9 November 2018Murat Volkan DülgerCommentary

Introduction

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

On 30 October 2018 six members of parliament submitted to the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye the “Bill Amending Certain Laws and Decree-Laws Relating to Health” (the bill). The bill, which is currently on the agenda, aims to regulate many matters, from rules on preventing violence against healthcare workers to extending the scope of the smoking ban. The bill, which has had wide public resonance and is described in the medical community as the “violence in healthcare law”, consists of forty articles. The subject of this article, however, is confined to my assessment of Articles 17 and 18 of the bill, which contain the rules on organ and tissue transplantation and on surrogacy and sperm donation.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger*

On 30.10.2018 six members of parliament submitted to the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye the “Bill on the Amendment of Certain Laws and Decree-Laws relating to Health” (the Bill).

The Bill now on the agenda aims to regulate a great many matters, ranging from provisions on the prevention of violence against healthcare workers to the extension of the scope of the smoking ban. The Bill, which has met with a wide response among the public and has been described in the medical community as the “violence in healthcare law”, consists of forty articles. The subject of this paper, however, is confined to my assessment of Articles 17 and 18 of the Bill, which contain the provisions on organ and tissue transplantation and on surrogacy and sperm donation.

An Overview of Organ and Tissue Transplantation, Surrogacy and Sperm Banks

Since the beginning of human existence, people have struggled with various health problems and tried to overcome them. Over time this became a public service assumed by society and the modern state and, in parallel, a field governed by legal norms. For this reason, developing new methods of treatment, curing diseases, improving the quality of life and prolonging life are among the aims that societies and states have set themselves, and work has been carried on continuously in pursuit of these aims. Technological developments in medical science in particular, the increase in opportunities for travel throughout the world and the rapid spread of the health tourism sector have led people to try many methods in the hope of finding a cure, but have at the same time brought with them the use of human beings as guinea pigs as well as socio-economic problems and dilemmas.

Organ and tissue transplantation is one of the most important of these developments. At the point which today’s medical science and (biomedical) technology have reached, organ or tissue transplants can be carried out provided that the necessary conditions are met, and both the length and the quality of human life are thereby increased. What is more, organ transplantation is today accepted as a valid method of treatment for many advanced-stage diseases. According to official data, approximately 25,000 patients in our country are waiting for an organ transplant1.

The lack of a sufficient number of donors to meet this need drives patients waiting for an organ, in the hope of being saved, towards transplant tourism and the purchase of organs for money, while it drives the economically weak to sell organs illegally. Unfortunately the situation is no different in the world at large. It is frequently said that India in particular is Asia’s black market for kidneys. Various sources state that a similar situation also exists with regard to the refugees who have been forced to flee Syria because of the civil war.

An organ denotes a part of the body which performs a specific function and whose boundaries are precisely defined; a tissue denotes the totality of cells forming one of the structural elements of a body or of an organ. Organ transplantation, for its part, is the procedure whereby an organ that can no longer perform its function in the body is replaced by a healthy organ, taken from a living donor or from a deceased person, which will assume the same function. It is this subject of organ and tissue transplantation – today accepted as a valid method of treatment for advanced-stage diseases and, from a legal point of view, perhaps the most controversial of all – that Article 17 of the Bill submitted to Parliament seeks to regulate anew.

By the provisions contained in Articles 17 and 18 of the Bill it is also sought to prohibit surrogacy and sperm donation. In United States practice, the term “surrogate mother” is used for a woman who, under a surrogacy contract, in return for a specified fee and assuming various obligations – for example not to smoke or drink alcohol, to see a physician at regular intervals, to lead a particular way of life and to hand the child over to its parents after the birth – carries an embryo transferred from another, married couple and gives birth to the child2. Sperm donation is the name given to the legal transaction whereby healthy sperm, whose capacity to fertilise has been established beforehand by all the necessary tests, is stored by cooling and then given to a person or persons who are unable to have children; the centres at which this procedure is generally carried out are called sperm banks.

The subjects of “in vitro fertilisation” treatment, to which couples wishing to have children resort with great hopes in our country in particular, and of “surrogacy” and “sperm donation and sperm banks”, which it has recently been sought to prohibit on the ground that they are incompatible with the value judgements of our society but which are widely practised throughout the world, have likewise been made subject to regulation in Article 18 of the Bill, entitled “assisted reproductive treatment practices”.

Assessment of the General Explanatory Memorandum of the Bill

The general explanatory memorandum of the Bill emphasises that work is being done on matters such as health promotion and healthy-living programmes for a better future, multi-faceted health responsibility for inter-sectoral cooperation, and cross-border health services and health tourism that will increase the country’s strength in the international arena.

It is further stated that the Bill is intended, with a view to protecting lineage, in other words parentage, to regulate matters such as donation in assisted reproductive treatment practices, the non-use of reproductive cells and embryos in other persons, and surrogacy, and to introduce sanctions for conduct in breach thereof, and also to extend general health insurance in respect of assisted reproductive treatment (in vitro fertilisation) practices.

First of all, where a matter such as unlawful organ and tissue transplantation and transplant tourism – which the law brings within the scope of a prohibition and which is a common problem of all the nations of the world and of humanity – is concerned, the mere fact that it is prohibited by law, or that conduct in breach of the prohibition is made an offence and subjected to a sanction, is not sufficient to prevent the commission of these offences. These acts should be made offences; but, having regard to the economic and social inequalities among the members of society, work must also urgently be undertaken to remedy those inequalities. Unless this is done, it is truly very difficult to cope with the illegal trade in organs. For what is at stake is human life.

I must also state that it is not sound from the standpoint of criminal policy for the Bill to seek to prohibit, on the ground of protecting lineage, matters such as sperm donation and sperm banks and surrogacy – which I regard as practices that ought not to be prohibited but to be applied subject to regulation – and to provide for criminal sanctions where they are practised. For even if doing these things is made an offence, it will not be possible to prevent persons who are willing and have the money from having these procedures carried out abroad. I therefore consider that this provision, which is sought to be introduced out of purely political concerns, is mistaken; that a matter which cannot be prohibited ought to be brought under control by being regulated; and that this is a more appropriate method for public health.

Assessment of the Content of the Bill

a. Assessment with regard to Organ and Tissue Transplantation

Under Article 15, entitled “Prohibited acts”, of Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues, which is currently in force:

“Those who remove, store, graft or transplant organs and tissues in contravention of this Law, and those who buy and sell them, act as intermediaries in their purchase and sale or act as brokers therein, shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of two to four years and to a heavy fine of 50,000 to 100,000 liras, unless the act calls for a heavier penalty”.

Article 17 of the Bill at issue provides that Article 91 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK) shall apply to persons who unlawfully remove, sell, purchase, act as intermediaries in the sale of, store, transplant or graft organs and tissues, or who place or publish notices or advertisements aimed at procuring organs or tissues. In this connection, the provision of Article 91 of the Turkish Criminal Code referred to, which is entitled “trade in organs and tissues”, reads:

“(1) Any person who removes an organ from a person without consent that is valid in law shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of five to nine years. (2) Where the object of the offence is tissue, a term of imprisonment of two to five years shall be imposed. Any person who unlawfully removes an organ or tissue from a deceased person shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of up to one year. (3) A person who purchases or sells an organ or tissue or acts as an intermediary in its sale shall be liable to the penalties specified in the first paragraph. (4) Where the offences defined in the first and third paragraphs are committed within the framework of the activities of an organisation, a term of imprisonment of eight to fifteen years and a judicial fine of up to ten thousand days shall be imposed. (5) Any person who stores, transplants or grafts an organ or tissue obtained by unlawful means shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of two to five years. (6) Any person who, in return for a certain benefit, places or publishes a notice or advertisement aimed at procuring organs or tissues shall be punished with imprisonment for a term of up to one year. (7) Where the offences defined in this Article are committed within the framework of the activities of a legal person, the security measures specific to legal persons shall be imposed on the legal person. (8) Where the commission of the offence defined in the first paragraph results in the death of the victim, the provisions on the offence of intentional killing shall apply.”

In this way the aim is to achieve harmony between Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues, which is a special law, and the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, which is a general law, without entering into a conflict between special law and general law. It is also sought to extend the scope of the above-mentioned Article 15 of Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues. I should like to say that the objective pursued is a positive step in that it removes the conflict between the laws and extends the scope of the offence. In my view this provision, which ought to have been made when the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 entered into force, is in fact overdue. For the provision in the TCK is an offence that is far more comprehensive, has been drafted with various eventualities in mind and carries sanctions that are more proportionate to the offence. In this way it is sought to put an end both to the differing views on this matter in legal scholarship and to the divergent approaches in practice. Where the TCK contains a provision on this matter, including a similar provision in the special law is wrong from the standpoint of legislative technique. This provision also removes that error.

Another point I wish to touch upon in this connection is that paragraph 1 of Article 22, entitled “Administrative Sanctions”, of the Regulation on Organ and Tissue Transplantation Services currently contains the following provision:

“(1) It is prohibited for physicians and other persons to open private centres for the purpose of carrying out organ and tissue transplantation, or to carry out organ and tissue transplantation, without possessing the qualifications and meeting the conditions laid down by this Regulation and without obtaining permission from the Ministry. The activities of centres found not to have complied with this prohibition shall be suspended by the Ministry and the provisions of the relevant legislation shall be applied to them.”

Such is the provision as it stands. By Article 17 of the Bill, Article 15 of Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues has been amended to read:

“…The certificates and permits of persons who are found to have committed an act in contravention of Additional Article 1 of this Law shall be revoked and they shall not be permitted to work in the relevant field. It is prohibited to open an organ transplantation centre or an assisted reproductive treatment centre without obtaining permission from the Ministry. In respect of health institutions and establishments operating in contravention of this Law and of the procedures and principles laid down by the Ministry, the Ministry shall apply the sanction of suspension of activity or revocation of the operating licence, depending on the nature of the act and on whether it has been repeated.”

In this way the aim is to ensure harmony and uniformity between the law and the regulation in the application of sanctions. Since centres of this kind work directly on human health, it is in any event as it should be that they are opened and operate with the permission of the Ministry. It is also appropriate that sanctions extending as far as closure are provided for these centres where they fail to comply with the rules.

In accordance with the principle of the social state, the state is under an obligation to protect the health of its citizens and to provide the necessary services. Indeed, as stated in Article 2 of the Constitution of 1982, “The Republic of Türkiye is a democratic, secular and social state governed by the rule of law, within the notions of public peace, national solidarity and justice, respecting human rights, loyal to the nationalism of Atatürk, and based on the fundamental principles set forth in the preamble”. Consequently, to open an organ and tissue transplantation centre or to carry out organ and tissue transplantation without obtaining the necessary permits from the official institutions of the state, or without the necessary inspections having been carried out, means, so to speak, playing with human life. In order to prevent this, it is as it should be that provision is made for the sanction of suspension of their activities or closure.

It must not be forgotten, however, that the fact that penalties are laid down by law or involve severe sanctions does not mean that the laws are vigorously enforced in the country concerned. For a sanction to be a deterrent, it must be applied with certainty.

i. The Marriage Requirement for Organ and Tissue Transplantation

Paragraph 1 of Article 16, entitled “organ transplantation and donation from living persons”, of the Regulation on Organ and Tissue Services, which entered into force upon publication in the Official Gazette on 01.02.2012, reads as follows:

“Organ transplantation from a living person may be carried out from the spouse with whom the recipient has actually been living for at least two years and from relatives by blood and by marriage up to the fourth degree (fourth degree included). The recipient, the donor and the results of the transplantation shall be recorded in TODS3.”

The provision in the Regulation requires, for organ transplantation and donation from living persons, that the spouses actually live together. The intention was thus to prevent illegal organ and tissue transplantation attempted by circumventing the law through sham marriages. However, the article contained in Article 18 of the Bill at issue, which is to be added as Additional Article 2 to Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues, lays down only a requirement of marriage for organ donation and transplantation from living persons and does not require that the spouses have actually lived together for two years within the marital union. It provides:

“Organ transplantation from a living person may be carried out from the spouse to whom the recipient has been married for at least two years and from relatives by blood and by marriage up to the fourth degree (fourth degree included). Where the disease requiring organ transplantation is diagnosed after the marriage, the requirement that the spouses have been married for at least two years shall not apply.”

The Bill makes no amendment to the Regulation. It would not be surprising, however, if, should the Bill become law in this form, the Regulation were also brought into line with the law within a short time. In my view, by contrast, what ought to be done is to incorporate this condition of the Regulation unchanged into the law as well. On the other hand, the explanatory memorandum to Article 18 of the Bill, which provides for the amendment, still requires that “the spouses have actually lived together for two years”. It therefore seems that in the first version of the Bill this condition was required, as it is in the Regulation, but that by a sudden amendment made later the phrase was removed from the text of the Bill while the phrase in the explanatory memorandum was forgotten; that, at any rate, is the impression this state of affairs conveys. In my view, what ought to be done is to retain in the law, unchanged, the Regulation’s requirement of actually living together for two years.

In my view such a provision is, as I have already said, liable – in a country where approximately 25,000 people are waiting for an organ transplant – to lead to the hollowing out and abuse of the institutions of family and marriage, which form the smallest building block of society. Just as there may be couples who marry solely in the hope of being cured, so too, were economically powerful persons to resort to sham marriages with poor persons in return for money, this would amount to a kind of black-market trade in organs. It should therefore not be overlooked that such a provision, if enacted, will cause unease in society, and its consequences should be considered now.

Another new provision introduced by the Bill is that the requirement of two years of marriage does not apply where a disease that emerges some time after the marriage and requires organ transplantation is diagnosed. While this is reasonable and logical, it is a provision that lends itself to abuse; for that reason it should be required that the spouses have actually lived together from the time the marriage took place until the diagnosis was made, and an effort should thus be made to prevent, as far as possible, sham marriages and, most importantly, the illegal trade in organs.

ii. Establishment of the Organ Transplantation Evaluation Ethics Commissions and

the National Organ Transplantation Ethics Board

The “National Organ Transplantation Ethics Board”, for which no provision was made in the Regulation on Organ and Tissue Services that entered into force upon publication in the Official Gazette on 01.02.2012, will come into operation if the Bill now on the agenda becomes law. Under the proposed provision, a “National Organ Transplantation Ethics Board” will be established to examine objections lodged against the decisions of the “Organ Transplantation Evaluation Ethics Commissions”, which were regulated in a similar manner in the earlier regulation4 as well and which are to be set up in every province for the purpose of evaluating organ transplants from living persons from an ethical point of view.

At present, the decisions of the ethics commissions established in the provinces are challenged before the administrative courts, and in some cases the administrative court orders a stay of execution of the decision of the ethics board, whereupon the organ transplant is carried out. A subsequent decision dismissing the action then no longer has any meaning, for the organ has long since been transplanted into the recipient. Since the administrative court is not itself expert in this field, it decides on the basis of an examination which it has had carried out by experts and of the report it has obtained. These experts, however, generally consist of surgeons who perform organ transplants. Yet the reports given by these persons contain only an examination from the surgical point of view, and what is involved is a medical approval. In the ethics boards, by contrast, the matter is addressed in all its dimensions, with even a member of the police and a lawyer being included, and it is considered not only in its medical but also in its ethical and legal dimension. It is therefore an extremely positive development that the authority hearing objections against the decisions of these boards is to be not the administrative courts but a national ethics board of this kind.

If, however, by a possible amendment to the Bill, recourse to the administrative courts is opened against the decision to be given by the national ethics board, the qualifications of the specialists who must sit on the panel of experts to be appointed in such cases should be specified separately and expressly, and an effort should be made to constitute a panel of experts similar in structure to the ethics board. Accordingly, the professional competence of the persons who are to make up this board, which is to be established in a field in which human life is at stake, should also be subjected to a very thorough assessment. In conclusion, I consider this to be an extremely positive provision which answers the needs and expectations of practice.

b. Assessment with regard to Surrogacy and Sperm Donation

In surrogacy, the egg and sperm cells taken from volunteer couples are combined in the laboratory and, once an embryo has been formed, transferred to the surrogate mother. Thereafter the birth takes place once the foetus has completed the nine-month period in the surrogate mother’s womb. This practice is a ray of hope particularly for women who, at a young age and before being able to become mothers, have permanently lost their uterus because of various diseases, in that it enables them to have a child from their own genes/eggs.

In many societies it has been regarded as normal, very often because of infertility or because the physical constitution is unsuited to pregnancy, for some sisters or female friends to act as surrogate mothers purely out of a wish to do good5. In Iran, for example, the practice of surrogacy is encountered, and in some medical centres in Tehran, Isfahan and other cities surrogacy is offered as an option for infertile couples.

i. The Prohibition of Surrogacy with a View to Protecting Lineage

With the development of science and technology, practices based on new reproductive techniques have emerged. Two of these, which have also given rise to debate from the legal and ethical points of view, are “surrogacy” and “sperm donation”. Whereas activities of this kind were prohibited by the “Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres”6 of 2010, the Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres7 of 2014 did not regulate these activities as falling within the scope of a prohibition.

It is now sought to reintroduce this prohibition, which is not laid down in the Regulation, by Article 18 of the Bill, which adds to Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues, as Additional Article 1, the provision: “It is prohibited to have a child by applying to other persons reproductive cells taken from one or both of the spouses and the embryo obtained from these cells, and to act as a surrogate mother.”

Furthermore, by Article 17 of the Bill, procedures such as donation, the use of reproductive cells and embryos in other persons and surrogacy are also made offences in Article 15, entitled “prohibited acts”, of Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues. It provides:

“Those who donate, graft, possess, use, store or transfer embryos and reproductive cells in contravention of this Law, and those who buy and sell them, act as intermediaries in their purchase and sale or act as brokers therein, or persons who encourage or direct others towards these acts or who place or publish notices or advertisements relating to them, shall be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of three to five years and to a judicial fine of one thousand to two thousand days, unless the act constitutes an offence calling for a heavier penalty…”.

In our country these two methods of reproduction have not found much acceptance, on account of traditions and religious beliefs. Yet no one is being forced to resort to these methods either. If one looks at the explanatory memorandum to the article on the prohibition of surrogacy now being regulated, reference is once again made to the beliefs, value judgements and socio-cultural level of our people. It will of course take time for these practices to be regarded as normal in our country; perhaps they will never be accepted and used by a broad section of society. But democracy is not a system in which the ideas and beliefs of those who form the majority prevail and life is lived according to that majority; it is a system in which the views and preferences of those in the minority are respected at least as much as those of the majority and their rights are protected. Accordingly, even if they are only a minority, those who wish to resort to methods of this kind should be given the opportunity to do so, and they should not be forced into expensive options abroad. Moreover, criminal policy requires that what cannot be prohibited be brought under control by being regulated. I am of the opinion that, rather than taking this opportunity away from couples who live with the longing to have a child, this controversial matter – which, in particular because it has not been placed on a legal footing, drives citizens to have children by illegal means, through trafficking in women and children – ought, for the sake of public health, to be brought under control by being regulated instead of being prohibited.

On the other hand, assuming a situation in which surrogacy – referred to, as the general explanatory memorandum of the Bill also states, in the context of a measure “aimed at protecting lineage” – is not prohibited, the question will arise of how parentage, that is, lineage, is to be established. Under Article 282 of the Turkish Civil Code, parentage between mother and child is established by birth. Well then, as regards parentage: is the mother in law of the child borne by the surrogate mother the surrogate mother, or the woman to whom the egg cells used in forming the embryo transferred to the surrogate mother belong? In such a case the provisions of the Civil Code governing parentage would have to be recast.

ii. The Prohibition of Sperm Donation with a View to Protecting Lineage

By Article 18 of the Bill, the following provision has been added, as Additional Article 1, to Law No. 2238 on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues: “It is prohibited to carry out a donation procedure by using reproductive cells and/or embryos belonging to another person and, for this purpose, to donate, sell, possess, use, store, transport, import or export reproductive cells and/or embryos or to act as an intermediary in these transactions.” As I have stated above, by the amendment proposed to Article 15 of Law No. 2238 it is sought at the same time to make these acts offences.

There are two main approaches to sperm donation. According to the first, in order to be able to speak in law of a “human being”, the condition of being born complete and alive is required, which under Art. 28 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 is at the same time the moment at which personality is acquired. Consequently a foetus that has not been born complete and alive, or sperm, has not yet acquired the status of a human being. Indeed, offences such as intentional killing or intentional injury, which are regulated in the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK) and can be committed against a living human being, cannot be committed against a foetus/sperm, for these are not regarded as human beings. That being so, whether purchasing sperm constitutes trade in human beings in law is a controversial matter (it must be emphasised here that the trade in human beings referred to is not the “human trafficking” regulated as a criminal provision in Art. 80 TCK, but the making of a human being the object of any commercial activity). Consequently, just as sperm donation is possible, so too is it normal to have a child in this way.

The other view, which is opposed to sperm donation, argues both that human beings and biological products derived from human beings cannot be made the object of commerce and cannot be bought and sold like market goods, and that such a practice ought not to be carried out on the ground that, because of the general beliefs of society, it would run counter to the Turkish family structure and to the socio-cultural structure of our country. According to this group, the prevailing view in society is that “the birth of fatherless children is not looked upon kindly”.

With developing technologies, the point reached by medical science offers many innovations to human life. Prohibiting these innovations, as is done in our country, may sometimes lead to quite different results; for example, it will direct individuals towards illegal sperm donation or abroad. For that reason, scientific developments throughout the world on this subject should first be followed from the legal, medical and ethical points of view, and only then should the statutory provisions sought to be made be placed on a rational legal footing. Otherwise, should provisions be enacted which, like those in the Bill at issue, in some respects provide for nothing but offences, sanctions and prohibition and are not based on a broad perspective, it will be inevitable that greater social problems and offences will be encountered.

Conclusion

Articles 17 and 18 of the “Bill on the Amendment of Certain Laws and Decree-Laws relating to Health”, submitted to the Grand National Assembly of Türkiye on 30.10.2018, contain its provisions on organ and tissue transplantation and on surrogacy and sperm banks. I can summarise the findings, conclusions and proposals set out in this article as follows:

• The Bill at issue has been prepared, as regards illegal organ and tissue transplantation and trade, in a manner parallel to earlier practice, and, although overdue, it is positive and encouraging in that it removes the discrepancy between the provisions of the law and of the regulation as regards the application of penalties.

• The provision in the TCK is an offence that is far more comprehensive, has been drafted with various eventualities in mind and carries sanctions that are more proportionate to the offence. In this way it is sought to put an end both to the differing views on this matter in legal scholarship and to the divergent approaches in practice. Where the TCK contains a provision on this matter, including a similar provision in the special law is wrong from the standpoint of legislative technique. This provision also removes that error.

• In accordance with the principle of the social state, the state is under an obligation to protect the health of its citizens and to provide the necessary services. Indeed, as stated in Article 2 of the Constitution, the Republic of Türkiye is a social state governed by the rule of law. Consequently, to open an organ and tissue transplantation centre or to carry out organ and tissue transplantation without obtaining the necessary permits from the official institutions of the state, or without the necessary inspections having been carried out, is, so to speak, to play with human life. In order to prevent this, it is as it should be that provision is made for the sanction of suspension of their activities or closure.

• Where a matter such as unlawful organ and tissue transplantation and transplant tourism – which the law brings within the scope of a prohibition and which is a common problem of all the nations of the world and of humanity – is concerned, the mere fact that it is prohibited by law, or that conduct in breach of the prohibition is made an offence and subjected to a sanction, is not sufficient to prevent the commission of these offences. These acts should be made offences; but, having regard to the economic and social inequalities among the members of society, work must also urgently be undertaken to remedy those inequalities. Unless this is done, it is truly very difficult to cope with the illegal trade in organs. For what is at stake is human life.

• The article which is to be added as Additional Article 2 to the Law on the Removal, Storage, Grafting and Transplantation of Organs and Tissues lays down only a requirement of marriage for organ donation and transplantation from living persons and does not require that the spouses have actually lived together for two years within the marital union. The Bill makes no amendment to the Regulation. It would not be surprising, however, if, should the Bill become law in this form, the Regulation were also brought into line with the law within a short time. In my view, by contrast, what ought to be done is to incorporate this condition of the Regulation unchanged into the law as well. On the other hand, the explanatory memorandum to Article 18 of the Bill, which provides for the amendment, still requires that “the spouses have actually lived together for two years”. This therefore gives the impression that in the first version of the Bill this condition was required, as it is in the Regulation, but that by a sudden amendment made later the phrase was removed from the text of the Bill while the phrase in the explanatory memorandum was forgotten. In my view, what ought to be done is to retain in the law, unchanged, the Regulation’s requirement of actually living together for two years.

• A National Organ Transplantation Ethics Board will be established to examine objections lodged against the decisions of the Organ Transplantation Evaluation Ethics Commissions, which are to be set up in every province for the purpose of evaluating organ transplants from living persons from an ethical point of view. It is an extremely positive development that the authority hearing objections against the decisions of these boards is to be not the administrative courts but a national ethics board of this kind. If, however, by a possible amendment to the Bill, recourse to the administrative courts is opened against the decision to be given by the national ethics board, the qualifications of the specialists who must sit on the panel of experts to be appointed in such cases should be specified separately and expressly, and an effort should be made to constitute a panel of experts similar in structure to the ethics board.

• The Bill has also prohibited “surrogacy” and “sperm donation” by mandatory provisions. As I have already said, medical practices such as surrogacy and sperm banks are practices that ought not to be prohibited but to be applied subject to regulation, and

a statutory framework specifically devoted to the matter needs to be established as soon as possible, with similar practices in the world also being taken into account.

• I must also state that it is not sound from the standpoint of criminal policy for the Bill to prohibit, on the ground of protecting lineage, matters such as sperm donation and surrogacy – which I regard as practices that ought not to be prohibited but to be applied subject to regulation – and to provide for conduct in breach thereof to be made an offence. For even if doing these things is made an offence, persons who are willing and have the money cannot be prevented from having these procedures carried out abroad. I therefore consider that this provision, which is sought to be introduced out of purely political concerns, is mistaken; that a matter which cannot be prohibited ought to be brought under control by being regulated; and that this is a more appropriate method for public health.

Footnotes

  1. Member of the faculty for Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure Law and IT Law, Yeditepe University Faculty of Law / Attorney-at-Law. ↑
  2. https://organkds.saglik.gov.tr/KamuyaAcikRapor.aspx?q=ORGANBEKLEME ↑
  3. Ergun Özsunay, “Taşıyıcı Annelikle ilgili Hukuksal Sorunlar”, Güncel Hukuk Dergisi, Ağustos 2007, s. 28; Canan Bozkurt, “Taşıyıcı Annelikte Akıl Karıştıran Soru: Anne Kim?”, Güncel Hukuk Dergisi, Ağustos 2007, s. 31; Thomas Jäggi/Pierre Widmer, “Innominatverträge”, Festgabe zum 60. Geburtstag von Walter R. Schluep, Zurich 1988, s. 70. ↑
  4. Turkish Organ and Tissue Union System. ↑
  5. In the Regulation on Organ and Tissue Services, which entered into force upon publication in the Official Gazette on 01.02.2012, it was designated the “Ethics Commission”. ↑
  6. Özsunay, s. 28. ↑
  7. Resmi Gazete, 06.03.2010, 27513. ↑
  8. Resmi Gazete, 30.09.2014, 29135. ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic