewart Room, Data Protection& Compliance in Context, Swindon, BCS, 2007, s.1-3.

WEBSITES

https://ec.europa.eu/ info/law/law-topic/data-protection/internationaldimension-data-protection/ binding-corporaterules-bcr_en#approvalof-binding-corporaterules,Erişim Tarihi: 19.01.2020.

https://ico.org.uk/fororganisations/bindingcorporate-rules, Erişim Tarihi: 24.01.2020.

https://ico.org.uk/fororganisations/guideto-data-protection/ guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/ principles/, Erişim Tarihi: 24.01.2020.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Data_Protection_Act_1998, Erişim Tarihi: 25.02.2020.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ International_Safe_Harbor_ Privacy_Principles, Erişim Tarihi: 25.01.2020.

https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/ MevzuatMetin/1.5.6698.pdf, Erişim Tarihi: 25.01.2020.

https://www. kisiselverilerinkorunmasi. org/wp-content/ uploads/2017/09/GDPR- T%C3%BCrk%C3%A7e- %C3%87eviri-AB-

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic