2013Murat Volkan DülgerArticle

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

Today, with the increase in the scale and variety of surgical interventions that can be carried out on human beings in particular, the need for a new approach to the question of the lawfulness of such medical interventions has begun to be felt. By the nature of their profession, physicians interfere with a person’s bodily integrity, and by their conduct they may even either save the person’s life or cause the person’s death. Determining which act or omission of the physician, at which moment, will constitute lawful or unlawful conduct is of the utmost importance for criminal law.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Asst. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger**

Today, particularly with the growth in the scale and variety of the surgical interventions that can be performed on human beings, the need for a new approach to the problem of the lawfulness of medical interventions of this kind has begun to be felt. By the nature of their profession, physicians interfere with a person’s bodily integrity and may indeed, by their conduct, either bring about the saving of the person’s life or cause his death. Determining at which moment the performance or non-performance of which act by the physician will constitute lawful or unlawful conduct is of the utmost importance from the standpoint of criminal law.

A person who is competent under the law (this varies according to the circumstances, but in general terms it may be said to mean being of full age and having the capacity of discernment) has the right to decide what is to be done to his body and must not be compelled to undergo any intervention against his will. It is assumed that the physician and health-care staff know what is best for the patient in line with the interests of the person being examined or treated. One of the most fundamental principles of medical ethics is that persons are able to assess what is best for themselves. At this point the principle of informed consent assumes importance. That is to say, in the relationship between physician and patient/participant, the participant’s consent to take part in the research/the proposed treatment must be obtained after he has been given the necessary information on the matter. Once sufficiently informed, the participant/patient declares whether or not he consents to the treatment, for only in this way can he decide what is best for himself. This decision that the person takes with regard to his own body is, of course, not valid unconditionally. Under the legislation, which is framed according to the social, moral, economic, psychological and ethical conditions of the period in question, certain acts are prohibited by law and the breach of the prohibition is made subject to a sanction.

In the light of the developments in present-day medical science, entirely new problems have emerged beyond the classical problems of this field and of the law. In particular, the development of technology, the increase in opportunities for travel and the emergence of a new sector called health tourism can turn people’s search for a cure into a nightmare and place them in the position of victims. Proceeding from this perspective, our study examines and seeks to assess, in turn, the current national situation, the international dimension and the lawfulness/unlawfulness of a number of health services provided across borders, such as the organ trade, sperm banks and surrogate motherhood.

The Organ Trade - Since We Consider That Human Organs and Tissues Cannot Be the Subject of Trade, We Do Not Find It Necessary to State Separately That It Is Unlawful

In biology an organ is defined as a group of tissues performing a specific function or set of functions, and a tissue as the totality of cells forming one of the structural elements of a body or an organ. Organ transplantation is the procedure of transferring, in place of an organ that is unable to perform its function in the body, a healthy organ taken from a living donor or from a dead person which will assume the same function. Organ transplantation is today accepted as a valid method of treatment for many advanced-stage organ diseases. The number of people awaiting an organ transplant in our country is very high. The lack of a sufficient number of donors to meet this need drives patients awaiting an organ to buy organs, while also driving persons in economic hardship to sell organs. The situation is no different worldwide. It is a known fact that wealthy dialysis patients, particularly where the organ trade is prohibited by law and subject to a sanction in their own countries, travel the world for an organ transplant; that the British and the Germans go to India, the Japanese to the USA, and North Americans to Peru and Brazil; and that this trade is professionally organised under the name of “medical tourism”.

Under Article 17(2) of the 1982 Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye, “Except in cases of medical necessity and in the cases prescribed by law, the bodily integrity of the person may not be interfered with; he or she may not be subjected to scientific and medical experiments without his or her consent”. Accordingly, the manner in which organ transplants are to be carried out is regulated in our law by Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues (ODNK). The ODNK contains a provision headed prohibited acts. Under Art. 15 ODNK, “Those who remove, store, graft and transplant organs and tissues in a manner contrary to this Law, and those who buy and sell them, act as intermediaries in their purchase and sale or act as brokers therein, shall be sentenced, unless the deed requires a heavier penalty, to imprisonment from two years to four years and to a heavy fine from 50,000 liras to 100,000 liras”. In addition, in the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK) the offences relating to the subject in question are regulated in Art. 91 et seq. Within the scope of application of the provisions of the TCK, which has the character of the later law, it is the provisions of the TCK, and not Art. 15 ODNK, that are applied. However, since Art. 91 TCK lays down the criminal sanction relating to the matter without determining the conditions for the transplantation of organs and tissues, the regulation in the ODNK is valid as regards the conditions for the transplantation of organs and tissues. Moreover, for acts that are regulated in the ODNK but not in the TCK, the sanction provision in Art. 15 ODNK is used. For example, inquiring and ascertaining, under Art. 7(d) ODNK, where the donor is married, whether the spouse with whom he lives is aware of the donor’s decision to donate an organ or tissue, and recording in a report that this has been ascertained; or, under Art. 7(f) ODNK, not disclosing the names of the recipient and the donor, save in cases where relationships of kinship by blood or by marriage or close personal relationships exist; or, pursuant to Art. 10 ODNK, the removal, storage, grafting and transplantation of organs and tissues not being carried out by health institutions that have the specialist staff, equipment and materials necessary for these tasks.

Alongside these provisions, Türkiye has signed the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine (Council of Europe Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine) and, by Law No. 5013, published in the Official Gazette on 9.12.2003, approved the ratification of the said international convention, but entered a reservation to sub-paragraph 2 of Article 20 of the Convention on the ground that it was not compatible with Article 5 of the ODNK. The scope of the 2012 Regulation on Organ and Tissue Transplantation and of the relevant provisions of the TCK is explained in Article 2 of the ODNK. Accordingly, the removal, grafting and transplantation of autografts, hair and skin, and blood transfusion, do not fall within this scope and are to be carried out within the framework of the health legislation in force.

The basic distinction in the removal of organs or tissues is drawn between removal from the dead and removal from a living human being. Both in our country and in other countries, the rules on organ transplantation have been made subject to conditions that differ from one another. In our law, the prohibition on engaging in the trade in organs or tissues outside the scope that is permitted is contained in Arts. 91, 92 and 93 TCK. According to the findings yielded by the present level of development of medicine, the criterion for determining the moment of a human being’s death today is brain death, and from the moment brain death occurs one can no longer speak of a living being. Organ or tissue transplantation from a living person is likewise regulated by the provisions of the ODNK.

Under the heading “trade in organs and tissues”, Article 91 of the TCK regulates the acts of removing organs and tissues from a person without legally valid consent, unlawfully removing organs and tissues from a dead person, buying and selling organs and tissues and acting as an intermediary therein, storing, transporting or grafting organs and tissues obtained by unlawful means, and placing or publishing announcements or advertisements aimed at procuring organs or tissues in return for a specific benefit. The existence of a ground of justification for the procedure of removing an organ from the organ donor depends on the purpose of curing the recipient. Consent given for reasons other than this, or to interventions that are not proportionate to conformity with the purpose of cure, will not be valid. In this context the problem of the donation of organs and tissues for commercial purposes arises in particular. According to Article 21 of the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, “the human body and its parts may not, as such, be the subject of any commercial gain”. Indeed, the World Medical Association, too, at its 37th General Assembly held in Brussels in October 1985, condemned in a statement the sale of human organs for transplantation. This, however, does not apply to the person to whom the organ is transplanted. For even if this person has agreed to pay money in order to receive the organ, his real aim will be to save his health or life, and the validity of the consent given must therefore be accepted. However, where the organ removed is important for the donor’s continued life and the removal of the organ creates a disproportionate danger to that person’s health, the conclusion is likewise reached that the consent given to the organ transplant is contrary to law and morality. Since organ and tissue transplants are not directed at curing the donor, there is a consensus that in such cases the physician’s obligation to inform must be understood in its widest scope. Everything that could influence the donor’s decision must be disclosed, and nothing must be concealed.

Under Art. 3 ODNK, “The removal and sale of organs and tissues in return for a price or other benefit is prohibited”. The sanction for this prohibition is regulated in the TCK. Trading in organs and tissues is therefore prohibited in our law. It is the trade in kidneys that makes up a large part of the organ trade. Unfortunately, the buying and selling of kidneys has become very widespread in various countries of the world. This takes the form, in particular, of buying from a poor donor and selling to a rich recipient; in other words, of putting the poor at risk in order to restore the health of the wealthy recipient. Hundreds of kidney patients in the Arab countries and from South-East Asia go to India for transplantation. Over the years India has become one of the world’s centres of kidney transplantation, for prices are low and kidneys are plentiful. It has even come to be called the “kidney market” by physicians. A great many back-street/backroom clinics carrying on this trade have opened. What is more, clinics of this kind place advertisements in order to attract donors and, so as not to run into any legal obstacle, carry on this business under the name of the “rewarded gift”. Concepts such as the rewarded gift and rewarded donation are further problems brought about by the trade in organs and tissues. A rewarded gift or rewarded donation is a specific amount of material benefit offered to the donor in return for the organ he gives. The donor is rewarded in return for the donation made. In other words, it is the softened name for buying and selling in the organ trade. Particularly in countries situated in regions of the world such as India and the Far and Near East, where cadaveric organs are not available and there is a marked difference in wealth between the different sections of the population, and in countries such as China, Nepal, Egypt and Türkiye, the rapidly growing population has led to the development of the international trade in human organs. It is known that the organ trade has also increased in recent years in Russia, Romania and Moldova. As a result, a type of medical practice has emerged in which human kidneys are bought from poor and needy persons in order to be transplanted into a wealthy group of recipients and which yields high profits for brokers, private hospitals and doctors. These poor and needy persons who give their kidneys very often do not receive the consideration promised to them, which was meant to contribute at least a little to the economic situation that led them to sell their kidneys under the pressure of hardship, and are left with nothing but the loss of their kidneys. Under China’s “Regulation on Human Organ Transplantation”, for example, the persons who donate their organs may only be married couples or close relatives. For this reason, various intermediaries have sprung up in order to document with forged papers a closeness, in terms of these degrees of relationship, that does not exist in material reality.

The World Health Organization (WHO), which is affiliated to the United Nations, laid bare the horrifying point that organ trafficking has reached in a statement it made in mid-2012. According to the research carried out by the Organization, approximately ten thousand black-market kidney sales take place every year, which amounts to more than one kidney per hour. The Organization stated that the demand for the sale of kidneys has risen owing to the increase in diabetes and similar diseases. Stating that kidneys account for 75% of illegally transplanted organs, the Organization revealed that patients mostly undergo surgery in China, Pakistan and India and stated that recipients may pay up to 200 thousand dollars (367 thousand TL) for a single kidney. It stated that the amount paid to those who give their kidneys, by contrast, is at most 5 thousand dollars (9 thousand TL) and that the remainder of the money is shared between the intermediaries and the doctors. Moreover, since Türkiye is in the position of a transit country between rich and poor countries and is also in a very good position in terms of medical capability (in terms of hospitals and doctors), it is a preferred country in the choice of the country in which the operations are to be carried out.

There are three fundamental principles in organ transplantation from a living donor. First, the removal of an organ from the donor must not impair the donor’s health, life or functional integrity. Second, they must be volunteers acting of their own free will, without pressure or coercion to donate an organ. Third, the donor must be fully informed of the possible consequences and risks of the intervention.

In the system of the organ trade, most donors come from a section of society in which health and nutrition are already restricted owing to poverty and economic hardship. It is not realistic to say that, in the conditions in which they find themselves, these individuals possess a consent that is voluntary and uncoerced in the true sense. Moreover, in transplants carried out in the insanitary conditions of back-street operating theatres, without the medical knowledge and experience of the physicians performing the operation being questioned or known, it is highly probable that the donor’s health, the functional integrity of his organs and his life will be impaired. In addition, the donor is not sufficiently informed about the transplant; the wishes of donors who change their minds at the last moment are disregarded, and the donor’s organs are taken virtually by force, by means of superficial assurances to the effect that the operation is simple and on the pretext that, now that this path has been taken, there can be no turning back. Besides this, recipients too are at the mercy of hospitals and physicians as regards the costs, the selection of the donor and the quality of the assessments and examinations.

If the human body is accepted as a commodity that can be sold, like ordinary goods, for known and predetermined sums, corruption in society and an unjust and unfair system of access and distribution are invited, because in such a system the rich will always be on the receiving side and the poor on the giving side.

In order to prevent the organ trade, emphasis should be placed on cadaver-based transplant programmes, and the removal of organs from donors who, apart from living relatives, have no kinship or emotional closeness should be prevented on account of the danger of commercialisation. Both in the world at large and in Türkiye, one has to wait in very long queues for an organ transplant by lawful means, and very often one’s turn does not come before death. For this reason, recourse to the organ trade by illegal means is preferred. Individuals are reluctant to donate organs for religious, economic or social reasons. While there are a great many recipients waiting in line worldwide, it is difficult under these conditions to find lawful donors. Therefore, either people should be encouraged to donate organs, and this should be ensured both by the State and through NGOs, or organ donation from living human beings should be kept far more limited and organ transplantation carried out under strict supervision. Indeed, in 1987 the World Health Assembly voiced its concern about the trade for profit in human organs among living human beings and stated that this trade is incompatible with the most basic human values and contrary to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a product of the UN, and to the spirit of the Constitution of the World Health Organization.

The Sperm Bank – A Practice That Is Shunned and Not Permitted for Socio-Cultural Reasons but That, for This Very Reason, Leads to Recourse to Illegal Means and Drives Individuals to

Solutions Beyond the Border

The legal transaction that takes place when healthy sperm, whose capacity to fertilise has been proven beforehand by carrying out all the necessary tests, is stored by being frozen and subsequently given to a person/persons unable to have children is called sperm donation, and the centres in which this procedure is generally carried out are called sperm banks.

When a woman wishing to receive a sperm donation, or a clinic, applies to the bank, the bank explains the medical and legal conditions to the recipient, and the contract is concluded when the recipient accepts the conditions and makes the payment. The recipient makes a choice among the donors who do not wish to conceal their identity by looking at their photographs and all their personal information, and the bank sends the requested sperm to the clinic at which the recipient is to be treated. Those wishing to obtain sperm make their choice in accordance with the criteria they have determined, such as the sperm donor’s nationality, skin colour, eye colour, height, blood group and level of intelligence.

Under Art. 18 of the 2010 Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres, under the heading of prohibitions relating to the practice of assisted reproductive treatment methods, it is provided that donating sperm and opening a sperm bank are not legally possible in Türkiye.

However, those wishing to have a child by means of a sperm bank go abroad or have this procedure carried out within the country by illegal means. Although sperm donation is prohibited in our country, counselling services used to be provided to persons wishing to resort to this procedure abroad. With the amendment of the Regulation, however, becoming pregnant by means of sperm or eggs obtained from a sperm bank, using this method and recommending this method have also been prohibited. On the other hand, it is also alleged that illegal sperm banks exist in our country, and it is known that there are women who have given birth after buying sperm from countries such as Israel, Greece and Cyprus.

The Ministry of Health, which does not permit sperm banks on the ground of “protecting the Turkish lineage”, will also have to close the in vitro fertilisation centres that refer their patients to sperm banks abroad or encourage them to use them. A clinic that makes such a referral or acts as an intermediary will be closed for three months on the first occasion and indefinitely if it commits the same act a second time. The certificates relating to in vitro fertilisation work held by physicians who encourage their patients will likewise be cancelled by the Ministry of Health, and the person who carries out the procedure, the person who acts as an intermediary in it, the person who becomes pregnant and the donor will be reported to the Public Prosecutor’s Office. This means that an investigation will be opened against them.

In this context, the Ministry of Health has announced that an assessment will be made within the framework of the provision of Art. 231 of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK).

Provisions containing offences and penalties may be laid down only in a law, and it is plain to see that the provision prohibiting sperm banks is a provision of a regulation. While it is stated that those who act contrary to these provisions will be subject to an administrative sanction, the fact that a criminal report is to be filed with the Public Prosecutor’s Office and an investigation opened on the basis of Art. 231 TCK, virtually by way of analogy, amounts to disregarding the principle that offences and penalties must be determined by law and the prohibition of analogy in criminal law. If, as a matter of criminal policy, it is desired to punish acts of this kind, a separate type of offence must be created for them either in the TCK or in the relevant law.

Although those who oppose the practice of sperm banks contend, in support of their arguments, that human beings cannot be made the subject of trade and cannot be bought and sold like market goods, in order to be able to speak of a “human being” in law, Art. 28 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 requires the condition of being born complete and alive, which is at the same time the moment at which personality is acquired. Consequently, a foetus that has not been born complete and alive, or sperm, has not yet acquired the status of a human being. Indeed, offences that can be committed against a human being, such as intentional killing, regulated in the TCK No. 5237, cannot be committed against a foetus/sperm, because these are not deemed to be human beings. Whether buying sperm constitutes trade in human beings in law is therefore a debatable matter. (What must be emphasised here is that the trade in human beings referred to is not the “human trafficking” regulated as a criminal norm in Art. 80 TCK, but the making of the purchase and sale of human beings the subject of trade).

The reasons for opting for sperm donation vary. A couple within the bond of marriage wishing to resort to sperm donation may, in situations such as testicular damage due to radiotherapy or chemotherapy administered for the treatment of cancer or a congenital absence of sperm production, or where the man has a hereditary disease that is likely to be passed on to his children, ask for his sperm to be frozen by sperm banks for use at a later time; or men who have failed in their attempts owing to the complete absence of sperm, a low sperm count, the failure to achieve pregnancy in the treatments carried out or abnormalities in sperm morphology, and couples at risk on account of a marriage between relatives, may decide on sperm donation treatment. Apart from these, an unmarried single woman may also wish to have a child by giving birth herself by means of the method of sperm donation.

Cryos, the world’s largest sperm bank, which is located in Denmark and was founded by Ole Schou, is instrumental in the birth of more than 2000 babies a year and also exports sperm to more than 70 countries. The majority of the bank’s donors are university students, who come to the bank once or twice a week to donate and thus earn an income from sperm donation. The founder of the bank has stated that when he had just set up the bank it needed advertising, that those who heard of the sperm bank and of sperm donation for the first time could not conceal their astonishment, but that in time people became accustomed to it and that it no longer even needs advertising. There are sperm banks in many countries such as Denmark, Greece, Cyprus, the USA, England and Belgium, and there is no legal obstacle to sperm donation. Although the sperm bank is an institution that has been heard of in our country for quite a long time, it has not been able to escape being viewed with prejudice.

It cannot be said, however, that giving it a statutory regulation and placing it on a legal footing removes all the problems. Even in that case various legal problems arise, and indeed even the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), which we may call the highest judicial body in the jurisdiction in which we find ourselves, is obliged to deliver various judgments. Thus, in its latest judgment on the subject of the foetus, dating from 2006, the ECtHR examined an application lodged against the United Kingdom. In the case giving rise to that application, the applicant and her partner applied to a reproduction clinic in 2000, and as a result of the tests carried out it was determined that the applicant had ovarian cancer and that her ovaries had to be removed. Before the operation, eleven of the applicant’s eggs were removed and fertilised with her partner’s sperm, and six embryos were frozen. Some time after this procedure the applicant separated from her partner and wished to have a child from the embryos by means of a surrogate mother. At that point the former partner, who had learned of the situation, stated that he did not wish to be the genetic father of the child and prevented the use of the embryos. The national court decided in favour of the partner. Proceeding from the view that there is no Europe-wide consensus on this subject, the ECtHR pointed out that each legal system has its own margin of appreciation. In conclusion, the ECtHR rejected the application and held that an embryo produced by artificial fertilisation is not protected by United Kingdom law until it is placed in the womb of the surrogate mother and that it therefore does not have the right to life.

It would not be wrong to say that, owing to the moral structure of our country, which is bound up with its socio-cultural traditions, customs and usages, the practice of sperm banks is not looked upon favourably. For a view prevails in society to the effect “that the birth of fatherless children is not welcomed”. It is also thought that a problem of descent will arise with regard to the child to be born. In addition, certain problems may arise from the standpoint of the law of succession. The possibility that, after a donor has made a donation to the sperm bank, sperm from the bank may in the future be transferred to the donor’s own sister as well causes moral and ethical rules to be questioned anew. The Ministry of Health, for its part, emphasises by means of the “Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres” that pregnancy by means of sperm and eggs that belong to others or whose owner is unknown is prohibited on the ground that in Türkiye the certainty of “parentage”, that is, of paternity, is taken as the basis.

Looking at the regulations of the countries in which sperm donation is lawful, there is no change or innovation that could not be accommodated by making the necessary amendments to the legislation of our country. Indeed, science and technology advance with each passing day, and new statutory regulations must be made concerning the new concepts and practices that emerge in the face of new developments. The practice of sperm donation is such a case. Otherwise, as in societies that are unable to keep pace with what advancing technology brings, there is a danger in our country too that sperm donation will be resorted to illegally. To bar people from certain rights by imposing on them rules whose reasons they question and whose purpose they do not understand will make illegal cross-border routes attractive.

Surrogate Motherhood – A Practice That Should Not Be Prohibited but Should Be Applied

Subject to Regulation

In surrogate motherhood, the egg and sperm cells taken from the commissioning couple are combined in a laboratory environment and, after an embryo has been formed, transferred to the surrogate mother. Thereafter the birth takes place once the foetus has completed the nine-month period in the surrogate mother’s womb. This practice is a ray of hope particularly for women who, at a young age and before being able to become mothers, have permanently lost their uterus owing to various diseases, in that it enables them to have a child from their own genes/eggs. A woman who carries in her womb, in the place of another woman, the child of that woman who for whatever reason lacks the ability to bear a child or for whom giving birth might be dangerous is called a surrogate mother. The only way of doing this is to use the uterus of a healthy woman who has previously given birth.

The child developing in the surrogate mother’s womb receives nutrients and oxygen from the surrogate mother’s body. It is also affected by the psychological traumas resulting from the excessive stress and distress experienced by the surrogate mother. In addition, certain viral diseases present in the surrogate mother, such as AIDS and hepatitis, may also be transmitted to the child. The health screening of the surrogate mother must therefore have been carried out very thoroughly.

Practices based on new reproductive techniques of this kind run counter, for various reasons, to the traditional understanding of the family in our society as regards having children. As in the case of the practice of sperm donation, surrogate motherhood is prohibited in our country under Art. 18 of the 2010 Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres.

Alongside the USA, England, Brazil and Belgium, where surrogate motherhood, which is prohibited in Türkiye, is permitted, one of the places in which surrogate motherhood is lawful is Greece. Many couples wishing to become parents by means of surrogate motherhood go to the Greek island of Crete, and the families who have the transfer procedures carried out there subsequently return to Türkiye and spend the nine months out of sight, in accordance with the contract they have concluded between themselves. Since the practice of surrogate motherhood is legally prohibited in Cyprus too, Turkish families mostly prefer Crete because of its proximity. This lays bare the cross-border illegal dimension of surrogate motherhood as far as Türkiye is concerned and shows that it is not very difficult to do this by illegal means.

Doctors working in countries in which surrogate motherhood is not prohibited practise their profession and carry out their procedures in accordance with the law of the country in which they work, irrespective of which country the couples are citizens of or in which country they live. As a result, citizens of our country too are able to have children abroad in this way. In the face of such a basic instinct, therefore, prohibitions do not constitute an obstacle; they merely push people into illegal routes that are prohibited as far as our country is concerned.

Surrogate motherhood is also encountered in Iran, which is an Islamic country, and is offered as an option to infertile couples in certain medical centres in Tehran, Isfahan and other cities.

In countries such as Germany, France and Spain, which, like Türkiye, prohibit surrogate motherhood, the basic purpose of this prohibition is to prevent the commodification of the human body and to oppose the sale of children. Some countries such as Belgium, the Netherlands, Finland and India, on the other hand, remain silent by not enacting any statutory regulation on surrogate motherhood and thereby display a kind of tacit consent. Surrogate motherhood is permitted in Ukraine, in the State of California in the USA and in the Canton of Zurich in Switzerland and, where certain conditions are met, in England (the reproductive cells must belong to the mother or the father and there must be a court decision), and likewise under certain conditions in Greece (court authorisation). The basic reasons for the acceptance of surrogate motherhood in these countries are protection against illegal practices in this field and against genetic diseases.

Prohibiting surrogate motherhood and pointing to adoption as its alternative does not appear to be a very apt choice. For whereas in surrogate motherhood a full or partial genetic link is established between the child and the parents, in adoption there is no genetic link with either parent. Whereas in a typical adoption an existing child is adopted, in surrogate motherhood the parents are able to choose a surrogate mother according to her character/physical characteristics. In short, the practices of adoption and surrogate motherhood are entirely different from one another.

Unless there is evidence that the child born as a result of a surrogacy contract is exposed to harmful effects of this situation, the reproductive decisions taken by individuals should be respected.

The surrogacy contract exploits women who are less advantaged in social and economic terms, and the poor women of the third world are used as a means of making up for the reproductive deficiencies of western women who are infertile or who postpone their reproductive plans because of their careers. The new assisted reproductive techniques have now become an international industry. Reasons such as the legal prohibitions and restrictions in their own countries, the possibility of finding a surrogate mother more cheaply, quickly and easily, and the possibility of choosing the sex encourage reproductive tourism from the West to third-world countries. Although there are no adequate legal regulations to protect them, for many young and unskilled Asian or Eastern European women surrogate motherhood promises far more money than they could earn from a lawful job in their own countries. In India, for example, where annual per capita income is around 500 dollars, this sector, which offers the opportunity of earning an income of between 3000 and 6000 dollars, presents an attractive financial option for poor Indian women. Indeed, it is claimed that this sector has become the country’s second-largest industry.

The question, debated in connection with the practice of sperm donation, whether the baby who is the subject of the practice, that is to say a human being, can be made the subject of trade is likewise a matter of continuing debate in connection with the practice of surrogate motherhood. The surrogacy contract is not the same thing as the sale of a baby and is regarded as equivalent to the transfer of parental rights over the child. One further point must, however, be corrected in this regard. From the legal point of view, the payment made to the surrogate mother is not a price paid in return for the transfer of the parent’s right of custody to the commissioning couple; it is merely the consideration for the surrogate mother’s waiver, in favour of the commissioning couple, of her legal claim to parenthood over the child. For the surrogate mother’s right is not a right that can be transferred but one that can only be waived. Yet even though the surrogacy contract cannot be regarded as the sale of a baby, it continues to be rejected on moral grounds. The handing over of the baby by the surrogate mother to the commissioning couple is an essential feature of the contract, and the giving of a child to another person for anything other than love and generosity is, in a sense, the objectification of the child.

Looking at practice around the world, in some states of the USA and in some European countries it is prohibited to turn surrogate motherhood into a trade by carrying it out in return for money; in some others, by contrast, it is made a legal requirement that surrogate motherhood be carried out in return for a certain fee. Various surveys/studies have been conducted with surrogate mothers. The research that Ragone carried out in the USA from 1988 to 1996 in three different surrogate motherhood programme centres is the product of both face-to-face conversations and formal interviews conducted with twenty-eight surrogate mothers. Ragone observed, first of all, that the answers given by the surrogate mothers to the question “What are the reasons that led you to become a surrogate mother” were identical to one another, and generally encountered a few principal but recurring reasons such as the wish to help an infertile couple to have a child, financial gain and a love of pregnancy. In addition to this, however, Ragone’s study indicates that the feeling of guilt arising from an abortion the women had previously undergone and/or from having given up a child for adoption may also motivate them to become surrogate mothers. When the women were asked whether they thought that the baby they gave birth to belonged to them, all of them without exception replied that they did not think so. According to them, giving the babies they have borne to their real mother and father after a certain time means not giving up the baby but giving it back to its parents. However, statistical data of this kind will of course vary according to the traditions, structure and culture of the society in which they are gathered.

Under Art. 282 of the Turkish Civil Code, parentage between mother and child is established by birth. Should surrogate motherhood become legally possible, provisions such as this will also have to be changed, in addition to the new regulations to be made. Indeed, it is not very easy to determine the legal status of a child born by means of a surrogacy contract. For it is highly debatable whether the mother of a child borne by a surrogate mother will, in law, be the surrogate mother or the woman who is the owner of the egg cells used in the formation of the embryo transferred to the surrogate mother. With whom will the child’s parentage have been established? The surrogate mother’s body has been used merely as an intermediary for the embryo to develop and come into the world as a baby. Yet the baby has completed its physical development in the surrogate mother’s womb and has been nourished by her during this process. As for paternity, parentage will likewise be established, after the real mother has been determined, with the husband who is in a bond of marriage with the mother, or by way of acknowledgement, or by the judgment of a court. If these provisions remain as they stand at present, the surrogate mother will be accepted as the mother with whom parentage is established, and the mother whose eggs were used in the formation of the baby will be able to adopt the child only by fulfilling the conditions for adoption. This leads to a strange situation. Where the surrogate mother is married, too, while the surrogate mother is accepted as the mother, the father will be accepted to be the surrogate mother’s husband, since under the presumption of paternity the child came into being within the marital union. Should the surrogate mother, in order to prevent this, be admitted to the hospital in which she is to give birth under the name of the woman from whom the eggs were taken, the offence of altering the parentage of a child laid down in Art. 231 TCK will also have been committed.

Indeed, the UK newspaper Independent of 4 July 1995 published a report that the Dutch police had caught a gang which entrapped and marketed young Polish women to act as surrogate mothers for couples living in the Netherlands, Germany and Belgium who were unable to reproduce, that the women had been deceived by advertisements in Polish newspapers promising that they could act as surrogate mothers at their own discretion and earn good money, and that the gang had been sentenced to imprisonment for organising surrogate motherhood for commercial purposes and for trading in women.

In this context, the fact that reproductive tourism has not been given a legal framework appears to be a major shortcoming. It can be seen that reproductive tourism is a dirty sector that exploits people’s emotional and economic needs and that, since the surrogacy contract has a commercial side, a trade in children and women is in a sense being carried on.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the examination we have carried out by taking three important medical developments as our headings shows that methods of treatment which offer people hope and bring healing can be abused and that, while the parties are turned into victims, certain persons (in particular organised criminal groups) thereby obtain large amounts of unjust gain. These bad consequences, however, must not prevent the application of these treatments and scientific work in this field. Legislation on the conditions for scientific work on these developments and on their application must be created without delay; unlawful situations must be identified and regulated as offences; an effective investigation must be conducted into the perpetrators and those found to have committed an offence must be punished; and joint international work must without fail be carried out in this field and uniform rules established.

A further conclusion we have reached, and our proposal, is that legal concepts need to be redefined. The legal status of human existence before birth has been debated for many years. Until a short time ago this debate remained confined to abortion. In today’s world, however, embryos are used for the purposes of research, experimentation and application across a wide spectrum, ranging from the use of the embryo in experiments on account of stem-cell research, to the production of living beings by cloning, the use of the possibilities of fertilisation outside the womb by means of artificial fertilisation, and the combination of the human egg with animal genetic material. In present-day legal systems, human existence before birth is not accepted as a “person”. Consequently, just as it is possible to regard the embryo as a mere thing consisting of nothing but a mass of cells, it is also possible to accord it a status equal to that of a person on the ground that it is a living being belonging to the human species. Thus both of the solutions arrived at by proceeding from classical legal thought harbour problems of their own. Faced with such a dilemma, our proposal is that the distinction between thing and person, which has come down to the present day from humanity’s “hunter-gatherer” stage, be reconsidered and that consideration be given to creating a third category by redefining these concepts.

A further conclusion we wish to state in this context is that, although surrogate motherhood, particularly in its international dimension, has become one of the most popular assisted reproductive treatment techniques, there is a complete legal vacuum in this field at both the national and the international level. The law has fallen behind the advances in medicine and the social developments connected with them. The rule “Mater semper certa est” (the mother is always certain), which is still valid today and has its source in Roman law, is today no longer adequate for solving legal problems. New and solution-oriented regulations must therefore be made in this field, taking medical, social and legal needs into account.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Erman, Barış, Ceza Hukukunda Tıbbi Müdahalelerin Hukuka Uygunluğu, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2003.

Korkut, Levent, “Biyohukuk Bakış Açısıyla AİHM Kararlarında Ceninin Hukuki Statüsü”, Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, s.25, Aralık-Ocak-Şubat 2012-2013.

Metin, Sevtap, “Yörüngesinden Çıkan Tabiat: Etik, Sosyal, Psikolojik ve Hukuki Görünümleriyle Taşıyıcı Annelik”, Sağlık Hukuku Makaleleri, İstanbul Barosu Yayınları, İstanbul, 2012.

Özbek, Veli Özer/M. Nihat Kanbur/Koray Doğan/Pınar Bacaksız/İlker Tepe, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2010.

Sayman, Yücel, “Mevcut Hukuk Sistemi Biyolojik Gelişmeler Karşısında Aciz Kalıyor”, Röportajı Yapan: Ömer Çakkal, Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, s.25, Aralık-Ocak- Şubat 2012-2013.

Şensöz Malkoç, Ebru, “Milletlerarası Özel Hukukta Boşluk: Taşıyıcı Annelik”, Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, s.25, Aralık-Ocak-Şubat 2012-2013.

Taşkın, Ahmet, Organ ve Doku Nakillerinde Hekimin Cezai Sorumluluğu, Ankara, Adil Yayınevi, 1997.

Tek, Gülen Sinem, “Türk Hukukunda Kadının Vücudu Üzerindeki Tasarruf Hakkını Sınırlayan Düzenlemeler”, Sağlık Hukuku Makaleleri, İstanbul Barosu Yayınları, İstanbul, 2012.

Vatanoğlu, Elif, “Günümüzde Tıp Bilimindeki Etik İlkeler”, Sağlık Alanında Etik ve Hukuk Uluslararası Sempozyumu 17-19 Nisan 2008, T.C. Yeditepe Üniversitesi, İstanbul, 2008.

Yıldız, Ali Kemal, “Organ Naklinden Kaynaklanan Etik ve Hukuk Sorunları”, Sağlık Alanında Etik ve Hukuk Uluslararası Sempozyumu 17-19 Nisan 2008, T.C. Yeditepe Üniversitesi, İstanbul, 2008.

http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/85107.asp, erişim: 5.2.2013. http://epochtimestr.com/index.php/bir-dolandiricilik-olayi-cindeki-yasadisi-organ-ticaretinigozler-onune-serdi, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://haber.sol.org.tr/devlet-ve-siyaset/insanlik-disi-bir-pazar-organ-ticareti-haberi-38363, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://health.howstuffworks.com/pregnancy-and-parenting/pregnancy/fertility/sperm-bank.htm, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ, erişim: 4.2.2013.

http://www.bulenttiras.com/medyada-tup-bebek/sperm-bankarlarina-yasak-gerekcesi-turksoyunu-koruma/, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.cryosinternational.com/franchise/what-is-a-sperm-bank.aspx, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.cyprusivf.net/sperm_donasyonu.html, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2193780/Sperm-donation-Wife-man-secretlydonated-sperm-calls-spouses-consent-mandatory.html#axzz2Jx2qJ976, erişim: 4.2.2013.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2012/nov/02/worlds-biggest-sperm-bank-denmark, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.hastahaklari.net/NewsPrint.aspx?Id=124&ModuleName=haberleri, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.hurriyetaile.com/bebek-bekliyoruz/genel/tasiyici-annelikle-ilgili-hukukiduzenleme-yok_22439.html, erişim: 6.2.2013.

http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/ekonomi/20491210.asp, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.sabah.com.tr/Gunaydin/Yazarlar/tuzun/2008/12/22/Baskasinin_rahmi_ile_anne_o lan_kadinlar_var, erişim: 6.2.2013.

http://www.saglikaktuel.com/haber/kacakcilarin-son-slogani-bir-bobrek-bagisla,-yeni-biripad-al-26139.htm, erişim: 5.2.2013.

http://www.tasiyicianne.com/dr-murat-vural-ile-tasiyici-annelik-uzerine, erişim: 6.2.2013.

Footnotes

  1. This article was published under the title “Yasa Dışı Sınır Ötesi Sağlık Sektörü: Organ Ticareti, Taşıyıcı Annelik ve Sperm Bağışı” in Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, No. 26, Spring (March–May) 2013, pp. 68–73. The text on this page is the author’s manuscript; the version published in the journal is abridged. ↑
  2. Member of the Faculty, Department of Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Law, Faculty of Law, Istanbul Medipol University. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic