2019Murat Volkan DülgerArticle

Abstract

This work was written in Turkish. The summary on this page is a translation; the citation gives the original title in parentheses.

I think we should begin with the question of what “blockchain” is. Although it is generally understood as a concept that is mentioned together with bitcoin and is made to seem as if it existed only alongside it, blockchain is in fact a technology that has a wider field of use and also forms the infrastructure of bitcoin. Blockchain is essentially a distributed database that enables data containing value to be stored and managed securely. A software system is the system that makes up the programs enabling electronic devices to perform a particular task, that is, the system that allows us to do what we want on a computer.

They are thus systems that manage the hardware components of the computer and can also create algorithms that allow users to do what they want. This software, too, has to be programmed. That is done with a programming language. There are many programming languages, and each of them also has an architecture.

Full text

This text is a translation of the Turkish original, prepared for this website. Numbers in square brackets are the page numbers of the original; sources in the footnotes are given as in the original. For citation, the original publication (PDF) is authoritative.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Murat Volkan DÜLGER

I think we need to begin first of all with the question “what is blockchain?”.

Although it is generally understood as a concept that is mentioned together with bitcoin and is made to appear as if it existed only with it, blockchain is in fact the technology that has a wider field of use and that also forms the infrastructure of bitcoin.

Blockchain is basically a distributed database that enables data containing value to be stored and managed securely.

volkan.dulger@dulger.av.tr

I. DEFINITION OF BLOCKCHAIN

A software system is the system that makes up the programs enabling electronic devices to perform a particular task, that is, the system that allows us to do the task we want on a computer. Such systems are thus systems that manage the hardware components of the computer and can also create algorithms allowing users to do what they want.

This software, moreover, has to be programmed.

That is done with a programming language. There are many programming languages, and they also have an architecture.

By architecture we mean software architecture.

We encounter two software architectures: centralised and distributed. These architectures are distinguished according to how data are processed, how they are stored and in what way the data are transferred.

As the name indicates, centralised architectures have a single centre, and all the computers are controlled through that centre.

The flow of data, too, can take place only through this centre. In a system with this architecture, the power to alter and delete data lies with the persons at the centre, and third parties can be prevented from accessing the old data in question.

The best example of this is transactions carried out with banks. Frankly,

the crises that have occurred in these systems, which rest on the principle that whoever holds the centre has to be trusted, have begun to steer people towards other systems with a distributed architecture. In the distributed architecture, by contrast, there is a computer belonging to each user, and these computers are on an equal footing. These computers join the system without any centre being needed for the flow, input and output of data. Although it is seen as a more convenient mechanism, freezes may occur when a large number of data are entered into the system at the same time and have to be placed, that is, at the point of coordination. Blockchain, for its part, shows its effect here: it is a technology created so that these failings in the system can be prevented.

Thanks to blockchain, all data are stored on the computers of the persons using the blockchain. It thus becomes impossible for a single person or centre to alter or delete the data. This stems from the immutability function that blockchain has by virtue of its architecture.

Well then, can these data in no way be altered in that case? Of course they can.

But in that case, too, a different

path has to be followed.

In this technology every user can access the data; that is, every user holds a copy of these data. However, a single user cannot alter the data in the blockchain network on his own; for that, the other users also have to

approve these changes. Yet this, although technically possible, is close to impossible to apply, since it requires the chain to be altered from the beginning and every user to approve this. This situation must by now be accepted as “immutable”.

If the technical structure of blockchain is examined in greater depth, it consists, as the name indicates, of the chain of blocks formed by linking together the blocks that hold the data. The security-

providing function of the blocks derives not so much from the data being inaccessible as from the fact that the data entered are not allowed to be altered again.

The impossibility of altering this information is, in turn, ensured by the use of cryptographic hashing and a timestamp.

A block basically consists of two parts: the data, and a header for checking the integrity of the data.

The header, in turn, basically contains the hash value, the Merkle root value, the timestamp and, defined as the variable numerical value used in order to produce the desired block hash value,

the nonce (number used once) value. As will also be touched upon shortly, the “nonce” is the blockchain number that the miners solve. Each block contains the hash information of the block preceding it and generates its own hash information on that basis. The immutable character of the data in the blocks within the blockchain also shows itself at this point. This technology, which forms a virtual chain as it were, is so tightly interlinked internally that a change made in any one of the blocks causes the whole system to change. The process of adding one more block to the block chain is called mining. In the mining system, the data to be processed are first selected. The Merkle root value and the hash value of these data are generated. After the block header containing the information (the Merkle root value, the timestamp, the hash information of the previous block, the nonce value) • has been created, this block header is also hashed and the resulting value is checked in order to determine whether it is a suitable value within the system. Once the hash value has been generated without any problem, a new block has now been added to the chain as well. With this system, new data too are brought into the system as new blocks are added. In this way, both the desired transaction is completed and the correctness of the transaction is confirmed. Another function of blockchain is that, since there is no intermediary institution between buyer and seller, it enables people to carry out their transactions directly over the internet. However, although we may wish to make this concrete in our minds by means of bitcoin, it is not only virtual currencies such as bitcoin that fall within this scope. E-commerce, file sharing or news sharing, too, may perfectly well be

possible through this system. There have even been those who have taken this a stage further. A couple named Edurne & Mayel have had their marriage, over the blockchain,

that is, because the data are not gathered in a single centre, everyone can easily access all the data. Blockchain presents itself as a database in which a great many more personal data are stored, such as who paid how much money to whom and when, who married whom, which immovable property a person bought, which internet network he is connected to, which hospital he went to, and so on. It should also be added, before it is forgotten, that, unlike the centralised architecture, in blockchain, which has a distributed architecture, the data movements carried out on these data can be seen by every user, without any limit of time.

All this transparent order has its negative as well as its positive sides. For it may in this way provide a setting for fraud, for the laundering of the proceeds of crime, for dealings through this system in products whose purchase or sale is prohibited by the legal order and, alongside these, for many other offence types that can be committed by means of information systems. that can be carried out without recognising any borders concluded.

The use of blockchain is not, host even to transactions No state authority whatsoever

in itself, an unlawful a technology that is, as it were, does this couple recognise, and of course

act. For of people in the computer environment the question of this marriage of theirs, in the legal

the policies of countries, too, at sustaining their lives order, and of what kind of validity

rather than at prohibition, a world aimed, before us it will have is subject to separate examination. Here it places.

at keeping pace with this technology and securing a share for themselves What I mean by its having no centre, so are directed. This is seen in a good many further examples, such as the keeping of health records by means of blockchain in the USA (The MediLeger Project, SimplyVital Health, Robomed Network), the use of blockchain in issuing identity cards to migrants in Europe, and Russia’s issuing its own cryptocurrency.

Unofficial records show that the investment made in blockchain today exceeds two billion dollars. Abroad, job advertisements for blockchain software can now be seen. Whoever is able to keep pace with this new technology first will also take the largest slice of the cake.

In Türkiye too, if we bear in mind that the Central Bank has set up a separate working group for blockchain in which the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency, the Capital Markets Board and the Ministry of Treasury will take part, it is clear that initiatives relating to blockchain are being undertaken. These arrangements, however, are directed at commercial life and do not contain any legal regulation.

As can be understood from the examples mentioned, it is clear that this technology, when used efficiently and consciously, will, thanks to the benefits it will provide to individuals and to the state in every area of life

– economic advances such as the emergence of new lines of business, the obtaining of greater benefit with little capital, etc. – place its users in a privileged position in the world arena.

II. LEGAL FIELDS OF USE

Having first given a general introduction to blockchain technology, it is necessary to touch upon which legal transactions can be carried out in this field with this technology and what could be done. For with this rapidly developing new system, countries and individuals have begun to conduct a great many of their affairs by means of blockchain, and with every passing day this technology has begun to be seen in fields of activity that differ from one another. In this continuing process it is likely that areas in which nothing has yet been done but on which work is being carried out, and perhaps areas in which no work has yet been carried out, will also come onto the agenda within a very short time.

A. LEGAL TRANSACTIONS CURRENTLY CARRIED OUT BY MEANS OF BLOCKCHAIN 1. DIGITAL CONTRACTS (SMART CONTRACT)

Digital contracts, also known as smart contracts, have been created so as to be able to produce the legal effects and consequences

of a normal and valid contract. These contracts, which by another definition are characterised as a programmable protocol, contain every kind of arrangement that can be made by a physical contract. In addition, this contract is preferred by the parties because there is no possibility of the contract being destroyed and because it makes it easier to conclude a contract between persons at opposite ends of the world without losing time on a physical meeting.

Savings are thus made in terms of cost, of security and of time alike.

With blockchain technology, every transaction that can be programmed can be turned into a smart contract. For example, for bitcoin transactions to take place, the transfers must have been signed with the relevant key. If we arrange the same transfer system so that it also accepts more than one signature, which blockchain allows, it then becomes possible for contracts to be concluded with the signature of the counterparties as well. Indeed, the concept of the smart contract was put forward on the basis of this system. It should also be pointed out that in smart contracts it is generally Ethereum, rather than bitcoin, that is used.

Once signed, digital contracts remain on every user’s computer; the principle that contracts are to be held by the contracting

parties is satisfied in this way.

For example, a sale of real estate has been carried out over the blockchain for the first time. A person named Mark Ginsburg, living in Kiev, sold his home to another person named Michael Arrington for 600 thousand dollars. This sale, carried out using the smart contract procedure, eliminated the costs of physical contracts, such as legal services, and, by managing a very rapid process as regards the transfer of ownership, made for a much easier transaction. Of course, getting things done by the short route may be the foremost reason for preferring it, given the shortage of time that is the greatest problem of our day. For, as regards the remaining steps, keeping everything in a technology in which it can be held on record for ever, rather than sitting down and signing a mutual contract, is a reason for preference because it allows this to be used both for the security of the legal transaction and as evidence in legal disputes that may arise afterwards.

2. LEGAL ARRANGEMENTS THAT WILL TAKE SHAPE AS THESE ARRANGEMENTS ENCOUNTERED IN COMMERCIAL LIFE ARE MADE •

Money transfers – a means of payment – can be created over the blockchain. Money transfer carried out between individuals has been preferred because it is much quicker and less costly.

Subsequently the banks, too, which witnessed these transactions taking place between individuals, began to place their own internal arrangements on this basis.

In Russia, for example, Sberbank was the first to set up a blockchain-based payment system.

Thus the fact that these transactions carried out at banks take place more quickly, transparently and securely is the principal factor in the sector’s turning to this field.

In Austria, for its part, Bitcoin-Bank has gone down in history as the first Bitcoin bank, founded for the purpose of assisting people in transactions carried out with Bitcoin (the purchase and sale of Bitcoin) and of answering people’s questions. Moreover, in Austria, which follows this new technology closely, ATMs able to carry out transactions in Bitcoin had been installed three years earlier. Alongside all these banking activities, payment in bitcoin is also accepted in many cafés, restaurants and bars in Vienna.

In Japan, for its part, payment with Bitcoin was made official as of 1 April 2017 and has been put into practice.

The point to be noted here, however, is that although Bitcoin comes to our minds as a currency, Japan has accepted it not as money but as a means of payment (let us not forget that barter, too, is a means of payment).

3. ISSUING AN ELECTRONIC IDENTITY CARD IN THE FIELD OF CITIZENSHIP

We know what can be done once a person’s identity card can be accessed.

Since it is possible to issue a digital identity card using blockchain in place of the identity card bearing a wet-ink signature and an embossed seal, the whole legal process that requires an identity card can be kept under control. The first country to adopt this practice was Austria. In Switzerland, too, it is planned to move to the digital identity scheme at the earliest opportunity. Indeed, when we look back, our country was shaken by the theft of the identity records of 50 million people from a database with a centralised architecture.

In this process, in which these records to be kept by means of blockchain not only make people’s lives easier but also provide a secure environment, these arrangements made by countries are highly

appropriate; Türkiye, too, needs to begin work of this kind as soon as possible.

B. LEGAL TRANSACTIONS LIKELY TO BE CARRIED OUT BY MEANS OF BLOCKCHAIN

No initiative has yet been taken with regard to the two systems I am now going to mention. However, in these cases too it is perfectly possible to carry out transactions with programs to be created using the blockchain database. For this to happen, though, countries have to amend and update their legislation in line with this new technology.

1. BEING ABLE TO VOTE

In democratic societies, voting is both a duty and a right for the citizen. Unfortunately, given the conditions in Türkiye, voting in elections gives rise to one set of difficulties, and the counts after the election cause a separate chaos and controversy. People’s trust in the present system has been thoroughly shaken. Moreover, when the paper costs incurred for elections, the putting of citizens to work and the arrangements made nationwide specially for that day are also taken into account, being able to vote over the blockchain

will produce highly beneficial results.

In answer to all the problems, once blockchain-based programs have been created it will be possible to vote and to dispel the suspicions surrounding election results (by virtue of the nature of the system, data that have been entered cannot be altered once they have been processed), that is, to obtain correctly the results sought through the election.

2. LEGAL TRANSACTIONS REQUIRED TO BE CARRIED OUT BEFORE A NOTARY

Our legal order has laid down an obligation to carry out certain transactions before a notary so that some legal relationships are placed on a firmer footing. Considering that the main principle here is the obtaining of evidence should a dispute arise between the parties, and the keeping of a copy of the transaction in an impartial body as well, blockchain is a solution exactly suited to this. Indeed, bitcoin has developed a blockchain-based notary system. However, the notarial service in question is limited to transactions taking place between bitcoin users and has not been placed on any statutory footing.

C. THE FACILITATION OF THE COMMISSION OF UNLAWFUL ACTS THROUGH THE USE OF BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY

Of course, alongside all these positive results, using blockchain technology is also pregnant with some negative ones. First of all, there will be doubts as to who carried out the transaction. In addition, the taxation of the parties as a result of the commercial activities they have carried out forms a separate subject of debate.

Questions such as on what basis tax will be levied, who will be taxed, and so on will remain unanswered once the person becomes anonymous.

In recent months it emerged that the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS) had been working together with Chainalysis Startup since 2015 to monitor bitcoin transactions in order to prevent tax evasion. Taking this as a starting point, instead of disparaging the system by putting forward, as a bare allegation about blockchain, that it will give rise to tax evasion, it will be possible to prevent this by employing technically well-trained staff in the units of countries that carry out tax monitoring.

With the use of Bitcoin in particular, the offences defined in the laws have become capable of being committed in more than one way. Apart from the basic form in which offences are defined in the law, their commission by using information systems (as with the offence of fraud) constitutes an aggravated (qualified) form that increases the penalty. In any event, with the development of technology the number of cybercrimes committed has risen considerably in recent times. Indeed, where virtual currency is concerned, the commission of these offences will become a good deal easier.

Furthermore, since bitcoin is by its nature anonymous and its source cannot be determined, it is also almost impossible to know for what purpose the money obtained from it has come. In this context, the risk of the offence of laundering assets derived from an offence, governed by Article 282 of the Turkish Criminal Code (TCK), being committed is very high.

It should also be added, however, that in the report on monetary policies prepared by the United Kingdom Treasury, it was emphasised, with reference also to the report prepared by the National Crime Agency (NCA), that bitcoin is not a particularly suitable instrument for laundering the proceeds of crime. The Treasury

also specifically stated that no money laundering at all had been encountered in high-value transactions.

I must also say, however, that large sums are avoided in laundering operations.

Under another scenario, dealing in products or activities whose purchase or sale is prohibited by the legal order will become much easier by means of virtual currencies such as bitcoin. Besides all these criminal-law dimensions, it is also likely that many problems will be encountered as regards the security of trade secrets and the confidentiality of individuals’ private spheres.

The legal protection to be introduced must, with a pragmatic approach, also be such as to be capable of preventing these unlawful acts.

First, I tried to explain what kinds of arrangements have been made through the use of blockchain technology. Of course, in order for a move to these systems to be possible, domestic-law provisions on the matter are needed. It will then become possible once the programs that have to be created in conformity with each country’s own legal system have been written and put into practice.

Rather than trying to obstruct the development of technology and prohibiting its use, we need, by adopting a pragmatic approach,

to take it into our lives and into our legal system. For needs are now far beyond the dimension that the traditional system can meet.

To take two examples, I believe that it should be possible to vote using a blockchain base or to carry out the transactions performed before a notary through this system as well, and that legal fields of use should be created accordingly. For on both of these subjects debate continues both in Türkiye and in the world. No legal regulation has yet been adopted, however.

Although the offences likely to be committed which I listed a moment ago do not fall within blockchain’s legal fields of use, we face many dangers arising from the lack of a legal mechanism. I am of the opinion that, when the legal fields of use of blockchain technology are determined and solutions are sought accordingly, regulation must be made with due regard to the fact that it is much easier to commit the offences mentioned in this system than in ordinary life.

Download PDF (in Turkish)

More publications on this topic