2018Murat Volkan DülgerArticle

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

At a time when AI entities have entered every area of our lives, we have, in parallel with developments in technology, moved into a period in which this statement alone in fact falls short of describing the situation we are in. The reason is not only that artificial intelligence (AI) has entered every area of our lives but also that we ourselves have accepted AI into every area of our lives. Especially of late, we make the fullest use of the developments that make it easier for us to carry out every kind of activity and of the conveniences they provide, and we have reached a point where we can hardly do our work without using the benefits of these technological developments. Humans are becoming ever more intertwined with software equipped with AI algorithms and with AI entities that grow more advanced by the day.

This in turn results in AI software and robots having an effect on people’s sexual lives. One study has found that the great majority of technological developments, such as spacecraft and nuclear weapons, were triggered by wars, but that the area in which these developments have been most used and drawn upon is sexuality and sex. It is a known fact that developments in technology and science gained great momentum particularly in the period between the two wars. Since the day they began to develop, AI systems and robots have likewise been used, through various means, for the purpose of satisfying people’s sexual feelings.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER

In this period in which artificially intelligent entities

have entered every area of our lives, we have, in parallel with the developments in technology, entered a phase in which this expression alone in fact falls short of describing the situation we are in. The reason for this is that, just as artificial intelligence has entered every area of our lives, we too have in fact accepted artificial intelligence into every area of our lives.

Particularly of late, without benefiting to the fullest extent from the developments that make it easier for us to carry out all kinds of activities and from the conveniences these developments provide, and without, as it were, making use of the blessings of these technological developments,

volkan.dulger@dulger.av.tr

we have reached the point where we can no longer get our work done.

Humans and artificially intelligent entities, which develop further with each passing day through software equipped with artificial intelligence algorithms, are becoming ever more intertwined. This also has the consequence that artificially intelligent software and robots have an influence on people’s sexual lives.

A study has revealed that the great majority of technological developments have been triggered by wars, but that the fields in which these developments are most used and exploited are sexuality and sex.

It is also a well-known fact that, particularly in the period between the two wars, the developments in the technological and scientific field gained great

momentum. Artificial intelligence and robots, too, have been used, ever since they began to develop, through various means for the purpose of satisfying people’s sexual feelings. Recently, however, the idea has come onto the agenda that these entities may not merely be used from the outside to satisfy people but may themselves become part of the event, so that emotional intimacy may arise between humans and robots and, going even further, sex may take place between them as a result of sexual attraction.

All of the research on sexual intimacy between humans and robots is being conducted where artificial intelligence is more highly developed and where,

for political, religious and socio-cultural reasons, the phenomenon of sexuality and sex can be talked about and debated more freely, namely in America and Europe. In Türkiye there is as yet no research or forum for debate on the subject; but because technology is intensively used and is developing in our country too, the effects of artificially intelligent entities on sexuality and sex should also be debated in the context of their place in our lives, their future and the problems they may cause. Could it really be possible for people to derive pleasure from being with a robot and for their sexual feelings to be more fully satisfied? Will people derive more pleasure from robots

and be able to prefer robots as sexual partners, and even fall in love with these robots? Could jealousy, arguments and quarrels really arise between a married couple because of a robot, and could these people divorce? In countries where adultery is regulated as an offence, could a spouse who has sex with a robot be regarded as the perpetrator of an offence? Can, and should, having sex with a robot be regarded as a justified ground for divorce? Will a person who forces intercourse on a robot be the perpetrator of the offence of sexual assault, or will being with these entities by using force be regulated as a different type of offence, or will it be assessed as damage to property?

BETWEEN HUMANS AND ARTIFICIALLY INTELLIGENT ENTITIES/ ROBOTS,

ARE EMOTIONAL INTIMACY AND SEX POSSIBLE?

First of all, it would be appropriate to answer this question, without hesitation, in the affirmative. When we look at the place and role of sexuality in human life, we see that it has in fact existed since very ancient times, and that research has nonetheless brought many different perspectives, chiefly psychological and social, to the concept of sexuality, which was thought to have only a reproductive aspect.

It is also seen that, even in ages when technology had not yet developed,

people strove to raise their sexual pleasure and satisfaction to the highest level and came up with various devices.

With the development of technology, these devices have evolved and become capable of giving people more pleasure, and people have come to harbour emotional feelings towards these devices and to wish to have sex with them rather than merely using them to obtain pleasure. In this process of human sexuality developing in this way, for robots that can behave just like humans and display humanoid characteristics to have no place

is impossible. Indeed, there are already many examples of this today. In the face of this rapid development of technology, I think that robots which display more human characteristics and can hardly be distinguished from a human being will be built in the near future, and that relationships of love and sex between humans and robots will become widespread and even normal. Research and studies on intimacy between humans and robots began in America and Europe – both because technology is more advanced in these countries and artificially intelligent entities came to be discussed earlier there, and because sexuality and sex are, as they should be, regarded as quite natural and form an area that is talked about and debated freely – and • are continuing apace.

Debates are being held on the subject, books and articles are being published and, by reflecting on its advantages and disadvantages, efforts are being made to devise solutions to possible dangers as well. Indeed, a large number of scientists who are experts in their field, sociologists in particular, will hold the fourth “International Congress on Love and Sex with Robots” at the University of Montana in America.

In the book “Love and Sex with Robots: The Evolution of Human-Robot Relationships”, published in 2007 by the Canadian astronomer David Levy, which deals with the emotional and sexual relationships that will arise between robots and humans, it is argued that, just as humanity has in time accepted same-sex marriage, it will in time also accept love with robots and marriage to them. The book states that people suffer from a problem of loneliness and that this problem will be overcome by sex robots.

Indeed, research findings indicate that, particularly as social media tools have become so widespread, people have in fact become not more sociable but lonelier. It appears possible that this very loneliness will be filled by robots and

that people will consequently harbour emotional feelings towards these robots. Mention is also made of the potentially advantageous aspects of relationships between humans and robots, such as the possibility of using robots in the treatment of paedophilia.

Today the debate on the possible benefits and harms of humans and robots being together continues within the framework of a variety of ideas.

What consequences will it have for an individual who has only just entered puberty to have his first sexual experience with a robot?

While it may be regarded as beneficial that such a person can draw on and learn from the experience of a robot built solely for this purpose, and can moreover derive considerable pleasure from a conscious robot, will that person, in being with this robot, be able to experience, particularly in emotional terms, the feelings that he could experience with a human being?

Will the use of robots with the appearance of a child for the treatment of paedophilia patients ensure that the treatment takes a positive course, or will it cause the illness to progress? From another angle, even if positive developments are achieved in treatment, will the use of child robots in this way be regarded as compatible with morality and the law? Will this incompatibility

be assessed from the standpoint of the other people in society or from that of the child robot used? For the psychological effects of such a method on other people must be assessed. On the other hand, where the robot displays humanoid characteristics at an advanced level and is granted various rights, an attempt must be made to determine the lawfulness of this method in the context of its effects on the child robot.

Finally, in the event that advancing technology makes it possible to build robots that can truly feel like a human being, will the use of these robots in this way be acceptable?

On the other hand, in the present day, when it is mostly women who are used as sex slaves, it is thought that robots designed and programmed specifically and solely for sex could be a solution to this problem. In this way there would be a decrease in the use of human beings as sex slaves, and sexually transmitted diseases would also be prevented. Although, in terms of the balance of interests, using a robot as a sex worker seems for the time being a better idea than using a human being, in the periods when, as is foreseen, there will be robots that claim or possess rights and freedoms of their own, will the use of these robots by humans

in this way be compatible with the law of that period? Will robots allow themselves to be used as sex slaves? Moreover, even if consent is given to this, once robots too are granted rights similar to the personality rights of human beings, should this consent be accepted as a ground of justification?

As can be seen, ideas are being produced on the foreseeable possible consequences of emotional and sexual intimacy between artificially intelligent entities and humans, particularly as to whether it can provide a solution to existing problems, and efforts are being made to develop these ideas through various criticisms. Every issue debated brings to light a problem, and hence a consequence, falling within a separate field of law. For this reason, thought must be given to the possible effects that the developments in this area may have on the existing legal order, and, although the use of robots for sex would serve a practical purpose, the lawfulness of this must be determined in the light of the possibility that robots will in future be regarded as persons. It should be noted at this point that, although sexual relations with artificially intelligent entities and robots, including child robots, have not yet been

restricted by any country, the European Commission has begun work in this direction.

CAN A RELATIONSHIP WITH SEX ROBOTS CONSTITUTE THE SUBJECT MATTER OF ADULTERY OR BE REGARDED AS A JUSTIFIED GROUND FOR DIVORCE?

In our national law, the Turkish Civil Code, in which family law is regulated, provides that adultery by one of the spouses is a ground on which the other spouse may bring an action for divorce. In the light of this provision, which is placed under the heading of grounds for divorce, is it possible to bring sexual relations with sex robots within its scope? Adultery is sexual intercourse which a married man or woman has, of his own free will, with someone other than his spouse. Can a sex robot be included in the concept of “someone other” that appears in the definition? Sex robots, which today are designed very differently from smart sex toys, have now become entities that can feel, that can respond to the person before them and with which mutual sharing is possible, rather than a toy for one-sided pleasure, and have begun to display characteristics just like those of a human being. Such a robot could perfectly well be accepted as someone else and be capable of being the subject of adultery,

could it not? However, much as they may display human-like characteristics, given that they have not yet been recognised by the legal order or been given a classification akin to personality, how lawful would it be to accept these sex robots as one of the parties to adultery by interpreting the concept of adultery broadly?

A man living in America who has been married for 36 years, and who is the subject of the documentary “The Sex Robots Are Coming”, has sex four days a week with his robot, whom he has named April, takes her out to dinner and buys her presents. He says that, when they go out to dinner, the people around them take her for a living woman, as it were, and that April listens to him and is able to understand him.

If you remove the word robot from the sentences I have written up to this point, we come to the conclusion that what is being talked about is in fact quite simply another woman or man.

Does the fact that such a situation, solely on account of the attribute of being a robot, is not prohibited by law, and is moreover not regarded as acceptable in the eyes of society, mean that there is no legal protection whatsoever for the other spouse?

Since the existing legal norms are unfortunately not sufficient to overcome the problems where their subject matter is artificially intelligent entities, it is at the conclusion that new legislation on the subject is needed

that we arrive. My personal opinion is that, where adultery is concerned, the overriding interest of the other spouse, whom it is sought to protect, must be upheld. The reason for this is that, thanks to humanoid robots, people can now, as it were, create with their own hands the person they will have sex with and determine that person’s personality.

This is of such a nature as to drive the married spouse away from his wife/her husband and to push the other spouse into loneliness. On the other hand, in this situation, which, as with most legal problems, may take shape according to the specific case, the attitude of the other party must also be taken into account. Having regard also to the provision of the Code which lays down that the party who forgives has no right of action, it must be stated that the provisions on adultery should not be applied in respect of a spouse who accepts this situation and is not disturbed by it.

Indeed, in the example above, the wife of the man who has a relationship with his robot named April has stated that, although she found the situation strange at first, she got used to it over time and that she feels at ease because the robot is not a real woman.

As regards the possibility of one of the spouses being in a relationship with a sex robot, a solution, framed around the question of which situations may be accepted as grounds for divorce within the limits of the existing legal system,

is being sought. If these robots are recognised by the legal order, that is, if they are regulated in the Constitution and the Civil Code and, just like human beings, have legal capacity and capacity to act and are accepted as being on the same level as human beings, it will be possible for us to accept this situation directly as adultery. Once it is accepted as adultery, then, in addition to the ground for divorce, actions for non-pecuniary damages that may be brought against a sex robot which is aware that it is having relations with a married person will also come onto the agenda. A robot which thus has legal capacity and capacity to act will also be able to be a party to proceedings. However, even if it may be thought that, under the existing rules, this is the most reasonable solution, would granting robots, too, a personality equal to that of human beings be capable of meeting present-day needs? I think it is still too early for that.

For the time being, in our existing legal order robots are, in accordance with the distinction between persons and things derived from Roman law, regarded as things. However, the fact that the entity in question is a humanoid robot takes us away from the simple concept of a thing and, by bringing us close, as it were, to the concept of “human being”, directs us towards the rules laid down under the concept of natural person. Is there any difference between a married man using a sex robot and a married woman • using a vibrator? When sex robots are regarded as a simple sexual object, they are in fact no different from an ordinary vibrator. However, a woman who uses a vibrator cannot talk to it and share her troubles with it, nor, for instance, does she take her vibrator out to dinner and buy it presents. Looking at the matter from the other side, a vibrator, while it is being used, can neither give commands by saying things to the person before it, nor take pleasure in the situation and declare that it is in love with that person. Regarding these robots as an ordinary object, then, cannot provide a solution to the possible problems or meet the needs arising in this area. At the same time, however much they may display humanoid characteristics, and even if distinguishing them from a human being becomes difficult in time, defining and accepting these robots as human beings would not be a correct approach either. We thus reach the conclusion that the distinction between persons and things, which has come down to the present day by tradition, is no longer sufficient for us in the face of technological developments.

In my view, as artificially intelligent entities and humanoid sex robots develop and become fully part of our lives, the concepts of sexuality, marriage, infidelity, adultery,

divorce and polygamy/monogamy will have to be redefined.

CAN A RELATIONSHIP WITH SEX ROBOTS LEAD TO A SITUATION IN WHICH THE CONTINUATION OF THE MARITAL UNION CAN NO LONGER BE EXPECTED?

Since the institution of marriage establishes a new family, which forms the nucleus of modern society, it has for many years been said that it is one of the most fundamental and most important components of society. For this reason marriage has always been defined as a sacred phenomenon that must be protected, and it has been accepted that the spouses must refrain from any conduct by which the marriage might be harmed.

Proceeding from this idea, conduct that would constitute a breach of the duty of fidelity between spouses, and any conduct that makes the continuation of the marriage difficult, have been regulated as a ground for divorce by many legal systems.

Where the marriage has been shaken to its foundations to such a degree that one of the parties cannot be expected to continue the common life, this is a general ground for divorce.

This also covers every kind of unforeseeable conduct between the spouses that is harmful to the duty of fidelity.

Although we try to solve the problems that have emerged with today’s developing technology by means of these existing rules, at some points it is not possible to provide an answer.

Can one of the spouses having a relationship with a sex robot be regarded as a breach of the duty of fidelity? In order to be able to speak of a breach of the duty of fidelity, must the relationship be entered into only with another human being?

It is clear that an emotional and sexual relationship with a sex robot cannot be equated with a woman’s use of a vibrator.

For there is a difference between the other party being with a robot and using a sexual object, and the two do not have the same effect on the other spouse.

Where a spouse spends time outside with a sex robot, the concern that the other spouse’s dignity may be harmed is highly likely to arise. Can the marital union be continued for a party who has a spouse involved in such a relationship with a sex robot?

SEXUAL HARASSMENT OR ASSAULT OF SEX ROBOTS BY HUMANS: WILL SEX ROBOTS BE CAPABLE OF BEING VICTIMS OF SEXUAL OFFENCES?

The offence of sexual assault regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK) means that, through sexual assaults, a person’s physical inviolability

is violated. For the offence to be made out, the person’s physical inviolability must have been violated by conduct aimed at satisfying sexual desires. The legal interest protected by the offence is first and foremost the victim’s sexual freedom, within the scope of sexual inviolability, and thereafter his physical and mental integrity and inviolability. While the victim of the offence of sexual assault must be a person, no distinction is made as to the characteristics of that person. Accordingly, the perpetrator may commit the offence against anyone, woman or man, young or old. At this point, however, it must be borne in mind that where the victim is under the age of eighteen, it is not the offence of sexual assault but the offence of sexual abuse that will be made out.

Sexual harassment, for its part, is the performance of disturbing acts with a sexual purpose which are directed at a person’s sexuality, whether verbal or written, and which do not involve physical contact. As regards the victim, it does not differ in any way from the offence of sexual assault. As for the protected legal interest, while this is in the first place sexual freedom, it is also important to prevent individuals from being disturbed and thereby to ensure that they live in peace and tranquillity. The criterion that distinguishes these two offences from each other is that, in the offence of sexual harassment, the victim’s

physical inviolability is not violated. Here there is no contact of any kind with the victim’s body.

Where a person finds a sex robot very beautiful or sexy and is greatly attracted to it, and even, having become aroused, strokes the legs of this robot in order to satisfy his sexual desires, takes out and displays his sexual organ without making bodily contact with the robot, or says “I am burning, I am melting for you” while passing by the robot, a number of questions arise as to how these acts are to be assessed:

First, was the act which the person carried out by stroking the robot’s legs carried out with the robot’s consent or without its consent?

For it is clear that, for the offence of sexual assault to be made out, there must be no consent on the part of the other party. But can one speak of the consent of a sex robot?

If robots are built that have the ability to choose their own partner or to reject a person who desires them, it may be said that one must also speak of the consent of these robots.

For protection to be afforded in respect of an act carried out with or without the consent of the sex robot, there must be a legal interest. For the offence of sexual assault, in which the protected legal interest is the victim’s sexual freedom and physical and mental

integrity, to be made out, the sex robot’s sexual freedom must also be recognised. But can one speak of the bodily integrity of a sex robot? Can the robot’s mental health be impaired and its mental integrity harmed as a result of the act? When we turn to the offence of sexual harassment, which also envisages the interest of ensuring that individuals are not disturbed and live in peace, can it be said that the robot’s peace has been disturbed as a result of the acts in question? If we accept that this is so, harm will have been done to the interest which the Code seeks to protect, but a problem will arise as regards the material elements of the offence.

Given that sex robots are in any case created for the purpose of satisfying people’s sexual desires, whether acts carried out against these robots would be unlawful is another point that needs to be discussed. It is clear that the situation is not comparable to our being free to buy a pen, which is made for writing, and to write with it as we please. Similarly, it cannot be said that the situation is like that of a woman who, wishing to satisfy her sexual desires, buys a vibrator and can do what she wants with it. From this point of view, then, a sex

robot cannot be regarded as an ordinary object. When we look at the situation from the standpoint of human beings, the example may be given of a person who practises the profession of medicine in order to treat patients being forced, say, to carry out an examination or an operation.

Can a person be forced to do the work in question merely because he chose the medical profession for that very purpose? Within the scope of this example, I reserve the provisions on the physician’s obligations to provide treatment.

It is not possible to say that either of the two examples given, the one with regard to things and the other with regard to human beings, fully

captures the situation. Although the sex robot bears humanoid characteristics and has the ability to reject a person who desires it, to accept, solely in view of the purpose for which it was created,

that the act is lawful is not, in my view, a justified approach. It may be that the situation should be resolved first according to the legal status of robots and then according to the characteristics that the sex robot possesses.

Today, when robots are being produced with ever more diverse features, mention must also be made of the possibility of these robots being coerced in respect of a particular stage for the sake of sexual relations. An example on this point is the sex robot Samantha, produced by the Spanish engineer Sergi Santos, which cannot • switch to sexual mode without passing through the stages of romance and foreplay. In such a scenario, how may forcing Samantha to have intercourse without giving her the romance she wants be defined?

By what act could Samantha become what kind of element of which offence?

The sex robots whose capacity to be victims we have discussed up to this point are the classic robots that come to mind when robots are mentioned in general. However, the development of technology is not limited to this. Alongside robots with a classic appearance, child sex robots, envisaged mainly for the treatment of paedophilia patients, and robots designed in the shape of animals are also being made.

Whether these robots can be victims where the acts that constitute sexual offences are committed against them must be discussed separately.

The idea of using child sex robots for the treatment of paedophilia patients has attracted a great deal of criticism. The great majority of the criticism is to the effect that such use, rather than treating patients, will increase paedophilia and be used as a means of encouragement. If child sex robots emerge and the acts constituting the offences defined above

are committed against these robots, will the offence of sexual abuse be made out, and will the child robot be capable of being the victim of that offence?

On the assumption that we move to a world of robots recognised by the legal order, this will give rise to a horrific era in which there are child sex workers.

First of all, I should state that I am opposed to child sex robots for various physical and psychological reasons. Even though they are envisaged for the purpose of treating the illness, I agree with the criticisms made on the subject and am of the opinion that such a method of treatment cannot produce positive results and, moreover, cannot be accepted as lawful.

The first reason for this is that, at the present time, when artificially intelligent entities are not yet accepted as persons and have not fully acquired the status of victim, it is society itself that is the victim. Robot though it may be, making an entity with the appearance of a child the object of sex must not be accepted in any way. The destructive effect and consequences of such a situation for society cannot be avoided.

From the other angle, in a future in which robots possess artificial intelligence in the true sense and one can speak of the attributes of consciousness, will and emotion, the use of these child robots in any way as sex

robots, even for the purpose of treatment, cannot be accepted as compatible with morality and the law. In that case the child robot with artificial intelligence will, just like a human being, have a consciousness and be able to feel.

Thus the victim will be both the child robot, on account of its humanoid characteristics, and society.

For these reasons, I take a firm stance against the production and use of robots with the appearance of a child as sex robots, whatever the reason may be.

To this end, the making of child sex robots must first of all be prevented. Thereafter, where persons unlawfully produce a child sex robot, the individuals who make up society or the robots themselves should, depending on the characteristics of these robots, be accepted as the victim.

The use of these robots as sex robots after they have been produced may also be regulated as a separate type of offence or as an aggravated (qualified) form of the offence of production.

Another type of robot designed differently from the classic image that first comes to mind when robots are mentioned is robots in the shape of animals.

Today, sexual assaults committed by humans against animals are regarded as one of the most shameful aspects of humanity, and such incidents are, unfortunately,

something we encounter frequently. The growing importance of animal rights has given rise to the idea that attacks on animals must be subject to serious sanctions. For this reason work on the subject has begun in our country too, albeit belatedly, and a bill for an Animal Protection Law has recently been submitted to parliament. In this period, in which preventive work against attacks on animals is being carried out and the importance of animal rights is being recognised more with each passing day, it must also be debated whether the production of sex robots made in the shape of animals and the use of these robots by humans can be accepted as lawful in view of their possible effects and consequences for society. If it is assessed as unlawful, will the animal-shaped sex robot be capable of being accepted as a victim? This question, too, of course needs to be answered.

SEXUAL HARASSMENT OR ASSAULT OF HUMANS BY SEX ROBOTS: WILL SEX ROBOTS BE CAPABLE OF BEING PERPETRATORS OF SEXUAL OFFENCES?

In the Continental European legal system, which is accepted today and is also in force in our country, according to the

theory of the offence the perpetrator of an offence can only be a natural person. The same is true of the offences of sexual assault and sexual harassment.

The existing legal system is unable to provide an answer to sex robots being involved in any way in any sexual offence. Consequently, as matters stand today, the answer to this question is essentially that sex robots cannot be perpetrators of the offence of sexual assault. For this reason, under this heading I shall make my assessments in the context not of the legal order as it is but of the legal order as it ought to be.

If we proceed on the assumption that a robot has come into being which, irrespective of the purpose for which it was created, is capable of learning by itself and possesses, even if only in part, consciousness and will, the following steps must be gone through in order to determine whether this robot can be a perpetrator of sexual offences:

First, it must be examined whether artificially intelligent entities and robots have been defined, and their legal status determined, by the Constitution and the Civil Code.

Whether they can be perpetrators can be foreseen according to the classification to which they are made subject. For example, if robots are made the subject of statutory provisions but, in a manner similar to the distinction between immovables and movables, are classified as a thing,

it is not possible for them to be perpetrators of the offence.

It must be determined whether the act or acts giving rise to the offence took place upon a command given to the robot or by the robot’s own conscious will.

There must be a difference between a robot touching, of its own desire and will, a man by whose muscles it is greatly impressed and its acting upon its owner’s command to touch a woman whom the owner finds beautiful. Where the robot carries out the act constituting the offence entirely of its own consciousness and desire, without receiving any order, advice or command, it is possible to accept it as the perpetrator, whereas where it carries out the offence upon the command of another person, one cannot speak of perpetration in the full sense. In both cases the position of the robot is open to debate. In the second case, where the advice and suggestions of another are involved, might instigation come into question? Where the person giving the command and the robot carry out the acts constituting the offence together, can each of them be accepted as a co-perpetrator?

Or is it a case of perpetration because the robot’s will has been brought under influence? And in the last scenario, is the robot merely a simple instrument in the commission of the offence?

The possible scenarios could be multiplied with different examples.

In order to answer all these questions, it is first necessary to clarify the nature of the act of the artificially intelligent entity in the commission of the offence. Thereafter it must be determined whether the artificially intelligent entity can be a perpetrator and, if it can, what kinds of sanctions, consistent with the general principles of the law developed in respect of this entity, may be applied.

As can be seen, where artificially intelligent entities and crime are concerned, the topics of the theory of the offence on which criminal lawyers have for years engaged in profound debate and sought solutions – such as the act, the causal link, the mental element, fault and culpability – and legal philosophy’s problem of whether the will is free, together with the answers given to them, need to be redefined.

Consequently, any study to be carried out on the criminal responsibility of artificially intelligent entities must cover these fundamental topics and debates of criminal law.

CAN SEX ROBOTS BE USED IN PREVENTING THE OFFENCE OF HUMAN TRAFFICKING?

Another of the uses currently envisaged for sex robots is

the prevention of the offence of trafficking in women. It is a known fact that one of the greatest problems of our day is that women are forcibly held and made to work for the purpose of prostitution. The annual number of victims of the offence of human trafficking worldwide has reached millions. And 90% of these victims are women and children between the ages of 15 and 26 who are held for the purpose of prostitution. However severe the sanctions introduced to curb these rates, it is unfortunately not possible, as with any unlawful conduct, to prevent this entirely. It is also known that people are prepared to risk many sanctions for the sake of their sexual pleasures. Moreover, very high economic gains are at stake in this cycle of trade, and this plays an encouraging role for people. With the advent of sex robots, the possibility has come to mind that they could be used to prevent the offence of trafficking in women and could be a solution to this situation. Having regard to the present nature of artificially intelligent entities, the use of robots produced for this purpose appears more appropriate in terms of the balance of interests than the use of women and children. The reintegration into society of a woman or child after such severe traumas • is hardly possible.

However, for sex robots, which are not conscious of this situation and whose very purpose of production is the satisfaction of sexual feelings, there is no question of traumatic consequences of this kind arising.

For this reason, it may be possible for the spread of the use of sex robots for people’s sexual satisfaction to have a positive effect on the prevention of trafficking in women.

Thanks to the sex robots they own, people will not harm women or children and will not use them for the purpose of prostitution.

At the stage technology has reached today, the use of sex robots in place of women may be preferable, but this will in all likelihood change as technology advances. If the humanoid robots envisaged with developing technology are developed and these robots acquire personality just like human beings, the balance of interests we have struck will not be able to provide a solution to the problem.

In that case the sexual inviolability of the robot, too, must be accepted as a value to be protected, just like that of a human being.

Moreover, even if we as human beings do not accept this, what shall we do when a robot capable of claiming its rights stands before us and demands its sexual freedom?

On the other hand, as regards sex robots,

another development that sounds quite astonishing is that these robots work in brothels as workers. Although when first heard of it is perceived as an impossible practice, this is not merely an idea but a reality that has already been put into practice. In Spain, England, Germany, the Netherlands, Austria and Russia, brothels in which only sex robots provide services have been opened and have begun operating. Demand for these brothels comes not only from men but also from women.

It is also observed that women who are afraid of being cheated on choose the sex robots working in these brothels for their husbands. The sex robots working in these brothels are not simple and featureless; on the contrary, they also possess various abilities.

Henry in England, thanks to the love poems he can recite in addition to the conversation and jokes he makes, works for a jaw-dropping price, while the sex robots that have gone into operation in Russia may have heating systems that regulate their body temperature and vibration mechanisms.

The presence of sex robots instead of women in these brothels – in that it will reduce the number of sexually transmitted diseases and that women will no longer be used as sex objects –

is said to have its advantages.

Conducting research on cyberculture and cybersexuality at the University of Portsmouth, Dr

Trudy Barber argues that people will, after a while, meet their need for sex with robots.

I should state that I am not opposed to brothels made up of sex robots and, moreover, that I think these brothels will become widespread over time.

As I mentioned above, this may be more advantageous than brothels made up of human beings in respects such as health and the prevention of certain offences. The sexual desires of people who will derive more pleasure from being with sex robots must also be borne in mind. Considering that there are people who wish to spend time with sex robots, to be with them and to have sexual intercourse with them, would taking a stance against brothels made up of sex robots not be conduct of a kind that infringes the rights and freedoms of these people?

For these reasons, I think that the State and the companies that produce sex robots may adopt a supportive attitude on the matter.

Although the cost of owning a sex robot is very high for the time being, a scenario awaits us in which these robots will in time become part of every area of our lives and in which passing a robot while walking about outside,

or waiting in a queue together with one, will no longer be very strange. The increase in production and demand will naturally bring the cost down as well. In this way people will be able to use sex robots easily and satisfy their sexual desires in this manner. And the provision of brothel services by robot sex workers rather than by real human beings will, at least for a certain time, be a more beneficial approach.

WHAT SOLUTION SHOULD BE PURSUED IN RESPONSE TO ALL THESE PROBLEMS CONCERNING SEX ROBOTS?

At a time when artificial intelligence has taken such a hold on our lives, and when we can hardly get through a single day without using applications written with artificial intelligence algorithms, it is an inescapable fact that artificially intelligent entities will enter our lives in the same way. Just as we cannot now manage without the artificial intelligence applications we use, is it not possible that the day will come when we are unable to go on with our lives without robots? Yet if we had been told beforehand that the artificial intelligences which we ourselves now use would enter our lives to this extent, and that we would adapt to them in this way, how credible

would it have sounded?

It is predicted that, as a result of these rapid developments in technology, artificial intelligence will reach a highly advanced point.

Indeed, in the period in which we are now living, advanced artificial intelligence programs are already being coded and various robots equipped with artificial intelligence are being produced. As a result, questions arise as to how artificially intelligent entities will be reflected in the world of law and how the legal status of these entities will be determined.

As robots have, over time, come to be produced as sex robots in order to satisfy people’s sexual desires, various problems are arising in relation to sex robots as well.

As I explained in detail above, the use of sex robots has given rise to many physical, psychological, social and societal question marks. It is not known what course should be followed where these robots are used as instruments of crime, where they are programmed and produced in order to prevent various offences and, finally, where they commit an offence. In order to be able to answer these questions and arrive at the right solution, I think that, with regard to technology and artificial intelligence and in parallel with technological developments, work must begin at the level of law, ethical principles must be determined and legislation

must be enacted. My view as to the legal principles on which these regulations should be based and the form they should take is, in order of priority, as follows:

First of all, the subject must be addressed in the context of constitutional law. Here the legal status of artificially intelligent entities should be defined and their fundamental rights and freedoms clearly determined.

Next, civil law, which is the foundation of the law, should come into play. A heading along the lines of a “law of artificially intelligent entities”, similar to the law of persons, should be provided for, and under this heading provisions should be laid down on the beginning and end of the existence of artificially intelligent entities and on family law, the law of succession and the law of property.

I am of the opinion that criminal law should follow next in this order. It should be made clear what is to be done in a criminal law dispute in which artificially intelligent entities are involved, and how and by what criteria their responsibility is to be established.

Lastly, since artificially intelligent entities will have social, economic and cultural relations and activities, regulation is also needed in other branches of law such as commercial law, labour law and the law of obligations. Indeed, when one thinks of robots with artificial intelligence that have been granted citizenship, it is possible to say that even international

law must come into play.

Once robots have been defined, regulated and determined in general terms by means of legal instruments, work should be carried out specifically on the characteristics of these robots. Sex robots are among the types of robot that need to have special rules of their own.

Many of the debates which I examined above, and in which I pointed out the question marks surrounding the possible problems that I foresee, exist only in relation to sex robots.

For this reason, after the general provisions, special provisions on sex robots should be enacted on the points where those general provisions prove insufficient.

WHAT APPROACH SHOULD BE ADOPTED NOW THAT SEX ROBOTS HAVE ENTERED OUR LIVES?

The fact that sexuality is, contrary to what is assumed, of considerable psychological, physical and social importance in our lives and is defined as a form of expression of a person’s own personality, and the fact that sex robots appeal to people’s sexual desires, place sex robots in a position quite different from that of other robots. Although various objects have been used throughout human history, the creation of sex robots marked a first, and it became possible for people to enter with these robots into

an emotional and sexual relationship. Given that in many societies even sexuality between human beings has been all but mythologised into a taboo and turned into an area that must not be spoken of, the sexual life of humans and robots may well be rejected, and research and debate on the subject avoided. Yet fleeing from technological developments and acting as though they did not exist will not benefit us; on the contrary, it will cause us to fall behind. Since sex robots have now become an inescapable reality, they must be examined in depth, with their benefits and harms, from every angle and from the standpoint of every scientific discipline.

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic