15 May 2018Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

Article 16(2) of the Law on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) established the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry, known for short as “VERBİS”. The same article stated that exemptions from the obligation to register with the data controllers’ registry could be introduced, and that both the establishment and operation of the registry and what the exemptions would be were to be set out in a regulation to be issued. Article 15 of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry, issued for this purpose, set out the cases in which an exemption applies, and Article 16 set out the exemption criteria.

Article 16(2) of the Regulation stated that the Board has the power to take decisions in order to determine the scope of the exemptions set within the framework of the criteria listed in the first paragraph and the procedures and principles for their application, and that the Board would announce its decisions to the public by publishing them through appropriate means. In all sectors that have to plan for the protection of personal data, and among all those concerned with this subject, there had long been an expectation that the exemptions would be published. The Board’s decision on this matter, dated 2 April 2018 and numbered 2018/32, was published in the Official Gazette of 15 May 2018, No. 30422. In this article I will examine the salient points of that decision.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

Article 16(2) of the “Law on the Protection of Personal Data” (KVKK) laid down the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry, known for short as “VERBİS”. The same article stated that exceptions might be introduced to the obligation to register with the data controllers’ registry and that both the establishment and operation of the registry and what the exceptions would be were to be governed by a regulation to be issued. Article 15 of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry, issued for that purpose, set out the cases in which an exception would apply, and Article 16 the criteria for exceptions. Article 16(2) of the Regulation stated that the Board has the power to adopt decisions in order to determine the scope of the exceptions established within the framework of the criteria listed in the first paragraph and the procedures and principles for their application, and that the Board would make its decisions known to the public by publishing them through appropriate means. In all sectors that have to plan for the protection of personal data, and among all those concerned with this subject, there had long been an expectation that the exceptions would be published. The Board’s decision on this matter, dated 2.4.2018 and numbered 2018/32, was published in the Official Gazette of 15 May 2018, No. 30422. In this article I shall examine the salient points of that decision.

List Annexed to the Decision, Article 1

Under this provision, “those who process personal data solely by non-automated means, provided that the processing forms part of a data filing system” have been exempted from the obligation to register with VERBİS. The meaning of this article can be derived by looking at the definition of the concept of “processing of personal data” in Article 3(1)(e) of the KVKK, Law No. 6698. According to that definition, “any operation performed on personal data … wholly or partly by automated means or, provided that it forms part of a data filing system, by non-automated means” constitutes data processing. The same provision is also found in Article 4(1)(i) of the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry.

When this exception is read together with the definition of processing of personal data in the Law and the relevant Regulation, the conclusion is that all controllers who process “personal data by wholly or partly automated means” are required to register with VERBİS. They cannot in any way escape the obligation to register with VERBİS; consequently, they are also under an obligation, pursuant to the Regulation, to draw up a Personal Data Inventory.

Where data are processed without forming part of any data filing system, on the other hand, there has in any event never been, from the very outset, an obligation to register with VERBİS under either the Law or the Regulation. For under these provisions, in order for there to be data processing, the operation must, even where it is carried out by non-automated means, be carried out as part of a data filing system. If there is no data processing linked to a data filing system, there is no personal data processing activity within the meaning of Law No. 6698 either, and accordingly it is not possible to speak of the obligations imposed by the Law.

For whom, then, has this exception been introduced? The exception has been introduced for those who process data “solely” by non-automated means, albeit as part of a particular data filing system. They are under no obligation to register with VERBİS. Frankly, it is not possible to understand exactly what is meant by this wording. In my view it is even debatable whether this is really an exception at all. Because, with today’s developing and ever cheaper information-processing technology solutions, virtually even the kiosk on the corner or the neighbourhood butcher keeps its credit ledger or its customers’ contact details on a computer in an “excel” spreadsheet. This shows both that there is a data filing system and that the data are processed automatically (and indeed digitally). Even where a small business does not use a computer but keeps a customer list in a card index or in an index arranged by initial letters, this shows that a kind of system and automation exists. It is therefore quite difficult to find a controller that would genuinely fall within this exception. At most, the small tradesmen-repairers in industrial estates may not use systems of this kind.

Indeed, the general view and expectation among those active in this field and among controllers was that a limitation would be drawn according to either the number of employees or annual turnover, and that controllers below a certain number of employees and/or annual turnover would be kept within the scope of the exception. However, according to the decision published today, it can be seen that the Board has, “at least for now”, taken no such approach. The exception in Article 1 introduces a limitation in a very narrow area and brings only a limited number of controllers within the scope of the exception.

This Decision will undoubtedly have its most significant impact on SMEs. In our country a large part of the real sector consists of SMEs. On that side there were expectations that they would be, or ought to be, kept within the scope of the exception. It is apparent, however, that controllers of this size, too, are obliged to register with VERBİS and, most importantly, to draw up a Personal Data Inventory. This entails a certain cost in terms of time, effort and money alike. The process will be troublesome particularly for SMEs which lack sufficient resources, or are reluctant to obtain outside consultancy on this matter, or have no resources to devote to it. I observe that controllers above a certain size have either completed the compliance process, or are continuing it, or are at the stage of obtaining quotations in order to start it; among SMEs, however, there is an understandable hesitancy owing to the expectation that they would be counted within the scope of the exception. This decision thus serves as an important warning for dispelling that hesitancy.

I think this situation will have two important effects:

• First, this situation will put a strain on the VERBİS system from a technical standpoint. For, because the scope of the exception has been kept very narrow, a large number of controllers are obliged to register with the system. It is therefore necessary both to provide adequate technical infrastructure for this and, given the sheer numbers, to set a sufficient period for registration. Otherwise it will be inevitable that the system will frequently crash and cease to function. I believe, however, that the Board has also considered these matters and will take the necessary measures accordingly. To this end,

the solutions that first come to mind as possible proposals are the issuing over time of block exemption communiqués, as in competition law, or the balancing and reduction of the workload by successive postponements for particular scales, as in the field of occupational health and safety.

• The second consequence concerns the solutions as to how SMEs will carry out the process of compliance with the KVKK. At present both the consultancy fees and the software offered for controllers’ compliance with the KVKK are very high. For, since this is skilled work, the man-day cost both of the consultancy and of the software produced for it remains at a very high level. I think, however, that the consultancy and IT sectors will soon find a solution to this and will produce solutions which combine these two services, leave to automation those parts of the work where that is possible, require consultancy services for its specialised parts, lower costs by reducing the number of man-days, and thus also address SMEs and are accessible to them. In this way it will be possible for small-scale controllers to fulfil the responsibilities imposed by the Law on a low budget, and to create an ecosystem in which all actors within the scope of the Law are compliant with the process from end to end.

Without this ecosystem, it is not possible for the KVKK and the system of personal data protection it envisages to function. Indeed, this process unfolded in a similar way in Europe. On the other hand, the fact that a controller is brought within the scope of the exception as regards the obligation to register with VERBİS in no way means that it is also exempted from the other obligations imposed by the Law and the Regulations (for example, the obligation to inform or ensuring data security). Unless a separate exception has been laid down for the other obligations, they apply in full.

List Annexed to the Decision, Articles 2, 4, 5 and 6

In these articles notaries, political parties, attorneys, certified public accountants and sworn-in certified public accountants have been brought within the scope of the exception.

• Notaries: Notaries operating in accordance with the Notaries Law No. 1512 of 18.1.1972 hold and process a large quantity of personal data. Notaries carry out these activities on the basis of provisions contained both in their own law and in various other laws (for example the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK), the Civil Code (MK), the Code of Obligations (BK), etc.), and they record and process the data in question in that context. In addition, notaries, who operate under the Ministry of Justice and under the umbrella of the Union of Notaries, attach importance to data security because they carry on an extremely sensitive activity founded on the establishment of trust. They are, moreover, regularly inspected by the Ministry of Justice. In my view it was an appropriate approach to bring notaries, who have not been exempted as regards the other obligations, within the scope of the exception in this respect.

• Political Parties:

Political parties, which are established and operate under the Political Parties Law No. 2820 of 22.4.1983 and are indispensable elements of democracy, hold a large quantity of personal data and special categories of personal data relating to party members and electoral rolls. It is difficult to understand and to explain why political parties, which process these data haphazardly, transfer them and do not erase them, have been brought within the scope of the exception. Political rather than practical reasons must lie behind this. As I am not a politician, I prefer not to express a view on the matter.

• Attorneys: Attorneys practising under the Attorneyship Law No. 1136 of 19.3.1969 have also been listed among the exceptions to the obligation to register with VERBİS. Those who practise the profession of attorney store and process a large quantity of personal data in the files and computers in their offices, whether the dispute is one of criminal law, private law or administrative law. In disputes concerning divorce, child abuse, sexual assault or obscenity in particular, the data involved are generally special categories of personal data. Owing to the opening of a large number of law faculties in our country in recent years, to the fact that these faculties graduate everyone who enrols without performing any filtering function, to the fact that the bar associations take no initiative whatsoever in this regard and accept the application of every law-faculty graduate and grant a licence to practise, and to the fact that no review of competence and proficiency is ever carried out within the profession either, there has been an explosion in the number of attorneys in our country, and especially in Istanbul, over the last ten years. By exempting this professional group, a significant number of controllers have been kept from entering the system. In any event, Article 5(2)(e) of the KVKK (Law No. 6698) lists as one of the exceptions to obtaining explicit consent the case where “data processing is necessary for the establishment, exercise or protection of a right”. Accordingly, just as attorneys are not obliged to obtain explicit consent in order to process data, so their obligation to register with VERBİS has also been removed by the decision in question. This is not, however, a privilege granted to attorneys but a requirement of the profession they practise. The other obligations imposed by the Law and the Regulations, for their part, apply to attorneys just as they do to other controllers.

• Certified Public Accountants and Sworn-in Certified Public Accountants: Certified public accountants and sworn-in certified public accountants practising under Law No. 3568 of 1.6.1989 on Certified Public Accountancy and Sworn-in Certified Public Accountancy have also been listed among the exceptions to the obligation to register with VERBİS. These members of the liberal professions, too, provide technical support to natural and legal persons liable to tax in fulfilling those obligations and in making payments such as their tax debts to the State or insurance contributions. In order to be able to provide this support/service, this professional group holds a large quantity of personal data for reasons arising from various laws. Again, as with attorneys, this professional group is numerically large. In this way the obligation of a large number of members of the profession to register with VERBİS has been removed. As far as this professional group is concerned, the other obligations arising from Law No. 6698 continue to apply.

List Annexed to the Decision, Article 3

I think that this article contains provisions that need to be read carefully. Under it, “those associations established under the Associations Law No. 5253 of 4.11.2004, foundations established under the Foundations Law No. 5737 of 20.2.2008 and trade unions established under Law No. 6356 of 18.10.2012 on Trade Unions and Collective Labour Agreements which process personal data only within the limits of the relevant legislation and of fields of activity consistent with their purposes and only in respect of their own employees, members, affiliates and donors” have been exempted from the obligation to register with VERBİS.

Accordingly, for associations, foundations or trade unions to fall within the scope of the exception, so that they are not required to fulfil this obligation, three conditions must be met cumulatively. The first is that the personal data they process be limited to the legislation relevant to these legal persons; the second, that they be limited to fields of activity consistent with their purposes; and the third, that only personal data concerning their own employees, affiliates and donors be processed. If even one of these conditions is not met, the legal person concerned must register with VERBİS.

The question to be asked here is this: should any one of these legal persons happen to process personal data outside these limits (for example, where one of its suppliers is a natural person or, even if it is a legal person, where records of its representative are kept), the obligation to register with VERBİS, and hence the requirement to draw up a personal data inventory, will arise. In that case, is the personal data inventory to be drawn up for all personal data or only for the data falling outside the exception? The answer to this question will also answer the question of which data are to be registered in VERBİS. Moreover, should such a possibility materialise, how functional will it be to draw up an inventory and conduct a compliance process for only a few data or a very small quantity of personal data?

CONCLUSION

Although this decision of the Personal Data Protection Board had long been awaited by those concerned with the subject, so that they could be sure whether or not they were obliged to register with VERBİS, I think that the decision has given rise to new questions rather than answers. I should state first of all that, contrary to what was expected, the scope of the exceptions has been kept extremely narrow. Provided that it is not widened over time, I think this is a positive decision in terms of the rapid formation of the ecosystem for the protection of personal data. At the same time, however, I foresee that in the short term it may lead to difficulties and various practical problems in implementation.

What matters here above all is the situation of SMEs in particular, which have not been brought within the exception. I think it is essential that the consultancy and IT sectors produce, for these entities, which are already under a host of financial burdens and form the backbone of the economy, solutions that rely more on automation and thereby reduce the number of man-days and the cost.

As for the exception introduced for associations, foundations and trade unions, I think that it brings with it a great many question marks and is not very functional.

I hope that the Board’s new decisions and examples from practice will prove these concerns of mine unfounded and that a system emerges with which we all comply and which we all apply with ease. In this way an ecosystem will emerge in which personal data are protected and the principles and rules are applied with ease.

Footnotes

  1. Academic/Attorney-at-law. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic