Abstract
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
Cryptocurrencies and their best-known example, Bitcoin, are regarded as the first product of blockchain technology and promise radical changes to traditional commerce and to the concept of money accepted today. Governments are seen to take differing attitudes in the face of this effect of cryptocurrency. While developed countries recognise cryptocurrencies as assets and tax them, some countries are known to have chosen to prohibit their use. Despite the prohibition and taxation efforts in this area, there is as yet no legal instrument regulating cryptocurrencies at national or international level.
The study first examines the concepts of money and cryptocurrency and then sets out the national and international developments in this field. In the second and final part of the study, cryptocurrencies are assessed under the provisions of the Turkish Criminal Code, with particular attention to the question whether cryptocurrencies can constitute the object of the offence of theft.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
FESTSCHRIFT for Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin ARTUK
FESTSCHRIFT for Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin ARTUK
Editor Prof. Dr. Mahmut KOCA
Editorial Board of the Festschrift
Prof. Dr. İzzet Özgenç
Prof. Dr. Mahmut Koca
Prof. Dr. İlhan Üzülmez
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin Alşahin
SEÇKİN | Law
Ankara 2020 Academic and Professional Publications
FESTSCHRIFT for Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin ARTUK
Editor: Mahmut KOCA
SEÇKİN | Law 1623 Pages, 17x25 cm.
No: 2415
ISBN 978 975 02 6015 5 1. Curriculum Vitae of Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin Artuk
CRYPTOCURRENCY CRIMES: THE LEGAL DIMENSION OF CRYPTOCURRENCIES AND
THEIR ASSESSMENT UNDER THE TURKISH CRIMINAL CODE
(Cryptocurrency Crimes: Legal Aspects of Crypto Currencies and Evaluation in Terms of Turkish Penal Code)
Cryptocurrency Crimes: The Legal Dimension of Cryptocurrencies and Their Assessment under the Turkish Criminal Code
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER• - Onur ÖZKAN•
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER - Onur ÖZKAN
SUMMARY
Cryptocurrencies and their best-known example, Bitcoin, are regarded as the first product of blockchain technology (Blockchain) and promise radical changes to traditional commerce and to the concept of money accepted today. In the face of this effect of cryptocurrency, governments are seen to adopt attitudes that differ from one another. While developed countries recognise cryptocurrencies as an asset and tax them, some countries are known to have resorted to banning their use. Despite the efforts at prohibition and taxation made in this field, there is as yet no legal instrument regulating cryptocurrencies at the national or international level. In our study, the concepts of money and cryptocurrency are examined first, and the national and international developments in this field are then set out. In the second and final part of our study, cryptocurrencies are assessed in the light of the provisions of the Turkish Criminal Code, with particular emphasis on the question whether cryptocurrencies can form the subject matter of the offence of theft.
Keywords: Cryptocurrencies, Virtual currency, Electronic money, Cybercrime, Cryptocurrency crimes, Offences against property, Theft, Cyber theft, Fraud, Laundering of the proceeds of crime.
| Cryptocurrency Crimes: Legal Aspects of Crypto Currencies and | |
|---|---|
| Evaluation in Terms of Turkish Penal Code |
ABSTRACT
Crypto currencies and its most well-known example, Bitcoin, are considered to be the first layer of the Blokchain technology and offer radical changes to traditional trade and to the notion of currency today. It is seen that governments follow different attitudes towards this effect of crypto currencies. While the developed countries accept and tax the crypto currency as an asset, some countries try to ban the use of it. In spite of the prohibition and taxation activities on the subject, there is not yet a legal instrument regulating crypto currencies at national and international level. In this study, firstly the concepts of currencies and crypto currency are examined and then national and international developments in this field are discussed. In the second part of our study, crypto currencies are evaluated in terms of the provisions of the Turkish Penal Code and especially the question of whether the crypto currency would constitute the subject of theft crime is emphasized.
Keywords: Cryptocurrency, Virtual Money, Electronic Money, Cybercrime, Cryptocrime, Crimes against property, Theft, Cybertheft, Fraud, Money laundering.
Introduction
When money is mentioned, the first things that come to mind are tangible and visible forms of money with a physical existence, in the form of coins or banknotes. But is it essential for money to have a concrete reality? The tremendous development of technology has for some time been prompting us to ask these questions. For it is inevitable that technology, which plays a major role in every area of our lives and brings about changes there, should affect money, the economy and hence commerce.
Before pointing to the basic questions concerning cryptocurrencies, it is necessary first to clarify the question “What is money?” and thereby to provide an introduction to the problem of how cryptocurrencies are to be classified. Although it has no single settled definition, we may define money as the generally accepted common medium of exchange used in paying the price of goods and services and in discharging debts. At this point money is expressed in particular by its functions1, and in this sense the ontological explanation of money can be given without recourse to any idea of a form that it must have. Accordingly, every kind of means of payment that is used to pay a price and is generally accepted must be regarded as money.
When we examine the history of money, we see first that in primitive societies in which goods were bartered, goods of value such as salt, tobacco, hides, dried fish and head of livestock were used as the measure of exchange. This type of money is called commodity money. Even if we classify these as barter transactions, it should not be forgotten that at the root of commodity money lies a phenomenon of trust built on a relationship of debt and claim. Thereafter, kinds of money such as coined money, gold and silver certificates and representative paper money tied to gold and silver (representative money) are known to have been used. The banking system developed together with the widespread use of paper money, and central banks were established as “authorised institutions” so that money, which lies at the axis of the modern economic system, could be controlled by states.
Initially, the element of trust here lay in the fact that money was issued by governments, through authorised institutions, against precious metal. The issuing institutions also undertook to give those holding the money, in exchange for the representative money in question, the precious metals that constituted its backing. This practice, which was basically the reason why people accepted banknotes, was abandoned because banks did not hold metal reserves commensurate with the money they issued and because people rushed to the banks (bank run) upon talk that the banks were in a poor condition. Subsequently, when the practice known as the Bretton Woods system, under which the dollar was pegged to gold and the other countries in the system pegged their currencies to the dollar, was abolished by the USA in 1971, the gold standard system came to a complete end throughout the world and money began to be printed without backing. Thus the trust placed in money today has been reduced to the trust placed in the governments holding the power of issue and to the standing of economic institutions and organisations2.
Finally, the money also referred to as book money, which is held in bank accounts but has no physical existence, has come to lie at the centre of the debates on the future of the monetary system as a result of developments such as the decline in the use of cash and the spread of electronic money circulation networks3. That on which we shall dwell and which forms the main subject of our study, likewise without a physical existence and differing in important respects from book money as well, is cryptocurrency, which has come into being thanks to the development of technology and the internet and has today become a much-debated subject.
What Is Cryptocurrency?
A cryptocurrency, on the definition of which there is no consensus, is an electronic money system that makes the transfer of money between parties possible without the need for any third-party service. Bitcoin, the first and most famous cryptocurrency, uses the Blockchain infrastructure and technology and, indeed, in describing the evolution of that technology, is referred to as Blockchain 1.04. By means of the open-source material made available by Bitcoin, many altcoins have been developed and the number of types of cryptocurrency has increased considerably5. Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies can be understood more clearly by comparing them with other currencies and breaking them down into their elements:
a) The Element of Structure- An Independent and Distributed Structure: Unlike “traditional” money, cryptocurrencies are not printed by a physical central bank, owing to their characteristic of not being tied to governments holding a monopoly of issue or to a central authority. For this reason bitcoin is held in a digital wallet in a computer file saved on a personal computer or with an online service6. The Bitcoin network has no intermediary, administrator or supervisor; it consists of computers that are connected to one another peer to peer and participate on a voluntary basis. In this respect Bitcoin is exempt from the decisions of banks and states that would affect the value of money and from external influences7. Bitcoin is an “independent” currency, and what is involved is a system in the virtual environment in which anyone who wishes to produce Bitcoin can do so and in which, essentially, its users also take part in the activity of production. The computers referred to as miners solve mathematical problems very rapidly in order to confirm the correctness of transactions, and through this process 25 new Bitcoin are given to the persons who, thanks to their computer systems, find a solution and thereby create a new block of money. In Nakamoto’s words, thanks to this incentive system money is able to enter the system, which has no central authority to print it, in a “distributed” manner, as desired. It must be noted, however, that Bitcoin is limited to a certain monetary supply.
b) The Element of Trust: The basic motivation behind the emergence of Bitcoin is the absence of a mechanism by which payment can be made over a communication channel without a trusted third party. According to Nakamoto, the ever-increasing weight of financial institutions as trusted third parties in electronic commerce raises costs, transactions carried out through a third party contain security vulnerabilities and, since there is generally a lower limit, it becomes difficult for the small-value movements made with cash to take place in the electronic environment. As a solution to this, Bitcoin proposes an electronic payment system which is based on cryptographic proof “instead of trust” and which brings the two parties directly face to face without an intermediary8. In this system virtual coins are transferred to the counterparty by means of a digital signature, and each transfer is effected by taking the “hash” of the previous transaction and signing the recipient’s public key. The transfers carry the stamp of the time at which the transfer was made, and this stamp also contains the time of the previous transfer. In this way, by means of unique and unrepeatable codes, the problem of double spending is also prevented9.
c) The Element of Privacy: Transactions are anonymous and are carried out under pseudonyms. Transactions have no connection with real persons, institutions or bank accounts. Users are able to enter the system and carry out money movements without having to disclose their real identities10. “Privacy” is ensured by the use of cryptographic techniques11. In traditional money movements, on the other hand, the majority of which take place through banks and various intermediary institutions, these institutions keep a variety of information and personal data, chief among them the identity details of the parties.
d) The Element of Transparency: Anyone who wishes may follow the money movements taking place on the Bitcoin network. In this respect persons can see the amount of Bitcoin on the market, and it is also possible to follow, in the context of transfers between wallets, on which date a transaction of how many Bitcoin was carried out. Transactions are transparent, fast and global. This is one of the fundamental points on which cryptocurrencies differ from conventional currencies. It should of course be noted that, in the face of this transparency, privacy is not pushed into the background either, since the identity of the Bitcoin user concerned is kept secret.
Within this framework it is possible to summarise cryptocurrencies, and Bitcoin in particular, as currencies which are not tied to any public or private sector body, in whose regulatory and supervisory processes the users themselves take part, whose issue is likewise carried out by the users and is distributed and limited, and in whose money movements the ensuring of privacy and transparency is taken as the basis.
The Legal Dimension of Cryptocurrencies
As always, the law follows behind technology; today people first turn their ideas into various works by means of technology, and governments thereafter, having regard to the spheres of impact of these works and developments, set about regulating them by law. This is also the case for cryptocurrencies and the other innovations brought by Blockchain technology12. At present there is neither an international nor a national instrument of legal regulation governing the functioning of cryptocurrencies13.
In such a legal vacuum, states aim to introduce regulations concerning Bitcoin and the currencies derived from it, in particular on the ground that they are used as an instrument in the commission of various offences and that, in addition, assets derived from crime are laundered, and with the aim of preventing these. It should be noted that, notwithstanding the absence of a legal instrument regulating virtual currencies, some countries (Algeria, Bolivia, Bangladesh, Egypt, Nepal, Cambodia, Thailand, Indonesia, Pakistan, China, Vietnam, the UAE, Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia)14 have banned the use of cryptocurrency, whereas in some countries (the USA, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Russia, Japan, Switzerland, Denmark, Spain, Sweden, Austria, Norway)15 the income arising from cryptocurrency transactions is taxed.
A. Efforts to Regulate Cryptocurrencies at the International Level
International efforts have focused on achieving unanimity on the potential benefits and risks of cryptocurrencies16. One of the most comprehensive pieces of work on this subject was carried out by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), which was established in 1989 by the G-7 countries within the OECD with the aim of ensuring international cooperation in the field of combating the laundering of the proceeds of crime and the financing of terrorism. In its report of June 201417 the FATF first undertook work towards defining virtual currencies and the risks they entail and, a year later, in June 2015, published its guidance on a risk-based approach to virtual currencies18.
In its report the FATF defined virtual currencies as a digital representation of value that can be digitally traded and functions as a medium of exchange and/or a unit of account or a store of value, while stating that they have not yet attained legal status in any jurisdiction. In this respect, the exchange of virtual currency between persons can be subject only to the rules of the contract between them19. The FATF goes on to address the risk dimension of virtual currencies, stating that decentralised/distributed systems are particularly vulnerable to the risks that may arise from anonymity. Similarly, it was stated that their being open to global access also increases the risks in the fight against money laundering and the financing of terrorism20.
In the FATF’s guidance of June 2015, the applicability of the recommendations previously published by that body for combating the laundering of the proceeds of crime and the financing of terrorism to the new situations created by virtual currencies was addressed21, and the risk-based approach to be adopted with regard to those currencies was then set out22. The report also includes the various preventive measures taken in respect of cryptocurrencies in some countries, such as the United States of America, the United Kingdom, China, France and Switzerland, with the aim of preventing money laundering and the financing of terrorism23.
Another important international piece of work relating to our subject is the report published by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in 2016 under the title “Virtual Currencies and Beyond: Initial Considerations”24. The report deals with a scope wider than cryptocurrencies, namely virtual currencies, but also provides important explanations for cryptocurrencies.
In this report virtual currencies are defined as digital representations of value issued by private developers and denominated in their own unit of account25. It goes on to discuss whether virtual currencies can be regarded as money and states, in a manner with which we do not agree, that owing to the volatility of their value virtual currencies are not a reliable store of value, that owing to the small size of their current scale and network their acceptance as a medium of exchange is difficult, and that there is insufficient evidence to show that they can be regarded as an independent unit of account26.
The report further states that the regulation of the field of virtual currencies and the development of policy pose difficulties for state institutions and points out, by way of the example that the US tax authority, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), classifies virtual currency as property whereas the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCen) treats these currencies as value for its own purposes, that, above all, agreement on a definition cannot be achieved even among the institutions and legislation of one and the same government27. It then touches on the difficulties in tracing virtual currency and on the problems which its cross-border technology creates for legal regulation at the national level28. Finally, on the subject of risks, it is stated that virtual currency technologies pose a threat to financial integrity and that, even on the assumption that all the major risks it carries had been eliminated, it would be very difficult, by reason of its distributed structure, to intervene in this transaction network, which is seen as an important area for money laundering, and to apply and enforce the law in this field29.
In particular through its assessments concerning the definition of virtual currency and to the effect that it cannot be classified as money, the International Monetary Fund is seen to adopt a conservative stance towards cryptocurrency technologies, which pose a kind of threat to its own future. In parallel with this, it should be noted that, at the end of the principles recommended to countries that are to introduce regulation on virtual currencies, emphasis is placed on integration between virtual currencies and the traditional financial system30.
Apart from these pieces of work, at the regional level the work carried out within the European Union (EU) by the European Banking Authority (EBA), which is responsible for monitoring financial movements, and by the European Central Bank (ECB) is noteworthy. The EBA has issued a warning dated 13 December 201331, an opinion dated 4 September 201432 and a report dated 9 January 201933.
In its warning the EBA defined virtual currency as a form of unregulated digital money that is not issued, regulated or guaranteed by a central bank and that can function as a means of payment. The warning goes on to draw attention to the risks that virtual currencies may create, and users were warned of the theft of virtual currency on exchange platforms or from digital wallets, of virtual currencies not being protected as a means of payment, of prices being subject to rapid change and being volatile, of money movements being liable to become the subject of criminal activities and of the possibility of being subject to tax obligations34.
In its opinion of 2014, for its part, the EBA set out definitions concerning virtual currencies and market participants35, explained the potential benefits of virtual currencies36 and addressed the risks they entail37 and the approach to be taken in the event of regulation38. According to the EBA, virtual currencies carry significant economic benefits in that they reduce the cost and time spent on money movements, ensure the finality of payments, may contribute to economic growth and provide for financial outreach beyond the EU. As benefits they may offer to individuals, the fact that they ensure the security of personal data and the limited nature of intervention by public bodies were listed.
The opinion contains a comprehensive risk analysis and sets out a total of seventy risks ranked by high, medium and low degree of significance. In sum, according to the EBA, virtual currencies carry the risk of causing various kinds of economic loss to users through activities such as fraud and theft; they pose a danger to financial integrity in that they may become the subject of money laundering and economic crime; and, for regulatory authorities, they involve various regulatory risks because they are a new field. In the face of these risks the EBA recommends to governments an approach that envisages long-term and international legal regulation39.
Finally, when the report of 9 January 2019 is considered, it should first be noted that the EBA essentially addresses the question of the applicability of EU law to crypto-assets (virtual currencies, and tokens/coins used for investment and for the purchase of goods and services). According to the report, crypto-asset activities do not constitute one of the services falling within the scope of EU banking, payments and electronic money regulation and, for this reason, there are risks for consumers, who are not protected by any regulation at EU level40. In its report the EBA, referring to its opinion of 2014 and to the work of the FATF, identifies the risks of money laundering and terrorist financing41 and also draws attention to the development of crypto-assets and of the markets in which these assets are traded42. According to the EBA, these developments in the market at the same time point to a need for further review of the EU’s anti-money-laundering legislation. The EBA therefore recommends that the European Commission carry out a comprehensive cost/benefit analysis taking account of the problems inside and outside the financial sector, and states that the steps to be taken by the EU institutions with regard to crypto-asset activities and the consumer will be monitored43.
B. Efforts to Regulate Cryptocurrencies at the National Level
As of today there is no statutory regulation in Türkiye concerning cryptocurrency assets. However, the statement made on this subject by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Board (BDDK) on 25 November 201344, that made by the Undersecretariat of Treasury on 11 January 201845, and the General Letter sent to institutions by the Capital Markets Board (SPK) on 27 November 201746 together with the statement it made in its Weekly Bulletin of 27 September 201847 are steps taken by Türkiye’s official bodies.
When the BDDK statement, the earliest of the pieces of work listed above, is examined, it is seen that the Board addresses in particular the question whether the cryptocurrency Bitcoin falls within the scope of Law No. 6493 “on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions”. The statement uses the words “Bitcoin, which is known as a virtual currency that is not issued by any official or private institution and for whose counter-value no guarantee is given, is not regarded, by reason of its present structure and functioning, as electronic money within the scope of the Law, and its oversight and supervision within the framework of the said Law is therefore not considered possible.” and reaches the conclusion that it does not fall within the scope of the Law.
Article 3 of Law No. 6493 contains the “Definitions” section and
in sub-paragraph (ç) electronic money is defined as follows: “It means the monetary value which is issued against funds accepted by the electronic money issuing institution, is stored electronically, is used to carry out the payment transactions defined in this Law and is also accepted as a means of payment by natural and legal persons other than the electronic money issuing institution.” According to this legislation, it is understood that four criteria have been laid down for a currency to be classified as electronic money. These may be stated as (i) being issued against funds by the electronic money issuing institution, that is, pursuant to Art. 3(1)(d), the legal person authorised to issue electronic money under the Law48, (ii) being stored electronically, (iii) being used for the purpose of carrying out payment transactions, which are defined in Art. 3(1)(u) of the Law as the activity of depositing, transferring or withdrawing funds carried out on the instruction of the sender or the recipient, and (iv) also being accepted as a means of payment by natural and legal persons other than the electronic money issuing institution.
Since cryptocurrencies are stored in a digital wallet in a computer file saved on a personal computer or with an online service, they fulfil the criterion of being stored electronically; since they are used for the purpose of carrying out the payment transactions defined in the Law, they fulfil the third criterion listed; and since they are accepted as a means of payment between natural and legal persons, they fulfil the last criterion. However, cryptocurrencies cannot satisfy the first and perhaps most decisive condition, both because they have no legal structure capable of fulfilling the conditions listed in the Law and do not conduct their activities in accordance with Law No. 5411, and because the BDDK has no means of supervising and overseeing cryptocurrency institutions that have no head office or branch in Türkiye, and also because they are issued not against funds by a specific central institution but only by their users in return for solving difficult mathematical problems and are introduced into the system in a distributed manner. In this respect it is not possible for cryptocurrencies to be classified as “electronic money” within the scope of Law No. 6493. Approaching the matter theoretically, when it is borne in mind that electronic money is merely a digital representation of the fiat money in circulation issued by governments, the conclusion is reached that cryptocurrencies are not electronic money but “virtual currency”, and in our study too cryptocurrencies are at present examined on the basis of this premise.
Returning to the statement, the Board went on to state that the fact that the identities of the parties are not known in transactions carried out with Bitcoin and similar virtual currencies makes it easier for those virtual currencies to be used in illegal activities. According to the BDDK, moreover, in addition to risks such as the fact that the market value of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin may be extremely volatile and that digital wallets may be stolen, lost or used improperly without their owners’ knowledge, they are also exposed, because the transactions carried out are irreversible, to risks arising from operational errors or from abuse by malicious sellers.
The Undersecretariat of Treasury, for its part, in its press release of 11 January 2018 first recalled that cryptocurrencies have no legal basis in our country and that the transactions carried out in this context are not under the guarantee of any official authority. Subsequently, in parallel with the BDDK, attention was drawn to the risks relating to cryptocurrencies, and it was stated that the practices of ventures that are to issue cryptocurrency which are aimed at obtaining start-up capital provide, owing to the absence of regulation and supervision, a fertile ground for fraud. In conclusion the Undersecretariat states that it has issued reminders to users about the risks relating to cryptocurrencies and that persons should be aware that they may encounter adverse outcomes.
The SPK, in turn, in its General Letter of 27 November 2017, its first piece of work on this subject, includes the words “it was notified that, taking into account that there is no regulation or definition in Türkiye concerning virtual currencies and that virtual currencies are not among the elements that may constitute an underlying for the derivative instruments falling within the scope of the Capital Markets Law, it had been decided to give notice that at this stage no spot or derivative transactions based on virtual currencies should be carried out for clients.” Accordingly, the Board states that virtual currencies do not have the features capable of constituting an underlying for the derivative instruments falling within the scope of Capital Markets Law No. 6362.
When the Law is examined, it is seen that Article 3 contains the “Definitions” section and that derivative instruments are dealt with in three different ways49. Accordingly, derivative instruments may be used in transactions for the sale, purchase or exchange of securities, may be issued by reference to the price of, or changes in the price of, certain assets, or denote leveraged transactions to be carried out on foreign exchange, precious metals or other transactions to be determined by the Board. Derivative instruments are financial instruments involving the purchase, sale or exchange of the financial product at a specified place and on a specified date at the price fixed on the transaction date. In that case transactions in derivative products are effected by forward, futures, option and swap contracts. Since cryptocurrencies are neither issued on the basis of an asset nor made the subject of transactions with a view to changes in a specific price, they cannot be classified as a “derivative instrument” either under positive law or in theory. Similarly, as they do not represent any share and are not used as a debt instrument, they cannot be regarded as a “security” either50.
In its Weekly Bulletin, in which it assessed initial virtual currency offerings (Initial Coin Offering, ICO), the SPK stated that ICOs are very high-risk and speculative investments. It is stated that many of the practices aimed at raising money, generally by using blockchain technology, which are also known as a “Cryptocurrency Sale” or “Token Sale”, fall outside the SPK’s sphere of regulation and supervision. The SPK goes on to warn persons about the risks involved in ICOs; it draws attention to the fact that, as with cryptocurrencies, extreme volatility may also be seen in the value of the tokens purchased, that the money raised may not be used for the stated purposes, that the documents provided by sellers may contain incomplete and misleading information and that, since the majority of the projects for which funds are raised through practices of this kind are early-stage projects, the project may fail and the whole of the investment made may be lost. Finally, the SPK states that the work on secondary legislation being carried out at the Board concerning the procedures and principles governing crowdfunding activities to be carried out within the framework of capital markets legislation is continuing, and that whether “token sale” practices, which have features similar to and different from public offering and crowdfunding activities, fall within the Board’s regulatory boundaries will vary from case to case; it is stated that, before the secondary legislation on this subject enters into force, the Board will apply every necessary administrative and criminal measure in respect of activities carried out without authorisation under the name of crowdfunding. According to the Board, at this stage investors should give no credence to crypto-asset sales that are likely to be carried out under the name of crowdfunding.
When the point reached by our country with regard to cryptocurrencies is assessed, it is seen that our public bodies have begun work on the subject but that, as with the international bodies, an approach focused rather on risk has been developed towards it. When Law No. 6493 on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and Electronic Money Institutions and Capital Markets Law No. 6362 are examined, it is understood that these regulations cannot find application with regard to cryptocurrencies, for cryptocurrencies can be classified neither as electronic money nor as a security nor as a derivative instrument. On the other hand, in the light of current developments, the remedying of this absence of regulation concerning cryptocurrencies appears probable and near. This finding of ours has, as it were, been borne out in particular by the statement in the eleventh development plan that the Central Bank of the Republic of Türkiye (TCMB) will issue a cryptocurrency, and regulating this field has now become unavoidable for our law51. This initiative of the TCMB shows that even a centralised system cannot remain indifferent to technological developments that promise to change it entirely. Cryptocurrency technology has profoundly affected central banking, which rests on the accumulated experience of centuries, in a period of only ten years.
Cryptocurrency Crimes
Perhaps the area in which cryptocurrencies have found most coverage in the media is their being made the subject of acts of cybercrime. Since it is very difficult in the Bitcoin system to trace money movements and to get from pseudonyms to real persons, offenders wishing to carry out their illegal activities anonymously and secretly have over time continued these activities by means of cryptocurrencies.
Cryptocurrencies are generally used to sever the link between the proceeds of crime and their source and to render them untraceable; they may also be made the subject of acts of theft by hackers and, in addition, serve as an instrument in the carrying out of drug trafficking, smuggling, child pornography, prostitution and similar acts whose subject matter constitutes an offence52. For the “offences committed by means of cryptocurrencies”, which bring major innovations to the commission of these offences and are seen as an important area of criminality, it is seen that the terms “crypto crime”53, “cryptocurrency crimes”54 and “crimes related to cryptocurrencies” (crypto currencies related crimes)55 are used in international work and by the public. In this study we prefer the expression “cryptocurrency crimes” as the title of the subject. For we are of the opinion that this term is a highly comprehensive, concise and memorable expression for explaining the subject.
It should not be forgotten, however, that cryptocurrencies are used as an instrument in the commission of the offences in question and as an alternative to traditional money on account of the opportunities they create for offenders, such as anonymity and the absence of any need for an intermediary, which have been set out in detail above. Accordingly, there is no separate type of offence called cryptocurrency crime; the term merely denotes a new manner of committing the offences we have listed56.
A. Cryptocurrency Crimes as a Type of Cybercrime
Since cryptocurrency crimes are directed, by means of information systems, at the information system and at data, and at the proper and functional operation, security and integrity of the system/data, they display their character in cyberspace and are in this sense seen as a means of committing cybercrime and as an area of cyber criminality.
One of the first and best-known examples in this field concerns the website named Silk Road. The site in question was set up in February 2011 on the internet network known as the Deep Web, which provides connection only through special servers. The web-based organisation, which was a platform for trade in drugs, forged identity cards, counterfeit products, credit cards and software and offered the facility of remaining anonymous, began by virtue of these features to be used by illegal organisations and in time became an application used solely in the financing of trafficking in drugs, human beings and organs. Upon its coming to be used intensively by criminal organisations, it was made the subject of an investigation by the US Department of Justice in September 2013, and a criminal complaint was filed against the owner and operator of the website on the ground that the site sold illegal goods and services through anonymous accounts.
In October 2013 the website was shut down by the FBI and Ross Ulbricht, one of the site’s administrators, was apprehended. It was noticed that on the website, which faced charges of drug trafficking, computer hacking and money laundering, payments were made in Bitcoin, in contrast to traditional payment methods. Indeed, 173,991 Bitcoin used in illegal activities were seized in the course of the investigation.
It was recorded that Silk Road earned commission income of 1.2 billion dollars from these activities. In addition, it was emphasised that millions of dollars were laundered through the transactions and that as much again was obtained from the drug trade57. Recently, on 12 April 2019, Thomas White, founder and administrator of Silk Road 2.0, was sentenced to imprisonment for the offences of supplying drugs, money laundering and possessing a large number of indecent images of children on his computer58.
In another case, the organisation named Liberty Reserve, based in Costa Rica and founded in 2006, was a website set up so that offenders could distribute, store and launder their proceeds from credit card fraud, identity theft, investment fraud, computer hacking, drug trafficking and child pornography59. The website, which operated on a global scale, had more than one million users worldwide, 200,000 of them in the USA, and carried out approximately 55 million transactions, almost all of which were illegal.
The fact that cryptocurrencies too could be used as a means of payment and that users, when transferring money, could render the transfers completely untraceable by concealing their Liberty Reserve account numbers played a part in its coming, over time, to be preferred by many criminal organisations and money launderers as well. In May 2013 the US Department of Justice took into custody a total of seven of its employees, including the administrator of the website, on the ground that an amount of more than 6 billion dollars had been used for the purpose of money laundering. Violation of section 311 of the USA Patriot Act was given as the ground for this operation. Arthur Budovsky, the Liberty Reserve executive responsible for financial affairs, was sentenced to 20 years’ imprisonment for his acts60.
In conclusion, the various features offered by cryptocurrencies, such as anonymity, the possibility of carrying out transactions without identification and the untraceability of money movements, have led criminal organisations, perpetrators who launder money and criminals engaged in other illegal activities to turn to websites that use cryptocurrency and its technology as a platform and to carry on their activities in this field. Cryptocurrency has, as it were, an ambivalent nature: on the one hand there are the positive developments and innovations it brings, and on the other the risks it harbours and the opportunities it affords to perpetrators. It is precisely here that the difficulty of regulating this field lies for legislatures as well: they are unable to decide whether the positive developments offered by cryptocurrency or the significant dangers it brings weigh more heavily and ought to be taken as the basis.
B. Assessment of Cryptocurrency Crimes under the Turkish Criminal Code
First of all, one should begin by clearing up a confusion on this matter. The use of cryptocurrencies does not constitute any offence and does not give rise to criminal liability. For, pursuant to Article 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK), “No one may be punished or subjected to a security measure for an act which the law does not expressly define as an offence. No penalty or security measure other than those laid down in the law may be imposed.” In the Turkish criminal law system, legality in respect of offences and penalties is fundamental, and the article in question is the normative basis of this principle. Considering that cryptocurrency or its use is not addressed in any statutory provision, being a user of cryptocurrency, which is not expressly defined as an offence, cannot be regarded as an offence because it is not regulated as an offence type in the TCK or in other laws; on that account no one may be punished or subjected to a security measure. The perception that “Using cryptocurrency is an offence”, which has arisen in connection with the fact that cryptocurrencies are for the most part made the subject of acts of money laundering, does not reflect the truth.
In assessing cryptocurrencies under the TCK, the first offences that come to mind as ones of which they may form the subject matter are “Theft” (Art. 141 TCK), “Fraud” (Art. 157 TCK), “System Interference, Destruction or Alteration of Data” (Art. 244 TCK) and “Laundering of Assets Derived from an Offence” (Art. 282 TCK).
1. The Offences of Theft and of System Interference, Destruction or Alteration of Data Committed by Means of Cryptocurrencies
It was noted above that cryptocurrencies may be stolen from persons’ digital wallets or via the exchange platforms they use, that persons may suffer pecuniary loss and, in particular, that hackers may carry out attacks directed at cryptocurrency movements. At this point, then, the question “Can cryptocurrencies form the subject matter of the offence of theft?” comes to mind. Further, since the term cryptocurrency denotes a form of money which, like book money, has no physical existence, and since the acts will be carried out on data held in information systems, it may be thought that the acts would instead constitute the offence of system interference, destruction or alteration of data and the obtaining of an unjust benefit from those acts. For this reason, we prefer to assess the two offences together and comparatively under this sub-heading.
a. Can Cryptocurrencies Form the Subject Matter of the Offence of Theft?
One must begin with the following observation: it has not yet become clear in Turkish law how cryptocurrencies are to be classified, that is, whether they will be accepted as money or as some other kind of value. As we stated above, the BDDK stated in its press release of 25 November 2013 that cryptocurrency is a virtual currency which is not issued by any official or private institution and for whose counter-value no guarantee is given, that by reason of its present structure and functioning it is not, within the scope of Law No. 6493, regarded as electronic money and that its oversight and supervision within the framework of that Law is therefore not considered possible. The SPK, for its part, states that there must first of all be a real product or asset on which a security is based and that, since no such product can be spoken of in the case of Bitcoin, it does not fit its own definition of a security. What is odd is that both institutions warn users that there are risks such as the fact that the identities of the parties to transactions carried out with bitcoin and similar virtual currencies are not known, that these virtual currencies create a suitable environment for use in illegal activities, that the market value of Bitcoin may be volatile and that digital wallets may be stolen, lost or used improperly without their owners’ knowledge, and yet take no counter-step whatsoever with regard to the legislative gap in this matter.
The offence of theft, for its part, is regulated in Article 141 of the TCK as follows: “Any person who, without the consent of its possessor, takes movable property belonging to another from the place where it is located, with the aim of obtaining a benefit for himself or for another, shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of one to three years.” Following the clear wording of the provision, it is seen that there is consensus in legal scholarship that the subject matter of the offence of theft is “movable property belonging to another”61. The decisive issue at this point lies in the meaning to be given to the concept of movable property and in the sources to be consulted in defining it. When the views are examined, it is seen to be stated that the concept of property must be determined in accordance with the Turkish Civil Code and that, as a result, the property must have a “material” (physical) existence62.
In the light of all this information, it is understood that Bitcoin and the cryptocurrencies derived from it, being virtual assets, do not yet have the character of movable property, and in this respect it comes to mind that, by virtue of the principle of legality of offences and penalties, no criminal liability would arise from acts carried out on cryptocurrencies with regard to offences against property and, in particular, the offence of theft. Yet this assumption may not always lead us to the correct conclusion.
b. The Offence of Cyber Theft and Its Assessment with regard to Acts of Theft Carried Out through Cryptocurrency
The case in which the offence of theft is committed through the use of information systems is regulated, as an aggravated form, in Article 142, paragraph 2, sub-paragraph “e” of the TCK No. 523763. With developing technology, the emergence every day of a new way of committing cybercrime has given rise to the need for such a provision64. However, there are question marks as to whether the subject matter of the offence consists of tangible objects or of data. While data may form the subject matter of this offence, which may be termed cyber theft, the fact that the provision has been placed under the offence of theft and as an aggravated form of it is the main factor behind the emergence of questions of this kind. For this reason, we are of the opinion that it was not appropriate to include the provision in question in this manner.
In our view, the subject matter of this offence consists of the “data” that are the object of the act of theft committed by using information systems. Data may take the form of digital representations of traditional money, as in the case of electronic money, or the form of virtual assets which, like cryptocurrencies, directly express an economic value in themselves and change hands in that form.
Determining what the subject matter of the offence is lies at the heart of the debate as to which offence type must be applied: the offence of cyber theft (Art. 142(2)(e)) or the offence of obtaining an unjust benefit from data by means of an information system (Art. 244). For some time this debate continued in the form of different chambers of the Court of Cassation delivering judgments on the basis of different offence types, and it subsequently became the subject of a decision of the General Criminal Assembly of the Court of Cassation (YCGK) in such a way as to ensure uniformity in the decisions65.
In the case that was the subject of the decision, the accused, acting together, used the internet banking password of the intervening company, which they had previously obtained unlawfully, and accessed the victim’s bank account over the internet. They then transferred the money in the account to an account opened in the name of one of the accused. They also withdrew the transferred amount from another bank branch.
In its decision the YCGK rightly stated that the intent of the perpetrators in their acts, which took the form of transferring the money in the account and then withdrawing it from another bank, was directed not so much at sending the data held in the intervening company’s bank account elsewhere as at acquiring, as property, the money represented by those data. The Assembly went on to state that, in order to reach the money in the victim’s internet banking account, the accused had, apart from using information systems as a means, no other alternative. In conclusion, the court characterised the act not under Art. 244(4) but as the offence of “theft through the use of an information system”. Since this decision of 2009, the Criminal Chambers of the Court of Cassation have been applying Art. 142(2)(e) of the TCK to acts of this kind.
Although this decision was given in relation to book money, it is an extremely important indicator for cryptocurrency crimes. For although money has a cost and a value as paper, that is, as an object, what gives money its real value is its purchasing power. Money, which expresses purchasing power, may be printed on paper, just as it may be struck on metal or on stone, or, as we are discussing today and as will inevitably confront us everywhere in the future, it may consist of a code and a set of blocks. It can be seen that money, in terms of its kind as an object, has kept pace with technological developments in the course of history and, with the stage it has reached today, has attained the form of data66.
At this point a further debate arises when the matter is considered together with the preceding sub-heading. It was stated that the subject matter of the offence of theft must be “movable property”; however, cryptocurrencies have not been made the subject of any legal regulation in Turkish law, nor have they been regarded as falling within the scope of any regulation. In addition, the requirement that movable property have a physical existence must also be recalled. In that case, is the application of the offence of theft to cryptocurrencies, which, unlike book money, have not yet been legally characterised and have no direct corporeal existence/counterpart, to be regarded as falling within extensive interpretation, or will this interpretation amount to analogy? In essence, our examination under this sub-heading has been built upon this question67.
Following the view that the subject matter of the offence of cyber theft consists of data, it is seen that some authors in legal scholarship, too, regard data carriers as falling within the offence of theft but argue that the economic benefit obtained in such a data transfer must relate to a thing having a material substance in the outside world68. It should also be recalled that there is an opposing view in legal scholarship to the effect that the subject matter of the act taking the form of a transfer of book money consists of data and that, given that Art. 244 TCK has the character of a special norm, it is that provision which must be applied to acts of this kind69.
Unlike book money, cryptocurrency has no direct counterpart in the outside world. In other words, cryptocurrency differs from the numerical counterpart, visible in your internet banking account, of an amount held in a deposit account. The data representing the cryptocurrency are at the same time the economic value itself.
Bitcoin and the cryptocurrencies derived from it are a value that can be purchased for a price on their own exchanges and that is used between buyers and sellers, as an alternative to traditional money, in the virtual shops opened by hosting providers in the online environment known as e-commerce; it cannot in reality be touched or seen and is not printed or minted at any printing house or mint. Just as bitcoin is bought and sold online, it is paid by the buyer to the seller as the consideration for the sale of products, and the seller in turn can convert the bitcoin obtained into a currency in circulation, for example the US dollar, through exchanges that likewise exist online. Cryptocurrencies are therefore, in themselves and from a teleological point of view, virtual assets that express an economic value and change hands in that form. This economic value will manifest itself in the outside world by being converted into a traditional currency or by the purchase of goods in return for it. From this perspective it is understood that cryptocurrencies constitute, in so far as they are digital data, the numerical values representing the bitcoin or derivative cryptocurrency held and, in so far as they are accepted as money in the virtual world, the counterpart of asset values, that is, an economic value in their own right.
On the other hand, by regulating the offence of cyber theft the legislature has also made its intention in this matter clear. To adhere strictly to the elements of the basic form of the offence, together with the wording of the provision, in seeking to apply this offence type would, however, render the application of the offence impossible. Removing the possibility of protecting virtual assets and the asset values in cyberspace under the heading “Offences against Property” would be incompatible with the intention of the legislature and the ratio legis of the provision.
On the other hand, applying the provision of Art. 244(4) to acts relating to cryptocurrency or electronic money ought not to be possible, since we do not share the idea that, in a world that is digitalising in this way, data constituting an economic value should be treated like simple data70.
The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), too, in a judgment it delivered concerning the sale of bitcoin, accepted bitcoin and the cryptocurrencies derived from it as a currency, albeit a virtual one, within the scope of the Value Added Tax Directive 2006/112/EC and held in this sense that, pursuant to Art. 135(1)(e) of the Directive, they are to be exempted by the Member States, just as is the case with transactions in traditional currency71. In line with the case law of the CJEU, accepting cryptocurrencies merely as data and thereby relegating the economic value they carry to the background does not reflect the current situation, and, by means of a “purposive interpretation”, acts of cryptocurrency theft directed at persons’ property must be punished within the framework of Art. 142(2)(e)72.
In sum, cryptocurrencies should be classified as “data” that represent an asset value and constitute its counterpart. As a result of this classification, persons’ crypto-assets can be protected by those instruments of criminal law that aim to protect property.
It cannot be maintained that the legislature, which by the offence of theft seeks to protect even the smallest asset values that can easily be transferred and which has, in addition, also included a provision on cyber theft, did not intend to protect cryptocurrencies and virtual assets, which embody a very large economy and significant asset values and their circulation. Extensive interpretation is resorted to precisely where the expressions used by the legislature fall short of, and are narrower than, the meaning it wished to give them, in order to interpret that intention in the light of current developments and to give the statutory text the intention of the legislature and the ratio legis of the text. In this period in which the whole of our lives, financial values first and foremost, has been digitalised, there is no strictly binding rule to the effect that the concept of movable property must, for the purposes of criminal law, have a direct “physical” counterpart; the concept of movable property, too, is expected to undergo a transformation. It must nevertheless be stated that, on this fine line between analogy and extensive interpretation on which we stand, it is unfortunately possible to approach an interpretation of this kind in either way. Although our opinion is that this is an extensive interpretation, a view accepting the contrary may also be encountered in future debates on this point.
It must nevertheless be repeated that including the offence of cyber theft in the form of an aggravated form of the offence of theft makes the application of the provision considerably more difficult and is methodologically problematic, since it takes no account of the technological transformation the offence has undergone and of its nature. Considering the fact that today a large part of money movements takes place through the circulation of data on information systems, we are of the opinion that concepts such as “movable property”, “possession” and “ownership”, the legacy of Roman law, are unable to meet present-day needs.
To arrive at the elements of the offence of theft by way of these concepts and to remain bound by literal interpretation amounts to remaining indifferent to acts that will take place in cyberspace. In fact, this very situation gives rise to the necessity of arriving at the definition of the offence by means of “purposive interpretation”. Yet the offence in question needs to be regulated as a “separate” offence type whose elements relating to the statutory definition meet present-day needs, and the debates and question marks concentrated on this point need to be answered.
2. The Offence of Fraud Committed by Means of Cryptocurrencies
Sub-paragraph “f” of paragraph 1 of Article 158 of the TCK regulates the offence of fraud committed through the use of information systems73. This article regulates one of the most frequently encountered types of cybercrime and punishes acts of obtaining an unlawful benefit as a result of fraudulent operations carried out on information systems.
In the offence of fraud committed by means of information systems, the Court of Cassation adheres to the basic form of the offence and requires that fraudulent conduct be directed by the perpetrator against a natural person. Proceeding, moreover, from the view that such fraudulent conduct cannot be directed against an information system, it requires, for the offence to be constituted, that the fraudulent conduct be directed at a natural person and that an unjust benefit be obtained through information systems also being used in the course of deceiving the natural person who believes this deception74.
In connection with our subject, the offence in question may arise in particular during virtual currency offerings (Initial Coin Offering, ICO). Where an unjust benefit is obtained through deceptive ruses that may be employed in projects for which funds are raised by practices of this kind, such as the money collected in the framework of these offerings not being used for the stated purposes, or the documents provided by those carrying out the offering containing incomplete and misleading information and persons being deceived in this way, the offence of fraud committed through the use of an information system will be constituted.
3. The Offence of Laundering the Proceeds of Crime Committed by Means of Cryptocurrencies
Article 282 of the TCK regulates the offence of laundering of assets derived from an offence. For the offence of laundering the proceeds of crime, to use the expression we prefer, to be completed, an asset value obtained from a previously committed offence must be taken abroad, its source must be concealed, or it must be subjected to various transactions with the aim of creating the impression that it was obtained by legitimate means75.
Considering that the offence of laundering the proceeds of crime is regulated in the chapter on “Offences against the Judiciary”, it is seen that the legal interest protected by this offence is primarily the proper functioning of justice. For the acts that give rise to the laundering offence prevent the investigating authorities from reaching the assets that are the subject of the offence and make it difficult, and even impossible, to uncover the predicate offences from which the proceeds were obtained and their perpetrators. Apart from this, when the reasons for and the aims of combating laundering are assessed, it is seen that preventing the possession and use of the proceeds of crime, cutting off financial support for new offences and protecting public order constitute the other legal interests protected by the laundering offence76.
When the laundering of the proceeds of crime is spoken of, what must be understood is not a single, simple transaction but a whole set of numerous and complex transactions. For money launderers use a great number and variety of methods in order to achieve their aims. These laundering operations are carried out by passing through various stages. Foreign and national legal scholarship and practice are in agreement that laundering consists of three stages77.
First, in the placement stage the value obtained as a result of the offence is introduced into the legal economic system; in the second stage, the layering stage, numerous financial transactions of different kinds are carried out in an attempt to differentiate the proceeds of crime, to eliminate their links with the source thoroughly and to render them untraceable; and finally, in the integration stage, the proceeds of crime whose link with the source has been severed are introduced, by means of lawful transactions, into the financial system of the country in which they were obtained or in which the criminal organisation is established78.
Owing to the features of decentralisation and anonymity brought by blockchain technology, cryptocurrencies can be used in all three stages of the laundering offence. In the placement stage, when the proceeds of crime are transacted as cryptocurrency instead of cash or other financial instruments, they are not subject to the strict supervisory requirements to which the banking and financial systems are subject, because cryptocurrency technology enables the parties to transact with each other without the need for an intermediary or for verification79.
In the layering stage, in turn, by carrying out with cryptocurrencies the complex money movements known as “mixing”, which prevent the tracing of identity and bring transactions together in unpredictable combinations, the link between the proceeds of crime and their source can be severed and their trail can thus be lost80. In this respect, blockchain technology and the fact that the layering stage is carried out via information systems offer the perpetrators of offences opportunities in a negative sense.
Cryptocurrencies can also be used in the integration stage of the laundering offence. When asset values obtained from an offence are held as cryptocurrency, real and virtual goods and services can, as stated above, be purchased with this money, and it can be converted into national currencies at exchange centres. In this way it is possible for asset values obtained from an offence to be introduced into the financial system by lawful transactions81.
Conclusion
Cryptocurrency systems are merely one product of blockchain technology, and this technology has enormous potential and the power to permeate our lives with different areas of use, ranging from the way we do business to our habits of managing our assets, and from our habits of using our machines and vehicles to how we can vote securely. It is said that within this transformation there will be many sectors and institutions whose present-day working methods will change completely, and that many institutions and lines of business built on the principle of intermediation, such as insurance and banking, will also disappear.
In this process cryptocurrencies, too, are accepted in daily life and in the context of commercial activities by many companies worldwide as a means of payment for the purchase of real and virtual goods and services, are traded at hundreds of exchange and trading centres and are traded in both directions against the national currencies in circulation. The fact that cryptocurrencies have attained a market size that grew to as much as 850 billion US dollars also makes plain the scale of this sector. While cryptocurrencies attract the interest of individuals and companies with the various possibilities they offer, the vulnerability of the technology to misuse constitutes the other side of the coin.
Cryptocurrencies have recently been turning into a system used in the commission of the offences of theft, fraud, tax evasion, drugs, online gambling and laundering of the proceeds of crime. Although the concepts inherited from Roman law make it difficult to apply offences against property such as theft, robbery and fraud to attacks carried out against cryptocurrency values, purposive interpretation requires that the offences in question find application. On the other hand, there is also a need for a separate offence type in order to provide protection against acts, such as cyber theft, directed at persons’ virtual assets in cyberspace.
As the area of use of cryptocurrencies evolves towards illegal fields, governments are unable to foresee what kind of regulations they should introduce and what measures they can take in this regard; instead, they resort directly to blocking the technology and to prohibiting these movements.
We are of the opinion that the fact that countries resort directly to prohibitive regulations, without introducing provisions that define and regulate cryptocurrencies, determine their legal status and supervise them, stems from the conservative attitude taken in this matter. Imposing an outright ban by way of the legal order, instead of accepting scientific and technological developments and keeping pace with them, does not solve the problems brought by technology; on the contrary, it escalates them. Yet it appears that the future will change the fundamental values we are trying to protect, regardless of what we think about it. Resisting development and innovation will not slow the pace of this transformation.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
I. Books and Articles
Acemoğlu, Daron/David Laibson/John List, Macroeconomics, 1. Ed., Pearson, London, 2016.
Artuk, M. Emin/Ahmet Gökcen/M. Emin Alşahin/Kerim Çakır, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 17. Bası, Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, 2018.
Başbüyük, İsa, “İnternet Bankacılığı Aracılığıyla Gerçekleştirilen Hukuka Aykırı Havalenin Bilişim Suçları Açısından Değerlendirilmesi”, Ceza Hukuku Dergisi, Yıl: 8, Sayı: 21, 2013, s. 197-214.
Birch, David, Before Babylon, Beyond Bitcoin: From Money that We Understand to Money that Understands Us (Perspectives), London Publishing Partnership, London, 2017.
Boehm, Franziska/Paulina Pesch, “Bitcoin: A First Legal Analysis - with reference to German and US-American law”, in: Rainer Böhme/Michael Brenner/Tyler Moore/Matthew Smith (eds.), Financial Cryptography and Data Security: FC 2014 Workshops, BITCOIN and WAHC 2014, Christ Church, Barbados, March 7, 2014, Revised Selected Papers, Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg, 2014, s. 43-57.
Brill, Alan/Lonnie Keene, “Cryptocurrencies: The Next Generation of Terrorist Financing?”, Defence Against Terrorism Review, Vol. 6, No. 1, Spring&Fall 2014, Centre of Excellence-Defence Against Terrorism, (Çevrimiçi) https://ssrn.com/ abstract=2814914 (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019), s. 7-31.
Campbell-Verduyn, Malcolm, “Bitcoin, Crypto-Coins, And Global Anti-Money Laundering Governance”, Crime Law and Social Change, V.69, I.2, Springer, 2018, s. 283-305.
Campbell-Verduyn, Malcolm/Marcel Goguen, “The Mutual Constitution of Technology and Global Governance: Bitcoin, Blockchains, and the International Anti-money-laundering Regime”, in: Malcolm Campbell-Verduyn (ed.), Bitcoin and Beyond: Cryptocurrencies, Blockchains, and Global Governance, RIPE Series in Global Political Economy, Routledge, Oxford-New York, 2018, s. 69-88.
Case, Karl E./Ray C. Fair/Sharon M. Oster, Principles of Macroeconomics, 12. Ed., Pearson, London, 2017.
Dornbusch, Rudiger/Stanley Fischer/Richard Startz, Macroeconomics, 11. Ed., McGraw-Hill Education, New York, 2011.
Durdu, Erdal, Kripto Para Birimi Olarak Bitcoin ve Ceza Hukuku, Yayımlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Galatasaray Üniversitesi, 2018.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, 7. Bası, Seçkin, Ankara, 2018.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar, Seçkin, Ankara, 2011.
Dyson, Simon/William J.Buchanan/Liam Bell, “The Challenges of Investigating Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain Related Crime”, The Journal of The British Blockchain Association (The JBBA), Vol. 1, I. 2, s. 55-63.
Foley, Sean/Jonathan R. Karlsen/Tālis J. Putniņš, “Sex, drugs, and bitcoin: How much illegal activity is financed through cryptocurrencies?”, The Review of Financial Studies, V. 32, I. 5, Oxford University Press, 2019, s. 1798–1853.
Girasa, Rosario, Regulation of Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain Technologies, Palgrave Studies in Financial Services Technology, Springer, 2018.
Koca, Mahmut/İlhan Üzülmez, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 5. Bası, Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, 2018.
McConnell, Campbell R./Stanley L. Brue/Sean Masaki Flynn, Macroeconomics, 21.
Ed., McGraw-Hill Education, New York, 2017.
Narayanan, Arvind/Joseph Bonneau/Edward Felten/Andrew Miller/Steven Goldfeder, Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency Technologies: A Comprehensive Introduction, Princeton University Press, 2016.
Özbek, Veli Özer/Koray Doğan/Pınar Bacaksız/İlker Tepe, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 13. Bası, Seçkin, Ankara, 2018.
Papadopoulos, Georgios, “Money in the New Technological Paradigm” (Çevrimiçi)
https://ssrn.com/abstract=1586028, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Sutherland, Edwin H., “White-Collar Criminality”, American Sociological Review, Vol. 5, No. 1, s. 1-12.
Swan, Melanie, Blockchain: Blueprint for a New Economy, O'Reilly Media, California, 2015.
Şen, Ersan, “Bitcoin Çalınır mı?”, Haber7, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.haber7.com/yazarlar/ prof-dr-ersan-sen/1948163-bitcoin-calinir-mi (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Tezcan, Durmuş/Mustafa Ruhan Erdem/R. Murat Önok, Teorik ve Pratik Ceza Özel Hukuku, 16. Bası, Seçkin, Ankara, 2018.
Wright, Aaron/Primavera De Filippi, Decentralized Blockchain Technology and The Rise Of Lex Cryptographia, 2015, (Çevrimiçi) https://papers.ssrn.com/ sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2580664, s. 1-58, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Yıldız, Ali Kemal, Hırsızlık Suçu, Özel Ceza Hukuku, c. IV, Malvarlığına Karşı Suçlar, On İki Levha Yayıncılık, İstanbul, 2018.
Yüksel Bozkurt, Armağan Ebru, "Elektronik Para, Sanal Para, Bitcoin ve Linden Doları’na Hukuki Bir Bakış", İÜHFM, C. LXXIII, S. 2, 2015, s. 173-220.
II. Documents, Opinions, Research, News and Reports
Bankacılık Denetleme ve Düzenleme Kurulu (BDDK), Bitcoin Hakkında Basın Açıklaması (Çevrimiçi) https://www.bddk.org.tr/ContentBddk/dokuman/ duyuru_0512_01.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Benoit, Angeline/James Regan, "Facebook's Cryptocurrency Plan Draws ECB Warning on Regulation", Bloomberg, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.bloomberg.com/news/ articles/2019-07-07/facebook-s-cryptocurrency-plan-draws-ecb-warning-onregulation (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019).
Chainalysis, Crypto Crime Report, (Çevrimiçi) https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/ 5a9360f88433cb00018022c2/5c4f67ee7deb5948e2941fda_Chainalysis%20Ja nuary%202019%20Crypto%20Crime%20Report.pdf, Ocak 2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Disparte, Dante, “Crypto Crime Is Taking A Violent Turn”, Forbes, (Çevrimiçi)
https://www.forbes.com/sites/dantedisparte/2019/01/28/crypto-crime-is-taking-a-violent-turn/#3556778d15a5, 28.01.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
European Banking Authority (EBA), EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, (Çevrimiçi) https://eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/657547/EBA-Op-201408+ Opinion+on+Virtual+Currencies.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
European Banking Authority (EBA), Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets, (Çevrimiçi) https://eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/ 2545547/EBA+Report+on+crypto+assets.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
European Banking Authority (EBA), Warning to Consumers on Virtual Currencies, (Çevrimiçi) https://eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/598344/EBA+Warning+on+Virtual+Currencies.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Financial Action Task Force (FATF), Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach to Virtual Currencies (Çevrimiçi) https://www.fatf-gafi.org/media/fatf/docu-ments/ reports/Guidance-RBA-Virtual-Currencies.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Financial Action Task Force (FATF), Virtual Currencies: Key Definitions and Potential AML/CFT Risks (Çevrimiçi) https://www.fatf-gafi.org/media/fatf/documents/ reports/Virtual-currency-key-definitions-and-potential-aml-cft-risks.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Hileman, Garrick/Michel Rauchs, Global Cryptocurrency Benchmarking Study, Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, Cambridge Judge Business School, University of Cambridge, 2017, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/ fileadmin/user_upload/research/centres/alternativefinance/downloads/2017-global-cryptocurrency-benchmarking-study.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Houben, Robby/Alexander Snyers, Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain: Legal context and implications for financial crime, money laundering and tax evasion, European Union, 2018, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.europarl.europa.eu/cmsdata/ 150761/TAX3%20Study%20on%20cryptocurrencies%20and%20blockchain.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
International Monetary Fund (IMF), Virtual Currencies and Beyond: Initial Considerations, (Çevrimiçi), https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2016/ sdn1603.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Libra, White Paper, (Çevrimiçi) https://libra.org/en-US/white-paper/ (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019).
Nakatomo, Satoshi, “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System” (Çevrimiçi)
https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Ramey, Corinne, “The Crypto Crime Wave Is Here”, Wall Street Journal, (Çevrimiçi)
https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-crypto-crime-wave-is-here-1524753366, 26.04.2018 (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Rieth, Yulia, “How Crypto Crimes Change Players' Security Approach”, DeCenter, (Çevrimiçi) https://decenter.org/en/how-crypto-crimes-change-players-security-approach, 06.02.2018, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Sermaye Piyasası Kurulu (SPK) Araştırma Dairesi, Kripto-Para Bitcoin, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.spk.gov.tr/SiteApps/Yayin/YayinGoster/1130, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Simms, Thomas, “At Least 95 Percent of Crypto Crimes Involve Bitcoin, Chainalysis Executive Says”, Yahoo, (Çevrimiçi) https://finance.yahoo.com/news/least-95- percent-crypto-crimes-112200840.html, 25.04.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Suberg, William, “EU: Malta Needs to Improve Readiness to Respond to Cryptocurrency Crime”, Cointelegraph, (Çevrimiçi) https://cointelegraph.com/news/eu-malta-needsto-improve-readiness-to-respond-to-cryptocurrency-crime, 05.06.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
The Law Library of Congress, Regulation of Cryptocurrency Around the World (Çevrimiçi) https://www.loc.gov/law/help/cryptocurrency/cryptocurrency-world-survey.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019).
Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Cumhurbaşkanlığı Strateji ve Bütçe Başkanlığı, On Birinci Kalkınma Planı (2019-2023), (Çevrimiçi) http://www.sbb.gov.tr/ wp-content/uploads/2019/07/OnbirinciKalkinmaPlani.pdf, Temmuz 2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019).
United States House of Representatives Committee on Financial Services, “Examining Facebook’s Proposed Cryptocurrency and Its Impact on Consumers, Investors, and the American Financial System” (Çevrimiçi) https://financialservices.house.gov/uploadedfiles/hhrg-116-ba00-20190717-sd002-_memo.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019).
White, David J., “Cryptocurrency Crimes Are in a Class of Their Own”, Corporate Counsel Business Journal (CCBJ), (Çevrimiçi) https://ccbjournal.com/articles/ cryptocurrency-crimes-are-in-a-class-of-their-own, 03.01.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Wieczner, Jen, “Bitcoin Accounts for 95% of Cryptocurrency Crime, Says Analyst”, Fortune, (Çevrimiçi) http://fortune.com/2019/04/24/bitcoin-cryptocurrency-crime/, 25.04.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019).
Footnotes
- 2. Works of Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin Artuk First Edition: June 2020 3. Written about Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emin Artuk Page Design: Memoirs Ayşegül KEMEÇ 4. Scholarly Papers 5. Festschrift Cover Design: Yiğit Can AYDIN © Seçkin Yayıncılık San. ve Tic. A.Ş. All publication rights in this book belong to Seçkin Yayıncılık San. ve Tic. A.Ş. Without the written permission of the publisher, neither the whole nor any part of the book may in any way be published or reproduced in any medium, with the exception of quotations for promotional purposes not exceeding one page in total. Sales and Distribution: Publisher’s Head Office Mustafa Kemal Mahallesi 2158. Sokak No:13 Çankaya/ANKARA Tel: 0-312-435 30 30 Fax: 0-312-435 24 72 seckin@seckin.com.tr Istanbul Çağlayan Courthouse Istanbul Kartal Courthouse Istanbul Şişli Branch Regional Court of Appeal Ankara Sıhhiye Branch Branch Branch Abide-i Hürriyet Cad. Branch Strazburg Caddesi D Blok 2. Bodrum Kat No: 5 C Blok Zemin Kat No: 29 Kartal No:183/A Şişli C Blok Zemin Kat No: 23/B Sıhhiye Çağlayan Tel: (216) 303 11 23 Tel: (212) 234 34 77 No: 23 Kartal Tel: (312) 230 52 62 Tel: (212) 240 0015 Fax: (216) 303 11 23 Fax: (212) 231 24 69 Tel: (216) 303 20 00/5462 Fax: (312) 230 52 62 Fax: (212) 240 0015 kartalsube@seckin.com.tr sislisube@seckin.com.tr bamsube@seckin.com.tr ankarasube@seckin.com.tr caglayan@seckin.com.tr Website: www.seckin.com.tr Seçkin Yayıncılık Certificate No: 45644 Printing: Sözkesen Matbaacılık Tic. Ltd. Şti. – Certificate No: 46586 İVOGSAN 1518 Sok. Mat-Sit İş Merkezi No: 2/40 Yenimahalle/ANKARA - Tel: (0-312) 395 21 10 • Faculty Member, Istanbul Aydın University Faculty of Law/Attorney-at-Law. • Trainee Attorney.
- Among the functions performed by money, the literature mostly lists the following: expressing a unit of account (unit of account), being accepted as an instrument of exchange (medium of exchange), representing a value (store of value) and operating as an instrument of payment at a later date (means for deferred payment). Karl E. Case/Ray C. Fair/Sharon M. Oster, Principles of Macroeconomics, 12. Ed., Pearson, London, 2017, s. 188-189; Daron Acemoglu/David Laibson/John List, Macroeconomics, 1. Ed., Pearson, London, 2016, s. 275-276; Campbell R. McConnell/Stanley L. Brue/Sean Masaki Flynn, Macroeconomics, 21. Ed., McGraw-Hill Education, New York, 2017, s. 290; Rudiger Dornbusch/Stanley Fischer/Richard Startz, Macroeconomics, 11. Ed., McGraw-Hill Education, New York, 2011, s. 380; David Birch, Before Babylon, Beyond Bitcoin: From Money that We Understand to Money that Understands Us (Perspectives), London Publishing Partnership, London, 2017, s. 27-28. ↑
- The “traditional” currencies in circulation today may be defined as legal means of payment used for the exchange of goods and services, which are issued on the basis of a government decision, are not backed by precious metals such as gold, silver, etc., and are founded on trust in the body whose signature they bear and in the fact that the paper it issues cannot be counterfeited. Since they are determined, regulated, supervised and issued by a central authority such as a central bank and rest on the standing enjoyed by the government and institution in question, they are classified as fiat money (fiat currency). ↑
- Georgios Papadopoulos, “Money in the New Technological Pardigm” (Çevrimiçi) https://ssrn.com/ abstract=1586028, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019); Bitcoin, the best-known and first cryptocurrency, is also one of the favourite topics of the debates on the future of the monetary system. Satoshi Nakamoto, the developer of Bitcoin (a pseudonym used by the person, group or institution that developed Bitcoin), states in the famous paper in which he introduced Bitcoin that commerce on the internet relies for the most part on financial institutions serving as trusted third parties for the processing of electronic payments. In this sense, Bitcoin aims to take the place of these financial institutions. According to Nakamoto, what we need is an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust, in which two parties can transact directly with each other without the need for a trusted third person. See: Satoshi Nakamoto, “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System” (Çevrimiçi) https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- Melanie Swan, Blockchain: Blueprint for a New Economy, O'Reilly Media, California, 2015, s. 1. ↑
- For a long time cryptocurrency has been mentioned in the same breath as bitcoin, and the two concepts have been virtually identified with each other. However, the cryptocurrency named “Libra”, which was introduced on 18 June 2019 and whose founders include major companies such as Facebook, Visa, Paypal, Uber, Spotify and Mastercard, appears to be powerful enough to break this dominance of bitcoin and also to change the way the concept of cryptocurrency is viewed. See: Libra, White Paper, (Çevrimiçi) https://libra.org/en-US/white-paper/ (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019). This impact of Libra, which is to become operational in 2020, is already making itself felt in the field of law. In the face of this initiative by Facebook, the Financial Services Committee of the United States of America (USA) took the first step towards regulating the field by preparing a report on Libra and its effects on consumers, investors and the US financial system. United States House of Representatives Committee on Financial Services, “Examining Facebook’s Proposed Cryptocurrency and Its Impact on Consumers, Investors, and the American Financial System” (Çevrimiçi) https://financialservices.house.gov/uploadedfiles/hhrg-116-ba00-20190717- sd002_-_memo.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019). Similarly, the European Central Bank, too, is calling on legislators to regulate in the face of this impact of Libra. Angeline Benoit/James Regan, "Facebook's Cryptocurrency Plan Draws ECB Warning on Regulation", Bloomberg, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-07- 07/facebook-s-cryptocurrency-plan-draws-ecb-warning-on-regulation (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019). Although the developments in this area were still very recent at the time our study was carried out, this initiative by Facebook is a starting point for grasping the importance of the subject and is capable of triggering many future legal studies, reports and national and international regulations. ↑
- Robby Houben/Alexander Snyers, Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain: Legal context and implications for financial crime, money laundering and tax evasion, European Union, 2018, s. 31, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.europarl.europa.eu/cmsdata/150761/TAX3%20Study%20on%20cryptocurrencies%20and%20blockchain.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- Rosario Girasa, Regulation of Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain Technologies, Palgrave Studies in Financial Services Technology, Springer, Heidelberg, 2018, s. 7. ↑
- Nakamoto, s. 1. ↑
- Armağan Ebru Bozkurt Yüksel, “Elektronik Para, Sanal Para, Bitcoin ve Linden Doları’na Hukuki Bir Bakış”, İÜHFM, C. LXXIII, S. 2, 2015, s. 200-201. ↑
- Sermaye Piyasası Kurulu Araştırma Dairesi, Kripto-Para Bitcoin, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.spk.gov.tr/ SiteApps/Yayin/YayinGoster/1130, s. 16, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019); Erdal Durdu, Kripto Para Birimi Olarak Bitcoin ve Ceza Hukuku, Yayımlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi, Galatasaray Üniversitesi, 2018, s. 28. ↑
- Arvind Narayanan/Joseph Bonneau/Edward Felten/Andrew Miller/Steven Goldfeder, Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency Technologies: A Comprehensive Introduction, Princeton University Press, New Jersey, 2016, s. 139. ↑
- One of the main factors behind countries’ efforts to draw up legal regulations on cryptocurrencies is the developments in the use and technology of Bitcoin and other kinds of cryptocurrencies, which cannot be ignored. To this effect see Franziska Boehm/Paulina Pesch, “Bitcoin: A First Legal Analysis - with reference to German and US-American law”, in: Rainer Böhme/Michael Brenner/Tyler Moore/Matthew Smith (eds.), Financial Cryptography and Data Security: FC 2014 Workshops, BITCOIN and WAHC 2014, Christ Church, Barbados, March 7, 2014, Revised Selected Papers, Springer, Berlin-Heidelberg, 2014, s. 43. According to a large-scale study carried out in 2016, although the exact figures cannot be known, it is estimated that 5.8 million people actively hold cryptocurrency and that there are close to 35 million cryptocurrency wallets. Garrick Hileman/ Michel Rauchs, Global Cryptocurrency Benchmarking Study, Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance, Cambridge Judge Business School, University of Cambridge, 2017, s. 27, 52 (Çevrimiçi) https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/fileadmin/user_upload/research/centres/alternativefinance/downloads/ 2017-global-cryptocurrency-benchmarking-study.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- It can be said that even today decentralised technologies such as cryptocurrency, smart contracts and crypto-assets, and organisations capable of acting autonomously, play a major role in digital commerce and are shaping its future. By contrast, besides the fact that this field is still, so to speak, virgin territory from a legal point of view, it is seen that states are pursuing a strategy that virtually amounts to “turning a blind eye”. It is argued that, with the widespread use of the technologies in question, state institutions and large multinational companies will lose their control over commerce and their ability to steer it, and that this paradigm shift will, just like the Lex Mercatoria, lead the rules governing commerce to form their own customs and usages over time and the subjects to follow this law; in other words, that with regard to crypto technologies it will give rise to the field of law of "Lex Cryptographia". Aaron Wright/Primavera De Filippi, “Decentralized Blockchain Technology and The Rise Of Lex Cryptographia”, 2015, (Çevrimiçi) https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2580664, s. 48, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- For the full list of the countries in which cryptocurrencies are prohibited, together with its presentation on a world map and in a table, see: The Law Library of Congress, Regulation of Cryptocurrency Around the World (Çevrimiçi) https://www.loc.gov/law/help/cryptocurrency/cryptocurrency-world-survey.pdf, s. 4 (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- The Law Library of Congress, s. 5. ↑
- Durdu, s. 36. ↑
- Financial Action Task Force (FATF), Virtual Currencies: Key Definitions and Potential AML/ CFT Risks (Çevrimiçi) https://www.fatf-gafi.org/media/fatf/documents/reports/Virtual-currency-key-definitions-and-potential-aml-cft-risks.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- FATF, Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach to Virtual Currencies (Çevrimiçi) https://www.fatfgafi.org/ media/fatf/documents/reports/Guidance-RBA-Virtual-Currencies.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- FATF, Virtual Currencies: Key Definitions and Potential AML/CFT Risks, s. 4. ↑
- FATF, Virtual Currencies: Key Definitions and Potential AML/CFT Risks, s. 9. ↑
- FATF, Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach to Virtual Currencies, s. 6-12. ↑
- FATF, Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach to Virtual Currencies, s. 25-32. ↑
- FATF, Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach to Virtual Currencies, s. 15-22. ↑
- International Monetary Fund (IMF), Virtual Currencies and Beyond: Initial Considerations, (Çevrimiçi), https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/sdn/2016/sdn1603.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- IMF, s. 7. ↑
- IMF, s. 17. ↑
- IMF, s. 24. ↑
- IMF, s. 25. ↑
- IMF, s. 27-28. ↑
- IMF, s. 36. ↑
- European Banking Authority (EBA), Warning to Consumers on Virtual Currencies, (Çevrimiçi) https://eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/598344/EBA+Warning+on+Virtual+Currencies.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- EBA, EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, (Çevrimiçi) https://eba.europa.eu/documents/ 10180/ 657547/ EBA-Op-2014-08+Opinion+on+Virtual+Currencies.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- EBA, Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets, (Çevrimiçi) https://eba.euro-pa.eu/documents/10180/2545547/EBA+Report+on+crypto+assets.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- EBA, Warning to Consumers on Virtual Currencies, s. 2-3. ↑
- EBA, EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, s. 10-16. ↑
- EBA, EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, s. 16-21. ↑
- EBA, EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, s. 21-38. ↑
- EBA, EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, s. 38-45. ↑
- EBA, EBA Opinion on ‘Virtual Currencies’, s. 37-41. ↑
- EBA, Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets, s. 4. ↑
- EBA, Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets, s. 20-22. ↑
- EBA, Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets, s. 29. ↑
- EBA, Report with Advice for the European Commission on Crypto-Assets, s. 29-30. ↑
- Bankacılık Düzenleme ve Denetleme Kurulu (BDDK), Bitcoin Hakkında Basın Açıklaması (Çevrimiçi) https://www.bddk.org.tr/ContentBddk/dokuman/duyuru_0512_01.pdf (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- https://www.ntv.com.tr/ekonomi/hazineden-kripto-para-aciklamasi-bitcoin-icin-ilk-adim, vnVCCQyDWkywrV66EtH0fA?_ref=infinite (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- https://www.ntv.com.tr/teknoloji/spkdan-sanal-paralara-dayali-islemler-hakkindaaciklama, 4zk6GcRVf0O-pj4T_NQ-fA, (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- Sermaye Piyasası Kurulu (SPK), Haftalık Bülten, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.spk.gov.tr/Bulten/ Goster? year=2018&no=42 (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- The provisions on the legal persons authorised to issue electronic money are contained in Article 18 et seq. of the Law. Pursuant to Article 18 of the Law, these institutions may be established only as joint-stock companies; their capital, paid up in cash and free of any kind of collusion, must be at least five million Turkish liras; those holding ten per cent or more of their capital and those exercising control must possess the qualifications required of bank founders under Banking Law No. 5411; they must conduct their activities through the banks defined in Law No. 5411; and they must also fulfil the other conditions listed in the article. ↑
- Abbreviations and definitions Article 3 - (1) In the application of this Law, the following terms shall have the meanings set out below; o) Securities: With the exception of money, cheques, bills of exchange and promissory notes; 1) shares, other securities similar to shares and depositary receipts relating to such shares, 2) debt instruments or debt instruments based on securitised assets and revenues, and depositary receipts relating to such securities, u) Derivative instruments: The derivative instruments listed below or other derivative instruments determined by the Board to fall within this scope: 1) derivative instruments conferring the right to buy or sell securities or to exchange them for one another, 2) derivative instruments whose value depends on the price or yield of a security; on the price of a foreign currency or a change in that price; on an interest rate or a change in that rate; on the price of a precious metal or precious stone or a change in that price; on the price of a commodity or a change in that price; on statistics published by institutions deemed appropriate by the Board or a change in them; or on the level of an index which provides for the transfer of credit risk, has measurement values such as energy prices and climate variables and is composed of the foregoing, or on a change in that level; the derivatives of these instruments and derivatives conferring the right to exchange the listed underlying assets for one another, 3) leveraged transactions on foreign currencies and precious metals and on other assets to be determined by the Board. ↑
- Durdu, s. 53. ↑
- “Blockchain-based digital central bank money will be put into practice.”, see: Türkiye Cumhuriyeti Cumhurbaşkanlığı Strateji ve Bütçe Başkanlığı, On Birinci Kalkınma Planı (2019- 2023), (Çevrimiçi) http://www.sbb.gov.tr/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/OnbirinciKalkinmaPlani.pdf, Temmuz 2019, s. 42, (Erişim Tarihi: 20 Temmuz 2019). ↑
- Illegal activities account for a significant part of bitcoin transactions. In a study dated 2017, approximately one quarter of all users (26%) and close to half of bitcoin transactions (46%) are associated with illegal activities. According to the study, approximately 37 million transactions take place via bitcoin each year, and the value of the transactions amounts to 76 billion dollars. See Sean Foley/Jonathan R. Karlsen/Tālis J. Putniņš, “Sex, drugs, and bitcoin: How much illegal activity is financed through cryptocurrencies?”, The Review of Financial Studies, V. 32, I. 5, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2019, s. 1800. ↑
- Corinne Ramey, “The Crypto Crime Wave Is Here”, Wall Street Journal, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-crypto-crime-wave-is-here-1524753366, 26.04.2018 (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019); Thomas Simms, “At Least 95 Percent of Crypto Crimes Involve Bitcoin, Chainalysis Executive Says”, Yahoo, (Çevrimiçi) https://finance.yahoo.com/news/least-95-percentcrypto-crimes-112200840.html, 25.04.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019); Dante Disparte, “Crypto Crime Is Taking A Violent Turn”, Forbes, (Çevrimiçi) https://www.forbes.com/sites/dantedisparte/2019/01/28/crypto-crime-is-taking-a-violent-turn/#3556778d15a5, 28.01.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019); Chainalysis, Crypto Crime Report, (Çevrimiçi) https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5a9360f88433cb00018022c2/5c4f67ee7deb5948e2941fda_Chainalysis%20January% 202019%20Crypto%20Crime%20Report.pdf, Ocak 2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019). ↑
- Jen Wieczner, “Bitcoin Accounts for 95% of Cryptocurrency Crime, Says Analyst”, Fortune, (Çevrimiçi) http://fortune.com/2019/04/24/bitcoin-cryptocurrency-crime/, 25.04.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019); William Suberg, “EU: Malta Needs to Improve Readiness to Respond to Cryptocurrency Crime”, Cointelegraph, (Çevrimiçi) https://cointelegraph.com/news/eu-malta-needs-to-improvereadiness-to-respond-to-cryptocurrency-crime 05.06.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019); David J. White, “Cryptocurrency Crimes Are in a Class of Their Own”, Corporate Counsel Business Journal (CCBJ), (Çevrimiçi) https://ccbjournal.com/articles/cryptocurrency-crimes-are-in-a-class-of-their-own, 03.01.2019, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019); Yulia Rieth, “How Crypto Crimes Change Players' Security Approach”, DeCenter, (Çevrimiçi) https://decenter.org/en/how-crypto-crimes-change-playerssecurity-approach, 06.02.2018, (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019). ↑
- Simon Dyson/William J Buchanan/Liam Bell, “The Challenges of Investigating Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain Related Crime”, The Journal of The British Blockchain Association (The JBBA), Vol. 1, I. 2, s. 55-63. ↑
- The widely used present-day terms "white-collar crimes" and "white-collar criminality", too, are named not by reference to the type or subject matter of the offence committed but on the basis of the perpetrators of the offence. For there is no type of offence called white-collar crime; the offences meant by this expression are generally offences such as embezzlement, abuse of trust, fraudulent bankruptcy, bid rigging, rigging the performance of an obligation, market fraud (manipulation) and tax evasion. However, the term "white-collar criminality" was used for the first time in 1940 by the American criminologist Edwin H. Sutherland and was subsequently accepted and preferred by the great majority throughout the world. For the article see Edwin H. Sutherland, “White-Collar Criminality”, American Sociological Review, Vol. 5, No. 1, s. 1-12. We, too, have preferred the term "cryptocurrency crimes" for similar purposes; its long form, which would cover the subject fully, ought however to be "offences committed by means of cryptocurrencies". ↑
- Malcolm Campbell-Verduyn, “Bitcoin, Crypto-Coins, And Global Anti-Money Laundering Governance”, Crime Law and Social Change, V.69, I.2, Springer, 2018, s. 299-300; Alan Brill/ Lonnie Keene, “Cryptocurrencies: The Next Generation of Terrorist Financing?”, Defence Against Terrorism Review, Vol. 6, No. 1, Spring & Fall 2014, Centre of Excellence-Defence Against Terrorism, s. 21 (Çevrimiçi) https://ssrn.com/abstract=2814914 (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/apr/12/uk-man-jailed-guiding-mind-behind-silkroad-drugs-site-dark-web (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- FATF, Virtual Currencies: Key Definitions and Potential AML/CFT Risks, s. 11. ↑
- https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-36247289 (Erişim Tarihi: 25 Nisan 2019). ↑
- M. Emin Artuk/Ahmet Gökcen/M. Emin Alşahin/Kerim Çakır, Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 17. Bası, Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, 2018, s. 459; Durmuş Tezcan/Mustafa Ruhan Erdem/R. Murat Önok, Teorik ve Pratik Ceza Özel Hukuku, 16. Bası, Seçkin, Ankara, 2018, s. 682; Mahmut Koca/İlhan Üzülmez, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 5. Bası, Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, 2018, s. 557; Veli Özer Özbek/Koray Doğan/Pınar Bacaksız/İlker Tepe, Türk Ceza Hukuku Özel Hükümler, 13. Bası, Seçkin, Ankara, 2018 s. 610; Ali Kemal Yıldız, Hırsızlık Suçu, Özel Ceza Hukuku, c. IV, Malvarlığına Karşı Suçlar, On İki Levha Yayıncılık, İstanbul, 2018, s. 19. ↑
- Artuk/Gökcen/Alşahin/Çakır, (17), s. 460; Tezcan/Erdem/Önok, (16), s. 683-684; Koca/Üzülmez, (5), s. 558; Özbek/Doğan/Bacaksız/Tepe, (13), s. 610; Yıldız, s. 20. ↑
- Aggravated Theft Article 142 - (2) Where the offence is committed; e) through the use of information systems, a sentence of imprisonment for a term of five to ten years shall be imposed. ↑
- Murat Volkan Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, 7. Bası, Seçkin, Ankara, 2018, s. 461. ↑
- Yargıtay Ceza Genel Kurulu (YCGK), E. 2009/11–193 K. 2009/268, T. 17.11.2009. ↑
- Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, s. 468. ↑
- A similar debate concerning the offence of theft had also taken place in the period of the repealed TCK No. 765. The legal issue centred on whether the “natural forces” regarded as movable property under the Civil Code, namely electrical energy and the telephone line, could form the subject matter of the offence of theft even though they have no corporeal existence. The Court of Cassation regarded the illicit use of electrical energy as falling within the offence of theft (for the decision see YCGK, 1976/6–433 E., 1976/444 K., T. 25.10.1976.). With regard to the telephone line, it first ruled that there was theft (YCGK, 1988/6–175 E., 1988/206 K., T. 27.06.1988.) but subsequently departed from this case law before even a year had passed (YCGK, 1988/6–443 E., 1989/2 K., T. 30.01.1989.). These acts of illicit use, which also became the subject of a decision on the unification of case law, were for their part regarded by the Grand General Assembly of the Court of Cassation for the Unification of Case Law as falling within the offence of theft (Yargıtay İçtihadı Birleştirme Büyük Genel Kurulu, 1989/2 E., 1990/2 K., T. 06.04.1990.). All these debates came to an end in 1991 with the introduction into the offence of theft of an additional paragraph worded “Any kind of energy having an economic value shall also be deemed movable property.” In the TCK No. 5237, the use of a telephone line, electrical energy, water and natural gas has been made a separate offence type by the provision on “Obtaining Benefits without Payment” (Art. 163 TCK). The experience gained from this issue has also been taken into account in our study. It must not be forgotten, however, that crypto and book money have characteristics different from natural forces such as electrical energy and from the telephone frequency. Above all, the raison d’être and purpose (Fr. finalité) of the money in question is, unlike electrical energy, to represent economic values, to facilitate the exchange of goods and services between persons and to serve as a carrier. It must therefore be assessed differently from electrical energy, and the nature of this money must also be taken into consideration. ↑
- Koca/Üzülmez, (5), s. 559, 879. ↑
- Özbek/Doğan/Bacaksız/Tepe, (13), s. 993; Tezcan/Erdem/Önok, (16), s. 711. According to yet another view, money deposited in a bank deposit account has the character of a “claim” in favour of the right holder. In this respect, since a claim cannot be regarded as falling within the act of theft and, as in the YCGK decision assessed above, no operation on data is involved either, one is faced with a legislative gap in this matter. For this view see İsa Başbüyük, “İnternet Bankacılığı Aracılığıyla Gerçekleştirilen Hukuka Aykırı Havalenin Bilişim Suçları Açısından Değerlendirilmesi”, Ceza Hukuku Dergisi, Yıl: 8, Sayı: 21, 2013, s. 197-214. ↑
- Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, s. 469. ↑
- Avrupa Birliği Adalet Divanı (ABAD), Skatteverket/Hedqvist, C-264/14, T. 22.10.2015, para. 52, 58. ↑
- “In conclusion; although the sending elsewhere without permission, or the taking from the place where it is located, of a datum, information or program held in an information system does not constitute the offence of theft, the sending of money elsewhere by removing in this way the possessor’s power of disposal over money belonging to another must be assessed as falling within the offence of theft. At this point there is no breach of the principle of legality of offences and penalties, nor can it be said that the prohibition of analogy has been violated.”. To the same effect see: Ersan Şen, “Bitcoin Çalınır mı?”, Haber7, (Çevrimiçi) http://www.haber7.com/yazarlar/ prof-dr-ersan-sen/1948163-bitcoin-calinir-mi (Erişim Tarihi: 10 Haziran 2019). ↑
- Aggravated Fraud Article 158 - (1) Where the offence of fraud is committed; f) by using information systems (…) as a means, a sentence of imprisonment for a term of five to ten years shall be imposed. A sentence of imprisonment for a term of three to ten years and a judicial fine of up to five thousand days shall be imposed. However, in the cases listed in sub-paragraphs (e), (f), (j), (k) and (l), the lower limit of the term of imprisonment may not be less than four years and the amount of the judicial fine may not be less than twice the benefit obtained from the offence. ↑
- Dülger, Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku, s. 476. ↑
- Murat Volkan Dülger, Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar, Seçkin, Ankara, 2011, s. 527-546. ↑
- Dülger, Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar, s. 443-455. ↑
- Dülger, Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar, s. 70. ↑
- Dülger, Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasına İlişkin Suçlar ve Yaptırımlar, s. 72-79. ↑
- Malcolm Campbell-Verduyn/Marcel Goguen, “The Mutual Constitution of Technology and Global Governance: Bitcoin, Blockchains, and the International Anti-money-laundering Regime”, in: Malcolm Campbell-Verduyn (ed.), Bitcoin and Beyond: Cryptocurrencies, Blockchains, and Global Governance, RIPE Series in Global Political Economy, Routledge, Oxford-New York, 2018, s. 74; Durdu, s. 189. ↑
- Campbell-Verduyn/Goguen, s. 80; Durdu, s. 189. ↑
- Durdu, s. 190. ↑
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Use of Crypto Assets in the Laundering of Proceeds of Crime and the Measures to Be Taken” (Kripto Varlıkların Suç Gelirlerinin Aklanmasında Kullanılması ve Alınması Gereken Önlemler), Istanbul Aydın University Faculty of Law Journal (İstanbul Aydın Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi), Vol. 10, No. 1, 2024, pp. 41-94.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Legal Regime of Social Network Providers, Internet News Sites and Over-the-Top Service Providers, and a Critique” (Sosyal Ağ Sağlayıcıların İnternet Haber Sitelerinin ve Şebekeler Üstü Hizmet Sağlayıcıların Hukuki Rejimi ve Eleştirisi), Dülger Law Office, 1 June 2023.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “The Electronic Document as the Object of Document Forgery Offences” (Belgede Sahtecilik Suçlarının Konusu Olarak Elektronik Belge), Symposium on Forgery of Documents and Tax Offences (Belgede Sahtecilik ve Vergi Suçları Sempozyumu), 21–24 October 2019, Publication of the Presidency of the Court of Cassation / TOBB ETÜ Faculty of Law, Ankara, 2020.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “What Does WhatsApp's Privacy Change Mean? Will Our Data Be Shared?” (WhatsApp Güvenlik Değişikliği Ne Anlama Geliyor? Verilerimiz Paylaşılacak mı?), Dülger Law Office, 5 January 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Commercial Electronic Messages and the Message Management System” (Ticari Elektronik İleti ve İleti Yönetim Sistemi), Dülger Law Office, 15 November 2020.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, Cybercrime and Internet Communication Law (Bilişim Suçları ve İnternet İletişim Hukuku), 11th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2025.

