14 December 2018Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

With the publication of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) in the Official Gazette on 24 March 2016 and its entry into force, personal data protection law began to appear at many points of our daily lives. There is the KVKK, which is the primary source of personal data protection law in our country, and alongside it there are regulations, communiqués and the decisions of the Personal Data Protection Board. Even so, many problems are still encountered in practice and answers are being sought to a large number of questions. These are of vital importance, particularly for the private sector, so that commercial life operates lawfully while trade is at the same time not obstructed.

In this article I will try to address “the problems arising in the application of the KVKK and in the compliance process” and to say out loud the questions that are in fact on the mind of almost everyone who works in this area. I should state first of all that the KVKK entered into force in 2016 and has not yet fully settled in practice. There are many points on which the KVKK is criticised and falls short in practice. Although some of these points have been clarified by decisions of the Board, there are still many shortcomings in practice that need to be remedied. Below I will touch on the problems I have identified under main headings and explain the solutions I have been able to propose for some of them. These are not definitive solutions, however; they are proposals intended to start the debate on this subject.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

Since Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) was published in the Official Gazette and entered into force on 24.03.2016, data protection law has begun to confront us at many points of our daily lives. Although there is Law No. 6698, which is the primary source of data protection law in our country, and alongside it regulations, communiqués and the decisions of the Personal Data Protection Board, many problems are still encountered in practice and answers are being sought to a large number of questions. For the private sector in particular, these are of vital importance for ensuring that commercial life operates lawfully while, at the same time, trade is not obstructed.

In this paper I shall attempt to address “the problems arising in the application of the KVKK and in the compliance process” and to voice aloud the questions that are in fact on the mind of almost everyone who deals with this subject.

I must state first of all that Law No. 6698 entered into force in 2016 and has not yet fully settled in terms of its application. There are many respects in which the Law is criticised and proves inadequate in practice. Although some of these matters have been clarified by decisions of the Board, there are still many shortcomings in practice that need to be remedied. Below I shall touch upon the problems I have identified under main headings and set out the solutions I am able to propose for some of them. These are not, however, definitive solutions; they are merely proposals intended to start the debate on this subject.

1. Questions and Problems in Practice under the VERBİS Registry Regulation

Article 13 of the VERBİS Registry Regulation provides: “Where the information recorded in the registry changes, controllers shall notify the Authority of the changes via VERBİS within seven days.” Accordingly, persons or institutions having the status of controller are placed under an obligation, where the records change, to notify the Authority of the change in question within 7 days. It is unclear, however, from which moment the 7-day period laid down here begins to run.

The provision in question does not state whether the 7-day period laid down in the VERBİS Registry Regulation begins to run from the moment the change becomes known or from the moment the change occurs. Judging by the examples I have seen in practice, it is not always possible to detect possible changes in personal data immediately and easily. Where the change is detected, and if the 7-day period is made to run from the moment at which the change occurred, I consider that the 7-day period for notification to the Authority (through VERBİS) is short. For this reason, I consider that the controller should check, within an organisational structure and at regular intervals, whether the personal data are up to date and accurate, and that the 7-day period should begin to run from the detection of the change in the personal data as a result of these checks.

The assessment on this point may be developed by analogy with the assessment made under the GDPR with regard to establishing the accuracy and currency of data. In Article 5(1)(d), in which it sets out the “principle that personal data be accurate and, where necessary, kept up to date”, the GDPR has also explained what a controller must do when it realises that it is processing data that are not up to date. Accordingly, if the controller realises in any way that it is in fact processing inaccurate data that are not up to date, it must take every reasonable step necessary to ensure that such data, having regard to the purposes for which they are to be processed, are erased or rectified without delay1.

We may also apply, by way of analogy, the interpretation made in this context under the GDPR to the starting point of the 7-day period introduced by the VERBİS Registry Regulation. Accordingly, the controller's notification of the change to the Board within the 7-day period may be regarded as a step necessary to ensure erasure or rectification without delay, and the moment at which the controller learns in any way that it is processing data that have undergone a change may be taken as the start of the 7-day period.

I must nevertheless repeat that, in order for the controller not to face adverse consequences and not to be exposed to allegations by the data subject that his rights have been infringed, the controller must check the data within an organisational structure. In this context, policies and procedures must be established on how to proceed where new data processing operations emerge and on who is to make a notification, within what period and in what manner; persons must be assigned to these tasks; and it must be ensured that the persons concerned act in accordance with these arrangements so that no breach occurs.

2. May Additional Advantages Be Offered in Return for Consent When Explicit Consent Is Obtained?

As is expressly stated in the GDPR, the Directive and Law No. 6698, the declaration of explicit consent must be the product of the data subject's free will. A declaration made of one's own free will means that the person is able to reach his own decision freely and to express it outwardly in a free manner. Since the controller's imposition “that the service will be performed only if explicit consent is given” impairs the quality of explicit consent as a declaration made of one's own free will, it is accepted that consents obtained in this way are not lawful. It is disputed, however, whether, conversely, explicit consent is valid where it is obtained not by imposing it as a condition for the performance of the transaction in question but by means of a practice whereby the person gains an additional benefit by giving explicit consent.

In my opinion, offering an additional advantage in return for consent does not impair the person's free will. An imposition concerning the performance of the transaction means that, if the person does not give explicit consent, what he wishes to have done will not be done; it makes it compulsory for the person to give explicit consent to the processing of his personal data in order for the transaction in question to be carried out. The result is therefore that the person's free will is eliminated. Offering an additional advantage, by contrast, does not affect the transaction in question; it merely serves to encourage the person with a view to obtaining his consent. I consider that situations such as a controller attempting, within the framework of the activity it carries out, to influence the data subject to a degree that does not amount to coercion should not be perceived as situations vitiating free will. For if this were accepted, the concept of a declaration made of one's own free will would be interpreted very broadly and commercial activities would also be adversely affected. Moreover, this may have negative effects not only on the controller carrying out a commercial activity but also on the data subject who would benefit from it2.

This question arises most often in the specific context of the loyalty card. In order to attract customers and to secure their continued loyalty, commercial companies collect certain personal data of their customers and, in return, grant them advantages by offering discounts or giving various gifts. It is precisely at this point that the view I have expressed above comes into play. A company issuing a loyalty card does not refrain from selling goods or services to customers who do not wish to provide their personal data and take the card; it merely does not grant them advantages. Consequently, what is in fact at issue here is not an influencing of the will but a reciprocal contract, and reciprocal obligations are performed as the performance of that contract requires. In my view, the point to be observed here is that the customer must be given the right to terminate this contract easily at any time and that, once this declaration of intent has been made, the controller must actually erase the customer's personal data collected in this context.

3. Gaps and Contradictions between Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce and Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data

There are a number of contradictions, from the standpoint of data protection law, between the Electronic Commerce Law No. 6563, which entered into force in 2015, and Law No. 6698. The main contradictions are the following:

• The Electronic Commerce Law No. 6563 essentially accepts implied consent with regard to the transfer and processing of personal data. As is expressly stated in the provisions of Law No. 6698 and the GDPR, however, there can be no implied consent in data protection law. In that case, as far as practice in our country is concerned, a question mark arises as to whether implied consent will be valid for personal data collected under the Electronic Commerce Law. My view on this matter is that the Electronic Commerce Law No. 6563 should apply to personal data processed within the scope of the Electronic Commerce Law. There are two reasons for this view.

The first of these is the rule, fundamental to the application of laws, that in a conflict between a general law and a special law the special law applies. According to this rule, where a provision of a general law and a provision of a special law conflict on a given matter, it is not the general law but the special law that applies. For the purposes of our assessment, Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data is a general law, whereas Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce

is a special law. For this reason, where there is a conflict between the two sets of rules, Law No. 6563 must be applied to personal data processed within the scope of Law No. 6563.

The second reason is that “being provided for by law” is laid down in Article 6(3) and in Article 5(2)(a) of Law No. 6698 among the grounds of justification for the processing of personal data. Seen from this angle, Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce contains an express provision for personal data processed in the context of electronic commerce. For this reason, as regards data processed within the scope of that law, an exception applies in the cases falling under Article 6(3) and Article 5(2)(a) of Law No. 6698, and explicit consent need not be obtained in those cases.

This interpretation will not, however, be of use with regard to special categories of personal data in cases falling outside Article 6(3), and for data of this kind explicit consent must be obtained in every case.

• We mentioned above that, under Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce, approval must be obtained in order for personal data collected in the electronic environment to be processed. In addition, another provision of that law gives the controller the right to ask the data subject twice a year whether he approves, even if the person has refused the approval requested. Although such a provision has been introduced in Law No. 6563, Law No. 6698 contains no limitation on this subject. A limitation on this point should be introduced by Law No. 6698. Otherwise data subjects may be contacted at very frequent intervals for the purpose of obtaining approval.

The lawfulness of consent obtained in this way is a separate matter for debate. Obtaining consent by contacting data subjects every day by telephone, e-mail and similar means will render unlawful the explicit consent, which must be the product of the person's free will. For this reason a limitation must be placed on the exercise of this right.

• Furthermore, can the notification to be given under Law No. 6563 on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce and the information to be provided under Law No. 6698 be given together? Can the notification text also cover the information notice, or must they be given separately? This question, which gives rise to many question marks and hesitations in practice, also needs to be clarified.

In this context, pursuant to Article 5(1)(f) of the “Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles to Be Followed in Fulfilling the Obligation to Inform”, published by the Personal Data Protection Authority on 10 March 2018, the obligation to inform and the obtaining of explicit consent must be carried out separately. When the problem in question is assessed in the light of this communiqué, I consider that the notification to be given under the Law on the Regulation of Electronic Commerce must also be given separately. I must also state, however, that being able to do both together in a single text would be an easier and more functional method.

In my opinion, it would be appropriate and useful for the contradictions and question marks between the two laws in question, which we have set out above, to be eliminated and for the Board and the Ministry of Trade to publish a joint communiqué on these matters.

4. Are Data Collected with Lawful Consent before the Date of Entry into Force of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data Valid?

Pursuant to paragraph 3 of Provisional Article 1 of Law No. 6698, “consents lawfully obtained before the date of publication of this Law shall be deemed to be in conformity with this Law unless a declaration of intent to the contrary is made within one year”. Accordingly, where data collected before 7 April 2016, the date on which Law No. 6698 entered into force, were collected with a lawful consent within the meaning of Provisional Article 1 of Law No. 6698, they are deemed to be in conformity with this Law “unless a declaration of intent to the contrary is made within 1 year”.

It must be stated first of all that the expression “consents lawfully obtained” referred to in this provision of the Law is a general concept and that it is not clear whether this article is to apply to all types of consent or is to cover only cases of explicit consent. In other words, will implied consents lawfully obtained beforehand be valid? This uncertainty needs to be removed.

Moreover, however explicit consent may have been obtained, in cases where explicit consent must be obtained under Law No. 6698, information must also be provided together with the explicit consent. Will there be a requirement to provide information retroactively for data processed on the basis of lawfully obtained explicit consents within the meaning of paragraph 3 of Provisional Article 1? In my view, given the large volume of data concerned, providing information retroactively for all of them does not appear very feasible in practice; nevertheless, this point too needs to be clarified by communiqués to be issued or by a decision of the Board.

On the other hand, Provisional Article 1 allows a period of 1 year for making a declaration of intent to the contrary, but there is no clarity as to the manner in which this declaration of intent is to be made. Must data subjects contact controllers within 1 year and make a declaration of intent to the contrary, or must the controller call all data subjects within 1 year and ask whether the lawful consent they gave is still valid?

In my opinion, it would be more reasonable for data subjects to contact the controller and express their declaration of intent to the contrary. For if the opposite view were accepted, the controller's contacting, within 1 year, all the data subjects whose data it processes on this matter would impose on the controller an obligation that is highly disproportionate in terms of time and cost. In this scenario too, the question arises of how these negative declarations of intent may be communicated. Should data subjects in this case state their intent by any method whatsoever? Or are these notifications to be made by using the methods for applying to the controller? This subject is likewise a separate problem of practice. In any event, more than 1 year elapsed between the date of publication of the law and the determination of the procedures for applying to the controller. For this reason, in order that the data subject should not suffer a loss of rights, it may be appropriate for him to state his intent by any method whatsoever. This, however, will also entail problems for controllers in managing the system. In conclusion, I consider that the Authority should provide guidance on this matter, taking into account the interests of both parties.

5. What Will Be the Lawfulness of Data Processed in the Period between Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data and the Publication of the Board's Decisions?

Law No. 6698 was published in the Official Gazette and entered into force on 7 April 2016, and controllers were given a period of 2 years following that date to bring all the data they had processed until then into conformity with the Law. Some controllers began to carry out work as part of the process of compliance with Law No. 6698 as from 7 April 2016. The Law in question, however, contains general provisions; attempts are being made to remedy its shortcomings in practice by means of Board decisions, and this process is still continuing.

One of the most important problems we encounter in this process is what will become of the data collected in the period between 7 April 2016 and the issuing of the Board decision on the matter concerned. To give a concrete example: the communiqué on the points to be observed when obtaining explicit consent and providing information (the Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles to Be Followed in Fulfilling the Obligation to Inform) was published on 10 March 2018. In the period from 7 April 2016 to 10 March 2018, companies obtained explicit consent from data subjects in accordance with the provisions of the Law. If the consents obtained and the information provided in this period do not meet the conditions laid down in the communiqué that was published, what will become of these data? Will they be regarded as lawful if they were processed in conformity with Law No. 6698, or will they be expected to conform to the procedures and principles laid down in the communiqués? If they are expected to conform to the principles laid down in the communiqué, will it be possible to obtain explicit consent retroactively?

In my opinion, explicit consents obtained during the period that has elapsed for data processed in conformity with Law No. 6698, but obtained without complying with the procedures laid down in the communiqué of 10/03/2018, should be regarded as lawful, provided that this is limited to the period in question. Otherwise, if we regard operations carried out in conformity with the Law as part of the compliance process before the Board decisions as unlawful merely because they do not comply with a Board decision, the process of compliance with Law No. 6698 will never come to an end and a vicious circle will arise. For Board decisions are still being published and the law on the protection of personal data continues to change and develop. Moreover, to regard the operations in question as unlawful would also be contrary to the fundamental rules adopted on the temporal application of laws.

What is more, if conformity with the points laid down in the communiqués were to be expected, the need to obtain explicit consent retroactively would arise. Having regard to the conditions and nature of explicit consent, however, it should not be possible to obtain explicit consent retroactively.

6. The Uncertainty of the Scope of Performance of a Contract as One of the Grounds of Justification in Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data

By providing in Article 5(2)(c) of Law No. 6698 for the case in which “it is necessary to process personal data of the parties to a contract, provided that this is directly related to the conclusion or performance of that contract”, the Law has made it possible for personal data of the parties to a contract to be processed without explicit consent, provided that this is directly related to the conclusion or performance of the contract.

In practice, the scope of the concept of “performance of a contract” is of considerable importance, particularly with regard to data collected through websites. To give a concrete example: on some sites on which we register as members in order to shop online, a great deal of personal data is processed at the membership stage. If, however, a decision is made after the membership stage to purchase a product, the personal data collected at the membership stage are processed for that purpose as well. Is it necessary here to obtain explicit consent at the membership stage for data that are collected at that stage and are later used directly in the distance sales contract too, without any additional approval being given? In order to answer this question, it must be explained what can and what cannot be regarded as falling within the scope of the performance of the contract.

Indeed, where a membership contract is concluded via a website, only as much data as is indispensable for the conclusion of the membership contract should be collected; these data should be used in accordance with the purpose; no more data should be collected than suffices to achieve the intended purpose; and the data subject should be clearly informed on this matter. Only where these conditions are met can the consents obtained when becoming a member of sites of this kind be valid. Moreover, if the data collected when the person is registered as a member are also to be used in the course of the sales transaction, it is necessary and sufficient that the data subject be informed of this as well. For in this case the ground of justification of performance of a contract will apply. The company carrying out this operation must also structure the relevant policies and procedures accordingly.

7. Questions and Problems Arising in Practice Where Personal Data Are Not Obtained from the Data Subject

According to Article 6, headed “Obligation to inform where personal data are not obtained from the data subject”, of the “Communiqué on the Procedures and Principles to Be Followed in Fulfilling the Obligation to Inform”, published by the Board on 10/03/2018: “Where personal data are not obtained from the data subject, the obligation to inform the data subject must be fulfilled within a reasonable period after the personal data have been obtained; where the personal data are to be used for the purpose of communicating with the data subject, at the time of the first communication; and where the personal data are to be transferred, at the latest at the time when the personal data are transferred for the first time.”

Accordingly, the controller is also placed under an obligation to inform the data subject within a reasonable period in the case where the personal data are not obtained from the data subject. This provision is not, however, sufficient for the purposes of practice, and in most cases there is in addition no possibility of reaching all the data subjects.

To give a concrete example: in the case of personal data concerning an employee's family and children which the employee provides in order to take up employment, or personal data of referees provided by the applicant in job applications, and even personal data of third parties contained in documents drawn up by public authorities (for example payment orders in enforcement proceedings, traffic penalty reports, expert reports and the like), it is extremely difficult to inform the persons to whom the data belong. In this case I think that informing the third parties in the examples in question would be an unbearable burden for controllers.

Although this provision introduced by the Communiqué appears possible in theory, it causes problems in practice. For this reason, controllers should not be burdened with more obligations than necessary, and the hardship that controllers would suffer in this respect should be prevented.

8. The Scope of Special Categories of Personal Data, the Two-Factor Authentication System and the

Preparation of Separate Policies and Procedures for Special Categories of Personal Data:

Question Marks in Practice

As stated in Decision No. 2018/10 of the Personal Data Protection Board dated 31/01/2018 on the “Adequate Measures to Be Taken by Controllers in the Processing of Special Categories of Personal Data”, in the words “the determination of a separate policy and procedure for the security of special categories of personal data which is systematic, has clearly defined rules and is manageable and sustainable,...”, the establishment of a separate policy and procedure for the security of special categories of personal data is envisaged.

Does a separate policy and procedure here mean separate texts, or may the policies and procedures for special categories of personal data also be included under a separate heading within a single policy and procedure?

As is expressly defined in Law No. 6698, data relating to the race, ethnic origin, political opinion, philosophical belief, religion, sect or other beliefs, appearance and dress, membership of associations, foundations or trade unions, health, sexual life, criminal convictions and security measures of persons, as well as biometric and genetic data, are special categories of personal data. An important issue concerning special categories of personal data is the scope of the categories in question. For example, images of a person's appearance and dress are capable of providing information on many matters such as the person's ethnic origin, political opinion, philosophical belief, religion or sect. In that case, can images of appearance and dress be regarded as special categories of personal data? If we regard these data as special categories of personal data, the requirement will arise that these data be encrypted in order for the controller to be able to continue to keep them. It must be said, however, that it is not possible to encrypt camera footage. Likewise, the occupational health and safety legislation3 contains a provision requiring these recordings to be kept for a certain period. It should be clarified whether personal data of this kind can be regarded as special categories of personal data and, if so, a solution should be provided for this situation.

In my view, images of appearance and dress should not, on their own, be regarded as special categories of personal data. Only if these data are analysed in a systematic manner in order to determine the person's race, ethnic origin, political opinion, philosophical belief, religion, sect or other beliefs do they acquire the character of special categories of personal data, and from that point onwards the rules on the protection of special categories of personal data apply to these data as well.

At the same time, Board Decision No. 2018/10 envisages a “two-factor authentication system” where special categories of personal data are accessed remotely. No explanation has been given, however, as to what the two-factor authentication system is and how it is to be provided. In information security, a two-factor authentication system is a security system built on authentication in two layers, namely “information that is known and information that is possessed”. In the Board decision in question, however, no explanation has been given as to what this system is and how it is to be applied. This point too needs to be clarified.

9. The Position of Processors under Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data

When we look at Law No. 6698, it can be seen that, unlike the GDPR and the Directive, there is no complete standard for processors. In Law No. 6698 the processor is defined as “the natural or legal person who processes personal data on behalf of the controller on the basis of the authority granted by the controller…”.

In practice there are natural or legal persons who do not have the status of processor but to whom a very large volume of personal data is transferred. For example, there are institutions that come to companies in order to carry out medical examinations, and companies to which data are transferred intensively, but these do not process data on behalf of the controller.

Is it possible to conclude with the institutions/companies in question, although they do not have the status of processor, a contract meeting the standards of a processor agreement? In order to reduce the risks in this respect, a contract similar to those concluded with processors should also be concluded with natural or legal persons to whom, as stated above, data are transferred intensively or special categories of data are transferred intensively but who do not have the character of a processor, and mechanisms should be established to secure an undertaking by these persons too to protect personal data.

10. The Uncertainty Concerning the Transfer of Personal Data Abroad and Cloud Service Providers

Lastly, it will be appropriate to touch upon the questions and problems we encounter in practice in connection with the transfer of personal data abroad.

One of the most important problems with regard to the transfer of personal data abroad is that the “safe countries” in which adequate protection exists have not yet been announced. On the premise that it cannot at present be foreseen when this list will be announced, recourse is had in practice to obtaining consent for transfers abroad until the list is announced. For the development of correct practice too, it is important that the countries in which adequate protection exists be announced and, in addition, that the Board make known its views with regard to personal data held with cloud service providers.

Under the heading of the transfer of personal data abroad, although the countries in which adequate protection exists have not yet been announced, the Board has made oral statements to the effect that it will apply the principle of reciprocity in this matter. In addition, in the discussions held, agreement was reached that it cannot at present be foreseen when the list will be announced and that, for this reason, recourse must be had to consent for transfers abroad until the list is announced.

In this context, which operations will be/ought to be regarded as a transfer of data abroad is also an important issue. Today there are a great many arrangements in which various units of international companies are managed from abroad and all the data relating to the units concerned are kept abroad, or in which the company's servers are located abroad. International hotel chains would be an apt example in this respect. Although at present the preferred course in practice is to advise companies to obtain consent for all the data they transfer abroad or to keep their servers within the country, it is clear that recommendations of this kind will not be practical, quick and fully achievable in practice, or that problems may be encountered in obtaining consent from individuals and where consent is withdrawn. In view of the difficulties that will be encountered in practice, it would be useful to adopt a different approach to data transfers by international companies of the kind described here.

On the other hand, even if the list of countries in which adequate protection exists is published, the published list may prove inadequate at this point, considering that cloud service providers generally keep data in more than one country and back up their data in various countries. In response, it might be thought that the problem could be solved by companies restricting the countries in which the data will be backed up, by means of clauses inserted in the contracts they conclude with their service providers. A solution of this kind may, however, give rise to serious costs for controllers. Moreover, most cloud service providers operate according to their own standards, and the fact that the contracts of some of them are not open to negotiation may also cause problems in practice. The Board's approach to cloud solutions is not yet known. If, however, the direction it has so far given to practice on various matters is taken into account, it would not be surprising if the Board, in all probability, were to treat data processed through cloud service providers as falling within the scope of transfer abroad4.

Another important point here is whether, once the safe countries have been determined, the question of whether a country is a safe country will be assessed, as far as cloud service providers are concerned, by reference to the country in which the data are kept or by reference to the country of origin of the company to which the cloud service provider belongs. Should it be determined that safety is to be assessed by reference to the country in which the data are held, it is in most cases not known exactly where cloud service providers keep the data, and this is also very difficult to establish.

The last point I shall touch upon under this heading is that, even if the list of safe countries is published, there is no rule on how companies are to proceed with regard to the sudden transfers they have to make in their day-to-day operations. Having regard to the way companies operate, this gap in the legislation is a shortcoming that must necessarily be remedied. In my view, the procedure for the transfer of data to countries that are not safe must be regulated in such a way that it can accommodate sudden situations.

In the light of all the points I have explained above, provisions geared to practice must be adopted, in terms of both substance and procedure, on the transfer of personal data abroad, and certain concepts must be clarified.

Conclusion

The conclusions I have reached as a result of assessing, within the framework of the points explained above, the questions and problems arising in the application of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data and in the compliance process are as follows:

• The time at which the 7-day period laid down in Article 13 of the VERBİS Registry Regulation begins to run must be expressly regulated. In my view, this period should begin to run from the detection of the change.

• There is no obstacle to offering an additional advantage in return for consent when explicit consent is obtained. Moreover, this does not prevent the condition that explicit consent be the product of the person's free will from being met.

• The Board and the Ministry of Trade should publish a joint communiqué in which the contradictions and question marks between Law No. 6563 and Law No. 6698 with regard to data processed in the electronic environment are eliminated. On this subject, Law No. 6563 must be applied to personal data processed in the electronic environment, both because of the relationship between special law and general law and because the case of “being provided for by law” is listed as an exception in Article 5 of Law No. 6698.

• The fate of data collected with lawful consent before the date of entry into force of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data, and the concept of lawfully obtained consent, need to be clarified. It is particularly important to determine the fate of implied consents obtained in that period.

• As regards the lawfulness of data processed in the period between Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data and the publication of the Board's decisions, these data must be regarded as lawful if they were processed in conformity with Law No. 6698.

• In order that no problems arise in practice and that no matter is left unprotected in the protection afforded to personal data, a definite standard should be introduced with regard to the concept of processor. This is highly important for ensuring the protection of the data in question, particularly in the case of entities which do not fall within the category of processor under the present rules but which have very extensive access to personal data.

• Important rules need to be adopted on the transfer of personal data abroad. The Board's view of systems offering cloud services should be made known, and indeed separate rules should be introduced for these systems.

• In addition, the procedure that companies must apply when transferring data abroad is one which, having regard to the speed at which companies operate in daily life, works so slowly that it is liable to cause disruption to their operations. For this reason these procedures should also be revised.

Footnotes

  1. Member of the academic staff for Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Law and IT Law, Yeditepe University Faculty of Law / Attorney-at-law. ↑
  2. Murat Volkan Dülger, Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku, İstanbul, Hukuk Akademisi, 2018, s. 132. ↑
  3. For details see: Dülger, Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku, s. 25. ↑
  4. İşyeri Açma ve Çalışma Ruhsatlarına İlişkin Yönetmelik m.5. Tehlikeli Madde Taşıyan Araç ve Üst Yapıların Teknik Muayeneleri Hakkında Yönetmelik’ m.6. ↑
  5. Kişisel Veriler Platformu Çalışma Notları, Amaç Tartışılan Konular Toplantı Notları, Tespit ve Öneriler, Ocak – Haziran 2018, s.7 vd. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic