Introduction
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
One of the developments in the field of personal data protection that all stakeholders had been awaiting with interest for some time took place on 28 October 2017: the “Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data”, issued by the Personal Data Protection Authority on the basis of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK), was published in Official Gazette No. 30224 of 28 October 2017. I should say straight away that, under Article 14 of the Regulation, its date of entry into force was set as 1 January 2018. Indeed, 1 January 2018 was also set as the date of entry into force in the other regulations still in draft form. This date has therefore been fixed as something of a starting date for personal data protection law. Article 3(1)(b) of the KVKK defines the concept of “anonymisation”, and Article 7 governs “the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data”.
Paragraph 3 of Article 7 states that the procedures and principles for the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data are to be laid down by regulation. In addition, Article 22(1)(e) of the Law provides that the Board has the duty and power to adopt the necessary regulatory acts on matters relating to its own remit and to the functioning of the Authority. The regulation in question was drawn up and published pursuant to this provision. Below, under separate headings, I will address the new rules and concepts introduced by the Regulation and the points that need explanation, without going into theoretical detail.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger•
One of the developments in the field of personal data protection that all stakeholders had been awaiting with interest for some time took place on 28 October 2017, when the “Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data”, issued by the Personal Data Protection Authority on the basis of Law No. 6698, was published in Official Gazette No. 30224 of 28.10.2017. I should say at once that, under Article 14 of the Regulation, the date of entry into force has been set at 1 January 2018. Indeed, 1 January 2018 has also been set as the date of entry into force in the other regulations that are still in draft form. This date has thus been fixed as, so to speak, a starting date for personal data protection (KVK) law.
Sub-paragraph (b) of paragraph 1 of Article 3 of Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK) defines the concept of “anonymisation”, and Article 7 governs the “erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data”. Paragraph 3 of Article 7 states that the procedures and principles for the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data are to be laid down by regulation. In addition, sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 22 of the Law provides that the Board has the duty and power to adopt the necessary regulatory acts on matters relating to its own field of competence and to the functioning of the Authority. It is pursuant to this provision that the regulation in question has been drawn up and published.
Below, under separate headings and without going into theoretical detail, I shall touch upon the new rules and concepts introduced by the Regulation and the points that call for explanation.
Personal data inventory
The first provision of the Regulation to attract attention is the definition of the personal data processing inventory in sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 4, headed “Definitions”. Accordingly, the personal data inventory is defined as “the inventory which controllers create by associating the personal data processing activities they carry out in connection with their business processes with the purposes of processing personal data, the data category, the recipient group to which data are transferred and the group of data subjects, and which they detail by setting out the maximum period necessary for the purposes for which the personal data are processed, the personal data envisaged to be transferred to foreign countries and the measures taken with regard to data security”.
This is one of the matters on which we too place the greatest emphasis, both in the training we provide and in the compliance projects we have carried out, and it also constitutes the first phase of compliance projects. Thus, by this article of the Regulation, the minimum requirements to be met by the personal data
• Member of the Faculty of Law of Istanbul Medipol University (Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Law and IT Law), Attorney-at-Law. inventory have been determined and, at the same time, the existence of this inventory has been made mandatory, as follows from the Regulation read as a whole.
Under the Regulation, the minimum items that must be included in the personal data inventory are the following:
• the purpose of processing personal data,
• the data category,
• the recipient group to which data are transferred,
• the maximum period for which the personal data will be kept,
• the personal data envisaged to be transferred to foreign countries,
• the measures taken with regard to data security.
While these sub-headings form the main headings of a compliance project, I must say that it is possible and necessary to have further breakdowns that set them out in detail. In this way the minimum standards for creating a personal data inventory, which is the indispensable component and first step of the process of compliance with personal data protection, have been determined. That this is mandatory is apparent from Article 5 of the Regulation, to which we shall turn below.
Recipient group
The term recipient group is defined in sub-paragraph (a) of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Regulation, headed “Definitions”. Accordingly, the recipient group is described as “the category of natural or legal persons to which personal data are transferred by the controller”. This definition, too, is a new concept created by the Regulation. Under the Regulation, the recipient group must also be indicated when the personal data inventory is created. There will therefore be not one but several recipient groups. Identifying the recipient group correctly is one of the most important steps in creating the inventory correctly. For example, where the recipient group is a particular State institution and there is an exception arising from statute, the period and manner of erasure, destruction or anonymisation will be determined according to that statute. The data in question must also be shown accordingly in the inventory, by reference to this recipient group.
Relevant user
The Regulation defines the concept of “relevant user”. Accordingly, relevant users are defined as “the persons who process personal data within the organisation of the controller or in accordance with the authority and instructions received from the controller, with the exception of the person or unit responsible for the technical storage, protection and backup of the data”. The first point to be made is that, whereas the data subject is the natural person whose data are processed, the relevant user is the person who processes the personal data in question on behalf of the controller.
Certain points in this definition deserve attention. First, the controller and the relevant user are different from each other. For the relevant user is not the person who determines the purposes and means of processing personal data and who is responsible for establishing and managing the data filing system. As the Regulation expressly states, relevant users are persons who process personal data either as part of the controller's organisation (for example, an employee of the company) or on the basis of the authority and instructions received from the controller (for example, third parties providing services in this field, such as consultancy firms).
Furthermore, relevant users are persons other than the “information technology / IT” unit, which in companies or institutions generally provides the infrastructure services for the storage, transfer and protection of all kinds of digital data, and other than the staff of that unit. This finding of the Regulation is extremely apt and corresponds to the realities of practice. An important point which we too have observed in awareness training and in the compliance processes we conduct is the mistaken perception that the IT unit is responsible for all kinds of data, including personal data. Yet, as is very well expressed in the Regulation, the IT unit is responsible only for storing, protecting, backing up and transmitting the data and for keeping them in a state fit for processing. Those who record and process personal data, on the other hand, are – if we are speaking of a company – the other business units such as marketing, purchasing and human resources. With this definition introduced by the Regulation, it has been made clear that the “relevant user” means these business units.
Personal data storage and destruction policy
Article 5 of the Regulation lays down the principles governing the personal data storage and destruction policy. Accordingly, controllers who are obliged to register with the Data Controllers' Registry1 are required to draw up a personal data storage and destruction policy in conformity with the personal data processing inventory they have created. As I stated above, this article in fact imposes on controllers the obligation to create a personal data inventory. For in order to fulfil the obligation to draw up a personal data storage and destruction policy, which is likewise imposed on controllers as an obligation and forms the subject of this article, the personal data processing inventory must first be created. Under the Regulation, the personal data storage and destruction policy must be consistent with the personal data inventory.
Making this inventory and drawing up the personal data storage and destruction policy does not mean that the operations in question are carried out in practice. Policies and practice must run in parallel. Indeed, this point is stated in paragraph 2 of Article 5.
The matters to be covered by the personal data storage and destruction policy are, for their part, laid down in Article 6 of the Regulation. Accordingly, the storage and destruction policy must, as a minimum, contain information on:
• the purpose for which the personal data storage and destruction policy has been prepared,
• the recording media governed by the personal data storage and destruction policy,
• the definitions of the legal and technical terms used in the personal data storage and destruction policy,
• the definitions of the legal and technical terms requiring the storage and destruction of personal data,
• an explanation of the legal, technical and other reasons requiring the storage and destruction of personal data,
• the technical and administrative measures taken to store personal data securely and to prevent their unlawful processing and unlawful access to them,
• the technical and administrative measures taken to destroy personal data lawfully,
• the titles, units and job descriptions of those involved in the personal data storage and destruction processes,
• the table showing the storage and destruction periods,
• the periodic destruction intervals,
• where the existing personal data storage and destruction policy has been updated, the change in question.
In order to ensure compliance with the Law and the Regulation and for the controller to be able to discharge its responsibility under the Law, the policy in question must be drawn up at least to the standards indicated and must be put into practice. This is a matter that requires transformation and can be achieved only through a KVKK compliance process.
Recording of erasure, destruction and anonymisation and
retention of these records
Paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the Regulation states that all operations carried out in connection with the erasure, destruction and anonymisation of personal data are to be recorded and that these records are to be kept for at least three years. It is also stated that, where there are periods arising from other legal obligations, these too must be taken into account. Accordingly, erasing, destroying and anonymising personal data is not sufficient for compliance with the personal data protection (KVK) legislation. These operations must be recorded (a printed or digital record must be drawn up for this purpose) and these records must be kept for at least three years.
Method of erasure, destruction and anonymisation
Personal data may be held on printed media as well as on digital media. For both types of media, the methods for the operations to be carried out must be determined, and the methods so determined must be set out both in the personal data storage and destruction policy and in the policies in which the methods are determined. This, again, is a task that falls to the controller. This is laid down in paragraph 4 of Article 7 of the Regulation. For example, simply throwing a printed document containing personal data into the waste bin is not sufficient for destruction. Depending on the circumstances, the document must be burnt or, as is more common in practice, passed through a paper shredder in order to be destroyed. Similarly, moving an item of data to the recycle bin on a computer does not amount to erasure. It means that the item of data in question has been deleted from the index (active directory). The data in fact remain where they were on the disk. To erase them in the true sense, the data must be removed from the hard disk completely. For this, the main memory must be formatted. Even then, however, it is possible to recover the data with data recovery software. To be able to speak of the destruction of the data, therefore, other techniques must be used – for example, destroying the magnetic property of the disk by the “degauss” method so that the data are wiped. The final stage here is shredding the device holding the data in order to destroy it physically. Thus the controller must state clearly in its relevant procedures, in the light of the nature of the data for which it is responsible and of the policies and needs determined in this regard, which types of data it will subject to what kind of operation and what it aims to achieve at the end of that operation.
In this context, unless the Board decides otherwise, the controller has the right to determine which of the methods of ex officio erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data is appropriate. Where personal data are erased, destroyed or anonymised at the request of the data subject, the controller again has the right to determine the method, but is obliged to explain the reasons for its choice.
Erasure, destruction and anonymisation of personal data
Article 8 of the Regulation governs the erasure of personal data, Article 9 their destruction and Article 10 their anonymisation.
According to Article 8 of the Regulation: “(1) Erasure of personal data is the operation of rendering personal data inaccessible and non-reusable in any way for the relevant users. (2) The controller is obliged to take all necessary technical and administrative measures to ensure that the erased personal data are inaccessible and non-reusable for the relevant users”.
In the Regulation's definition, rightly, what has been defined is what the end result must be, without specifying what technique is to be used for the erasure operation. Rendering the personal data inaccessible and non-reusable in any way for the relevant user is the operation of erasing the data. In this method, therefore, it is not required that recovery of the personal data be impossible. What matters is that those who appear in the personal data inventory as users of the data can no longer access and use them. It is, however, possible for a third party other than the data user (for example, judicial police officers engaged in a criminal investigation) to recover these data and thereby access and use them.
Determining the method for this is the controller's task; indeed, paragraph 2 of the article states that taking all technical and administrative measures in this regard is the controller's obligation.
According to Article 9 of the Regulation: “(1) Destruction of personal data is the operation of rendering personal data inaccessible, irretrievable and non-reusable by anyone in any way. (2) The controller is obliged to take all necessary technical and administrative measures relating to the destruction of personal data”.
Definition without specifying a technique has been used for the destruction operation as well. Destruction, unlike erasure, is the rendering of personal data inaccessible, irretrievable and non-reusable by anyone in any way. For the destruction of personal data , therefore, a method must be applied by which the data cannot be accessed even with digital forensics and data recovery software. For this, it is possible to apply methods or hardware such as the degaussing I mentioned above. As a result of this operation, not only the user of the data but no one at all should be able to reach the data. Determining the method for this again falls to the controller.
According to Article 10 of the Regulation: “(1) Anonymisation of personal data is the rendering of personal data incapable of being associated in any way with an identified or identifiable natural person, even if they are matched with other data. (2) For personal data to have been anonymised, the personal data must be rendered incapable of being associated with an identified or identifiable natural person even through the use, by the controller, the recipient or recipient groups, of techniques appropriate to the recording medium and the relevant field of activity, such as reversal and the matching of the data with other data. (3) The controller is obliged to take all necessary technical and administrative measures relating to the anonymisation of personal data”.
In the Law, personal data had been defined as any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person. Accordingly, anonymisation will be at issue where the possibility that the information identifies a natural person or renders that person identifiable is eliminated. It is on this basis that Article 10 of the Regulation, adhering to the Law, governs anonymisation. Anonymisation must be carried out by such a method that, even if the personal data are matched with other data and a link is established between them, they do not in any way render identifiable the natural person to whom they belong. In this context, masking the personal data is not enough. For with masking it is possible to reach the owner of the data if they are matched with other data. Similarly, anonymisation must be carried out in such a way that even the person who carried it out cannot subsequently go back and identify the data owner. At the end of the anonymisation operation, there must be no possibility of matching the data with natural persons by using methods and techniques such as social engineering, digital forensic applications and the like. For this operation too, the task of choosing the method and the administrative measures to be used has been left to the controller.
I must say that, for the erasure, destruction and anonymisation of personal data, controllers need to obtain support both from lawyers specialising in this field and from IT security experts. For the needs and risks in both the legal and the IT security spheres can be fully identified and addressed only with the support of these persons. In particular, the fact that the field of personal data protection is quite new for our country turns this need into a necessity.
Periods for ex officio erasure, destruction and anonymisation
The first concept we encounter under this heading is the “periodic destruction operation”. From the moment the controller begins to record and process data, matters requiring the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data, for the reasons specified in the Law or in the data processing policy, will arise continuously in parallel with these processes. However, carrying out the erasure, destruction or anonymisation of data continuously on the one hand, while operations such as the recording, processing and transfer of data are being carried out on the other, would require considerable time and effort. Taking this situation into account, the Authority has provided for this to be tied to a periodic process and has required this of controllers.
Accordingly, the interval at which periodic destruction is to be carried out must be specified in the personal data storage and destruction policy. This period may not exceed six months. The operation of erasure, destruction or anonymisation must be carried out at the first periodic destruction operation following the date on which the obligation arose. For example, where a company sets these dates as 1 January and 1 July, every operation relating to an obligation to destroy arising in the period from 1 January to 30 June will be carried out on 1 July and this will be recorded.
For a controller that is not obliged to prepare a personal data storage and destruction policy (these being the group that constitutes the exception to the obligation to register with the Registry), this period is three months from the moment the obligation to destroy arises. Controllers of this kind therefore need to set themselves three-monthly intervals.
Periods for erasure and destruction on request
In addition to ex officio erasure, destruction and anonymisation, Article 12 of the Regulation also lays down the periods for erasure and destruction at the request of the data subject. Accordingly, where all the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist, the controller shall erase, destroy or anonymise the personal data that are the subject of the request. The request shall be complied with within thirty days at the latest and the data subject shall be informed. Since the Regulation makes no distinction in this respect, I take the view that a total of thirty days is allowed for complying with the request and for giving notice of it.
Where the personal data have been transferred to third parties, the controller shall forward the request to those third parties and shall ensure that the request so made is complied with by the third party. Since no other time limit is specified, the thirty-day period applies even if the data are held by the third party.
Where, on the other hand, not all the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist, the request may be refused, and the data subject shall be notified of this together with the reasons. The notification may be made in writing and by electronic means. In my view, a notification made by electronic mail should be regarded as sufficient. This notification, too, must be made within thirty days.
Removal of doubts
It is entirely natural that various doubts and uncertainties should arise in the interpretation and application of the field of personal data protection, which is new for our country, and of the legislation enacted specifically for this field. It has been stated that, where doubts of this kind arise, the power to remove them also lies with the Board. Accordingly, the Board will also guide practice both through the decisions it will give and, where necessary, through the resolutions of principle or communiqués it will adopt specifically on this subject.
Although this article of the Regulation seeks to keep this power with the Board, in my view this is merely the expression of an intention. For, just as is the case at present, the legislation and practice on the protection of personal data may be interpreted and criticised in legal scholarship, and it is likewise an inescapable fact that both the legislation and the decisions to be given by the Board will be subject to judicial review. Accordingly, the decisions to be given by the judicial authorities in particular will also provide guidance in this field. As far as I know, an action for annulment concerning the Law on the Protection of Personal Data is currently pending before the Constitutional Court, awaiting decision. The decision the Court will give on this matter, whether it dismisses the action or annuls the Law, is extremely important for the clarification of the subject.
Main points in lieu of a conclusion
The main points which I have arrived at as a result of examining the Regulation and which I think should be taken into account are the following:
• The “Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data” was published in Official Gazette No. 30224 of 28.10.2017.
• Under Article 14 of the Regulation, the date of entry into force was set as 1 January 2018.
• The first provision of the Regulation to attract attention is the definition of the personal data processing inventory in sub-paragraph (e) of paragraph 1 of Article 4, headed “Definitions”.
• This article of the Regulation not only determines the minimum requirements that the personal data inventory must contain; the existence of such an inventory has also been made mandatory, as follows from the meaning of the Regulation as a whole.
• Under the Regulation, the minimum items that must be included in the personal data inventory are the following: the purpose of processing personal data, the data category, the recipient group to which data are transferred, the maximum period for which the personal data will be kept, the personal data envisaged to be transferred to foreign countries, and the measures taken with regard to data security.
• The recipient group is defined in sub-paragraph (a) of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of the Regulation, headed “Definitions”.
• Identifying the recipient group correctly is one of the most important steps in creating the inventory correctly.
• The Regulation defines the concept of “relevant user”. Relevant users are persons who process personal data either as part of the controller's organisation (for example, an employee of the company) or on the basis of the authority and instructions received from the controller (for example, third parties providing services in this field, such as consultancy firms).
• Relevant users are persons other than the “information technology / IT” unit, which in companies or institutions generally provides the infrastructure services for the storage, transfer and protection of all kinds of digital data, and other than the staff of that unit.
• Controllers who are obliged to register with the Data Controllers' Registry must draw up a personal data storage and destruction policy in conformity with the personal data processing inventory they have created.
• Making the personal data inventory and drawing up the personal data storage and destruction policy does not mean that the operations in question are carried out in practice. Policies and practice must run in parallel. Indeed, this point is stated in paragraph 2 of Article 5.
• The matters which the personal data storage and destruction policy is to cover are laid down in Article 6 of the Regulation.
• In order to ensure compliance with the Law and the Regulation, and for the controller to be able to discharge its responsibility under the Law, the policy in question must be drawn up at least to the standards indicated and must be put into practice. This is a matter that requires transformation and can be achieved only through a KVKK compliance process.
• Paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the Regulation states that all operations carried out in connection with the erasure, destruction and anonymisation of personal data are to be recorded and that these records are to be kept for at least three years.
• The controller must state clearly in its relevant procedures, in line with the nature of the data for which it is responsible and with the policies and needs determined in this respect, which types of data it will subject to what kind of operation and what it aims to be the outcome of that operation.
• Unless the Board decides otherwise, the controller has the right to determine which of the methods of ex officio erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data is appropriate.
• Where personal data are erased, destroyed or anonymised at the request of the data subject, the controller again has the right to determine the method, but is obliged to explain the reasons for its choice.
• Article 8 of the Regulation governs the erasure of personal data, Article 9 their destruction and Article 10 their anonymisation.
• The Regulation's definition, rightly, does not specify what kind of technique is to be used for the erasure operation but defines what the end result must be.
• Rendering the personal data inaccessible and non-reusable in any way for the relevant user is the operation of erasing the data.
• This method does not require that recovery of the personal data be impossible. What matters is that those who appear in the personal data inventory as users of the data can no longer access or use those data.
• A definition that does not specify the technique has also been used for the destruction operation.
• Destruction, unlike erasure, is the rendering of personal data inaccessible, irretrievable and non-reusable by anyone in any way.
• Anonymisation must be carried out by such a method that, even if the personal data are matched with other data and a link is established between them, they do not in any way render identifiable the natural person to whom they belong. In this context, masking the personal data is not sufficient.
• The interval at which periodic destruction will be carried out must be determined in the personal data storage and destruction policy. This period may not exceed six months.
• The erasure, destruction or anonymisation operation must be carried out in the first periodic destruction operation following the date on which the obligation arose.
• For a controller that is not obliged to prepare a personal data storage and destruction policy (these being the group that constitutes the exception to the obligation to register with the Registry), this period is three months from the moment the obligation to destroy arises.
• Controllers of this kind therefore need to set themselves three-monthly intervals.
• Where all the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist, the controller shall erase, destroy or anonymise the personal data that are the subject of the request.
• The request shall be complied with within thirty days at the latest and the data subject shall be informed.
• Where the personal data have been transferred to third parties, the controller shall forward the request to those third parties and shall ensure that the request so made is complied with by the third party.
• Since no other time limit is specified, the thirty-day period applies even if the data are held by the third party.
• Where, on the other hand, not all the conditions for processing personal data have ceased to exist, the request may be refused, and the data subject shall be notified of this together with the reasons.
• The notification may be made in writing and by electronic means. In my view, a notification made by electronic mail should be regarded as sufficient. This notification, too, must be made within thirty days.
Footnotes
- Articles 16 and 17, contained in Chapter Four, headed “Exceptions to the Registration Obligation”, of the draft Regulation on the Data Controllers' Registry, which has been sent by the Authority to the Prime Ministry for publication, determine the controllers who are not obliged to register. Accordingly: Cases in which the exception applies ARTICLE 16 – (1) With regard to the personal data processing activities specified below, the controller is under no obligation to enter these activities in the Registry and to notify them. a) The processing of personal data being necessary for the prevention of the commission of offences or for a criminal investigation. b) The processing of personal data made public by the data subject himself. c) The processing of personal data being necessary, on the basis of the power conferred by law, for the performance of supervisory or regulatory duties and for disciplinary investigation or prosecution by the competent and authorised public institutions and organisations and by professional organisations having the status of public institutions. ç) The processing of personal data being necessary for the protection of the economic and financial interests of the State in relation to budgetary, tax and financial matters. Exception criteria determined by the Board ARTICLE 17- (1) The Board may introduce exceptions to the registration obligation, taking the following criteria into consideration: a) The nature of the personal data, b) The number of the personal data, c) The purpose for which the personal data are processed, ç) The field of activity in which the personal data are processed, d) Whether the personal data are transferred to third parties, e) The personal data processing activity arising from laws, f) The period for which the personal data are retained, g) The group of data subjects or the data categories. ↑
- The Board has the power to adopt decisions in order to determine the scope of the exceptions determined within the framework of the criteria listed in the first paragraph, the principles governing their application, the methods of calculation and the procedure. The Board shall make these decisions known to the public by publishing them by appropriate means.
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Right to Be Forgotten” (Unutulma Hakkı), Essays in Honour of Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli (Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli’ye Armağan), Savaş Publishing, Ankara, 2024, pp. 1019–1141.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Assessment of the Amendments to the KVK Law on the Processing of Special Categories of Personal Data and the Transfer of Data Abroad” (KVK Kanunu’nda Özel Nitelikli Kişisel Verilerin İşlenmesi ve Yurt Dışına Veri Aktarımı Kapsamında Yapılan Değişikliklere İlişkin Değerlendirmeler), Academia.edu, 25 March 2024.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Our Assessment of the Decision Summaries Published by the Personal Data Protection Board on 18 July 2022” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulunun 18 Temmuz 2022 Tarihinde Yayınlanan Karar Özetlerine İlişkin Değerlendirmelerimiz), Dülger Law Office, 1 September 2022.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Use of Personal Health Data as Evidence in Divorce Proceedings” (Kişisel Sağlık Verilerinin Boşanma Davasında Delil Olarak Kullanılması), Hukuk ve Daha Fazlası Dergisi (Law and More), No. 9, June 2022, pp. 76–84.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “A Very Important Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board on Lawyers' Access to Enforcement Files Without a Power of Attorney” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulu’ndan Avukatların İcra Takip Dosyalarına Vekaletname Olmaksızın Erişebilmesine İlişkin Çok Önemli Bir Karar), Dülger Law Office, 15 August 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, Personal Data Protection Law (Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku), 4th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2026.

