2017Murat Volkan DülgerArticle

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

When we speak of money, what first comes to mind is money with a tangible, visible physical existence, in the form of coins or banknotes. But must money have a concrete reality? For some time now, the enormous development of technology has been leading us to ask these questions as well. For it is inevitable that technology, which plays a major role in every area of our lives and brings about change, will affect money, the economy and therefore trade. First of all, the question “What is money?” needs to be clarified.

Although it has no single settled definition, the generally accepted definition of money is that it is a common and generally accepted medium of exchange used to pay the price of goods and services and to settle debts. There is therefore no requirement as to what form money must take. Money is merely a representation and a common medium of exchange. Anything that is used to pay a price and is generally accepted can be regarded as money. In primitive societies in which goods were bartered, goods of value such as salt, tobacco, hides, dried fish and head of livestock were used as a measure of exchange. This type of money is called commodity money. It is known that forms of money such as coined money, paper money backed by gold and silver, and banknotes were used afterwards.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER, Academic & Attorney-at-Law

A Digital Means of Payment in the Digital Age:

Bitcoin and Digital Money

When money is mentioned, the first thing that comes to mind is coins or banknotes: tangible, visible money with a physical existence. But must money have a concrete reality? The tremendous development of technology has for some time now been prompting us to ask these questions as well.

For it is inevitable that technology, which plays a major role in every area of our lives and brings about changes, should affect money, the economy and, consequently, trade.

First of all, the question “What is money?” needs to be clarified. Although it has no single settled definition, the generally accepted definition of money is that it is the generally accepted common medium of exchange used to pay the price of goods and services and to settle debts. There is therefore no requirement as to what form money must take. Money is merely an instrument of representation and a common medium of exchange.

Anything that is used to pay a price and is generally accepted may be regarded as money.

In primitive societies where goods were bartered, goods of value such as salt, tobacco, hides, dried fish and heads of cattle

were used as the measure of exchange. This type of money is called commodity money. Thereafter, as is known, money such as metallic money, paper money backed by gold and silver, and banknotes came into use. Lastly, money that is held in bank accounts but has no physical existence, also called book money, gained importance with the development of commercial life and the advance of the banking sector. Digital money, on which I shall dwell and which is in fact the main subject of this article, came to life thanks to the “MORE SIMPLY development of technology and the internet and TO DEFINE IT has today become a much-debated

topic. IF NEED BE, IN

Although the concept of digital money came onto the agenda in the European Union and the United ESSENCE Kingdom in earlier years, Electronic Money, in Türkiye this subject took its place in legislation with Law No. 6493 OF THE COMPUTER on Payment and Securities Settlement Systems, Payment Services and OR Electronic Money Institutions, DATA STORAGE adopted in 2013. In Article 3 DEVICE of that Law, electronic money is defined as monetary value that, in return for funds accepted by the electronic money issuing institution, IN THE MAIN MEMORY is issued, (ON THE HARD DISK) electronically

HELD IN OUR NAME AND, VIA THE INTERNET,

stored, used to carry out the payment transactions defined in this Law and also accepted as a means of payment by natural and legal persons other than the electronic money issuing institution. To define it more simply, electronic money is essentially the means of payment that is held in our name in the main memory (hard disk) of a computer or data storage device and that we use for the payments and purchases we make via the internet. Electronic money, referred to for short as e-money, has many advantages and, alongside these, some disadvantages. Its principal benefits are that it eliminates the risks arising from the use of credit cards, saves time in commercial life and takes the form of a single currency rather than different currencies. Its use in the laundering of the proceeds of crime and in the financing of illegal activities, and

THE PAYMENTS WE MAKE

the fact that it is frequently attacked by hackers, on the other hand, constitute its principal

AND THE PURCHASES IN WHICH WE USE IT, IS A Means of Payment.”

disadvantages.

ARE THERE SANCTIONS CONCERNING ELECTRONIC MONEY? The Law does of course provide for a number of sanctions. Law No. 6493 regulates the procedures and principles relating to electronic money institutions and specifies the institutions that may issue electronic money. Article 27 of the Law, headed “non-compliance with regulations and decisions”, provides for the sanction of an administrative fine against legal persons operating as payment service providers that act contrary to matters which are contained in the Law and in the regulations to be issued and the decisions taken on the basis of the Law and for which no separate criminal sanction is laid down in this chapter.

Article 28 of the Law, headed “operating without authorisation”, for its part provides for imprisonment for natural persons, and for the officials of legal persons, who operate as a system operator, payment institution or electronic money institution without having obtained the authorisations required under the Law. •

WHAT DO THE CONCEPTS OF VIRTUAL MONEY AND CRYPTOCURRENCY MEAN?

The novelty and complexity of the subject have also given rise to many new words in the literature.

For this reason, in order that the subject may be better understood and that readers are not confused as to meaning, these concepts too need to be explained in detail. Virtual money is essentially a type, a subset, of electronic money. What they have in common is that both are digital. There are, however, many points of distinction as well.

First of all, the most fundamental and most obvious difference is that, whereas electronic money, as I explained in detail above, is legally regulated and governed by the Law, there is no statutory regulation whatsoever concerning virtual money.

In parallel with this, while the institutions that issue electronic money are determined by the Law, virtual money is issued by private persons. Certain other differences likewise stem from the distinction as to whether or not statutory regulation exists.

The facts that electronic money is subject to supervision under the Law, that its value is guaranteed and that its supply is fixed are among the differences linked to this. Another important difference is that the units of account of electronic money are currencies that are legal tender. In other words, electronic money is in fact of a kind that can be expressed in currencies such as the dollar and the euro. Virtual money, however, has no such characteristic. Virtual currencies are units of account subsequently adopted by the persons who issue them. The Bitcoin currency, which I shall explain shortly, belongs to this group.

Accordingly, although electronic money encompasses virtual money, the two also differ in many respects.

Having clarified the concept of virtual money, another matter we need to address is what exactly cryptocurrency denotes. Cryptocurrency is in fact one of the most popular topics of recent years. The word crypto literally means secret or hidden. A cryptocurrency, for its part,

is a digital and virtual currency that uses the science of cryptology for security purposes; these currencies are encrypted on a mathematical basis. Cryptology, in turn, is a science of encryption. Accordingly, we call a digital and virtual currency that uses a particular encryption method a cryptocurrency. Although it appears rather complicated, what is involved is in fact a process that works very simply: let us imagine that we are shopping over the internet with our debit cards; during this purchase no money actually leaves the bank vaults physically, yet we make the payment. Similarly, in every kind of commercial transaction we carry out in the virtual environment we are in essence using cryptocurrencies. For in this way, even though no physical transaction takes place, changes in figures occur in the systems.

WHERE DID CRYPTOCURRENCY COME FROM, WHO CREATED IT, AND WHY DID IT SUDDENLY BECOME SO POPULAR?

This is precisely the biggest question exercising the world of technology at present: who created cryptocurrency, and where did it come from? All history books record that the money we use today has its origins with the Lydians, and we have known this since our very first years at school. The concept of cryptocurrency, however, is quite foreign to all of us.

The first and most popular type and unit of cryptocurrency is Bitcoin. Bitcoin's symbol is “ ” and its abbreviation is BTC. Although it has no clear-cut definition, the Bitcoin currency may be explained as an electronic money system that makes it possible to transfer money between the parties without the need for any third-party service. So who created this Bitcoin? This is the part of the matter that is a complete mystery. Although it is known to have been developed in 2008 by Satoshi Nakamoto, who this person actually is remains unknown. More precisely, it is not even known whether this is one person, whether he is Japanese as the name suggests, or whether it is an institution. As to who, whether one person or several, created it, the only

“LET US IMAGINE THAT WE ARE SHOPPING OVER THE INTERNET WITH OUR DEBIT CARDS; DURING THIS PURCHASE No Money Physically Leaves THE BANK VAULTS IN REALITY, YET WE MAKE THE PAYMENT. SIMILARLY, IN EVERY KIND OF COMMERCIAL TRANSACTION WE CARRY OUT IN THE VIRTUAL ENVIRONMENT WE ARE IN ESSENCE USING CRYPTOCURRENCIES. FOR IN THIS WAY, EVEN THOUGH NO PHYSICAL TRANSACTION TAKES PLACE, Changes in Figures OCCUR IN THE SYSTEMS.”

piece of information we have is this name, because all the sources point to it. This name may be the pseudonym of a group or of a person, or it may be an institution or organisation; that we do not yet know.

HOW IS BITCOIN PRODUCED AND BY WHOM IS IT MINTED?

When we consider currencies such as the dollar, the euro and the Turkish lira, we all know that these currencies are managed by a central authority. Cryptocurrencies, by contrast, are not managed by a government.

And that is the most appealing aspect of the matter.

This is in fact also the reason underlying its great popularity. Bitcoin is an independent currency, and its value is determined by the extent of its use in daily life and the amount of it on the market. In parallel with this, we may say that its production too is user-driven. According to the protocols first published, we know that for the present there can be at most 21 million Bitcoins. In other words, production is limited. This has led to increased interest in the currency, because its value rises as it becomes harder to find; in technical terms, it appreciates because demand exceeds supply. In addition, Bitcoin is divisible. This means that there is no obligation to buy 1 whole Bitcoin. A further question then comes to mind: how many Bitcoins are on the market at present? It is known that as of 31 March 2017 16,246,200 Bitcoins were in use and that approximately 2 thousand Bitcoins are produced per day. Although the possibility that the Bitcoins on the market might run out may come to mind, it is fair to say that, since Bitcoin is constantly in circulation, there is no question of Bitcoin running out or of being unable to buy it.

Because it is not tied to any government or central authority, Bitcoin is not printed by a physical central bank.

Bitcoin is an independent currency, and what is involved is a system in which anyone who wishes to produce Bitcoin can do so in the virtual environment and in which the users themselves in essence take part in the production activity.

Its production, for its part, is denoted by a word derived from the English verb “mined”,

namely “mining”. Its Turkish equivalent is “madencilik”. Computers referred to as miners solve mathematical problems very rapidly in order to confirm the accuracy of transactions, and 50 new Bitcoins are given to the persons who, through this operation and by means of computer systems, find a solution. “Mining” is thus the name given to the process of solving complex mathematical formulas by computing power. DOES BITCOIN OFFER CERTAIN ADVANTAGES?

There are of course advantages to using Bitcoin in many respects. It must nevertheless be said that there are also points requiring caution. First, I mentioned above that Bitcoin is an independent currency. This means that Bitcoin policy is not regulated by a government. The anonymity of users is also one of the reasons why it is preferred. Although Bitcoin transactions are carried out publicly, the identity of the user is concealed. It should not be forgotten, however, that in order to benefit from this confidentiality the procedures to be followed must be complied with. These procedures are explained on Bitcoin's own website. The absence of a transaction fee and of place and time

“IT IS KNOWN THAT AS OF 31 MARCH 2017 16,246,200 BITCOINS WERE IN USE AND THAT APPROXIMATELY 2 Thousand BITCOINS ARE PRODUCED PER DAY.”

restrictions are undoubtedly among its other advantageous aspects. In certain special cases, however, for example where it is requested that the transaction be carried out more quickly than its normal duration, a fee may have to be paid.

In conclusion, although it has some advantageous aspects, it should also be borne in mind that there are circumstances such as the irreversibility of money transfers and the public nature of transfers.

ARE BITCOINS SECURE? The security of cryptocurrencies rests on a database called the “blockchain”, rendered in our language as “blok zinciri”. In this distributed database every piece of information is linked to the others in blocks by advanced encryption algorithms. Users are thus able to carry out transactions without being tied to a centre. In parallel with this, secure transactions take place directly between seller and buyer. In other words, Bitcoin is fundamentally secure. But are there exceptions? The answer to this question is inevitably “yes”. The loss, as a result of a computer crash, of Bitcoins that have not been transferred to virtual wallets, and the problem of hacking, which is in fact a problem of all kinds of virtual networks and activities, constitute the two main exceptions to the fundamental security of Bitcoins.

CAN BITCOIN BE AN INVESTMENT INSTRUMENT? Bitcoin is a currency whose value is rising rapidly and which is expected to replace paper money in the future. This being so, the idea of investing money in Bitcoin has arisen among people. One of the most frequently encountered questions of recent times concerns how to invest in Bitcoin and whether doing so would make sense. However, the facts that Bitcoin is not issued by an official institution, is not the subject of legal regulation and, moreover, can give no assurance as to its value are significant risk factors. Although, as I also stated above, it has many advantages • to offer, it is not possible to say anything definite and clear on this matter. It is also uncertain whether it can definitely be sold after it has been bought. Since it is not recognised as electronic money by the laws, there is no guarantee that it can be sold. In other words, there is a risk, however small, of being left holding it when confidence in it is lost.

IS BITCOIN LEGALLY REGULATED?

As I explained in detail above, virtual money, unlike electronic money, has not yet found a place in the legal sphere. It therefore has no place in Turkish law. According to the press release of the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency (BDDK) dated 25.11.2013:

“Bitcoin, known as a virtual currency that is not issued by any official or private institution and the backing of which is not guaranteed, is, by reason of its present structure and functioning, not regarded as electronic money within the scope of the Law, and its oversight and supervision within the framework of the said Law is therefore not considered possible.

On the other hand, the fact that the identities of the parties are not known in transactions carried out with Bitcoin and similar virtual currencies creates an environment conducive to the use of such virtual currencies in illegal activities. Furthermore, in addition to risks such as the possibility that its market value may be excessively volatile and that digital wallets may be stolen, lost or used improperly without their owners' knowledge, Bitcoin is also exposed, because the transactions carried out are irreversible, to risks arising from operational errors or from abuse by malicious sellers.

In order that no one should suffer loss, it is considered useful to announce the matters set out above and, in this context, to remind the public of the potential risks inherent in Bitcoin and similar virtual currencies.”

ACCORDING TO THE BDDK PRESS RELEASE DATED 25.11.2013: “BITCOIN, KNOWN AS A VIRTUAL CURRENCY THAT IS NOT ISSUED BY ANY OFFICIAL OR PRIVATE INSTITUTION AND THE BACKING OF WHICH IS NOT GUARANTEED, IS, BY REASON OF ITS PRESENT STRUCTURE AND FUNCTIONING, Not Regarded as Electronic Money WITHIN THE SCOPE OF THE LAW, AND ITS Oversight and Supervision WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE SAID LAW IS THEREFORE Not Considered Possible.”

From this statement we understand that, while the use of Bitcoin has not been categorically prohibited, neither is it an activity that has been left entirely free. For the Agency has clearly stated that it is not responsible for any losses that may be suffered and that caution must therefore be exercised.

IS USING BITCOIN AN OFFENCE? The first thing I wish to emphasise at this point is Article 2 of the Turkish Criminal Code. According to that provision: “No one may be punished, nor may a security measure be imposed on anyone, for an act that the law does not expressly define as an offence. No penalty or security measure may be imposed other than the penalties and security measures laid down in the law.” I have stated that neither the Bitcoin currency nor its use has found a place in any statutory regulation. Consequently, being a Bitcoin user, which is not expressly defined as an offence, cannot be regarded as an offence within the meaning of the Turkish Criminal Code and other laws; no one may therefore be punished or subjected to a security measure on that account. WHY, THEN, DOES THE POSSIBILITY THAT THE USE OF BITCOIN MIGHT BE REGARDED AS AN OFFENCE CAUSE CONFUSION, AND WHERE DOES THE DIFFICULTY COME FROM? As is known, most of the types of offence defined in the Code can be committed in more than one way. For example, one of the aggravated forms of the offence of fraud regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code consists in its commission by using information systems, banks or credit institutions as an instrument. In both cases the basic offence is the offence of fraud. Is the use of information systems, then, sufficient on its own for the offence of fraud to be constituted? No. These possibilities may be qualified forms that increase or reduce the penalty, but in whatever manner it is committed, the act of fraud, that is, deceitful conduct, must lie at the root of the offence. It is precisely at this point that the question whether being a Bitcoin user is to be regarded as an offence arises. For while the rate at which cybercrime is committed has in any event risen considerably with technological developments, the offences that can be committed by means of such a virtual currency are also becoming considerably more varied and numerous. However, the existence of Bitcoin and similar digital money does not in itself mean that these offences have been committed. First, Bitcoin is by its nature such that its source cannot be determined and it is therefore not possible to know how the money obtained from it was acquired. At this point there is a great risk that the offence of laundering assets derived from an offence, regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code, will be committed. For money obtained from criminal activities may be used to buy Bitcoin. Bitcoin may subsequently be converted into book money and introduced into the legal economic system.

Secondly, it may be possible for products or dealings whose purchase or sale is prohibited by the legal order to be transacted through Bitcoin, or for the commission of the offences in question to become easier in this way.

Where are these prohibited products offered for sale, and where do the buyers come from? At this point certain concepts need to be clarified. For the internet environment in which these sales take place has a complex structure.

The “Deep Web”, the Turkish equivalent of which means “deep internet”, is an encrypted communication network between parties that exists in the internet environment and in which very great importance is attached to secrecy. This communication network lies outside the visible web, and it is known that the boundaries of the internet as we know it today make up only a 4% portion of the entire internet world. The remainder consists of the dimensions referred to as the deep web and the dark net, the part of it in which more offences are committed. The reason I say dimensions is that there is not a single dimension

and that it is possible to go deeper layer by layer. The question of how the deep web is to be used is answered by installing a special browser, the “Tor Browser”, on the computer. This browser carries out the operations between the computers on which it is installed in encrypted form. Moreover, since it provides a high level of security, it is very widely preferred by users. In addition, the degree of this secrecy is increased by using a VPN (virtual private network). Let us now turn to what goes on here. Why has such a need arisen, and why do users prefer this route? First and foremost, this area provides users with complete anonymity. For that reason the identity of the user cannot be established. Although this wish mostly stems from the aim of carrying out a criminal activity, it may also arise from a purely personal preference. In other words, even if a person has not committed and would not be able to commit an offence, he may wish to remain hidden simply because he feels like it, and may choose this route; and we do come across such examples. From buying drugs to hiring a contract killer, from buying weapons to a wall clock fitted with a hidden camera, the purchase and sale of many illegal products and services takes place in this

area. When you wish to purchase these products or services, you are directed to a page on which you can pay from a Bitcoin wallet. Consequently, Bitcoin is used as money in many criminal activities in this area, and this virtual currency facilitates the carrying out of the illegal activities mentioned. Does the fact that Bitcoin and similar digital means of payment facilitate the transactions carried out make using them an offence in itself? Of course not. Unless it is expressly defined as an offence by law, it cannot be characterised as an offence. As a natural consequence of information systems having taken up such a place in our lives, criminal gangs have looked for ways of committing offences by these means as well, and, because the internet is an area suited to this, their search has met with success. The offences committed by these means are increasing day by day and will go on increasing. However, this alone is not sufficient for something to be regarded as an offence.

Finally, I should point out that there is a major gap in this field both in foreign legal systems and in the law of our country, and that legal regulation is needed in this matter.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER Academic & Attorney-at-Law volkan.dulger@dulger.av.tr

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic