Abstract
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
This article assesses certain health services provided across borders from the standpoint of Turkish domestic law. It examines organ trafficking, sperm banks and surrogacy, looking at national regulation, the international dimension of these practices and the question of their lawfulness.
The conclusion calls for prompt legislation in these fields, for unlawful conduct to be defined as criminal offences, for effective investigations and for common international rules, and it draws attention to the need to redefine the legal status of the unborn human being.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
Today, as the scope and variety of surgical interventions that can be performed on human beings have grown, the question of the lawfulness of such medical interventions has come to call for a new approach. In the exercise of their profession, physicians interfere with a person's bodily integrity; by their conduct they may even save that person's life or cause his or her death. Determining which act a physician must or must not perform at which moment in order for his or her conduct to be lawful or unlawful is of the utmost importance for criminal law.
A person who has legal capacity (in general terms, who is of age and has the capacity to discern) has the right to decide what is done to his or her body and must not be compelled to undergo any intervention against his or her will. Physicians and healthcare workers are presumed to know what is best for the patient in the interests of the person being examined or treated. One of the most fundamental principles of medical ethics is the idea that individuals are able to judge what is best for themselves. The principle of informed consent is essential in enabling the participant/patient to decide what is best for himself or herself. Under informed consent, within the relationship between physician and patient/participant, the participant/patient, after having been adequately informed, declares whether or not he or she consents to the treatment. Naturally, the decision a person takes regarding his or her own body is not valid unconditionally. Under legislation shaped by the social, moral, economic, psychological and ethical conditions of the time, certain acts are prohibited by law and the breach of that prohibition is made subject to sanctions.
In the light of the developments in modern medical science, entirely new problems have arisen that go beyond the classical problems of this field and of law. In particular, the advance of technology, the growth of travel opportunities and the emergence of a new sector called health tourism can turn people's search for a cure into a nightmare and make them victims. Proceeding from this perspective, our study examines and seeks to assess, in turn, the present national situation, the international dimensions and the lawfulness or unlawfulness of certain cross-border health services such as organ trafficking, sperm banks and surrogacy.
In biology, tissue is defined as an aggregate of cells forming one of the structural elements of a body or an organ, and an organ as a group of tissues performing a specific function or set of functions. Organ transplantation is the procedure by which a sound organ, taken from a living donor or from a deceased person and capable of assuming the same function, is transferred in place of an organ in the body that can no longer perform its function. Today, organ transplantation is accepted as a valid method of treatment for many end-stage organ diseases. In our country the number of people awaiting an organ transplant is very high. The lack of a sufficient number of donors to meet this need drives patients awaiting an organ to buy organs, while it drives people in economic hardship to sell them. The situation is no different worldwide. It is a well-known fact that wealthy dialysis patients travel the world for organ transplants, especially where organ trading is legally prohibited and subject to sanctions in their own countries; that the British and Germans go to India, the Japanese to the USA and North Americans to Peru and Brazil; and that this trade is professionally organised under the name of “medical tourism”.
Under Article 17(2) of the 1982 Constitution of the Republic of Turkey, “Except in cases of medical necessity and cases prescribed by law, the bodily integrity of the individual shall not be violated; no one shall be subjected to scientific or medical experiments without his or her consent”. Accordingly, in our law the manner in which organ transplants are to be carried out is regulated by Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues (ODNK). The ODNK contains a provision entitled prohibited acts. Under Art. 15 ODNK, “Those who remove, store, graft or transplant organs and tissues in breach of this Law, those who buy or sell them, and those who act as intermediaries or brokers in their purchase and sale shall, unless the act calls for a heavier penalty, be sentenced to imprisonment of two to four years and a heavy fine of 50,000 to 100,000 lira”. In addition, the offences relating to this subject are regulated in Art. 91 et seq. of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK). Within the scope of application of the provisions of the TCK, which is the later statute, the provisions of the TCK rather than Art. 15 ODNK apply; however, since Art. 91 TCK lays down the criminal sanction on the subject without specifying the conditions of organ and tissue transplantation, the provisions of the ODNK govern the conditions of organ and tissue transplantation. For acts regulated in the ODNK but not in the TCK, the sanction laid down in Art. 15 ODNK is applied, as in the following examples: failing, where the donor is married, to inquire and ascertain whether the spouse living with the donor is aware of the donor's decision to give organs and tissues and to record that finding in a written report, as required by Art. 7(d) ODNK; disclosing the names of the recipient and the donor, save where there is kinship by blood or marriage or a close personal relationship, contrary to Art. 7(f) ODNK; or the removal, storage, grafting and transplantation of organs and tissues by health institutions that do not have the specialist staff, equipment and materials required for this work, contrary to Art. 10 ODNK. Alongside these provisions, Turkey signed the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine (Council of Europe Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine) and, by Law No. 5013 published in the Official Gazette on 9.12.2003, approved the ratification of that international convention; however, it entered a reservation to Article 20(2) of the Convention on the ground that it was not compatible with Article 5 of the ODNK. The scope of the 2012 Regulation on Organ and Tissue Transplantation and of the relevant provisions of the TCK is set out in Article 2 of the ODNK. Accordingly, autografts, the removal, grafting and transplantation of hair and skin, and blood transfusion fall outside this scope and are to be carried out within the framework of the health legislation in force.
The rules on organ transplantation, both in our country and in other countries, are subject to differing conditions. In our law, the prohibition of trade in organs or tissues outside the permitted scope is laid down in Arts. 91, 92 and 93 TCK. The basic distinction in the removal of organs or tissues is drawn between removal from a deceased person and removal from a living human being. According to the findings produced by the present level of development of medicine, the criterion for determining the moment of a person's death today is brain death, and once brain death has occurred one can no longer speak of a living being. Organ or tissue transplantation from a living person is likewise regulated by the provisions of the ODNK.
Article 91 TCK, under the heading “trafficking in organs and tissues”, regulates the following acts: removing organs and tissues from a person without legally valid consent; unlawfully removing organs and tissues from a deceased person; buying, selling and acting as an intermediary for organs and tissues; storing, transporting or grafting organs and tissues obtained by unlawful means; and placing or publishing announcements or advertisements aimed at procuring organs or tissues in return for a specific benefit. Whether a ground of justification can exist for the removal of an organ from an organ donor depends on the purpose of healing the recipient. Consent given for any other purpose, or to interventions that are not proportionate to the purpose of healing, will not be valid. In this context, the problem of donating organs and tissues for commercial purposes arises in particular. Under Article 21 of the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, “the human body and its parts shall not, as such, give rise to financial gain”. Indeed, at its 37th General Assembly held in Brussels in October 1985, the World Medical Association likewise condemned, by a declaration, the sale of human organs for transplantation. This does not, however, apply to the person into whom the organ is transplanted. Even if that person has agreed to pay money to receive the organ, the validity of his or her consent must be accepted, since his or her principal aim will be to save his or her health or life. However, where the organ removed is of importance for the donor's continued survival and its removal creates a disproportionate danger to that person's health, the conclusion is reached that the consent given to the organ transplantation is contrary to law and morality. Since organ and tissue transplants are not directed at healing the donor, there is consensus that in such cases the physician's duty to inform must be construed in the broadest possible terms. Everything that could influence the donor's decision must be disclosed and nothing must be withheld.
Under Art. 3 ODNK, “The removal and sale of organs and tissues for a price or any other benefit is prohibited”, and the sanction for this prohibition is laid down in the TCK. Trade in organs and tissues is thus prohibited in our law. Kidney trading makes up the greater part of organ trafficking. Unfortunately, the buying and selling of kidneys has become very widespread in various countries of the world. In particular, it takes the form of taking from a poor donor and selling to a rich recipient; in other words, of exposing the poor to risk in order to restore the health of the wealthy recipient. Hundreds of kidney patients from Arab countries and South-East Asia travel to India for transplantation. The low prices and the abundance of kidneys available
have over the years made India one of the world's centres of kidney transplantation, and have even led physicians to call it a “kidney bazaar”. A large number of back-street/makeshift clinics engaged in this trade have opened. Such clinics place advertisements to attract donors and, so as not to run up against legal obstacles, conduct this business under the name of a “rewarded gift”. A rewarded gift, or rewarded donation, is a specific amount of material benefit offered to the donor in return for the organ he or she gives. The donor is rewarded in return for the donation; in short, the rewarded gift is a softened name for buying and selling in the organ trade. Particularly in countries located in regions such as India and the Far and Near East, where cadaveric organs are unavailable and there are marked differences in wealth between different sections of the population, and in countries such as China, Nepal, Egypt and Turkey, rapidly growing populations have led to the development of the international trade in human organs. It is also known that organ trafficking has increased in recent years in Russia, Romania and Moldova. As a result, a type of medical practice has emerged in which human kidneys are bought from poor and needy people to be transplanted into a group of wealthy recipients, and which yields high profits for brokers, private hospitals and doctors. These poor and needy people who give their kidneys very often do not receive the payment promised to them, which was meant to ease, however slightly, the economic situation that forced them to sell their kidneys, and are simply left without their kidneys. For example, under China's “Regulation on Human Organ Transplantation”, the persons who donate their organs may only be married couples or close relatives. For this reason, various intermediaries have sprung up to document, by means of forged documents, a closeness of these degrees of relationship that does not exist in material reality.
In a statement made in mid-2012, the World Health Organization (WHO), an agency of the United Nations, revealed the appalling level that organ trafficking has reached. According to the Organization's research, some ten thousand black-market kidney sales take place every year, which amounts to more than one kidney an hour. The Organization stated that demand for kidney sales has risen owing to the increase in diabetes and similar diseases. Noting that kidneys account for 75% of illegally transplanted organs, the Organization revealed that patients mostly undergo surgery in China, Pakistan and India, and stated that recipients may pay up to 200 thousand dollars (367 thousand TL) for a single kidney. It stated that the amount paid to those who give their kidneys is at most 5 thousand dollars (9 thousand TL), while the rest of the money is shared between the intermediaries and the doctors. Moreover, Turkey is preferred in the choice of the country where the operations are to be carried out, since it is both a transit country between rich and poor countries and well placed in terms of medical competence (as regards hospitals and doctors).
There are three basic principles in organ transplantation from a living donor: First, the removal of an organ from the donor must not impair the donor's health, life or functional integrity. Second, donors must donate organs voluntarily, of their own consent, without pressure or coercion. Third, the donor must be fully informed of the possible consequences and risks of the intervention.
In the organ trafficking system, most donors come from a section of society in which health and nutrition are already restricted because of poverty and economic hardship. It is not realistic to say that, in the conditions in which these individuals find themselves, they give genuinely voluntary and uncoerced consent. Furthermore, in transplants carried out in the unsanitary conditions of back-street operating theatres, where the medical knowledge and experience of the operating physicians are neither questioned nor known, it is highly likely that the donor's health, the functional integrity of his or her organs and his or her life will be impaired. In addition, the donor is not adequately informed about the transplant; the wishes of donors who change their minds at the last moment are disregarded, superficial assurances are given that the operation is simple, and it is argued that there can be no turning back once this path has been taken, so that their organs are, as it were, taken by force. Recipients, for their part, are at the mercy of the hospitals and physicians as regards costs, donor selection and the quality of assessments and examinations.
If the human body is accepted as a commodity that can be sold, like ordinary goods, for known and predetermined sums, corruption in society and an unjust and inequitable system of access and distribution are invited; because in such a system the rich will always be on the buying side and the poor on the giving side.
In order to prevent organ trafficking, transplantation programmes should turn to cadavers, and, because of the danger of commercialisation, the removal of organs from donors who are neither living relatives nor persons having a family or emotional bond with the recipient should be prevented. Both worldwide and in Turkey, one must wait in very long queues for an organ transplant through legal channels, and often one's turn does not come before death. For this reason, organ trafficking through illegal channels is preferred. Individuals are reluctant to donate organs for religious, economic or social reasons. While there are a great many recipients waiting in line worldwide, it is difficult under these conditions to find legal donors. Consequently, either people should be encouraged to donate organs, both by the state and by NGOs, or organ donation from living persons should be kept far more limited and organ transplantation carried out under strict supervision. Indeed, in 1987 the World Health Assembly expressed its concern about the commercial trade in human organs between living persons, stating that this trade is inconsistent with the most basic human values and contrary to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a product of the UN, and to the spirit of the Constitution of the World Health Organization.
Sperm bank
The legal transaction whereby healthy sperm, whose fertility has previously been proven by carrying out all the necessary tests, is stored by freezing and then given to a person or persons unable to have children is called sperm donation; the centres where this transaction is generally carried out are called sperm banks.
When a woman or a clinic seeking a sperm donation applies to a sperm bank, the bank explains the medical and legal conditions to the recipient, and the contract is concluded when the recipient accepts the conditions and makes the payment. The recipient chooses, by looking at their photographs and all their personal details, from among the donors who do not wish to conceal their identity, and the bank sends the requested sperm to the clinic where the recipient will be treated. Those who wish to obtain sperm make their choice according to criteria they set, such as the sperm donor's nationality, skin colour, eye colour, height, blood group and level of intelligence.
Under Art. 18 of the 2010 Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres, under the heading prohibitions relating to the application of assisted reproductive treatment methods, it is provided that it is not legally possible in Turkey to donate sperm or to open a sperm bank.
However, those who wish to have a child by way of a sperm bank go abroad or have the procedure carried out in Turkey by illegal means. Although sperm donation is prohibited in our country, counselling services used to be provided to persons wishing to resort to this procedure abroad. However, by an amendment to the regulation, becoming pregnant by means of sperm or eggs obtained from a sperm bank, using this method and even recommending this method have been prohibited.
The Ministry of Health, which does not permit sperm banks for various reasons that it considers justified, will also have to close the IVF centres that refer or encourage their patients to go to sperm banks abroad. A clinic that makes such a referral or acts as an intermediary will be closed for three months on the first occasion and indefinitely if it commits the same act a second time. The IVF certificates of physicians who encourage their patients will also be revoked by the Ministry of Health, and the person performing the procedure, the person acting as intermediary, the woman who becomes pregnant and the donor will be reported to the Public Prosecutor's Office. In this context, the Ministry of Health has announced that, in the investigation to be opened against these persons, an assessment will be made within the framework of Art. 231 TCK.
Provisions establishing offences and penalties can only be laid down in a law, and it is plain that the provision prohibiting sperm banks is a provision of a regulation. While it is stated that acting in breach of these provisions will be subject to administrative sanctions, the fact that a criminal complaint is to be filed with the Public Prosecutor's Office and an investigation opened on the basis of Art. 231 TCK, by what amounts to analogy, disregards the principle that offences and penalties must be determined by law and the prohibition of analogy in criminal law. If, as a matter of criminal policy, such acts are to be punished, a separate offence must be created for them either in the TCK or in the relevant special law.
Although opponents of the sperm bank practice argue, in support of their case, that a human being cannot be made the object of trade and cannot be bought and sold like a market commodity, in order to speak of a “human being” in law, Art. 28 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 requires complete and live birth, which is also the moment at which legal personality is acquired. Consequently, sperm and a foetus that has not yet been completely and alive born have not yet acquired the status of a human being. Indeed, offences that can be committed against a human being, such as intentional killing as regulated in TCK No. 5237, cannot be committed against a foetus/sperm, since these are not regarded as human beings. It is therefore a contested question whether buying sperm constitutes trafficking in human beings in law. (It must be emphasised here that the trafficking in human beings referred to is not the “trafficking in human beings” laid down as an offence in Art. 80 TCK, but the making of the buying and selling of human beings an object of trade.)
The reasons for which sperm donation is chosen vary. A married couple wishing to resort to sperm donation may ask for the man's sperm to be frozen by a sperm bank for later use in situations such as testicular damage resulting from radiotherapy or chemotherapy administered for cancer treatment or a congenital absence of sperm production, or where the man has a hereditary disease that may be passed on to his children; alternatively, couples may decide on sperm donation where the man has no sperm at all or a low sperm count, where the existing sperm shows morphological abnormalities and no pregnancy has been achieved as a result of the treatments carried out, or where they are at risk because of a consanguineous marriage. Apart from these cases, a single woman with no marital bond may also wish to have a child by giving birth herself through the method of sperm donation.
Cryos, the world's largest sperm bank, located in Denmark and founded by Ole Schou, contributes to the birth of more than 2000 babies a year and also exports sperm to more than 70 countries. The majority of the bank's donors are university students who come to the bank once or twice a week to donate, thereby earning an income from sperm donation. The bank's founder has stated that when he first set up the bank he needed advertising, that those hearing of a sperm bank and of sperm donation for the first time could not hide their astonishment, but that over time people became accustomed to it and he no longer even needs advertising. There are sperm banks in many countries such as Denmark, Greece, Cyprus, the USA, England and Belgium, and there is no legal obstacle to sperm donation. Although the sperm bank has been a known institution in our country for quite a long time, it has not escaped being viewed with prejudice.
However, it cannot be said that giving the practice a statutory basis and placing it on a legal footing removes all problems. Even then, various legal problems arise, and even the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), which may be described as the highest judicial body in the jurisdiction to which we belong, has had to deliver a number of judgments. Indeed, in its most recent judgment on the foetus, delivered in 2006, the ECtHR examined an application lodged against the United Kingdom. In the facts giving rise to that application, the applicant and her partner had applied to a fertility clinic in 2000, and as a result of the tests carried out it was determined that the applicant had ovarian cancer and that her ovaries had to be removed. Before the operation, eleven of the applicant's eggs were harvested and fertilised with her partner's sperm, and six embryos were frozen. Some time after this procedure, the applicant separated from her partner and wished to have a child from the embryos with a surrogate mother. Meanwhile, the former partner, having learnt of the situation, stated that he did not wish to be the genetic father of the child and prevented the use of the embryos. The national court ruled in favour of the partner. Proceeding from the view that there is no European consensus on this matter, the ECtHR pointed out that each legal system has its own margin of appreciation. In conclusion, the ECtHR dismissed the application, holding that an embryo produced by artificial fertilisation is not protected by the law of the United Kingdom until it is implanted in the womb of the surrogate mother, and therefore has no right to life.
It would not be wrong to say that, owing to our country's moral structure, which is bound to its socio-cultural traditions, customs and usages, the sperm bank practice is not looked upon favourably. For the view prevails in society that “the birth of fatherless children is frowned upon”. It is also thought that problems of descent will arise in respect of the child to be born. In addition, certain problems may arise from the standpoint of the law of succession. The possibility that sperm from the bank might in future be transferred to the sister of a donor who has donated to a sperm bank causes moral and ethical rules to be called into question anew. The Ministry of Health, for its part, emphasises in the “Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres” that pregnancy with sperm and eggs belonging to others or of unknown origin is prohibited in Turkey on the ground that “descent”, that is, the certainty of paternity, is taken as the basis.
Surrogacy
In surrogacy, the egg and sperm cells taken from the commissioning couple are combined in a laboratory and, once an embryo has been formed, transferred to the surrogate mother. Birth takes place after the foetus has completed the nine-month period in the surrogate mother's womb. This practice is a ray of hope, in particular for women who have permanently lost their womb owing to various illnesses at a young age and before becoming mothers, enabling them to have a child from their own genes/eggs. A woman who carries in her womb the child of a woman who, for whatever reason, is incapable of bearing children or for whom giving birth could be dangerous, in that woman's place, is called a surrogate mother. The only way of doing this is to use the womb of a healthy woman who has given birth before.
The child developing in the surrogate mother's womb receives nutrients and oxygen from the surrogate mother's body. It is also affected by psychological traumas linked to extreme stress or distress experienced by the surrogate mother. In addition, certain viral diseases such as AIDS and hepatitis present in the surrogate mother may be passed on to the child. The surrogate mother's health must therefore be checked very thoroughly.
Practices based on such new reproductive techniques run counter, for various reasons, to the traditional understanding of the family in our society with regard to having children. As with the practice of sperm donation, surrogacy is prohibited in our country under Art. 18 of the 2010 Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres.
The practice of surrogacy, which is prohibited in Turkey, is also found in Iran, an Islamic country, where certain medical centres in Tehran, Isfahan and other cities offer surrogacy as an option for infertile couples. Besides the USA, England, Brazil and Belgium, one of the places where surrogacy is legal is Greece. Many couples wishing to become parents through surrogacy go to the Greek island of Crete, and the families who have the transfer procedures carried out there then return to Turkey and spend the nine months out of sight, in accordance with the contract they have concluded among themselves. Since surrogacy is also legally prohibited in Cyprus, Turkish families mostly prefer Crete because of its proximity. This reveals the cross-border illegal dimension of surrogacy from Turkey's perspective and shows that it is not very difficult to do this through illegal channels.
Doctors working in countries where surrogacy is not prohibited practise their profession and carry out their procedures in accordance with the law of the country in which they work, regardless of the nationality of the couples or of the country in which they live. As a result, citizens of our country, too, are able to have children abroad in this way. Consequently, in the face of such a basic instinct, prohibitions do not form an obstacle; they merely push people towards illegal channels that are prohibited from the standpoint of our country.
In countries such as Germany, France and Spain which, like Turkey, prohibit surrogacy, the basic aim of the prohibition is to prevent the commodification of the human body and to oppose the sale of children. Some countries, such as Belgium, the Netherlands, Finland and India, on the other hand, remain silent by not adopting any legal rules on surrogacy, thereby giving a kind of tacit consent. Surrogacy is permitted in Ukraine, in the US State of California and in the Swiss Canton of Zurich, in England subject to certain conditions (the reproductive cells must belong to the mother or the father and there must be a court order), and likewise in Greece subject to certain conditions (court authorisation). The basic reasons for accepting surrogacy in these countries are protection against illegal practices in this field and against genetic diseases.
Prohibiting surrogacy and pointing to adoption as an alternative is not regarded as a very appropriate choice. For in adoption there is no genetic link whatsoever with either parent. Whereas in a typical adoption an existing child is adopted, in surrogacy the parents can choose a surrogate mother according to her character/physical characteristics. In short, adoption and surrogacy are entirely different practices.
Unless there is evidence that the child born as a result of a surrogacy contract has been exposed to harmful effects of this situation, the reproductive decisions taken by individuals should be respected.
The surrogacy contract exploits socially and economically less advantaged women; it causes poor women of the third world to be used as instruments to make up for the reproductive deficiencies of Western women who cannot have children by normal means or who postpone such plans because of their careers. New assisted reproductive techniques have now become an international industry. Reasons such as the legal prohibitions and restrictions in their own countries, the possibility of finding a surrogate mother more cheaply, quickly and easily, and the possibility of choosing the sex of the child encourage reproductive tourism from the West to third-world countries. Although there are no adequate legal rules to protect them, surrogacy promises many young and unskilled Asian or Eastern European women far more money than they could earn from a legal job in their own countries. In India, for example, where annual per capita income is around 500 dollars, this sector, which offers the opportunity to earn an income of between 3000 and 6000 dollars, presents an attractive financial option for poor Indian women. Indeed, it is claimed that this sector has become the country's second largest industry.
The question, debated in the practice of sperm donation, of whether the baby that is the object of the practice, that is, a human being, can be made the object of trade has likewise long been debated in the practice of surrogacy. The surrogacy contract is not regarded as the same thing as the sale of a baby, but as equivalent to the transfer of parental rights over the child. One further point must, however, be corrected in this respect. From a legal point of view, the payment made to the surrogate mother is not a price paid in return for the transfer of the parent's custody rights to the commissioning couple; it is merely consideration for the surrogate mother's waiver, in favour of the commissioning couple, of her claim to legal parenthood over the child. For the surrogate mother's right is not a transferable right but one that can only be waived. Yet even if the surrogacy contract cannot be regarded as the sale of a baby, it continues to be rejected on moral grounds. The handing over of the baby by the surrogate mother to the commissioning couple is an essential feature of the contract, and giving a child to another person for reasons other than love and generosity amounts, in a sense, to the objectification of the child.
Looking at practice worldwide, in some US states and some European countries it has been prohibited to turn surrogacy into a trade by performing it for money, while in others it has been made a legal requirement that surrogacy be performed for a certain fee. Various surveys/studies have been conducted with surrogate mothers. Ragone's research, conducted in the USA from 1988 to 1996 at three different surrogacy programme centres, is the product of both face-to-face conversations and formal interviews with twenty-eight surrogate mothers. Ragone first observed that the answers given by surrogate mothers to the question “What are the reasons that led you to become a surrogate mother?” were identical, and generally encountered certain recurring principal reasons such as the wish to help an infertile couple to have a child, financial gain and the love of pregnancy. In addition, however, Ragone's study indicates that an abortion the women had previously undergone and/or a sense of guilt arising from giving a child up for adoption may also motivate them to become surrogate mothers. When the women were asked whether they thought the baby they had given birth to belonged to them, without exception they all replied that they did not. In their view, handing over the babies they had borne to the real parents after a certain time did not mean giving the baby up, but returning it to its parents. Naturally, however, statistical data of this kind may vary according to the traditions, structure and culture of the society in which they are collected.
Under Art. 282 of the Turkish Civil Code, descent between mother and child is established by birth. Should surrogacy become legally possible, provisions of this kind would also have to be changed in addition to the new rules to be adopted. Indeed, determining the legal status of a child born under a surrogacy contract is not at all easy. For the question whether the mother of the child born by the surrogate mother is in law the surrogate mother or the woman to whom the egg cells used in forming the embryo transferred to the surrogate mother belong is highly contested. “With whom will the child's descent be established?” The surrogate mother's body has been used merely as a vehicle for the embryo to develop and be born as a baby. Yet the baby has completed its physical development in the surrogate mother's womb and has been nourished by her during this process. Descent from the father, likewise, will be established after the real mother has been determined, through the husband married to the mother, or by acknowledgement, or by court judgment. If these rules remain in their present form, the surrogate mother will be regarded as the mother with whom descent is established, while the mother whose eggs were used in forming the baby will only be able to adopt the child by fulfilling the conditions for adoption. Where the surrogate mother is married, the surrogate mother will be regarded as the mother and, under the presumption of paternity, since the child was born within the marriage, the surrogate mother's husband will be regarded as the father. Should the surrogate mother, in order to prevent this, be admitted to the hospital where she is to give birth under the name of the woman from whom the eggs were taken, the offence of changing the descent of a child laid down in Art. 231 TCK will be committed.
Indeed, the UK newspaper The Independent of 4 July 1995 published a report that the Dutch police had caught a gang that lured and marketed young Polish women to act as surrogate mothers for couples lacking the ability to reproduce living in the Netherlands, Germany and Belgium; that the women had been deceived by advertisements in Polish newspapers promising that they could act as surrogate mothers at their own discretion and earn good money; and that the gang had been sentenced to imprisonment for organising surrogacy for commercial purposes and for trafficking in women.
In this context, the fact that reproductive tourism has not been given a legal framework appears to be a major shortcoming. The view emerges that reproductive tourism is a dirty sector that exploits people's emotional and economic needs and that, since the surrogacy contract has a commercial aspect, it in a sense permits trafficking in children and women.
Conclusion
In conclusion, our examination, which took three important medical developments as its headings, shows that treatment methods that offer people hope and bring healing can be abused and that, while the parties are made victims, certain persons (especially organised criminal groups) obtain large amounts of unjust gain by these means. Unlawful practices must therefore be identified and defined as offences, effective investigations must be conducted against the perpetrators, those found to have committed offences must be punished, and uniform rules must be created in this field through international cooperation.
In addition, another conclusion we have reached, and our proposal, is that legal concepts need to be redefined. The legal position of prenatal human life has been debated for many years. Until fairly recently this debate was confined to abortion. In today's world, however, embryos are used for research, experimental and practical purposes across a broad spectrum, ranging from the use of embryos in experiments in stem cell research, to the production of living beings by cloning, the use of possibilities of fertilisation outside the womb by artificial fertilisation, and the combination of a human egg with animal genetic material. In present-day legal systems, prenatal human life is not recognised as a “person”. Consequently, just as it is possible to regard the embryo as a mere object consisting of nothing more than a cluster of cells, it is also possible, since it is a living being belonging to the human species, to regard it as having a status equal to that of a person. Both solutions reached by starting from classical legal thinking therefore contain problems of their own. In the face of this dilemma, our proposal is that the distinction between property and person, which has come down from humanity's “hunter-gatherer” stage to the present day, should be reconsidered and that consideration should be given to redefining these concepts and creating a third category.
A further conclusion we wish to state in this context is that, although surrogacy, especially in its international dimension, has become one of the most popular forms of assisted reproduction, there is a complete legal vacuum in this field at both national and international level. Law has fallen behind the advances in medicine and the social developments associated with them. The rule “Mater semper certa est” (the mother is always certain), which is still in force today and has its origin in Roman law, is now inadequate for resolving legal problems. New, solution-oriented rules must therefore be adopted in this field, taking into account medical, social and legal needs alike.
References
Erman, Barış, Ceza Hukukunda Tıbbi Müdahalelerin Hukuka Uygunluğu, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2003.
http://arsiv.ntvmsnbc.com/news/85107.asp, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://epochtimestr.com/index.php/bir-dolandiricilik-olayi-cindeki-yasadisi-organ-ticaretini-gozleronune-serdi, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://haber.sol.org.tr/devlet-ve-siyaset/insanlikdisi-bir-pazar-organ-ticareti-haberi-38363, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://health.howstuffworks.com/pregnancy-andparenting/pregnancy/fertility/sperm-bank.htm, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://tr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ, (Erişim tarihi: 4.2.2013)
http://www.bulenttiras.com/medyada-tup-bebek/ sperm-bankarlarina-yasak-gerekcesi-turk-soyunukoruma/, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://www.cyprusivf.net/sperm_donasyonu.html, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2193780/ Sperm-donation-Wife-man-secretly-donatedsperm-calls-spouses-consent-mandatory. html#axzz2Jx2qJ976, (Erişim tarihi: 4.2.2013)
http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2012/nov/02/ worlds-biggest-sperm-bank-denmark, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://www.hastahaklari.net/NewsPrint.aspx?Id=12 4&ModuleName=haberleri, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://www.hurriyet.com.tr/ekonomi/20491210.asp, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://www.hurriyetaile.com/bebek-bekliyoruz/ genel/tasiyici-annelikle-ilgili-hukuki-duzenlemeyok_22439.html, (Erişim tarihi: 6.2.2013)
http://www.sabah.com.tr/Gunaydin/Yazarlar/ tuzun/2008/12/22/Baskasinin_rahmi_ile_anne_ olan_kadinlar_var, (Erişim tarihi: 6.2.2013)
http://www.saglikaktuel.com/haber/kacakcilarinson-slogani-bir-bobrek-bagisla,-yeni-bir-ipadal-26139.htm, (Erişim tarihi: 5.2.2013)
http://www.tasiyicianne.com/dr-murat-vural-iletasiyici-annelik-uzerine, (Erişim tarihi: 6.2.2013)
Korkut, Levent, “Biyohukuk Bakış Açısıyla AİHM Kararlarında Ceninin Hukuki Statüsü”, Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, s.25, Aralık-Ocak-Şubat 2012-2013.
Metin, Sevtap, “Yörüngesinden Çıkan Tabiat: Etik, Sosyal, Psikolojik ve Hukuki Görünümleriyle Taşıyıcı Annelik”, Sağlık Hukuku Makaleleri, İstanbul Barosu Yayınları, İstanbul, 2012.
Özbek, Veli Özer/M. Nihat Kanbur/Koray Doğan/ Pınar Bacaksız/İlker Tepe, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2010.
Sayman, Yücel, “Mevcut Hukuk Sistemi Biyolojik Gelişmeler Karşısında Aciz Kalıyor”, Röportajı Yapan: Ömer Çakkal, Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, s.25, Aralık-Ocak-Şubat 2012-2013.
Şensöz Malkoç, Ebru, “Milletlerarası Özel Hukukta Boşluk: Taşıyıcı Annelik”, Sağlık Düşüncesi ve Tıp Kültürü Dergisi, s.25, Aralık-Ocak-Şubat 2012-2013.
Taşkın, Ahmet, Organ ve Doku Nakillerinde Hekimin Cezai Sorumluluğu, Ankara, Adil Yayınevi, 1997.
Tek, Gülen Sinem, “Türk Hukukunda Kadının Vücudu Üzerindeki Tasarruf Hakkını Sınırlayan Düzenlemeler”, Sağlık Hukuku Makaleleri, İstanbul Barosu Yayınları, İstanbul, 2012.
Vatanoğlu, Elif, “Günümüzde Tıp Bilimindeki Etik İlkeler”, Sağlık Alanında Etik ve Hukuk Uluslararası Sempozyumu 17-19 Nisan 2008, T.C. Yeditepe Üniversitesi, İstanbul, 2008.
Yıldız, Ali Kemal, “Organ Naklinden Kaynaklanan Etik ve Hukuk Sorunları”, Sağlık Alanında Etik ve Hukuk Uluslararası Sempozyumu 17-19 Nisan 2008, T.C. Yeditepe Üniversitesi, İstanbul, 2008.
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Imprisonment in Defiance of the Law: Enemy Criminal Law in Türkiye in the Light of the European Court of Human Rights Judgments in Osman Kavala and Can Atalay” (Hukuka Rağmen Hapis: Avrupa İnsan Hakları Mahkemesinin Osman Kavala ve Can Atalay Kararları Işığında Türkiye’de Düşman Ceza Hukuku), Dülger Law Office, 20 November 2026.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Demanding Accountability Is Not a Crime: On the Investigation Initiated Against Av. Prof. Dr. Osman Korkut Kanadoğlu” (Hesap Sormak Suç Değildir: Av. Prof. Dr. Osman Korkut Kanadoğlu Hakkında Başlatılan Soruşturma Üzerine), Dülger Law Office, 27 October 2026.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “On the Events Known to the Public as the ‘Fund Scandal’: An Assessment in Terms of Criminal Liability, Investor Rights and Supervisory Liability” (Kamuoyunda “Fon Skandalı” Olarak Anılan Olaylar Hakkında: Ceza Sorumluluğu, Yatırımcı Hakları ve Denetim Sorumluluğu Bakımından Bir Değerlendirme), Academia.edu, 1 October 2026.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Delayed Occurrence of the Result (Dolus Generalis / Weber's Intent)” (Gecikmiş Neticenin Gerçekleşmesi (Dolus Generalis / Weber Kastı)), Essays in Honour of Asst. Prof. Dr. Sesim Soyer Güleç (Dr. Öğr. Üyesi Sesim Soyer Güleç’e Armağan), eds. Koray Doğan / Behiye Eker Kazancı, Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2025, pp. 223–288.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Assessment of the Constitutional Court's Decision on the Provisions Governing the Simplified Trial Procedure” (Anayasa Mahkemesinin Basit Yargılama Usulü Hükümlerine İlişkin Kararının Değerlendirilmesi), Dülger Law Office, 12 October 2023.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Offences and Sanctions Relating to the Laundering of Proceeds of Crime (The Offence of Money Laundering) (Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar (Kara Paranın Aklanması Suçu)), 3rd ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2026.

