2007Murat Volkan DülgerArticle

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

Terrorism has existed since very early periods of history, and its intensity and harmful effects have steadily increased, particularly since the 1960s. Owing to the rise in international terrorist acts from 1968 onwards, it has become one of the social, political and legal concepts most discussed in the 20th century and in the present 21st century. Terror, which derives from the Latin word “terrere”, meaning to tremble or shudder, is used in many senses but is generally used in the sense of political terror. Political terror, in turn, may be defined in general as violent acts aimed at overthrowing the regime in a country or placing it in difficulty.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Murat Volkan Dülger

INTRODUCTION

Terrorism, which has existed since the earliest periods of history and whose intensity and harmful effects have steadily increased, particularly from the 1960s onwards, has, owing to the rise in international acts of terror since 1968, become one of the social, political and legal concepts most dwelt upon in the 20th century and in the 21st century in which we live1. Terror, which derives from the Latin word “terrere”, meaning to tremble or shudder, is used in many senses but generally in the sense of political terror2. Political terror, in turn, may be defined in general terms as acts involving violence aimed at overthrowing the regime of a country or placing it in a difficult position3.

Studies of this concept carried out from the standpoint of political science, sociology, criminal law and criminology point not only to the socio-economic causes that contribute to the emergence of terrorism but also to the existence of causes that contribute to the development of terror in the social environment and to the intensification of its effects on society4.

Terrorist acts are generally seen to be carried out with two different aims. One of them is the aim of overthrowing the regime in force in the country where the terrorist act is carried out; the other is to bring about, by using the method of terror, a change in the policies which the government pursues on certain matters. In seeking to attain these two aims of terrorism, terrorists apply two different methods. These methods may be conceptualised as “direct application” and “indirect application”. In the direct application of terror, an act of terror is undertaken directly against the regime of the country and against those who implement/represent that regime, whereas in the indirect application of terror the attempt is made to attain the intended aim by creating panic and insecurity among the population through planting bombs and committing murders5.

With this study I commemorate my dear elder brother, the author of the first scholarly study and doctoral thesis on terrorism in our country, Av. Dr. M.

Şükrü Alpaslan, whom I remember once again with love and longing.

Attorney-at-law; doctoral student in the Department of Public Law, Institute of Social Sciences, Istanbul University.

Indeed, it is apparent that, as far as terrorism is concerned, the use of political violence can acquire continuity and become effective in the social environment only with the help of certain facilitating factors. When one considers what these auxiliary factors might be, what comes to mind first are the opportunities and conveniences offered by modern technology and, connected with them, the new means of communication, of obtaining resources and of propaganda which the mass media have, albeit unintentionally, provided to terrorism and to terrorists.

In this study, too, some observations will briefly be made on the effects on terrorism of technology and the mass media, which have developed at a dizzying pace over the last fifty years, and proposals will be made for solving the problems that have arisen. Although this subject is in fact broad enough to form the topic of a doctoral thesis, the function which this study seeks to fulfil is to help raise some questions on the subject in the minds of individuals.

I. The Effects of Technological Developments on Terrorism

In the 20th century humanity achieved great successes in almost every field of science and technology and applied them to its daily life. These scientific advances and technological developments, aimed at enabling people to live in better conditions, more comfortably and longer, continued at an increasing pace from the beginning of the 20th century and continue to increase in the 21st century.

When these developments in the field of technology are considered in terms of their effects on human life, it is seen that electronic devices and information systems in particular play a very important role in almost every field. The fields in which their effect is felt most intensely in the daily life of today’s modern society, however, are the transport, communications and finance sectors.

Alongside those developments in technological progress that affect human life positively, it is seen that there are also some negative effects. Indeed, the fact that the 20th century witnessed two world wars, in one of which nuclear weapons were used, many regional wars and a large number of local conflicts also led to great developments in weapons technology. Thus, in the two desert operations launched against Iraq by countries led by the United States of America and the United Kingdom, the technological evolution of weapons and the misuse of technology were shown to the whole world extremely clearly, and moreover in live broadcasts by media which themselves benefit from the blessings of technology.

These developments are still continuing in a world conjuncture based on delicate political balances. In particular, the chaos into which the Middle East has been dragged on account of, and on the pretext of, nuclear, chemical and biological weapons, which represent an important stage reached by science and technology and an example of their misuse, both constitutes a very good example of this situation and concerns us very closely as societies located in the immediate vicinity.

Whether positive or negative, developments in science and in technology, which is its reflection, provide humanity with new opportunities and conveniences in many fields. Not only people leading a normal life but also those engaged in illegal activities, those who commit offences and those who oppose the social order are able to benefit from these opportunities and conveniences, and they continue their acts contrary to the social order or aimed at disrupting that order by making use of these opportunities and/or conveniences6.

Scholars conducting research in this field also point out that the technological developments mentioned above made an important contribution to the development of the phenomenon of terror in the 20th century7. While it is stated that in this century it is especially democracies that are transparent, respectful of individual rights and freedoms and governed by the principle of the rule of law that have been more affected by acts of terror8, it is also said that developing technology, communications and modern means of transport have provided persons inclined to violence with tools and opportunities, and that they, abusing this situation, have carried out their acts of violence more easily9.

What is obtained by putting the results of scientific progress into practice is called technology. These technological advances may take place in more than one field simultaneously or one after another. Among these developments, those that have had the greatest effect on the phenomenon of terrorism may be stated as the developments in means of transport, weapons, means of individual communication, the mass media and information systems. These concepts will be dealt with briefly below under separate headings, while the mass media, because of their importance, will be examined in a separate section.

1. The Effects on Terrorism of Technological Developments in Means of Transport

The technological advances in means of transport are seen to have affected the development of terrorism in two respects. First, means of transport, having gained great speed, have shortened the distance between cities, countries and even continents; this has given terrorists, as it has the whole of humanity, wide freedom of movement and has directly contributed to the phenomenon of “international terrorism”10 coming into being11. Terrorists making use of these conveniences have been able to cover great distances in a short time within the country in which they carry out their acts of violence and, by crossing from one country to another to carry out their acts, have also caused terrorism to acquire an international character12. In this way, persons engaged in terrorist activities have gained a mobility that is rapid and covers great distances, and also the possibility of escaping very easily. This is one of the important reasons why international connections and terrorist organisations operating in the international arena generally turn out to be behind the terrorist acts and political murders committed today.

Aircraft, the means of transport that have benefited most from the developments in this field, have also become the means of transport most affected by terrorism, having been subjected to hijackings by various terrorist organisations13. Hijackings of aircraft, referred to as air piracy (aircraft hijacking), may have various causes; examples include a person’s attempt to escape trial in the country where he is, evasion of military service, escape from social pressure, and political protest. Particularly since 1968, however, air piracy has come to be carried out by armed persons for political reasons14.

As air piracy increased and became a serious problem, various arrangements concerning hijackings of aircraft were made at the international level, and efforts were made to have these acts made criminal offences in all countries and to ensure that air pirates are tried wherever they are apprehended15. In this way, by not leaving these offences unpunished, an attempt was made to meet the demand of the international community in this regard, and these acts ceased to be the problem solely of the country whose nationality the hijacked aircraft bears or of the country in which the aircraft was hijacked; consequently, an attempt was also made to secure international adjudication and justice16. The Convention on Offences and Certain Other Acts Committed on Board Aircraft (1963 Tokyo Convention)17, the Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Seizure of Aircraft (1970 Hague Convention)18 and the Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Acts against the Safety of Civil Aviation (1971 Montreal Convention)19 may be cited as examples of these arrangements20.

Moreover, in the terrorist attack on the twin towers of the World Trade Center in New York on 11 September 2001, the most extreme example of the malicious use of means of transport in terrorist activities was displayed when, alongside other technological developments, passenger aircraft, themselves products of technology, were used virtually as bombs. This was perceived as a new dimension in international terrorism and even led to the adoption of some measures incompatible with the principle of the rule of law.

2. The Effects on Terrorism of Developments in Weapons Technology

Very great progress was also made in the 20th century in the manufacture and use of weapons and explosives. In parallel with this, as early as 1890 a British police expert predicted that, under the influence of developing weapons and explosives, persons and organisations inclined to violence would pose a serious problem within society21.

Along with other factors, technological development brought the mechanisation of weapons manufacture, and weapons consequently became smaller, more readily available and cheaper; with production increasing particularly in the United States of America (USA) and the countries of Western Europe and being distributed from there to all the world’s markets, weapons became easier to obtain. As a result, terrorists have either obtained highly advanced, effective, latest-model weapons with superior features or come to possess simple weapons and ammunition in large quantities22. There is no other country in the world where, to the same extent as in the USA, strict regulations on the manufacture of weapons and the possession of firearms are lacking and the arms manufacturing industry is so highly developed23. Consequently, American manufacturers, citizens of that country and even foreigners coming to the country were able to trade in arms with ease in the period before 11 September. After the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center in New York, however, an attempt was made, through new laws enacted in the USA such as the “Patriot Act”, to bring at least the arms trade and shipments carried on by individuals under control. It is these and similar conveniences that have created a “technological escalation” in terms of the weapons used by terrorists and have also contributed to the increase in terrorist activities24.

Apart from the dangerous environment created by ever more advanced weapons, there is also always the danger that the chemical, biological and nuclear weapons developed during both world wars and in the Cold War period may fall into the hands of terrorists. One of the greatest dangers today is that a nuclear weapon might fall into the hands of terrorists; this has even been the subject of many horror films25. It has been pointed out that one of the most striking and frightening developments in this regard emerged with the attack of 20 March 1995 in a Tokyo underground station, in which an extreme religious organisation named Aum Shinrikyo used nerve gas, and it has been said that this act showed the possibility that weapons of mass destruction might also fall into the hands of other organisations26.

3. The Effects on Terrorism of Developments in the Technology of Means of Individual Communication

Apart from weapons and explosives that have become smaller in size without losing any of their power, satellite telephones, mobile telephones and radio sets, which are likewise produced in very small sizes and provide communication with any place at any moment, have increased terrorists’ possibilities of communication. Ensuring communication is of vital importance for a terrorist act: in this way acts are planned, information obtained through intelligence gathering is shared, the time and place of the act are conveyed to the groups, and even simultaneous acts are made possible. Another negative aspect of individual communication having become so easy is that the communication which is so necessary for international terrorism is secured very easily and cheaply. Thus the leader of an illegal organisation in his secret hideout in the mountains can give the necessary information and orders to his militants far away, and can even direct terrorist activities himself.

In addition, with the help of means of individual communication and the equipment developed in connection with them, it is possible to break into the radio communications of the security forces and to learn the timing and methods of their operations. These possibilities of individual communication make it considerably more difficult to apprehend terrorists and bring them swiftly before the courts, and it becomes easier for individuals encouraged by this to turn, and to be steered, towards violence.

4. The Effects on Terrorism of Developments in Information Systems

Information systems and data transmission networks have entered human life with ever-increasing intensity over the last twenty years and have become the vital artery of developed societies in terms of the production and transmission of information. Their importance becomes clearer when it is considered that possessing information is today regarded as the greatest power. As with all new technological inventions, the emergence and steady increase of abuses as information systems and data transmission networks became widespread has also proved to be an inevitable phenomenon27. Thus, not only have new types of offence called “cybercrime” emerged, but we have also been confronted with long-existing types of offence, such as terrorist activities, being committed through intensive use of this new technology.

With this great development in the field of information technology in recent years, we have encountered a new type of crime, called virtual (cyber) terrorism, which has emerged with the globalisation of information technology and its being made available to the masses. It has become very easy to disrupt the normal course of life in society and to damage the State’s defence systems by an attack on information systems carried out over the internet, which consists of interconnected networks, for example by means of an effective computer virus28.

Whereas during the communications revolution that preceded the information revolution developments in communications technology centralised the power held by groups or individuals, in today’s information age central control has become impossible. While this is a very positive development for the democratisation and liberation of the individual and of society, unlimited freedom and the freedom of anyone to access any information they wish also enable certain ill-intentioned persons to access information capable of harming the individual and society29. For example, the information systems of nuclear power plants, the defence industry and facilities providing public services such as transport, health, water, heating and electricity may be accessed for malicious as well as for well-intentioned purposes. This is called the “democratisation of violence”30.

Virtual terrorism is defined as efforts to intimidate and put pressure on society and those who govern it by using information systems to cause harm to individuals, property and the order of social life in order to attain a particular political and social aim31.

Examples given of acts which terrorist organisations could carry out by means of virtual terrorism, which could cause very great damage to society and against which urgent measures need to be taken, include: stopping all the traffic lights of a chosen city, paralysing telephone lines, cutting off electricity and natural gas, putting information systems out of operation, disrupting the functioning of transport and water systems, bringing down the banking and finance sector, and preventing the emergency services, the police, hospitals and fire brigades from operating32.

In the forecasts made in the late 1990s it was stated that the greatest concern felt for the future of the international community was that developments in information systems, and hence in information transmission and communications technology, might give terrorism a new dimension, and, furthermore, that the complex and integrated structure of the information and communication systems built on information systems by the public sector and the private sector for the functioning of the modern social order constituted a very favourable environment for terrorists who might take action with the aim of damaging it33.

Today, when technology has advanced and almost all public activities have become dependent on an information-system infrastructure, States need to devote time and resources not to conflicts involving physical contact but to preventing attacks on infrastructures built on information systems, in which the perpetrators may remain unknown (anonymous)34, and to researching how they can counter them. One example pointing to the scale of the danger in this field states: “… a command that could be sent over the information network to the control computer of a power generation plant may perhaps be as destructive as a suitcase full of explosives, and it is also very difficult to identify and apprehend the person who does this … an internet connection established with a computer and a simple telephone line that can be used from anywhere in the world can cause great damage…”35.

It is stated that the internet offered very wide and uncontrollable possibilities for the organisation, support and training required in particular for the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001 which destroyed the World Trade Center in the city of New York in the USA, known as the twin towers36. After that act, and after US officials announced that the terrorists had communicated over the internet in preparing it, work was begun in many countries on taking measures against virtual terrorism37. As regards the USA, it is stated that the attacks of 11 September not only caused the death of nearly three thousand people but also led to radical changes in the field of substantive criminal law and in the working methods of the security agencies, and to an increase in criminal-law measures38.

It is known that terrorist organisations use the Internet in order to ensure secrecy in their communications, to conduct their propaganda and to increase their financial resources. Ramzi Yousef, the planner of the 1993 bomb attack on the twin towers, confessed that he had planned to destroy the encrypted files of American Airlines by using his laptop computer. Furthermore, terrorist organisations, which use information systems in line with their own interests, are able to use their funds over the internet39. Indeed, terrorist or mafia-type organisations need financing in order to survive and to continue their acts; this financing is provided through transactions carried out by way of virtual banking, and the monies obtained by these criminal organisations are even laundered and rendered legal by the same methods40.

Proceeding from the concerns set out above, some States decided, at the Conference of Foreign Ministers on terrorism held in Paris in 1996, that there should be co-operation between States in order to combat effectively the offences that terrorists would commit in attacks carried out by using electronic or wire communication systems or network (data network) systems and cyberspace41.

In April 1997, Europol (the European Police Office) issued a notice recommending to the police forces of the European States in particular that areas of the internet containing illegal information be placed under scrutiny, that information be exchanged in this field, that the domestic laws of the countries be harmonised with one another, that research be carried out on this subject and that there should without fail be co-operation where necessary42.

On the internet it is also possible to gain access to information that will influence in particular persons prone to the use of violence and that will enlighten and guide potential perpetrators of terrorist acts. One study revealed that the internet contains tactics, maps, photographs and secret communication codes that could be used in terrorist attacks and, beyond that, that instructions and formulas showing how to make and use bombs and other explosives can be found there43. Indeed, it is stated that in the preparatory work preceding the 11 September attacks the terrorists communicated with one another via the internet, and even practised with flight simulators on their personal computers and were helped by this in flying the aircraft they used as bombs.

For the time being, the latest stage reached in terms of the measures taken against offences committed via the internet, and accordingly against the commission of offences by terrorist organisations via the internet, is the European Convention on Cybercrime. This Convention was opened for signature on 23 November 2001 in Budapest, the capital of Hungary, and has so far been signed by a total of forty-three countries, thirty-eight of them members of the Council of Europe and five of them non-member countries (the USA, Japan, South Africa, Canada and Montenegro)44. With the signing of this text, the first international convention on offences committed via the internet and other computer networks came into being. Another important aspect of this Convention is that five countries, three of them highly advanced in the field of information technology, signed it although they are not members of the Council of Europe and declared their intention that it should also apply in their own legal systems. An important step has thus also been taken towards achieving international co-operation in combating cybercrime, which is the aim of the Convention45.

The aim of the European Convention on Cybercrime was stated by those who drafted it as follows:

“This Convention, in order to prevent harmful acts directed against the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information systems, networks and data, as well as the misuse of such systems, networks and data, provides for arrangements designed, as set out in the Convention, to ensure that these acts are defined as criminal offences and, by adopting the powers necessary for combating these offences effectively, to facilitate the detection, investigation and prosecution of these acts at both the national and the supranational level and to bring about fast and reliable international co-operation.46”

As can be seen, if the European Convention on Cybercrime attains its aim, it will be possible to investigate, try and punish those who engage in terrorist activities using information systems and networks, wherever they may be.

II. The Effects on Terrorism of Developments in the Mass Media

1. The Relationship between the Mass Media and Terrorism in General

As a concept, “mass communications” or “mass communication” covers every kind of broadcast or publication made by radio, television, cinema films, videotapes and the internet, which are defined as the mass media. The common feature of these media is that they convey news, ideas and feelings to anonymous masses by reproducing them as text, pictures, images and/or sound. Another important feature is that they have the functions of informing, educating and entertaining society47. Mass communication, like interpersonal communication, is an activity based on communication; however, whereas in personal communication this activity remains at the individual level, in mass communication it acquires a public character. Consequently, the most important difference distinguishing mass communication from personal communication is that the former is public in nature and reaches very broad sections of the population48.

That one of the aims of terrorism is “to attract the attention of the public” is a view widely accepted today. This attention is most easily attracted by using the mass media. Indeed, in legal scholarship “bombing”, the most widely used form of terrorist act, is characterised as a “press event” (media events)49, because such incidents immediately become the subject of live television news, are carried on the front pages of the newspapers and become, as it were, the number one item on the agenda of the country in which the act was carried out.

Indeed, technological developments have given the mass media the quality of being “…the most influential on social life and on people’s attitudes and behaviour…”50, and terrorists, who pursue the aim of “…influencing the population by means of psychological pressure…”, have also made use of media that are so influential on society. Some authors characterise this use as a “parasitic relationship”51.

Individuals can be frightened and affected by acts of violence only if those acts are seen, read about and learned of down to the smallest detail. For this reason, one of the things most necessary for terrorists to attain their aims is that acts which will create a psychological effect and fear in individuals and in society at large be made known to the public and, to that end, that acts likely to be reported to the public be carried out. The best examples of this are the 11 September attacks on the USA and, in our country, the simultaneous terrorist attacks carried out on 23 November 2003 on the head office building of HSBC Bank, the Consulate General of the United Kingdom in Istanbul and a synagogue in Şişli. The violence of these events and the damage they caused were so great that they dominated the agenda both of the countries where the acts took place and of the international media, and occupied it for a long time.

Apart from those organs which knowingly support acts of terror and terrorists and seek to disseminate their ideas and demands, the mass media which, while acting within the “principle of informing the public”, report acts of terror in every detail and as extensively as possible are, albeit unintentionally, instrumental in spreading the fear that terrorists wish to see arise in society. Besides the spread of fear and anxiety, some authors also hold the press responsible for helping terror tactics, acts and slogans to be adopted by other terrorist groups or by persons inclined to become terrorists52.

It must be emphasised here that what is meant by the above explanations is not the creation of crimes of opinion by characterising any philosophical or political view as a terrorist act, but acts carried out by terrorists which, in concrete terms, contain the structural elements of an offence that must be present from the standpoint of criminal law and are therefore classified as offences.

2. The Mass Media’s Coverage of Terrorist Acts

As a rule, the press, in line with the great desire to learn of events that cause excitement in society, tends to give more space to events of a “sensational” nature. All the more so in today’s media market, which is driven by what is called “ratings” and is founded on commercial concerns, this must be regarded as entirely natural.

When the targets chosen in acts of terror are examined, it can be seen that they have dramatic features both for individuals and for the mass media. What is to be understood by the notion of dramatic feature is the wish to create a certain degree of excitement and fear in society.

Terrorists wish to appear in the print and audiovisual press through the acts they carry out, and thereby seek both to make their ideas, slogans and names known and to create fear and pressure in society53. To give examples, it must be said that the killing of the Israeli athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympic Games, the killing of the Puerto Rican passengers in the raid on Lod airport and, likewise, the killing of large numbers of people in the acts carried out in New York on 11 September 2001 and in Istanbul on 23 November 2003 had no political value whatsoever, but were merely “press events” aimed at achieving the greatest psychological effect by taking advantage of the extensive coverage which the press gives to such events54.

There are also those who see the reason why terrorists gradually abandoned this method, at a time when aircraft hijackings had gathered pace, in the fact that society and the press had by then become inured to these events55. The hijackings in the 11 September acts, however, are different. In the hijackings referred to above, the aim is for the hijacking itself to be made news in the media, which enables the perpetrators of the terrorist act to try to voice their names, views or demands. In the 11 September attacks, by contrast, the hijacking of the aircraft was used as a mere means of carrying out a larger act. To explain this in the terms of criminal law, the hijacking in this event plays the role of a transitional offence in relation to the offences of homicide and damage to property committed by crashing the aircraft into the tower.

In view of these consequences of the mass media’s coverage of acts of terror, debates began on whether such coverage is necessary and, if a restriction is to be imposed, on the method of doing so, and a large number of views have been put forward. The issue particularly dwelt upon and debated in legal scholarship concerns the manner in which the mass media cover acts of terror. These may be examined under two main headings: “coverage while the act is in progress” and “coverage after the act”.

a. The Mass Media’s Coverage of Terrorist Acts While the Act Is in Progress

While any social event or act of terror is in progress, the most effective mass media are television, radio and internet journalism. These media can relay the event instantly, “live”, and the fact that television and internet journalism also appeal to the eye increases their effectiveness still further. Thanks to satellite links, these media can within a second reach a vast audience made up of millions of people from all over the world. If the act of terror is regarded as a theatrical performance, it can safely be said that it is impossible to find a larger audience than this56.

An individual watching an act of terror in a live broadcast feels himself to be inside an event that arouses horror and fear, takes an interest in those who carried out the act and in their stories, and with each new event tries to learn and understand the slogans used by the terrorists. This shows that terrorists are able to attain their aims and that the mass media, albeit unintentionally, play an important part in this57.

It is pointed out that while an act of terror is in progress the audiovisual mass media in particular may go beyond informing the public and actually help the terrorists. This help should not, of course, be perceived as knowing and deliberate collaboration. What is meant here is that the information given in broadcasts made while the act is in progress may in some cases also be of use to the perpetrator of the terrorist act. For example, a television broadcast showing images from the scene also conveys to the terrorists the measures taken in the area, the working methods of the police, the attitude adopted by public officials towards the act and their attempts at a solution. In an act that took place in March 1977 in Washington, the capital of the USA, the perpetrators, who had occupied three separate buildings including the governor’s office building and were holding the occupants hostage, learned from live radio and television broadcasts of the presence of persons who were trapped on the fifth floor of the governor’s office building but whose presence there was unknown to the perpetrators. The attempts to rescue the trapped persons were abandoned because the perpetrators were instantly aware of the situation.

Likewise, at the 1972 Munich Olympic Games, the perpetrators of Arab origin who carried out an armed raid on the Olympic village and took Israeli athletes hostage first began negotiations with the German authorities concerning their demands. During this time, however, the press and the public were not removed from the vicinity of the Olympic village; indeed, every movement at the scene was relayed live by television. When disagreement arose at one point in the negotiations, the German police decided to carry out an operation, but the police officers who climbed onto the roofs with weapons in hand or took up positions around the building where the hostages were held were shown to the whole world, just as they were, live on television. Since the terrorists were watching the same broadcast, however, the operation could not be carried out although the circumstances were favourable, and as a result of the operation later carried out at the airport in unfavourable conditions all the Israeli athletes and some security officers lost their lives. This is perhaps the most striking example of events in which the media, albeit unintentionally, have played a negative role.

With regard to broadcasts made while the act is in progress, criticism is levelled at the fact that some members of the press turn to matters outside their duties, enter into direct or indirect bargaining with the hostage-takers, and give out information that may agitate a terrorist as much as an ordinary criminal and cause them to behave unpredictably – for example, telling the person held hostage that the police have placed snipers in the surrounding buildings – and it is accepted that such conduct will make the work of public officials more difficult58.

b. The Mass Media’s Coverage of Terrorist Acts After the Act

Although there is no significant criticism of the media regarding coverage after the act of terror has ended, it is said that if such coverage goes to extremes, persons inclined to terror may be encouraged with a view to appearing in the press59.

With regard to coverage in this period, views have been put forward in legal scholarship to the effect that the terrorists who carried out the act “… should not be presented as an idealist using the wrong means to achieve social aims, or as a hero who has made a mistake, but should be identified as a criminal, with the act being specified…”60.

Indeed, it can sometimes be seen that certain organs of the print press in particular, whatever their outlook, endeavour to show terrorists from behind a veil of heroism. In this context, giving terrorists nicknames, making their lives the subject of detailed examination and virtually glorifying these persons and what they have done confirms the view cited above, at least in part. In reality, however, these are persons who have in one way or another disrupted the democratic social order, have not complied with the rules of social life and have resorted to violence instead of defending their ideas and their struggle in a democratic environment and according to the rules of democracy. The fact that these persons advocate views close or identical to those held by the individuals who make up democratic society does not alter the fact that the acts they have carried out involve violence and constitute offences under the criminal laws. Yet from time to time even the failure of the press and broadcasting organs at least to react against violence, when they ought to do so, can give rise to misunderstandings and to the impression that the terrorists are being supported.

3. An Assessment, from the Standpoint of Freedom of the Press, of the Debates on the Mass Media’s Coverage of Terrorist Acts

The debates on the methods by which acts of terror are covered by the mass media have also brought with them concerns about the restriction of freedom of the press61, because the “relative freedom” which the press has attained today could only be won through a struggle lasting many long years. The concerns about the restriction of freedom of the press stem in particular from the restrictions proposed for the manner of covering an act of terror62. There have been debates on how the restriction should be made and various views have been put forward63; these may be examined under two main headings, namely that the restriction should be made by law and that the restriction should be made by self-regulation.

a. The View that the Restriction Should Be Made by Law

According to this view, it is necessary, and possible, to impose certain restrictions on the coverage of acts of terror for the public, by reference to the laws in force in the domestic law of some countries.

This view, however, is heavily criticised, and it is accepted that statutory arrangements of this kind would not, particularly in democratic countries, withstand the “necessity test” (test of necessity) and would therefore entail adverse consequences for freedom of the press64. It must be emphasised here that a “general and excessively restrictive” arrangement of this kind concerning restriction could also be a significant problem in particular for a member State of the Council of Europe which has signed and ratified the European Convention on Human Rights, and, if made the subject of an application, would in all probability be interpreted by the European Court of Human Rights as a violation of the Convention, provided that the circumstances of the specific case are also taken into account. For under this legal system, too, freedom is the rule and restriction the exception; a restriction of freedom of expression in particular can come into question if and only if it is “necessary in a democratic society”65.

It must nevertheless be stated that, if such an arrangement and its application were made the subject of an application, the specific case would in any event be assessed and, in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 10 of the Convention, it would also be possible for the Court to hold in the specific case that the arrangement and its application did not violate the Convention, where this was “necessary in a democratic society” and there was “a social need” in that regard.

Notwithstanding the views set out above, it must be said that in some Western European countries there are restrictive arrangements concerning the press’s coverage of acts of terror for the public. For example, in the United Kingdom, under the practice called the “Defence Notice System”, which is applied where the State is endangered, press organs are notified in advance that the publication of a particular item of news would undermine the security of the State and breach the relevant laws. Failure by the press organs so notified to comply with this restriction constitutes a breach of the Official Secrets Act of 192066.

b. The View that the Restriction Should Be Made by Self-Regulation

Since self-regulation of the press is regarded as “…the emergence of an order that will prevent the harmful consequences which may arise from the abuse of freedom of the press, and the formation in this way of a press ethic…”67, it is said that resorting to this method with regard to the coverage of news concerning acts of terror, too, would be beneficial for the protection of freedom of the press68.

If self-regulation is accepted, the mass media will comply of their own volition with certain rules or guiding provisions which they themselves lay down concerning the coverage of terrorist incidents. The most striking practice relating to this method is found in the USA. “CBS News”, one of the largest press organisations in that country, has drawn up a set of guiding rules (guidelines) to be followed by its own staff in conveying acts of terror to the public. The aim which this broadcaster wishes to achieve by this arrangement is to keep the effect of terrorism on society under control and to avoid becoming, albeit unintentionally, an instrument of the aims which terrorists wish to attain.

However, even those who favour such guidelines and the method of self-regulation are opposed to terrorist incidents not being covered at all or being covered only very little. In their view, the press cannot act in disregard of the principle of informing the public on a given matter; what matters here is that the right choice be made between society’s right to receive news, on the one hand, and the prevention of terror and security, on the other.

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

It is seen that terrorism, which emerges when it finds a suitable social environment, became widespread and easier to carry out with the technological developments that advanced rapidly in the 20th century, and particularly with the rapid developments in the fields of transport, communications, weapons technology and information technology. These developments have given terrorism an international dimension; the point reached today is that terror has become a scourge for the whole of humanity. For this reason, in order to succeed in combating terrorism, international co-operation is, alongside all other measures, a priority and a sine qua non. Indeed, various international conventions have been concluded on this subject; for example, the “European Convention on the Suppression of Terrorism”, a product of the Council of Europe, is one of the most important. It is by the States Parties putting this and similar conventions into practice that important steps will have been taken against terrorism69.

When the problem is viewed from the standpoint of restricting the individual use of technology by terrorists, however, it is seen that large-scale restrictions for the purpose of prevention are in fact hardly possible. As explained above, it is not possible to prevent the use of devices open to individual use, such as mobile telephones, satellite telephones and the internet in particular. One good side of these, however, is that they make it possible, provided this is done lawfully, to carry out technical surveillance of terrorists using these devices, and thus make it easier for public officials to reach offenders. In addition, strict security measures must be taken on boarding vehicles frequently used in acts of terror, such as aircraft, and instruments capable of being used to commit offences must on no account be allowed on board. Indeed, it is observed that after the 11 September attacks in the USA changes were made to the security measures relating to these matters in almost every country in the world.

As regards virtual terrorism, the use in State institutions of an “intranet”, which may be defined as a closed-circuit data transmission network, is today recommended as, in one respect, an effective means against virtual terrorism, particularly in order to ensure the security of the data of State institutions. It is emphasised, however, that as the network grows it is inevitable that this system, too, will develop security vulnerabilities70. Another measure recommended in relation to virtual terrorism is that cyberspace be kept under constant surveillance by States; this measure, however, is heavily criticised because it constitutes a direct interference with the fundamental rights and freedoms of the individual. Since this measure may be used, outside virtual terrorism, for bad as well as good purposes and, in theory, directly infringes the individual’s freedom of communication and the inviolability of private life, it may be regarded as a human rights violation. For this reason, the scope of such arrangements must be narrow and their limits clear71.

When one looks at the legislation in force in our country, it is seen that, although terrorism has been and is being combated for many years and much harm has been suffered and much pain endured in this regard, no provision whatsoever has been made from the standpoint of criminal law against virtual terrorism, which is a serious threat, and against virtual terrorist acts that may be carried out by using information systems. As will be seen when the types of cybercrime regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 and in special laws are examined, there is not the slightest reference to this subject72. Yet, taking the phenomenon of virtual terrorism into account, carrying out acts of terror by making use of data transmission networks ought to be regarded as an aggravating circumstance for the relevant type of offence. This is because, whereas the perpetrators of an act of terror put even their own lives at risk in the classic types of offence, where the acts are carried out by means of information systems both the personal risk run by the perpetrators and the risk of being identified and apprehended are reduced and the commission of the offence becomes easier73.

The picture of the problem from the standpoint of the mass media is as follows. It is seen that the fear and excitement which terrorism causes in society were, for a time, reinforced by the mass media without this being noticed and through what was virtually an “unintended collaboration”, but that responsible press and broadcasting organs, which place the interests of the societies in which they operate before commercial concerns, soon moved to take measures to prevent this.

All organs of the print and audiovisual press, which may be referred to in short as the media, in fact derive their power from society’s right to obtain information. In the assessments made in legal scholarship of the responsibility of the mass media, it is stated that “foremost among the basic functions of the media is the function of providing news; and that news reporting and commentary which is accurate and undistorted, which respects personal rights, private life and local, national and universal values, which has regard to individual and national freedoms, in which the sense of responsibility is never abandoned and the laws are not broken, constitutes the basic function of the media and, indeed, its ethical principles”74. Of these ethical principles, “respecting personal rights and local, national and universal values, having regard to individual and national freedoms and never abandoning the sense of responsibility” already contain the answer to the questions asked by this study. If these principles are observed, the use of technology, and of the mass media in particular, in the interests of terror, albeit unintentionally, will have been prevented.

The proposals and views set out above on restricting the coverage of terrorist acts were formulated with the aim of preventing the mass media from benefiting terrorists and terrorist acts. It does not appear possible to prevent altogether the use by terrorists of developments in science and technology, because these persons, too, as part of the society from which they come, in fact use products of technology such as mobile telephones, personal computers, etc. Nevertheless, terrorists must as far as possible be prevented from freely using the mass media in particular in their own interests.

In doing so, however, as little as possible must be sacrificed of individuals’ right to obtain information and of the press’s freedom to report, and the restriction to be imposed must also be prevented from being used by the political power as an instrument for silencing the press. For this reason, self-regulation appears to be the most suitable method of restriction for press organisations, which are closely concerned with the healthy and orderly functioning of the society in which they operate. Important tasks fall in this regard particularly to the boards and/or organisations that bring press organisations together under one roof; this restriction, however, must be a method of self-regulation only to the extent necessary and must never turn into censorship.

A view that may be put forward on this subject, and that would combine the two views on restriction mentioned above, is the adoption of a mixed method. Accordingly, as in the United Kingdom’s arrangement, the press should be notified in advance of the acts which it has been decided should not be covered for the public. However, the decision as to which acts may not be published should be taken, for example, by the Press Council or by another board composed of representatives of the press, and the notification should likewise be made by that body. Failure to comply with the restriction in question despite this decision and notification should then be met with a sanction under criminal law and/or administrative law. In this way, a general framework on the subject would be laid down by law, while the filling-in and application of that framework would be carried out by way of the self-regulation of the print and audiovisual press.

This, in turn, requires a strong sense of responsibility to develop among all those working in the press. “Since there can be no responsibility without authority and no authority that carries no responsibility, when we remove the sense of responsibility from the press its power, too, will disappear of its own accord. This sense of responsibility must be felt by everyone, from the reporter to the editor-in-chief and even to the owner of the newspaper75.” Consequently, a great duty and responsibility falls to the press, particularly as regards restricting the coverage of terrorist incidents.

In conclusion, it must be stated once again that the most appropriate method of protecting freedom of the press and individuals’ right to receive news and to be informed is for mass communication institutions to limit their coverage of acts of terror according to rules which they lay down of their own free will.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Alacakaptan, Uğur, “Terörün Değişen Yüzü ve Dünya - 1”, Hukuk ve Adalet Eleştirel Hukuk Dergisi Y.1, S.1, Ocak-Mart 2004, s.127-139.

Alpaslan, M. Şükrü, “21. Yüzyılda Da Terör Gündemde Olacak”, Güncel Hukuk, S.1, Ocak 2004, s.12 - 15.

Alpaslan, M. Şükrü, “Avrupa İnsan Hakları Sözleşmesi Uygulamasında Düşünce ve Basın Özgürlüğü”, Prof. Dr. Sahir Erman’a Armağan, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Eğitim Öğretim ve Yardımlaşma Vakfı Yayını, 1999, s.27 - .35.

Alpaslan, M. Şükrü, Kriminoloji ve Hukuk Açısından Tedhişcilik, İstanbul, Teknik Yayınları, 1983.

Bassiouni, M. Cherif, “The Media and Terrorism”, A Seminar Sponsored by Chicago Sun Times and Chicago Daily News, 1977, QUDARNI, Vol II, 1978.

Bassiouni, M. Cherif Bassiouni, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975.

Bassiouni, M. Cherif, “Methodological Options for International Legal Control of Terrorism”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.484 – 492.

Byford, Lawrence, “Terrorism and Democracy”, New Dimensions in Transnational Crime, Ed: Donald E. J. MacNamara/Philip John Stead, New York, The Jonh Jay Press, 1982, s.66-71.

Calvert, Peter, A Study Of Revulation, Oxford, 1970.

Crelinsten, Ronald D./Danielle Laberge–Altmejd/Denis Szabo, Terrorism and Criminal Justice, Massachusetts, Lexington Books, 1979.

Değirmenci, Olgun, Mukayeseli Hukukta ve Türk Hukukunda Suçtan Kaynaklanan Malvarlığı Değerlerini Aklama Suçu, Ankara, Turhan Kitabevi, 2007.

Dönmezer, Sulhi, “Her Yönü İle Tedhiş”, Son Havadis, 10 – 13 Kasım 1977, s.7.

Dönmezer, Sulhi, Basın ve Hukuku, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1976.

Dönmezer, Sulhi, Kriminolji, 5. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1975.

Dönmezer, Sulhi, “Tedhişcilik Üzerine”, Devir, 11.12.1972, S.6, s.20.

Dönmezer, Sulhi, “Basında Oto-Kontrol”, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Mecmuası, C.XLI, S.1-4, 1969.

Dülger, Murat Volkan, Bilişim Suçları, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2004.

Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Avrupa İnsan Hakları Sözleşmesi’nde Düşünce Özgürlüğü”, Prof.

Dr. Çetin Özek Armağanı, İstanbul, Galatasaray Üniversitesi Yayını, 2004, s.283-300.

Dülger, Murat Volkan, “Kitle İletişim Araçları ve Terörizm”, Çevrimiçi:

http://www.hukukcu. com/bilimsel/kitaplar/kitleiletisim _teror.htm, 02.04.2007.

Elcock,Ward, “Submission to the Special Committee of the Senate on Security and Intelligence”, June 24, 1998.

Ellis, James/David Fisher/Thomas Longstaff/Linda Pesante/Richard Pethia, Report to the President’s Commision on Critical Infrastructure Protection, Pittsburgh, January 1997.

Evans, Alona E., “Aircraft Hijacking: What Is Being Done”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.219 - 247.

Hyams, Edward, Terrorists and Terrorism, London, J M Dent&Sons Ltd., 1975.

İçel, Kayıhan /Yener Ünver, Kitle Haberleşme Hukuku, 6. Bası, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2005.

Janke, Peter, “The Response to Terrorism”, Royal United Services Institude for Defence Studies Ten Years of Terrosim, New York, 1979.

Krieger, David, “What Happens If Terrorists, Revolutionaries and Nuclear Weapons”, The Annals Of The American Academy, Vol.430, March 1977.

Laqueur, Walter, Terorism, London, Weidenfeld and Nichdson, 1977.

Lee, Andrew, “International Suppression Of Hijacking”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.248 - 256.

McClintoc, Michael C., “Skyjacking: Its Domestic, Civil and Criminal Ramifications”, Journal of Air Law and Commerce, Vol.39, 1973.

Murphy, Jonn F., “Computer Network Attacks by Terrorists: Some Legal Dimensions”

SSRNEL, (Çevrimiçi) http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=208671, 02.05.2004.

Murphy, Patric, “The Media and Terrorism”, A Seminar Sponsored by Chicago Sun Times and Chicago Daily News, 1977, QUDARNI, Vol II, 1978.

Narlı, Nilüfer, “Yeni Küresel Tehditler ve Yeni Paradigma”, Polis Bilimleri Dergisi, C:4, S:1- 2, Ocak-Haziran 2002, s.9-19.

Netanyahu, Benjamin, “Terrorism and the Media. Abdication of Responsibility”, The Jonathan Institute, The Jerusalem Conference on International Terrorism, July 2 – 5, 1979.

Özcan, Mehmet, “Siber Terörizm ve Ulusal Güvenlik”, İnternet ve Hukuk, Der: Yeşim M.

Atamer, İstanbul, İstanbul Bilgi Üniversitesi Yayını, 2004, s.301-340.

Özek, Çetin, Basın Özgürlüğünden Bilgilenme Hakkına, İstanbul, Alfa Yayıncılık, 1999.

Özek, Çetin, Türk Basın Hukuku, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1978.

Pierre, Andrew J., “The Politics of International Terorizm”, ORBIS, Vol.XIX, No.4, Winter 1976.

Rigel, Nurdoğan, Kağıt Kaplanlar, İstanbul, Der Yayınları, 1993.

Rosen, J.S./R. Frank, “Measures Against International Terorism”, International Terorism and World Security, Ed. David Carlton/Carlo Schaerf, New York, Halsted Press, 1975.

Sabetta, Anne R., “Transnational Terror: Causes And Implications for Response”, Stanford journal of International Studies, Vol.XII, Spring 1977.

Salıcı, Berfu/İsmail Güneş, “İnternette Güvenlik ve Denetim: Masumiyet Yitiriliyor Mu?”

(Çevrimiçi) http://www.bilgiyonetimi.org/cm/pages/mkl_gos.php?nt=243, 14.04.2004.

Salomone, Franco, “Terrorism and the Mass Media”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.43-46.

Shaffer, Lymann H., “Illegal Arms Traffic”, New Dimensions in Transnational Crime, Ed:

Donald E. J. MacNamara/Philip John Stead, New York, The Jonh Jay Press, 1982, s.103 - 118.

Small, William J., “The Media and Terrorism”, A Seminar Sponsored by Chicago Sun Times and Chicago Daily News, 1977, QUDARNI, Vol II, 1978.

Tanyol, Tuğrul, “Anarşizm ve İnternet”, Cogito-İnternet: Üçüncü Devrim, Yapı Kredi Yayınları, S.30, Kış 2002, s.204-210.

Thaman, Stephen F., “ABD’de 11 Eylül Açısından Önleyici ve Baskılayıcı Tedbirler”, Hukuki Perspektifler Dergisi, S.5, Aralık 2005, s.110-115.

Tezcan, Durmuş, “Terörle Mücadelede İşbirliği Sorunu”, Hukuki Perspektifler Dergisi, S.5, Aralık 2005, s.103-107.

Whine, Michael, “Cyberspice – A New Medium for Communication Command and Control by Extremist”, Studies in Conflict and Terrorism”, Routledge, Vol.22, N.3, July 1999, s.231 - 245.

Whine, Michael, “Communication on Criminal Use of the Internet, European Comission/Europol Report”, April 9, 1997.

Whine, Michael, “Cyber-Terrorism, Foreign Report”, London, September 25, 1997.

Wilkinson, Paul, Political Terorism, London, Macmillan, Press Ltd., 1974.

Wolf, John B., “Controlling Political Terrorism in a Free Society”, ORBIS, Vol.XIX, No.34, Winter 1976, s.1289-1308.

Vural, Ali Murat, “Medyanın Toplumsal İşlevleri ve Medya Profesyonellerinin Sorumluluğu”, Güncel Hukuk, S.40, Nisan 2007, s.22,23.

Yamaç, Fatih/Semih Dokurer/MehmetÖzcan, “Bilişim Suçları” (Çevrimiçi)

http://inet-tr.org/inetconf7/bildiriler/86.doc, 11.04.2004.

Yenisey, Feridun, Milletlerarası Ceza Hukuku Ceza Yargılarının Milletlerarası Değeri ve Mevzuatı, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1988.

Yıldız, Sevil, Suçta Araç Olarak İnternetin Teknik ve Hukuki Yönden İncelenmesi, Ankara, Nobel Yayıncılık, 2007.

Yılmaz, Alia, Uluslararası Ceza Hukuku, 2. Bası, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2001.

Zafer, Hamide, Sosyolojik Boyutuyla Terörizm, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1999.

Zafer, Hamide, Ceza Hukukunda Terörizm, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1999.

Zlataric, Bogdan, “History of International Terrorism and Its Legal Control”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.474 – 484.

Footnotes

  1. M. Şükrü Alpaslan, Kriminoloji ve Hukuk Açısından Tedhişcilik, İstanbul, Teknik Yayınları, 1983, s.3. ↑
  2. Hamide Zafer, Ceza Hukukunda Terörizm, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1999, s.9-12. ↑
  3. Paul Wilkinson, Political Terorism, London, Macmillan, Press Ltd., 1974, s.9-11. ↑
  4. Hamide Zafer, Sosyolojik Boyutuyla Terörizm, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1999, 20 vd. ↑
  5. Edward Hyams, Terrorists and Terrorism, London, J M Dent&Sons Ltd., 1975, s.10. ↑
  6. Murat Volkan Dülger, “Kitle İletişim Araçları ve Terörizm”, Çevrimiçi: http://www.hukukcu.com/bilimsel/kitaplar/kitleiletisim _teror.htm, 02.04.2007. ↑
  7. Andrew J. Pierre, “The Politics of International Terorizm”, ORBIS, Vol.XIX, No.4, Winter 1976, s.1253; David Krieger, “What Happens If Terrorists, Revolutionaries and Nuclear Weapons”, The Annals Of The American Academy, Vol.430, March 1977, s.4 vd.; Walter Laqueur, Terorism, London, Weidenfeld and Nichdson, 1977, s.82. ↑
  8. Lawrence Byford, “Terrorism and Democracy”, New Dimensions in Transnational Crime, Ed: Donald E. J. MacNamara/Philip John Stead, New York, The Jonh Jay Press, 1982, s.66-71. ↑
  9. Ward Elcock, “Submission to the Special Committee of the Senate on Security and Intelligence”, june 24, 1998. ↑
  10. For the definitions of this concept formulated by international organisations see: Alia Yılmaz, Uluslararası Ceza Hukuku, 2. Bası, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2001, s.222-228. ↑
  11. For a detailed explanation of the concept of international terrorism see: Bogdan Zlataric, “History of International Terrorism and Its Legal Control”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.474 – 484; M. Cherif Bassiouni, “Methodological Options for International Legal Control of Terrorism”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.484 – 492. ↑
  12. Anne R. Sabetta, “Transnational Terror: Causes And Implications for Response”, Stanford Journal of International Studies, Vol.XII, Spring 1977, s.150; Sulhi Dönmezer, “Tedhişcilik Üzerine”, Devir, 11.12.1972, S.6, s.20. ↑
  13. Michael C. McClintoc, “Skyjacking: Its Domestic, Civil and Criminal Ramifications”, Journal of Air Law and Commerce, Vol.39, 1973, s.34. ↑
  14. Alona E. Evans, “Aircraft Hijacking: What Is Being Done”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.223,224. ↑
  15. Andrew Lee, “International Suppression Of Hijacking”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.249,250. ↑
  16. Ronald D. Crelinsten/Danielle Laberge–Altmejd/Denis Szabo, Terrorism and Criminal Justice, Massachusetts, Lexington Books, 1979, s.39. ↑
  17. This convention was approved by Law No. 1889 of 17.04.1975 and published in the Official Gazette of 08.12.1975. ↑
  18. This convention was approved by Law No. 1634 of 30.11.1972 and published in the Official Gazette of 31.03.1973. ↑
  19. This convention was approved by Law No. 1888 of 17.04.1975 and published in the Official Gazette of 29.11.1975. ↑
  20. For the original texts of these conventions see: M. Cherif Bassiouni, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.257 - 281; for their Turkish translations see: Feridun Yenisey, Milletlerarası Ceza Hukuku Ceza Yargılarının Milletlerarası Değeri ve Mevzuatı, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 1988, s.387-407. ↑
  21. Laqueur, a.g.e., s.64. ↑
  22. Peter Calvert, A Study Of Revulation, Oxford, 1970, s.22. ↑
  23. Lymann H. Shaffer, “Illegal Arms Traffic”, New Dimensions in Transnational Crime, Ed: Donald E. J. MacNamara/Philip John Stead, New York, The Jonh Jay Press, 1982, s.103. ↑
  24. Peter Janke, “The Response to Terrorism”, Royal United Services Institude for Defence Studies Ten Years of Terrosim, New York, 1979, s.23. ↑
  25. Krieger, a.g.y., s.45,51; Elcock, a.g.y., s.4. ↑
  26. Elcock, a.g.y., s.4. ↑
  27. Murat Volkan Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, Ankara, Seçkin Yayıncılık, 2004, s.9. ↑
  28. Nilüfer Narlı, “Yeni Küresel Tehditler ve Yeni Paradigma”, Polis Bilimleri Dergisi, C:4, S:1-2, Ocak-Haziran 2002, s.13. ↑
  29. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.323. ↑
  30. Uğur Alacakaptan, “Terörün Değişen Yüzü ve Dünya - 1”, Hukuk ve Adalet Eleştirel Hukuk Dergisi Y.1, S.1, Ocak-Mart 2004, s.134,135. ↑
  31. Mehmet Özcan, “Siber Terörizm ve Ulusal Güvenlik”, İnternet ve Hukuk, Der: Yeşim M. Atamer, İstanbul, İstanbul Bilgi Üniversitesi Yayını, 2004, s.308,309. ↑
  32. Fatih Yamaç/Semih Dokurer/MehmetÖzcan, “Bilişim Suçları” (Çevrimiçi) http://inet-tr.org/inetconf7/bildiriler/86.doc, 11.04.2004; Salıcı/Güneş, a.g.y. ↑
  33. Michael Whine, “Cyberspice – A New Medium for Communication Command and Control by Extremist”, Studies in Conflict and Terrorism, Routledge, Vol.22, N.3, July 1999, s.231; Elcock, a.g.m., s.3. ↑
  34. Whine, Cyberspice, s.234; on anonymity the author states: “…cyberspace provides secret communication and anonymity; this is a trend observed in terrorist acts in recent years…”. ↑
  35. James Ellis/David Fisher/Thomas Longstaff/Linda Pesante/Richard Pethia, Report to the President’s Commision on Critical Infrastructure Protection, Pittsburgh, January 1997, s.3. ↑
  36. Tuğrul Tanyol, “Anarşizm ve İnternet”, Cogito-İnternet: Üçüncü Devrim, Yapı Kredi Yayınları, S.30, Kış 2002, s.207. ↑
  37. Jonn F. Murphy, “Computer Network Attacks by Terrorists: Some Legal Dimensions” SSRNEL, (Çevrimiçi) http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=208671, 02.05.2004. ↑
  38. Stephen F. Thaman, “ABD’de 11 Eylül Açısından Önleyici ve Baskılayıcı Tedbirler”, Hukuki Perspektifler Dergisi, S.5, Aralık 2005, s.110-115. ↑
  39. Berfu Salıcı/İsmail Güneş, “İnternette Güvenlik ve Denetim: Masumiyet Yitiriliyor Mu?” (Çevrimiçi) http://www.bilgiyonetimi.org/cm/pages/mkl_gos.php?nt=243, 14.04.2004. ↑
  40. For details on this subject see: Olgun Değirmenci, Mukayeseli Hukukta ve Türk Hukukunda Suçtan Kaynaklanan Malvarlığı Değerlerini Aklama Suçu, Ankara, Turhan Kitabevi, 2007, s.125 vd. ↑
  41. Whine, Cyberspice., s.232. ↑
  42. Michael Whine, “Communication on Criminal Use of the Internet, European Comission/Europol Report”, April 9, 1997, s.3. ↑
  43. Michael Whine, “Cyber-Terrorism, Foreign Report”, London, September 25, 1997; the report in question states that the website showing how bombs and other explosives are made and used was prepared in the United Kingdom, where the European headquarters of the Hamas organisation is located. ↑
  44. For the dates and list of signatures and ratifications of the Convention see: http://www.conventions.coe.int/Treaty/Commun/ChercheSig. asp?NT=185&CM=8&DF=4/3/2007&CL=ENG, 03.04.2007. ↑
  45. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.105. ↑
  46. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.105,106. ↑
  47. Kayıhan İçel/Yener Ünver, Kitle Haberleşme Hukuku, 6. Bası, İstanbul, Beta Yayıncılık, 2005, s.9-11. ↑
  48. Sevil Yıldız, Suçta Araç Olarak İnternetin Teknik ve Hukuki Yönden İncelenmesi, Ankara, Nobel Yayıncılık, 2007, s.8,9. ↑
  49. M. Şükrü Alpaslan, “21. Yüzyılda Da Terör Gündemde Olacak”, Güncel Hukuk, S.1, Ocak 2004, s.13. ↑
  50. Sulhi Dönmezer, Kriminolji, 5. Bası, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1975, s.239. ↑
  51. Benjamin Netanyahu, “Terrorism and the Media. Abdication of Responsibility”, The Jonathan Institute, The Jerusalem Conference on International Terrorism, July 2 – 5, 1979, s.35. ↑
  52. Sabetta, a.g.y., s.150. ↑
  53. Franco Salomone, “Terrorism and the Mass Media”, International Terrorism and Political Crimes, Ed. M. Cherif Bassiouni, Springfield Illinois, Charles C. Thomas Publisher, 1975, s.44. ↑
  54. J.S. Rosen/R. Frank, “Measures Against International Terorism”, International Terorism and World Security, Ed. David Carlton/Carlo Schaerf, New York, Halsted Press, 1975, s.63. ↑
  55. M. Cherif Bassiouni, “The Media and Terrorism”, A Seminar Sponsored by Chicago Sun Times and Chicago Daily News, 1977, QUDARNI, Vol II, 1978, s.137. ↑
  56. Dülger, Kitle İletişim Araçları, s.6. ↑
  57. Dülger, Kitle İletişim Araçları, s.6. ↑
  58. Patric Murphy, “The Media and Terrorism”, A Seminar Sponsored by Chicago Sun Times and Chicago Daily News, 1977, QUDARNI, Vol II, 1978, s.141. ↑
  59. Murphy, The Media and Terrorism, s.141. ↑
  60. Sulhi Dönmezer, “Her Yönü İle Tedhiş”, Son Havadis, 10 – 13 Kasım 1977, s.7. ↑
  61. Çetin Özek, Basın Özgürlüğünden Bilgilenme Hakkına, İstanbul, Alfa Yayıncılık, 1999, s.15–36. ↑
  62. Çetin Özek, Türk Basın Hukuku, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1978, s.283 vd. ↑
  63. For the debates conducted and the views put forward on this subject in the field of the internet see: Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, s.328-330. ↑
  64. M. Şükrü Alpaslan, “Avrupa İnsan Hakları Sözleşmesi Uygulamasında Düşünce ve Basın Özgürlüğü”, Prof. Dr. Sahir Erman’a Armağan, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Eğitim Öğretim ve Yardımlaşma Vakfı Yayını, 1999, s.30. ↑
  65. Murat Volkan Dülger, “Avrupa İnsan Hakları Sözleşmesi’nde Düşünce Özgürlüğü”, Prof. Dr. Çetin Özek Armağanı, İstanbul, Galatasaray Üniversitesi Yayını, 2004, s.297,298. ↑
  66. John B. Wolf, “Controlling Political Terrorism in a Free Society”, ORBIS, Vol.XIX, No.34, Winter 1976, s.1298. ↑
  67. Sulhi Dönmezer, “Basında Oto-Kontrol”, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Mecmuası, C.XLI, S.1-4, 1969, s.3; Sulhi Dönmezer, Basın ve Hukuku, İstanbul, İstanbul Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Yayını, 1976, s.344. ↑
  68. William J. Small, “The Media and Terrorism”, A Seminar Sponsored by Chicago Sun Times and Chicago Daily News, 1977, QUDARNI, Vol II, 1978, s.143. ↑
  69. For details on this subject see Durmuş Tezcan, “Terörle Mücadelede İşbirliği Sorunu”, Hukuki Perspektifler Dergisi, S.5, Aralık 2005, s.103-107. ↑
  70. Özcan, a.g.y., s335,336. ↑
  71. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, 324,325. ↑
  72. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, 325. ↑
  73. Dülger, Bilişim Suçları, 333. ↑
  74. Ali Murat Vural, “Medyanın Toplumsal İşlevleri ve Medya Profesyonellerinin Sorumluluğu”, Güncel Hukuk, S.40, Nisan 2007, s.22. ↑
  75. Nurdoğan Rigel, Kağıt Kaplanlar, İstanbul, Der Yayınları, 1993, s.125. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic