2005Murat Volkan DülgerArticle

Where to read

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Murat Volkan Dülger

The subject of this paper is the provisions on cybercrime introduced in the new Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (YTCK). Cybercrime is in fact a broad subject which calls for a very extensive examination and, before that, for the various problems of concept and definition relating to it to be identified and explained. However, since this study is a conference paper, explanations will be given with the aim of providing brief information on the subject, without going into the debates on it in legal scholarship or a detailed explanation of the relevant types of offence, and in this way the study will, as far as possible, avoid being wide-ranging and detailed.

A. Comparison of the Cybercrimes Regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK) and in the YTCK

Cybercrimes appear in the YTCK under the following numbers and headings:

In Chapter Nine of the Part “Offences against persons”, under the heading “offences against private life and the confidential sphere of life”: Art. 135 “the offence of recording personal data”, Art. 136 “the offence of unlawfully giving or obtaining personal data”, Art. 138 “the offence of failing to destroy data”.

In Chapter Ten of the Part “Offences against society”, under the heading “offences in the field of information technology”: Art. 243 “the offence of unlawfully accessing an information system or remaining in the system”, Art. 244(1)-(2) “the offence of obstructing or disrupting the functioning of an information system, destroying or altering data”, Art. 244(4) “the offence of obtaining an unlawful benefit by means of an information system”, Art. 245 “the offence of misuse of bank or credit cards”.

In addition to these, the YTCK also contains types of offence which can be committed by means of information systems but which cannot be characterised solely as cybercrimes. The following types of offence may be given as examples of these.

Attorney-at-law; doctoral student at the Department of Public Law, Institute of Social Sciences, Istanbul University.

In Chapter Nine of the Part “Offences against persons”, under the heading “offences against private life and the confidential sphere of life”: Art. 132 “the offence of violating the confidentiality of communications”; in Chapter Seven of the Part “offences against persons”, the chapter “offences against liberty”: Art. 124 “the offence of obstructing communications”; in Chapter Eight, the chapter “offences against honour”: Art. 125 “the offence of insult”; in the chapter on offences against property: Art. 142(2)(e) “the offence of aggravated theft”, Art. 158(1)(f) “the offence of aggravated fraud”; and in Chapter Seven of the Part “offences against society”, the chapter “offences against public morality”: Art. 226 “the offence of obscenity”, Art. 228 “the offence of providing a place and facilities for gambling”.

The article-by-article comparison of the TCK No. 765 and the YTCK No. 5237 with regard to cybercrime is as follows:

TCK Art. 525a(1) YTCK Art. 135, Art. 136 TCK Art. 525b(1) YTCK Art. 244(1)-(2) TCK Art. 525b(2) YTCK Art. 244(4), 245, 158(1)(f), Art. 142(2)(e).

B. Types of Offence Regulated in the Chapter on Offences in the Field of Information Technology

1. The Offence of Unlawfully Accessing an Information System or Remaining in the System (Art. 243)

In the chapter on offences in the field of information technology, the first provision, Art. 243, regulates “the offence of unlawfully accessing an information system or remaining in the system”. By including this article in the YTCK, the legislature has made the act of “unlawfully accessing the whole or part of an information system or continuing to remain there” a type of offence1.

The type of offence contained in this article achieves parallelism with the provision on “illegal access” laid down in Art. 2 of the European Convention on Cybercrime2.

By this provision, acts of unauthorised access to data without the data being obtained have been made a type of offence in the YTCK3. Art. 243 YTCK removes the condition of “the obtaining of data” for access to an information system to be punished and makes it an offence to access an information system unlawfully, that is, to breach the security of the information system, whether or not data are obtained4. This is an extremely apt and modern provision which may be effective particularly against computer pirates5.

2. The Offence of Obstructing or Disrupting the Functioning of an Information System, Destroying or Altering Data (Art. 244(1)-(2))

Art. 244(1) and (2) YTCK regulate as types of offence acts of causing damage, by whatever method, to an information system and to data. Art. 244(1) makes the acts of “obstructing the functioning of an information system and disrupting the system” a type of offence, while paragraph 2 does so for the acts of “damaging, destroying, altering or rendering inaccessible the data in an information system, introducing data into the system and sending data elsewhere”6.

By including this type of offence in the YTCK, an attempt is made to achieve parallelism with the provisions on “data interference” laid down in Art. 4 and on “system interference” laid down in Art. 5 of the European Convention on Cybercrime7.

This type of offence has been regulated in the YTCK to replace “the offence of damaging data or data processing” regulated in Art. 525b(1) TCK. The aim of the type of offence in question is to punish the obstruction, in whatever way, of the operation of an information system or the disruption of the system. The explanatory memorandum to the article also states that by this article acts of causing harm directed at information systems have been made a separate offence. With an apt approach, and unlike the provision in the TCK No. 765, the provision does not use the term “causing damage” , so that acts carried out against the hardware part of an information system with the intent of damaging property are kept outside the scope of this article8.

3. The Offence of Obtaining an Unlawful Benefit by Means of an Information System (Art. 244(4))

Art. 244(4) YTCK regulates “the offence of obtaining an unlawful benefit by means of an information system”. This type of offence has been regulated by reference to Art. 244(1) and (2); when both paragraphs are read together, the type of offence in Art. 244(4) reads: “where the obtaining of an unjust advantage for oneself or for another by obstructing or disrupting the functioning of an information system, damaging the data contained in the system, introducing data into the system, sending existing data elsewhere, rendering them inaccessible, altering them or destroying them does not constitute another offence, a penalty of ... shall be imposed”.

In the YTCK No. 5237, the acts regulated in Art. 525b(2) of the TCK No. 765, namely obtaining an unlawful benefit by means of information systems, misusing bank and credit cards, fraud by means of an information system and theft by means of information systems, have been made into different types of offence. Of those acts, this type of offence regulates the acts of “obtaining an unlawful benefit by means of an information system”9.

Again in Art. 244(4), by the use of the expression “where it does not constitute another offence” with regard to this type of offence, it is stated that where an unlawful benefit is obtained by carrying out the same acts but this is regulated in another type of offence, this type of offence will not apply. What is to be understood by this provision, which is not very appropriate in terms of legislative technique, is stated in the explanatory memorandum to the law; according to it, “for a penalty to be imposed on the basis of this paragraph, the act must not constitute another offence requiring a heavier penalty. In this respect, where the act constitutes the offence of fraud, theft, abuse of trust or embezzlement, no penalty will be imposed on the basis of this paragraph”10.

4. The Offence of Misuse of Bank or Credit Cards (Art. 245)

One of the important and positive changes introduced by the TCK with regard to cybercrime is that Art. 245 of the law regulates the acts of “misuse of bank or credit cards” as a type of offence in a separate article11.

Both in legal scholarship and in practice, the acts in question were assessed as falling within the scope of “the offence of obtaining an unlawful benefit by means of an information system” in Art. 525b(2) TCK; however, various distinctions were drawn according to the manner in which the card, the instrument of the offence, was obtained and used, and it was debated whether the acts in question constituted the classic offence of fraud or the offence of obtaining an unlawful benefit by means of an information system. It is these debates and distinctions that this provision sought to bring to an end12, and the explanatory memorandum to the article also states that every kind of act of obtaining an unlawful benefit carried out with a credit or bank card will constitute this type of offence13.

This article seeks to prevent banks and cardholders from being caused loss through the unjust, unlawful use of the cards in question and an unlawful benefit from being obtained in this way14. This is also clearly expressed in the explanatory memorandum to the article15.

C. Types of Offence Regulated in the Chapter on Offences against Private Life and the Confidential Sphere of Life

1. The Offence of Recording Personal Data (Art. 135)

Art. 135(1) YTCK regulates as a type of offence the act of unlawfully recording personal data, and paragraph 2 of the same article the acts of entering as personal data persons’ political, philosophical and religious views, racial origins, trade union affiliations, sexual lives and state of health16.

A type of act which, with the development of information technology, is encountered very frequently in our country and in the world and which at the same time constitutes an attack on personality rights is the entry of persons’ personal data into information systems without their consent17. It is known that, in particular, hospitals collect and use data of this kind concerning their patients, financial institutions and insurance companies concerning their customers’ creditworthiness and ability to pay, and commercial companies for advertising and marketing purposes.

It is the transfer of information of this kind to the virtual environment as data, and the failure, in doing so, to obtain the permission of the person to whom the data relate, that the article under examination has made a type of offence18. In this way the relevant provisions of the “Convention for the Protection of Individuals with regard to Automatic Processing of Personal Data”, which is one of the instruments produced by the Council of Europe and to which Türkiye too is a party by due ratification, will find a field of application in the law of our country19.

2. The Offence of Unlawfully Giving or Obtaining Personal Data (Art. 136)

Art. 136 YTCK, for its part, regulates as an independent type of offence the acts of unlawfully giving personal data to another, disseminating them or obtaining them. This provision was enacted in particular against acts of identity theft, which are encountered very frequently in countries such as the USA and England and are said to be the most frequently committed cybercrime, so that acts of this kind do not go unsanctioned.

Today almost all personal information and identity information is to be found, in particular, on the internet; it has been an apt step to regulate as a type of offence the unlawful giving of this information to third parties, its dissemination or the obtaining of these data by third parties20.

3. The Offence of Failing to Destroy Data (Art. 138)

By Art. 138 YTCK, the failure of persons who are responsible for destroying personal data within the system, although the statutory period has expired, to fulfil this duty is made an offence21. By this type of offence included in the YTCK, a sanction is provided for those who do not remove the data from the system, that is, those who neglect their duties in this regard, so as to prevent personal data lawfully held in the system from remaining in these systems permanently and thus being accessible at any moment.

Both the individual and the State want these data to be destroyed. For a State that constantly collects and records information about its citizens, in short, that keeps files on its citizens, can never be a pluralist, liberal and democratic State and cannot make its citizens into a society committed to these modern principles. It is this that the type of offence in question seeks to prevent22. This type of offence is regulated for the first time by the YTCK No. 5237.

D. Other Types of Offence That May Be Committed by Means of Information Systems

Apart from the types of offence explained above, there are also other types of offence which are regulated in different chapters of the YTCK and which may be committed by means of information systems. These types of offence are the following:

“The offence of obstructing communications” regulated in Art. 124 YTCK, “the offence of insult” in Art. 125, “the offence of violating the confidentiality of communications” regulated in Art. 132, “the offence of aggravated theft” in Art. 142(2)(e), “the offence of aggravated fraud” in Art. 158(1)(f), “the offence of obscenity” regulated in Art. 226 and “the offence of providing a place and facilities for gambling” regulated in Art. 228.

E. Criticisms Made with regard to Cybercrime in the YTCK

The types of offence regarded as cybercrimes and briefly indicated above are regulated in the YTCK, having regard to the legal interest protected by the offence, in the chapters to which they relate, according to the legal interest they protect. Types of offence whose protected legal interest is of a mixed nature, on the other hand, are placed in a separate chapter with the information system taken as the common denominator. However, although the offence of misuse of bank or credit cards ought, according to the legal interest it protects, to be placed in the chapter on offences against property, this has not been done and it is regulated in the chapter on offences against information systems. This situation needs to be corrected and the type of offence placed in the chapter to which it relates23.

While Art. 525a(1) of the TCK No. 765 regulated the act of obtaining data as an offence, it did not regulate as a type of offence what is in fact a more frequently encountered type of act, namely gaining unauthorised access to an information system and learning the information in it without obtaining it. It must be said, as a positive criticism, that Art. 243 YTCK has remedied this situation and that an attempt has thus been made to take a measure, by means of criminal law, against the acts of the computer pirates described by the term “hacker”24.

An important deficiency that must be addressed here concerns “the offence of forgery of data”, which was regulated both in the TCK No. 765 and in the government bill submitted to the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye (TBMM). This type of offence was not included in the text of the bill as amended and adopted in the parliamentary sub-committee; in the end, this type of offence did not appear in the YTCK as enacted either. Since, from the standpoint of criminal policy, documents of this kind can be drawn up and used by means of an information system and public trust can thereby be violated, this type of offence should be expressly regulated in the YTCK and placed in the chapter on offences against public trust. This type of offence should either be regulated independently in the relevant chapter indicated above or be provided for, by way of a separate provision in each case within the offences of forgery of official and of private documents, as an aggravating circumstance of those offences25.

The use of information systems in organised crime and in cyberterrorism must be regulated urgently, and provisions on this subject must be made in the relevant laws. In addition to these, provisions must also be made on the acts of racism, incitement to violence, incitement of the people to hatred and enmity, incitement to commit offences and propaganda of terrorist organisations carried out in the virtual sphere by means of information systems26.

Having regard to the phenomenon of cyberterrorism, carrying out terrorist acts by making use of data transmission networks should be treated as an aggravating circumstance. For whereas the activists who carry out a terrorist act put even their own lives at risk in the classic types of offence, carrying out the acts by means of information systems reduces both the risk they take and the risk of being identified and caught, and facilitates the commission of the offence27.

Likewise, the acts whereby organised criminal groups communicate with their members and use and transfer their financial resources should also be separately regulated and treated as an aggravating circumstance; the explanations given above on this subject apply here too. The absence of any provision on this subject in the YTCK is regarded as an important deficiency28.

The act of organising and engaging in gambling over data transmission networks must without fail be regulated as a separate type of offence. There is a major legal gap in this area. There is no specific provision to this effect in the YTCK. Yet while even physical casinos, which not everyone can reach, have been banned in our country, anyone who so wishes can today gamble in virtual casinos. Although Art. 228 YTCK uses a broad expression in saying “providing a place and facilities for gambling” and it is considered possible for this article to be applied also to acts carried out over the internet, it would be an appropriate provision for “the organisation of gambling in the virtual sphere by means of information systems” also to be stated in the text of the article, so that problems of interpretation do not arise and no confusion is caused in practice29.

In the USA and Australia in particular, acts of sending unsolicited electronic mail (spam) are regulated as an offence. This is a situation which is truly disturbing, which increases the density of traffic on data transmission networks, which takes up very large amounts of space in the electronic mail of organisations and individuals and which therefore hampers international trade. This act too needs to be regulated as a type of offence in the YTCK30.

An important provision that needs to be made with regard to cybercrime is to make the sexual abuse of children for commercial purposes in the virtual sphere an independent type of offence31. The coercion of children by persons such as their parents or guardians into being made the subject of materials such as pornographic pictures and films, and the marketing and purchase of these over the internet, should be made a type of offence32. In addition, the possession in information systems of any kind of material containing child pornography, making it available for sharing, transmitting it and using it should be regulated as a type of offence33.

“Every kind of act relating to child pornography”, especially those carried out over the internet, should be made an offence. What these acts are is set out one by one in the European Convention on Cybercrime. The fact that this Convention describes in detail the acts of producing, distributing and possessing data with child-pornographic content by means of information systems, which today have become almost a bleeding wound and which, since the emergence of the internet, have been regarded as the most harmful side of this very useful network system34, and that it provides for every form of commission of the acts in question, even virtual, to be regulated as an offence, is one of the most striking and important provisions of this Convention35. Although making these acts, which are also set out in detail in the Convention in question, an offence needs to be done as a matter of great urgency, Art. 226, the provision of the YTCK relating to this subject, is extremely inadequate in this respect36. This inadequacy needs to be remedied as soon as possible, in recognition of the importance of the subject.

Finally, it must be stated that all the provisions to be made should be made with a positive and constructive approach, in such a way that freedom is the rule and restriction the exception; and there must be no compromise on the principle of the rule of law, the principle of legality of offences and penalties, the principle of the essence of the fundamental rights and freedoms set out in our Constitution , or the criterion of necessity in a democratic society set out in the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and in the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR)37.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Akbulut, Berrin, “Türk Ceza Hukukunda Bilişim Suçları”, Yayınlanmamış Doktora Tezi (Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Kamu Hukuku Anabilim Dalı Ceza ve Ceza Usul Hukuku Bilim Dalı), Konya, 1999.

Çeken, Hüseyin, Council of Europe’s Convention 2001 on Cybercrimes and Turkey, Unpublished Master of Science Thesis (University of Marmara European Community Institute Law of European Union), İstanbul, 2003.

Değirmenci, Olgun, “Bilişim Suçları”, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi (Marmara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Hukuk Anabilim Dalı Kamu Hukuku Bilim Dalı), İstanbul, 2002.

Dülger, Murat Volkan, Bilişim Suçları, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2004.

Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Avrupa Konseyi ve Avrupa Birliği Düzenlemelerinde Çocuk Pornografisinin İnternet Aracılığıyla Yayılmasına Karşı Yapılan Düzenlemeler”, İBD, İstanbul, S:4, 2004, s.1485-1496.

Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi”, Türk Ceza Kanunu Tasarısı: Türk Ceza Hukuku Derneği Toplantısı (10 Temmuz 2004): İstanbul Barosu-Türk Ceza Hukuku Derneği Toplantısı (10 Eylül 2004): Kurumsal Raporlar- Toplantılara Sunulan Raporlar-Bilimsel Raporlar, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu-Galatasaray Üniversitesi-Türk Ceza Hukuku Derneği Ortak Yayını, 2004, s.109-113.

Özel, Cevat, “Bilişim Suçları İle İletişim Faaliyetleri Yönünden Türk Ceza Kanunu Tasarısı”, İBD, İstanbul, C: LXXV, S: 7-8-9, Eylül 2001, s.858-872.

Raman, Jari, “Computer Crime” (Çevrimiçi) http://www.urova.fi/home/oiffi/enlist/ commentary/ computer crime. html, 21.12.2004.

Sokullu Akıncı, Füsun, “Avrupa Konseyi Siber Suç Sözleşmesi’nde Yer Alan Maddi Ceza Hukukuna İlişkin Düzenlemeler ve İnternette Çocuk Pornografisi” İÜHFM, İstanbul, C:LIX S:1-2, 2001, s.11-38.

Ünver, Yener, “Türk Ceza Kanunu’nun ve Ceza Kanunu Tasarısının İnternet Açısından Değerlendirilmesi”, İÜHFM, C:LIX S:1-2, İstanbul, 2001, s.51-153.

Yazıcıoğlu, Yılmaz, “Bilişim Suçları Konusunda 2001 Türk Ceza Kanunu Tasarısının Değerlendirilmesi”, Hukuk ve Adalet: Eleştirel Hukuk Dergisi, İstanbul, Y:1, S:1, Ocak- Mart 2004, s.172-185.

Footnotes

  1. Murat Volkan Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2004, s.212. ↑
  2. Yılmaz Yazıcıoğlu, “Bilişim Suçları Konusunda 2001 Türk Ceza Kanunu Tasarısının Değerlendirilmesi”, Hukuk ve Adalet: Eleştirel Hukuk Dergisi, İstanbul, Y:1, S:1, Ocak-Mart 2004, s.177. ↑
  3. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.213. ↑
  4. Berrin Akbulut, “Türk Ceza Hukukunda Bilişim Suçları”, Yayınlanmamış Doktora Tezi (Selçuk Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Kamu Hukuku Anabilim Dalı Ceza ve Ceza Usul Hukuku Bilim Dalı), Konya, 1999, s.78; Olgun Değirmenci, “Bilişim Suçları”, Yayınlanmamış Yüksek Lisans Tezi (Marmara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Hukuk Anabilim Dalı Kamu Hukuku Bilim Dalı), İstanbul, 2002, s.153; Yazıcıoğlu, a.g.y., s.177. ↑
  5. Murat Volkan Dülger, “Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi”, Türk Ceza Kanunu Tasarısı: Türk Ceza Hukuku Derneği Toplantısı (10 Temmuz 2004): İstanbul Barosu-Türk Ceza Hukuku Derneği Toplantısı (10 Eylül 2004): Kurumsal Raporlar-Toplantılara Sunulan Raporlar-Bilimsel Raporlar, İstanbul, İstanbul Barosu-Galatasaray Üniversitesi-Türk Ceza Hukuku Derneği Ortak Yayını, 2004, s.111. ↑
  6. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.230. ↑
  7. Yazıcıoğlu, a.g.y., s.179; Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.230. ↑
  8. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.230,231. For the opposing view see: Cevat Özel, “Bilişim Suçları İle İletişim Faaliyetleri Yönünden Türk Ceza Kanunu Tasarısı”, İBD, İstanbul, C:LXXV, S:7-8-9, Eylül 2001, s.860,865; Değirmenci, a.g.e., s.154; Yazıcıoğlu, a.g.y., s.179. ↑
  9. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.244. ↑
  10. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.244. ↑
  11. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.250. ↑
  12. Yazıcıoğlu, a.g.y., s.182; Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.250. ↑
  13. “In fact, it has been considered appropriate to make these acts, which embrace the ratio legis of all of the offences of theft, fraud, abuse of trust and forgery, into independent offences, in order to prevent hesitation and divergences in the case law.” ↑
  14. Özel, a.g.y., s.862; Değirmenci, a.g.e., s.158, 159, Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.251. ↑
  15. “The article has been drafted with the aim of preventing banks or credit holders from being caused loss through the unlawful use of bank or credit cards and benefit from being obtained in this way, and of punishing the perpetrators.” ↑
  16. Özel, a.g.y., s.865; Değirmenci, a.g.e., s.156, 157. ↑
  17. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.267. ↑
  18. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.267. ↑
  19. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.267. ↑
  20. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.276. ↑
  21. Özel, a.g.y., s.865; Değirmenci, a.g.e., s.157. ↑
  22. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.281. ↑
  23. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.332; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.109. ↑
  24. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.332. ↑
  25. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.332,333; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.109. ↑
  26. Yener Ünver, “Türk Ceza Kanunu’nun ve Ceza Kanunu Tasarısının İnternet Açısından Değerlendirilmesi”, İÜHFM, İstanbul, C:LIX S:1-2, 2001, s.106,107; Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.333. ↑
  27. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.333; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.111. ↑
  28. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.333; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.111. ↑
  29. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.333; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.112. ↑
  30. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.333,334; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.112. ↑
  31. Ünver, a.g.y., s.99. ↑
  32. Ünver, a.g.y., s.101. ↑
  33. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.336,337. ↑
  34. Jari Raman, “Computer Crime” (Çevrimiçi) http://www.urova.fi/home/oiffi/enlist/commentary/ computer crime. html, 21.12.2004; Füsun Sokullu Akıncı, “Avrupa Konseyi Siber Suç Sözleşmesi’nde Yer Alan Maddi Ceza Hukukuna İlişkin Düzenlemeler ve İnternette Çocuk Pornografisi” İÜHFM, İstanbul, C:LIX S:1-2, 2001, s.37; Hüseyin Çeken, Council of Europe’s Convention 2001 on Cybercrimes and Turkey, Unpublished Master of Science Thesis (University of Marmara European Community Institute Law of European Union), İstanbul, 2003, s.56. ↑
  35. Murat Volkan Dülger, “Avrupa Konseyi ve Avrupa Birliği Düzenlemelerinde Çocuk Pornografisinin İnternet Aracılığıyla Yayılmasına Karşı Yapılan Düzenlemeler”, İBD, İstanbul, S:4, 2004, s.1485, 1486. ↑
  36. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.337; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.111. ↑
  37. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.337; Dülger, Bilişim Suçlarına İlişkin Düzenlemelerin Eleştirisi, s.113. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic