Abstract
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
Attacks on women for various purposes have long been a subject of criminal law; although under different names and for the protection of different legal interests, they are regulated by criminal law as offence types. Among them, however, perhaps the most important and the one that attracts the most attention is sexual assault against women.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
MURAT VOLKAN DÜLGER***
Introduction
Attacks on women carried out for various purposes have for a very long time been a subject of criminal law; albeit under different names and with a view to protecting different legal interests, they are regulated by criminal law as offence types. Among these, however, perhaps the most important, and the one attracting the most attention, is sexual assault against women.
Sexual assaults against women in fact both constitute a particular manifestation of violence against women and present themselves as a multidimensional phenomenon in their own right. The source of violence against women lies in the inequality of physical strength between women and men and in the abuse of that inequality by men, who are physically dominant, as an instrument of pressure on women in order to impose, maintain and/or reinforce their power1.
With the emergence and growing strength, in the 1970s, of the women’s rights movements referred to as “feminist movements”, which maintain that, apart from the roles she plays in social life such as “mother, wife, housewife, elder sister, younger sister or daughter-in-law”, a woman also has a role in social life as an individual and is in every respect on the same level as, and equal to, a man, violence and sexual assaults against women came to be heard of more and taken more seriously, and women came to be protected against such acts by criminal law as well.
___________________________________________________
It is an undeniable fact that sexuality is a need for every individual who has reached a certain maturity; for the law of nature directed at the continuation of the species, which is the purpose of life, can be realised, and nature’s end fulfilled, only through individuals of the opposite sex living out their sexuality. However, the sexuality referred to here is sexual intercourse that takes place with the mutual wish and consent of those taking part in it. Sexual intercourse carried out by force without the consent of one of the parties is not accepted by the legal order of today’s modern society.
Sexual union within the family is protected all the more by the legal order so that the father may be known for the purpose of determining in whom the lineage continues with regard to the division of inheritance, a concern that has come down from feudalism to the present day2. It should be noted, however, that what is protected here is the order of the family and the privacy of the sexual union taking place within that order; the woman, who is physically and in many cases economically in a weaker position than the man, is not the object of the protection.
Under the influence of the view that the institution of marriage forms the nucleus of society, and because the father’s role within the family was treated as dominant and important with regard to the division of inheritance and the transfer of private property, the rights of women were always disregarded and it was accepted as a woman’s primary duty to say yes unconditionally to her husband’s wishes; as a natural consequence, families taught their daughters this duty from a very early age. Accordingly, disposing of his wife’s body and having sexual intercourse with her by force even against her will was recognised as a right of the husband.
However, from the 1970s referred to above, debates and initiatives aimed at having sexual assault recognised as an offence also where it takes place within marriage began, first in the United States of America (USA) and later in Western Europe. As a result of these efforts, the act in question entered the criminal codes as an offence type. In our country the same tendency began to be voiced very late, from the second half of the 1990s, and, despite opposition from various quarters, the act was regulated as an offence type and brought within the protective scope of criminal law by the New Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (YTCK), which entered into force on 1 June 2005.
The subject of this study is “sexual assaults committed against women within the institution of marriage and the effects of this act on the woman who is the victim of the assault”. As can be seen, the study is in fact organised around two main axes. The first of these, which also forms the first part of the study, is the examination of the subject from the standpoint of criminal law within the framework of the normative provisions. In carrying out this examination, however, purely technical explanations will not be given; an attempt will also be made to convey the way of thinking underlying those provisions. In this part, explanations will first be given on the offence of aggravated sexual assault (rape) in general, followed by an examination of how acts of aggravated sexual assault are regulated in foreign legal systems and in Turkish law and of the offence of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage. The second main axis of the study is the examination of the subject from the standpoint of victimology, that is, the science of the victim. This main axis too will be examined in two parts. First, the physical and psychological problems of women victims who have been sexually assaulted by their husbands will be set out; thereafter, an attempt will be made to explain the measures envisaged and needing to be taken to remedy the trauma in question, and proposals will be put forward.
I. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault in General
A. Concept The concept of sexual assault is one that has newly entered legal terminology. In Arts. 414, 415 and 416 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 765 (TCK), the concepts of “ırza geçme” (rape) and “ırza tasaddi” (indecent assault) were used as its equivalents. The concept of ırza geçme denoted sexual assaults comprising the act of sexual intercourse, while the concept of ırza tasaddi denoted sexual assaults falling short of sexual intercourse.
In the YTCK No. 5237, by contrast, “sexual assault” is used in place of the concepts of ırza geçme and ırza tasaddi. Consistently with this, Art. 102(1) of the Code regulates, as the basic form of the offence, the acts formerly covered by the concept of ırza tasaddi, while paragraph 2 of the article regulates, as the aggravated form of the offence, the acts covered by the concept of ırza geçme, and these are set out under the heading “sexual assault”3. Accordingly, instead of the concept of ırza geçme within marriage, the concept of aggravated sexual assault within marriage must now be used.
The use of this concept is appropriate; for ırz means honour, and what is meant by the concept of violating honour (ırza geçme) is the defilement of the honour of the husband or of the family by the act committed by the perpetrator. Indeed, having regard to the place this offence type occupied within the system of Law No. 765 and the legal interest it protected, this was a fitting term; for in the TCK No. 765 sexual offences were regulated in the title on “felonies against public decency and family order”, and the legal interest protected in sexual offences was accordingly public morality and family order4. Hence, as far as the TCK No. 765 is concerned, the use of the concept of “ırza geçme” was also in harmony with the philosophy of that Code.
In truth, however, the legal interest protected by this offence is not the honour of the husband or of the family but the sexual freedom and inviolability of the individual, and hence the physical and mental integrity of the victim, which will be affected as a result of the sexual assault5. In Law No. 5237 this offence type is regulated in order to protect the individual’s sexual freedom, and hence the legal interest of the individual’s sexual inviolability; for this reason the concept of “sexual assault” has, correctly and appropriately, been used in place of the concepts of ırza tasaddi and ırza geçme.
B. The Act of Aggravated Sexual Assault The core of the concept of aggravated sexual assault within marriage is “aggravated sexual assault”. The act of aggravated sexual assault is the most significant kind of attack directed, against the individual’s will, at his sexual freedom and inviolability6. There are many definitions of aggravated sexual assault: for example, it has been defined as “having sexual intercourse with a person by force against his or her will”7 or as “a man’s having sexual intercourse, in a natural or unnatural manner, with a human being by force”8, and it is also defined as “having sexual intercourse by force upon the body of a person”9. For present purposes, in order to be more specific and comprehensive, the act may briefly be defined as “the insertion of a sexual organ or an object into a person by the vaginal, oral or anal route”10.
The act of aggravated sexual assault may be committed by a man against a woman, and it may equally be committed by a woman against a man or between persons of the same sex11. As stated above, the commission of this act does not necessarily require the insertion of the perpetrator’s sexual organ into the sexual organ of the person assaulted; the use instead of any object having this function or, for example, of the fingers will also suffice for the act to be committed12. Moreover, for there to be a sexual assault, physical or psychological coercion must be applied to the victim; in particular as regards adults, sexual relations engaged in voluntarily without physical or psychological coercion do not constitute an offence.
II. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault as Regulated in the Turkish Criminal Codes
A. The Offence of Rape (Irza Geçme) in the TCK No. 765 In the TCK No. 765 the offence of sexual assault was regulated, under the name of rape (ırza geçme), in Arts. 414 et seq. of the Code. The legal interest protected by the act of rape regulated in that Code is identified as “public decency and family order”. As can be seen, in the system of that Code what was placed in the foreground was not the sexual freedom of the individual, and of women in particular, but the protection of the honour of the husband, father, brothers and/or other relatives of the person sexually assaulted. Social judgments and the concept of honour were thus preferred to the personality and sexual inviolability of the individual, and especially of the female individual13. In the criminal policies prevailing in today’s modern societies this conception has now been superseded. In our country too, the conception in question prevailed until 1 June 2005, the date up to which the TCK No. 765 was in force.
As regards the offence of rape (ırza geçme) regulated in the TCK No. 765, it is necessary to explain who may be the perpetrator and who the victim. When the matter is examined from the standpoint of the perpetrator of the offence, the prevailing view in legal scholarship is that only men can be perpetrators of this offence14. The authors who hold this view in legal scholarship state that the expressions “ırzına geçer” (rapes) and “ırzına geçen” (one who rapes) in Arts. 416 and 417 of the TCK No. 765 support it15. Indeed, this view has also been adopted by the criminal codes of many foreign countries; for example, Art. 213 of the Brazilian Criminal Code, Art. 216 of the Danish Criminal Code, Art. 177 of the German Criminal Code and Art. 276 of the Hungarian Criminal Code provide that this offence can be committed only by men16.
When the matter is examined from the standpoint of the victim, on the other hand, it is seen that the relevant articles of Law No. 765 draw no distinction in this respect and that both women and men may be victims of this offence17.
Again under the provisions of the TCK No. 765, it is stated that acts of inserting an artificial penis, or fingers and similar instruments, into the victim’s vagina or anus constitute not the offence of aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme) but the basic form of the offence of sexual assault (the offence of ırza tasaddi)18.
B. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault in the YTCK No. 5237 In the YTCK No. 5237 the offence of sexual assault is regulated in Art. 102, which is located in Chapter Six, entitled “offences against sexual inviolability”, of Part Two, entitled “offences against persons”, of Book Two of the Code, in which the offence types are regulated. In the YTCK the concept of “sexual assault” is used in place of the concepts of ırza geçme and ırza tasaddi. The acts characterised in the former Code as “ırza tasaddi and ırza geçme” have thus been regulated within the overarching concept of “sexual assault”.
Paragraph 1 of Art. 102 of the Code, in which the offence of sexual assault is regulated, governs, as the basic form of the offence, the acts formerly covered by the concept of ırza tasaddi, while paragraph 2 of the article governs, as the aggravated form of the offence, the acts covered by the concept of ırza geçme, and these are set out under the heading “sexual assault”. Accordingly, in the YTCK the concept of “aggravated sexual assault” has taken the place of the concept of “ırza geçme”.
1. The Process of Change in the Legal Interest Protected
in Offences against Sexual Freedom
It was stated above that the legal interest protected by the offence of rape (ırza geçme) in the TCK No. 765 was, according to the place the offence type occupied within the Code and according to the prevailing view put forward on this point in legal scholarship, “public decency and family order”, but that this was the subject of criticism, because in modern societies and codes this offence is regulated as an offence type protecting sexual inviolability. Indeed, at the IXth International Congress of Penal Law in 1968, the sexual freedoms of individuals and the extent to which criminal law may affect that freedom were discussed19, and the contemporary tendencies that developed as a result of that congress were reflected in the criminal codes. Accordingly, first of all the principle of drawing a distinction between offences against public decency/morality and offences against the family was adopted; in addition, the concept of “individual sexual freedom” was introduced into the codes in place of a criterion such as “public decency/morality”, which is difficult to determine precisely and is also outdated in terms of legislative technique20. In line with the modern views that took shape after that congress, in the Federal Republic of Germany, for example, by a legislative amendment made in 1973, the heading of Chapter 13 of the German Criminal Code, which had read “offences against public decency”, was changed to “offences against sexual freedom”. According to this amendment, the protection by criminal law of the individual’s “power to shape his or her sexual life” is confined solely to the area necessary for the protection of public order and for young people to complete their sexual development without harm21. Under the same influence a similar amendment was made to the Swedish Criminal Code in 1972, providing that sexual offences are offences committed not against public decency but against sexual freedom.
These examples, which show the change in the legal interest protected by the offence of aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme) and by the other offences against sexual inviolability, have the distinction of being the first bold provisions rejecting the traditional conception in this field. Today, in contemporary society, the legal interest protected by sexual offences is expressed not as values such as public decency/morality and the like, but as the sexual freedom and inviolability of the individual22.
It was under the influence and pressure of these modern ideas, the effects of which are seen more frequently today, that, when the YTCK was drafted, the offences concerning sexual freedom were likewise regulated in a separate chapter, apart from the offences against family order. Aggravated sexual assault, which forms the subject of our study, was also regulated on the basis of this idea.
2. Elements of the Offence
The legal interest protected by this offence is, as also indicated in the heading of the chapter in which the offence type is located, “the sexual inviolability of the individual”; indeed, this is expressly stated in the explanatory memorandum to the article23. Thus, taking into account the criticisms voiced in legal scholarship regarding the legal interest protected by the act of rape (ırza geçme) in Law No. 765, this unsatisfactory state of affairs has been corrected by the provisions of the new Code. Henceforth the legal interest protected by the offence of aggravated sexual assault is not the honour of any person but the sexual freedom, and hence the sexual inviolability, of the individual upon whom the act of aggravated sexual assault is committed24.
In the offence of aggravated sexual assault regulated in Art. 102 of the YTCK, no distinction is drawn as regards perpetrator and victim. Accordingly, this offence may be committed against a man or a woman, and it may equally be committed by a man or a woman. Furthermore, since the article draws no distinction, the offence may also be committed by persons of the same sex against one another.
Nor is the use of a sexual organ necessarily required for this offence to be committed. As the article expressly states, the offence may be committed by the insertion of an organ or another instrument into the victim’s body. In this way, the explanations given in relation to the offence of rape (ırza geçme) regulated in Law No. 765 – which, taking the organ as their starting point, held that only a man could be the perpetrator of this offence because the act of rape required the insertion of the penis, the male sexual organ, and that, although some women have a highly developed clitoris, it is not capable of effecting sexual intercourse – have also been superseded. For the article states very clearly that objects other than the sexual organ may also be used for aggravated sexual assault25. Indeed, in foreign legal systems, for example in the USA, it is accepted that this offence type is committed by the insertion of an organ or another instrument into the victim’s body26.
The criticism that must be made of the way this offence type is drafted is that the act of aggravated sexual assault is defined by the phrase “commission of the act by inserting an organ or other object into the body”. The phrase “commission by inserting... into the body” used in the text of the article is unclear and liable to cause confusion. For example, will this offence have been committed if the perpetrator, with the aim of committing a sexual assault, inserts a finger into the victim’s ear or nose? Likewise, will this offence be committed if a perpetrator displaying deviant behaviour carries out, with the intent of sexual conduct, the act of inserting a knife into the body, which he perceives as sexual conduct? For the statutory definition speaks of “the insertion of ... other object into the body”, and a knife may perfectly well be regarded as an “other object”. Moreover, the explanatory memorandum to the Code states that, unlike the basic form of the offence regulated in paragraph 1 of the article, as regards the offence of aggravated sexual assault regulated in paragraph 2 of the article it is not a requirement that the perpetrator’s conduct be directed at the satisfaction of sexual desires; consequently, where the perpetrator inserts an object into the victim’s body without any such aim of gratification, the act described in the statutory definition will have been committed. Admittedly, it is appropriate that, as regards the offence of aggravated sexual assault, the perpetrator is not required to have acted in order to gratify his sexual feelings; nevertheless, as it stands the provision is contrary to the “principle of certainty”, one of the important rules of criminal law.
As can be seen, this article conflicts with the principle of certainty, one of the fundamental principles of criminal law, because it is not clear what is to be understood by the expression of inserting an organ or other object into the body. The legislature has used for this article too a method that it applied throughout Law No. 5237 and has stated in the explanatory memorandum to the article what is to be understood by this expression; this, however, is not sufficient to satisfy the principle of legality27. According to the memorandum, what is to be understood by the expression is the act of “introducing an organ or other object into the body by the vaginal, anal or oral route”. The explanatory memorandum to the Code describes the act correctly and clearly; yet the explanatory memorandum is not binding on those who apply the law and at most serves as guidance. For this reason, what criminal law requires is that definitions which make the act contained in the offence type definite and leave no room for the debates mentioned above be included in the statutory definition itself.
For the offence of aggravated sexual assault regulated in Art. 102(2) of the New Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (YTCK), imprisonment of seven to twelve years is prescribed.
III. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage from the Standpoint of Criminal Law
A. Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage in Comparative Law In comparative law the approach to the offence of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage differs from country to country. On the question whether an act of aggravated sexual assault between spouses can be regarded as an offence, countries may be divided into three groups. Those in the first group expressly make the act of aggravated sexual assault an offence where it is committed outside marriage. Those in the second group remain silent on the matter and leave the solution of the problem to legal scholarship and practice. Those in the third group, which has emerged in recent times, expressly state that the act of aggravated sexual assault also constitutes an offence when it is committed within marriage.
Laws which, by including in the statutory definition of the offence of aggravated sexual assault the express phrase “compelling a woman to have extramarital sexual intercourse”, designate as an offence only the case in which the act is committed outside marriage, that is, laws which do not recognise as an offence the act of aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme) committed within marriage, fall into the first group28. Examples of such laws are Art. 187 of the Swiss Criminal Code in the version in force until 01.10.1992, Art. 242 of the Dutch Criminal Code, Chapter 20, §§ 1-2 of the Finnish Criminal Code and Art. 121 of the East German Criminal Code, which is no longer in force today29.
Examples of the laws in the second group, which remain silent on aggravated sexual assault and do not touch on this matter at all, are Art. 519 of the 1930 Italian Criminal Code, Art. 332 of the former French Criminal Code of 1810, Art. 375(1) of the Belgian Criminal Code, Arts. 216-217 of the Danish Criminal Code, Art. 192 of the Norwegian Criminal Code, Art. 168 of the Polish Criminal Code, Art. 265 of the Mexican Criminal Code, Art. 361 of the Chilean Criminal Code and Art. 429 of the Spanish Criminal Code. As stated above, these laws make no mention of the commission of aggravated sexual assault within marriage, but the matter has been debated in legal scholarship and in judicial decisions30. It must be said at once, however, that in the regulations of this group, to which the Criminal Code of our country also belongs, the fact that the act in question is not separately mentioned in the statutory definition of the offence type does not mean that it cannot be committed within marriage; on the contrary, the fact that no distinction is made as regards the perpetrator of the offence shows that this act may perfectly well be committed between married spouses too.
The German regulation on this matter has a particular feature. In its former version, section 177 of the German Criminal Code, in defining the offence of aggravated sexual assault, contained the phrase “whoever compels a woman to have sexual intercourse outside marriage”, so that the commission of the act within marriage was not made an offence. The reform efforts undertaken in Germany with a view to criminalising acts of aggravated sexual assault occurring within marriage ended successfully, and by the amendment made to section 177 of the German Criminal Code the words “outside marriage” were removed from the text of the statute, so that the provision applies to every kind of aggravated sexual assault31. When the text of the statute is read comparatively, with its pre-amendment version in mind, it is seen that the case in which the act is committed within marriage has in fact clearly been brought within the regulation; since, however, this is not stated in the text of the statute, the German Criminal Code too belongs to the second group.
An example of the modern laws in the last group, which expressly make the commission of aggravated sexual assault within marriage an offence, is Art. 190(1) of the Swiss Criminal Code as amended by the law of 21.06.1991 (this law entered into force on 01.10.1992); in paragraph 2 of the article, by making the prosecution of the act subject to complaint “as regards spouses living together”, it is expressly stated that the act of aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme) also constitutes an offence where it is committed within marriage32.
Some important and exemplary developments in the field under examination have also come about through court decisions in Anglo-Saxon law. In Great Britain the question whether an act of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage constitutes an offence was first resolved in Scotland. In the case of Stallard v. Her Majesty’s Advocate, decided in 1989, it was accepted that a husband’s aggravated sexual assault on his wife constitutes an offence even where not so much as a decree of separation has been granted in respect of the spouses33.
In England, by contrast, the commission of the act in question within marriage was for very many years not regarded as an offence. Although the matter came before the courts repeatedly, the English courts held that the act in question did not constitute an offence under the “common law”. However, as a result of the pressure that built up in public opinion under the influence of new thinking on the subject, and of social needs, the House of Lords, sitting with five judges in the case of R. v. R., which came before it on appeal, accepted, referring also to the developments in Scots law on this point, that the commission of aggravated sexual assault within marriage also constitutes the offence of sexual assault34. Lord Keith of Kinkel, who wrote the judgment on behalf of the House of Lords, stated very clearly, in a manner that should serve as an example to the legislatures of all countries, that nowadays a woman no longer loses her character as an individual by marrying and that, as a natural consequence, she is not the property of her husband35.
In the United States of America the situation varies from state to state. The definition of aggravated sexual assault in the USA was generally formulated as “sexual intercourse by a man with a woman – not his wife – without her consent”36. Accordingly, the institution of marriage provided husbands with a “licence” to commit aggravated sexual assault on their wives and also with an “exemption” from being tried for this act37.
The origin of this exemption is traced to the decision of the English judge Sir Matthew Hale mentioned above. According to it, as also stated above, a woman, once married, does not have the right to refuse sexual intercourse with her husband. The immunity from prosecution based on this reasoning remained untouched in the USA until the 1970s, when members of the women’s movement began to contest this decision in order to abolish the exemption deriving from being a spouse and on the ground that it did not protect all women equally against aggravated sexual assault38.
In the USA, on 5 July 1993, aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage (marital rape) was recognised as an offence in all 50 states, in at least one section of the laws that regulate sexual offences. Of these, in 17 states and in the District of Columbia there is no exemption whatsoever granted to husbands in respect of prosecution for aggravated sexual assault39. In the remaining 33 states, however, husbands still enjoy immunities from prosecution40. Where the woman has been badly hurt (has suffered mental/physical harm, has lost consciousness...) and is not in a position to give legally valid consent, the husband is exempt from prosecution in most of these 33 states41.
These immunities from prosecution show the following as regards US law: aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is still characterised as a less serious offence than the other forms of this act. Consequently, this assault is an act deserving less censure than the others, and the view that wives are the property of their husbands and that the marriage contract confers a licence for forced sexual intercourse still holds good in these states42.
B. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage under the TCK No. 765 In Arts. 414 and 416 of the TCK No. 765, which regulate the offence of aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme), the expressions “whoever” and “a person” are used with regard to the perpetrator and the victim. Accordingly, since the statutory definition of the offence type in question contains no specification as regards “wife and husband” and no ground of justification is provided for persons of that status, it must be concluded that acts of rape committed within marriage also fall within this offence type.
However, the traditional view put forward with regard to the commission of aggravated sexual assault between spouses is that the husband cannot be the perpetrator of this offence, because, as regards the offence of aggravated sexual assault, the marital bond constitutes a ground of justification43. According to this view, marriage brings for the spouses the right and the obligation to have sexual intercourse and to consent to sexual intercourse; hence the husband’s wish to have sexual intercourse with his wife is a right for him, and fulfilling this wish of the husband is an obligation for his wife. Accordingly, a husband’s having sexual intercourse with his wife without her consent is not regarded as an offence, and the husband’s sexual acts upon his wife remain outside the protective scope of criminal law44. Moreover, legislating on this matter is not considered right, since it would amount to criminal law interfering in relations within the family45.
Although this is the practice and the prevailing view in legal scholarship under the TCK No. 765, it is stated that the husband’s right to have sexual intercourse without his wife’s consent has a limit, and that where this limit is exceeded and the right is abused the husband will incur liability.
According to this view, since the purposes of marriage include founding a family that also comprises children and ensuring the continuation of the line, it is entirely natural for spouses to have sexual intercourse in order to attain this purpose; where, however, sexual intercourse between the spouses is not performed by the vaginal route, it falls outside the concept of sexual intercourse described above and necessary for marriage, sexual intercourse performed by a non-vaginal route is not accepted as a ground of justification, and the act thus constitutes an offence. However, where sexual intercourse between spouses is performed by a non-vaginal route against the will of the spouse, legal scholarship regards this act not as the offence of aggravated sexual assault regulated in Art. 416 of the TCK No. 765 but as the “offence of ill-treatment of family members” regulated in Art. 478(1)-(3)46; indeed, this view of legal scholarship is also to be seen in the settled decisions of the Court of Cassation47.
As stated above, as far as the regulation in Art. 416 of the TCK No. 765 is concerned, there is in fact nothing that prevents an act of aggravated sexual assault between spouses within marriage from being regarded as an offence and the perpetrator from being punished48. Under the regulation of the TCK No. 765, the reason why aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is not treated as an offence lies in the mistaken views in legal scholarship and in erroneous practice49. Nevertheless, the prevailing view in legal scholarship and the Court of Cassation accept the opposite view and do not regard the act of aggravated sexual assault as an offence, however it may be committed. Only where this act is committed against the spouse not by the vaginal route but by a different route, such as the anal or oral one, is it regarded as the “offence of ill-treatment of family members”. This is the product of an old system of thought that has now been abandoned and that, in particular, regards women as second-class beings.
C. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage under the YTCK No. 5237 Although the prevailing view in Turkish criminal law scholarship is as set out above, some authors, influenced in particular by comparative law, have formed their views on the subject under the influence of these modern systems and have approached the subject from a very different angle. These authors have pointed out that in the legal systems of modern countries the legal interest protected by sexual offences has undergone a change, and that the legal interest protected in sexual offences in general and in the offence of sexual assault in particular is the individual’s sexual freedom and hence sexual inviolability. Consequently these authors state that acts of sexual assault committed within marriage must also be regarded as offences because they violate the individual’s sexual freedom. According to those who hold this view, where one of the spouses refuses sexual intercourse, the other spouse has the right to seek divorce or separation, and that right alone50.
As is also seen in the decision of the House of Lords referred to above, the traditional view that by marrying a woman grants her husband the power to deal with her body as he pleases has nowadays been abandoned. According to the new view that has developed in this field, a woman’s bodily integrity and sexual inviolability must be protected by the legal order without any distinction between the married and the unmarried51; this is the task of the law. A woman must be protected by criminal law against attacks on her body, wherever the attack may come from, be it a person she does not know at all, her boyfriend, the person she lives with or the husband to whom she is married, and such attacks must be regulated as an offence type in the criminal code.
It is these modern views in comparative law and in legal scholarship that were influential when the provisions on sexual offences were drafted in the YTCK No. 5237. Thus the offences of sexual assault, which in the TCK No. 765 were regulated under the heading of felonies against public decency and family order, have been regulated as a separate chapter, in Chapter Six, entitled “offences against sexual inviolability”, of Part Two, entitled offences against persons, of Book Two of the new Code. An important consequence of this manner of regulation is that it has made clear what legal interest these offences protect, a matter that was an important point of criticism in respect of the former Code. Accordingly, the legal interest protected by the offences of sexual assault is the individual’s sexual freedom and hence the individual’s sexual inviolability; indeed, this is expressly stated in the explanatory memorandum to Art. 102 of the YTCK, which regulates the offence of sexual assault. This regulation has been influential in the acceptance that acts of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage also constitute an offence.
As stated above, Art. 102 of the YTCK regulates the “offence of sexual assault”, and in regulating this offence type what was placed under protection was not the honour of the husband, the family or other third parties, but the individual’s sexual inviolability. In doing so, the distinction between the married and the unmarried was also removed. However, because, although Law No. 765 did not make this distinction either, such a distinction was drawn in legal scholarship and practice and an erroneous view and practice became established, a provision relating to the law of criminal procedure was included in the second sentence of Art. 102(2), stating that where the act of aggravated sexual assault is committed within marriage it is an offence whose prosecution is subject to complaint. Thus, as in the regulation made in the Swiss Criminal Code, under the YTCK No. 5237 too it has been expressly laid down that the act of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is an offence.
Since no distinction is made in respect of this offence as to the sex of the perpetrator or the victim, in the offence of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage the perpetrator or the victim may be a man or a woman. Law No. 765 did not make this distinction either, but legal scholarship and practice stated that, for rape to be committed, the male sexual organ had to enter the woman’s vagina or the man’s or woman’s anus. Since the YTCK No. 5237, by contrast, expressly states that the act may be committed by inserting an organ or any other object, a discriminatory interpretation proceeding from the distinction of the “sexual organ” has also been precluded. Under this regulation, a woman too may perfectly well commit the offence of aggravated sexual assault by inserting an artificial penis into a man’s anus or mouth.
Among the many responsibilities and obligations that spouses mutually assume within marriage is also the satisfaction of each other’s sexual desires. However, as the explanatory memorandum to the article also rightly states, the solution to, and in a sense the sanction for, the failure to fulfil these responsibilities and obligations is the institution of divorce regulated in the Turkish Civil Code. It is in no way acceptable for one of the spouses, against the will of the other and by using force, to have sexual intercourse with the other. Since 1 June 2005, when the YTCK entered into force, acts of this kind committed within marriage are regarded as offences, and the spouse who commits such an act commits an offence.
This regulation is very apt, especially with regard to women, who are physically weaker and in need of protection. This article of the Code is therefore a very important advance in terms of the bodily and intellectual freedom of the woman as an individual; at least with this article, even if only on the normative plane, the married woman has become the holder of rights over her own body.
It must be said at once, however, that the commission of the basic form of this offence by spouses should also have been made an offence. This conclusion is reached when it is considered that the legal interests protected by both the basic form and the aggravated form of the offence of sexual assault are the same and that the basic form of the offence may also have adverse consequences for the victim, and when it is borne in mind that the commission of this offence type by a spouse is in any event an offence whose prosecution is subject to complaint52.
IV. The Offence of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage from the Standpoint of Victimology
A. The Situation in Our Country and the Studies Carried Out in This Field With the recognition in the criminal code of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage as an offence type, the problem has been overcome only from the normative point of view. This, however, is not a complete solution to the phenomenon of sexual assault within marriage as a whole; at most it is the removal of the visible part of the iceberg. The large, invisible part of the iceberg consists in examining this phenomenon from the standpoint of the sciences of criminology and victimology and in providing the victims of the offence with support for the severe trauma that follows the act.
Before turning to the explanation of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage from the victim’s point of view, the following observation has to be made. In our country, statistical data produced in the field of criminology and victimology by using scientific methods and carrying out field studies, and scientific studies evaluating such data, are almost non-existent. And when such studies are carried out, albeit in limited number, the questions relating to sexuality in particular go unanswered because of the pressure that society exerts on individuals.
A study on this subject carried out in our country that is both recent and comprehensive and that, in its very good evaluation of the data, is of an exemplary
___________________________________________________ nature was conducted by the Research and Application Centre for Criminal Law and Criminology of the Istanbul University Faculty of Law, and this study and its results, together with the evaluations of the data obtained, were presented to the 13th World Congress of Criminology (XIII. World Congress of Criminology) held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, on 10 – 15 August 200353.
An evaluation of the data of this research rightly states that domestic violence is a reality in our country and that, in particular, sexual offences committed within the family are reaching ever more alarming proportions54. An important finding to be drawn from this study, however, is that the total number of persons who took part in the survey was 1133, that of these 31 persons answered the question put on sexual violence within the family, while the great majority, 1102 persons, refrained from answering this question. Considering also that the 31 persons who answered this question said that they had not been subjected to sexual harassment, it can readily be said that in our country there is still an unwillingness to disclose acts of sexual assault that take place within the family.
Victimology shows that the victims of sexual offences are one of the groups of victims who suffer most among the victims of the many other offence types; that, despite this, owing to many factors the victims of these offences are reluctant to bring the offence to light; and that, as a result, there is a very large dark figure55 in respect of these offence types56.
In fact, according to various studies, it is stated that acts of sexual assault occur most often and most widely between spouses; that the part consisting of physical assault and wounding (müessir fiil) is made the subject of a complaint, whereas the part consisting of aggravated sexual assault is, as it were, concealed; and that there are very diverse reasons for this concealment and for not applying to the judicial authorities57.
It is seen that there are four basic reasons why offences of sexual assault largely fail to come to light. The first reason is that victims, in order to free themselves as quickly as possible from the trauma caused by the act, do not pursue the matter and lodge a complaint against the perpetrator, and try to forget it and push it into the subconscious. The second reason is that cultural prejudices concerning sexual offences, and society as the bearer of that culture, put pressure on victims, and that victims who shrink from this pressure do not dare to lodge a complaint against the perpetrator. The third reason is that, because of the feeling of shame the victim experiences, the victim does not wish to disclose the matter to others, and that the public officials who are to hear and assess the complaint and the incident do not show the necessary help and sensitivity either. The fourth reason is that the victim believes that it is for the victim to prove the act suffered and, both not knowing how to do so and foreseeing that it will be difficult, gives up the idea of lodging a complaint.
All of these reasons also apply to acts of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage. In addition, however, there are several further reasons that contribute to acts of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage remaining a dark figure. The first of these is that the act in question “takes place in the bedroom of a married couple, in other words at the most intimate point of the marriage”, and that this is an important factor preventing “female victims in whose minds the idea of the sanctity of privacy has been engraved” from resorting to legal remedies58. Another important factor is that, because in the patriarchal family order widespread in our country the man is always placed in the foreground and girls are taught from an early age that he has rights over his wife, victims are unable to perceive that the act performed on their bodies is unlawful. A last important factor to be mentioned here is that until very recently this act was not accepted as an offence type in legal scholarship and practice and that, as a natural consequence, married women in particular have no knowledge that acts of this kind are an offence.
It is for these reasons that we have no data for our country with which to assess acts of aggravated sexual assault within marriage and to determine the situation of the victim as a result of such an act. For this reason, an attempt will be made to explain the subject by taking into account the research carried out in the United States of America (USA) in particular, where a large number of studies have been conducted in this field.
B. The Occurrence of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage It should first be noted that the great majority of the research carried out on this subject is based on surveys and/or interviews concerning the experiences of women who have been subjected to sexual assault. An important point to be borne in mind regarding the results of this research is that, while these results may fail to show women who have been sexually assaulted by their husbands for years but have never spoken about it, they may also overstate the number of women who have been sexually assaulted, because this research mostly uses women victims of sexual assault who are in women’s shelters59. The assessments made below should also be read subject to this reservation.
Despite this reservation, the research in question provides very important explanatory data on the structure of the act of aggravated sexual assault60 committed within marriage and, in particular, on the effects it leaves on its victims, and the subject will be explained below on the basis of this research.
There are two further important points to be made here. The first is that, in explaining below the situation of the victims affected by this act, only “women” have been taken into account, because in all the sources consulted the subject was examined from the standpoint of women victims and the research was conducted on women victims. In the ordinary course of life too, it is overwhelmingly women who become the victims of this offence: women who, first, cannot resist this act because of their physical weakness and who, afterwards, do not lodge a complaint owing to the various factors listed above. Although we have come across no such case, an act of aggravated sexual assault within marriage of which a man is the victim, if it exists at all, constitutes an exceptional situation.
The second point to be made is that the marriages taken into account in the examination of this act are marriages between one woman and one man. Today, particularly in some Western European countries, legislation has been enacted allowing persons of the same sex to enter into marriage as well. For the present, however, no study on aggravated sexual assault within marriage covers homosexuals and lesbians, even where they are married61.
1. The Social Situation of the Victims
A striking finding as regards the social situation of the victims is that the act under examination occurs in marriages in all social strata, irrespective of age, social class, ethnic origin and family. One of the very comprehensive studies on this subject established that women from different age groups had been subjected to aggravated sexual assault by their spouses. 2/3 of these women were first raped by their husbands when they were under the age of 2562.
As regards social class, it is stated that it is difficult to make an assessment63. According to a study conducted in the USA, women belonging to the middle class in socio-economic terms become victims of this offence in smaller numbers; again according to this study, the proportion of women who are victims of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is higher among black women than among women of Latin American origin, white women and Asian women64. In another study conducted in the USA, it is stated that victims of sexual assault who are at a low socio-economic level report aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage at a higher rate65.
An important conclusion reached as a result of the research conducted in the USA concerns the tendency of women subjected to aggravated sexual assault within marriage to leave their husbands as a result of this act. According to this, the rate at which women of Latin American origin describe this act directed against them as “aggravated sexual assault” and end their relationships is lower than for other women. Some women of the same origin also regard having sexual intercourse as a duty attaching to marriage66. This finding sheds light on our country as well; for, as is well known, the most widespread religious belief in Latin America is the Catholic denomination of Christianity, and according to this denomination the woman belongs to her home and her husband; it is quite natural that women brought up in this belief do not characterise the act performed on their bodies as sexual assault and perceive it as a duty of marriage. The same holds true for Islam, which is the faith of the individuals who make up the great majority in our country. According to the teachings of this religion too, a woman must be ready at any moment to have sexual intercourse with her husband and must never say no when her husband wishes to have sexual intercourse. For this reason, in our country too religious belief is an important factor in this act not being perceived as sexual assault and in its being characterised as a duty for the woman. Consequently, this understanding is also one of the reasons why this question was left unanswered in the above-mentioned study carried out by the Research and Application Centre for Criminal Law and Criminology of the Istanbul University Faculty of Law. For in our country the great majority of married women still do not perceive the act of forcing sexual intercourse within marriage as conduct that ought not to occur, let alone as an offence.
Another similarity between the conclusion reached with regard to women of Latin American origin and the women of our country is the reluctance of women who have been subjected to aggravated sexual assault within marriage to leave their husbands. Women of Latin American origin living in the USA are generally poor people who have immigrant status or have only recently acquired citizenship and who are at the lowest level in socio-economic terms. In their families it is generally only the husband who works and provides for the household; even where the women work, they do so in temporary jobs, for low pay and without social security. Even if these women define the act in question committed within marriage as aggravated sexual assault, they are unable to leave their husbands, on whom they are dependent because of their economic weakness. It is a known fact that the same situation applies to a great many women in our country. For this reason, even where women in our country are victims of the offence of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage, since they do not have such an option as separating from the husbands who commit this act, they regard it as their fate and endure this form of violence.
Indeed, confirming the explanation given above, a study conducted in the USA shows that white women continue to live with husbands who have committed aggravated sexual assault against them at a lower rate than black women and women of Latin and Asian origin. It is thus seen that economic power plays a particularly important role in the ability of women who are sexually assaulted by their husbands to end their marriages. Accordingly, it is seen that the women who are highly likely to be able to end their marriages are the women who have attained economic independence67.
Another important conclusion drawn from this study is that traditional women who behave in accordance with the sex roles assigned to them hold themselves responsible for the aggravated sexual assault of which they are victims and for the fact that they still continue to live with their husbands68. It can readily be said that the same holds true for the great majority of women in our country, who behave in accordance with the roles assigned to them.
2. Types of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage
The research conducted shows that acts of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage occur together with other forms of violence69. On this basis, researchers have found that aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is an extension of domestic violence70. On the other hand, that this act is an extension of domestic violence is the result of a logical inference, for the research also shows that most of the women subjected to aggravated sexual assault by their husbands were at the same time battered / beaten. In this type, referred to as “battering rape”, the victim is subjected to both sexual and physical violence71.
Women who are sexually assaulted and battered by their husbands experience various forms of violence together; some are battered during the sexual assault, while others experience an episode of physical violence after the sexual assault; some, again, experience sexual assaults containing “sadistic” and “obsessive” elements, which involve torture, perverse sexual acts and physical violence. Sexual assault committed in a sadistic manner frequently also contains pornographic elements72.
In response to this view, some researchers state that aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage should not be examined under the heading of “domestic violence”, because assessments of this kind made in earlier periods prevented aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage from being considered as a separate problem in its own right73.
Indeed, aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage should be defined as an autonomous problem, because for many women who are subjected to it and battered this act is devastating and destructive. The resulting trauma must therefore be specifically addressed by those providing help74. It should also be noted that not all women victims of sexual assault within marriage have also been battered, for some women who state that they have been sexually assaulted within marriage state that they have not been battered/beaten. It should be noted that most of the research on aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage has been obtained from women who have also been subjected to physical violence. This methodological problem may overstate the rate at which women are both battered and sexually assaulted by their partners. Indeed, Russell found that 4% of women who had never married had been subjected to aggravated sexual assault by their partners but had not been battered75.
In the type of aggravated sexual assault termed “force – only rape” by Finkelhor and Yllo, husbands use force only to frighten, coerce and compel their wives, but engage in no battering beyond the act they commit76. For this reason, to regard aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage merely as an extension of domestic violence would mean excluding and setting apart the women who are subjected to aggravated sexual assault without being battered. Therefore, particularly in order to provide medical, psychological and legal support to the victims of this offence, it must be accepted that aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is both a form of aggravated sexual assault and a form of domestic violence.
Another aspect of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is that the victims of this act, compared with other women sexually assaulted by persons close to them, have been forced to engage in unwanted oral and anal sexual intercourse as well77. Since this too is done against their will, it makes the matter even worse.
Husbands generally sexually assault their wives while they are asleep, by making verbal threats, by using physical violence, or by using a weapon in order to force them into intercourse. Another important conclusion reached in the research is that men who sexually assault their wives and use physical violence against them are particularly dangerous, are highly likely to injure their wives severely and have the potential to carry the violence they inflict as far as murder78.
3. Persons at Risk and the Factors Giving Rise to the Risk
Most of the research on this subject accepts that aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is a form of violence. It is further stated that husbands use their physical superiority as a means of trying to establish dominance and supremacy over their wives, and that the act of sexual assault they commit is a manifestation of this. For this reason, although it is not possible to draw up a general profile of the persons who commit the act in question, it is stated that they are generally persons who are jealous, authoritarian and individualistic and who think of sexual intercourse as being with their own property79.
Having made this observation about the perpetrators of this act, it is seen that, as regards exposure to this act too, some women are at greater risk than others. In particular, as stated above, women who have been battered/beaten by their husbands are highly likely to be sexually assaulted by their husbands80. In addition, the fact that the woman is pregnant emerges as a high-probability factor for being subjected to physical/sexual humiliation81. Being ill or having just been discharged from hospital is also a risk factor for women82.
Another fact emerging from the research conducted with battered/beaten women is that, when these women attempt to leave the persons who batter/beat them, this attempt constitutes, for those who commit this act, a challenge, and this gives rise to a high risk, in particular of experiencing physical and sexual violence. For the attempt of the wives they assault to separate from them has the effect of a challenge on husbands and makes them even more aggressive. According to the research carried out by Finkelhor and Yllo, 2/3 of the women making up the sample group were sexually assaulted at the end of their relationships83. According to the data obtained in other research in this field too, women who separate from their partners or divorce their husbands constitute a group at high risk of sexual assault84.
C. The Effects of Aggravated Sexual Assault Committed within Marriage on the Victims Despite the historical myth that regards a woman’s being sexually assaulted by her husband as a relatively insignificant event causing little trauma, the research on this subject has in fact revealed that aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage produces very severe and long-lasting effects85. These effects leave both physical and psychological marks on the victim.
The following are cited as the physical manifestations of the trauma suffered by the women who are victims of this act. According to the research carried out by Campbell and Alford, half of the women subjected to this act were beaten and/or burned during sexual intercourse. The specific gynaecological consequences of this act are stated to be vaginal stretching, miscarriage, anal infections, infertility and the potential spread of sexually transmitted diseases including AIDS86.
The psychological side of the trauma suffered by the victims is far worse and more lasting. These victims are in all likelihood sexually assaulted more than once and fall into a deep crisis of trust. It is seen that the persons who are victims of this act are exposed to severe and long-lasting effects87. As with other victims of aggravated sexual assault, some of the short-term effects of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage observed in the victim are anxiety, shock, intense worry, depression, thoughts of suicide, post-event trauma and a heightened level of anxiety88. When women sexually assaulted by their husbands are compared with women sexually assaulted by persons wholly unknown to them, those in the first group show high rates of signs of anger and depression89.
The long-term psychological effects of this act on the victim manifest themselves as disordered eating, sleep problems, depression, problems of trust in relationships and increased negative feelings about themselves90.
An important piece of information revealed by the research is that the psychological effects are in all likelihood long-lasting. Some women subjected to this act state that, even though years have passed, they experience flashbacks, sexual dysfunction and emotional pain91.
D. The Approach of the Judicial Authorities to Victims and the Support That Must Be Provided
1. The Approach of the Judicial Authorities to Victims
As with many offence types, in this offence type too the person to whom victims turn after the criminal act and whom they first encounter is the police officer; important duties therefore fall to the police. In all offences of aggravated sexual assault the police must carry out the necessary initial intervention both in order to clear up the offence and so that the victim can more easily overcome the trauma suffered.
It is stated that police officers may be reluctant to help the victim when they learn that the act of aggravated sexual assault took place within marriage92. In such a case the police may refrain from responding to the victims’ call, may refuse to open a complaint file, or may be unwilling to go with the victim to a specialist doctor in order to obtain scientific evidence93. It is stated that the police must be trained in this matter and that it is essential for them to be informed about how women who are victims of this act should be approached94.
Here it must be ensured that rape victims can easily reach the police immediately after the incident. For many women, and especially in our country for a married woman who has been sexually assaulted by her husband, going to the local police station and making a report to the police is no easy matter. To this end, rape support lines should be set up in police stations by means of the possibilities offered by communications technology, and it should be ensured that police officers who are trained and supervised in this matter respond to the incident as soon as a call comes in. Indeed, a very effective structure of this kind has been set up in the English police force and is still in operation95. Establishing a similar structure in our country too would be extremely appropriate for supporting the victims of this offence and for apprehending and punishing its perpetrators.
The adjudicating, prosecuting and defence authorities that make up the machinery of justice do not attach sufficient importance to the case in which the offence of aggravated sexual assault is committed within marriage and may think that this is a normal situation that can occur within a marriage. This is due in particular to the influence of the old ideas on this subject, which have come down through the centuries and become entrenched. Today, however, this act too is expressly defined as an offence in criminal codes, and the perpetrators of this act must also be investigated and prosecuted. For this reason, public prosecutors in particular, when faced with a complaint of this kind, must heed the matter and take it seriously, as with other offences of aggravated sexual assault, and must open the necessary investigation immediately. Likewise, once a case has been brought on the matter and the prosecution stage has begun, the adjudicating authorities must conduct a meticulous trial that protects the victim, bearing in mind also the particular nature of the case.
Here important duties fall to the lawyers who will stand by the women victims in bringing acts of this kind to light and in having the perpetrators punished. In particular, in the sections of the bar associations that work on women’s issues, lawyers should also undergo special training on how to approach acts of this kind and their victims.
However, in applying to the judicial authorities, the reservations of all victims of aggravated sexual assault in general, and the negative experiences they undergo, also apply, particularly and to an even greater degree, to victims subjected to this act within marriage; this in turn causes the dark figures for these offences to rise.
Several matters are pointed to as the reasons why these offences are not reported to the judicial authorities. It is stated that some victims do not report the offence so as not to relive over and over again the trauma resulting from the act, because at the police station and in court the trauma is relived and kept alive by being recounted again and again. It is also said that some victims do not report it in order to avoid being confronted with the accusation, which exists as a prejudice, that they themselves encouraged the perpetrators. It is stated that a further group of victims, although they set out to report it, do not do so, out of a feeling of shame and for reasons such as the indifference and insensitivity of the official authorities and the lack of understanding shown to the victim by the police and the prosecutor96. In addition to these reasons, which apply to all offences of aggravated sexual assault, a further negative factor for the victims of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage is the reluctance of the judicial authorities to perceive this act as an offence and their tendency to see it as a normal occurrence that can happen within a marriage, and hence their reluctance to conduct an investigation into it.
To prevent this, the police should pay greater attention to protecting the victims of this offence when hearing them; taking statements from these persons repeatedly should be avoided; care should be taken as far as possible that the statement is not taken by more than one officer; and if this is absolutely necessary, it should be ensured that the same officer takes the second statement. Care should also be taken that the officers taking the statement have received training in this field and, in particular, are of the same sex as the victim. When the statement is taken, an effort should be made to create a relaxed and sincere atmosphere, and it should be ensured that the interview is not interrupted for unnecessary reasons97.
This sensitivity towards the victim, which begins to be shown at the police in the first stage of the investigation, must also be ensured, in a manner compatible with the rules of procedure, at the public prosecutor’s office in the later stage of the investigation and in court during the prosecution98.
2. The Support That Must Be Provided to Victims
Experts estimate that victims subjected to aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage are less likely than victims subjected to other acts of aggravated sexual assault to report the assault on them to the persons or organisations that provide support in this field, to family members or to friends99.
According to the research, women sexually assaulted by acquaintances report the assault at a lower rate than women sexually assaulted by a stranger100. Moreover, reporting an act of this kind committed within marriage may become complicated for the victim because of her relationship with the perpetrator. Women subjected to aggravated sexual assault by their husbands may hesitate to disclose it; the reasons given for this include family loyalty, fear of retaliation by the assailant, the victim’s inability to break off the relationship, or not knowing that this act constitutes an offence101.
Another important reason why the women who are victims of this act do not disclose it is that they do not define the act as aggravated sexual assault. While some women define only aggravated sexual assault committed by strangers as a real sexual assault, some women perceive such an act, even if carried out by force, as an obligation under the marital union and a woman’s duty. The bad side of this is that, where women who think in this way do not define the act that has occurred as sexual assault, it will not be possible to provide support from outside in order to stop this violence102.
As regards support for victims, it is stated that those subjected to this act do not find the necessary attention and support when they seek support. The persons and organisations that fail to show this necessary attention are the police, the adjudicating and defence bodies, and the counsellors of the institutions that support women
(103) .
It is stated that there are two important sources of support for the victims of aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage. These are identified as shelters for women subjected to violence/battered women and sexual assault crisis centres104. As for comparable institutions, in our country in particular there are women’s shelters, but apart from these there are no sexual assault crisis centres.
It is stated that the best sexual assault crisis centres, and those with equipment, staff and organisation fit to serve as an example to the whole world, are to be found in the countries of Northern Europe, and that different institutions there work very well, in harmony and towards the same goal. For example, it is said that in the model applied in Iceland, among these, rehabilitative work is carried out step by step for the post-traumatic condition of the persons who are victims of this offence, while at the same time evidence is collected from the victim’s body for a possible complaint and investigation
(105) .
The research shows that the majority of these structures too fail to address aggravated sexual assault committed within marriage adequately106. For while the programmes there and the training of the staff cover the other forms of aggravated sexual assault, the case in which it is committed within marriage has been neglected. It is stated that, if importance were attached to this matter, support could be given to a great many women victims.
Conclusion
Two different but interconnected conclusions have been reached in this study. The first is the conclusion concerning the regulation of acts of this kind on the normative plane, both in comparative law and in the law of our country; the other is the conclusion reached, from the standpoint of victimology, concerning the trauma experienced by the women subjected to this act and the support provided to them.
On the normative plane, in comparative law the offences of sexual assault were first removed from the category of offences against public morality and decency and, with the legal interest they protect correctly identified, were regulated as offences against sexual freedom; subsequently, and particularly from the 1990s onwards, the commission of offences of sexual assault within marriage was also made an offence. It should not be forgotten, however, that in many states of the USA this is still not the case and that being a “husband” confers immunity in offences of sexual assault.
As for our country, it was with the New Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (YTCK), which entered into force on 1 June 2005, that both the regulation of the offences of sexual assault on the basis of sexual freedom, the legal interest they protect, and the coverage of their commission within marriage became possible. It must be said at once that this has been one of the most positive and most praiseworthy provisions of the new criminal code, which has been criticised in many respects. In this way the outdated distinctions drawn by the majority view in legal scholarship and by the Court of Cassation have also been done away with.
Viewed from the standpoint of victimology, however, a regrettably sad picture emerges. In many parts of the world and of our country, individuals shaped by social and religious views regard sexual intercourse with their spouses as a right and exercise it even by force. The truly striking aspect of the matter is that women too define this as a right of their husbands and a duty of their own and do not characterise this act as sexual assault. This becomes more pronounced particularly as one moves down to the lower socio-economic levels; this once again proves the fact that the base determines the superstructure. In our country the matter takes on an even graver form: in the surveys conducted, our women refrain even from answering the questions on this subject.
As regards support for the women who are victims of this act, both other countries and our country fall short, because aggravated sexual assault is always perceived as an act committed by strangers and it is not thought, in particular, that it can occur between spouses. For this reason, the police, the machinery of justice and the civil society organisations, which ought to provide support in this field, do not receive the necessary training on the subject and/or do not wish to become involved in the matter.
In this situation, which involves long-term trauma, the matter must be approached exclusively by trained experts, and the women who are victims must be offered a complete support service at every stage.
Finally, it must be said that the people who gave birth to us, the people we share our lives with, the people to whom we owe something, or our friends, are women; and these women, even if they are married, are individuals, and they alone hold the rights and the say over their own bodies. For this reason, as a society both men and women must first attain this awareness, and both sexes must be educated about and protected against every kind of sexual assault and abuse.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Agnarsdottir, Gudrun, “Tecavüze Uğrayan ve Cinsel Tacize Maruz Kalan Kadına Acil Servis’te ve Tecavüz Kriz Merkezi’nde Yaklaşımlar”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.68-72.
Arın Canın, “Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddet”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.8-11.
Artuk, Mehmet Emin/Ahmet Gökcen/A. Caner Yenidünya, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 6. Bası, Ankara, Turhan Kitabevi, 2005.
Artuk, Mehmet Emin, “Kadına Yönelik Cinsel İstismara Örnek Olarak Evlilik İçinde Irza Geçme ve Fücur”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.31-48.
Artuk, Mehmet Emin/A. Caner Yenidünya, “Evlilik İçinde Irza Geçme”, Cumhuriyet’in 75. Yıl Armağanı, İstanbul Üniversitesi Yayını, İstanbul 1999, s.57-70.
Barshis, V., “The Question of Marital Rape”, Women's Studies International Forum, S.6 , 1983, s.383-393.
Bergen, Raquel Kennedy, Wife Rape: Understanding the Response of Survivors and Service Providers, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage Publications, 1996.
Bergen, Raquel Kennedy, “Maritial Rape”, National Electronic Network on Violence Against Women, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.vaw.umn.edu/documents/vawnet/mrape/ mrape.html#bergen1996, 12.03.2005.
Bidwell, L./P. White, “The Family Context of Marital Rape”, The Journal of Family Violence, S.1, 1986, s.277-287.
Browne, Angele, When Battered Women Kill, New York, The Free Press, 1987, s.95-103.
Campbell, J. C., “Women's Responses to Sexual Abuse in Intimate Relationships”, Health Care for Women International, S.10, 1989, s.335-346.
Campbell, J. C./P. Alford, “The Dark Consequences of Marital Rape”, American Journal of Nursing, 1989, s.946-949.
Centel, Nur, “Cinsel Suç Mağduru Kadının Korunması”, Prof. Dr. Kenan Tunçomağ’a Armağan, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Eğitim Öğretim ve Yardımlaşma Vakfı Yayını, 1997, s.59-70.
Dobash, R. Emerson/Russell P. Dobash, Women, Violence and Social Change; London, Routledge. 1992.
Donald, Bernice Bouie, “Amerikan Hukuku’nun Cinsel Suçlara Yaklaşımı”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.24-30.
Dönmezer, Sulhi, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1975.
Dönmezer, Sulhi, “IX. Milletlararası Ceza Hukuku Kongresi ve Cinsiyet Ahlakına Karşı Suçlar”, İÜHFM, C.XXX, S.3-4, 1964, s.451-465.
Erdal, Meryem, “Cezasızlık, UCMK ve Tecavüze İlişkin Tanımlar”, Humanite, S.5, Nisan-Mayıs 2004, s.112-120.
Erman Gül, “Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddet”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.15-23.
Finkelhor, David/Kersti Yllo, License to Rape: Sexual Abuse of Wives, New York, Free Press, 1987.
Frieze, I., “Investigating The Causes and Consequences of Marital Rape” Journal of Women in Culture and Society, S.8, 1983, s.532-553.
Groth, Nicholas/H. Jean Birnbaum, Men Who Rape: The Physchology Of The Offender, New York, Plenum Press, 1984.
İçel, Kayıhan, “Sunuş”, Suçla Mücadele Bağlamında Türkiye’de Aile İçi Şiddet: Ülke Çapında Kriminolojik – Viktimolojik Alan Araştırması ve Değerlendirilmesi, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2003, s.5,6.
Johnson, Ida M./Robert T. Sigler, Forced Sexual Intercourse in Intimate Relationships, New York, New York University Press, 1997.
Karakaş, Fatma, “Evlilik İçi Cinsel Tecavüz Bağlamında, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddet ve AİHM’nin Yaklaşımı”, Humanite, S.6, Haziran-Temmuz 2004, s.115- 132.
Kırbıyık, Şerife, Irza Geçme Cürmü ve Benzer Suçlardan Ayrımı, Ankara, Sözkesen Matbaacılık, 2001.
Kilpatrick, D. G./C. C. Best/B. E. Saunders/L. J. Vernon, “Rape in Marriage and in Dating Relationships: How Bad is it for Mental Health?”, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, S. 528, 1988, s.335-344, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.annalsnyas. org/content/ vol528/issue1/, 17.03.2005.
Koss, M. P./T. E. Dinero/C. A. Siebel/S. L. Cox, “Stranger and Acquaintance Rape: Are There Differences in Victim's Experiences?”, Psychology of Women Quarterly, S.12, 1988, s.1-24.
Kurz, Demie, For Richer for Poorer: Mothers Confront Divorce, New York, Routledge, 1995, s.66.
Mahoney, Patricia/Linda M. Williams, “Sexual Assault in Marriage: Prevalence, Consequences And Treatment of Wife Rape” Partner Violence: A Comprehensi-
ve Review of 20 Years of Research, Ed: J. Jasinski/L. Williams, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage Publications, 1998, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.agnr.umd.edu/nnfr/research/pv/ pv_ch5.html, 17.03.2005.
Nuhoğlu Ayşe, “Cinsel Suç Mağdurunun Beyanı ve İspat”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.49-67.
Oral, Mehmet, Irza Geçme Suçu, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi (İstanbul Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Kamu Hukuku Anabilim Dalı), İstanbul, 1994.
Önder, Ayhan, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 4. Bası, İstanbul, Filiz Kitapevi, 1994.
Örücü, Esin, “Karşılaştırmalı Hukuk’ta Evlilik Birliği İçinde Irza Geçme”, İstanbul Barosu Dergisi, C.66, S.1-2-3, 1992, s.90-105.
Özden, Cevdet, “Irza Geçme Cürmü”, Adalet Dergisi, C.II, S.11-12, 1946, s.1176-1193, 1334-1355.
Pagelow, M., “Adult Victims of Domestic Violence” Journal of Interpersonal Violence, S.7, 1992, s.87-120
Peacock, P.L., Marital Rape “Intimate Betrayal”, Ed: V. Wiehe/A. Richards, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage Publications, 1995 s.55-73.
Rice, Philip F., Human Sexuality, Portland, William C. Brown Pub, 1989.
Russell, Diana E. H., Rape in Marriage, Expanded and Revised Edition with a New Introduction, Indiana Universty Press, 1990.
Saunders, D. G./P. B. Size, Attitudes About Woman Abuse Among Police Officers, Victims, and Victims' Advocates. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, S.1, 1986, s.25-42.
Selçuk, Sami, Karşıoylarım: Hukukumuzda Tartışılan Hükümler ve İçtihatlar, Der: Cengiz Otacı, Ankara, Turhan Kitabevi, 2001, s.433-438.
Serozan, Rona, Miras Hukuku, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2000.
Sınar, Hasan, “Evlilik İçinde Irza Geçme Eylemi Üzerine Düşünceler”, Yayınlanmamış Doktora Seminer Ödevi, 2000.
Sokullu Akıncı, Füsun, Viktimoloji, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1999.
Sokullu Akıncı, Füsun, Kriminoloji, İstanbul, 1994.
Soyaslan, Doğan, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, Ankara, 1997.
Thompson/Haas, Marital Rape: Methods of Helping and Healing, Unpublished Manuscript, 1987.
Tuna, Yalçın, “Irza Geçme Üzerine Mukayeseli İnceleme”, Adalet Dergisi, C:IL- VI, S.4-5-6, 1955, s.331-357, 466-477, 558-568.
Ünver, Yener, “Türkiye’de Aile İçi Şiddetin Boyutları, Nedenleri ve Çözüm Önerileri”, Suçla Mücadele Bağlamında Türkiye’de Aile İçi Şiddet: Ülke Çapında Kriminolojik – Viktimolojik Alan Araştırması ve Değerlendirilmesi, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2003, s.11-71.
Ünver, Yener, “Özellikle Cinsel Suçlar Alanında Olmak Üzere Kadınlarla İlgili Ceza Hukuku Normlarındaki Değişim ve Türkiye’deki Durum”, Adalet Yüksekokulu 20. Yıl Armağanı, İstanbul, 2001, s.293-350.
Whatley, M., “For Better or Worse: The Case of Marital Rape”, Violence and Victims, S.8, s.29-39.
Yarsuvat, Duygun, “Türk Ceza Kanununda Cinsel Özgürlüğe Karşı Suçlar”, Değişen Toplum ve Ceza Hukuku Karşısında TCK’nın 50 Yılı ve Geleceği, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1977, s.647-684.
Yarsuvat, Duygun, “Mukayeseli Hukukta Cinsi Suçlar”, İÜHFM, C.XXX, S.1-2, 1964, s.115-170.
Yearnshire, Stephanie, “Aile İçi Şiddet ve Tecavüz Konularında Yasal İhtilaflar Polisin Yaklaşımı”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.73-86.
Yokuş Sevük, Handan, “5237 Sayılı Türk Ceza Kanunu’nda Cinsel Saldırı ve Cinsel Taciz Suçları”, Türkiye Barolar Birliği Dergisi, S.57, Mart-Nisan 2005, s.243-282.
Footnotes
- This article concerning our women is respectfully dedicated to the cherished memory of Attorney Gül Erman, a human being and a woman who stood tall and unbowed. ↑
- Attorney-at-law; doctoral student in the Department of Public Law, Institute of Social Sciences, Istanbul University. ↑
- Canın Arın, “Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddet”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.8. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Rona Serozan, Miras Hukuku, İstanbul, 2000, Beta Yayıncılık, s. 6,7. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Mehmet Emin Artuk/Ahmet Gökcen/A. Caner Yenidünya, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 6. Bası, Ankara, Turhan Kitabevi, 2005, s.32. ↑
- Handan Yokuş Sevük, “5237 Sayılı Türk Ceza Kanunu’nda Cinsel Saldırı ve Cinsel Taciz Suçları”, Türkiye Barolar Birliği Dergisi, S.57, Mart-Nisan 2005, s.245,246. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Artuk/Gökçen/Yenidünya, a.g.e., s.33; Yokuş Sevük, a.g.y., s.246. ↑
- Nicholas Groth/H. Jean Birnbaum, Men Who Rape: The Physchology Of The Offender, New York, Plenum Press, 1984, s.3 vd. ↑
- Philip F. Rice, Human Sexuality, Portland, William C. Brown Pub, 1989, s.490. ↑
- Ayhan Önder, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, İstanbul, Filiz Kitabevi, 1994, s.444. ↑
- Sulhi Dönmezer, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1975, s.46. ↑
- For the differing definitions of the offence of aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme) in the various legal systems, see also: Yalçın Tuna, “Irza Geçme Üzerine Mukayeseli İnceleme”, Adalet Dergisi, C.ILVI, S.4-5-6, 1955, s.332-333; Duygun Yarsuvat, “Mukayeseli Hukukta Cinsi Suçlar”, İÜHFM, C.XXX, S.1, 1964, s.125 vd. ↑
- Artuk/Gökçen/Yenidünya, a.g.e., s.39; Yokuş Sevük, a.g.y., s.256. ↑
- Yokuş Sevük, a.g.y., s.258. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Meryem Erdal, “Cezasızlık, UCMK ve Tecavüze İlişkin Tanımlar”, Humanite, S.5, Nisan-Mayıs 2004, s.116. ↑
- Dönmezer, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, s.51;Önder, a.g.e., s.445. ↑
- Mehmet Oral, Irza Geçme Suçu, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi (İstanbul Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Kamu Hukuku Anabilim Dalı), İstanbul, 1994, s.33; Cevdet Özden, “Irza Geçme Cürmü”, Adalet Dergisi, C.II, S.11-12, 1946, s.1178. ↑
- Mehmet Emin Artuk/A. Caner Yenidünya, “Evlilik İçinde Irza Geçme”, Cumhuriyet’in 75. Yıl Armağanı, İstanbul Üniversitesi Yayını, İstanbul 1999, s.57. ↑
- Dönmezer, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, s.51;Tuna, a.g.y., s.445. ↑
- Oral, a.g.e., s.34; Arın, a.g.y., s.10. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- On this congress and the topics discussed there, see: Sulhi Dönmezer, “IX. Milletlararası Ceza Hukuku Kongresi ve Cinsiyet Ahlakına Karşı Suçlar”, İÜHFM, C.XXX, S.3-4, 1964, s.451 vd. ↑
- Duygun Yarsuvat, “Türk Ceza Kanununda Cinsel Özgürlüğe Karşı Suçlar”, Değişen Toplum ve Ceza Hukuku Karşısında TCK’nın 50 Yılı ve Geleceği, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1977, s.679. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Oral, a.g.e., s.31. ↑
- On the change undergone by the legal interest protected by sexual offences, see: Yener Ünver, “Özellikle Cinsel Suçlar Alanında Olmak Üzere Kadınlarla İlgili Ceza Hukuku Normlarındaki Değişim ve Türkiye’deki Durum”, Adalet Yüksekokulu 20. Yıl Armağanı, İstanbul, 2001, s.294 vd. ↑
- “Sexual inviolability is violated by engaging in sexual conduct on the body of persons. The common legal interest protected by the offences contained in this chapter is the sexual inviolability of persons.” ↑
- Some authors in legal scholarship, however, state that sexual offences should be brought together under the heading “sexual coercion, violence”, as in the report prepared by the 1971 Swedish Criminal Code Commission, because acts such as aggravated sexual assault (ırza geçme) do not merely violate sexual freedom but at the same time involve a physical attack on the bodily and psychological integrity of the victim. Gül Erman, “Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddet”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.17. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Dönmezer, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, s.50,51. ↑
- Bernice Bouie Donald, “Amerikan Hukuku’nun Cinsel Suçlara Yaklaşımı”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.26,27. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Yokuş Sevük, a.g.y., s.257. ↑
- Artuk/Yenidünya, a.g.y., s.59. ↑
- Artuk/Yenidünya, a.g.y., s.59. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Artuk/Yenidünya, a.g.y., s.59. ↑
- Artuk/Yenidünya, a.g.y., s.60. ↑
- Artuk/Yenidünya, a.g.y., s.60. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Esin Örücü, “Karşılaştırmalı Hukuk’ta Evlilik Birliği İçinde Irza Geçme”, İstanbul Barosu Dergisi, C.66, S.1-2-3, 1992, s.92. ↑
- Örücü, a.g.y., s.95. ↑
- Lord Keith of Kinkel set out the following exemplary reasoning in the judgment: “It appears that for 150 years from that date (from 1736) the courts did not discuss this matter. In other words, this view was accepted as reflecting the common law. But the English common law is capable of changing and evolving in the light of changing social, economic and cultural developments. Hale’s view ( according to this view, by mutual matrimonial consent and contract the wife has given herself to her husband in this sense and cannot withdraw that consent. For this reason the husband benefits from an exemption in respect of rape) reflects the values of his own time. Since then the status of women, and particularly of married women, has changed out of all recognition in many respects. One of the most important of these changes is that in the modern age marriage is no longer regarded as a contract based on the view that the wife is a chattel who must obey her husband, but as a partnership between equals. According to Hale’s view, the wife is deemed to have given her husband an irrevocable promise to have sexual intercourse, whatever her state of health or her feelings may be. No reasonable person can accept this view today. The Scottish High Court examined this matter in depth and held that Hume’s views, whatever they may have meant in their time, cannot be accepted today. In my opinion this decision holds good for England as much as for Scotland. As a matter of principle, one cannot today speak of an exemption arising from marriage in the offence of rape.” Cited in: Örücü, a.g.y., s.95,96. ↑
- V. Barshis, “The Question of Marital Rape”, Women's Studies International Forum, S.6 , 1983, s.383- 393. ↑
- Raquel Kennedy Bergen, “Maritial Rape”, National Electronic Network on Violence Against Women, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.vaw.umn.edu/documents/vawnet/mrape/mrape.html#bergen1996, 12.03.2005. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- L. Bidwell/P. White, “The Family Context of Marital Rape”, The Journal of Family Violence, S.1, 1986, s.277-287. ↑
- These states are: New Jersey, New York, Colorado, North Carolina, North Dakota, Florida, Georgia, Oregon, Indiana, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, District of Columbia, Montana, Nebraska. Nor is there any exemption granted to husbands in cases where federal laws apply. ↑
- Of these, in Connecticut, Iowa, Minnesota and West Virginia the exemptions in question have even been extended to relationships lived outside marriage. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Erman, a.g.y., s.21. ↑
- Doğan Soyaslan, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, Ankara, 1997, s.298; Dönmezer, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, s.59; Özden, a.g.y., s.1173; Tuna, a.g.y., s.470. ↑
- Önder, a.g.e., s.445. ↑
- Yokuş Sevük, a.g.y., s.259; Dönmezer, Genel Adap ve Aile Düzenine Karşı Cürümler, s.59; Tuna, a.g.y., s.469. For the criticism on this point see: Ünver, Cinsel Suçlar, s.322,323. ↑
- “Since the accused had unnatural sexual intercourse (anal intercourse) with his wife by using psychological coercion, his act constitutes the offence in Art. 478(1)-(3) of the TCK.” Y. 4.CD., K.t. 19.12.1990, E.1990/5557 K.1990/7044, YKD., Şubat 1993, s.291. To the same effect see: Y. 4.CD., K.t. 07.07.1994, E.1900/2788 K.1900/6217, YKD., Kasım 1994, s.1847-1852. ↑
- For the same view see: Sami Selçuk, Karşıoylarım: Hukukumuzda Tartışılan Hükümler ve İçtihatlar, Der: Cengiz Otacı, Ankara, Turhan Kitabevi, 2001, s.433-438; Şerife Kırbıyık, Irza Geçme Cürmü ve Benzer Suçlardan Ayrımı, Ankara, Sözkesen Matbaacılık, 2001, s.54-59; Fatma Karakaş, “Evlilik İçi Cinsel Tecavüz Bağlamında, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddet ve AİHM’nin Yaklaşımı”, Humanite, S.6, Haziran-Temmuz 2004, s.121. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Mehmet Emin Artuk, “Kadına Yönelik Cinsel İstismara Örnek Olarak Evlilik İçinde Irza Geçme ve Fücur”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.41,42. ↑
- Artuk/Yenidünya, a.g.y., s.64. ↑
- Nur Centel, “Cinsel Suç Mağduru Kadının Korunması”, Prof. Dr. Kenan Tunçomağ’a Armağan, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Eğitim Öğretim ve Yardımlaşma Vakfı Yayını, 1997, s.63. ↑
- To the same effect see: Yener Ünver, “Türkiye’de Aile İçi Şiddetin Boyutları, Nedenleri ve Çözüm Önerileri”, Suçla Mücadele Bağlamında Türkiye’de Aile İçi Şiddet: Ülke Çapında Kriminolojik – Viktimolojik Alan Araştırması ve Değerlendirilmesi, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2003, s.63; Yokuş Sevük, a.g.y., s.26. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Kayıhan İçel, “Sunuş”, Suçla Mücadele Bağlamında Türkiye’de Aile İçi Şiddet: Ülke Çapında Kriminolojik – Viktimolojik Alan Araştırması ve Değerlendirilmesi, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2003, s.6. ↑
- Ünver, Aile içi Şiddet, s.42. ↑
- In criminology, the dark figure is defined as the offences and offenders that have remained hidden and in respect of which no investigation has been brought about, whether by their being reported to the judicial authorities or by those authorities learning of them of their own motion. See: Füsun Sokullu Akıncı, Kriminoloji, İstanbul, 1994, s.48 vd. ↑
- Füsun Sokullu Akıncı, Viktimoloji, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1999, s.57. ↑
- Erman, a.g.y., s.20,21. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Hasan Sınar, “Evlilik İçinde Irza Geçme Eylemi Üzerine Düşünceler”, Yayınlanmamış Doktora Seminer Ödevi, 2000, s.10. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- In various sources the term “rape” (“ırza geçme” or “tecavüz”) is used as the equivalent of this concept; however, in order to preserve the unity of the study and because the term used in Law No. 5237 is the apt one, the term “aggravated sexual assault” will also be used in the explanations to be given from the standpoint of victimology. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Diana E. H. Russell, Rape in Marriage, Expanded and Revised Edition with a New Introduction, Indiana Universty Press, 1990, s.27. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Russell, a.g.e., s.30. ↑
- David Finkelhor/Kersti Yllo, License to Rape: Sexual Abuse of Wives, New York, Free Press, 1987, s.30. ↑
- Raquel Kennedy Bergen, Wife Rape: Understanding the Response of Survivors and Service Providers, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage Publications, 1996, s.20,21. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Russell, a.g.e., s.57 vd. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Ida M. Johnson/Robert T. Sigler, Forced Sexual Intercourse in Intimate Relationships, New York, New York University Press, 1997, s.22. ↑
- Finkelhor/Yllo, a.g.e., s.31. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Finkelhor/Yllo, a.g.e., s.32; Russell, a.g.e.,s.143-146. Bergen, Wife Rape,s.17,18. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Finkelhor/Yllo, a.g.e., s.33. ↑
- Russell, a.g.e., s.145. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- P.L. Peacock, Marital Rape “Intimate Betrayal”, Ed: V. Wiehe/A. Richards, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage Publications, 1995 s.55-73. ↑
- Angele Browne, When Battered Women Kill, New York, The Free Press, 1987, s.95-103; J. C. Campbell, “Women's Responses to Sexual Abuse in Intimate Relationships”, Health Care for Women International, S.10, 1989, s.335-346. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- I. Frieze, “Investigating The Causes and Consequences of Marital Rape” Journal of Women in Culture and Society, S.8, 1983, s.532-553. ↑
- Bergen, Wife Rape, s.22,23. ↑
- Patricia Mahoney/Linda M. Williams, “Sexual Assault in Marriage: Prevalence, Consequences And Treatment of Wife Rape” Partner Violence: A Comprehensive Review of 20 Years of Research, Ed: J. Jasinski/L. Williams, Thousand Oaks CA, Sage Publications, 1998, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.agnr.umd.edu/nnfr/research/pv/pv_ch5.html, 17.03.2005; J. C. Campbell/P. Alford, “The Dark Consequences of Marital Rape”, American Journal of Nursing, 1989, s.946-949. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Demie Kurz, For Richer for Poorer: Mothers Confront Divorce, New York, Routledge, 1995, s.66; R. Emerson Dobash/Russell P. Dobash, Women, Violence and Social Change; London, Routledge. 1992, s.213 vd. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Campbell/Alford, a.g.y., s.946-949. ↑
- D. G. Kilpatrick/C. C. Best/B. E. Saunders/L. J. Vernon, “Rape in Marriage and in Dating Relationships: How Bad is it for Mental Health?”, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, S. 528, 1988, s.335-344, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.annalsnyas.org/content/vol528/issue1/, 17.03.2005; Frieze, a.g.y., s.540. ↑
- Russell, a.g.e., s.200,201. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- M. P. Koss/T. E. Dinero/C. A. Siebel/S. L. Cox, “Stranger and Acquaintance Rape: Are There Differences in Victim's Experiences?”, Psychology of Women Quarterly, S.12, 1988, s.1-24. ↑
- Bergen, Wife Rape,s.59; Frieze, a.g.y., s.542. ↑
- M. Whatley, “For Better or Worse: The Case of Marital Rape”, Violence and Victims, S.8, s.29-39. ↑
- M. Pagelow, “Adult Victims of Domestic Violence” Journal of Interpersonal Violence, S.7, 1992, s.87- 120; D. G. Saunders/P. B. Size, Attitudes About Woman Abuse Among Police Officers, Victims, and Victims' Advocates. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, S.1, 1986, s.25-42. ↑
- Bergen, Wife Rape,s.61. ↑
- Ayşe Nuhoğlu, “Cinsel Suç Mağdurunun Beyanı ve İspat”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.52; Russell, a.g.e., s.115. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- For detailed information on this subject see: Stephanie Yearnshire, “Aile İçi Şiddet ve Tecavüz Konularında Yasal İhtilaflar Polisin Yaklaşımı”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.73-86. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Nuhoğlu, a.g.y., s.50. ↑
- Nuhoğlu, a.g.y., s.52,53. ↑
- Nuhoğlu, a.g.y., s.52,53. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Koss/Dinero/Siebel/Cox, a.g.y., s.2 vd.; Mahoney/Williams, a.g.y. ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ___________________________________________________ ↑
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Although, as regards the USA, the clergy (priests) have also been named among the persons from whom this support is sought, it is stated that, in accordance with the teachings of religion, they are the persons who give the least support. As regards our country, in view of the social position assumed by men of religion, it is known that no such situation arises.
- Bergen, Maritial Rape. ↑
- Gudrun Agnarsdottir, “Tecavüze Uğrayan ve Cinsel Tacize Maruz Kalan Kadına Acil Servis’te ve Tecavüz Kriz Merkezi’nde Yaklaşımlar”, Kadına Yönelik Cinsel Şiddete Karşılaştırmalı Hukukun Yaklaşımı, 2. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu Kadın Hakları Uygulama Merkezi Yayını, 2002, s.68-72.
- Thompson/Haas, Marital Rape: Methods of Helping and Healing, Unpublished Manuscript, 1987. ↑
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Imprisonment in Defiance of the Law: Enemy Criminal Law in Türkiye in the Light of the European Court of Human Rights Judgments in Osman Kavala and Can Atalay” (Hukuka Rağmen Hapis: Avrupa İnsan Hakları Mahkemesinin Osman Kavala ve Can Atalay Kararları Işığında Türkiye’de Düşman Ceza Hukuku), Dülger Law Office, 20 November 2026.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Demanding Accountability Is Not a Crime: On the Investigation Initiated Against Av. Prof. Dr. Osman Korkut Kanadoğlu” (Hesap Sormak Suç Değildir: Av. Prof. Dr. Osman Korkut Kanadoğlu Hakkında Başlatılan Soruşturma Üzerine), Dülger Law Office, 27 October 2026.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “On the Events Known to the Public as the ‘Fund Scandal’: An Assessment in Terms of Criminal Liability, Investor Rights and Supervisory Liability” (Kamuoyunda “Fon Skandalı” Olarak Anılan Olaylar Hakkında: Ceza Sorumluluğu, Yatırımcı Hakları ve Denetim Sorumluluğu Bakımından Bir Değerlendirme), Academia.edu, 1 October 2026.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Delayed Occurrence of the Result (Dolus Generalis / Weber's Intent)” (Gecikmiş Neticenin Gerçekleşmesi (Dolus Generalis / Weber Kastı)), Essays in Honour of Asst. Prof. Dr. Sesim Soyer Güleç (Dr. Öğr. Üyesi Sesim Soyer Güleç’e Armağan), eds. Koray Doğan / Behiye Eker Kazancı, Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2025, pp. 223–288.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Assessment of the Constitutional Court's Decision on the Provisions Governing the Simplified Trial Procedure” (Anayasa Mahkemesinin Basit Yargılama Usulü Hükümlerine İlişkin Kararının Değerlendirilmesi), Dülger Law Office, 12 October 2023.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Offences and Sanctions Relating to the Laundering of Proceeds of Crime (The Offence of Money Laundering) (Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar (Kara Paranın Aklanması Suçu)), 3rd ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2026.

