2019Murat Volkan Dülger, Neslihan CanArticle

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

This study examines, on a comparative basis, the version revised in 2018 of the “Declaration of Istanbul”, one of the most important documents issued on organ trafficking and organ transplantation.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan Dülger1

Research Assistant Neslihan Can2

INTRODUCTION

Organ transplantation, which may be regarded as one of the most important miracles of the last century, is a hope for those whose organs have ceased to function; yet it has not only been a hope of treatment but has at the same time given rise to a new illegal sector called organ trafficking. For this reason, a number of instruments have been adopted at national and international level in order to prevent the human body from becoming a commodity and the product of this sector. The Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (Biomedicine Convention), which the Council of Europe opened for signature in 1997 and to which Türkiye is also a party, expressly provides that the human body and its parts may not be the subject of commercial gain. Consequently, although the donor has consented to the violation of his own bodily integrity for the benefit of the recipient, he will not be able to obtain a benefit in return.

Organ trafficking also constitutes one strand of the fight against trafficking in human beings at the level of the United Nations and the Council of Europe. Accordingly, the States that are parties to the binding international conventions drawn up under the leadership of these organisations combat organ trafficking in a deterrent and preventive manner. However, since the conventions mentioned do not relate solely to organ trafficking, they did not provide for acts capable of establishing the distinction between organ transplantation and organ trafficking and were unable to afford specific protection.

The first international-level document in which sharp definitions of organ trafficking and transplant tourism were given is the Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism, proclaimed in 2008. Although the document is not binding, it is important because it was the first to lay down principles and definitions relating to the fight against organ trafficking. The Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs, which entered into force in 2018, is also consistent with the Declaration and directs the Contracting States to enact criminal provisions and to establish acts in the nature of organ trafficking as types of offence in order to combat organ trafficking effectively. The Declaration does not merely serve as a guide for international conventions; it also recommends that States, in order to combat organ trafficking, establish at the same time an effective system of organ transplantation and donation and thereby remove the need for persons to turn to organ trafficking.

In our study, the international conventions relating to organ trafficking will be mentioned briefly, and the innovations introduced by the version, revised in 2018, of the Declaration of Istanbul, which was proclaimed in 2008 and which seeks, by means of its principles, to ensure standardisation in the fight against organ trafficking and transplant tourism, will be assessed.

A. Legal Bases

1) Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the Application of Biology and Medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (1997)

Art. 21 of the Biomedicine Convention states that the human body and its parts may not, by reason of that character, be the subject of commercial gain. It is nevertheless possible to remove organs and tissue from a living donor or from a cadaver for the purpose of transplantation. The recipient may benefit from treatment by the transplantation of an organ or tissue removed from a living person where there is no suitable organ or tissue that can be taken from a deceased person and no other method of treatment. However, in Art. 5, as a specific manifestation of the principle of autonomy, the Convention requires the donor’s consent in this matter, given expressly and specifically, in writing or before an official body. The Additional Protocol to the Convention, which entered into force in 2002, also orders the Contracting States to apply appropriate sanctions where the human body is made the subject of commercial gain and this prohibition is thereby violated3.

2) Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime (2003)

According to Art. 3 of this Protocol, which was drawn up essentially in order to combat trafficking in human beings, trafficking in human beings is defined comprehensively4 and is determined as the procurement, delivery, transportation and transfer of persons for the purpose of exploitation. The removal of a person’s organs is also inherent in the concept of exploitation. Where a person’s organs are removed by deceiving him through the methods specified in the Article, the removal of the organs is regarded as trafficking in human beings even if the victim consents to this exploitation.

3) Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings (2005)

It is an instrument produced by the Council of Europe with the aim of developing the standards in the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. The Convention defined trafficking in human beings in a manner consistent with the concept of trafficking in human beings. Accordingly, the removal of the organs of victims by the means listed in Art. 4 or by deception is trafficking in human beings.

4) Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism (2008)

In 2008, at the end of the meeting of The Transplantation Society (TTS) and the International Society of Nephrology (ISN) at which participants from member countries of the Council of Europe and the United Nations and from different disciplines, above all medical experts, came together in Istanbul and at which an attempt was made to achieve standardisation with regard to organ transplantation and the prevention of organ smuggling, a number of principles were set out under the name of the Declaration of Istanbul on Organ Trafficking and Transplant Tourism. Although the Declaration is not legally binding, it is important in that it lays down common principles. For its main purpose, as is also stated in its explanatory report, is to provide ethical guidance to professionals and to legislators. The Declaration stated that a distinction must be drawn between the removal of organs carried out in return for an economic benefit and organ donation, that the human body must be prevented from being made the subject of economic gain, that organ donation must be encouraged, that a reliable data system on organ trafficking must be established and that States must adopt a common definition of organ trafficking.

According to the Declaration, organ trafficking means the following:

a) the removal of organs from a cadaver or from a living person without valid consent or the authorisation of the administrative authority, or the removal of organs in exchange for an economic or other benefit to the donor or to a third person

b) the transportation, manipulation and transplantation of these organs and their use for other purposes

c) the requesting or offering of an unlawful benefit by health personnel, a State authority or an employee of a private institution for the removal of organs or for the facilitation of their removal

d) the recruitment and inducement of recipients and donors in exchange for an economic or other benefit

e) attempting, aiding and instigating the commission of the acts mentioned

This is what organ trafficking means.

Another definition in the Declaration is that of trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal. According to this definition, which is also consistent with the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime:

“the transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons by means of threat, use of force or other coercion, their abduction, their deception, their being led into error, the abuse of their vulnerability, the making of payments or the provision of other benefits in order to obtain their consent, or the taking advantage of their being in a position of difficulty, for the purpose of the removal of their organs”

constitutes trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal.

According to the Declaration, what is to be understood by the term resident is a person who lives in a country irrespective of any bond of citizenship, whereas what is to be understood by the term non resident is a person who lives in a place temporarily, who travels to a place or who is in a place for the purpose of transplantation.

Travel for transplantation, for its part, is the crossing of different jurisdictional borders by persons for the purpose of organ transplantation. This travel becomes transplant tourism where it involves trafficking in persons for the removal of their organs in an unethical manner or organ trafficking, or where State bodies, members of the health professions or private transplant centres make the transplant services of the country in which they are located available for transplants to non-residents without regard to the population of persons in need of a transplant in that country.

Self sufficiency in organ donation and transplantation, for its part, means that States are in a position to carry out transplants for those resident in the country by using the transplantation and donation services within their own countries and, as far as their means allow, to share resources with persons in other jurisdictions as well. Self-sufficiency must be the fundamental aim of States in organ transplantation and donation, for it is because States are not self-sufficient in terms of transplant services that persons may turn to organ trafficking.

Financial neutrality means that donors and their families neither suffer an economic loss nor obtain a gain on account of organ donation. While it is understandable that the donor should be unable to obtain a benefit, so that the human body and its parts are not reduced to the status of a commodity, a person cannot be expected to consent to organ transplantation by putting his own life at risk either; the removal of the organ and the donor’s medical care and treatment in the subsequent period must therefore not give rise to a burden for the donor. For, although there is no medical indication in respect of the donor, he has been subjected to a medical intervention for the benefit of the recipient and must also be protected by special provisions. Otherwise, donating organs will not be a preferable course for persons and there will be a turn to organ trafficking. In order to prevent this, the original version of the Declaration provided that the medical care and follow-up of the living donor, covered by general health insurance or by private insurance, must be carried out during and also after the organ donation. That is to say, the payments to be made for the donor at this point essentially do not constitute consideration for the donation but are part of the legitimate cost of treating the recipient by reason of the organ transplant.

Although the Declaration of Istanbul is not a legally binding document, its impact has been very considerable and it has become a document used as a reference by many bodies, above all the European Union and the Council of Europe. Although the Declaration defines a number of acts and lists them as acts constituting organ trafficking and transplant tourism, since it is expressly not binding it has encouraged States to combat these acts5.

The Declaration has also had effects in respect of Turkish law, and, since the inability to establish what kind of relationship exists between the recipient and the donor may give rise to a suspicion of organ trafficking, a kinship requirement was introduced under Art. 9(1)(f) of the Directive on the National Organ and Tissue Transplantation Coordination System. It was thus provided that transplants may be made from a living donor to relatives by blood and by marriage up to (and including) the fourth degree, and that, in respect of persons who do not satisfy this kinship requirement, permission must be obtained from the ethics committee.

5) Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs (2015)

The Committee on Crime Problems, the Steering Committee on Bioethics and the European Committee on Organ Transplantation, which met in 2011 at the invitation of the Committee of Ministers, came to the conclusion that the existing binding international conventions contained significant gaps, and, in order to combat organ trafficking, the Council of Europe felt the need to draw up a new convention. For under the conventions mentioned, a person who consented to the removal of his organ was not regarded as a victim for the purposes of organ trafficking.

As is also stated in the explanatory report of the Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs6, organ trafficking is incompatible with human dignity and the right to life and at the same time poses a serious threat to public health. The purpose of drawing up the Convention is to create new types of offence in addition to the acts that already exist in international instruments and that impose on the States Parties an obligation to define them as offences in their domestic law, and ultimately to eliminate organ trafficking. Consequently, for the purposes of combating and preventing organ trafficking, which it characterises as a global threat, the Council of Europe imposes on the Contracting States the obligation to establish a detailed criminal procedure, to determine follow-up mechanisms for the prevention of organ trafficking and also to legislate in terms of substantive criminal law.

The aims of the Convention are not only to combat organ trafficking repressively by introducing criminal provisions, but also to protect victims and to increase international cooperation among the States Parties in order to combat organ trafficking, which has reached a global scale.

The acts which the Convention envisages being established as types of offence are: the unlawful removal of organs (Art. 4); the use of unlawfully removed organs for implantation or other purposes (Art. 5); the implantation of organs outside the domestic transplantation system (Art. 6); unlawfully requesting or offering a benefit, unlawful solicitation and recruitment (Art. 7); the preparation, preservation, storage, transportation, transfer, receipt, export and import of illegally removed organs (Art. 8); and aiding, instigating or attempting the acts listed (Art. 9).

What is to be understood by the illegal removal of an organ is explained in detail in Art. 4 of the Convention. Accordingly, the removal of an organ from a living person or from a cadaver which is not in conformity with domestic law and is not based on free, informed and specific consent is unlawful. The removal or offering of an organ from a living person, a cadaver or a third person in exchange for an economic consideration or a consideration of that kind is also unlawful.

Moreover, the Convention regards as falling within organ trafficking not only the removal of organs for the purpose of transplantation, but also the removal of organs for scientific research, for the collection of organs and cells in the form of the removal of the heart valve from the heart, and for unlawful cell therapy7.

Art. 12 of the Convention provides for the application of criminal sanctions, including penalties involving deprivation of liberty, as the sanction for the acts listed as the use of unlawfully removed organs for implantation or other purposes, unlawfully requesting or offering a benefit, unlawful solicitation and recruitment, and aiding, instigating or attempting the acts which the Convention proposes should be established as offences. These sanctions, which must be dissuasive, effective and proportionate, may in addition take the form of a judicial or administrative fine, temporary or permanent disqualification from commercial activity, intervention in the activity by a State body, or winding-up. Furthermore, the proceeds derived from the types of offence listed by the Convention may also be seized.

B) The Changes Introduced by the 2018 Revision of the Declaration of Istanbul

Although criminal provisions vary in their wording, quid pro quo organ transplantation has essentially been characterised as organ trafficking. Since the proclamation of the Declaration of Istanbul in 2008, the Declaration of Istanbul Custodian Group (DICG), which is made up of professionals and whose activities are financed by the TTS and the ISN, has been disseminating the principles set out in the Declaration. For with the dissemination of the principles, the encouragement of people to donate organs with due regard for ethical principles and the spread of organ transplantation, countries will become self-sufficient in transplantation, which is resorted to as a method of treatment, and organ trafficking and tourism will come to an end8. Thanks also to the efforts of the DICG, important steps have been taken at global level; for example, the provisions concerning the use of organs taken from prisoners in China have been repealed9.

In its original version of 2008, the Declaration did not draw a distinction between organ trafficking and trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal; this distinction was introduced by the 2018 revision.

In the 2008 version, the acts constituting organ trafficking were essentially defined as organ transplantation carried out, in respect of an organ to be taken from a living person or a cadaver, by threat, use of force, other coercion, abduction, leading into error, deception, or by taking advantage of vulnerability and of a precarious situation. That is to say, it did not characterise as organ trafficking a person’s consenting of his own free will to organ transplantation in exchange for an economic benefit. The extension of the definition of organ trafficking to transplantation carried out consensually in exchange for an economic or other benefit was made in order to achieve consistency with Art. 4 of the Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs, which entered into force in 2018. The existence of consent is not sufficient to distinguish organ transplantation from organ trafficking; that consent must in addition be free from any economic or other benefit, the donor must have the capacity to consent and the consent must be informed.

Not prohibiting organ transplantation carried out where the person’s consent exists paves the way for organ trafficking. For in organ trafficking most donors choose to become donors because of poverty and other social problems, and in that case one cannot speak of a consent that is voluntary and free of coercion10. Although this provision may give rise to the criminal liability of the donor, who is one of the parties to organ trafficking and transplant tourism, when the function of the law of protecting the person against himself is also taken into account, characterising consensual transplantation carried out for economic benefit as organ trafficking at the same time serves to protect the recipient and the donor as well.

Although organ transplantation carried out with consent in return for an economic or other benefit constitutes organ trafficking, in this situation the criminal provisions to be enacted should also change, taking into account the Declaration’s perspective on the victim of organ trafficking and on the protection of the victim, and this way of thinking. For instance, a person who has his kidney transplanted in order to obtain an economic benefit should not be regarded as a victim in this case. Undoubtedly, although those who become donors in order to obtain a benefit in this way do so, in most cases, in order to sustain their lives, the donor too must be punished when this phenomenon is combated by means of criminal law. For example, under the type of offence in Art. 91 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, which regulates trafficking in organs and tissues, those who sell their organs and tissues are likewise sentenced to the same penalty as those who remove an organ from a person without legally valid consent. However, the Turkish legislature, also having regard to the economic situation and the hardship in which the person selling his organs and tissues finds himself, provides for a reduction of the penalty or for no penalty to be imposed, as a personal ground mitigating the penalty or a ground for exemption from punishment. While deterrence can be achieved only through criminal provisions of this kind, eliminating the circumstances that drive donors into organ trafficking, and the financial ground on which these persons stand, will in turn be possible through the social policies of the State.

The original version of the Declaration did not distinguish between organ trafficking and trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal; this distinction was introduced in 2018. The entry into force of the European Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs, and the fact that this Convention provides for more detailed and refined rules on organ trafficking than the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings, caused this distinction to be reflected in the Declaration as well.

In listing the acts of trafficking in persons for the purpose of organ removal, the 2018 version of the Declaration starts from the premise that the persons concerned have not given their consent. In other words, where the donor consents of his own free will to acts constituting organ trafficking, this should, according to the Declaration, be punished as organ trafficking; whereas a person who of his own free will consents to trafficking in persons for the removal of his organs should not be punished for organ trafficking.

In the original version of the Declaration, transplant commercialism was defined as the practices and policies that treat an organ as a commodity which can be bought, sold or used for material gain; no such definition is included in the 2018 version. For that definition emphasised the fight against vulnerable groups such as illiterate and impoverished persons, illegal immigrants, prisoners and economic or political refugees becoming the object of organ trafficking and being victimised because of the difficult situation in which they find themselves11. With the 2018 version, however, the Declaration and the international view of organ trafficking changed, and it was accepted that organ donors do not exist solely by reason of a state of necessity and that these donors, too, are perpetrators of the offence of organ trafficking.

The 2018 revision drew a distinction between residents (resident) and non-residents (non resident). The introduction of this definition is important for determining the persons who will be the subject of transplant tourism.

Whereas in 2008 travel for transplantation was the movement of organs, donors, recipients and health professionals specialised in transplantation across a different jurisdictional border for the purpose of transplantation, in 2018 it was described as the movement of persons. It was stated that, in the context of the Declaration, what is to be understood by a jurisdictional border is not only different nations; it also covers travel between states, provinces, other officially defined places within a country, and regional and supranational legal entities with authority to regulate organ donation and transplantation.

Attempting to commit, instigating and aiding the commission of acts constituting organ trafficking, which had not been listed as acts constituting organ trafficking in the original version of the Declaration, have also been included in the definition of organ trafficking as independent types of offence. When the reason for this amendment is examined, it is understood to be to ensure consistency with the type of offence of attempting, instigating and aiding organ trafficking which Art. 9 of the Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs requires the Contracting States to introduce.

The 2008 version, referring to resolution No. 44.25 on the purchase and sale of organs for transplantation of the World Health Assembly (WHA), the governing body of the World Health Organization (WHO), provided for the prohibition and punishment of advertising, including in electronic and print media, of soliciting and of brokering for the purpose of transplant commercialism, organ trafficking and transplant tourism. Indeed, under Art. 21(3) of the Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs, one of the preventive measures that the Contracting States must take at national level is the prohibition of activities such as advertising and promotion carried out for economic benefit or other gain. Incomprehensibly, however, the 2018 version of the Declaration has not laid down a principle on the prohibition of promotional and advertising activities of this kind.

C) Solutions and Proposals

One pillar of the fight against organ smuggling and trafficking is undoubtedly to prevent people who need an organ transplant for their treatment from obtaining that treatment by illegal means. In practice, the fact that in transplantation from a cadaver the relatives are given a say in the matter, even though the person had donated his organs or had made a will to that effect, impedes organ donation.

With developing technology, stem cell therapy and therapeutic cloning (curative cloning) mean the copying of stem cells for the purpose of producing organs. This practice, too, may eliminate the need for organ donation, and since the problem of the organs and tissues obtained being rejected by the body will not arise either, a more effective treatment becomes possible. However, as this will also give rise to new problems, like the many ethical problems encountered at one time until organ transplantation came to be accepted as a method of treatment, it has not yet gained acceptance. In addition, with the development of bioengineering, the transplantation of artificial organs may also become widespread and the need for the transplantation of organs and tissues of human origin may thus be reduced.

In legal terms, too, since the Biomedicine Convention and, in Turkish domestic law, the Regulation on Assisted Reproductive Treatment Practices and Assisted Reproductive Treatment Centres do not permit the creation of embryos solely for research purposes, cloning does not yet appear possible under Turkish law either ethically or legally. Nevertheless, by also making use of the stem cell therapy brought by technology, the need for organ transplantation may be reduced, and it may consequently become possible to combat organ trafficking.

Footnotes

  1. Faculty member, Department of Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Law, Faculty of Law, Istanbul Aydın University, volkan.dulger@dulger.av.tr ↑
  2. Research assistant, Department of Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Law, Faculty of Law, Istanbul Aydın University, neslihancan@aydin.edu.tr ↑
  3. See Art. 26. ↑
  4. “It means the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons for the purpose of exploitation, by means of the use of force or the threat of the use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of influence, of taking advantage of the person’s helplessness, or of the giving of payments or benefits to that person or to others in order to obtain the consent of persons having control over another person. The term exploitation includes, at a minimum, the exploitation of the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs.” ↑
  5. Ata Bozoklar, “İstanbul Deklarasyonunun Önemi”, II. Uluslararası Tıp Hukuku Kongresi Bildiriler Kitabı, Ed. Hakan Hakeri/ Cahid Doğan, Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, 2018, ss.805-809. ↑
  6. The Convention prepared by the Council of Europe was opened for signature in 2015 by the European Union, the member States of the Union, the countries having observer status with the Council of Europe and other non-member States, and entered into force on 01/03/2018. Although Türkiye signed the Convention on 25/03/2015, it has not incorporated it into its domestic law. ↑
  7. Explanatory Report to the Council of Europe Convention against Trafficking in Human Organs, para. 21. ↑
  8. Francis L. Delmonico, The Declaration of Istanbul and Its Global Impact on Organ Transplantation, s.1 https://www.kidneynews.org (27.05.2019). ↑
  9. Delmonico, s.1. ↑
  10. Murat Volkan Dülger, “Organ Bağışı ve Nakline İlişkin Düzenleyici Kuralların Önemi”, II. Uluslararası Tıp Hukuku Kongresi Bildiriler Kitabı, Ed. Hakan Hakeri/ Cahid Doğan, Adalet Yayınevi, Ankara, 2018, ss.781-789. ↑
  11. See Principle 6 “Organ trafficking and transplant tourism violate the principles of equity, justice, and respect for human dignity and should be prohibited. Because transplant commercialism targets impoverished and otherwise vulnerable donors, it leads inexorably to inequity and injustice and should be prohibited” ↑

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic