15 June 2021Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

With the Covid-19 pandemic, which has affected the whole world, we went from PCR test results, the medicines used and contact status to the PCR test results of family members, and we are now, at last, talking about the problems brought by vaccination. Before this, we discussed on various platforms whether such information is personal data, and by whom and under which exceptions it may be processed. In fact there was no doubt that this information, as health data, falls within the special categories of personal data; the problem was how these data could be processed. Now the same problems have arisen with vaccination, and a debate has begun as to who may process the “information on whether a person has been vaccinated” and under what conditions.

Can anyone really ask whether a person has been vaccinated, and can the data subject be compelled to give this information? How is the balance to be struck between the benefit to the public of the information that a person has been vaccinated and the right to the protection of personal data, which is interfered with when the person is compelled to give that information?

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

ON COVID-19 VACCINATION AND THE PROTECTION OF PERSONAL DATA

May Employers Process Vaccination Information?

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

With the Covid-19 pandemic, which has affected the entire world, we have moved from PCR test results, medicines used, contact status and the PCR test results of family members to, finally, the problems raised by vaccination. Before this, we discussed on various platforms whether the information mentioned qualifies as personal data and by whom, and under which exceptions, it may be processed. In fact, there was never any doubt that this information constitutes special categories of personal data in the form of health data; the problem was how such data could be processed. The same problems have now arisen with vaccination, and the debate has begun as to by whom and under what conditions “the information whether a person has been vaccinated” may be processed.

Can anyone really ask whether a person has been vaccinated, and can the data subject be forced

to provide this information? How is a balance to be struck between the benefit to the public of the information that a person has been vaccinated and the right to the protection of personal

data that is interfered with when he is forced to provide this information?

These questions undoubtedly arise most acutely in the employer–employee relationship. For this reason, in this article I have chosen to discuss mainly how vaccination information is to be processed between employee and employer. Here we will try to bring together under one roof the questions relating to vaccination and to vaccination information in the workplace: For society, which moved to a new order with the Covid-19 pandemic, wishes to return to its former state through vaccination, and for this it needs the information whether people have been vaccinated or not.

I. The Relationship between Vaccination and the Protection of Personal Data in General

With the Covid-19 vaccination programme, information on whether individuals have been vaccinated has come into existence. This information undoubtedly constitutes special categories of personal data in the form of health data. Its disclosure and processing must therefore comply with the provisions and conditions of the data protection legislation. The importance of sharing this information lies in the fact that it is needed in order to return from the new order adopted in response to the Covid-19 pandemic to the former state of affairs. For example, workplaces that switched to working from home now wish to determine the return to their former working arrangements on the basis of vaccination. For this, they need to know who has been vaccinated and who has not.

It should be noted at this point that the debate on whether vaccination may be made compulsory is not the subject of this article, since that question concerns the principles of constitutional law. As a lawyer, however, I consider that forcing a person to be vaccinated is incompatible with the concepts of human rights and human dignity. Under the provisions on “the inviolability, material and spiritual existence of the individual” laid down in Art. 17 of the Constitution, such compulsion would be unconstitutional1. Measures that encourage vaccination may, of course, be adopted, and statements and initiatives in the nature of recommendations may be made. For example, while it is an extremely useful and appropriate practice for workplaces to issue announcements encouraging vaccination, making vaccination compulsory is contrary both to the ideal of human rights and, as stated above, to the rules of positive law.

II. The Nature and Processing of Vaccination Information

In order to determine the scope and limits of the processing of vaccination information by employers, let us briefly look at the nature of these data and the conditions for their processing.

1. What Is the Nature of Vaccination Information?

Health information constitutes special categories of personal data under Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (“Law No. 6698”) and is defined in the Regulation on Personal Health Data, published in the Official Gazette No. 30808 of 21 June 2019, as “all kinds of information relating to the physical and mental health of an identified or identifiable natural person and information relating to the health services provided to that person” .

In this context, every kind of information concerning an individual’s health, such as his disability, infectious diseases, the treatment he has received and the medicines he uses, forms part of data concerning health. Accordingly, there should be no doubt that the vaccines developed in response to the Covid-19 pandemic, and the information whether a person has received these vaccines, fall within the category of “health information”.

In support of this, the UK data protection authority (“ICO”), assessing the matter under the General Data Protection Regulation (“GDPR”), has stated that vaccination information is personal health data and must be processed in accordance with Art. 9 GDPR.2 Under Art. 9(2)(i) GDPR, the processing of special categories of data is possible where “processing is necessary for reasons of public interest in the area of public health, such as protecting against serious cross-border threats to health or ensuring high standards of quality and safety of health care and of medicinal products or medical devices, on the basis of Union or Member State law which provides for suitable and specific measures to safeguard the rights and freedoms of the data subject, in particular professional secrecy” .

2. What Are the Conditions for Processing Vaccination Information?

Under Art. 6(3) of Law No. 6698, data of this kind may be processed only in the following case: “..Personal data relating to health and sexual life may be processed without seeking the explicit consent of the data subject only by persons under an obligation of confidentiality or by authorised institutions and bodies, for the purposes of protecting public health, preventive medicine, medical diagnosis, the provision of treatment and care services, and the planning and management of health services and their financing”.

Accordingly, under Law No. 6698 vaccination information may be processed only where the following conditions are met:

- Explicit consent, or

- Protection of public health, Presence of any

- Preventive medicine, one of these

- Medical diagnosis, provision of treatment and care services,

- Planning and management of health services and their financing

- Persons under an obligation of confidentiality, or By

- Authorised institutions and bodies

III. Processing of Vaccination Information in the Context of the Employer–Employee Relationship

I would like briefly to clarify why vaccination information has become an issue in the employer–employee relationship. As is well known, because of Covid-19 a switch to working from home took place from March 2020 onwards. Some workplaces moved entirely to working from home, while others adopted a new system under which employees come to the office on certain days of the week and work from home on the others. When the pandemic eased, work from the office continued; when it intensified, work from home resumed. At the end of a process that continued in this way, we are now witnessing the first steps being taken, with vaccination, towards a complete return to working from the office. This, of course, requires the employees’ vaccination information. For example, at some workplaces the Human Resources department can be seen requesting and processing employees’ vaccination information. But is this a correct practice?

Below, we will try to clarify the problems that may come to mind on this subject in a question-and-answer format.

1. On which legal basis may vaccination information be processed in the workplace?

Since there is no doubt that vaccination information is health data within the meaning of Law No. 6698, the conditions required for the processing of health data must be fulfilled, and it must therefore be discussed on which legal basis these data may be processed.

In my opinion, vaccination information, like the PCR test result and the other personal health data that have become relevant in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic, may be processed on the legal basis of “protection of public health” set out in Art. 6(3). Indeed, in the statements made by the Personal Data Protection Board (“Board”) during this period, it was likewise stated that these data relate to public health and that public health is paramount.

Indeed, all personal health data connected with Covid-19 essentially concern public health. Although such an approach increases the risk of interference with personal data, the alternative would be to put public health at risk. When a balance is struck between the two interests, I consider that public health prevails.

Moreover, over the past year and more we have also experienced that the view that personal data prevail is not workable. During this period our temperatures were taken almost everywhere, our HES codes were scanned, our test results were notified to persons who might have been in contact with us because of the risk of contact, and we were asked whether we had been in contact with an infected person. That all of this should be done disproportionately and without limits can, of course, not be accepted. But in the face of a pandemic such as we had never experienced before, it became necessary to share this information up to a certain point in order to protect the health of society. Nor would it be reasonable to expect that, at the drafting stage of the Law, a pandemic would have been foreseen and an exception directly tied to a pandemic introduced. That being so, I see no objection, from the point of view of data protection, to getting through this period by relying on the most general and fundamental exception, namely the protection of public health. At this point it need only be recalled that the processing to be carried out must comply with the general principles laid down in Law No. 6698.

In conclusion, I consider that vaccination information, like the other personal health data that have arisen and gained importance in connection with Covid-19, may be processed in accordance with Law No. 6698 on the legal basis of the protection of public health.

2. By whom may vaccination information be processed?

Under Law No. 6698, health information may be processed only by persons under an obligation of confidentiality. The place where this information is to be collected and kept is therefore the workplace physician. Accordingly, at a workplace, vaccination information may be processed without obtaining the employees’ explicit consent, on the legal basis of the protection of public health, provided that it is collected and kept by the workplace physician. However, since not every workplace is required to employ a full-time workplace physician, this will not be possible for all employers.

3. How can employers that do not employ a workplace physician process vaccination information?

Where there is no workplace physician at the workplace with whom vaccination information can be collected and kept, the most reasonable method appears to be obtaining the employees’ explicit consent.

4. Is the explicit consent of employees valid in such a case?

At this point the question of the validity of explicit consent arises. For the subordinate position of employees vis-à-vis the employer creates a presumption that they are under pressure and cannot make a declaration of their own free will. Explicit consent, however, must be given freely and in the confidence that no adverse consequence will follow if it is withheld. Otherwise, under the provisions of Law No. 6698 and the decisions of the Board, the consent will be invalid. For this reason, we recommend that employers avoid, as far as possible, processing personal data on the basis of explicit consent obtained from employees.

In this case, however, there seems to be no other way for an employer that absolutely needs vaccination information. I therefore consider that explicit consent on this matter may be obtained from employees in an extremely transparent and careful process, observing all the rules on obtaining explicit consent. The most important point here is that employees are given an assurance that they will not face any adverse consequence if they do not give their explicit consent.

5. Does the obligation to inform continue to apply?

There is no doubt whatsoever that, in order for vaccination information to be processed, the obligation to inform must be fulfilled. It must not be forgotten that, apart from the exceptions listed in Art. 28(2) of Law No. 6698, the obligation to inform continues to apply to every kind of personal data processing activity. Accordingly, where an employer wishes to collect employees’ vaccination information at the workplace, information on the matter must in any case be provided at the latest at the stage of collection. Whether this processing is carried out on the legal basis of the protection of public health or on the basis of the employees’ explicit consent makes no difference with regard to the obligation to inform.

For example, the obligation to inform may be fulfilled by including, in the announcement requesting vaccination information, all the minimum elements that must be covered by the obligation to inform, such as why the information is needed and where it will be kept.

6. Which data may be processed as vaccination information?

An assessment must also be made of the data that may be processed as vaccination information, and the process must be conducted accordingly. For although it may be accepted that vaccination information can be processed under certain conditions, no concession may be made on the general principles of data protection. For this reason, the principle that personal data may be collected only to the extent necessary to achieve the purpose must not be abandoned.

In this context, I consider that employees may be asked whether they have been vaccinated and, if so, the date of vaccination (for example, in order to determine the date of the switch from working from home to working at the office). Beyond this, I am of the opinion that there can be no reasonable justification for requesting information such as which type of vaccine was received or at which hospital it was administered. On the other hand, some employers can be seen to be making copies of the cards kept during the vaccination process, such as vaccination tracking cards. I consider that such a practice is contrary to the general principles of the Law and therefore constitutes unlawful data processing.

7. May vaccination be assessed within the scope of occupational health and safety?

The provisions of the Occupational Health and Safety Law No. 6331 apply to ensuring occupational health and safety at workplaces. Under that Law, the employer is obliged to ensure the work-related health and safety of employees. Similarly, under Art. 417(2) of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 employers are under an obligation to take all measures necessary to ensure occupational health and safety at the workplace and to keep the tools and equipment complete.

Under this Law, in the event of an outbreak of the epidemic diseases listed in Art. 57 of Law No. 6331, vaccination is made possible under Art. 72(2) of the same Law. For compulsory vaccination, however, the names of the vaccines must be specified by law. Yet the Covid-19 vaccine in question has not been included in any group of vaccines that are compulsory under the occupational health and safety legislation. For this reason, it is not possible to accept vaccination within this framework and both to make it compulsory and to carry out processing on the ground that it is a processing activity provided for by law.

At this point, one can speak only of measures by the employer encouraging vaccination. Indeed, even before vaccination began during the Covid-19 period, employers had been subject to a number of obligations, such as providing masks and disinfectant at the workplace and ensuring compliance with hygiene and social distancing rules. An obligation of the employer may likewise be spoken of in respect of presenting Covid-19 vaccination as a recommended and encouraged practice of the same kind. For example, practices such as giving an employee time off to get vaccinated and allowing him to rest in the event of any side effects should be in place at every workplace without exception.

These points, however, do not mean that vaccination information may be processed within the scope of occupational health and safety. For the protection of personal data is a fundamental right and freedom, and an interference with this right cannot be effected by way of interpretation in this manner.

8. What will be the position of an employee who refuses to provide vaccination information?

Frankly, although I think that this information should be provided on condition that it is processed in accordance with the Law for the purposes of public health and the organisation of the workplace, I am also of the opinion that an employee who refuses to provide it should not be subjected to any adverse sanction.

What the consequence will be must be determined according to why the employer is requesting the information. For example, the employer may wish to switch to working from the office and may need vaccination information in order to plan this. When the position of an employee who refuses to provide vaccination information to an employer that will process it for these purposes is assessed, it appears possible to decide that this employee should continue to work from home. Subjecting him to an adverse sanction instead would be contrary to equity.

For the employee must inform the employer only if he has an infectious disease that would affect other employees.3 Beyond that, he is not legally required to provide information on whether he has been vaccinated.

The ICO states clearly that requesting these data, and the internal security steps to be taken to protect them, must be reasonable, fair and proportionate. On this basis, the focus must be on the question whether collecting these data will make the workplace safer. Can the workplace be made safe through other practices without collecting these data? The answers to whether vaccination information should be obtained, and accordingly to what the position of an employee who refuses to provide it will be, will vary depending on the answers given to these questions.

9. May vaccination information be asked for during recruitment?

Finally, another question to be discussed is whether it is possible, during recruitment, to ask job applicants whether they have been vaccinated.

I am of the opinion that under normal circumstances no health data should be requested from job applicants, but that certain questions that are important with regard to the qualities required by the nature and character of the job may be asked. It is, however, open to debate whether the Covid-19 vaccine falls within the nature and character of a particular job. For example, while asking this question when recruiting staff to work in a hospital may be accepted as required by the nature of the job, how this would work in other sectors may be unclear.

In my opinion, an employer’s wish not to employ unvaccinated staff in order to protect the health of other employees, and accordingly asking candidates about their Covid-19 vaccination status in job interviews, may be regarded as a reasonable ground from the employer’s point of view. This matter must, however, be clarified not by way of interpretation but by means of a statutory provision. Until such a provision is made, there will always be a risk of the existing law being violated. For since the interference with fundamental rights and freedoms is not provided for by law, it amounts, from the point of view of the existing law, to a disproportionate interference. On the other hand, the situation is one that is unworkable in practice. I therefore consider that the most reassuring solution for practice, too, should be introduced by statutory provisions as soon as possible.

At this point it can be said with certainty that detailed questions by the employer about the applicant’s state of health that are not required by the job and/or the job description are impermissible, and that the applicant cannot be said to be under an obligation to answer them truthfully.4

I would also like to point out here that it would not be right to ask a job applicant who has chosen not to be vaccinated detailed questions such as why he has chosen not to be vaccinated.5

10. Are there international examples on this subject?

As vaccination has begun to be carried out systematically in almost every country, problems similar to those in our country are arising in working life. In this part of the article I would like briefly to address the problems that vaccination has raised at workplaces in the USA and Germany.

In the USA, the laws in force allow employers to require their employees to be vaccinated and to dismiss those who are not. Although the law permits this, looking at the practice at workplaces in the USA we can see that, rather than compelling the disclosure of vaccination information, efforts in keeping with equity are made mostly in the direction of employees providing their own information themselves. An example of this is a news report published in the New York Times on 20 May 2021. The report mentions that a company will give its employees gift cards if they submit their vaccination cards to the company.6 From this it may be said that companies will in fact obtain their employees’ health information in return for a payment made to them under the heading of a “gift card”.

By contrast, some jurisdictions take a stricter view. In France and Germany, for example, employers cannot obtain information on whether an employee has been vaccinated.7 In Germany, however, financial bonuses are being created for employees to get vaccinated against Covid-19. For example, the supermarket chain Lidl gives its employees a shopping card worth 167 euros if they get vaccinated.8 In addition, vaccinated employees in Germany are also being granted days off or extra payments. The debates arising from all these vaccination incentive schemes have taken their place on the agenda in a manner similar to the debates in our country. Accordingly, in Germany too it is considered that this situation may lead to unfairness among employees. In this debate it is pointed out that, although under German law employers are legally required to treat employees equally, the law also allows vaccinated and unvaccinated employees to be treated differently at the workplace within certain limits. For employers must also take the health of employees into account and must not expose them to unnecessary physical dangers. In the context of the pandemic, too, since the health of employees is given priority, different treatment of vaccinated and unvaccinated persons at the workplace may be accepted. Accordingly, if employees are working from home during the pandemic, it will be possible to allow vaccinated employees to return to the office earlier or to give them privileged access to the company’s common areas.

Conclusion

In Türkiye, as elsewhere in the world, Covid-19 vaccination rates have risen day by day, and with this increase many questions have arisen. Undoubtedly, as explained in detail above, all these questions in fact come together under a single basic heading: How will the new social order established with the pandemic return to its former state? For over the past year and more a series of legal measures has been introduced, and within their framework many rules, prohibitions and sanctions have been laid down. It must be discussed whether all these measures will be lifted when the pandemic ends and which practices will apply during this transition period. However, having regard to the lawfulness of the manner in which these measures were introduced (introducing legal norms by circular, meetings held by bodies not provided for in the Constitution, moreover decisions concerning the whole country being taken as a result of these meetings, these decisions being announced at midnight, and, going even further, certain sales bans being imposed without even the need for any rule or regulation, etc.), I must state that I am not hopeful as regards their coming to an end either.

Since Covid-19 vaccination is the first step towards the return of the new social order to its former state, the information whether a person has been vaccinated has begun to gain importance. As explained above, I am of the opinion that every kind of processing activity to be carried out on this information, such as its disclosure, request and storage, must be placed within a process that takes into account the provisions of Law No. 6698 and the decisions and statements of the Board. In doing so, while safeguarding the interest in the protection of personal data is treated as the primary aim, the most realistic method applicable in both working and social life should be adopted. Accordingly, care must be taken to ensure that the interference with this right that will be carried out from various angles is equitable in accordance with the philosophy and principles of data protection. At the same time, however, I would like once again to emphasise strongly that the matter should be clarified by statutory provisions as soon as possible so that violations of the existing law are no longer tolerated.

Footnotes

  1. Academic / Attorney-at-law. ↑
  2. The Constitutional Court’s Halime Sare Aysal judgment of 11.11.2015 on compulsory vaccination is important at this point. In that judgment the Court stated that fundamental rights and freedoms may be restricted only by law and that the names of the vaccines made compulsory must also be expressly specified in such laws. Since the smallpox vaccine, which was compulsory at that time, was included in the relevant article of the Public Hygiene Law No. 1593 in force at the date of the judgment, the Constitutional Court did not find any unlawfulness. However, that Law dates from 1930, and the Covid-19 virus that we encountered in 2020 does not fall within its scope (Anayasa Mahkemesi, Halime Sare Aysal, Başvuru No: 2013,1789, 11.11.2015). ↑
  3. ICO, Vaccinations, Erişim Tarihi: 18.06.2021, https://ico.org.uk/global/data-protection-and-coronavirus-information-hub/coronavirus-recovery-data-protection-advice-for-organisations/vaccinations/#collect ↑
  4. Erbil Beytar, İşçinin Kişiliğinin ve Kişisel Verilerinin Korunması Onikilevha Yayıncılık, 2018, s. 171. ↑
  5. Selen Uncular, İş İlişkisinde İşçinin Kişisel Verileri, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2018, s. 197 ↑
  6. SHRM, Can employers ask applicants about vaccination?, Erişim Tarihi: 18.06.2021, https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/legal-and-compliance/employment-law/pages/coronavirus can-employers-ask-applicants-about-vaccination.aspx ↑
  7. The New York Times, I Shouldn’t Tell My Employer I’m Vaccinated, Right?, Erişim Tarihi: 19.06.2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/20/style/employee-vaccination-incentive-social-qs.html ↑
  8. Osborne Clarke, Media comment: Vaccine passports and data protection, Erişim Tarihi: 19.06.2021, https://www.osborneclarke.com/news/media-comment-vaccine-passports-data-protection/ ↑
  9. DW, German retailer offers bonus to vaccinated workers, Erişim Tarihi: 20.06.2021, https://www.dw.com/en/german-retailer-offers-bonus-to-vaccinated-workers/a-57217050 ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic