19 August 2018Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

Following the unanimous decision that four of the decisions rendered by the Personal Data Protection Board on the subject be published on the Authority’s website and in the Official Gazette, those decisions were published in the Official Gazette of 18 August 2018, No. 30513. In this study I will assess the decisions in question, also taking into account the legislative provisions previously made on the Data Controllers’ Registry.

On the basis of this assessment, I will make suggestions as to what data controllers running projects for compliance with the Law should pay attention to at the stages of the obligation to register with the Registry. In this way I will try to ensure that the “obligation to register with VERBİS”, a matter on which there are serious uncertainties and open questions for data controllers, is understood at least to some extent in light of the decisions rendered.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

Article 16 of the Law on the Protection of Personal Data regulates the Data Controllers’ Registry, known for short as “VERBİS”, which is to be kept publicly accessible by the Presidency under the supervision of the Personal Data Protection Board. Paragraph 2 of the same article of the Law provides that natural and legal persons who process personal data must register with the Data Controllers’ Registry before they begin to process data, but that the Board may provide for exceptions to this requirement; paragraph 3 sets out the particulars which the application for registration with the Data Controllers’ Registry must contain. If these particulars change, the changes must be notified to the Presidency without delay pursuant to paragraph 4 of the article. Lastly, by paragraph 5 of the same article the Law provides that the other procedures and principles concerning the Data Controllers’ Registry are to be laid down by regulation.

The “Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry”, which contains comprehensive provisions on the Data Controllers’ Registry envisaged in the Law on the Protection of Personal Data, was published in the Official Gazette of 30 December 2017, No. 30286, and entered into force on 1 January 20181. Article 16(2) of the Regulation stated that the Board has the power to adopt decisions in order to determine the scope of the exceptions established within the framework of the criteria listed in the first paragraph and the procedures and principles for their application, and that it is to publish its decisions by appropriate means and announce them to the public. The Board’s decision of 2.4.2018, No. 2018/32, on the exceptions to the obligation to register with the Registry, which it rendered on the basis of this power, was likewise published in the Official Gazette of 15 May 2018, No. 304222.

Although the legal rules on the Data Controllers’ Registry have thus made progress, I observe that expectations and doubts on the matter persist in all sectors that have to plan for the protection of personal data and among all those concerned with the subject. When the obligation to register with the Registry will begin, within what periods registration must take place, and whether all controllers, large or small, are required to register are the points on which the question marks are most concentrated. All these questions will undoubtedly be answered, and the doubts removed, through the steps to be taken by the Board.

It was precisely for this purpose that, following the unanimous decision to publish four of the Board’s decisions on the matter on the Authority’s website and in the Official Gazette, the decisions in question were published in the Official Gazette of 18 August 2018, No. 30513. In this study I shall assess those decisions, taking into account also the legislative arrangements previously made concerning the Data Controllers’ Registry. On the basis of this assessment I shall make recommendations as to what controllers conducting projects for compliance with the Law should pay attention to at the stages of the obligation to register with the Registry. In this way I shall try to ensure that the subject of the “obligation to register with VERBİS”, on which there are serious uncertainties and question marks for controllers, is understood at least to some extent in the light of the decisions rendered.

The Official Gazette of 18 August 2018: The Personal Data Protection Board’s

Published Decisions

Three of the Board’s decisions, which will be examined in detail below, concern the exceptions to the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry. Before turning to these decisions, it is necessary to state by which criteria the Board is bound in respect of all the exception decisions it will render and on what basis it will determine these exceptions. According to Article 16 of the Regulation, headed “Exception criteria”, the Board is to take the following matters into account when providing for an exception to the registration obligation:

• The nature of the personal data,

• The quantity of the personal data,

• The purpose for which the personal data are processed,

• The field of activity in which the personal data are processed,

• Whether the personal data are transferred to third parties,

• Whether the personal data processing activity arises from laws,

• The period for which the personal data are retained,

• The group of data subjects or the categories of data.

Accordingly, the Board may render an exception decision only within the framework of the criteria set out above. In determining the scope of the exceptions and the procedures and principles for their application, it must rely on one or more of these criteria. An exception decision rendered without any of these criteria being present will therefore be unlawful.

The last of the decisions to be assessed concerns the dates on which the obligation to register with the Registry begins. Important points such as when controllers may begin to apply for registration and by what time limits they are bound have thus been determined in concrete terms.

In order to appreciate the importance of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry, the sanctions provided for in the Law must also be mentioned. Article 18 of the Law, headed ‘Misdemeanours’, provides that an administrative fine of 20,000 to 1,000,000 Turkish liras is to be imposed on those who act contrary to the obligation to register with and notify the Data Controllers’ Registry. As can be seen, this amount is quite high, and care must be taken in this regard.

1. Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board of 28/06/2018, No. 2018/68, concerning the "Request for an Opinion on the Exception of Customs Brokers from Registration with the Registry"

It was stated above that, pursuant to the Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry, the Board rendered a decision determining the exceptions to the obligation to register with the Registry. After that decision, the Customs Brokers’ Associations of Ankara, Bursa, İstanbul, İzmir and Mersin sent the Board a letter of explanation and request dated 25.5.2018. In that letter it was requested, on the basis of the decision in question, that customs brokers and authorised customs brokers also be brought within the scope of the exception.

Following the examination it carried out in response to the request received, and taking into account also the relevant provisions of the Law and the Regulation, the Board decided to provide for an exception to the obligation to register with the Registry in respect of those operating as customs brokers and authorised customs brokers.

Customs brokers are self-employed professionals who, on the basis of the licence granted to them by the Ministry of Customs and Trade, follow up and complete, by way of indirect representation, the customs formalities relating to

the assignment of goods to a customs-approved treatment or use. Authorised customs brokers, for their part, arepersons authorised to carry out the verification operations
determined by the Ministry of Customs and Trade in order to ensure the correct application of
customs procedures with economic impact, end-use, simplified-procedure
practices and other customs formalities.
Both groups operate under the Customs Law No. 4458. Within the framework of
the obligations which that Law imposes on them, they process, as controllers, the data of the persons
whose customs formalities they carry out, and make declarations to the competent authorities on behalf of those persons.
They are required to keep the information and documents which they are obliged by law to maintain for five
years, to share them with the persons required and, provided that certain conditions are met,
to produce them to the officials specified3. For example, a customs broker
must declare to the customs inspector what he has written concerning a customs formality carried out in respect of a customs-approved use,
together with its annexes.
Customs brokers are therefore obliged, under the Law pursuant to which they operate, to keep,
store, share and transfer personal data. Moreover, since they are required by law to carry out
these activities, they are not required to obtain explicit consent under Law No. 6698
either. The request addressed to the Board for inclusion in the exception was in fact intended
to prevent the possible hardship that might arise from the danger that the personal data processing activities in question,
which they are in any event obliged by law to carry out, could be regarded as a breach
of the provisions of the Law.

It should be noted that Law No. 6698 in any event allows personal data to be processed
without the explicit consent of the data subject where conditions are met such as the processing activity being expressly provided for by laws
or being necessary for the controller to be able to fulfil
its legal obligation. Consequently, it is not possible for the personal data processing activities
which customs brokers carry out in order to fulfil the obligations imposed on them by the legislation to which they are subject
to amount to a breach of the provisions
of the Law.

The obligation to register with the Registry is, however, a matter distinct from the conditions for the processing of personal data. According to the report of the Ministry of Customs and Trade containing data current as at 2 May 2017, there are 9411 assistant customs brokers, 3127 customs brokers and 383 authorised customs brokers4. By including customs brokers and authorised customs brokers in the scope of the exception, the Board aimed to prevent a significant number of controllers from entering the system.

Moreover, the fact that the personal data processing activity arises from laws is listed among the criteria which the Board is to take into account when providing for an exception. For this reason I think that the criterion in question is the reason why the professional groups mentioned were brought within the scope of the exception. Nevertheless, I regard it as a major shortcoming that, in the decision it published, the Board set out only the exception decision and did not explain its reasons for bringing them within the scope of the exception. An explanation of why the Board felt the need to bring them within the scope of the exception could have been more useful for controllers and for those interested in the subject. Furthermore, since there are controllers who have not been brought within the scope of the exception, it is important from the standpoint of lawfulness that the exception decision be reasoned. Indeed, by virtue of the principles of legal security and legal certainty, individuals must have the right to know the regime to which they are subject and the reasons for it, and hence, in this specific context, controllers must have the right to learn clearly and definitively why they have not been brought within the scope of the exception.

In conclusion, customs brokers and authorised customs brokers, who can in any event process personal data without the explicit consent of the data subject under Law No. 6698, have by the decision in question also been exempted from the requirement to register with VERBİS.

On the other hand, I would like to underline emphatically that a controller’s being brought within the scope of the exception as regards the obligation to register with VERBİS in no way means that it is also released from the obligations imposed by the Law and the relevant Regulations. Although customs brokers and authorised customs brokers are not required to register with the Registry, they must act in compliance with the Law and the Regulations at every stage involving personal data. For example, they must not keep data that are not necessary to achieve the purpose they have determined, must not share the data they hold with more persons than necessary, and must not transfer them to persons to whom they are not obliged to produce them. A statutory obligation or exemption from registration with the Registry cannot be a legitimate justification for processing personal data in a manner contrary to Law No. 6698.

2. Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board of 05/07/2018, No. 2018/75, concerning the "Exception of Mediators from the Requirement to Register with the Data Controllers’ Registry"

In the letter sent to the Board on 25.05.2018 by the Mediation Department of the Directorate General for Legal Affairs of the Ministry of Justice, a request was made for mediators to be excepted from the requirement to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry. Following its examination, and taking into account also the provisions of the Law and the Regulation, the Board accepted the request and decided to provide for an exception in respect of mediators.

Mediation denotes “the method of dispute resolution which is conducted on a voluntary basis and with the participation of an impartial and independent third person who has received specialist training, who brings the parties together for the purpose of meeting and negotiating by applying systematic techniques, who establishes a process of communication between them so that they understand one another and thereby produce their own solutions, and who may also put forward a proposal for a solution where it becomes apparent that the parties are unable to produce one”. The mediator is the person who carries out the activity so described.

These persons operate under Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Civil Disputes. Under that Law, although the mediator is authorised to keep the information submitted to him or otherwise obtained in the course of his activity, he is obliged to keep such information, documents and records confidential. Nevertheless, it is possible and necessary for certain information to be disclosed to the extent that this is ordered by a provision of law or is necessary for the implementation and enforcement of the agreement reached at the end of the mediation process. Thus, under the legislation to which they are subject, mediators have rights and powers to keep and process personal data and, provided that the necessary conditions are met, to share such data.

In the course of the activities carried out in order to fulfil his professional obligation, the mediator obtains a significant amount of personal data relating to individuals, and often special categories of personal data. For example, a mediator acting in an employee–employer case may obtain data on the employee’s trade union membership, while a mediator acting in a compensation case between a hospital and a patient who was treated at that hospital is likely to obtain the person’s health data. The mediator is obliged to record the data obtained confidentially in accordance with the Law to which he is subject and to disclose them to the extent necessary under the conditions specified by that same Law.

Mediators are therefore able to base the processing activities they carry out on personal data in their capacity as controllers on conditions for processing such as the processing being expressly provided for by laws or being necessary for the fulfilment of the obligation, and do not need the explicit consent of the data subject. By the decision in question, persons carrying out the activity of mediation, in addition to being able to process personal data without explicit consent, have also been exempted from the requirement to register with VERBİS.

This exception decision, too, needs to be addressed from two different angles. First, I think that the Board’s decision to bring the profession of mediator within the scope of the exception is likewise based on the criterion that the personal data processing activity arises from laws. For, as explained, mediators are obliged to carry out personal data processing activity under the legislation to which they are subject. That said, the criticisms I expressed in respect of the previous decision, namely that the Board did not give reasons for its exception decision in that it failed to explain on which criterion or criteria it relied, apply to this decision as well.

Turning to the reasoning of the exception decision from the other angle, we again see that there is a large number of controllers carrying out the activity that is the subject of the decision. According to the list of mediators published by the Mediation Department of the Directorate General for Legal Affairs of the Ministry of Justice, 7832 mediators are active throughout Türkiye5. It can therefore be said that by this decision, too, the Board aimed to prevent a significant number of controllers from entering the system.

Lastly, it must not be forgotten that the other obligations imposed by the Law and the Regulations continue to apply to mediators as well, who have been brought within the scope of the exception as regards the obligation to register with VERBİS.

3. Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board of 19/07/2018, No. 2018/87, concerning the "Controllers to Be Excepted from the Obligation to Register with the Data Controllers’ Registry"

Lastly, by its decision published on 18 August 2018, and without any request having been addressed to it, the Board established new exceptions in addition to the controllers already excepted from the obligation to register with the Registry. Accordingly, among natural or legal person controllers whose annual number of employees is fewer than 50 and whose annual balance sheet total is less than TL 25 million, those whose main field of activity is not the processing of special categories of personal data have been included in the scope of the exception. The greatest question concerning the exceptions to be made to the obligation to register with the Registry has thereby been resolved, and a wide scope of exception has been created.

By Article 1 of the List Annexed to the Decision in its previous exception decision, the Board had stated that all controllers processing “personal data wholly or partly by automatic means” were under an obligation to register with VERBİS. In my assessment of that Decision I had set out my criticism that it was unclear what exactly was to be understood by this expression and, beyond that, whether this was really a case of exception at all. Thanks to today’s information-processing technologies, which are developing and spreading and whose cost is falling in parallel, it can be seen that data are processed by automatic means through a data filing system even in very small enterprises. Hence, at a time when automation is taking place in every sense, it would be very difficult to find controllers falling within this case of exception, so that in my view one could not, in essence, really speak of a scope of exception at all.

Since the entry into force of the Law, the expectation of controllers, and my own prediction as well, had been that a limit would be set according to the number of employees or annual turnover, and that controllers below a certain number of employees and/or annual turnover would be kept within the scope of the exception. It can be said that the shortcomings or uncertainties on the points mentioned have been remedied by this decision of the Board. For it has both widened the scope of the previous case of exception, the content of which could not be precisely determined, and met the expectations on the matter.

In order to fall within the scope of the exception set out in the Decision, it must be examined whether the following conditions are present in the case of the controller:

• The annual number of employees must be fewer than 50.

• The annual balance sheet total must be less than TL 25 million.

• The main field of activity must not be the processing of special categories of personal data.

This Decision will undoubtedly have its most important effect on SMEs (KOBİ), on which expectations on the matter were most concentrated. Since the previous decision had not established an exception for SMEs, I had stated in my assessment of that Decision that they too were under an obligation to register with VERBİS and were therefore required to draw up a Personal Data Inventory.

With this decision, however, the situation has changed and some SMEs have also been brought within the scope of the exception as regards the obligation to register with the Registry. Which SMEs, then, of what size and scale, will be able to benefit from this exception? To answer this, the enterprises that count as SMEs must be compared with the conditions set by the Board as to the number of employees and the annual balance sheet total.

SMEs (KOBİ), which make up a significant part of the real sector in our country, denote small and medium-sized enterprises. Which enterprises count as such is determined by the “Regulation on the Definition, Characteristics and Classification of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises”. Under it, economic units which employ fewer than 250 persons annually and of which either the annual net sales revenue or the balance sheet does not exceed 125 million Turkish liras are termed SMEs6. Hence, for SMEs whose annual number of employees is more than 50 and whose balance sheet is more than 25 million Turkish liras, this case of exception does not apply; the obligation to register with VERBİS and the requirement to draw up a Personal Data Inventory continue.

By this decision, therefore, the Board has exempted a very considerable number of controllers from the registration obligation and has prevented those controllers from entering the system. According to the news bulletin “Small and Medium-Sized Enterprise Statistics, 2016” of the Turkish Statistical Institute dated 25 November 2016, in 2014 SMEs accounted for

99.8% of the total number of enterprises7.The Employment Monitoring Bulletin of the Economic Policy Research Foundation of Türkiye (TEPAV),
in its issue No. 67, states that, according to the data for September 2017, the number of SMEs

rose by 101 thousand in one year to reach a total of 1 million 826 thousand8.
As can be seen, the great majority of controllers consist of SMEs9.
In order to fall within the scope of the exception set out in the Decision, the controller must, after the conditions as to the number of employees and
the balance sheet, satisfy the condition relating to the main field of activity. Accordingly,
for the controller to be able to benefit from this case of exception, its main field of activity must not be
the processing of special categories of personal data. However, what exactly is to be understood by the concept of
“main field of activity” is, in my view, unclear. I think that
two different meanings may be intended by it:
First, what may be meant is that, in order to fall within the scope of the exception,
the activities of processing special categories of personal data must not be central for the controller.
In that case, however, it is unclear what it means for special categories of personal data to be central
or to be essential for the controller.
For it is not possible to speak of an undertaking that has commenced its activity solely in order to process personal data.
From this angle, therefore, one must look at
whether, by the nature of the work it carries out, the controller essentially processes special categories of personal data.
For example, if it can be said of hospitals, whose core activities, by the very nature of the activity they carry out, consist in processing health
data and hence special categories of personal data, and,
thinking on a smaller scale, of small health-care establishments, that their main field of activity is
the processing of special categories of personal data, it will follow that these establishments
cannot benefit from the exception.
Secondly, it may be understood that, in order to be able to benefit from this exception, the controller
must not process special categories of personal data in any way whatsoever in the processes it designates as its main
activity. In that case, however, although in terms of the number of employees and the
balance sheet there are many SMEs that would fall within the scope of this exception,
it is very difficult to find controllers that do not process special categories of personal data in any way in their main processes,
so that the exception in question will have no significance whatsoever in practice.
Today, even in small enterprises, at least health data relating to employees
or information on trade union membership are kept.

I think that it is the first of these that is meant by the concept “whose main field of activity is not the processing of special categories of personal data”, laid down in the Board’s decision as a condition for inclusion in the scope of the exception. In that case, the existing number of SMEs, already narrowed in terms of employees and balance sheet, will be reduced further in respect of those whose core activity, by the nature of their work as described in the first reading, is the processing of special categories of personal data, and the number of controllers included in the scope of the exception will be at a reasonable level.

On the other hand, it can be seen that the Board, which in this decision too did not explain on which criteria it relied in establishing the exception, decided in the first place on the basis of the size of the field of activity in which the personal data are processed. In addition, the distinction drawn in respect of special categories of data shows that the criterion of the nature of the personal data was also taken as a basis. The criticisms I expressed in respect of the decisions above, as regards the Board’s failure to explain the criteria and reasons on which it relied, apply at this point as well.

Controllers that satisfy all three conditions and are thus understood to fall within the scope of the exception as regards the obligation to register with VERBİS are not required to register or to draw up an inventory; as I stated above, however, their responsibility continues in respect of the other obligations imposed by the Law and the Regulations.

Ever since the Law on the Protection of Personal Data entered into force and the obligation to become compliant with that Law arose for controllers, SMEs had expected that they would be excepted from the obligation to register with VERBİS and would therefore not be required to draw up a Personal Data Inventory, which is the first stage of the compliance processes. Because of this expectation, while many large-scale controllers have completed these processes, are about to begin them or are at the stage of obtaining proposals, SMEs have justified reservations about starting or continuing their compliance processes. Indeed, despite the first decision on exceptions published by the Board on 15 May 2018, SMEs continued to expect that they would be brought within the scope of the exception. The present decision, by contrast, is such as to dispel the doubts and reservations on the matter, in that it fully removes the uncertainties in every respect and defines the scope of the exception in concrete terms. My recommendation, therefore, to controllers who for reasons of this kind have been late in carrying out their compliance processes is that, if they fail to satisfy any one of the stated conditions as to the number of employees, the balance sheet and the nature of the data, they take concrete steps to become compliant with the Law as soon as possible. Indeed, 7 April 2018, the final date specified by the Law for compliance with the provisions it lays down, has already passed. In this context, infringement decisions and sanctions in the form of administrative fines have begun to make themselves felt. For this reason I recommend that controllers whose expectation of falling under an exception has not been met do not persist in this regard and begin work to become compliant with the Law as soon as possible, so as not to be faced with administrative fines.

4. Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board of 19/07/2018, No. 2018/88, concerning the "Dates on Which the Obligation to Register with the Registry Begins"

By this decision the Board has undoubtedly filled a major gap by answering one of the questions that arouse most curiosity on the subject and that we encounter most frequently in the compliance projects we conduct. The Decision determines the date on which controllers will begin to apply for registration with the Registry and how long this application period will last. The basis of the Decision is paragraph 2 of Provisional Article 1 of the Law: “Controllers must register with the Data Controllers’ Registry within the period determined and announced by the Board.”

The time limits by which controllers are bound in fulfilling the obligation to register with the Registry are as follows:

• For natural and legal person controllers whose annual number of employees is more than 50 or whose annual balance sheet total is more than TL 25 million, the starting date of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry is 01.10.2018, and the deadline for their registration with the Registry is 30.09.2019.

• For natural and legal person controllers established abroad, the starting date of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry is 01.10.2018, and the deadline for their registration with the Registry is 30.09.2019.

• For natural and legal person controllers whose annual number of employees is fewer than 50 and whose annual balance sheet total is less than TL 25 million but whose main field of activity is the processing of special categories of personal data, the starting date of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry is 01.01.2019, and the deadline for their registration with the Registry is 31.03.2020.

• For controllers that are public institutions and organisations, the starting date of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry is 01.04.2019, and the deadline for their registration with the Registry is 30.06.2020.

As can be seen, the Decision draws a distinction according to the size and nature of controllers. Accordingly, first place has been given to controllers whose annual number of employees is more than 50 or whose annual balance sheet total is more than TL 25 million, and to those which are under the registration obligation according to the criteria laid down and are established abroad. These controllers must have completed their application formalities between 1 October 2018 and 30 September 2019. At this point it is again necessary to mention the SMEs whose registration obligation continues because they do not meet the stated criteria. For I observe that many controllers of this kind are not yet even at the initial stage of their compliance processes. However, given that the application date begins in the near future and that compliance processes require time and effort, these controllers too must start these processes without further delay.

It was stated above that controllers whose main field of activity is the processing of special categories of personal data are not within the scope of the exception and must register with the Registry even if their annual number of employees is fewer than 50 and their annual balance sheet total is less than TL 25 million. Controllers of this kind are to apply between 1 January 2019 and 31 March 2020. In this respect it can be seen that later and shorter dates have been set. I think the reason for this is that controllers of this kind are of a smaller scale than the controllers placed first and, correspondingly, process a smaller amount of personal data.

The controllers that are to register with the Registry last have been determined to be public institutions and organisations. These institutions must fulfil their application obligations between 1 April 2019 and 30 June 2020. This is an extremely important point of emphasis. For in the contacts I have had I see that in many public institutions and organisations the idea prevails that “this Law does not apply to us”. Yet the Law has not brought any public institution or organisation other than the law enforcement and intelligence agencies within the scope of an exception. This decision is the clear proof and proclamation that there is no exception relating to them. Public institutions and organisations must therefore also begin their processes of compliance with the KVKK as soon as possible, draw up a personal data inventory and, when the time comes, fulfil the obligation to register with VERBİS.

First of all, I regard it as an appropriate step that the Decision has, without further delay, determined clearly and precisely the date on which controllers will begin to apply for registration with the Registry and how long this application period will last. The adoption, as we had anticipated, of a graduated approach according to the nature and size of the controllers that are to register has moreover been very useful. That the largest-scale controllers come first, because they process a large amount of personal data and the danger is therefore greater, and that a long date range has nevertheless been granted, since a serious obligation is at issue for controllers of this kind, is effective in terms of the obligation being fulfilled effectively and being practicable. I therefore regard the Board’s decision as a very appropriate development in this respect.

Conclusion

The conclusions reached from the assessment of the decisions rendered by the Personal Data Protection Board and published in the Official Gazette of 18 August 2018, No. 30513, and the recommendations to controllers, may be listed as follows:

• Customs brokers and authorised customs brokers, who can process personal data without the explicit consent of the data subject under Law No. 6698, have, as a result of the request addressed to the Board, also been exempted from the requirement to register with VERBİS.

• As a result of the request made to the Board by the Mediation Department of the Directorate General for Legal Affairs of the Ministry of Justice, persons carrying out the activity of mediation have also been exempted from the requirement to register with VERBİS.

• The Board has widened the scope of the exception which it had set out in its decision published on 15 May 2018. Accordingly, among natural or legal person controllers whose annual number of employees is fewer than 50 and whose annual balance sheet total is less than TL 25 million, those whose main field of activity is not the processing of special categories of personal data have been included in the scope of the exception. Some of the SMEs, which under the previous decision were understood not to fall within the scope of the exception in any way, have thus been exempted from this obligation.

• What is to be understood by the concept “those whose main field of activity is not the processing of special categories of personal data”, which is one of the stated conditions, needs to be clarified.

• By the decisions it has rendered, the Board has prevented a considerable number of controllers, who in any event carry out their processing activity on the basis of laws, from entering the system.

• Although, in rendering an exception decision, the Board is bound by Article 16 of the relevant Regulation, headed “Exception criteria”, in none of the three decisions it rendered did it explain why such an exception was needed in respect of the controllers brought within the scope of the exception from registration with the Registry.

I think that decisions not rendered with reasons, besides running counter to the principle of certainty, would be more useful if they were reasoned.

• Controllers brought within the scope of the exception must in no way forget that, unless a separate case of exception is provided for, they are bound by the other obligations imposed by the Law and the relevant Regulations. The exception in question relates solely to the obligation to register with VERBİS. Consequently, every controller, regardless of whether or not it falls within the scope of the exception, must act in compliance with the Law at every stage involving personal data.

• For controllers not falling within the scope of any of the exceptions determined, including the Decision previously published by the Board, the dates on which applications for registration with the Registry begin and end have been clearly determined.

• It has been clearly stated that public institutions and organisations are not within the scope of the exception.

• It is highly appropriate that the dates on which controllers that are to apply for registration with the Registry must do so have been staggered according to their nature, size and scope.

Footnotes

  1. Academic/Attorney-at-law. ↑
  2. For the assessment I wrote on the Regulation in question, see: https://www.academia.edu/35552517/VER%C4%B0_SORUMLULARI_S%C4%B0C%C4%B0L%C4%B0_HAKKIN DA_Y%C3%96NETMEL%C4%B0K%C4%B0N_GET%C4%B0RD%C4%B0KLER%C4%B0_VE_Y%C3%96NETMEL%C 4%B0KTE_D%C4%B0KKAT_ED%C4%B0LMES%C4%B0_GEREKEN_HUSUSLAR. ↑
  3. For the assessment I wrote on the decision in question, see: https://www.academia.edu/36645483/VERB%C4%B0SE_KAYIT_Y%C3%9CK%C3%9CML%C3%9CL%C3%9C% C4%9E%C3%9CNE_GET%C4%B0R%C4%B0LEN_%C4%B0ST%C4%B0SNALAR. ↑
  4. Article 30 - Customs brokers are obliged to keep for five years, without prejudice to the provisions of special laws, the commercial or statutory books which they are required by law to keep, their powers of attorney and contracts, the letters, faxes, telegrams and similar documents which they have written and received in connection with their business, and the originals and copies of the invoices and receipts they have issued and of the documents relating to their expenses; to show these to the customs inspector, assistant customs inspector, controller, trainee controller and the competent customs chiefs and officers; to permit their examination and audit; and, where necessary, to produce them upon written request to the officials mentioned above.
  5. For the full report, see: http://risk.gtb.gov.tr/data/572b3a8a1a79f50cd8a22b1a/34-Gumruk%20Musavir %20ve%20Yardimcisi%20Sayilari.pdf ↑
  6. To access the list, see: http://www.adb.adalet.gov.tr/arabulucu/. ↑
  7. By the “Regulation Amending the Regulation on the Definition, Characteristics and Classification of Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises”, which entered into force upon its publication in the Official Gazette of 24 June 2018, No. 30458, the upper limit for annual net sales revenue and balance sheet was raised from TL 40 million to TL 125 million. The upper limit for the annual number of staff employed, on the other hand, was maintained at 250 employees. ↑
  8. In the statistics in question, TÜİK defined as SMEs only those enterprises with fewer than 250 employees, without applying any criterion relating to financial size (annual net sales revenue or balance sheet). For the full news bulletin, see: http://tuik.gov.tr/PreHaberBultenleri.do?id=21540.
  9. TEPAV, İstihdam İzleme Bülteni, 21/12/2017, Sayı:67, http://www.tepav.org.tr/upload/files/1513838381- 3.TEPAV_Istihdam_Izleme_Bulteni___Eylul_2017.pdf.
  10. It should not be forgotten that the studies carried out relate to the definition of SME prior to the amendment made on 24 June 2018. In addition to these, economic units whose annual net sales revenue or balance sheet is between TL 40 million and TL 125 million have also been included in SME status.

Download PDF (in Turkish)

Related practice areas

More publications on this topic