Introduction
This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.
The “Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry” was published in Official Gazette No. 30286 on 30 December 2017. Those who follow the field of personal data protection had been awaiting it with interest, and it contains extensive provisions on the Data Controllers’ Registry first provided for in Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK). The date of entry into force of the Regulation was set as 1 January 2018. It should be said at the outset that the concept of the Data Controllers’ Registry was already present in the KVKK before this Regulation. Under Article 16 of the Law: “A Data Controllers’ Registry open to the public shall be kept by the Presidency under the supervision of the Board.”
This article of the Law thus imposed an obligation both on the Personal Data Protection Board to keep a Data Controllers’ Registry and on natural and legal persons who process personal data to register with it. Paragraph 2 of the same article of the Law provides that the Board may introduce exceptions to this requirement, and paragraph 3 sets out what an application for registration with the Data Controllers’ Registry must contain. Lastly, by stating in paragraph 5 of the same article that the other procedures and principles relating to the Data Controllers’ Registry would be laid down by regulation, the Law gave an indication that the Regulation examined here would be issued. To understand the importance of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry, the sanctions provided for in the Law must also be mentioned.
Full text
This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.
Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*
The “Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry”, which had been eagerly awaited by those who follow the field of personal data protection and which contains comprehensive provisions on the Data Controllers’ Registry first provided for in Law No. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (KVKK), was published in the Official Gazette No. 30286 of 30 December 2017. The date of entry into force of the Regulation was set as 1 January 2018.
It must be stated at the outset that the concept of the Data Controllers’ Registry was already contained in Law No. 6698 before the Regulation in question. According to Article 16 of the Law, “A Data Controllers’ Registry open to the public shall be kept by the Presidency under the supervision of the Board.” The article of the Law thus imposed an obligation both on the Personal Data Protection Board, as regards the keeping of a Data Controllers’ Registry, and on the natural and legal persons who process personal data, as regards registration with the Registry.
Paragraph 2 of the same article of the Law provides that the Board may introduce exceptions to this obligation, and paragraph 3 sets out the particulars that an application for registration with the Data Controllers’ Registry must contain. Finally, by stating in paragraph 5 of the same article that the other procedures and principles concerning the Data Controllers’ Registry are to be laid down by regulation, the Law gave a hint that the Regulation which is the subject of our examination today would be issued.
In order to understand the importance of the obligation to register with the Data Controllers’ Registry, the sanctions provided for in the Law must also be mentioned. Article 18 of the Law, entitled ‘Misdemeanours’, provides that an administrative fine of 20,000 Turkish liras to 1,000,000 Turkish liras shall be imposed on those who act in breach of the obligation of registration with and notification to the Data Controllers’ Registry. As can be seen, this amount is very high, and care must be taken in this regard.
Lastly on this subject, the Law lists ensuring that the Data Controllers’ Registry is kept among the duties of the Board in Article 22, headed Duties and Powers of the Board, and keeping the Data Controllers’ Registry among the duties of the Presidency in Article 25, headed Formation and Duties of the Presidency.
Thus, although Law No. 6698 regulated in outline matters such as the keeping of the Data Controllers’ Registry, the obligation to register with the Registry and the sanction for acting in breach of that obligation, it did not deal with the subject broadly and comprehensively; it provided that the other procedures and principles concerning the Registry would be determined by the Regulation.
As I stated above, the Regulation in question was published on 30 December 2017; below, as in my other studies on the subject, I shall set out under headings, and assess, what the Regulation has introduced by way of new provisions and concepts, the changes made and the points that require attention.
Purpose, Scope and Legal Basis
The purpose of the Regulation is to determine, and to ensure the application of, the procedures and principles concerning the establishment and administration of the Data Controllers’ Registry, which is to be kept by the Presidency open to the public, and the entries to be made in the Data Controllers’ Registry. The answers to many questions that come to mind, such as how the Registry will be established, how it will be kept by the Presidency or how the application is to be made by those under the obligation to register, ought therefore to be found in this Regulation. In matters not determined in the Regulation, however, Law No. 6698 must be taken as the basis and action taken accordingly.
As to whom the Regulation concerns: while it is of course of interest to many people who carry out academic work in the field of personal data protection or who manage compliance processes, it is of importance principally for the persons who are under the obligation to register with the Registry in question. Article 2 of the Regulation refers to controllers by stating that the natural and legal persons who determine the purposes and means of the processing of personal data and who are responsible for the establishment and management of the data filing system fall within its scope. For the obligation to register with the Registry rests with controllers.
The legal basis for the drawing up and publication of the Regulation is constituted by the articles of Law No. 6698 relating to the Data Controllers’ Registry and, in particular, by paragraph 5 of Article 16.
Definitions
In Article 4 of the Regulation, entitled ‘Definitions’, we see that new concepts introduced in the field of personal data protection, or concepts which we had encountered before but which had not been defined, are now defined. Accordingly:
Contact person denotes “the natural person notified by the controller at the time of registration with the Registry for the purpose of the communication to be established with the Authority in connection with the obligations, under the Law and the secondary legislation to be issued on the basis of this Law, of legal persons established in Türkiye and of the representative of a legal-person controller not established in Türkiye”.
As this definition shows, when making the notification of the application for registration with the Registry, the controller will designate a contact person to communicate with the Authority in connection with its obligations as laid down by the Law and by the secondary legislation to be issued on the basis of the Law. This covers, alongside legal persons established in Türkiye, the representatives of legal-person controllers not established in Türkiye as well.
Registered electronic mail (KEP) address means “the qualified form of electronic mail which provides legal evidence concerning the use of electronic messages, including their sending and delivery”. This concept, too, appears for the first time in this Regulation. The KEP address, which is among the information contained in the Registry, is, as I shall explain in detail under the following articles, one of the items of information that may be disclosed to the public by the Board, and it is used by the Authority for the purpose of contacting the controller.
Data category means “the class of personal data belonging to the data subject group or groups in which personal data are grouped according to their common characteristics”. The concept of data category had previously appeared in Law No. 6698, among the particulars to be included in the application for registration with the Registry, and in the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data, which we refer to in short as the Destruction Regulation, as one of the parameters to be included in the personal data inventory; it had not, however, been defined. It is therefore an apt innovation in terms of clarifying the concept; I shall touch on the importance of the category to which data belong below, in the context of the relevant articles.
Data subject group denotes “the category of data subjects whose personal data are processed by controllers”. This concept, too, had previously appeared in Law No. 6698 and in the Destruction Regulation, but it has been clarified by this Regulation.
One of the concepts that appear for the first time in the Regulation is the Data Controllers’ Registry Information System (VERBİS). Accordingly, “the information system, accessible via the internet and created and managed by the Presidency, which controllers are to use in applying to the Registry and in the other relevant transactions concerning the Registry” is called the Data Controllers’ Registry Information System. On this point it is provided that controllers will apply to the Registry by means of an information system created by the Presidency. This system, called the Data Controllers’ Registry Information System, will be used not only for the application but also in the other transactions concerning the Data Controllers’ Registry. VERBİS has been designed as a system created and managed by the Presidency.
Controller’s representative denotes “the legal person established in Türkiye or the natural person who is a citizen of the Republic of Türkiye authorised to represent, at a minimum, controllers not established in Türkiye in the matters specified in the second paragraph of Article 11 of this Regulation”. The controller’s representative is also one of the concepts that we had seen earlier in Law No. 6698 but that are defined by this Regulation. In Law No. 6698 the controller’s representative is listed, under the heading of the controller’s obligation to inform, among the information that must be given to data subjects, and is provided for among the information to be included in the application for registration with the Registry. The controller’s representative is also mentioned where the adoption of regulatory acts concerning the duties, powers and responsibilities of the controller and its representative is listed among the duties and powers of the Board.
With the Regulation the concept in question has been defined, and it has been stated that the person to be appointed, with a minimum power of representation, to fulfil the obligations of legal-person controllers not established in Türkiye that are specified in the relevant articles will be called the controller’s representative.
Establishment, Administration and Supervision of the Registry and Access to the Registry
Chapter Two of the Regulation regulates the establishment, administration and supervision of the Registry and access to the Registry, together with the principles, procedures and rules to be observed in these cases.
According to Article 5 of the Regulation, with regard to the establishment, administration and supervision of the Registry,
• that controllers are obliged to register with the Registry before they start processing personal data,
• that controllers not established in Türkiye are obliged to register with the Registry through a controller’s representative before they start processing data,
• that the principle of ‘openness to the public’ is fundamental in the keeping of the Registry and that the Board is authorised to determine the scope of and the exceptions to this principle in a manner that does not impede its realisation,
• that the information to be disclosed to the Registry in the application for registration with the Registry must be prepared on the basis of the personal data inventory,
• that, in determining the obligation to inform imposed on controllers by the Law, the answering of data subjects’ applications and the scope of the explicit consent to be given by data subjects, the information submitted to the Registry on the basis of the inventory and published in the Registry must be taken as the basis,
• that controllers are responsible for ensuring that the information submitted to the Registry and published in the Registry is complete, accurate, up to date and lawful, and that registration with the Registry does not extinguish the other obligations,
• that, for controllers whom the Board does not hold subject to registration with the Registry on the basis of Article 16 of the Regulation, which sets out the exceptions and which I shall examine below, the other obligations under the Law are not extinguished,
• that the transactions concerning the Registry are to be carried out by controllers via VERBİS,
• that the maximum period necessary for the purpose for which personal data are processed is to be taken as the basis in the fulfilment of controllers’ obligations to erase, destroy or anonymise personal data
are the principles, procedures and rules that have been set out. In this way the obligation of controllers, and of legal persons not established in Türkiye as well, through a representative, to register with the Registry has been underlined once again after the Law. By not allowing provisions to be made that would run counter to the principle of openness to the public, the importance of the Registry being kept open to the public has been addressed.
The fact that the information to be disclosed in the application for registration with the Registry must be consistent with the personal data inventory, and that this information is to be taken as the basis in determining the scope of the other obligations imposed on controllers, demonstrates the importance of the personal data inventory. At this point, in order not to encounter problems in registration with the Registry and in the other transactions concerning the Registry, the personal data inventory must be drawn up accurately, comprehensively and in such a way as to include various parameters, taking into account the particular structures of the controllers themselves. Otherwise, not only will it be impossible to speak of full compliance with the Law, but certain problems may also be encountered at later stages because the inventory has not been kept correctly. For this reason I strongly underline that controllers, and companies in particular, must be careful in their processes of compliance with the Law.
What is to be understood by controllers being responsible for the information in the Registry is the requirement that controllers provide accurate and complete information in the application for registration and, in addition, give notification where a new situation arises or where the existing situation changes or ceases to exist. Although it can be inferred from Article 5 that these notifications, too, will be made via the VERBİS system to be used in conducting the transactions relating to the Registry, this is expressly stated in the subsequent articles.
In Article 6 of the Regulation, entitled ‘Establishment, administration and supervision of the Registry’, the establishment and administration of the Registry are entrusted to the Presidency and its supervision to the Board. Accordingly, the obligation to take every kind of administrative and technical measure necessary for setting up and operating VERBİS, for the purpose of establishing, administering, keeping up to date and preserving the Registry to be established by the Presidency, rests with the Presidency. The service unit responsible for the establishment and administration of the Registry is the Data Management Department. Accordingly, the purpose of VERBİS, which is to be set up and operated by the Presidency, is to make the administration of the Registry possible. It is also stated that the Data Management Department is the responsible service unit. Although the unit in question had not been mentioned before, Article 25 of the Law had stated that the Presidency would perform the duties assigned to it by the Law through service units organised in the form of departments. For this reason, in addition to the fact that the innovations are introduced in parallel with the Law and that matters previously stated in the Law are clarified, I find it important and appropriate that the Registry Regulation determines which unit is responsible for the establishment and administration of the Registry.
The step following the establishment and administration of the Registry is envisaged as its supervision, and the obligation to carry out this supervision is placed on the Board. The procedure by which the supervision is to be carried out is also explained in the same paragraph. Accordingly, supervision will be carried out by means of activity reports, the scope of which is to be determined by the Board and which are to be prepared by the Data Management Department at three-monthly intervals. The supervision of the Registry is important for the Registry being kept up to date and preserved. For even if the Registry is established and administered correctly, it cannot continue in the form in which it was established. The existing situation changes constantly, and for this reason the Registry must be reviewed at regular intervals in order to be kept up to date. For example, in order that changes such as innovations in the data categories in the personal data inventory or the addition of a new one to the recipient groups to which personal data may be transferred, which are among the matters that must be stated in the application for registration with the Registry, are present in the Registry in up-to-date form, it is important that supervision is carried out correctly and regularly.
It may be said that Article 7 of the Regulation has been drafted as an extension of the principle of “openness to the public”. After stating that the up-to-date information in the Registry will be disclosed to the public by the Presidency by the method to be determined by decisions of the Board, the article lists one by one which information will be disclosed. When we look at the information to be disclosed to the public, we see that, compared with the particulars listed in Article 16 of the Law that must be included in the application for registration with the Registry, there is a large degree of similarity. The Regulation provides that, in addition to these, the KEP address, the date of registration with the Registry and the date on which the registration ended will also be disclosed.
The principle of openness to the public means that, unless otherwise provided for in the laws, public officials do not perform their duties in secret and that they act transparently and publicly in performing them. The fundamental principle of the KVKK and of personal data protection law is that the natural person who is the real owner of the personal data that are recorded, processed and transferred has control over these data and that the right to determine the future of these data lies with that person. For this to be possible, however, it must first be determined by whom the data in question are recorded, processed and transferred. Since there is as yet no institutional culture in this sense in our country, the principle has been adopted that the Registry in question is to be established with this information and is to be open to the public. Yet the registry in question was abolished as an obligation in 2016 by the EU regulation, the GDPR, on which this legislation was modelled. Since our country has not yet matured in this sense, I regard the keeping of a Registry and the keeping of the information contained in the Registry open to the public as an appropriate and positive provision.
Commencement of the Registration Obligation, Information to be Entered in VERBİS, Application for Registration,
Renewal and Deletion of the Registration
Article 8 of the Regulation, entitled ‘Commencement of the registration obligation’, regulates the time limits by which controllers are bound in fulfilling their obligations to register with the Registry. Accordingly, first, controllers who are under the registration obligation must fulfil their obligation to register with the Registry before they start processing personal data. Controllers who are not under the registration obligation but subsequently become subject to it must register with the Registry within thirty days of becoming subject to the obligation. At this stage the point in time taken as the basis for the commencement of registration is the moment at which personal data are processed.
Paragraph 3 of the article clarifies what controllers who do not fulfil the registration obligation because of any factual, technical or legal impossibility are to do. According to the article, in such cases controllers may request an additional period from the Authority, provided that they state their reasons to the Authority in writing within seven working days at the latest of the date on which the impossibility in question arose. The Authority, for its part, may grant an additional period of thirty days at most, on one occasion only. Although it is not expressly stated at this point whether the controllers who may request an additional period include those who were not subject to the obligation at the outset but became so later, I think that the possibility of requesting an additional period may be relied on in both situations.
I must, however, state my reservation regarding the time limit. There are at present thousands of controllers in our country who hold, process and transfer personal data. In my view, the failure to lay down a transitional provision for them is extremely objectionable. For although Law No. 6698 and the related Regulations have been duly promulgated and have entered into force, the public has not been sufficiently informed on this subject. As I also know from practice, a great many controllers do not even know that they are controllers, let alone that they are under an obligation in this regard. I am therefore of the opinion that, first of all, public awareness on this subject needs to be created. Secondly, since the Regulation entered into force on 1 January 2018 and since the Regulation provides for a period of thirty days, controllers who at present hold and process data and controllers who will start to hold and process data in the meantime will have to complete their registration with the Registry within this period. Since it is provided that the registration in question and the subsequent transactions are to be carried out via VERBİS, VERBİS must already be operational and must have the technical infrastructure capable of handling a large number of applications. Yet as of 1 January no link for access to this system had yet been provided on the Authority’s website. Consequently, with regard to controllers who at present hold and process data, a provision on the time limit must be made or, at the very least, no administrative fine should be imposed on this ground until a certain date.
Article 9 of the Regulation, entitled ‘Information to be submitted within the scope of the registration obligation’, is of considerable importance and requires attention. First, paragraph 1 of the article lists one by one the information that the application for registration with the Registry must contain. The same matter, however, had already been listed in Law No. 6698, and we see that, apart from a few minor additions, the paragraph is identical to the Law. The Regulation is new in that, alongside the information on the controller and its representative, the information on the contact person is also to be submitted and, further, in that this information must fall within the information contained in the application form to be determined by the Board. In addition, whereas the Law speaks only of the maximum period necessary for the purpose for which the data are processed, the Regulation provides for two different periods, namely the maximum retention period prescribed in the legislation or necessary for the purpose for which they are processed.
The article goes on to specify and explain one by one which information is to be submitted and in what manner. First of all, it is clear from the article that the information on the controller, its representative, if any, and the contact person is to be filled in by means of the application form. Although it is not expressly stated, I anticipate that the application form, too, will be submitted via VERBİS. If another method (in writing, etc.) is envisaged for this, I think it would be better for that to be expressly stated in the Regulation. Whatever the method, however, it is stated that this application will be made in a uniform manner in accordance with the application form to be determined by the Board. It is then stated that the information on the purpose for which personal data will be processed, the explanations concerning the data subject group and groups and the data categories belonging to these persons, the recipient or recipient groups to which personal data may be transferred and the personal data envisaged to be transferred to foreign countries will be submitted to the Registry via VERBİS. In addition, the measures taken with regard to data security will likewise be submitted via VERBİS, in a manner that also covers Article 12 of the Law, which regulates the controller’s obligations concerning data security.
Finally, the maximum retention period for personal data prescribed in the legislation or necessary for the purpose for which they are processed is also among the information that must be included in the application for registration with the Registry. This matter is of considerable importance for controllers. For it is of great importance to the controller for how long it may retain the personal data it processes. In order to determine these periods, once the data categories have been properly identified in the personal data inventory, it must be examined which legislation prescribes what kind of periods for which data category. This is not an easy process and requires many different matters to be assessed together.
Paragraph 4 of Article 9 of the Regulation guides us precisely at this point. The paragraph first states the requirement that the information on the maximum retention period for personal data prescribed in the legislation or necessary for the purpose for which they are processed be notified to the Registry matched with the data categories. Which data the controller will retain for how long is therefore an important matter that must be determined and notified. It is possible, however, that the purposes of processing of the data categories notified to the Registry by the controller, and the maximum retention periods necessary for their processing on the basis of those purposes, differ from the periods prescribed in the legislation. For that eventuality it is provided that, if a maximum retention period is prescribed in the legislation, that prescribed period, and otherwise the longest of these periods, is to be taken as the basis for the notification to the Registry in respect of that data category. I must say that there is a confusion of meaning in this sentence of the article. For if there is no period in the legislation, it cannot be fully understood what is meant by the words ‘of these’ occurring in the sentence. I think that what is meant here is that, where there is more than one purpose in the processing of the data and where, accordingly, the maximum retention periods necessary for their processing on the basis of those purposes differ from one another, the longest of these periods must be taken as the basis. It would be appropriate for this confusion of meaning to be removed. In determining the retention period for personal data,
• the period accepted as a matter of general custom in the sector in which the controller operates, within the scope of the purpose of processing the data category concerned,
• the period for which the legal relationship established with the data subject, which makes it necessary to process the personal data in the data category concerned, will continue,
• the period for which the legitimate interest to be obtained by the controller, depending on the purpose of processing the data category concerned, will be valid in accordance with the law and the rules of good faith,
• the period for which the risks, costs and responsibilities that will be created by storing the data category concerned, depending on the purpose of its processing, will legally continue,
• whether the maximum period to be determined is suitable for keeping the data category concerned accurate and, where necessary, up to date,
• the period for which the controller is obliged, by virtue of its legal obligation, to store the personal data in the data category concerned,
• the limitation period determined by the controller for the assertion of a right connected with the personal data in the data category concerned,
are the criteria that will be taken into account. As can be seen, the determination of the retention period for personal data has, “as it should be”, not been made subject to very strict conditions as far as controllers are concerned. By stating that the data may be retained for the period necessary, provided that this is in keeping with the purpose for which they are processed, the interest of controllers has also been taken into account. The acceptance of the period of general custom is the clearest indication that the aim of the legislation in question is not to prevent the processing of personal data. For there is no wish to disrupt the existing order; the principal aim adopted is to bring the processing of personal data into conformity with the law. The fact that controllers may retain the data for the period during which their legitimate interest is valid, provided that this is in accordance with the law and the rules of good faith, likewise shows that the interest of controllers has been taken into account. Moreover, if the controller legally bears responsibility for risk and cost in connection with storing the personal data it processes, the controller will also be able to store the personal data it processes for as long as this risk continues. In this case, too, it has been borne in mind that the personal data processed by controllers may need to be stored against risks that may arise, and there has been no wish to place the controller in a difficult position. All that is required is that this period be determined correctly and in accordance with the law.
What must be done to supervise this and to monitor the periods, once controllers have submitted the necessary information to the Registry on the basis of the personal data inventory, is also explained, in paragraph 6 of the article. Accordingly, “Controllers shall prepare a personal data retention and destruction policy, and ensure the implementation of this policy, in order to determine the maximum period necessary for the purpose for which personal data are processed, to ensure that these periods are consistent with the information stated in the personal data processing inventory and to monitor whether the maximum period has been exceeded.” It may be said that this paragraph essentially runs parallel to the Destruction Regulation. Article 5 of the Destruction Regulation had likewise provided for a data retention and destruction policy to be prepared in conformity with the personal data inventory. I regard it as positive that consistency and coherence are ensured in the personal data protection legislation in this way.
The last paragraph of the article states that, where the headings in VERBİS cannot fully cover the data categories, the information to be submitted is to be submitted under the heading ‘Other’. For notification to the Registry is to be made under the headings and content contained in VERBİS. It is natural that, at this stage, it has not been possible to provide separate headings for each data category.
Application for registration
Article 10 of the Regulation states that the registration obligation is fulfilled when this information, which is listed in Article 9 and must be submitted to the Registry, is uploaded to VERBİS. The controller thus fulfils its registration obligation by uploading the information in question to VERBİS and need not carry out any further transaction. Controllers who have been granted an additional period by the Board must likewise complete the registration by the end of that period. The reservations I have expressed above regarding the time limit must not, however, be forgotten.
Obligations of the controller, the controller’s representative and the contact person
Article 11 of the Regulation is important in that it gives a clear answer to many questions that have been on people’s minds. First of all, although it was known that the controller is the legal person itself, it was a source of confusion who would fulfil the obligations arising from the Law and the regulations and who would be held responsible for these obligations. According to paragraph 1 of the article, which clarifies this matter, “The controller obligations under the Law of legal persons established in Türkiye shall be fulfilled through the body authorised under the relevant legislative provisions to represent and bind the legal person, or through the person or persons specified in the relevant legislation.” Here we see clearly that, in the case of companies, it is the Board of Directors that is under the obligation. For the paragraph goes on to state that this assignment may be made to one or more persons. The Board of Directors may therefore assign one or more persons to fulfil the obligations in this regard. Although the Regulation does not say so, under the general principles of company law and the Turkish Commercial Code (TTK) this assignment must take the form of a resolution of the Board of Directors and be in writing. In this way, ease of proof is also ensured with regard to disputes that may arise in the future.
I had stated that a controller’s representative, authorised at a minimum level, would be appointed to fulfil the obligations of controllers not established in Türkiye. A certified copy of the appointment decision to be taken by the competent body or person concerning the appointment of this controller’s representative, provided that it contains the minimum particulars specified further on in the article, must be submitted to the Board by the controller’s representative at the time of the application for registration.
Paragraphs 4 and 5 of the article also set out clearly the position of the contact person. For the contact person may be confused with the controller’s representative. On this point, the questions on the matter have been answered by the explanation that the contact person is not authorised to represent and is merely the person to be designated to ensure communication with regard to the answering of the requests which data subjects address to the controller.
Ensuring communication, changes in the registration information and deletion of the Registry entry
Article 12 of the Regulation regulates the channels through which the communication to be ensured between the Board and the controller will take place. Accordingly, for legal and natural persons established in Türkiye, the Board will communicate through the legal or natural person concerned by way of the identity, address or KEP address information notified to the Registry; for controllers not established in Türkiye, it will communicate through the controller’s representative notified to the Registry.
I stated above that the information recorded in the Registry must be up to date and that, in addition to controllers being responsible for keeping the information up to date, the Board too is obliged to ensure that the information in question is up to date. To ensure this, where there is a change in the recorded information, the changes that have occurred must be notified to the Authority via VERBİS within seven days.
Turning to the deletion of the Registry entry, Article 14 of the Regulation provides that the controller must likewise apply to the Authority via VERBİS in respect of the deletion of the Registry entry. The cases requiring deletion of the Registry entry are described as the termination or disappearance of the activity that gives rise to the registration obligation. Deleted entries will be accessible on request, but no changes may be made to them.
Exceptions to the Registration Obligation
Article 15 of the Regulation lists the activities which the controller is not obliged to enter in the Registry:
• Where the processing of personal data is necessary for the prevention of the commission of an offence or for a criminal investigation
Where the public prosecutor’s offices, which under the Code of Criminal Procedure (CMK) are responsible for conducting an investigation once an offence has been committed, and the law enforcement forces that assist them keep the personal data of suspects or of third persons from whom they obtain information (which is already the case at present; if these data are not recorded and/or processed, no criminal
investigation can be conducted), they need not register with the Registry. Similarly, it is a requirement of their duty that the police, who perform the function of preventive law enforcement, keep the personal data contained in the reports they receive. The police need not register with the Registry as controller in respect of these data.
• The processing of personal data that have been made public by the data subject himself
Where a person makes public a photograph of himself, or the records of the persons with whom he is in contact, by sharing them on social media, there is no longer an obligation to register with the Registry for the processing of these data.
• Where the processing of personal data is necessary for the performance of supervisory or regulatory duties, or for disciplinary investigation or prosecution, by the public institutions and organisations that are assigned and authorised on the basis of the power conferred by law and by professional organisations having the status of public institutions.
Personal data kept by the Social Security Institution, the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency, the Financial Crimes Investigation Board, the Bar Associations and other professional chambers fall within this scope.
• Where the processing of personal data is necessary for the protection of the economic and financial interests of the State in relation to budgetary, tax and financial matters.
The personal data of taxpayers that are recorded and processed by the Ministry of Finance fall within this scope.
Where these circumstances exist, there is no need to notify the data processing activities.
In addition to the activities which controllers are not obliged to have entered in the Registry, the Board may in certain cases grant controllers an exception. The criteria it will take into consideration in granting these exceptions are listed one by one in Article 16 of the Regulation. Accordingly, the Board, which will take into account the criteria of the nature of the personal data, their number, the purpose of processing, the field of activity in which they are processed, whether they are transferred to third parties, whether the processing activity arises from the laws, the retention period and the data subject group or data categories, has discretion to grant exceptions for controllers.
Administrative sanction
Article 17 of the Regulation, entitled “Administrative sanction”, refers to the Law in the following terms: “The administrative fine set out in sub-paragraph (ç) of the first paragraph of Article 18 of the Law shall be imposed on those who act in breach of the obligation of registration with and notification to the data controllers’ registry.” The penalty provided for in the relevant article of the Law is, as I stated at the outset, an administrative fine of 20,000 Turkish liras to 1,000,000 Turkish liras.
Main points and conclusion
• The Regulation, with the aim of determining the procedures and principles concerning the establishment and administration of the Data Controllers’ Registry and the entries to be made in the Data Controllers’ Registry,
has been drawn up so as to cover the natural and legal persons who determine the purposes and means of the processing of personal data and who are responsible for the establishment and management of the data filing system.
• The principal legal basis of the Regulation is constituted by the relevant provisions of Law No. 6698 and, in particular, by paragraph 5 of Article 16.
• The Regulation defines for the first time the concepts of contact person, registered electronic mail address, data category, data subject group, data controllers’ registry information system and controller’s representative.
• Article 5 of the Regulation lists the principles to be observed in establishing the registry and underlines such matters as that controllers not established in Türkiye will also register through a representative, the principle of openness to the public and the requirement that the information be consistent with the inventory. Attention must also be paid to the points that all transactions concerning the Registry will be carried out via VERBİS and that the maximum period necessary for the purpose for which the data are processed will be taken as the basis for the obligations under the Destruction Regulation.
• According to Article 6 of the Regulation, the Data Management Department, which is a service unit of the Presidency, is responsible for the establishment and administration of the Registry. The obligation to supervise the Registry rests with the Board.
• That the Registry is to be kept open to the public, and which information is to be shared with the public, are set out in Article 7 of the Regulation.
• According to Article 8, which regulates when the registration obligation commences, those subject to the obligation must fulfil the registration obligation before starting the processing activity, those who subsequently become subject to it within thirty days, and those who have been granted an additional period by the Board by the time that period expires. The failure to provide a transitional provision for those who are already processing data is, however, a significant shortcoming.
• Article 9 of the Regulation is of considerable importance, since it regulates which information is to be submitted to the Registry and in what manner. For this is the provision to which controllers must pay attention when fulfilling their registration obligation and which they must take as the basis at the time of the application.
• Indeed, the fact that Article 10 states that the obligation is fulfilled when the information specified in Article 9 is uploaded to the system is an indication of the importance of Article 9.
• Article 11 of the Regulation has clarified the concepts of controller, controller’s representative and contact person and has set out the obligations of these persons. It may be said to be another important article in that it has provided clear answers to a number of questions.
• Article 12 of the Regulation provides that the Authority will conduct its communication with the controller through the natural or legal person concerned or through the controller’s representative.
• Changes in the registration information and the deletion of the Registry entry will, according to Articles 13 and 14 of the Regulation, be effected by an application to be made via VERBİS.
• Even if the controller carries out the activities listed in Article 15 of the Regulation, it is not under an obligation to enter these activities in the Registry or to notify them. These are cases in which an exception applies.
• In addition to the cases in which an exception definitely applies, the Board has the power to grant exceptions to the registration obligation, provided that it takes into consideration the criteria listed in Article 16. These exception decisions will be announced to the public in an appropriate manner.
• By stating that the administrative fine provided for in Article 18 of the Law applies to those who act in breach of the obligation of registration with and notification to the data controllers’ registry, a provision parallel to the Law has been made.
• Article 18 provides that the Board is competent to decide, within the framework of the provisions of the legislation, on the resolution of doubts that may arise during the application of the Regulation.
• Article 19 of the Regulation sets the date of entry into force as 1 January 2018, and Article 20 states that the provisions of the Regulation shall be implemented by the President.
The fact that Law No. 6698, which is the basic instrument in the field of personal data protection and which entered into force on 7 April 2016, placed on controllers the responsibility of becoming compliant with the Law but set the matter out only as a general framework had raised many question marks. On the controllers’ side in particular, it had caused great panic to the effect that data could no longer be processed or used. Moreover, because there were as yet no other instruments, how the compliance process in question was to be carried out was a matter of great curiosity. The regulations published one after another in order to ensure compliance with the Law have provided significant guidance in this regard.
The latest stage in the developments in the field of personal data protection was the “Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry”, which was published on 30 December 2017, although those concerned had expected it to be published earlier. The fact that the data controllers’ registry was described in the Law in general outline and that the Law stated that this subject would be determined by Regulation already indicated that the Regulation in question would be issued. For although it was known that a data controllers’ registry would be established, many matters were uncertain, such as how and by whom application to the registry would be made, whether there would be cases in which an exception applied, what had to be done for the obligation to register with the registry to be fulfilled, and who was responsible for the establishment or supervision of the registry.
The Regulation on the Data Controllers’ Registry has been a very important development both because of its provisions running parallel to the Law and because it regulates the subject comprehensively and removes the uncertainties in this regard.
At no point does the Regulation contain provisions that would conflict with the Law; it has clarified matters that were stated in the Law but were not clear. The importance of this shows itself in the formation of personal data protection law. With the Law and the publication of regulations that are in this way in conformity with the Law, personal data protection law is taking shape over time.
In addition, I find it appropriate that the provisions of the Regulation are clear and that they provide guidance as to what is to be done and how. For because the subject is still not fully understood in our country, the unease of those under an obligation, in particular, persists.
The Regulation states clearly who is under the obligation to register with the data controllers’ registry, what principles and rules the Presidency, the Board and the controller must observe in the fulfilment of this obligation, which information is to be conveyed by controllers within the scope of the registration obligation and by what means and, finally, at what stage controllers have fulfilled their obligations. In doing so, the Regulation can be seen to protect and take into account the interests not only of the data subject but also of the controller. It is important in this respect that the controller’s interests are taken into account to a large extent in determining the retention periods for personal data and that controllers are granted exceptions in certain cases. For, as I also stated above, the aim of the Law is not to prevent the use or processing of personal data. Besides, even if there were such an aim, it could not be achieved today.
The principal aim sought to be achieved by the Law and the related regulations is to ensure that personal data are used and processed lawfully and in a manner that does not harm the rights of the data owner concerned. For this reason there is nothing for controllers, controllers’ representatives or contact persons to be uneasy about. What needs to be done is for controllers to fulfil the registration obligation within the time limits laid down by the Regulation and in accordance with the procedures and principles determined by the Regulation. Otherwise they will face the substantial administrative fines provided for in the Law.
Footnotes
- Academic, Attorney-at-law. Page 1 / 14 Page 2 / 14 Page 3 / 14 Page 4 / 14 Page 5 / 14 Page 6 / 14 Page 7 / 14 Page 8 / 14 Page 9 / 14 Page 10 / 14 Page 11 / 14 Page 12 / 14 Page 13 / 14 Page 14 / 14 ↑
Related practice areas
More publications on this topic
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Right to Be Forgotten” (Unutulma Hakkı), Essays in Honour of Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli (Prof. Dr. Yadigar İzmirli’ye Armağan), Savaş Publishing, Ankara, 2024, pp. 1019–1141.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Assessment of the Amendments to the KVK Law on the Processing of Special Categories of Personal Data and the Transfer of Data Abroad” (KVK Kanunu’nda Özel Nitelikli Kişisel Verilerin İşlenmesi ve Yurt Dışına Veri Aktarımı Kapsamında Yapılan Değişikliklere İlişkin Değerlendirmeler), Academia.edu, 25 March 2024.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “Our Assessment of the Decision Summaries Published by the Personal Data Protection Board on 18 July 2022” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulunun 18 Temmuz 2022 Tarihinde Yayınlanan Karar Özetlerine İlişkin Değerlendirmelerimiz), Dülger Law Office, 1 September 2022.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, “The Use of Personal Health Data as Evidence in Divorce Proceedings” (Kişisel Sağlık Verilerinin Boşanma Davasında Delil Olarak Kullanılması), Hukuk ve Daha Fazlası Dergisi (Law and More), No. 9, June 2022, pp. 76–84.
Dülger, Murat Volkan, “A Very Important Decision of the Personal Data Protection Board on Lawyers' Access to Enforcement Files Without a Power of Attorney” (Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulu’ndan Avukatların İcra Takip Dosyalarına Vekaletname Olmaksızın Erişebilmesine İlişkin Çok Önemli Bir Karar), Dülger Law Office, 15 August 2021.
Dülger, Murat Volkan / Gümüş, Gülçin, Personal Data Protection Law (Kişisel Verilerin Korunması Hukuku), 4th ed., Seçkin Publishing, Ankara, 2026.

