2019Murat Volkan DülgerPresentation / talk

Abstract

In 2008, medical experts around the world gathered in Istanbul to define the standards on organ transplantation and preventing organ trafficking under the leadership of the Transplantation Society and The International Society of Nephorology. At the end of meeting, they agreed on a bunch of principles which is called as Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism to advise countries to take steps by preparing legislation which can lead to encourage states to transplant from deceased and living organism.

Although the Declaration is not binding document from legal aspect, it is prominent for standardization on transplantation. by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability, or of the giving to, or the receiving by, a third party of payments or benefits to achieve the transfer of control over the potential donor, for the purpose of exploitation by the removal of organs for transplantationaccepts that as organ trafficking by being compatible with article 4/b of Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs.

Text of the presentation

This text is a short prose version of the presentation. The slides, images and tables are in the PDF version.

This presentation was given at the ITN Technical Workshop on Organ Donation and Transplantation, held in Istanbul from 29 May to 1 June 2019. It reviews the international instruments on organ trafficking, the changes brought by the 2018 version of the Declaration of Istanbul, and the approach of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK).

International legal instruments

The Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (1997) allows the removal of organs and tissues from living donors for transplantation. Its Article 21, however, prohibits financial gain: the human body and its parts shall not, as such, give rise to financial gain. The Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime (2000), and the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings (2005) were not drafted specifically to prevent organ trafficking. Even so, the illicit “removal of organs” referred to in Article 4 is accepted as human trafficking and must be punished.

The Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs (2015) sets out which acts should be criminalised. Article 4 covers the illicit removal of human organs: removal without the free, informed and specific consent of the living or deceased donor or, for a deceased donor, without authorisation under domestic law; and removal where the living donor or a third party has been offered or has received a financial gain or comparable advantage, or, for a deceased donor, where a third party has. Article 5 covers the use of illicitly removed organs for implantation or for other purposes, such as scientific research, the collection of organs or tissues (for example removing a cardiac valve from a heart) or illicit cellular therapy. Under Article 6, each Party shall consider criminalising implantation performed outside its domestic transplantation system or in breach of essential principles of national transplantation law. Article 7 concerns the solicitation and recruitment of donors or recipients for financial gain or comparable advantage, and the offering or requesting of undue advantages by or to healthcare professionals, public officials and persons working for private sector entities in connection with such removals or implantations. Article 8 covers the preparation, preservation, storage, transportation, transfer, receipt, import and export of illicitly removed organs, and Article 9 extends criminal liability to aiding or abetting and attempt.

The Declaration of Istanbul

In 2008 medical experts from around the world met in Istanbul under the leadership of the Transplantation Society and the International Society of Nephrology to set standards on organ transplantation and the prevention of organ trafficking. The principles they agreed on became known as the Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism. The Declaration advises countries to adopt legislation encouraging transplantation from deceased and living donors. It is not legally binding, but it is important for standardisation in transplantation and it sets out principles that distinguish organ trafficking from organ transplantation.

The Declaration has five aims: to maximise the use of deceased donor organs; to encourage countries with established deceased or living donor programmes to share their knowledge with countries that lack them; to protect vulnerable populations from abuse; to ensure the equitable allocation of donor organs based on sound ethical principles; and to prevent organ trafficking. It also defines key terms. Transplant commercialism is a policy or practice in which an organ is treated as a commodity, including by being bought, sold or used for material gain. Travel for transplantation is the movement of organs, donors, recipients or transplant professionals across jurisdictional borders for transplantation purposes. It becomes transplant tourism if it involves organ trafficking or transplant commercialism, or if the resources devoted to patients from outside a country undermine that country's ability to provide transplant services to its own population.

What the 2018 version changed

The most significant change is that quid pro quo transplantation is now also treated as trafficking. Under the 2008 version, removal of an organ with the donor's consent was not regarded as illicit. The donor had to be a victim of trafficking, for example through the threat or use of force or other coercion, abduction, fraud, deception, abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability, or payments or benefits given to a third party to gain control over the potential donor. The 2018 version treats removal in exchange for a financial gain or comparable advantage as organ trafficking, in line with Article 4(b) of the Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs. In our view, this is also consistent with human dignity and with the aim of protecting public health.

The 2018 version widened the definition of organ trafficking, in line with the Council of Europe Convention. It now covers removing organs without valid consent or authorisation, or in exchange for financial gain or comparable advantage to the donor or a third person; any transportation, manipulation, transplantation or other use of such organs; offering undue advantages to, or requests for them by, healthcare professionals, public officials or employees of private sector entities to facilitate or perform such removal or use; soliciting or recruiting donors or recipients for financial gain or comparable advantage; and attempting, aiding or abetting any of these acts. It also added a separate category, trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal, which covers the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons by coercive or deceptive means, or by payments to obtain the consent of a person having control over another, for the purpose of removing organs.

A further new criterion is the distinction between residents and non-residents. A resident is a person who makes their life within a country, whether or not as a citizen; all others are non-residents, including those who travel to a country and reside there temporarily to obtain a transplant. This helps to identify transplant tourism. Travel for transplantation is now the movement of persons across jurisdictional borders for transplantation purposes. It becomes transplant tourism, and thus unethical, if it involves either form of trafficking or if resources devoted to non-resident patients undermine the country's ability to serve its own population. “Jurisdictional” refers not only to nations but also to states, provinces, other formally defined areas within countries, and regional or supra-national entities with authority to regulate organ donation and transplantation.

An example from the Turkish Criminal Code

Article 91 of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK), on trading of organs and tissues, punishes taking an organ from another person without lawful consent with imprisonment from five to nine years; where the act concerns tissue, the penalty is imprisonment from two to five years. Unlawfully taking an organ or tissue from a deceased person is punished with imprisonment of up to one year. Anyone who buys or sells an organ or tissue, or acts as an intermediary, receives the penalties in the first subsection. A person forced by circumstances to sell his or her own organ is still a perpetrator. However, Article 92 provides that the punishment may be reduced or entirely lifted in view of the social and economic conditions of the person selling the organs or tissues.

Is criminal law the only way?

In our view, criminalising and punishing these acts is not enough to combat organ trafficking and illicit transplantation. An efficient donation system must also be established, so that people are not driven to such means. New methods such as stem cell therapy should be used to reduce the need for organ transplantation.

Download PDF

More publications on this topic